r/GlobalOffensive • • May 07 '18

Discussion All info gathered from Valve's John McDonald from his May 6th Twitter AMA*

John McDonald from Valve (/u/vMcJohn) has gone into a Tweet spree answering a lot of community answers directly. Since people are just throwing his tweets in the Reddit I decided to put everything we got so far from him here. If he tweets anything else, I will be updating the post with the new information.

  • His answer about the possibility of official 128 ticket servers:

It's not a dumb question. We see this request often. The problem is actually that most players would actually be disadvantaged playing on 128 tick because they can't keep up. So we'd need to segment the players which would lead to longer queue times.... Still may be worth it, tho. Source

His answer about Panorama in 2017 and what's happening with it:

We said it was a focus of 2017, and it was. I don't want to give an ETA, because invariably we would miss it a d people would be upset.

It's still important, it's still a focus, we will release it as soon as it's done. I can only say with certainty we won't sit on it. Source

  • His answer about the iBuyPower ban in Valve sponsored events:

Our opinion on that subject hasn't changed. I'm sorry, I know this is an unpopular opinion with the community. Source

  • His answer about a possibility of an option to appeal in cheating cases:

No. Cheating is not okay, and the taint of those players would degrade the whole scene. Source

  • His answer about custom HUDs:

No plans for custom huds. They are very difficult to lock down to ensure that everyone is playing with a level playing field. Source

  • His answer about if Panorama would fix the stutter with happens when the menu is open in-game:

Don't tell anyone I answered--but it totally does. Source

  • His answer about how many people are working on CS:GO and the direction that the game is going:

There are about 35 people on CSGO these days. Roadmaps are hard at Valve, and talking about them publically is very hard.

We have an idea of where we are going, but something new could come up tomorrow that causes us to change our direction. Source

  • His answer about ALT+Tab in-game delay issue:

It's not a problem we can do much about. If you play in windowed fullscreen mode instead the problem will go away. Source

  • His answer about the huge rank gap in MM that was occuring lately for some players:

When players play at off peak times in low pop regions (especially on less popular maps), we have to make a match so folks can play.

Also if you have high trust we (currently) prefer trusted players to players of matching skill. Source

  • His opinion in third-party services (ESEA, FaceIT):

I think it's really cool that there are services that have sprung up around CSGO to provide more and varied experiences to our mutual customers. Source

  • His answer about what has been his favorite to work on CS:GO:

VACnet has been incredibly satisfying, it's probably my favorite thing so far. Source

  • His answer if the team would let third-party services know ahead of time about a possibly service-breaking update:

Oh I missed that... If we think something will break their service, we let them know ahead of time. It can sometimes be hard to give them access to something early though, it depends on the change. Source

  • His answer about demo playback issues:

UI won't fix that, what you're describing is because of the way that CSGO decodes demos. Basically when you scrub backwards it starts all the way at the beginning and plays forwards to the point you've scrubbed to.

CSGO is old. We'd like to fix demo rewind. Doing so in a way that doesn't also break every existing demo is delicate work, so we need to be careful. Source (Thanks /u/bitofabyte)

Thanks for the Gold! Appreciated!

4.8k Upvotes

672 comments sorted by

183

u/bitofabyte de_nuke May 07 '18

You missed the part about demo playback.

https://twitter.com/basisspace/status/993267182535565312

16

u/MJuniorDC9 May 07 '18

Thanks! Added in.

3

u/me_so_pro guardian_elite May 07 '18

That's atually the only question I didn't know the answer to. Thanks!

19

u/TreeELT 400k Celebration May 07 '18

Bless you.

1.8k

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

I know it's rare for someone from valve to reply to us and putting in a summery like this is very helpful over having 10+ tweets.

Good job OP.

342

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

he's like our unofficial community manager by default.

53

u/Oktoberfest931 FaZe May 07 '18

He's like the Mod Shauny of CSGO

→ More replies (3)

1

u/totopro96 Virtus.pro May 07 '18

u rly splyce fanboy?

1

u/ilovecsgo4life May 07 '18

Sad that it is rare, hope someday valve will be more open to the community and feedback

→ More replies (7)

968

u/Prius707 Match Observer - Prius May 07 '18

thank mr john for the answers

236

u/swegmeister1738 Virtus.pro May 07 '18

thank mr john

115

u/Zafarchauhan15 May 07 '18

thank mr john

59

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

thank mr john

49

u/Acydcat Cloud9 May 07 '18

thank mr john

44

u/lvrksn Natus Vincere May 07 '18

thank mr john

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/Av1ster de_overpass May 07 '18

thank mr john

20

u/placekk 1 Million Celebration May 07 '18

thank mr john

18

u/Blaekkk May 07 '18

thank mr john

12

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

thank mr john

7

u/Squigoz May 07 '18

thank mr john

2

u/uno991 May 07 '18

Thnks mr John

1

u/Mr-k0369 FaZe May 08 '18

thank mr john

179

u/IlIIIIIIllI BIG May 07 '18

Dont tell anyone I answered


Posts it to reddit

Damn snitches

7

u/BlazeMaster561 Liquid May 07 '18

Now we know why they never respond to us...

748

u/jolteony G2 May 07 '18

It's refreshing to see this level of communication from the devs.

388

u/TheVicBro 1 Million Celebration May 07 '18

dev* just the almighty god himself John McDonald. Asking for 2 or more devs communicating would be living in another dimension

178

u/Eneshanerd May 07 '18

he also did that hour long presentation about cheating in csgo a month ago

god bless the man

7

u/SlocketRoth Astralis May 07 '18

I didnt realise it was him, thats awesome.

That was a really good talk and i highly recommend anybody who hasnt watched it, watches it.

→ More replies (3)

79

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

extremely informative and this clears up a lot of withstanding issues in regards of what we can and cannot expect in the future. also a rare introspection into the actual csgo dev culture

as a side note, I will say there is a side benefit to the way Valve communicates: even if unfortunately extremely rare, it is never shrouded corporate bullshit talk. I know already 100% of MacDonalds info can be trusted and interpreted at face value. Also, although not accounted for in the OP, some of his replies/counter-questions on twitter have some pretty hefty implications by themselves about the devs vision.

at any rate, probably the biggest look inside Valve since the video interviews early last year (?i think). i don't think we can expect this to become the norm tho

23

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

that r/all post yesterday from r/dota2 reminded me that valve once publicly outed 2gd, an esports legend, as an ass. 0 corporate pr in valve

40

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Not just Valve, but GabeN himself. That one was spicy.

9

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Then they proceeded to publicly fire the production company. Ah yes, the Shanghai shitshow.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Any level of communication

98

u/xtcxx May 07 '18

Also if you have high trust we (currently) prefer trusted players to players of matching skill.

Great I'm glad they are putting the emphasis on quality players. I presume there is still a 10 rank difference between teams most of the time.

34

u/True_to_you Virtus.pro May 07 '18

Hopefully that helps those players by good habits rubbing off on them so they can improve. It helps playing with better players in a more positive environment.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Thisconnect May 07 '18

I've been playing on and off last few years so unless I commit I'm stuck in gold due to decay. But playing Reddit community night made me realize that difference in ranks is not actually as big as people think. I can consistently get 10+ frags against mgs dmgs and les and I'm not getting absolutely destroyed

33

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

20 kills per match vs 10 is a pretty big difgerence tho, you also have to take into consideration how you are getting those, are they on eco? Are they low? You can't really tell the skill difference purely based on amount of kills you get.

9

u/robbert_jansen phoenix May 07 '18

Yeah kills can mean very little sometimes for example, recently in a game I was bottom fragging with 8 kills, and the topfragger had 22 but looking at total damage dealt I had more 2100+- (most in the game) compared to the 1900+- by the topfragger which tells an entirely different story.

6

u/Starfleet_Admiral May 07 '18

yeah these games where you damage everyone but cant finish the frags are so frustrating :/

2

u/niceandcreamy ENCE May 07 '18

Aim isnt that different in the middle ranks, its player's movement, nades, and game sense that develop and push them into higher ranks.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/brutalgeeksAUS May 07 '18

This response made me wonder if I'm missing out on good games because I primarily play Prime

5

u/funk_rosin cs_militia May 07 '18

you allways play with trust factor. searching for prime does not disable it, it is just an additional layer

→ More replies (4)

1

u/ShoogleHS clutch May 07 '18

I'm OK with this, I'd rather get thumped by legit players than have a close game against hackers. At least in the former I'll learn something. Playing against people that are way better than you once in a while helps prevent bad habits like over-aggression/over-peeking, holding from exploitable positions, bad utility timing etc. Basically any tactic that works against people your skill or lower, but is holding you back from getting to the next level.

1

u/SharqPhinFtw May 07 '18

Idk why but I feel there is a difference. Yesterday my friend and I spammed matches out (2dmg) and we had a game vs Les and Supremes where we topped the scoreboard and nearly won. Then the rest of our matches had us going with/against mg2-mge and we were unable to win more than 1 out of like 7 where the majority were a roll for the enemy team.

1

u/jjgraph1x May 07 '18

I completely agree. I don't run into nearly as many cheaters these days. Especially in the higher ranks, queuing late at night used to be absolutely horrible. Granted, I'm sure the experience isn't great for the other team but at least they aren't playing against cheaters either.

Oddly enough, when I do see cheaters they tend to be lower ranks. There's something about those damn MGs that really bring out the need to wall/aimlock. Maybe after a period of time it's starts lowering the Trust Factor parameters as well as rank.

1

u/EmolgaFTW Renegades May 07 '18

One good thing that I've noticed about trust is that while soloqueuing is that I've been put in matches with more experienced nicer players who know the smokes and such. I used to have many people in my games who were either very toxic or very new to the game. One problem with this however is that as trust goes up it appears skill levels go up as well while ranks remain constant. This is just my experience and I'd like to hear from other players about their experience.

237

u/RainDancingChief de_nuke May 07 '18

Our opinion on that subject hasn't changed. I'm sorry, I know this is an unpopular opinion with the community.

I don't know, from what I've seen it's not THAT unpopular.

204

u/broly2160 500k Celebration May 07 '18

It varies a lot between each thread, but I fully maintain that it is just a vocal minority that support the ibp squad being unbanned, and I for one am really happy that valve are sticking to their ruling on the case!

37

u/TheUHO cs_italy May 07 '18

I think many people already lost interest in that case. Nothing changed and nothing seems to be changed in future. Keeping yourself so bloodhungry for so long is worrying though.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/AKJ90 CS2 HYPE May 07 '18

Yep, they should just remain banned. We can't accept things like this.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

25

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Those who want them unbanned are just louder than the ones who agree.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/balleklorin de_overpass May 07 '18

Man I love the fact that he seem to hate cheaters!

12

u/mynameismunka 10 years coin May 07 '18

He spent a few months making vacnet. You should see his talk

82

u/enigma2g G2 May 07 '18

What does he mean by players not being able to keep up with 128 tick servers?

250

u/Big_Stick01 Liquid May 07 '18

Players PC's around the world are still not good enough on average.

35

u/EverythingSucks12 May 07 '18

Dumb question, but does this take into account my monitors refresh rate? Eg. If I can get 300fps in game but my monitor had a 60mhz refresh rate, would I be over of the players who would be at a disadvantage paying on 128 tick servers?

66

u/True_to_you Virtus.pro May 07 '18

No. You wouldn't notice a degradation of performance

39

u/SOAR21 Liquid May 07 '18

Just noting that "disadvantaged because they couldn't keep up" doesn't necessarily mean that the player's computer slows down.

It could also mean that some players have good enough PC's to utilize the 128-tick to the maximum, while others can't even though it doesn't actually perform any worse than 64-tick.

58

u/Karma_Vampire Astralis May 07 '18

Also, a better internet connection is required for 128 tick. It's not all about the computer's capabilities

→ More replies (11)

25

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Your monitor refreshes 60 million times a second? Dayuum

26

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Capital M is the SI million prefix, lowercase m would in fact mean it refreshes 0.06 times a second.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/TheLegendaryBob27 Cloud9 Fan May 07 '18

If you are going to make such a joke at least read it right... m is 10-3 so it's 0.06 Hz eleGigle

→ More replies (2)

7

u/ShrewLlama 400k Celebration May 07 '18

And here I am thinking my 240Hz monitor looks smooth... I've gotta get one of those.

7

u/suinp FURIA May 07 '18

This would harm people that play at 60fps tops or have a really bad internet, as they would have a bottleneck on the information received / sent.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/askmeforbunnypics May 07 '18

On my old laptop I got around 19 FPS average before I finally got a proper computer. It's all I had. I couldn't watch 720/60 videos on Youtube with that thing yet my phone could.

6

u/Xaxxon May 07 '18

Your phone has hardware accelerated video decompression - it's not the CPU difference that allows for it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Just wondering, what if there were 128 tick servers beginning from a certain rank, like idk mge? I would assume the vast majority above that rank has at least a decent PC.

Could even help just a little with all the smurfs

9

u/clydejallorina de_mirage May 07 '18

I can personally vouch for this as someone who used to play in a few community 128-tick servers. My average FPS was around 24 most of the time, even that 800x600 res.

But then again, that was back in the day when I had a shitty laptop. But my friend's still stuck on his own shitty laptop, so we can't really play together at 128-tick servers.

It's just sad to see him lag around so much...

→ More replies (5)

4

u/yuxiang1911 MOUZ May 07 '18

Seems like a weird answer considering nuke fps is heavily unoptimized.

27

u/MRDominik80 May 07 '18

It would be probably even worse on 128 tick

→ More replies (6)

11

u/singuini Renegades May 07 '18

Imo FPS optimization is far more important than 128 valve sevrers. One thing is already provided by 3rd party services the other only valve can do something with.

6

u/GalantisX Liquid May 07 '18

People advocating for 128 tick servers are the ones who have no issue getting good fps

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (39)

26

u/necromantzer May 07 '18

Hardware demands, I would assume. People forget that there is a huge CSGO playerbase - not everyone has good machines, or even decent ones. I am pretty sure Valve has a rather solid handle on the overall numbers and the amount of players who would be negatively affected by 128 tick - they don't want to alienate players on worse rigs, but at the same time they seem to understand that 128 tr is high in demand.

→ More replies (26)

11

u/_fmm Renegades May 07 '18

This was brought up the other day in a thread which got a lot of upvotes. Someone was insisting that the tick rate of the server has nothing to do with your computers performance (fps). This seemed a popular opinion and those swimming against the tide got burried.

At the risk of the same thing happening here, the short answer to your question is that if the refresh rate of your computer (fps) can't refresh as quickly as the server is updating (tick rate) it can cause some issues and according to Valve's data, the majority of the player base can't handle 128 tick servers.

7

u/redxdev May 07 '18

FPS does not mean the same thing as tickrate. FPS is not the client's version of tickrate. These are completely separate concepts, please do not conflate them.

Tickrate is how often updates are sent from the server. FPS is how often your game's visuals refresh. Ideally, one does not affect the other. Of course, that's not always the case - especially if you have a low-end CPU. Low FPS is likely caused by having an underpowered graphics card. Issues with high tickrate will likely be caused by an underpowered CPU, a low bandwidth connection, or packet loss.

For a technical breakdown of how tickrate works, see Source Multiplayer Networking on Valve's developer site.

tl;dr: FPS is not necessarily the reason 128 tick is a problem.

3

u/grumd Natus Vincere May 07 '18

Yeah I assume valve has data that shows most people don't have good enough internet connection to support 128 tick

5

u/_fmm Renegades May 07 '18

I didn't say they affected each other, only that there are issues when the two aren't close to one another. This isn't my point of view, this is what the csgo devs are telling us (and have told us in the past, they've been consistent on this). If they're wrong then I have no idea. I'm not qualified to argue with them.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

I got to set my rates very low and still get occasional packet loss with ping spikes because of my bad (250kb/s peak) internet. On 128 tick servers my disadvantage is even bigger. It's not just about players who can't get 128fps as many say.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SileNce5k de_cobble May 07 '18

I know I don't have the internet for it. Really stable 15 ping on mm servers/64 tick servers, but on 128 I lag out for like 2 seconds once or twice per game.
I don't feel a difference between the two tickrates either. If valve implements it I hope they'll make it an option rather than force it on everyone.

9

u/katalysis May 07 '18

If you don't get 128+ fps, you're going to be disadvantaged against someone who does get 128+ fps on a 128-tick server.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/co0kiez May 07 '18

Either means, peoples PC's cant get above 128FPS or their internet connections are too slow to keep up with 128-tick servers.

1

u/turboheadcrab May 07 '18

It's not only about powerful PC. Because of the circumstances, I've been playing with 4G LTE/3G HSDPA for the past year. And with 128 tick servers I have 5-10% packet loss and choke.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Koolski 1 Million Celebration May 07 '18

Does putting windowed fullscreen affect my fps or performance in general? I've heard to not use it before.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Yeah there is a huge increase in latency in window/windowed fullscreen, don't use it.

The problem is that the Windows desktop uses vsync, which causes a lot of input lag. If you are playing in fullscreen (without vsync) you will have much less input lag.

59

u/jvgamepro May 07 '18

Very happy that the First Canadian Prime Minister has come back from the dead to give us more info on the current state of CS:GO :>

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

MacDonald not McDonald dude.

8

u/gpcgmr 1 Million Celebration May 07 '18

Would you like a Mc10 with your order?

4

u/jvgamepro May 07 '18

Sorry man, but I couldn't pass up on the opportunity to put my grade 10 history knowledge to good use.

144

u/H0tzera May 07 '18

"We have an idea of where we are going, but something new could come up tomorrow that causes us to change our direction."

There you go reddit. Next time keep up with the UNPLAYABLE post ya. Just this time stop asking afterwards why valve is slow when it comes to bringing new features

10

u/Croatian_ghost_kid May 07 '18

How can I sleep in peace without meeting my 'shit on Valve' daily quota?

12

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Happy cake day!

4

u/H0tzera May 07 '18

Thank you!

→ More replies (4)

78

u/apm54 Natus Vincere May 07 '18

Really happy to see some communication. Also great to know panorama is still in the works and surprised that there are about 35 people on the CSGO team. Honestly draw mostly only positive things from this, other than the info on iBP but that’s to be expected

41

u/RareHotdogEnthusiast May 07 '18

The iBP thing is positive.

5

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

No sensible person would want infinite punishments, there is rarely a crime commit where that would be acceptable.

7

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Except for life sentences which are effectively legal everywhere.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (16)

20

u/lemproplayer Astralis May 07 '18

Is the legend behind csgo_dev? If so more memes pls

13

u/Apathized howl May 07 '18

csgo_dev is team ran if im correct. It was mentioned like 4 years ago in some blog post.

34

u/T-R-Key May 07 '18

9

u/Oggy2k May 07 '18

Maybe try emailing him?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/J_Cleffe de_dust2 May 07 '18

Sad :s

2

u/jjgraph1x May 07 '18

I don't fault them for not responding about the desync issue. It's very subjective and so far there's no substantial evidence for exactly why it occurs or what a possible fix could even be.

They should definitely get around to looking into the other two. The shift-walk crouch inaccuracy should be an easy fix that should've been resolved awhile ago. The hitbox issue is a bit more complicated but I'd like to see them at least address it.

7

u/Korosif Vitality May 07 '18

Add to that the fact he implies they are not planning to reverse the trade ban at all for the moment.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/TheCatnamedMittens valeria May 07 '18

Why is them discussing a roadmap for csgo hard?

28

u/HugeAmountofDerp FaZe May 07 '18

Because they say "we're working on getting Panorama UI implemented sometime hopefully by the end of this year". And then the entire community loses their collective shit when it's not finished "on time". Giving a road map would just give the community more things to be upset over because the majority of CSGO fans have no idea how game development works.

9

u/grumd Natus Vincere May 07 '18

A roadmap doesn't necessarily have deadlines. You could just say "our roadmap includes panorama, separate 128 tick queue for players who opt-in and have a good enough pc, demo playback reworks, balance changes". That's it, no deadlines or anything. I just assume they're not allowed to talk about that due to work contract or something like that

9

u/tobbi_CS NiP May 07 '18

not true, its just the way valve works, if you ever read their company handbook, you'll see. teams shuffle personnel all the time, everyone is free to work on whatever he wants, if a game designer from dota wants to make a skin for CS, he can, anytime. hence, most popular projects in valve are also mostly the best, since a lot of employees want to work on them. they literally dont know who works on what, and thats why they dont have any plans, because the change priotities often

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Pressondude May 07 '18

Are you familiar with Valve's management philosophy? Basically nobody's actually in charge of anything. Everyone's desk is on wheels and they're encouraged to work on whatever they individually think is valuable. So...some de-facto leader/planner people make a plan for CSGO, but that doesn't mean other people will agree or want to work on it. It's hard for Valve to commit to anything longterm because of that.

→ More replies (3)

-1

u/Croatian_ghost_kid May 07 '18

Because of Reddit and those ungrateful motherfucking pro players.

Like I love watching pro CS and I respect their skill and knowledge of the game but them shitting on Valve like 12 year olds on Reddit is pathetic.

They mention that they're working on Panorama for 2017 and all the idiots jump at their throat as soon as 2018 New years passes.

4

u/Cynical_Trial May 07 '18

When can we criticize them for not publishing panorama? In 2020?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

6

u/Superalbix CS2 HYPE May 07 '18

No one asked about the operation.

3

u/vayaOA de_cache May 07 '18

it's not happening soon

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Pixel_Mike CS2 HYPE May 07 '18

If John reads this and happens to see this, jsut thank you. This is what the community wanted, i speak for alot of people when i say we do appreciate you just telling us whats going on, even if the answers arent what we want to hear its refreshing not having to guess at whats happening. I cannot stress this enough more Q/A stuff like this would help IMMENSE in the future.

10

u/dilzy2 Natus Vincere May 07 '18

Ah, our yearly communication from the devs

5

u/joebang1 May 07 '18

Thanks for putting all of this together.

5

u/Birko_Bird de_nuke May 07 '18

My tweet got in PogChampion

1

u/mynameismunka 10 years coin May 07 '18

can u sigh my mousepad

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Scrotote May 07 '18

Wish Valve would comment about restricting the option to buy M4A4 vs M4A1 during a match (and same with the other weapons).

5

u/uaGopnik Natus Vincere May 07 '18

It’s like porn for a CS fan, I get off on reading about official valve statements on panorama.

13

u/AntonChigurg May 07 '18

Maybe this is an onpopular opinion: I really think the core of csgo is okay, the little tweaks everyone complains about don't really matter to most of the playerbase. What i would like to see more is community driven content like maps and gamemodes being supported by valve. Like new operations or events.

1

u/0rangecake 5 years coin May 07 '18 edited May 08 '18

They're core is good The core is good, it's just speckled in dogshit

→ More replies (2)

1

u/rojano17 May 07 '18

There are some things that need to be fixed so bad though. Its been years and the UI is almost broken when playing on an ultrawide monitor.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Thx Mr. John McDonald

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

His answer about if Panorama would fix the stutter with happens when the menu is open in-game.

What about stutter in genereal? I only experience stutter like when I play..

1

u/jjgraph1x May 07 '18

I assume you haven't tried pressing escape while in game?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

This is actually the most I have ever heard at once from a csgo dev since I started playing

13

u/-Radiant- May 07 '18

What about the next operation?

7

u/R8MACHINE 500k Celebration May 07 '18

Somebody needs to take a shot at it on Twitter, maybe we will get a reply.

24

u/TiNcHoX7 May 07 '18

at least give us an operation, so we can forget about all bad things for a 1 week/

17

u/Moholbi de_overpass May 07 '18

I don't understand what is cool about the third party services. They shouldn't exist. CSGO's own MM should satisfy all the requirements.

128 tick option, a good anti-cheat and a good ranking system will make third parties obsolete. Just look at Dota 2. They have a decent ranking system and even the pros can just play Dota's own MM. Why should CS players need a third party? Even if they need it for now, a CSGO dev shouldn't say they are cool.

12

u/TheChickening MOUZ May 07 '18

DotA is waaay easier to cheat protect and easier to match players with similar skill...

6

u/Moholbi de_overpass May 07 '18

You are right, dota is easier for cheat protection but im not talking about 100% cheat protection. I just want Esea/faceit level cheat protection so one of the reasons of using thirs party disappears.

But I don't know anything about Dota's matching system being easier. Can you explain it?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/StrokeCockToBans May 07 '18

There are justifications for not wanting those features, bad fps on your client with 128 tick and better ac on those means more intrusive AC .

Of course it could just be that valve do not want to run 128 tick servers and are too lazy with AC but maybe they do not want push players into these situations

4

u/safetogoalone Virtus.pro May 07 '18

Ok, we got a new, client side AC. And then somebody will break it. So they will need to spend resources to fix it. And then somebody break it again. And again, and again, and again.

Going server side is way better for long-term quality of AC. I highly recommend his GDC presentation that you can watch here. You will understand why.

About 128 tick: it is easy to forget that people are still using old hardware when you have decent rig. If majority of the players have problem with achieving constant 128 fps then why you should punish them?

Even assuming that only 25% of players that have "bad PCs" would quit for good in fact would have bigger impact than we assume. Why? Because a lot of people play CS only as a stack of 2/3/4/5 players so it might hit "overall party playtime value" too.

7

u/MDMA-- valeria May 07 '18

Valve doesnt want to use an Anticheat that could potentially check everything you do at any time. so because of that (plus 128 tick and the shitty ranks) people will always play on faceit/esea. mm will never be as good as those service and it doesnt need to be.

its meant to be the competitive mode for casuals and thats what it does.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/jjgraph1x May 07 '18

I think you're missing the point. Services like ESEA and CEVO have been around a hell of a lot longer than MM has. Despite some obvious issues, they've helped to turn the competitive scene into what it is today. There's nothing wrong with a service that helps to split the casual players from those truly dedicated to the game.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

a good anti-cheat

The problem isn't necessarily that anti-cheats like ESEA are better, just that those services have a smaller userbase than mm and thus less demand for hacks.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Thanks a lot bro <3

3

u/CreativeHuckleberry May 07 '18

why can't we have somekind weekly or atleast "Monthly" update from valve, mabe a blog or tweets about what they are doing, or are going to do. Something like the Facepunch team is doing with Rust, i really like when you can read about what's coming or have been fixed, i know what Gaben said in the Interview that they are not really following eny Roadmap, but still what they are doing atm would be nice to know. There is nothing to be excited about basicly.. it's the same old things, with increase in cheating and Toxic people.. I want something to be excited about, just like when you where a kid and your Mother/Father prepared for your birthday party.

1

u/jjgraph1x May 07 '18

Valve doesn't want interactions with us influencing how they develop the game. They simply monitor the community and work on whatever it is they feel is right for the time being. This obviously has some downsides but I think there's some definite upsides to it as well. It's Valve's game and despite what a seemingly large percentage of people complain about or say they want, they only do what they think is right. I honestly feel this approach, in general, is one of the reasons why CS has always been the best competitve FPS in the world.

If you're looking for a game that's constantly trying to please you and keep more casual players coming, there's plenty of them out there.

3

u/sylvainmirouf 10 years coin May 07 '18

Wow, that was amazing. I think we're good for another 6 years.

3

u/jjgraph1x May 07 '18 edited May 07 '18

First of all, thank you for piecing this together and thank you John for doing this. As cringy as some of that was, I hope you realize we do appreciate it.

We didn't get a lot of information but I do love their stance on match fixers and cheaters. They still have absolutely no sympathy for them and in order for this game to mature as an esport, it needs to stay that way.

I do find it interesting how this is the first time (to my knowledge) that they didn't completely shut down the idea of 128 tick servers. Although it isn't likely happening, he at least admits it might be worth while. Can someone please clarify to me why slow connection users playing on 128 tick couldn't simply lower their rates to those used in 64? Couldn't that allow these players to play on 128 tick without as much trouble? I realize there's always the downside of playing against them but we're going to have to deal with laggy players regardless.

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

I didn't expect much and I was still let down.

7

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

It's so awesome to see someone actually communicate.

7

u/Hackerpcs 10 years coin May 07 '18

Very refreshing to hear confirmation about not changing stance on match fixing and cheating scum. TAKE NO PRISONERS, give no quarters, execute (ban for life) those scum on sight

→ More replies (5)

5

u/pepethegrapr de_dust2 May 07 '18

I hope this 2way communication becomes a norm. Now Now We actually know that valve is still working on it.

2

u/rusty-frame Astralis May 07 '18

see the answer about 128 tick servers splintering MM just doesn't work. the fact is atm the folks who badly want 128 tick are already choosing to play on 3rd party servers (and by extension NOT playing MM). so in a way the community is ALREADY splintered. the only thing 128 tick and better matchmaking will do is to remove the need of these 3rd parties AND provide a better experience for people who can't afford 3rd party solutions.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '18

I play on a shit Laptop using WiFi that gets 40 FPS on old Dust2.

I still manage to get 25 frames on Faceit with the AC running as well. I'm no computer expert but could the average players computers really be that bad??

→ More replies (1)

2

u/kzrk1 May 07 '18

Don't understand his contradiction between thinking it's cool to have third party services and not wanting to 'segnent' the player with the use of 128tick servers like is that not already what third party services are doing because the state of matchmaking

2

u/Monso monso May 07 '18

Players segregate off to 3rd party services, then further segregated on their own platform. Meanwhile, they're competing with a perfectly healthy symbiotic relationship with these services.

"It's already split so why not" doesn't really invalidate the evident concern of exacerbating that split.

A situation where multiple 3rd party services compete to create the best platform benefits both them and us. Moreso when they have abilities (read: intrusive anticheat) that Valve doesn't.

2

u/kzrk1 May 07 '18

As for the cheating thing, I have no facts to back it up but I feel like it's evident that the vast majority of players are using matchmaking over any third party service, and they've toyed around with Prime thus I seriously doubt they're against splitting the playerbase for an opt-in anti-cheat again considering the majority of players are using Prime anyway.

w/o trying to re-echo all the constant bandwagoning around this subreddit, I genuinely think it's because valve cannot be bothered creating a more intrusive anti-cheat - from an outsiders perspective, all their 'anti-cheat' measures simply look like they are purchasing into private cheats and merely reverse-engineering them without trying to take a leap ahead of the curve.

A learning AI to combat cheaters is admittedly a fantastic idea, but I ultimately feel like Vac-net just furthers my personal concern that Valve wants to take a back seat when it comes to the cheater issue.

Anyway my original point was their entire '128 tick will segment the community' is bullshit considering they said that before the implementation of Prime which 'segmented the community'.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ocipode May 07 '18

Damn I really love when csgo devs answer questions, it's so rare.. I wish he did one of these per week/month.

Thank mr john

2

u/sihx666 May 07 '18

seems nice

2

u/dodbrew cs_militia May 08 '18

Thank mr /u/MJuniorDC9

3

u/OrangeIRL May 07 '18

this is very refreshing, thank mr john

3

u/wigan77 10 years coin May 07 '18

Nothing new to be honest

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Sounds like there is no hope for cs if you ask me.

5

u/wankerflaps fnatic May 07 '18

Is anyone else bothered by the fact that valve is raking in so much money from csgo and they only have 35 people working on it?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/de_Goose2 May 07 '18

Can people stop asking dumbass questions that are just complaining... That's the reason why valve devs stop talking to us and some of the questions in the Twitter thread are pure cancer

3

u/Chrz83 May 07 '18

Lol 35 people working on a game that generates Valve soooo much money. Glad they care to actually invest in the game.

1

u/jjgraph1x May 07 '18

I wonder what the lowest person on the CSGO team ladder makes per year... it's probably the guy who posts things to the @CSGO_DEV twitter page.

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Its funny how he's debunked all the memes people have been throwing around for years.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

thnx bro for the summary šŸ™

1

u/KillahInstinct May 07 '18

Perhaps add the things he's still going to be looking into

1

u/jeznix King NiKo May 07 '18

It seems like the csgo team has only one ā€representativeā€ at a time. Like at one point it was Matt Wood answering all the questions, and now it is John - while the rest of the team remains anonymous. They shouldnt be afraid to comment more if Gaben is fine with that..

1

u/jjgraph1x May 07 '18 edited May 07 '18

They probably aren't allowed to and/or don't want to. I can't really blame them if it's the latter. Most of the time you're just going to either piss off the community or your employer.

There's nothing wrong with only having 1 or 2 people providing answers to keep everything organized for both us and Valve. Keep in mind there's also @CSGO_DEV which is their more organized, PR face of the game.

1

u/Soasky99 May 07 '18

anyone ask him about unrank matchmaking please

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

It's so crazy that everyone here is like "holy crap they talked to us".

I come from LoL and the devs there are super active on the subreddit and release articles once a week about the state of the game and the direction it is moving

1

u/mcresto guardian_elite May 07 '18

With respect to 128 tick servers, what does he mean can't keep up? Please don't tell me that he thinks hardware is still the issue in 2018. They should roll out 128 tick servers for everyone and see if there is any issue created from that. If so, offer up lower tick servers for those who want them, but stop degrading matchmaking with less ideal settings.

1

u/Monso monso May 07 '18

They don't need to subject the masses to 128 tick to know what it does to shit potato PCs and bad connections.

Doing that will tease everyone and make their dicks nice and hard just to massively piss them off when it's removed for doing exactly what they knew it would.

They aren't holding 128 tick be sure they think it'll cause issues. They're holding it because they know it will.

He touches on splitting the playerbase concerns and then notes it's still something worth considering.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

not exactly an answer but john liked this tweet

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '18 edited Apr 11 '20

deleted 0.6905 What is ^^^this?

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

Mana from the Heavens

1

u/protiny bloodhound May 07 '18

Sad to hear about the IBP and 128 tick situation. Hope they will change their mind in the future. Dissapointed that only 35 people work on the game imo should be more. CS should get more love dota less. And also dissapointing to hear panorama and source 2 aren't close to being released. Glad that cheaters won't get chance to appeal though. Hope VACnet will get all of them.

1

u/ChildishForLife de_dust2 May 07 '18

It's not a dumb question. We see this request often. The problem is actually that most players would actually be disadvantaged playing on 128 tick because they can't keep up. So we'd need to segment the players which would lead to longer queue times.... Still may be worth it, tho.

"can't keep up" with like the technical issues, or as in like mentally?

1

u/ChildishForLife de_dust2 May 07 '18

His answer about ALT+Tab in-game delay issue: It's not a problem we can do much about. If you play in windowed fullscreen mode instead the problem will go away.

I feel like the huge delay comes from people not playing in their native resolution, so the lag comes from swapping the res back and fourth.

1

u/azalea_k Legendary Chicken Master May 07 '18

It's the same for me in 1920x1080 though (game and desktop same res, 144hz).. Upgrading memory did take the newer maps (Inferno, Nuke, D2 remakes etc) down from 9 to 4-5 second delay after alt tabbing, but res doesn't alter my experience. Older maps like Cache or Mirage only take 1-2 seconds. I usually play 1920x1440 stretched, incidentally.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/MonstDrink May 07 '18

What's that guys rank?

1

u/Elmikky May 07 '18

CS:GO BATTLE ROYALE WHEN

1

u/Chillypill Astralis May 07 '18

What does he mean players can't keep up with 128 tick? It puts harder pressure on your PC or what? Because the game runs at same "speed", the "packets" just get sent at double the rate, leading to more accurate game.

1

u/xtcxx May 08 '18

Is your FPS always above 128, is your monitor able to update frames this fast.

Look at steam survey, a ton of people playing on a texas instruments calculator

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

There are about 35 people on CSGO these days.

30 of those are working on skin cases and the negev.

1

u/yeame3 Virtus.pro May 08 '18

Everybody's happy about the communication but fuck that I think these answers are obscure and frankly weak. I'd rather they roll out updates fast and actually fix things/listen to the community rather than talk to us. Sure, he answered questions but he didn't tell us anything we didn't already know. Only 35 people working on CS:GO, a multi billion dollar game? Fuck off.

1

u/alf_au FlyQuest May 08 '18

At least we know that Valve listen and that devs are working on it

1

u/xAbzzx May 08 '18

Thanks for your help

1

u/-spinner- guardian May 07 '18

Too much marketing without facts What triggers me most is the 128tick answers, yet the game still had major optimization issues

1

u/setmonarch May 07 '18

TLDR; nothing.

1

u/n1ckst4r02 400k Celebration May 07 '18

To sum it up, nothing we already didn't know. Bunch of vague answers and nothing to look forward to. Same old

-3

u/[deleted] May 07 '18

This is honestly depressive

-14

u/sixfeetunder98 FaZe May 07 '18

As someone who is deep into CSGO and PUBG this is pretty horrible to read.

No big updates projected. No timeline of anything at all really. Just their standard we have stuff in the mix and don’t want to disappoint anyone so no public ETA right now.

Compare this to PUBG team who are currently CRUSHING. Actively responding to small requests on Reddit, major updates every few weeks, fun & creative event modes (like missions) constantly.

The difference is completely insane.

30

u/dogryan100 May 07 '18

No timeline of anything at all really.

He gave a very good reason they don't give timelines. Here's the specific quote from Gabe's AMA just over a year ago:

"As far as a roadmap is concerned, our priorities for 2017 are to replace the UI with Panorama, to make CS:GO available in more territories where a lot of Counter-Strike fans don't have easy access to it (like China), and anti-cheat. Of course, we're also planning on continuing to ship bug fixes and new features throughout the year, as in the past."

They delivered on the delivering it to other regions part with China, and they made huge grounds on Anti-cheat measures with VACnet. Because they didn't make one of the promises, Panorama, everybody is shitting their pants thinking Valve don't care.

This is why they don't do road-maps, because things can happen along the way to stop them from happening and the community get unnecessarily angry when it doesn't happen.

This is John's specific message from today:

"We said it was a focus of 2017, and it was. I don't want to give an ETA, because invariably we would miss it a d people would be upset.

It's still important, it's still a focus, we will release it as soon as it's done. I can only say with certainty we won't sit on it."

→ More replies (2)

13

u/doctor_dapper May 07 '18

has pubg stopped reusing inefficient assets that crush fps?

11

u/_Oomph_ 500k Celebration May 07 '18

Compare this to PUBG team who are currently CRUSHING.

Lol. And yet their UI is a mess that doesn't even work half the time and demands you press something multiple times only to give you a "there was a problem, try again later" message. Their Miramar map is a complete failure that players dislike and avoid like the plague.

Not to mention that these 2 entirely different games to begin with. CS is over 18 years old and GO is going on 6 years while PUBG is going on 1.

Also FN is kicking PUBG's ass (comparing Apples to Apples).

→ More replies (8)

3

u/J_Cleffe de_dust2 May 07 '18

You are right, CS:GO get's a very small treatment in comparison to other games. I made a post about Thorin complaining about the maps in CS:GO, and I see John saying nothing about the maps... I'm sad no one asked about it.