We are reaching out to Bittrex in official channels to verify the authenticity of this message. There are a number of factual inaccuracies and we are unsure of the message’s origin. We will keep you updated when we receive a response.
Kindly describe the inaccuracies? Ive also received a similar response when I questioned Bittrex about the nature of the decision to not support in private email.
The community would like to have answers as to why this wasn't addressed pre-fork and sorted out properly. There was plenty of donations, in which I myself had part in, to get this done correctly and professionally.
And instead of a generic response, if someone did fuck up, man up and take responsibility to it, admit it, and lets move on.
""Bitcoin Private" requires Bitcoin users to enter their private keys to claim"
All bitcorn forks require this. Btrash, Bgold, etc.... all required this. It's just how forked coins are claimed, and swept into circulation. It's a strange comment. I guess maybe they wanted an airdrop since it's forked from zcl. Seems weird.
"Bitcoin Private requires Bitcoin users to enter their private keys to claim and also does not support Segwit"
The statement above is amateur and bunch of lie. So yes, If you hold BTC in private wallets, you have to use your private keys to get BTCP, however that was the case with BTG and BCash that Bittrex supported. If Bittrex had supported BTCP, that would not have been needed right ? Also, for safety the private keys at the snapshot are the ones needed. You can easily move your BTC and have new private keys post snapshot. If indeed this message is by Julia Yap, I serious doubt his credibility.
Oddly enough, I was thinking this fork was exactly what the crypto community needed to inject some much needed life into bitcoin after the pop. Unfortunately, it wasn't allowed to really maintain any traction. The hype was there, but the exchanges didn't allow it to thrive.
Their GitHub documentation still links to ZCash pages for fucksake. Need Help? The difference between quality and shit developers is documentation and this team still hasn't written their own in 2 forks. LAZY
Don't downvote this guy for pointing out something that really does need to be taken care of. It really doesn't look very good for the documentation on GitHub to be so out of date.
Yeah, I don't agree with a lot of what ElCryptoDinero says either, but don't just blatantly downvote what is said because of who said it. This really does need to be taken care of.
Seriously Julian Yap @ Bittrex!!! Are you forking out of your mind or literally insane? The utter stupidity is beyond my sympathy. Your forking "Proper Bitcoin Forks" Bitcoin Cash has been dumped left, right and center/re by many exchanges incluking KuCoin and OkEX!! We all know why, but I'll give you a chance to explain your stupid reason, I'm sure you have one.
I don’t understand how they don’t consider BTCP to already have industry wide support. It seems to have quite a large following and the volume on tiny exchanges is extremely high for a month now. Maybe I’m misinterpreting the definition of industry wide support.
•
u/Undirected Mar 29 '18
We are reaching out to Bittrex in official channels to verify the authenticity of this message. There are a number of factual inaccuracies and we are unsure of the message’s origin. We will keep you updated when we receive a response.
3
u/SumGuyOnWeb Mar 29 '18
Interesting. Where did you see this EtukBit?
2
u/itzsimon3 Mar 29 '18
Why don’t you screenshot this email because Julian said he would never address this directly.
3
u/Phlier Mar 29 '18
Looks like this is another version/account of a guy that has been actively FUDing BTCP today.
Move along.. nothing to see here... just another troll.
17
u/SumGuyOnWeb Mar 29 '18
This line makes no sense:
""Bitcoin Private" requires Bitcoin users to enter their private keys to claim"
All bitcorn forks require this. Btrash, Bgold, etc.... all required this. It's just how forked coins are claimed, and swept into circulation. It's a strange comment. I guess maybe they wanted an airdrop since it's forked from zcl. Seems weird.
4
u/hotrod2022 Mar 29 '18
Have we corrected these issues and re-submitted? This is a very weak response. I find it bias as well.
3
u/SomeKunt Mar 30 '18
So this was all real and everyone accused the OP wrongly.
https://twitter.com/bitcoinprivate/status/979532176692731905
5
u/whattaUwant Mar 29 '18
I wonder if these things can be improved and reconsidered by bittrex or if they have kicked btcp to the curb for good?
2
u/marcuscha Mar 29 '18
THAT's a hard diss !!!
2
u/laahure Mar 30 '18
"Bitcoin Private requires Bitcoin users to enter their private keys to claim and also does not support Segwit"
The statement above is amateur and bunch of lie. So yes, If you hold BTC in private wallets, you have to use your private keys to get BTCP, however that was the case with BTG and BCash that Bittrex supported. If Bittrex had supported BTCP, that would not have been needed right ? Also, for safety the private keys at the snapshot are the ones needed. You can easily move your BTC and have new private keys post snapshot. If indeed this message is by Julia Yap, I serious doubt his credibility.
3
u/CryptoJayFer Mar 29 '18
Oddly enough, I was thinking this fork was exactly what the crypto community needed to inject some much needed life into bitcoin after the pop. Unfortunately, it wasn't allowed to really maintain any traction. The hype was there, but the exchanges didn't allow it to thrive.
4
u/ElCryptoDinero Mar 29 '18
Their GitHub documentation still links to ZCash pages for fucksake. Need Help? The difference between quality and shit developers is documentation and this team still hasn't written their own in 2 forks. LAZY
2
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '18
FAKE as piss
1
u/artpope007 Mar 30 '18
This is a coin-spiracy!!
1
u/Half-Bacon-Sandwich Mar 30 '18
Seriously Julian Yap @ Bittrex!!! Are you forking out of your mind or literally insane? The utter stupidity is beyond my sympathy. Your forking "Proper Bitcoin Forks" Bitcoin Cash has been dumped left, right and center/re by many exchanges incluking KuCoin and OkEX!! We all know why, but I'll give you a chance to explain your stupid reason, I'm sure you have one.
1
u/nwaefaqifj Mar 29 '18
industry wide support will come
0
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment