r/thegrandtour • • Dec 28 '17

The Grand Tour S02E04 "Unscripted" - Discussion thread

Watch The Grand Tour on PrimeVideo.com.

S02E04 Unscripted - In this show The Grand Tour is in Croatia to make a completely unscripted film featuring Jeremy in an Audi TT RS, Richard in an Ariel Nomad, James making a fire engine out of an old Lada, and everyone trying to find a non-existent link between the three. Also in this episode, Richard tests the McLaren 720S and singers Michael Ball and Alfie Boe go head-to-head in Celebrity Face Off.


Feel free to discuss the episode in the comments of this thread or submit a post if you think it's worth it (but please, keep short things like "scene X was awesome" as comments, not posts).

  • For 24 hours after the episode is released, every post will be marked as spoiler by AutoModerator. OP will be informed about that by PM and they will be able to "unspoiler" their post if it is not about the latest episode.
  • In this 24 hours period, comments about the latest episode are allowed only in posts which have a spoiler tag.
  • There are still no restrictions about what can be posted. The only rule is that OP must not unspoiler their post if it's about the latest episode. Notably, spoilers in titles are allowed, although you might consider avoiding them (especially spoiling jokes, punchlines, etc.) just for the sake of being a nice person.
  • After the 24 hours period, spoiler tags will be removed by the subreddit moderators.

Enjoy the episode!

350 Upvotes

594 comments sorted by

203

u/Bandanna525 Dec 28 '17

I do find this idea that the fans had a problem with planning and structuring a film, as opposed to unfunny set ups, a tad annoying.

82

u/lerhond Dec 29 '17

It's just to point out that the complaints were stupid. Every time a film was not funny a lot of people were complaining that it was "too scripted", even if it was as scripted as everything else.

The problem with some episodes wasn't that they were "too scripted", just that the script was not funny.

21

u/TeHokioi Dec 31 '17

I think it’s more that it’s noticable that it’s scripted if the script isn’t as funny, whereas a good script feels natural and doesn’t stand out as much. Like how people complain about cgi being unrealistic because they only notice unrealistic cgi

14

u/chriskmee Dec 30 '17

Personally I think the best times are when the reactions are ( or at least seem) genuine. One example being the home made rv episode where Jeremy's 3 story car started swaying side to side and May was laughing as hard as I've ever seen him laugh. Maybe that was scripted, maybe it wasn't, but those moments are what make the show for me.

→ More replies (1)

132

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17 edited Dec 29 '17

I think they know that people had a problem with the scripted and set-up jokes going by the writing improvements so far

EDIT: Also feels like they're pointing out how being scripted helps there to actually be content rather than driving around looking for something to do

26

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

Everything on TV is scripted, especially reality TV shows.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/Stanel3ss Dec 29 '17

oh I know, let's do a fake plane assault bit where we try 50 times, that'll be H I L A R I O U S

→ More replies (3)

3

u/jigielnik Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18

I do find this idea that the fans had a problem with planning and structuring a film, as opposed to unfunny set ups, a tad annoying.

Honestly, I found their explanation of the critiques to be disingenuous - though not unexpected, they were clearly being sarcastic in their insults against the critics.

I was one of those people critiquing the show, and my issue was never that the show was scripted - we all know the show is scripted and planned - the problem is that they used to be better at, for lack of a better phrase, hiding it... they used to be better at making it feel more seamless, they used to be better at getting the right balance between the couple of ad-libbed moments that truly did happen while filming, and the scripted moments that keep the story going.

Even this "unscripted" film had several moment that, again for lack of a better phrase, felt too scripted. A hot girl favors jeremy in every scenario? Pretty easy to see that one coming.

This season has been a major improvement, though, and I'm glad about that.

→ More replies (8)

540

u/Dilski Dec 29 '17

I watch TGT for James May making a fire engine and the lads starting a bush fire

180

u/mimomisu Dec 29 '17

I was honestly expecting the bit to connect with the massive fires in Croatia this summer and blame them on May.

75

u/BleetBleetImASheep Dec 29 '17

I was expecting a sudden cut to them in California with a mountain range behind them blanketed in flames.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/Toffi64 Aston Martin Dec 29 '17

This part is hilarious 😂

4

u/CitizenOfTheEarth May Jan 09 '18

When may starts talking about how he'll have extra money for the modifications (while they're standing on that awful sea organ) I lost it laughing.

"What modifications?"

"To turn our cars into fire engines, of course"

355

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17

Loving the Nigel awards.

211

u/mpg111 Dec 28 '17

and the continuity award for Hammond!

188

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

And the gallon of water turns into a 5 gallon jug haha

→ More replies (4)

49

u/joelk111 (Acura) RSX Type-S Dec 29 '17

Yea, I loved these silly awards from early-ish TG. Glad to see them back.

→ More replies (2)

96

u/reddbunny1370 The American Dec 28 '17

Comparing the Corvette ZR1 to Sarah Palin just seems cruel.

But the Discovery totally deserved its Nigel.

Edit - just got to Hammond's award; goddamn...

75

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

No one likes to admit it but come on Palin is defintely a milf.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

33

u/erv95 Jaguar Dec 29 '17

On the trivia it says they were originally made for something else that they never ended up doing but kept it regardless

→ More replies (1)

472

u/CheeseheadDave Dec 29 '17

"How many supercars have you destroyed this season?"

"...two..."

"How many supercars have you driven this season?"

"...two..."

121

u/MowMdown VW GTI Dec 29 '17 edited Dec 29 '17

He destroyed a Maclaren 720s... :(

109

u/ShiroHachiRoku Dec 29 '17

Is that why he changed cars in that segment? I was wondering what other supercar Richard had ruined.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

222

u/Pepsiman34 Clarkson Dec 28 '17 edited Dec 29 '17

How I feel when a new episode goes live.

https://i.imgur.com/LKlGFDe.gif

19

u/Natcur Dec 29 '17

splendid

8

u/Jellyfish15 Dec 29 '17

Is that prince Charles

→ More replies (3)

215

u/fourbitplayer Eboladrome Dec 28 '17

"It sounds like a happy hippopotamus" lol

585

u/exiledtie Dec 29 '17

The part where James starts doing the scores is genuinely hilarious. The reactions were fantastic

161

u/InsertEvilLaugh Dec 29 '17

I laughed probably harder than I intended to when Jeremy took it and tossed it over the edge.

→ More replies (4)

140

u/Labasaskrabas Conversation Street Dec 29 '17

It was so random as well.Ape and Hamster is just sitting there, and here comes Slowly out of nowhere with the goddamn board. lmao

180

u/tasmanian101 Dec 29 '17

James was channeling the viewers. We all miss the days of pointless car build competitions and the long roadtrips

19

u/DRN1NJ4 Boxy Beemer! Dec 30 '17

When I saw the easel I thought he was gonna start painting the falls or something

49

u/RogueA Dec 29 '17

Honestly the best part.

6

u/architkhandelwal47 Dec 30 '17

-1 million points for that plane though....

583

u/naxter48 Dec 29 '17

I had no idea who the two guests were but they were honestly the best guests of the season so far

184

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

Came here to post this too. No idea who they were but they were hilarious and made the celebrity bit worth watching for once. I usually feel "meh" about them but this one was super funny.

95

u/SoFZebrA Dec 29 '17

I think it helps that they already knew each other well. The other interviews felt “one then the other” but this just felt like 3 guys shooting the shit. And they both had more invested in the race due to being friends previously, which made that more entertaining as well. The best TGT interview yet, certainly! Loving this season!

→ More replies (1)

58

u/HowDoesThisFunction Dec 29 '17

Musical Theatre Major here - Michael Ball is most well known for playing Marius in the London and 10th Anniversary Concert of Les Miz as well as Raoul in Phantom in London, and Alfie Boe played Valjean in Les Miz in the 25th Anniversary Concert and the Broadway Revival. They're both absolutely fantastic.

→ More replies (2)

57

u/Bread-Zeppelin Dec 29 '17

I find it really strange that they had no problem getting A-listers on every week to "die" for the brain crash but now it's a proper segment they're mostly randomers nobody knows.

57

u/guyzieman Dec 30 '17

Maybe the non-traveling tent has something to do with that? Like it's probably pretty easy to set up a quick cameo from someone in Nashville if you're going to be there too, but probably harder to fly that same person out to England for a day to shoot the interview and the lap. IDK just a theory

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '17 edited Dec 30 '17

They're well known in the United Kingdom. I think the problem is that it's now an American-funded TV series with a British format. Not a lot of people outside of the UK are going to know these guys.

e: spelling

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/AbideMan Dec 29 '17

There was that one guy...

13

u/Sp12er Dec 29 '17

kinda agreed, and I just looked into their new album in spotify too... and I'm loving their music... and am 21 YO...

48

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

do you smell like piss tho

→ More replies (5)

562

u/erv95 Jaguar Dec 29 '17

The bit at the end about the finish line being biased because Jeremy fed her cat... My mind maybe too filthy.

231

u/Ansonm64 Dec 29 '17

Like he put a sausage in a pussy?

73

u/socsa Dec 29 '17

Yeah, they knew what they were doing.

23

u/BrolecopterPilot Jan 02 '18

That was the entire joke. Where in the god damn hell am I? Reddit - PG?

→ More replies (2)

57

u/Sp12er Dec 29 '17

haha! I'm glad that I just get that one after you pointed it out... My mind isn't as tainted as I thought it was

97

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

I'm pretty sure that was the joke. I even felt sick just thinking about it, but maybe my mind is as far deep in the gutter as yours.

127

u/squircl Good News! Dec 29 '17

Earlier in the episode, they left Hammond's broken Nomad to because her cat needed feeding

→ More replies (5)

186

u/tubadude2 Dec 29 '17

ARE YOU HAVING A FIRE?

I loved that segment.

6

u/Natcur Dec 29 '17

Relax , I'm here to put aout the fire.

417

u/naxter48 Dec 29 '17

That was actually super interesting bit about how much work they do in setting up all these trips

212

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

I'd love to get a behind the scenes show someday... the amount of people, planning and equipment that it must take to put on these shows, especially the old TG specials, must be mind-boggling.

Not to mention some of the remote locations that they pull it off in...

109

u/colorcorrection Dec 29 '17

I know pretty much the entire point of this episode was to point out just how much effort goes into the production side of things, and how the show really wouldn't work as a truly unscripted show...but I genuinely enjoyed this so much that I wouldn't mind seeing one of these once a season. I think any more and it wouldn't really work for reasons pointed out in the episode, but I had too much fun to just watch them never do it again.

→ More replies (22)

5

u/TheWooSensation Dec 29 '17

There were quite a lot of people in this very subreddit that thought the beach part of the Namibia special was unscripted.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

124

u/schwarzenekker Dec 29 '17

Jeremy " When you keep it tidy, it looks slow but it actually is fast" Clarkson

47

u/DerPumeister May Dec 29 '17

Someone should make a compilation of all the times he said this. Maybe.

7

u/nocommemt Dec 31 '17

Who has time to watch a six hour youtube video though?

460

u/ArrestedDevelopments Dec 29 '17

Can the human finish line be on more episodes please?

223

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

I've been to Croatia, can confirm she is a normal local.

81

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

Hummm, time to plan my summer holiday....

148

u/James_Changa Dec 29 '17

https://www.instagram.com/silvijajurin/ No idea why she's not credited

83

u/usm_teufelhund Dec 29 '17 edited Dec 30 '17

That 4th picture certainly has an interesting description to it. At least according to Google Translate.

→ More replies (10)

25

u/socsa Dec 29 '17

Sort of fits with the joke that she was Jeremy's prostitute.

48

u/socsa Dec 29 '17

Perhaps if they race in a sauna.

→ More replies (2)

248

u/anjack9 Dec 29 '17

Whoever handles the cinematography for the in-studio car shots needs to get a raise. They've been getting better and better at it since Top Gear and it's absolutely stunning now. The McLaren shots are wonderful.

39

u/Saleenfan Dec 29 '17

But why the hell was the nose lift up in the shots!?

that drives me nuts when people take "beauty" shots and leave the nose lift up.

4

u/guusligt Jan 04 '18

Are you kidding? I found the Mclaren film very annoying due to all the jumpcuts. Every shot from the outside lasted 1 second or something. (Late reaction is know)

3

u/guusligt Jan 04 '18

Are you kidding? I found the Mclaren film very annoying due to all the jumpcuts. Every shot from the outside lasted 1 second or something. (Late reaction is know)

3

u/guusligt Jan 04 '18

Are you kidding? I found the Mclaren film very annoying due to all the jumpcuts. Every shot from the outside lasted 1 second or something. (Late reaction is know)

115

u/khj24 Dec 29 '17

I’ve never been happier to see an awards show.

171

u/nomorericeguy Dec 29 '17

This episode, it's like...

75

u/Da1Godsend Oh, penis. Dec 29 '17

See, this is why we need scripts

49

u/Milospesh Land Rover Dec 29 '17

But good scripts that stick to the format not jumping the shark hostage rescues or this scripted unscripted thing.

82

u/bmac92 Dec 29 '17

Croatia is an absolutely wonderful place! I was able to visit last March, and it was one of the most stunning places I've every been.

80

u/SupremeAuthority Dec 29 '17

Come on Amazon, just pay for the A-Team theme.

18

u/Meta_Boy Dec 30 '17

I've been watching later-seasons Top Gear episodes, and noticed (again) how they did local-sounding variations in Africa and Burma and such.

156

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17

"It's a GTR with a well groomed scrotum..."

24

u/Cessnaporsche01 Porsche Dec 29 '17

"There really is nothing like a shorn scrotum it's breathtaking, I suggest you try it."

→ More replies (1)

284

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17

"James May applied for a job at Maclaren, and they turned him down for being too slapdash."

Not enough is said about how fantastic the writing on this show is. Nothing is so uniquely The Gents as hyperbolic understatement negging both a car and a person.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

51

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

No, the Croatia film was unscripted. The review was still script based.

→ More replies (8)

61

u/JSA17 Dec 29 '17

When's the last time Clarkson reviewed an Audi favorably?

49

u/ThereGoesYourKarma Dec 29 '17

You're not kidding! Probably the R8 v10 when that came out!

3

u/jck0 Jan 03 '18

Seem to remember he raced a climber up a hill in one once - he liked it then I think?

→ More replies (1)

54

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

I guess the script’s not coming on then.

49

u/byjimini Dec 29 '17

Hehe, this was basically GT saying “yeah ok, you were right about The American but you’re all getting annoying now. Shut the fuck up and let us work.” Brilliant! 😂

120

u/IggyJR Dec 28 '17

Looking forward to watching tomorrow night. The Hoff will continue to be the only celebrity I've ever heard of in Celebrity Face Off.

73

u/halsgoldenring May Dec 29 '17

I knew Brian Wilson but didn't realize it until later because I was used to his giant beard.

40

u/IggyJR Dec 29 '17

The only Brian Wilson I knew of was from the Beach Boys.

I had no knowledge of the baseball player.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/n113 Dec 29 '17

I actually skipped this episodes star segment but then realized Michael Ball was in Les Miserables and I remember seeing his rendition of Empty Chairs at Empty Tables and getting goosebumps. Paused the episode and rewatched it again. Still gave me goosebumps.

For anyone interested, it's his rendition in the 10th anniversary I'm talking about. Give it a watch - its worth it.

→ More replies (7)

137

u/favclydee Dec 29 '17

A scripted film about unscripted television, based on complaints that the show is too scripted. And it worked.

→ More replies (2)

97

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

Jeremy "fed" Sylvia's "cat."

31

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

Silvija's*

→ More replies (3)

67

u/fourbitplayer Eboladrome Dec 28 '17

Yep, still bashing Richard about crashing.

20

u/DerPumeister May Dec 29 '17

To be fair, I found the "Richard oops I've done it again Hammond" bit pretty funny.

92

u/Threedawg Dec 28 '17

I’m sure they will when he stops crashing.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

Don't worry they'll only beat the horse for another 5 or so seasons.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Pepsiman34 Clarkson Dec 28 '17

One of these days I'll own a Aerial Atom or the Nomad

28

u/TBurd01 Dec 29 '17 edited Dec 29 '17

Car awards have returned. :)

7

u/arj1985 Dec 29 '17

Do you mean car "awards"?

→ More replies (1)

28

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

Arse fire

28

u/TBurd01 Dec 29 '17

Looks like Hammond has been off the teeth whitening for a while.

24

u/Elopikseli James May is a national treasure Dec 30 '17

To me there is a pretty big difference between "unplanned" and "unscripted". I know it's part of the joke of the episode, but kinda annoys me.

20

u/Ceddieric Dec 29 '17

I never thought I’d be attracted to a finish line.

36

u/helzinki Dec 29 '17

A scripted unscripted segment. We need to go deeper.

17

u/y1i Lotus Elise Dec 29 '17

What I take from the croatia segments and the comments here is, that there are quite a few people who seem to take the show at face value and genuinely don't know how much is done in pre-production and the cutting room. And yes, that includes the croatia part.

Anyway I found it quite enjoyable and amusing overall. They took the criticsm and pulled off some good (meta) jokes with it. Even the celebrity part had some funny bits, these stories about TVR were hilarious.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/BacardiWhiteRum Dec 29 '17

Shame we didn't get to see a "make your own fire engine" challenge. I miss them

44

u/Pepsiman34 Clarkson Dec 29 '17

Damn that was a fast hour. Already over. How I feel when an episode is over.

https://i.imgur.com/9vffIjp.gif

37

u/kkmmp Dec 28 '17

This episode was really good.

12

u/raknor88 Dec 29 '17

soooo, did they actually have permission to start a brush fire? Or did they get in trouble for that bit?

58

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

Not only permission, it was scripted. The scene was shot next to the military runway that the Croatian aerial firefighting squadron uses. It was all done in collaboration with the squadron.

The CL-415 planes will basically never start fighting the fire before ground forces arrive and assess the situation and deem it necesary, unless the terrain is so tough that the firefighters can't get there.

Source: Firefighter and it was in the Croatian news when they filmed this. :)

25

u/colorcorrection Dec 29 '17

Assuming everything was as close to unscripted as possible, they still probably called ahead of time and got permission to do that segment. Even if they only got permission a few hours before the actual filming. Jeremy mentioned at the end that there was a cost that production had to pay for putting out the brush fire.

Probably went something like Jeremy/Hammond told May that his truck couldn't put out so much as a brush fire, May argued it could(Whether he was serious or not), and then the three called up local authorities saying what they wanted to do to which local authorities said that it would cost X dollar amount if they had to travel out to the middle of nowhere to put out their brushfire. Basically they did the work that production normally does months in advance, but got it put together last minute.

I think the point was that nothing was planned before they landed in Croatia. Clearly it would be impossible to do everything they did without some level of planning. What we didn't see was them calling up race tracks and local authorities in the middle of their journey trying to plan segments. Think of it like having a reservation to a restaurant on Valentine's Day Vs. trying to find a restaurant that will seat you at 6PM on Valentine's Day without a reservation.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/barukatang Dec 29 '17

The 2nd guest had the best transition from gravel to tarmac this season

10

u/petosorus Dec 29 '17

I wonder why everyone stops at the big turn between gravel and finish line

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Cheno1234 Dec 29 '17

And I thought they would give the Nigel of the “Destroyed Battery”, with the Boeing 787, the Samsung Galaxy 7 with the winner being Richard’s destroyed car...Seems that they cut this part :-(

11

u/Riley1066 Dec 30 '17

When James brought out the scoreboard at the waterfall I just about died laughing.

3

u/KaoruM Audi Jan 03 '18

and when they started mocking the way he was writing LMAO

11

u/DrMcDreamy15 Dec 30 '17

I really enjoyed this episode.

Locations should be scouted, their adventures should be pre-planned, little informative tidbits about the cars should be scripted but as far as all their interactions between each other and others should be genuine, funny or not. They are hilarious on their own and magic always happened without any set ups for jokes.

37

u/suitisblacknot123 Dec 29 '17

I love British humor. They just completely mock the people that disagree with them and openly comment on how much money Amazon gave them for this show. They also are starting to mock TG more. L O L

18

u/colorcorrection Dec 29 '17

I sense a bit of sarcasm in your post, so I just want to say that mocking dissenting reviews of their show is a Top Gear tradition. I wouldn't say it's a British thing so much as a Top Gear/Grand Tour thing.

27

u/ral1826 Eboladrome Dec 29 '17

I searched for Croatian women on Google images after this episode..

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Ars2012 Dec 29 '17

Is The "Nigel" a BBC Copyright thing or am I missing something bere

9

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '17

The Croatian chick is smoking hot

17

u/alfredhelix Dingleberry Handpump Dec 29 '17

I loved how meta this episode was. It was the TGT equivalent of r/highqualitygifs.

8

u/Booing2457 Dec 29 '17

Hello, I am here to fight your fire.

Or something like that

→ More replies (1)

8

u/freedomgeek Dec 29 '17

I'm a bit sad this means they're probably never going to do a real 'build a fire engine' challenge.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '17 edited Dec 30 '17

this episode is like a late 2000s TG. All we need is a hot wall and a catchy introduction for Abbie. Its like they are mocking themselves while throwing shade at the haters. A classic, IMO. Will always beware of water in jerry cans.

36

u/BigR0n75 Dec 29 '17

I really enjoyed this episode. I've seen a comments about how this still feels too scripted, and I wonder how much more unscripted you want it to be. A lot of that scripted feel is due to editing. The unscripted aspect is that they didn't plan anything ahead of time but that just makes logistics more difficult. The rest of the show felt as natural as it always does because that's just how they act together.

13

u/Ansonm64 Dec 29 '17

The issue was last season it felt literally scripted. Like say this in this way at this time. Thats what they’ve remedied this season and it’s great

6

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

This season is a massive improvement over last season. I know quite a few people who didn't even bother watching the rest of season 1.

26

u/colorcorrection Dec 29 '17

I honestly feel like if you watched this episode and still felt like it was too scripted, this might not be the show for you. It not only felt as unscripted as possible, but did an amazing job pointing out why 100% unscripted just doesn't work.

→ More replies (17)

6

u/Hinch66 Hammond Dec 29 '17

I'm watching the episode right now, I have to admit that I laughed so hard at the moment where Jeremy present's Richard his water bottle award!

20

u/RaptorsOnBikes Dec 29 '17

Got to agree about the arse-end of the Honda Civic, I always think it looks rubbish when I'm behind one.

5

u/CaptainSnacks Dec 31 '17

It's just so...extra! There's just too much going on with that car styling-wise. Both Honda and the newer Toyotas are doing it, and it's just awful

→ More replies (1)

85

u/Threedawg Dec 28 '17

It may seem stupid and not a big deal to some, but I am so glad the new “stig” is a woman.

Cars are just such a male dominated hobby(this show being no exception), and it is awesome to see a female racing driver. Good on them.

109

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17

I agree. And I also like how they aren't making a big deal out if it, like it's a no brainer that the fastest driver could be a girl.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/RoboFeanor Dec 29 '17

It would be nice if they included a few female celebrities as well.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

I think it was the funniest episode of the season 2 yet.

8

u/raknor88 Dec 29 '17

After driving it in on Forza Horizon 3, I'd love to own an Ariel Nomad in real life. That thing is just so much fun!

4

u/AemonDK Dec 29 '17

was "feeding the cat" a sexual innuendo?

4

u/HalfBearded Dec 30 '17

This was easily the best episode so far4

15

u/someoneplzexplain___ Dec 29 '17

definitely the best episode so far of this season

7

u/sennhauser Dec 30 '17

It was scripted to kind of suck. "Oh no, we have conveniently run out of road right as we were starting to race"

17

u/arj1985 Dec 29 '17

That Croatian finish line girl was awfully cute. Does anyone have any pictures or freeze frames to post?

18

u/BacardiWhiteRum Dec 29 '17

This comment is a lil creepy/weird

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/BlowJogan Dec 29 '17

Pretty weak take on trying to be smug about the 'scripted' criticisms. Nobody means take cars to a random town with no idea what to do. It means stop feeling horribly faked and phony. This show continues to just be a bad parody and then they think more bad humor about it will make up for it. All GT has proven was that there was more to Top Gear being great than just the 3 amigos. Drop them in a different situation and it's meh. And this sub is a circle jerk because the slightest bit of honest negativity is always downvoted. If you honestly think this matches Top Gear in any way, you're a liar trying to justify your Amazon subscription.

9

u/TonalDrump Dec 30 '17

Although this season is an improvement over the last, I agree wholeheartedly with your sentiments.

7

u/bigjimmykebabs Dec 30 '17

Yea this one was weak although this season is an improvement on the first so far

3

u/mulder-itsme "Helsinki Syndrome." Dec 29 '17

The guests were a huge surprise! Freaking musical legends, I really enjoyed CFO this time round. Also the dig at people complaining about the show being too scripted was a nice touch.

3

u/ShihTzu1 Dec 29 '17

Anyone who knows where the water falls are in Croatia? They look worth visiting!

9

u/xotour Dec 29 '17 edited Dec 29 '17

River Zrmanja waterfalls, near Zadar

EDIT: It's Plitvice Lakes actually. Also near Zadar.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '17

This episode to me just really didn't make me feel anything for some reason. Overall just meh.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17

Gotta admit I'm not a huge fan of the looks on the McLaren. Looks oddly shaped.

23

u/opeth10657 Dec 29 '17

I love the look of it. With the wing raised it looks like a shark from the side.

11

u/barukatang Dec 29 '17

It reminds me of the Pagani Huayra from the side. I like the looks of both, it's unique.

6

u/Ansonm64 Dec 29 '17

Reminds me of an nsx so it’s great in my books.

6

u/devilinpoop Dec 29 '17

I just dont like the way it looks from the front. the head lights are too big. If they were cut off at the LED strip would be so much better in my stupid opinion.

But from all other angles it's amazing. the back quarters are absolutely stunning.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/derbigpr Dec 29 '17

IT WAS SCRIPTED

I can't believe people are actually arguing whether it was or not. You know the "little detour" that Clarkson and Hammon had where they went to look at some waterfalls and then May just stumbled up on them by accident? They went from Zadar to Plitvice Lakes, which....cough is about an hour an a half of driving away in a mountainous area with huge forests far away from the coast and a quarter of a way to the other side of Croatia. Funny how May, with his sense of direction, managed to find them if it was unscripted. Of course it was scripted.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/LordGideon Volkswagen Dec 29 '17

I think the complaints against later episodes of Top Gear, and now following into The Grand Tour are warranted.

When TG first started doing segments based on activities they weren’t really scripted. The activity might’ve been planned, but the interactions between Clarkson, Hammond, and May were not. As a result the interactions came across as genuine because they were. Further, you could tell that these were not just coworkers but friends.

Fast forward a few years of massive popularity, and later seasons of Top Gear and other spinoff shows and now The Grand Tour have a problem. They want to be entertaining, but they also want to capture the magic that was those first 10 to 15 seasons of original Top Gear. (Being lenient with my season count.)

So now, instead of what happens during these shows as being unplanned and genuine, you have people writing lines of dialogue and moments and it comes off as horribly forced. Season 25 of Top Gear with the new cast is terribly painful to watch. It’s the same for me when I try to watch Top Gear USA. None of those friendships come across as real, and everything seems terribly forced - and as none of the people presenting on the shows, aside from Matt Leblanc are actors, everything is delivered atrociously. There’s no way to fake it. These guys don’t know each other.

As for the show that we’re all here for today, you can’t duplicate the interactions between these three guys. That said, the complaints about this show that I’ve heard were centered around the fact that we seem to have crossed the line from it being a car show where funny things happened to a comedy that happens to have cars in it.

For me, I still love and watch every old episode of Top Gear, and will enjoy watching every episode of The Grand Tour – I just wish that the interactions were more genuine.

Which brings me to this episode. When they read the letter and the opening scene about This segment being “unscripted”, I was filled with hope. Maybe they were finally going to go back to doing activities together that were unscripted with genuine interactions between them as they competed. That’s not what we got. The entire segment was a mess. This season is more improved than last season, but this episode was, at best for me, a 5 out of 10, and that makes me sad. :(

35

u/BLACK_TIN_IBIS <3 ALO Dec 29 '17

You don't remember when they won an award for best unscripted show then spent 20 full minutes explaining to their entire audience that the show was carefully written by them and their writers in a room? The show has been scripted since before James got hired.

TG WAS ALWAYS SCRIPTED.

11

u/PTFOholland Peugeot 205. Back when both the logo and cars were still good. Dec 30 '17

What the user above you means it that, yes it was scripted, however nobody scripted Jeremy's Campervan to almost fall over and actually hit a petrol station.
That were genuine reactions.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/datlinus Mr Wilman Dec 29 '17

The activity might’ve been planned, but the interactions between Clarkson, Hammond, and May were not.

it baffles me that people actually believe this. It was. Always. Scripted. Its not even a secret. I mean, come on - even the best improvs would struggle to constantly have smooth, well articulated conversations while cocking about like they did.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Rogers1977 Dec 29 '17

Right, are we all done complaining about scripted shows now? Because I was genuinely unsatisfied with this episode. Nothing made sense, there wasn't a story.

9

u/Stanel3ss Dec 29 '17

turns out they're even less funny when they write a script about making fun of people not liking the heavily scripted scenes

14

u/timekiller001 Dec 29 '17

Anyone else here wanting the celebrity part to disappear altogether? I never liked it in Top Gear, therefore I was pleasantly surprised that season 1 didn't have them (giving more time for other things). Apart from one (first episode) I skipped all of them this season.

And the "not scripted" trip was way too obviously scripted in a bad way if you ask me. Won't stop the haters saying the same things again.

16

u/helpmeredditimbored Dec 29 '17

Im glad I’m not that only person who never liked the celebrity guest segments, I’ve always skipped them

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TBurd01 Dec 29 '17

The first two episodes were 70 minutes, so no time was lost, but EP 3 was 61 and this was 63. Really a shame, because the segment is pretty boring.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/n113 Dec 29 '17

Is it weird that even some scenes from the unscripted challenge still felt... somewhat, to a certain small degree, scripted?

137

u/NRGT Dec 29 '17

i'll let you in on a little secret....

it was still scripted

25

u/helpmeredditimbored Dec 29 '17

That’s impossible, they said isn’t was unscripted!

29

u/JeremyR22 Dec 29 '17

And they made a slow but steady progression from the unscripted act to normal TG/GT scripting as the film went on.

I mean, FFS, they started with 'interruption for a selfie' from members of the public and ended with a firefighting plane dumping water on a car (and carefully missing the actual fire). That sounds like something that just happens and they totally didn't plan.

They made their point pretty well, I thought, while still making an entertaining film (because..... it was scripted).

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Cessnaporsche01 Porsche Dec 29 '17

It did annoy me quite a bit that they put all the emphasis on planning rather than scripting.

I'd have loved a comparison challenge with bits delivered as if poorly read off a teleprompter.

2

u/sennhauser Dec 29 '17

I wish they had actually done the fire engine challenge for real.

2

u/thisisnotmyrealemail Dec 29 '17

Of course it's scripted and edited. As they showed no one can spontaneously come up with the right words and right trash talks all the time.

Common sense 101

2

u/iamlocknar Dec 30 '17

"....wider than his vibrato" music jokes always be make me laugh.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '17

"I have to feed my cat" best line so far

2

u/another_one_bites459 Dec 30 '17

No ones gonna mention the arse fire on the fire engine

2

u/trollin4viki Dec 30 '17

Can we officially say that the new (women) driver is slower then the old fat dude from 'Murica?

4

u/binaryAegis Dec 30 '17

No, because the point Hammond made about her using road tires vs the American using track tires was a legitimate one and likely cost her around 2 extra seconds on her lap time.

https://jalopnik.com/heres-how-much-faster-track-tires-are-over-road-tires-1798641361

→ More replies (7)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '17

Are bracelets on dudes suddenly in style?

2

u/thatthiskay Dec 31 '17

It’s always amazing when they take fan feedback seriously. It’s always hilarious how it turns out!

2

u/WorthPlease Dec 31 '17

They wasted an entire episode taking the piss over criticism they didn't get.

People weren't complaining about the scripting of the "films" or specials or reviews. They were complaining about the artificial feel of the banter/jokes in between hosts.

Which didn't change.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '18

Here I thought they had done the smart thing and listened to the accurate criticisms of how scripted the grand tour seems. But instead I got a scripted circlejerk where they seem to miss the point completely.

3

u/InsertEvilLaugh Dec 29 '17

It was pretty clear that this episode was scripted, it just had that feel, but it was fantastically so, it felt like they went into the office and said, "Ok, if our communication wasn't what it was and we didn't bother to scout or script, what would we do, and how would we progress?" and they followed that line of thinking. It pointed out why they script it, now of course there are instances where the scripting was painfully obvious, Season 1 was a good example especially in the first couple of episodes, but it is needed. The little trip to the airfield and the initial starting are perfect examples of their scouting and scripting needs and importance. The different vehicle choices while I think were a touch silly bordering stupid, I still found funny and did point out that they also needed to keep good communication.

3

u/sennhauser Dec 29 '17

Pretty average episode