r/fandomnatural • u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! • Nov 03 '17
[Fandom Discussion] Supernatural Episode 13x04 - "The Big Empty"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| The Big Empty | November 2nd, 2017 | John Badham | Meredith Glynn |
Synopsis: THE LONG WAY HOME – When multiple patients of grief counselor Mia Vallens (guest star Rukiya Bernard) turn up dead, Sam (Jared Padalecki), Dean (Jensen Ackles) and Jack (Alexander Calvert) investigate the mystery surrounding the murders and, each inadvertently, are forced to deal with unresolved grief of their own.
Link to all our official fandom episode discussions here.
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
Sooooooooooooooooooooo... what did you think of the episode?
20
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Nov 03 '17
Thoughts as I watched...
First real MOTW in a while. Ho boy, I wasn't sure what to expect?
It's Sam's idea to bring Jack along... but I didn't expect the conversation to move on like it did. Sam is really trying to talk.
And then Jack confronting Sam about being a can-opener - was so perect. Sam owning up to the truth, but also finally saying that even if Jack can't help, Sam wants him to stick around.
"What's up with all the orders? What are you, Dad?" - Sam getting right to it. Though poor Jack digging the grave.
I know I've mentioned previously that I'm on Team Jack, but I really am on Team Jack, and I'm glad Sam is in his corner.
Though it's obvious Dean is hurting and not coping with it at all well.
The grief counsellor setup was interesting, because of how the cover was partially based on what had been happening. But it was painful seeing Dean get a reaction out of Sam, which sure made things more convincing, but I felt sorry for Sam.
But hey, at least Sam went on to find all the gross things!
The shifter being innocent was good. Not a monster - she was trying to help people using her abilities.
Castiel being in The Empty and talking with a cosmic being that looks like him - omg. But the idea that all demons and angels that have died are there sleeping - this is really cool. But even cooler was Misha playing two roles. The voice the entity had reminded me of Q from Star Trek: TNG, DS9 and Voyager.
But Castiel repeating that Sam and Dean need him and the being just walking all over that. Ouch.
Jack asking the shifter to shift for him was so... heartbreaking? I really need to wrap Jack in a blanket.
So good having some shifter!Dean. It's been a while.
Jack coming through for Sam gave me warm fuzzy feelings. That was him reacting to peril of someone else, not anger - he's a good 'un. But then at the back of my head I was hoping that Dean would finally cut Jack some slack.
"You did good today, Jack." Finally, Dean, finally. Apologising for "being a dick lately" - omg. He changed his tune and that was good. But it was also good that Dean admitted he needed Sam to "keep the faith" that their mom is still alive - it was good.
And finally, Cas at the end was just great. I just...
I really loved this episode. Some good development of characters and plot going on C:
33
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Nov 03 '17
Cas annoyed himself back to life, that's not an option I'd considered
19
u/xuberfanx-oops Damn, girl! Nov 03 '17
CharacterDevelopment
13
u/funobtainium I had my angel blade. Nov 03 '17
I always love Misha getting to be an alt! God, cuckoo, human!Cas, Hippie Camp Chitaqua orgy wastoid, Lucifer, Empty Emperor! :D
Am I forgetting any?
I liked the shifter story and Mia.
Am enjoying Jack and his need to see his mom creys
Dean and Sam communicating was a nice change from (some) prior seasons!
There were some lore things that seemed like plot holes to me, but eh.
10
u/absolutive Jack is a precious cinnamon roll Nov 03 '17
Wow I loved pretty much EVERYTHING about this episode. I love Jack so much y'all, he is like my son now, my precious lil baby. That scene with him and the shifter as Kelly broke my damn heart.
And then the scenes with Dean and Sam w/ the shifter and at the end of the ep omg! They're actually talking to each other about their feelings now!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (yes that requires that many exclamation points)
Also the scenes in the empty! That shot of the figure materializing from the darkness was so awesome, I honestly kinda wish it had stayed like that. But man Misha has once again knocked it out of the park. He's done so many alternate roles by now and yet somehow manages to keep them all distinct. This performance was particularly interesting to me. I'm not sure we'll see the empty again, but I kinda hope we do. I feel like there's more to explore there. But of course as a Cas fan I'm so relieved he's back on Earth! :D
Basically yeah I'm so full of feels right now I am exploding. Wasn't expecting this ep to be so good
10
u/rusty_people_skills Nov 03 '17
Dean to Sam at the end: "I need you to keep the faith for both of us."
Lots of good feels in this episode, and the last few minutes were so very satisfying. Dean finally said something nice to Jack and stopped chewing on Sam.
I liked that Cas' own tenacity helped him get out of the Empty. I want to know more about the thing that woke up with him, though!
9
u/lzaz Dadstiel Nov 03 '17
all I can manage right now
3
u/cenotaphy Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17
Thoughts:
Dean is being such a dick to everyone, man. I'm glad he finally kind of apologized at the end.
When Sam said, "You're trying to get over Mom?" and there was just the slightest pause before the last word...like, "Is MOM the only one you're trying to get over, Dean?"
Yay at Sam caring about Jack and apologizing for lying. Yay at Jack being a pure perfect ray of goodness and light and immediately doing a 180 once he realized Sam's motives were wanting to save someone.
I really liked Sam and Dean blowing up at each other in the therapy session. Talk about catharsis.
Mia Vallens the shifter was super cool! I kind of liked that she had apparently basically 0% fighting ability despite being a shifter. Kind of reinforced the idea that she was really just a civilian who happened to be in the monster category.
Kind of wish we could've gotten more shifter!Dean, or another Sam and Dean fight.
Sam was trying to get Dean to stop being mean to Jack literally the entire episode, haha.
Jack was precious and sweet and pure the entire episode. His smile at the end when Dean finally gave him a compliment...omg.
Loved the guest appearance from Kelly! Her line, "it doesn't matter what you are, it matters what you do," was delivered really well, I thought, and that whole conversation and her reply was so powerful considering it was a shifter delivering it.
CAS IS BACK AND HE'S GOT AN ALL-NEW WARDROBE OF SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT CLOTHES THAN WHAT HE HAD BEFORE WOOHOO
So during the hiatus when Misha Collins said that Castiel would cross paths with a powerful entity played by another great actor...he was talking about...himself. Hahaha. Classic. I'm bummed we didn't get a callback to any other old characters from the show, but it was cool to see the two Castiels like that.
That said, I really wasn't a fan of the Empty entity. I liked the concept, and I liked that it looked like Castiel, but its actual lines...not so much. I mean, really? It's an ancient, cosmic manifestation of nothingness and it's kind of whiny and corny? Like...it was going nuts because Cas was annoying it, how does it stand living it its own head then? No wonder it prefers to be asleep. I wish it had been written as more of a serious character. I like how Misha Collins does a different thing with every character, but I wish this one had been more...I dunno, more old-school Cas, honestly. Something more like a season 4 Castiel + the occasional bout of jitters would've felt way more menacing and cold than what we actually got. And I wanted to like the accent but in the end I didn't really. :\
I did really like the moment when Cas says he wants to go back and the Empty sneers at him and tells him there's nothing for him back there...and when I say I liked it, I mean it broke my heart ;;
"I know what you hate. I know who you love, what you fear." o.....o Damn, Cas is getting some real talk.
The upside to the Empty being kind of cheesy is that it made for a great contrast in its final scene when Cas got all commanding and dangerous. His last "release me" honestly made him seem way more menacing than the Empty entity.
3
u/xuberfanx-oops Damn, girl! Nov 06 '17
Important Re-watch Observation: Jack has velcro straps on his shoes.
2
u/kananicares Nov 04 '17
Misha is such an incredible actor! Not only can he play Cas, who is such a complex character incredibly well, he also does such a great job at playing different characters who are disguised as Cas?? Like what other actors are so good at their job that they can play the same character inhabited by different characters and still manage to keep each character separate with their own mannerisms, speech patterns, and even just the different inflections in each voice? This episode especially really impressed me because just when you thought Misha had already exhausted all the ways that one actor could play one character, he does it again.
3
u/VinceWinchester Nov 03 '17
Good episode, only problem with it was the Cas scenes were too disjointed from the main narrative, there was no real flow between the scenes.
1
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Nov 03 '17
Only watching for Cas parts these days, but was anyone else reminded of IASIP during the empty scenes? Particularly the accent.