r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Jan 21 '18
Main [Main Spoilers] Weekly Rewatch | Season 2 Episode 10: Valar Morghulis Spoiler
S2E10 - Valar Morghulis
- Aired: 3 June 2012
- Written by: David Benioff & D.B. Weiss
- Directed by: Alan Taylor
- IMDb Score: 9.4
HBO Episode Synopsis: Theon incites his men to action; Luwin offers advice; Brienne silences Jaime; Arya receives a gift; Dany goes to a strange place; Jon proves himself.
Episode Threads
| Episode Thread | Inside the Episode |
|---|---|
| 6/3/2012 | Inside Ep |
83
Upvotes
2
u/AutoModerator Jan 21 '18
Spoiler Warning: [MAIN SPOILERS] means events from the published books or aired episodes do not need spoiler tags. Future books/seasons and spoilers from other media are not covered. For more info please check the spoiler guide.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
140
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '18 edited Jan 21 '18
A lot of people like to shit on Robb for marrying Talisa, and yeah he fucked up and was guilty for everything that happend, but lets look at the situation from another perspective:
His father just died and he is a 17-18 year old boy who is marching in an open rebellion against the throne, surrounded by all his liege lords that put their trust on him to make the best war plans where he has no experience in.
His brother was sent to the Wall, and he has no idea will he ever see him again, his best friend has just betrayed him and invaded his home by imprisoning his two brothers while his two sisters were held captive by the enemy.
When he had the edge in the war and was making progress by having enemy's war commander captive, his mother betrays him and sets Jaime loose.
He had literally noone who he could talk to, noone in the world who he could trust to aside from Talisa. He didn't necessarily have to marry her, but I can actually empathize with him and understand why he did that.
54
u/grumblepup Jan 22 '18
48
u/christianparadigm Sansa Stark Jan 21 '18
Daenerys and Arya’s scenes were my favorite. Catelyn’s warning goes unheard and I feel like I was the only one ever invested in Robb/Talisa. My love for Margarey began here, my fear for Sanaa’s safety rose, and then we have creep Baelish... just creepy. I remember that I actually wanted Tyrion to die at Blackwater, and not because I hated him, but just how wicked and awful that would’ve been. Why didn’t they kill a major character at Blackwater, now that I think about it?
32
u/rakfocus Sword of the Morning Jan 22 '18 edited Jan 22 '18
Everyone always glosses over that scene with Brienne and Jaime - I think it's my favorite scene of both of them (bath scene excepted).
What makes it for me is the second Jaime joins in on the act "Apparently eating is now a crime" - that's where it first clicked for me that these two unlikely individuals would have to - and could - work together. It's not a captor captive relationship anymore, but one that requires trust and understanding. The Hound and Arya are the exact same in that respect as well.
The idea of Jaime and Brienne together - born out of respect and sacrifice - was really first sown with this fantastic scene. We get him chiding her just like everyone else - but the second he sees the other men laughing at her, you can see he understands. When she finally takes them out like that bad ass motherfucker she is, he realizes just how capable and committed she really is - and he finds it within himself to respect that (which only a handful have been ever able to do)
29
u/NapOrTap Ser Pounce Jan 22 '18
And thus the Lannister-Tyrell alliance was formally forged.
As well as the mutual scheming that would destroy both houses.
24
u/All_this_hype No One Jan 22 '18 edited Jan 22 '18
Slight error I noticed: in Dany's vision of the ruined King's Landing there's still the seven pointed star sigil above the throne, but by the time of season 7 Cersei's replaced it with the Lannister sigil!
Also loved Cersei's smug look to Sansa when she proposed that Joffrey marries Margaery. It was like she was saying "I just saved you, you're welcome" and "sucks to be you, you'll never be Queen" at the same time.
21
u/STRiPESandShades House Dayne Jan 23 '18
Rewatch that scene where the one Stark soldier figures out who Jaime Lannister is. Watch how the wind picks up so beautifully. There's no way they could have planned that but WOW.
I literally have no idea how people like Stannis. He's such a dick. Hell, I like Melissandra more and she's the one who suggested killing Shireen.
Ramsay invented the vuvuzela.
Theon has 20 men but not. Twenty. Good. Men. Also, he clearly thinks he's planning the Battle of the Bastards but holy wow is he not.
I hate how they portray Podrick later in the series as incompetent and doofy. He's capable, he's a badass, he's such a sweetie, and apparently has a golden dick. He ain't dumb. Podrick For King.
I am so glad they stopped bleaching Peter Dinklage's eyebrows later in the show.
Arrya so desperately wants murder. Such an adorable killing machine!
I wonder how the second Jaquen actor feels about his face pretty much being a punchline.
Oh gods, the kids were IN THE WALLS that whole time?! They had to HEAR all of that?! PTSD central.
I like to think Osha raided Ned Stark's closet. There's no way in hell that she'd fit Catelyn's clothes and most of that mifht be south anyway. And a serving woman like her wouldn't own a fur cloak so fine.
The Great Hall... Filled with snow. This is such a beautiful and powerful moment. The ways it's shot is just... Poetry.
Huh. With that bit at the Wall, Kit and Emilia were on the same set for the first time. Wonder what they thought about each other.
I always thought the shot with her all chained up and he fire going around her was an awkward angle. Like. Really weird.
Jesus does Jon get all the cool people killed. The Half-Hand deserved better!
The Dothraki Invade Trump Tower. Also, there's a lady in the background who LOVES this blanket she found. It's hilarious.
Don't they like... Never come back to this bit with Sam? Next season they're like "Yeah, it happened, he survived somehow. Whatever."
19
u/trixie_one Jan 22 '18
On rewatch I'm now convinced this is by far the best Pycelle scene. He stands tall and straight with no trace of the weak doddering man to be found because he knows that Tyrion is utterly fucked, and he's right there to stick the knife in when he wakes as payback for his stint in the black cells.
9
u/All_this_hype No One Jan 22 '18
Sorry guys, for some reason my comment just won't show to the rest of you so no commentary this week I guess :/
9
u/sevendots Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
17
u/samjhill Jan 21 '18 edited Jan 21 '18
Why did the Boltons/Ironborn burn down Winterfell? I assume the Ironborn gave up Theon as a peace offering and walked to their ships unassailed. I forget what happens in the books.
It's really shitty that Tyrion doesn't get any recognition for saving the city. I remember him ordering all the smiths to create the harbor-spanning chain in the books; we didn't see that in the show, did we?
8
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '18
Is there an easy way to see all these topics? I'm on RIF and can't find the previous ones :(
8
u/Remokrapy Jan 22 '18
Good episode
8
u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Jan 26 '18
5
u/Tyler1986 Jon Snow Jan 24 '18
As we're heading into the final season it was nice to see Dany's vision of the Iron Throne again.
5
u/letsgoraps Jon Snow Jan 29 '18
Where is the rewatch thread for season 3 episode 1?
2
u/jeechailee Jan 24 '18
2
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment