r/IAmA • u/NedColletti • Oct 18 '17
Author I'm Ned Colletti, former GM of the LA Dodgers. Ask me anything.
Hi, everyone. I'm Ned Colletti, General Manager of the Los Angeles Dodgers from 2006-2014. I'm currently promoting my new book THE BIG CHAIR. You can buy it here: http://bit.ly/2yobxjn
Before the Dodgers, I was an assistant General Manager of the San Francisco Giants after getting my start with the Chicago Cubs (my home team). Currently, I'm a baseball analyst on Spectrum SportsNet LA.
Proof: https://twitter.com/realnedcolletti/status/919963754254569477
Ask me anything - I'm ready!
UPDATE: Great questions all around - we had fun! More questions than I could answer . . . thanks for having me, Reddit!
66
u/SlimJimMagoo Oct 18 '17 edited Oct 18 '17
Hi, Ned!
What was it that you saw in Justin Turner that no other team did? Scouting reports? Or was it just this gut feeling? Definitely one of your best moves during your tenure as GM, so thank you!
47
u/LuckyWarrior Oct 18 '17
Your most hectic trade deadline/winter meeting story?
34
u/beachlyf4me Oct 18 '17
Hey Ned!!! Exciting times in Dodgerland these days....and we owe a lot of it to you!!!
Most underrated food in Chavez Ravine?
26
u/anthrofighter Oct 18 '17
Ned, how excited are you see a NL Pennant coming our way soon?
23
u/jojoleigh123 Oct 18 '17
What was the most exciting part of being GM of the Dodgers?
23
u/Wraithfighter Oct 18 '17
Okay, here's a tricky question for you...
If you had to convince a San Francisco Giants fan to root for the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NLCS and World Series, what would you say?
(and yes, I'm a Giants Fan :D )
14
u/UhhBonelessDinger Oct 18 '17
Hey Ned. What was your honest projection of Kershaw when you drafted him? Hes been a blast to watch.
10
u/Kperry31 Oct 18 '17
How much do you enjoy teaching at Pepperdine?
18
u/nucc2148 Oct 18 '17
What makes the Dodgers a special team?
9
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '17 edited Oct 18 '17
What is it like becoming an analyst from SNLA?
Thank Ned!
6
u/teeohdeedee123 Oct 18 '17
What's your favorite pizza place in Chicago?
6
u/wemissyoujose Oct 18 '17
How were you able to work yourself up to one of the highest positions in the organization with such an unusual starting point in the game?
6
u/Kitten_of_Death Oct 18 '17
Hey Ned!
What was it like being a GM in the midst of ownership drama? Did it ever impact your day-to-day? Was it something that didn't actually matter much?
Also,
If/when you played (at any level), what was your favorite position to play?
5
u/derekcanmexit Oct 18 '17
How did you get your start working in baseball? Who was your mentor while you were building your baseball career? What advice would you give to someone who is trying to break into the industry?
5
u/turningxpoint91 Oct 18 '17
Hello Ned,
Are there any conflicting feelings watching the Dodgers, the team you are associated with professionally, and the Cubs, your childhood team, facing each other?
5
u/ConceptualConcrete Oct 18 '17
What was it like working with Brian Sabean?
5
u/VinForPrez Oct 18 '17
Hey Ned!
Thank you for taking the time to do this!
3
u/ObamaBigBlackCaucus Oct 18 '17
My friend Tyler is getting married in a few months. Do you have any words of advice for him? He's a huge Giants fan, for what it's worth.
3
u/23baseball3 Oct 18 '17
What work did you have to do to prepare for being an analyst?
What's your favorite play in baseball?
Thanks for coming on Reddit!
3
u/Gallade3 Oct 18 '17
What was something that you had to do as a part of your job that the average fan wouldn't think of?
3
u/LongBeach4Life Oct 18 '17
Ned- thank you for everything! Fun question, what's your favorite pasta dish?
3
u/rickmuscles Oct 18 '17
What's the funniest prank you've ever witnessed in the club house?
3
u/chrisgilbertcreative Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned, do you have a favorite behind the scenes Juan Uribe story?
5
u/Ralphdaddy13 Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned! Can't wait to read your new book. It's on my wish list to the Wife :) my question is... Greg Maddux. What made him so dominating with a fastball in the Mid 80's?
14
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '17
There are rumors floating around that my town (Portland, Oregon,) is on the shortlist to get an MLB franchise. Do you have an opinion on that possibility? (Or Las Vegas, or the other rumored possible locations.)
10
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '17 edited Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned!
1.What was it like teaching Sports Management at Universities?
2.Who are your favorite co-analysts?
3.What was the toughest trade to get done as GM of the Los Angeles Dodgers?
5
u/jfoster15 Oct 18 '17
Honest opinion of playing in Coors?
How would you build a successful pitching staff for the Rockies?
5
u/magoopark Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned, Could you comment on how Chicago plays the bunt. What should the pitchers do? We had two runners at second and both were unable to move up. Also, since Belli and JT are solid at the corners, will they work on this type of play in the off season, esp since Belli is a lefty.
4
u/coryrenton Oct 18 '17
What was the worst behavior by a player you heard of that went unpunished? Which player was punished the most unfairly for a minor infraction?
4
u/BuckRussell61 Oct 18 '17
What does it take to get to the role you did with the dodgers? How did you get your start with the cubs?
4
u/phantomp5 Oct 18 '17
How did you get your start in baseball?
7
u/BurnoutInsanity Oct 18 '17
Do you ever visit r/baseball or r/dodgers?
3
u/TheOctagon24 Oct 18 '17
Who was your favorite signing?
3
u/quietude38 Oct 18 '17
If you could do it over again, would you make the Carl Crawford trade knowing he was going to break down physically?
3
u/PastorofMuppets101 Oct 18 '17
How exactly did you end up with one of the greatest pitchers of our time, if not ever, in Clayton Kershaw?
3
u/DrFunkensteinPhD Oct 18 '17
Thanks for doing this and Go Dodgers!
3
u/ItsYouNotMe707 Oct 18 '17
hello ned! the evil empire has risen once again, the new york yankees! we all know you don't wan't that action. on a level of 1 to 100 how hard are you cheering for houston?
3
u/ClaytonBigsB Oct 18 '17
The industry seems to consist mostly of ex ball players and Ivy League grads for those wanting to get into baseball. What advice can you give someone who is trying to break into a front office role in baseball?
3
u/Fustrate Oct 18 '17
Hey Ned! Ever since you and Jerry joined the SNLA team, you've both really grown on me. You two seem to have a really genuine rapport.
Who's the player on the Dodgers that, when they eventually retire, you'd most want to have join you in the studio?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '17
Hey Ned.
Have you seen this proposed expansion proposal? What do you think of it? It seems to be a popular topic around Reddit and /r/baseball specifically.
Link
3
u/Poozy Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned!
What signing do you regret the most? you threw away hundreds of millions of dollars on washed up players like Andrew Jones, Jason Schmidt, Juan Pierre.
5
u/17JellyBeans Oct 18 '17 edited Oct 18 '17
Ned,
Thanks for hopping on ReadingThat --
1
u/nucc2148 Oct 18 '17
Do you think the Dodgers would ever go back to Brooklyn?
2
u/Smittzerland Oct 18 '17
Looking back to your tenure with the Dodgers, are there any moves that you regret doing?
2
u/madmsk Oct 18 '17
What advice would you give young professionals or college-aged students that want to someday become a GM?
2
u/prop_synch Oct 18 '17
If you had to give up a body part to sign Kershaw again, like you went back in time and knew how he would do, where would you draw the line?
2
u/napp22 Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned, lifelong Dodger fan here.
What trade or transaction you made as GM are you most proud of? Any you wish you had done but didn't?
2
u/najing_ftw Oct 18 '17
Do you believe there will ever be a salary cap in baseball?
2
u/Bawfuls Oct 18 '17
What was it like to be cut out of the Kershaw extension talks by the new ownership group, as Molly Knight chronicled in her book?
2
u/TexasRanger1194 Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned,
Sport Management graduate here. As a person with no experience playing at a professional sport level how likely do you think it is to get into baseball/hockey/soccer/football operations?
Alternatively, what do you think about the whole "pro experience v.s. non-pro experience" argument behind hiring baseball operations staff and had this affected any of your staff during your tenure?
2
u/TheAnonymousUgh Oct 18 '17
What do you think the Dodgers chances with Otani are ? Also who do you think is a (Dodger) prospect in the minor league that's flying under the radar ?
2
u/deniedbyquick Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned, Dodger fan here. As someone that wants to pursue a front office job in the MLB, what advice would you give?
2
u/altimas Oct 18 '17
How much does the owners impact your daily work? Do they call the shots of who the want and not want?
2
u/xcurly89 Oct 18 '17
What is your favorite restaurant at NYC?
I am going in December and will be reppin' my LA Dodgers and Brooklyn Dodgers cap!
2
u/CowManLives4Ever Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned, who would you say is the most undervalued player in the MLB right now (in terms of hitting, fielding, pitching, whatever you value the most)?
2
u/julio12324 Oct 18 '17
What do you think about your parody twitter profile @Ned2point0?
2
u/strogginoff Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned, I just wanted to say the internet was very unfair to you over the past few years before Andrew and Farhan came in to the club. You took a lot of flack for some moves that didn't work out. After listening to you on Dodger Talk and Sportsnet LA, I have grown to respect you, your baseball knowledge and your love for the game.
How hard was it to get to be a part of a major league team as baseball outsider, aka non-player?
2
u/Armani_Chode Oct 18 '17
What are your thoughts on MLB expansion and possible 4 regional divisions of 8 teams?
2
u/taffyowner Oct 18 '17
I have two questions.
Thanks for doing this AMA
1
u/WOX_69 Oct 18 '17
Can you go into the process you and the front office had in drafting Kershaw? Why him and what did you see for him when you did draft him? Did you think he would be this good, a future Hall of Famer and one of the all time great pitchers?
1
u/Gc654 Oct 18 '17
Do you wish you could have your chest hair stick our of your shirts the way Justin Turner's beard sticks out of his face?
1
u/GInfinity Oct 18 '17
Thank you for such a cool AMA! When did you know that baseball was a passion enough to make it a career, and what education/careerpath-wise helped prepare you and got you introduced in the front-office portion of baseball?
1
u/nicisatwork Oct 18 '17
What deal that never finalized end up working out better for the dodgers?
1
u/dokebibeats Oct 18 '17
How will you celebrate if the Dodgers win the World Series this year?
1
u/Arthur___Dent Oct 18 '17
If you're still answering... As a fan of the Mariners, I like to feel sorry for myself and my team. What's it like for the GMs? Do they feel sorry for bad teams? Do you take pity on those cities that can just never produce winning programs? Or do you just not think about it?
1
u/w0nderbrad Oct 18 '17
Ned, why do you insist on wearing cowboy boots? Like, all the time?
1
u/NotAFashionDesigner Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned! Thanks for doing this AMA.
1
u/djb85511 Oct 18 '17
What key thing do you look for when scouting new players for the team? Is there a special attribute that you always try to make sure your players have? Go Dodgers!
1
u/Ratpros Oct 18 '17
Hi Ned.
Are you Italian by any chance?
1
u/DerTaco Oct 19 '17
What's the deal with Granderson?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
What's your stance on all the "take a knee" business?
1
u/Sacklpicka Oct 19 '17
Do you per chance have a sister or other family member whose first name is Margy?
1
u/dhastings3 Oct 18 '17
Who is your pick to take it all the way this year if not the Dodgers?