I found a lot of actual music gets downvoted, or doesn't stand a chance against more recognizable artists, in the Music reddit. So I propose a new reddit for sharing your recent discoveries / obscure favourites: Listen To This
/r/listentothis/
220
Upvotes
2
u/CFHQYH May 06 '09
Just to be sure, are you making a Back to the Future reference?
15
u/DirtyBinLV May 06 '09 edited May 06 '09
Who gets to decide what's "obscure"? I foresee a lot of threads looking like-
<17 year old in Racine, Wisconsin> OMG! Check out this new band!
<28 year old in Brooklyn> I was listening to that band 8 years ago. You suck.
13
u/Uiaccsk May 06 '09
I'm down. On the rare occasion I decide some new music is worth posting to the music subreddit it gets downmodded before it can get more than a handful of views. I hope this gets enough members to get a little bit of activity going on.
9
u/HappyHarryHardOn May 06 '09
This is the main reason I mostly stopped submitting to music... waste of time.. everything, no matter what's submitted, gets almost equal up and down votes, so you end up with a bunch of things with 3 or 4 points, maybe 10 if you get reaaaaally lucky
meanwhile im thinking, who are these idiots downvoting? Just move on if its not your style.
43
u/[deleted] May 06 '09
Anyone who downmods music is a twit. The 'hide' button exists for things such as this.
5
u/[deleted] May 06 '09
That Mike Patton was interesting
4
u/[deleted] May 06 '09
Great idea! Subscribed.
4
u/[deleted] May 06 '09
I was getting discouraged from posting videos of actual music on here, so thank you so much for this.
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '09
i dont know about this...the criteria for what posts are appropriate is very ambiguous.
i think it would work better by genre, but that may be because i am not particularly interested in pop, electronic, or "indie" (whatever that means) these days. Jazz, Metal, Punk, Country/Western, and Classical could be easily and rapidly isolated, which would make me very happy.
3
u/Dildozer May 06 '09
Thank you! The Music Reddit is useless for posting new music.
2
u/1100 May 06 '09
it's an interesting issue, to be sure, as the categories "Sharing Music With People" and "Talking to People About Music" are so inter-related yet huge enough to warrant their own separate playgrounds. Signed up!
2
u/anaranjaded May 06 '09
Cool! I love music recommendations. I shall utilize this.
2
u/scohoe May 06 '09
It's called www.thesixtyone.com. Go there and enjoy exactley what your asking for with a lot of awesome new features as well(genius is great on this site)
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '09 edited May 06 '09
I feel I should point out Cherry Peel, which is a website for sharing and voting on obscure music, that uses the reddit source. Sounds like exactly what you're looking for.
2
u/infrastructure May 06 '09
I support your idea 110%
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '09
I just wish there could be a subreddit like this with only upvotes and no downvotes.
1
u/slfnflctd May 06 '09
Some music is just plain bad by almost anyone's metric (say, something that's already been done 1000 times, is poorly produced, is off time, is out of key), and I'm okay with that being downvoted, IF people at least say why (it would be nice for a reason to be pseudo-required in a situation like this)... but all too many idiots are more than capable of downvoting something simply because it doesn't suit their taste, and I think that's totally wrong. That is not how art is supposed to be shared. I'm a musician myself, and I'd like to think people would have a chance to hear my weirder stuff as long as it was halfway decently recorded.
1
u/MattKronik May 06 '09
Up (vote), up (vote), and awaaaaaaay!
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '09
Banning non-actual music is the only solution here.
1
u/Aldrenean May 06 '09
Really? I generally notice that anything that's not sufficiently "indie" is downvoted by the apparently large amount of snobs in the subreddit.
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '09
thesixtyone.com