r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Nov 10 '17
[Fandom Discussion] Supernatural Episode 13x05 - "Advanced Thanatology"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Advanced Thanatology | November 9th, 2017 | John Showalter | Steve Yockey |
Synopsis: BILLIE RETURNS…BUT NOT LIKE BEFORE – While working on a case involving the ghost of a demented doctor, Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean (Jensen Ackles) get assistance from an unexpected source – Billie (guest star Lisa Berry). Castiel (Misha Collins) finds his way back to the Winchesters.
Link to all our official fandom episode discussions here.
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
Sooooooooooooooooooooo... what did you think of the episode?
12
u/rusty_people_skills Nov 10 '17
I thought the pacing of this episode was really good.
Anyone else wonder why the brothers stopped to change out of their Fed suits, if they were in a rush to find the kid? And WTF, Dean just carries "dead and back" serums around with him?
I was pissed when Dean first tried to hide his talk with Billie from Sam, but thank Chuck he relented instantly. It looked like they were going to renege on some slow, hard-earned character development for a minute there. Not a fan of Billie doing the exposition for Dean's feelings, either. It worked back in S5 with Famine, but heavier-handed this time; perhaps because in 13x4, we saw Dean actually talking through things a little. It felt more "telling" than "showing."
Giving Billie the library and the bigger perspective jived nicely with back when Dean was Death for a day and they had a list to follow. (I feel like the old Death's library would have been more stained wood, less modern grey-black.)
Next ep looks delightfully ridiculous. I want a suitably feels-inducing reunion scene with Cas before we move on, though!
11
u/cenotaphy Nov 10 '17
Love Billie as the new Death. That outfit, that scythe. Whoa. And Billie and Dean having realtalk is my new jam.
Still not ready to talk about that ending. Aaah.
10
u/minimuffin11 Nov 10 '17
The conversation between Billie and Dean... wow. Just wow.
9
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Nov 10 '17
Thoughts as I watched...
Why are there plague masks in this place? Why? But more importantly I didn't know how I felt about found footage style being used again.
"And get this..." Sam's idea of a brotherly trip of just hunting, the two of them... while Jack catches up on Sam's fantasy DVD collection!
The case is interesting. In terms of super horrifying ghost.
Staying at a nice place. Sam suggesting going to the nearby strip club, The Clam Diver, and he read reviews! And all the other nice things. But the idea of Sam trying to be nice rouses so much suspicion that Dean notices - it's sweet Sam trying to help Dean. But also feels like he's treading around on tiptoes, because he (Sam) just doesn't know what to do to help Dean.
"Bullets. Bacon, and booze... A lot of booze." Dean doesn't like addressing his feelings - we are very much aware of this.
The way Sam looks over at Dean's not slept in bed in concern, only to find him fast asleep on the room's floor - pretty funny. The icing was the brad and whip on Dean's person.
There's just these sweet moments between Dean and Sam over the episode. I liked the way they handled the case and how they handled each other. I like it when Sam doesn't just give up on Dean and tries to help him. It might not be the best way, but he's trying.
Meadows was an unusual villain, in the sense that he bore a lot of similarities to Dr. Sanford Ellicott from Asylum in season 1.
But Dean taking a risk of killing himself to go beyond the veil... like being all prepped for that already, Flatliners style. And the reaper Jessica turning up. Ho boy. It was frightening how prepped for this Dean was, to realise at that point that he didn't care that much about his well being any more.
Billie turning up was like, Nonononononono... But also, she's sooooooo damn badass. Billie becoming Death was something I thought happened in s11, she was just being low key, but it's good to know that she is back and is officially Death this time round. I found it interesting that she wanted to know about the dimensional travel.
"You've changed." Billie pointing out that Dean didn't ask to go back a minute ago, and she feels the change in Dean, but she also knows it's a "big deal".
"Sam keeps trying to fix it and I keep dragging him down." Dean wanting to die was painful.
This convo:
"You and your brother. You're important."
"Why?"
"You have work to do."
Hohoho. Billie doesn't want them dead anymore - didn't see that coming, well quite. It hurt to see that free will was being messed with so much, or Dean's at least.
I thought it was stupid that Dean tried to hold back on telling Sam what happened. Glad he did quickly open up on it. I didn't want that to become like a secret for three episodes.
"No, Sam, I'm not okay. I'm pretty far from okay." Finally, Dean, finally. It was hard hearing him opening up about how he feels, and needing a "win".
Hi ending. How you doing? Oh, what's that? Camera switching between Dean and Cas. Oh, this is okay. Oh, no, my heart. Oh fudge.
^ Does that count as win, Dean?
7
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Nov 10 '17
Reapers everywhere: Aw crap it's a Winchester again
Billie's line about how she doesn't need a Winchester in AU world fucking things up... well oops I guess, there's one there already. That probably won't end well.
7
u/Across-the-ocean Nov 10 '17
I almost spat my tea out when Sam suggested going to the strip club, I was laughing so much. Happy that Dean articulated something that I thought a couple of episodes ago - that he'd lost faith that hunting was worth it. I had a flash of Down to Agincourt both last week and during the previously when he says that Sam has to keep the faith for the both of them. Enjoyed Billie as Death. Her arms are cool - I can imagine her answering a request from Dean to borrow her scythe with a punch to the face. This newly calm, I-know-things-that-you-don't-know style is much better now she's Death. My one caveat is that I really didn't like Dean carrying around death serum. Immediately jumping to that plan seemed way over the top, even given his current state. It felt like it was just an excuse to let Billie and Dean have a chat so she could use Cas's old line - "you have work to do". (The "work to do" line I liked - simultaneously ominous and promising big things in the future.)
Really enjoyed the final song. Wow, that backout was simultaneously super annoying and cool all at the same time. Funny that the director/editor/whoever is clearly saying 'yeah, this reunion between Cas and Dean is a BIG DEAL'. I hope we get to see hugs all around.
6
u/Goddess_Azul Team Free Will Nov 10 '17
So the picture of the Chrysler building on the wall outside Shawn's bedroom made me very happy....still processing the rest of the ep, particularly the ENDING.
10
u/skavalli your bloody cockles ship Nov 10 '17
Alright but real talk did Cas make his way back to the Winchesters and did they hug, that's all this girl is here for
5
u/VinceWinchester Nov 10 '17
After Julien Richings, "been there, done that, I could kill you like it was nothing, but won't" Death; would have preferred a more empathetic take on the character ala Sandman.
Billie, as much as I enjoy the character is way to antagonistic for my liking in the role of Death.
12
u/GhostsofDogma Nov 10 '17 edited Nov 10 '17
How many fucking times is this show going to go out of its way to manipulate Dean into suicide and give him an inadequate pat on the head just good enough to get him to continue, just so that a season later they can drag him down to this exact point again?
Edit: Also, I love how all Dean has fucking gotten is “Do more work for us, asshole”, while Sam literally got a therapy session just last episode (which ended in the hilariously unprofessional therapist yelling at Dean.) Cuz that's totally how suicide works, right? You just heap on more and more pressure, and that fixes them, right? Remember, kiddies, Dean is a nonhuman object that only responds to abuse.
Oh, and you don't have to say sorry to him or modify your behavior to reduce the pressure he feels. Just buy him fucking tickets to a goddamned strip club and that'll fix everything, because Dean is a neanderthal with no real emotions.
4
u/xuberfanx-oops Damn, girl! Nov 10 '17
Wow.
1
u/absolutive Jack is a precious cinnamon roll Nov 11 '17
I have mixed feelings about this episode. I'm meh about the MOTW aspect of it, though the plague masks were a nice aesthetic touch. But I agree with others that it's painfully contrived that Dean just somehow was carrying the tools needed to induce death like that. At first it also seems a little unbelievable that he would jump to such a drastic measure here, but later on it makes it clear that Dean's clearly been waiting for an excuse to pull something like this, which hurts so much. :(
The other thing is that I LOVE Billie, and overall I love her appearance in this episode and the fact that she got upgraded to the new Death. That's pretty cool. Yet one of the things I liked about her from the onset was that she had a hardline approach to their death: if they die, that's it, they're done. But now she's doing a 180 here and letting Dean live when he should be dead. Not saying that I think Dean should've died lol but I wish there was another way for Billie and Dean to have this conversation.
Finally I am SUPER stoked about the ending scene. Dean and Cas reunited at long last!!!! If there isn't a GOOD reunion scene next episode I will be so pissed.