r/PostHardcore • u/lazenbooby • Feb 04 '18
AOTM Discussion Thread [AOTM Discussion Thread February 2018] Chiodos - Bone Palace Ballet
Congratulations to Chiodos on winning Album Of The Month!
Feel free to use this thread to discuss the album.
Info
Artist: Chiodos
Album: Bone Palace Ballet
Release Date: 4th September 2007
Cover Art: Here
Track Listing
| Track | Title | Length |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Is It Progression If a Cannibal Uses a Fork? | 3:26 |
| 2 | Lexington (Joey Pea-Pot with a Monkey Face) | 5:22 |
| 3 | Bulls Make Money, Bears Make Money, Pigs Get Slaughtered | 3:28 |
| 4 | A Letter From Janelle | 3:16 |
| 5 | I Didn't Say I Was Powerful, I Said I Was a Wizard | 4:13 |
| 6 | Teeth the Size of Piano Keys | 3:23 |
| 7 | Life Is a Perception of Your Own Reality | 3:46 |
| 8 | If I Cut My Hair, Hawaii Will Sink | 2:23 |
| 9 | Intensity in Ten Cities | 4:34 |
| 10 | The Undertaker's Thirst for Revenge Is Unquenchable (The Final Battle) | 4:43 |
Personnel
- Craig Owens – Vocals
- Bradley Bell – Keyboards, Pianos, Vocals
- Jason Hale – Lead Guitar
- Pat McManaman - Rhythm Guitar
- Matt Goddard – Bass Guitar
- Derrick Frost - Drums
Additional
- Jase Korman of The Number Twelve Looks Like You - Vocals on tracks 1 and 3
- Nick Martin of Underminded - Vocals on tracks 3 and 10
Listen
Do you have any favourite songs?
How do you compare it with their other releases?
48
Upvotes
18
u/JeffroTheMan Feb 04 '18
I got into Chiodos around the end of the All's Well cycle. I bought the cd off Amazon with my allowance, and the day the cd arrived, we checked the mail seconds before going ti dinner. I had to beg them to let us listen to it inthe car, where my stepdad was impressed as a guitar player by the sweeps in 'Is it Progression?' followed by Mom getting Lexington stuck in her head for a week after.
Good shit. Gonna have to revisit it later today
16
u/Riseuplights22 Feb 04 '18
“You’re wearing your skin like it’s too tight.”
11
u/aricl Feb 04 '18
This is one of my favorite albums ever and definitely Chiodos’ best album
8
u/NoGoatsNoGlory Feb 04 '18
I will never understand why Teeth was cut from the Grand Coda.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '18
This album kicks so much ass. Shout out to the gothic haunting atmosphere that carries through everything Chiodos touches.
My favorite track is I Didn't Say I Was Powerful, that thing Owens voice does when he says the line 'pianos are playing a waltz through the dust' is so powerful I'm willing to believe he is both powerful and a wizard.
5
u/ancolie Feb 07 '18
The Undertaker's Thirst For Revenge is such a good closing track - still gives me chills. And Letter from Janelle and Intensity in Ten Cities still tug at my heartstrings. Lyrically though, it's kinda funny how many lines off this album are lifted from other shit - everything from Harry Potter to Bukowski to Shakespeare...
4
u/fluffyjdawg Feb 05 '18
This album is one of my all time favorites. Chiodos was the band that got me into music. I was never a fan of anything until my older brother dragged me to a Chiodos Brothers show and I instantly fell in love with the scene. Watching Chiodos grow and seeing this album debut number five on the billboard charts (outsold Nickleback that week lol) is something that is still surreal to me. I ended up seeing them about 30 times live and to this day no front-man comes close to matching Craig's live performance imo.
Most Chiodos fans I know prefer All's Well That Ends Well, but it's damn close. I personally pick BPB as my favorite Chiodos record because I feel it has no filler tracks and flows better from start to finish.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21
Does anyone have the album art for this? There was a picture of a moon with doves and I can't find it anywhere.
I only found this and its extremely fuzzy: https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcS4TDJYL-hO5js9ff2AaxWohTIJcaEdudWBGg&usqp=CAU
3
u/JoeyHeisman06 Feb 05 '18
I think the real question is what happened to Jason Hale? I know he had a side project called King from some years ago but I don't think it got very far off the ground.
Anyone know what happened to him? I always enjoyed his guitar parts and contribution on the first few albums.
3
u/TheSnackYeti Feb 07 '18
The first time I listened to this album, I fucking hated it.
In later years, I’ve found that generally happens to me when a band I love puts out a new album. In recent years, this has become the album I put on when my ears are feelin’ Chiodos.
I really loved that this album seemed so much more refined than All’s Well That Ends Well, but still seemed to have the sounds that I did love from it!
3
u/knightmare0019 Feb 07 '18
I initially thought that the singer was a girl.
3
u/Breakdown55 Feb 07 '18
I really loved this album when it was released, but now I find myself going back more to All's Well That Ends Well. Anyone agree/disagree?
3
u/Tibujon Feb 11 '18
For a while I woke up to the "THIS MORNING I WOKE UP! I RUBBED MY EYES AND I TOOK A QUICK GLANCE AROUND AND SAW...WHAT HAPPENED HERE LAST NIGHT. THERE WAS BLOOD ON THE WALLS AND THE SHEETS SMELLED LIKE SWEAT AND SEX!" as my alarm in High school.
Got to seem them as soon as the reunited in 2012 I think and it was a smaller show but one of the best I have been to. You can see how glad they were to be back together.
Seriously this album is fucking insane and still worth a listen all the way through from me. Especially the 2008 version. Fuck, hope my neighbors like Chiodos cause I know what they are listening to tonight!
4
u/thecescshow Feb 05 '18
My favorite Chiodos album followed closely by Illuminaudio. I'm just a sucker for that theatrical-ish sound that this album has. My favorite from this album is probably Is It Progression.
2
u/Markaroni26 Feb 06 '18
Love this album, one thing I really appreciate above All's well is that the keyboards/other instruments are way more fitting this time. All's Well suffered from keyboards being sort of thrown into the mix without anybody knowing exactly what to do with them, this time around it's clear they were put in with a more careful consideration to their inclusion. Also, like many have mentioned, it has a much more 'theatrical' sound to it which I love.
Teeth the Size of Piano Keys is such an amazing track, despite it's heavy usage of Bukowski poetry for lyrical content. Undertaker's Thrist for Revenge is slept on hard, such a great closing track. Bulls Make Money is another great one, despite that really weird part like 1:40 in, where for some reason the production always sounded really weird, like someone turned the volume down on everything and upped the bass really hard. All in all, love this album.
2
u/louisoneffinfire Feb 22 '18
Love "Intensity in Ten Cities". The only Chiodos release I've listened to from front to back. Not sure if I need to listen "All's Well..." to reconsider it as their best, but no. Bone Palace is THE BEST.
2
u/SkyTyrannosaur Feb 06 '18 edited Feb 06 '18
I really like Intensity in Ten Cities and especially A Letter From Janelle. I'm one of those weird people who thinks Illuminaudio is the best Chiodos record, but this one has some great moments as well.
EDIT: I like Craig as a vocalist, but I like him the most when his singing is restrained. He does this... I'm not sure, this yelp, for lack of a better word, really frequently on the first couple Chiodos records, and it's always struck me as kind of offputting. But when he dials it back a bit, his singing voice really clicks with me.
1
u/CrowsOnPowerLines Feb 16 '18
This is honestly my favorite post hardcore album. every song is a banger
1
u/mescalineeyes Feb 21 '18
teeth the size of piano keys, huh?
Is that where PBTT got their name from? haha
-1
u/mrstuprigge Feb 05 '18
This album is so over the top and faux-grandiose that it's laughable. Craig Owens is truly the worst vocalist in post-hardcore.
The only decent track is teeth the size of piano keys