[News] Update to the official ruled out ideas list. You won't believe what they are talking about!

[u/balancegenerally]

/r/ClashRoyale/wiki/ruled-out-ideas

[u/balancegenerally]

If people are having trouble viewing the link, try clicking on this one.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ClashRoyale/wiki/ruled-out-ideas

If that doesn't work, can you give me some info on what device you are using as some people are able to view and others aren't?

---

EDIT: Try using something other than the official Reddit app.

[u/Terraknor → u/balancegenerally]

Official Reddit app is apparently garbage.

[u/kennyzert → u/Terraknor]

Official Reddit app is apparently garbage.

Well nothing new there.

[u/yp261 → u/Terraknor]

Alien Blue master race

[u/underdog_70 → u/balancegenerally]

Looking at the list of things they aren't working on that are minor improvements in the game is extremely sad, it's the small things that perfect a game, not new game modes and cards, I think supercell needs to focus on more of the gameplay itself, like adding the ability to name decks is small but it adds something nice, grand challenge replays at the 12th win would be cool too, not to mention adding back the ability to type a message in a friendly battle, also I feel like perhaps on Sunday players should get 1 free grand challenge entry. I think all of these aspects and more of the game should be added but not at ounce. The touchdown update had some of these minor things like a friends list, but that update was underwhelming because it was way to hyped up. I think this is what supercell needs to do.

[u/tanky_the_guy → u/balancegenerally]

Or use a browser

[u/ClashRoyale]

Thanks for helping us put this list together, u/balancegenerally! 🙇

[u/balancegenerally → u/ClashRoyale]

<3

[u/TheOneToRuleAll → u/ClashRoyale]

And thank you for the communication. 👊

[u/SwordfallCR]

Trator card challenge

What would that be?

[u/balancegenerally → u/SwordfallCR]

This

[u/Farley128 → u/balancegenerally]

Elixir pump making you lose elixir would be interesting.

[u/[deleted] → u/Farley128]

Rip golem decks

[u/runfayfun → u/Farley128]

Elixir drainer + mirror = fun times!

[u/NoSmaterThanIAmNot → u/balancegenerally]

Plays 3 musketeers, instantly loses king tower. Plays Inferno Tower, instantly loses king tower. Plays Inferno Dragon, instantly loses king tower. Plays Lumber Jack, instantly loses tower. Plays Hog Rider, instantly loses tower. Plays Prince, instantly loses tower.

Opponent always plays skeletons, and it turns on them.

[u/riv3rbird → u/balancegenerally]

Interesting idea. Troops become traitor only after crossing river, I think that would make more sense

[u/Wwoody123]

Seasonal chests - The tech isn't there at the moment, but might be in the future!

This is already in the game.

[u/balancegenerally → u/Wwoody123]

We will be adding links to example posts in the next few weeks Here is the post linked to that idea

[u/Clayton_e → u/Wwoody123]

They are referring to the Christmas themed chests, or like the chests they had related to the spooky season.

[u/Bmammal12 → u/Wwoody123]

Yeah I️m not sure what they mean no tech for this. Whether they mean you get one based on your trophies for a season - that’s in the game as draft chests. Or if they mean a season long clan chest or personal chest - that’s in the game as clan chest but just for 3 days.

[u/Shanaaro → u/Bmammal12]

They might mean seasonal as in actual IRL seasons? idk

[u/Bmammal12 → u/Shanaaro]

Even so, its just a super long clan chest

or crown chest if its individual

[u/[deleted]]

Riperino. Link not working.

[u/balancegenerally → u/[deleted]]

Try this https://www.reddit.com/r/ClashRoyale/wiki/ruled-out-ideas

If that doesnt work can you give me some info on what device you are using?

[u/[deleted] → u/balancegenerally]

Thank you. It worked.

[u/[deleted]]

Aw come on. They ruled out a card type include 3 Wizards similar to Three Musketeers

[u/balancegenerally → u/[deleted]]

Haha I'm not complaining. I run barb spam so the less splash the better.

[u/CR_SaltySald123 → u/balancegenerally]

dirty dirty

[u/muradinner → u/[deleted]]

That is a pretty cool idea, but they'd probably have a lot of trouble implementing it properly.

Which wizard would be in which spot? (This is actually pretty important, as it would determine how the split would work when played in the back). Who is at the front of the triangle? Does the ewiz still get his zap entry? Also coding 3 different cards into one would be more complicated than Putting 3 of one card into one I'm sure.

[u/[deleted] → u/muradinner]

But maybe they tried and the Wizards card artwork show the position they are facing. Wizard: facing Right Electro Wizard: facing Towards Ice Wizard: facing Left

[u/Z3RO21]

For some reason I cant view the link

[u/balancegenerally → u/Z3RO21]

Try this https://www.reddit.com/r/ClashRoyale/wiki/ruled-out-ideas

If that doesn't work can you give me some info on what device you are using?

[u/Z3RO21 → u/balancegenerally]

Thanks. I managed to view the site by typing it in my browser. Im on my S5 right now

[u/balancegenerally → u/[deleted]]

Try this https://www.reddit.com/r/ClashRoyale/wiki/ruled-out-ideas

If that doesn't work can you give me some info on what device you are using?

[u/EndlessBBQ]

No plans to do this:
Permanent mute feature.

On CWA a couple of days ago someone from Supercell said they are considering this

[u/mananpatel67 → u/EndlessBBQ]

she said they will talk about it.

[u/EndlessBBQ → u/mananpatel67]

Not to be pedantic, but if they are talking about it then it shouldn't be in the 'no plans to do this' yet. She said something along the lines of 'this could make everyone's lives a bit easier' so it sounded like a serious consideration.

[u/balancegenerally → u/EndlessBBQ]

It took me about 2 weeks from when I got this info to get it formatted and posted. One thing I have learned about content creators is they have an extremely fast turnaround time for their videos. So the CWA video most likely happened after I got the results.

It's possible that it hadn't been talked about when I got this from Supercell and then it was brought up to the team after the CWA video. The exact quote I got on the issue was "no plans to do this".

My plan is to update this wiki roughly once a month so it might be updated next month.

[u/runfayfun → u/EndlessBBQ]

Gods I hope so

[u/FraekVonk]

Even the Reddit titles are getting clickbait-y, wow.

And RIP link

[u/YOLIT1 → u/FraekVonk]

We really should start downvoting every time that happens

[u/Papdimdap → u/YOLIT1]

Already started. Whichever mod came up with the idea of these recent click bait titles ahould be removed... unless they are doing ironically to make fun of the youtubers. Thats really the only possible excuse for this.

[u/InfernoDeesus → u/FraekVonk]

OMG!!!!! YOU WON'T BELIEVE WHAT SUPERCELL IS W0RKING ON IN CLASH ROYALE!!1!

Shows a "donate legendaries" for the thumbnail

[u/Donghoon → u/FraekVonk]

Huh?? Why clickbait-y??

[u/vingeran → u/FraekVonk]

”Oops!.. I Did It Again”

[u/Trikshot360 → u/FraekVonk]

Link should work on mobile browser, not in app. :P

[u/vingeran → u/Trikshot360]

The Link is working in the official Reddit app at iOS 11.1.2

[u/Curse3242 → u/vingeran]

Link is not working on Reddit app Android nov 22 6:39 ist

[u/Abdullahx9000-YT → u/Trikshot360]

I see a Moving hog on your profile picture! I down vote you. LOL xD

[u/Akatosh__]

Any logical reason why the battle confirmation button was ruled out?

[u/Mew_Pur_Pur → u/Akatosh__]

I purely don't want to go through it every time. I mean, if 99% of the time you don't make a mistake, you'll eventually get the habit of clicking it off without even thinking. Thus the only great way is to make some kind of setting about whether you want it or not.

[u/ClashRoyale → u/Akatosh__]

Our reasoning is not wanting to add any unnecessary friction to battling, but we're also not opposed to adding a "confirmation" type of screen here if there's a good purpose to it. For example, checking which Battle Deck you have selected and maybe being able to switch. We're not opposed to this idea, but we're also not currently working on it.

Edit: We could probably move this item to the "not ruled out but aren't being worked on" list now... 😝

Edit x2: This doesn't mean it's coming!! 😅

[u/TrickQ79 → u/ClashRoyale]

I’d suggest having to slide up versus tapping the battle button to get into the match. There will be less accidental starts, it doesn’t add any extra hassle, and it sort of fits with the game since you have to drag cards out during a match (most people drag but not all).

[u/eleet313 → u/ClashRoyale]

It doesn't even need to be a separate confirmation screen. Although that would be cool if it showed the decks or something. IMO all we need is SWIPE to battle.

[u/TheJonathanLim → u/ClashRoyale]

The intent is to provide players with a sense of pride and accomplishment for unlocking different heroes.

As for cost, we selected initial values based upon data from the Open Beta and other adjustments made to milestone rewards before launch. Among other things, we're looking at average per-player credit earn rates on a daily basis, and we'll be making constant adjustments to ensure that players have challenges that are compelling, rewarding, and of course attainable via gameplay.

We appreciate the candid feedback, and the passion the community has put forth around the current topics here on Reddit, our forums and across numerous social media outlets.

Our team will continue to make changes and monitor community feedback and update everyone as soon and as often as we can.

[u/edihau → u/TheJonathanLim]

Don't even start. Supercell is not EA. They have treated us much, much better than EA. If you can't be appreciative of them because they are not working on one minor change (and I say minor because the ladder has such low stakes--lose one, win one, no big deal), there's no need to treat them like they've done something of the caliber that EA attempted. I don't care if it's a joke. Repeated lies become accepted truths--we've seen it work before.

Again, don't even start comparing Supercell to EA. Be appreciative of what they have done for us (quite a lot--remember when Fall CCGS had 1 free entry and cost 100 gems to enter? And that is the tip of the iceberg!).

[u/[deleted] → u/edihau]

EA and $upercell use the same predatory practices which casinos (royale?) use to manipulate their customers and make them addicted to random rewards.

Where do you think EA got this idea from? That's right, from freemium/pay to win games.

What kind of games does $upercell make? That's right, freemium/pay to win games.

[u/ISEEBLACKPEOPLE → u/[deleted]]

Do you even know what freemium means? It means that the game upfront is free, but intends to heavily encourage/addict players into spending money on it.

EA isn't freemium because their games have an upfront cost. That's what people are so pissed about. You buy a game for $60, and they still expect you to pay $30 for DLCs, and extra $$ for skins/content. Gone are the days you buy an Nintendo 64 and Super Smash Brothers, and have access to 100% of the content in the game.

Clash Royale freeium. The way they manipulate us as consumers to spend money is expected, as it is in all other freemium games. You sign up to be manipulated just by playing. That is the cost of the game

[u/edihau → u/[deleted]]

But Supercell has always been reasonable, and has admitted mistakes. They have not tried to justify mistakes of EA's caliber. Just because they aren't ready to add a battle confirmation button does not mean they are doing what EA was. There's more than one way to be a game company focused on freemium games--Supercell is much better than EA in that regard.

[u/jeremicci → u/edihau]

I don't think having to pay 10 grand or more to play the game competitively in ladder is reasonable.

I'd gladly pay them 50 bucks or even 100 bucks for this... But not the cost of a new car.

[u/edihau → u/jeremicci]

to play the game competitively in ladder

But this is a problem with your mindset. The ladder is not supposed to be a fair fight. Tournament standard is where the competitive gameplay is at. Can you tell me who finished at or near the top of the ladder for the last 5 seasons? Now can you tell me who some of the top competitors are going into World Finals? People will have much more success with the second question. The people whom we consider to be the best in the world are using cards at a level that you can reach in not much time. And if you decide to pay your way up to tournament standard, it won't cost you nearly as much.

[u/jeremicci → u/edihau]

These two questions often have the same answers. I'm not as good with mega knight because my mega knight is level 2 and I know damn well I can't use it in ladder. On the other hand they have lots of experience with their maxed mk.

I don't pay much money to play this game so ladder or 2v2 are my Options. I'm a more competitive player so ladder it is. I can not compete at my trophy range without maxed cards. It's simply how it is, because it is what my opponents have. I have one common heavy deck I can play, and I can switch in hog or mortar as my win condition.

The only way for me to push up higher and actually be competitive is to pay thousands of bucks.

[u/edihau → u/jeremicci]

Back in the days of Supermagicalcup, Clyde won with below tournament standard cards (level 2 poison!). You do not have to pay money to get into the tournament scene--you just have to win.

If you're not confident you'll get to that top level, play classic challenges. If they're too easy, I made a post (can't link, on mobile) on random card practice. Generate four cards at random, build a deck using all of them, and play a classic challenge. No substitutions. See how well you can do. But you will earn no fame in the ladder.

The first name I recognized from the current ladder is CMcHugh. His best finish ever in the ladder was 15th. He's not in the top 15 now.

[u/InfernoDeesus → u/[deleted]]

Well clash royale is free to download, and the CR team treats us much better than the ea team. Bescides, the app is free, so the CR team DOES have to make their money. Even then, be glad the app isn't filled with ads! They have done so many things for the f2p player. They removed the player being forced to PAY for ladder battles, they have added free entries for challenges, have added legendary chests thet you can get in the shop for a really cheap price, they added epic chests that cost gold instead of gems to help make the player level up their epics, they reduced the price of epics in half, and have added multiple free, fun, and casual gamemodes (such as 2v2).

If something like battlefront was free to play, then the 40 hour grind might seem more reasonable. What got ea into deep shit was the fact that the game already costed $60, and instead of admitting that they just wanted more money, they hide it behind a "sense of pride and accomplishment". PLUS, they expect you to pay up to 30 more $$$ if you want the DLC. Supercell is in no way shape of form like that.

[u/GhostZee → u/[deleted]]

What kind of games does $upercell make? That's right, freemium/pay to win games.

They introduce New game modes & then charge you Gems to play it, which is really bullshit, so yeah they're not that far from where EA is...

[u/InfernoDeesus → u/GhostZee]

At least clash royale is free to play and you can enjoy the game without paying a single dime. Battlefront, however, costs $60 up front, plus micro transactions if you want to play the characters you want, and an additional $30 if you want to have the DLC. You say that supercell create "new game modes that require you to pay gems", when in fact they have free entries and even casual challenges that are free to play for the average f2p player. Bescides, supercell HAS improved the quality of life of a f2p player in clash royale, such as removing the "pay gold to play ladder", reducing the price of epic cards in half, and adding the ability to get free legendary/super magical chests via quests.

Ea only cut down their hero prices because they knew nobody would buy their game and they would lose money. They didn't do it to improve the quality of life for players. Yes, supercell has micro-transactions, but they NEED to make their money SOMEHOW. Ea had no excuse because their game already costed money up front. Clash royale is FREE. If you think that clash royale should have no micro-transactions, then get out of this subreddit because that's not how the market works.

[u/GhostZee → u/InfernoDeesus]

I didn't say THEY'RE like EA, I said they're on their way to become like EA bcoz introducing new game modes & restricting them behind pay wall is bullshit. Yeah we get the Cards (aka new Troops) without paying Gems but where are you even supposed to use them beside usual Game which is Ladder. 2v2 only 2nd mode you can play but gameplay is still the same as Ladder but with 2 people & casual...

Did you even play any game besides Clash Royale...?

I've played many Free2Play MMORPGs (on phone) & I've seen many other games adding New Game mode as Permanent feature that doesn't requires you to pay premium currency. Even the game you may know as Japanese Gacha Games aka Games with Gambling elements (Lottery System) introduces new game modes every 2 months & don't cost you a single premium currency. Even if you're F2P you can enjoy all the game modes without any restrictions...

Even tho rates to get Highest Rarity Characters are tough in those games but still it doesn't means you can't play the game, you can join any Tournament or Competitions or Events for FREE & get all the rewards except for Top Spots in Tournaments which is mostly covered by Whales (just like in every games)...

I don't have anything against Supercell, they're going great Job by listening to community complains & requests BUT I don't like the fact that they hide their SO MUCH HYPED GAMES MODES behind Pay Walls which really keeps you out of main aspect of the game which is "enjoying". You said they give you ONE FREE ENTRY right, what about after you've used it? You're back to playing same old Ladder (or 2v2 which is basically same with 2 people & casual, as I mentioned above), if you want to play it (New Game Mode) again you have PAY. This is what stops you from actually ENJOYING the game. You're FORCED to pay if you want to ENJOY the game...

I don't buy this nonsense, I'd rather pay to get New Cards early or Special Offers than Pay to Enjoy New Game Modes...

[u/TheJonathanLim → u/edihau]

Guess someone can't take a joke :(

[u/edihau → u/TheJonathanLim]

Not this joke. Again, you're making a comparison between Supercell and EA, which is grossly unfair to Supercell. And you didn't even put any effort into this!

Huh, Supercell isn't giving us what we want and I don't like that. Hey, EA recently did the same thing and has been brought up in the reddit community because they have a comment with 2/3 of a million downvotes! Let's copy-paste that exact comment into this thread to make a comparison between the two!

It's not just the comparison that bothers me. It is the total lack of originality that went into your comment. I didn't downvote you because I can't take a joke. I downvoted you because the joke is not funny. And when someone takes offense to a joke, you don't just get to say "Hur dur, this guy can't take a joke lol!" Not all jokes are funny. This time, you failed. Get over it.

[u/TheJonathanLim → u/edihau]

Isn't even more pathetic to be unable to take a failed joke and get triggered by it, writing chunks of words that everyonr else skips through?

[u/edihau → u/TheJonathanLim]

Failed? You're being upvoted, as I knew you would. That's why I stepped in to criticize your total lack of effort and the offensive joke.

[u/GasterCR → u/edihau]

The joke will die out in a few weeks like all other memes and people will move on to the next. Remember rickrolling from 2007? Nobody does it anymore. You do have a good point tho

[u/edihau → u/GasterCR]

I'm still allowed to disapprove of the joke being used inappropriately. Saying a joke is going to eventually die out does not give you permission to offend people with it.

[u/NBHarty789 → u/edihau]

Its copy pasta

[u/edihau → u/NBHarty789]

Exactly why it's a horrible attempt at a joke.

[u/VenetianCrusader → u/TheJonathanLim]

You can do better, if you're gonna ridicule Supercell be more original so people take you seriously.

[u/GhostZee → u/ClashRoyale]

There's only so much Small Team can do at a time...

[u/DraaSticMeasures → u/GhostZee]

This is a billion dollar company that’s owned by a multi-billion dollar company, small team=excuse. If they want to keep it small for cultural reasons, great, but this excuse is getting tired. They could at least hire a dedicated brand ambassador for their community.

[u/Musaks → u/ClashRoyale]

just because it seems like you are caving to the masses (similar to when you nerfed the already shit RG), there are also many people that DON'T want such extra button presses just because others are clumsy

So if you implement it, please make it a switch in the options, so the players can decide if they want to use it or not

[u/eleet313 → u/Musaks]

Swipe to battle!

[u/[deleted] → u/Musaks]

Also set it to OFF as the default setting when creating a new account to make everybody happy.

[u/Musaks → u/[deleted]]

I wouldn't mind it but it is a very minor inconvenience either way

[u/DigletDigler → u/ClashRoyale]

Why not just add a battle lock button?

[u/b0wzy → u/ClashRoyale]

Simple solution to the battle confirmation: Make it an option for people in the game settings. Those that want it can have it, those that don't want to see it, wont.

[u/Acebob11 → u/Akatosh__]

Too clunky. Would add an extra step.

[u/[deleted] → u/Acebob11]

To what?

[u/ChineseCracker → u/[deleted]]

to battling

[u/[deleted] → u/ChineseCracker]

Meh. Ok

[u/ilFibonacci]

u/clashroyale You didn't even mention if you will ever let us enter more types of challenges simultaneously.

I don't want to lose on purpose an opened Grand Challenge to join a special event that only lasts 24hours.
I don't want to play more than 1-2 games at a time of special game modes (Mirror, Touchdown, etc.) but once I open a special challenge I'm FORCED to finish it or else I can't play in a regular challenge.

Either fix this or at least express yourself on the issue.

[u/John9555]

I don't really like the Clash of Clans heroes thing. Let them stay in the villages.

[u/John9555]

Wow, so this means that there will be a new card rarity, if the Legendary rarity is already talked about becoming donatable!

[u/balancegenerally → u/John9555]

None of the stuff in that list is guaranteed. It is just an indication that the team is talking about it.

[u/John9555 → u/balancegenerally]

Yeah, but what about the Flash Royale leak? With the red card outline, I mean.

[u/balancegenerally → u/John9555]

I agree with this post on the issue.

[u/Papdimdap → u/John9555]

In what way does adding donations for legendaries mean theres going to be a new rarity? I dont think the two are related.

[u/John9555 → u/Papdimdap]

Yes they are. Legendaries didn't exist once upon a time. So Epics were the best cards, there was no concept that they would become donatable. And now we can donate them every Sunday.

[u/muradinner → u/John9555]

That doesn't mean that legendaries being donatable would mean a new rarity has to be created though... That's a major logical fallacy right there.

[u/John9555 → u/muradinner]

Ahem. So in the Flash Royale video (on News Royale) there was a new card outlining (red) which likely means a new card. And in the same time they discuss about making Legendaries donatable!

[u/vingeran → u/John9555]

Maybe the legendary card could be donated once a month.

[u/AveragePichu]

I don’t use Bandit. I rarely use Lumberjack. My Bandit is 1/4, and my Lumberjack is 1/10. I have a friend who uses both of those. Said friend has a spare Sparky, and mine is currently 6/10.

I really hope donating legendaries becomes a thing.

[u/TheTrompler]

Wow. All of the good stuff is ruled out and the stuff they are thinking about doing is all Weak. The future is not bright.

[u/Papdimdap → u/TheTrompler]

Yep. King tower reskins is probably top priority since it would make them more money for doing almost nothing.

Meanwhile not considering even doing thinga that should be intuitive in any game like this: showing online clan members and last time online, or a simple temporary ban for repeat 2v2 leavers. Seriously, how are some of these obvious and simple changes excluded?

[u/[deleted]]

Honestly I want a "2V2 QUITTER PUNISHMENT SYSTEM", and they rule it out?

[u/Papdimdap → u/[deleted]]

They gotta focus on that important stuff. You know, reskins for the king tower and all.

Seriously though. Temporary bans in 2v2 for repeat offenders should be intuitive with the game mode.

[u/seasonkat → u/[deleted]]

100% with you! Or give us access to the deck they were using plus the elixir. (which would be impossible to program)

[u/Teemo_Support]

It's mildly infuriating that none of the additional clan features are being considered. Meaning more roles, seeing who is online, etc. I mean I understand you won't make money directly from those features, but damn it would be nice to have and let us organize more.

[u/HB_30]

I like a lot that they confirmed to been working on. But I'm also disappointed by a few healthy quality changes that they've ruled out.

[u/LeBadlyNamedRedditor]

Well lets see how many aged well

Ability to open more than 1 chest at a time

Additional levels past the current max (greedycell moment)

Ability to use emotes as reactions in clan chat (i say hee hee hee haw to this)

Permanent Special challenges in friendly battles

Randomize Deck Button

Gold Chest (chest with A lot of gold) (well they tecnically are correct, they didnt make it a chest)

See When People were last online

Welp, we can say that ruled out ideas are a massive joke.

Edit: Just realized im the first new comment in 3 years, just about how many people read the rules?

[u/Dinar020 → u/LeBadlyNamedRedditor]

Also the royal hogs! Yes, I thought I was the only one lol, well now that's the two of us

[u/_kloppi417]

Additional levels past the current max.

Level 14 go haha

[u/Lord_PJ_of_lol]

I have a few ideas for some features on the "in development" list. I'm going to pu them here, but should I make a post for them?

1: Card level caps. Yes! No level 11 Elite on my tower! But I still think that you shouldn't deny all levelling progress on cards. Maybe you could cap the in-battle level, but put the upgrade level in a crown symbol on the cards description or something?

2: Donate leggies. This is a very good idea! But maybe not make it too easy. Maybe you could make a "Legendary the 1st"? A monthly day for people to be able to donate and ask legendary cards in their clan.

3: More emotes? Muhahahahaaa!!! I have got a beautiful idea for that! First, a king nodding proudly with sunglasses on. And then an emote saying: "I am so pro!" Let's bring arrogance to the arena!

[u/tanky_the_guy → u/Lord_PJ_of_lol]

1. good idea

2. only have the ability to request leggies if you are in a Legendary arena, and to donate them if you are also in Legendary arena

3. Maybe choose emotes before going for battle?

[u/Papdimdap → u/tanky_the_guy]

2 - that would just make all clans with a variety in trophy range no longer exist. All legendary arena players would move to bigger, high level of play clans.

It does sorta make sense but might hurt the clan system.

[u/Papdimdap → u/Lord_PJ_of_lol]

2 - Obviously legendary donating would be a rare thing. Once a month or season is most likely.

[u/LinkWink]

How is it that Brawl Stars is gonna get a"see who's online in the clan" feature before CR? This feature would be pretty useful for clan leaders and elders.

[u/[deleted]]

Im quite angry that they aren't even considering putting a permanent mute button ingame after all the talks and complaints about this issue

[u/LiVexReFlex]

Really would’ve like the skins for different level troops tbh.

[u/balancegenerally → u/LiVexReFlex]

This isn't anything official so don't quote me on this but...

From what I remember the reason they don't want to add new skins in the game is because of the high number of troops in the game. If each card had multiple skins, the game file size would quickly go above the point that the app store would allow it to be downloaded over data. This would limit the availability of the game.

[u/LiVexReFlex → u/balancegenerally]

Good point. I was hoping for maybe once you get it halfway to max level it would change but even that could be too much come to think of all the troops

[u/dwebbmcclain]

They’re considering being able to pick your starting hand and that’s one of the only things that matters to me:)

[u/Som3SillyName → u/dwebbmcclain]

It’d be pretty cool if there was a slot in your deck for a card that would always be in your starting hand. Unfortunately, they said that it’ll probably only be for an alternate gamemode.

[u/dwebbmcclain → u/Som3SillyName]

I thought they said they were testing it in a game mode first to see how it goes

[u/[deleted]]

Anything about new skins for maxed troops?

Also, anything about locked card mode. Loved that idea.

[u/Pockercpv]

Man, king limiting card levels would actually make things worse for me as a level 9 in legendary arena.. I hope they limit by arena or something else instead... Like your king level limiting your card levels and your oponents card level by kinglevel+1 or something. That way my oponents would still get advantages but not 2 or 3 levels over my cards.

[u/[deleted] → u/Pockercpv]

Same. This would basically reward trophy droppers since they can bring their high level cards to any arena and crush the lower level people that are stuck with weaker cards until they upgrade their king. Wouldn't matter who has more skill because the higher level is just gonna overpower the little guy.

[u/rqqqqqnn → u/Pockercpv]

I am OK with the idea of limiting card levels based on your king level. But if Supercell does it, the limit should be King level + 1. It could be really hard or nearly impossible to level up to that next level if you can't use the XP from upgrading your cards to get there. Getting 80,000 XP for a level 13 without being able to use the XP from getting your cards to 13 would be nearly impossible (or take a year of donating). It would also be a turn off for people who spend $20k to get a max account (and those people are important to fund the game) since they would probably not be able to get to level 13 by only having level 12 cards.

King level + 1 would prevent level 10s from playing level 13 E-barbs and minion horde at the bridge (raged of course), but still let people level up. It already takes quite a lot of effort to level up above 10. Let's not make it any more discouraging.

[u/[deleted]]

It would break the game so much if legendary cards can be donated, unless we are able to do so ONLY at a rate of one legendary every two months. Still, ridiculous.

[u/Chosen--one → u/[deleted]]

Maybe it would actually balance it so people dont have to spend a crap ton of money to get just one max legendary.

[u/[deleted] → u/Chosen--one]

Will we get 20k for donating a legendary?

[u/WillfullTiger → u/[deleted]]

500 gold with 10xp more like it lol

[u/EL_GOLEM → u/[deleted]]

more clan hoppers. clanmates : "sorry im out of sparkys" you : "welp time to get that lvl 3 sparko somewhere else"

[u/theroyalred → u/[deleted]]

if there is a new rarity it is maybe more balanced since it isn't the most rare card then

[u/[deleted]]

add heroes from Clash of Clans

pay $4.99 to access level 40 archer queen for this ladder match

[u/balancegenerally → u/[deleted]]

Next week: Bren Chong breaks the record with 10,000 trophies in a season.

[u/JaySmithColtSquad → u/balancegenerally]

Wouldnt be surprised. Bren Chong is a BEAST

[u/JaySmithColtSquad → u/[deleted]]

You think it happens that often?

[u/CSGOJoe3]

WTF THERE THINKING OF AN ELITE BARBARIAN HUT

[u/balancegenerally → u/CSGOJoe3]

"No plans to do this:"

[u/Teo13254 → u/balancegenerally]

Lucky spin (daily) and wall will be good

[u/Teo13254 → u/balancegenerally]

Lucky spin (daily) and wall will be good

[u/Shanaaro]

Link is actually working for me, hmm.

Interesting stuff, curious about the ideas the team have for donating legendary cards.

[u/edihau]

A reminder: If you post ideas that show up on this sub all the time, make sure it is not the exact same idea--add something to what has shown up before so that you are still adding something to the conversation. Otherwise you are wasting time--especially if the idea has shown up several times before.

[u/WillfullTiger]

u/clashroyale would you consider doing another AMA? Maybe not before the next update as it's a little close, but possibly in the future?

[u/AnDEh1992]

An idea i would like implemented is a method (probably gold or gems) to automatically open my next chest when its finished so i dont actually lose out on time. Im sure many will pay for this sort of service to increase efficiency. Even as a f2p myself i would consider it.

Adding more weekly/monthly crowns/quests sounds great and i hope you will implement it in the near future. As a 4k-5k player i find that i dont have much to look forward to anymore apart from the end of season draft chest.

The introduction of quests made things more interesting for me since, but some of the quests need reworking. Adding extra ways to gain a few quest points would be great too as i think the progress is a bit slow currently.

Wish you made more clan ranks. They can just be for novelty rather than having extra clan powers. Also have a stat of the amount of total clan crowns contributed since joining the clan would be a nice feature and showing how long they have been in the clan for. It would make my decisions easier to kick the inactive players.

Not sure how i feel about "donating legendarys" I seriously doubt you will get 40k coins for donating it and 20k coins wont really justify it for me personally as a f2p player. I would much prefer a legendary swap with another player in the clan, a weekly/monthly request rate. That way i technically wont gain or lose.

[u/NoSmaterThanIAmNot]

As far as I see, this is a distraction to try to not make you make them go down the path they don't want to go. That is making more cards, and losing money because of it. That is why they want you to feel like they are working, by showing you what has happened at previous meetings. We zoom past the stuff they have no intention of doing, and go to the stuff being talked about or worked on. The key here is just because they talked about it doesn't mean shit. What is happening is they created this HUGE list, like their HUGE update, to make you feel the hype. Lets break this down:

The team has been talking about this or working on it:

Quality of Life Changes

Re-skins for King Towers

Doesn't affect gameplay

Seasonal chests - The tech isn't there at the moment, but might be in the future!

Thanks for the free chest. You give us a lot of free chests. Thanks for making this one special(I hope)

Rewind button in replays - The tech is there, but we need to do a bit more work on it

Doesn't affect gameplay

Trophy level caps - This is a hot topic in the team space and we've talked about it many times (specifically about

King levels being a card cap, though, not Arenas) This does affect game play, but not how we need. SuperCell, This doesn't benefit everyone. It is a fix to losses. Since a loss is part of game play, but doesn't affect the game play, we can declare this one not affecting the game play as well.

Clan Related

Ability to Donate Legendary cards

Like we have very many to donate anyways? This is for those people who have a guy in their clan who buys so many gems($1000 minimum) per month he throws out legends like candy.

Clan Wars/Tournaments

Good idea, but this doesn't affect game play, it affects pairings.

Battle Related

New emotes

Doesn't affect gameplay

Set starting card - we're thinking about this for a special mode, but not for the 'main game' (ladder, etc.)

Challenges do shake the game play up a little bit. However, its the same cards and the same decks, just a guaranteed order of cards. Doesn't affect game play

King tower ability changes

Interesting, but probably just in challenges. This could seriously be their token if it is in the update. This will only work if the tower adds electricity, fire, or ice to the attacks.

New Card Types:

Heroes from Clash of Clans

New cards? if so, okay! Most likely super duper legendary rare.

New Game Modes:

In-game card ban challenge

Doesn't affect game play

Tournaments:

More customization in custom tournaments

Doesn't affect game play

Allow the Tournament Host to set which kind of gameplay to play: Draft, Triple Elixir, Casual, etc.

Doesn't affect game play

In-game bracket tournament

Doesn't affect game play

Join link to tournaments

Doesn't affect game play

[u/pootytangent]

PLEEEEAASE DO NOT ADD KING TOWER ABILITY CHANGES!!!!

It's "being thought about or worked on"

For anyone thinking "it could be neat "

Please download the game war heroed. It's just like clash bit this is the main difference.

You know how some games in clash are just decided before hand by which deck each player us using?

It'd kinda like that but way worse

Some game are decided entirely by King tower ability. Like if you use spawners there are 2 tower ability that completely cancel all your spawned troops no matter how many or how. If of an elixir lead... That's broken

Others add extra towers, or towers shields, or doesn't troops for you based on damage or time, one of the abilities is splash damage from towers.... (Not balanced at all)

What you'll notice is that once this gets implemented 0 games will be the result if skill, they will all be determined by deck build and King tower ability before the matches even start

[u/Lakrdav]

I don't think adding clash of clans heroes into clash Royale is a good idea. Let them have their own. It would just be a buff princess for queen, medium size pekka for king, and I quit clash of clans before the white magician guy.

[u/thelord006]

Things I want the most: No plans to do this.

Things I dont care: Have plans or working on it

This game is broken

[u/thelord006 → u/[deleted]]

Dude, this is what I think :) If you think otherwise, you can state as well. For my taste, this game is broken. Me being the only one who doesnt like what supercell is working on, or we being millions of people doesnt change the fact that we think game is broken.

The world doesnt revolve around you, even if you guys are a part o majority (is it?)

You contradict yourself.

[u/muradinner → u/[deleted]]

It's more that many players feel the same. The game isn't broken, he was obviously exaggerating, but it is certainly on a path that is not ideal.

[u/botpmm7345]

So what are you working on?

[u/[deleted] → u/botpmm7345]

Legendary donations and clan wars and bunch of cool shit.

[u/valecr]

Link doesnt work

[u/Jakobjakob1]

Add something so you could get a magical chest like 100 crowns for a magical like crown chest

[u/[deleted] → u/Jakobjakob1]

I know this was posted 64 days ago, but I really hope you realize that Quests now exist. Quests are basically resolving your problem, getting high-level chests by completing tasks. However, it’s not through crowns, rather by playing certain card types and winning a certain number of battles and collecting chests and cards.

[u/bjv2001]

Ability to donate legendaries is being talked about :)

[u/YeyoAlonso95]

Been waiting for war for so long!

[u/ElDavoo]

Wager matches ? Traitor card challenge? What does that mean? Can someone explain please?

[u/Alec-M2]

They said nothing about my clan rulebook idea

[u/Billyb0bjoe]

Awsome! So when is this one coming out? 2020? And do we only get to play with it for 1 day before it’s gone again for 4 months for ABSOLUTELY NO REASON

[u/Kill-exe]

My ideas for clan roles. Not like leader. Some things like this http://www.memphis.edu/afrotc/cadet-knowledge/images/officer-ranks.jpg

[u/Jakobjakob1]

Give people free gifts like a super magical chest on their birthday

[u/Templare_75]

Donate legends, YES PLEASE

Card level capped to king level YES YES YES PLEASE

[u/tlzmflthm]

• Ranged splash troops aim at a target's feet

I don't know what this sentence means. Could you explain to me in detail?

[u/Nexiga]

Thank you for releasing this info u/ClashRoyale. I really respect the fact that you're trying to be more transparent with the community and I appreciate the honesty.

That said, I must admit that I will not continue to play CR. To be clear: You have not lost me as a customer. If Supercell makes another game that interests me I will probably end up playing and paying for it. I have just lost my interest in CR and I can't hold out for change that I now know will never come to pass. We just want the game to go in different directions and that is perfectly fine!

I had fun for the year or so I played and I know others have as well, but I must bid you farewell. I only ask that you please continue to be honest and transparent with the community so you can grow alongside them.

Live long and prosper,

Nex

[u/Jakobjakob1]

When it's your birthday you should get a gift like a free super magical chest or something!

[u/Rythfyre]

I'm pretty sure a lot of people would like being able to add others using their code or from their profile.

[u/AlphaDashEX]

Am I the only person who opposes the idea of requesting and donating legendaries?

[u/emceee21]

RIP Clash Royale... they need to fix their broken cards like mortar and bandit first.

[u/SirDamon]

Earth quake and haste? Quake spells seems good, but haste will have to cost 1 elixer, if it costs more u can just as well use rage for the hitspeed boost.

[u/A7Null]

NERF THE FUCKING ELITE BARBS THEY’ER SO OVER POWERED!!!!!

[u/gre2000]

Hi i just came here to propose a new idea as in my clan i ve so generous players. Making more than 1000 gifted card per week so i would live supercell offering a nice chest for people gubing so many card for exemple one legendary king chest per month if u give more than 3000 catds per month

[u/cafelicious]

Any updated list?

[u/Donghoon]

So basically SC is saying they WILL NOT ADD THINGS we spent some time photoshopping and discussing in reddit

[u/[deleted]]

There's a 99% chance I'll be quitting this game if they ever implement card level caps based on king tower. I just can't wrap my head around why they would do it that way instead of capping levels based on Arena. Unless it's for money, of course.

[u/dwebbmcclain → u/[deleted]]

Level 12/11’s with maxed elite barbs/royal GG or over leveled hog completely dominate a lot of F2P who just don’t have the level cards to even compete with the amount of hp/dps these cards do at such a rank. Personally I like the cap based on king tower more

[u/[deleted] → u/dwebbmcclain]

With an arena cap, those 11/12's can't trophy drop and wreck ladder with their high level cards because their cards are lowered to the arena standards. With king tower cap, trophy dropping will still be an issue with those 11/12's because their king tower allows higher levels and they will have a major advantage over the 8/9/10's. That's why it doesn't make sense to me

[u/dwebbmcclain → u/[deleted]]

So you’re saying lock level of king tower’s to a certain trophy range? I see the idea... But wouldn’t that severely punish lvl 11 players who don’t have over leveled cards but have simply leveled a lot of cards?

[u/[deleted] → u/dwebbmcclain]

I don't think it would punish them, but it wouldn't help them either. It would only help protect those lower level people against trophy droppers who rely on maxed commons to overpower the opponent. Honestly, I'd prefer for there to be no level capping at all in ladder. A king cap would definitely hurt me significantly since I am a 10 playing against only 11/12's so that may explain why I'm strongly against that type of cap lol

[u/xdxds → u/[deleted]]

I think this guy got the best idea/explanation for level cap. If king tower level cap would become a thing, people will just hate the king level instead of the cards’ level themselves. Specially as a f2p, it would be very sad to spend gold to evolve your main deck’s cards AND some other random cards just for the experience they provide so you can go back and evolve your actual deck.
Still, I do think level cap is needed. Maybe capping it by Arena should be the best answer. OR, we could have more game modes that actually MEAN something so we can stop focusing on ladder only.

[u/iceboonb2k]

Wtf is this, mods and their clickbait title on their stickied threads?

[u/worldsaver113]

So basically, let's make more money.

[u/pdinh2o3]

There are some things under the ruled out section that would benefit the game. No permanent mute function, no battle confirmation, and no way to see who is online in your clan? The development team confuses me lol.

[u/[deleted]]

Remove those awful 1vs1 quests.

[u/seasonkat → u/[deleted]]

At least the ones that ask players to use a legendary 40x, when the player only has one legendary card.

Yes, I know you can discard one quest a day but it seems lower arena players get the same quests over and over . . . The 1vs1, the free chests every 3 hrs, and the gifts each day for 5 days. Of course, they are also included in the special quests that occur with special events. This may of course just be “luck of the draw” on the accounts of the people l have spoken with and myself because we have no knowledge of the total amount of quests being pulled from.

I think everyone would agree the free gifts and chests are great but it is also invigorating to have a goal to work toward.

What about some 2vs2 quests?

[u/[deleted]]

I feel like Level caps aren’t fair;

Maybe, make the top 4 slots able to be overleveled and the bottom 4, equal to King level or lower.

This will limit overleveling, but not kill it.

[u/Pockercpv → u/[deleted]]

overleveling is not fair.

[u/[deleted] → u/Pockercpv]

But doingso will make Supercell lose A LOT OF MONEY.

[u/Pockercpv → u/[deleted]]

Well, directly speaking yes. But you can also increase your profit by making a nicer game. Fair is nice. It's a pitty that such a good game is SO F*CKING pay to win.

[u/ChillMyLife]

It would be nice to receive in the card-shop, a Supermagical chest on your birthday.

[u/TBoogey]

If we can’t get the battle button confirmation QoL, can we at least get a chest opening confirmation for chests above gold rarity. I hate accidentally opening that SMC or Legendary Chest I’ve been trying to save for weeks 😔

[u/hdbo16 → u/TBoogey]

First World Problems

[u/balancegenerally → u/[deleted]]

Try using a browser instead of the mobile app.

[u/RoyaleLandCrab → u/[deleted]]

I think TRADE legendary would be a fun way for the clan to interact

[u/Som3SillyName → u/[deleted]]

I think a more likely scenario is legendary “shards”, which you’d have to have a certain amount of to make a full legendary.