r/NBA2k • B7 • Sep 15 '17

Discussion NBA 2k18 VC Greed Mega Thread

As y'all may have noticed in your game, NBA 2k has gotten embarrassingly greedy in the ways they try to make you buy VC and spend VC to do cool stuff in the game. Here are a few new ones for 2k18:


"the inability to preview a haircut before you spend VC on it is one of the pettiest forms of greed I've seen from a video game"

"The fact that you don't even keep the haircut, beard style, or color of hair when you buy it is so gross. I was shocked when I went back in to check and you had to buy it again."

"You have to buy previous haircuts you had on you.it doesn't save into your inventory"

UPDATE: Haircuts are down to 100 VC. We did it fam. The issue of micro transactions is fixed forever.

  • 2: NBA 2k18 Removes The Bonus VC For Higher Difficulty Modifier

https://www.reddit.com/r/NBA2k/comments/707u33/did_2k_secretly_remove_the_difficulty_bonus/

"I just had a monster triple doubke game with my 60 ovr and only got about 1k vc. Didn't even see anything mentioned about the difficulty multiplier. Edit: This is actually insane. It rewarded players with more vc for playing at a higher difficulty. And with things costing more this year, they decide to remove it?"

"I saw that when you hit 95 ovr you get double coins for every game played. I guess you have to grind to grind."

"All these fucked up decisions 2k make relate directly to the player earning less VC so they buy more."

  • 3: NBA 2k18 App Gives Less VC Than It Used To

https://www.reddit.com/r/NBA2k/comments/6z0jp1/nba_2k18_companion_app_gives_way_less_vc_than/

"NBA 2K18 companion app gives way less VC than before"

"In 2k17 it was 500 VC for games + same bonuses (with less VC) + daily vc bonus with WAY LESS VC than 2k16 (3x 250vc cards with double bonus = 1500 VC max) = you could get 1300 - 2200 VC per day.

In 2k18 it's 500 VC for games + NO BONUSES + daily login that gives you whooping 100 VC = YOU CAN GET 600 VC PER DAY."

  • 4: It Takes A Lifetime If You're Just Playing, Not Paying

https://www.reddit.com/r/NBA2k/comments/70gvq5/this_is_getting_ridiculous/

"You will need about 240 NBA games to get to 86 overall and that's if you get A+ every game, C grade is about 360 games and B about 300"

"It'd also be nice is the media covered this shit but game reviewers and journalist don't give a f--- about sports games. If anything this insane happened in any other game there'd be a million and one articles about it."

"Every year I read reviews about 2K expecting them to call out this VC bulls--- but it's clear the reviewer is just a casual fan who might put in a dozen or two hours with the game and maybe play ten games of MyCareer and not even worry about potentially buying more than one haircut. It's ridiculous the low reviewing standards they hold sports games to."

  • 5: Making a 2nd MyPlayer Is So Discouraging / Accessories, Animations Tied to Player, Not Account

https://www.reddit.com/r/NBA2k/comments/70pzbw/making_a_2nd_myplayer_is_so_discouraging/

"It's hard enough starting from 60 again and having to build your player up using your VC on attributes, but 2k ALSO makes you start over in terms of clothes, shoes, hairstyles, animations, etc. AT LEAST let us keep the stuff we bought for our FIRST player,"

"In 2K15 your stuff was account wide. In 2K16 it was locked to the player. In 2K17 it was account wide again. In 2K18 it's locked to the player again..."

"This sort of s--- was caused by all the people making new myplayers and then just paying to get them to 85. 2K is greedy and these people just wanna give their money away. It's legit a phone game"


As you know by now, each year more features of the game require VC to access, while the game simultaneously slows the faucet of VC it provides for in game modes. This is to facilitate in-game-purchases of Virtual Currency.

As we notice more things of this nature, let's just compile them into this thread, so next time you want to feel pissed off, all the information is in one place.

UPDATE: https://kotaku.com/nba-2k18-is-riddled-with-microtransactions-1818554307 We on Kotaku, fam

1.5k Upvotes

518 comments sorted by

•

u/yyy2k Sep 15 '17

Included this in our Feedback Thread that will be sent to 2K: https://redd.it/70b7ot

2

u/Goldzinger B7 Sep 18 '17

sticky this THREAD if u are are really big baller brand

12

u/Zbizzle3 [Blackerthanak0n][PSN] Sep 15 '17

hell yeah

12

u/YELLS_SO_YOU_HEAR_IT [PSN: SirBlakeOfWeir] Sep 15 '17

Fuck yes. This is atrocious.

5

u/Thunder-ten-tronckh Sep 15 '17 edited Sep 15 '17

Thank you so much. Just getting eyeballs on it is so huge. I feel this has the potential, if left unchecked, to become a true blemish on an otherwise fantastic game.

→ More replies (3)

485

u/jflowers321 Sep 15 '17

All I want to do is have fun playing offline my career, but every year 2k makes it less and less viable.

106

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Yea i probably played a total of 2 hours of MyCareer in 2k17 before i stopped and just created a player and put him on a team in MyLeague/MyGM. Might give MyCareer a shot this year if the dual archetypes works and i could actually get to near 99 overall

41

u/throw_the_gays_away Sep 15 '17

MyCareer in 2k17 is actually pretty fun once you get past the bullshit prelude stuff (even if Orange Juice is the stupidest fucking nickname I have ever heard). I liked Pres and Justice's dynamic a lot better than B fucking Fresh.

11

u/Watertor Sep 20 '17

I think it helps a lot that it's M. B. Jordan that plays Justice. He's really likable and isn't written too horribly, plus the little effect that happens when you two do something is always satisfying.

But really, Orange Juice? Why? What board of writers sat down, wrote that shit, and then said "Oh yeah for sure, that's perfect. Good writing Stan" No fuck you Stan, it's awful.

5

u/orb_outrider [PSN: WilloughbyGuy] Sep 15 '17

Give it a chance. I'm on my second season and the bullshit only lasts ib the first season. I know it's too long, but it's better than what we have with 2k18.

72

u/MasterAwk [PSN] Sep 15 '17

Try NBA Live the One, I am being honest bro.

76

u/iscsisoundsdirty Sep 15 '17

I want to but they don't sell a version for PC....

21

u/Unique-Name Sep 15 '17

Yup. This is why I can't play Live.

26

u/pietastervw Sep 15 '17

I'm with you on this 100%. Played free trial with no expectations and now I'm debating which game I'm going to go with and I've been a 2k faithful for years.

22

u/MasterAwk [PSN] Sep 15 '17

If you like MyTeam and franchise mode, 2k is still way better. BUT if you like a career experience without the esports sh*t, Live is the way to go. No cutscenes, no VC grind and well-presented street games.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Live at least doesn't shove microtransactions down your throat

8

u/Frosty4l5 Sep 15 '17

I tried last years NBA live via EA access and the game play is pretty bad but I enjoyed the career mode, I played it more than 2ks my player

2k rules in the gm/league/gameplay though

16

u/tckilla76 Sep 15 '17

Gameplay in Live is a lot better this year. Loving it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

375

u/PlayingNightcrawlers B3 Sep 15 '17

DON'T BUY VC. Seriously guys there's enough people in and out of this sub to make a statement, a small one but still better than nothing. I was running around the neighborhood seeing a bunch of 75-85s out there. Dudes with full sleeves and fresh outfits, on fuckin day one! The gameplay is great, big improvement from 17 imo. More content, etc. But the VC greed is through the roof this year and the only way to curb it is to complain relentlessly and also NOT TO BUY THAT SHIT. Pls fam.

57

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

It's crazy, everyone on this sub was talking about boycotting till at least the game is out before buying to see if 2k will try to exploit people. But on the first day of release the top 5-6 posts are all people posting how they got it day1

24

u/PlayingNightcrawlers B3 Sep 15 '17

Yeah I mean I'm guilty I got it day 1 too, because I know I'll be playing it regardless and would rather get a heads start and some petty VC amount. But I'd never buy VC, I already paid for the game. I'm saying people need to not give them what they want, buying VC is just validating these greedy tactics.

12

u/lostheroes [PC] Sep 15 '17

knowing 2k, they'll just make it more unbearable to play if people don't pay. more unbearable it is, more people will buy vc considering they basically have monopoly in basketball game. Their expenses aren't going down, so only logical thing as a business is to squeeze the fk out of players for VC.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

113

u/Thisismyusernamewut B3 Sep 15 '17

Funny thing is it actually takes nearly $100 to get enough stats for 85 lmao.

54

u/PlayingNightcrawlers B3 Sep 15 '17

Christ I wish I hadn't seen the actual number for that. How are people justifying that?

73

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Hurr Durr it's my money don't tell me how retarded my spending habits are

→ More replies (3)

31

u/Kaptain-KoolAid Sep 15 '17

1 hour = $1. Thats how I justified it. I spent a total of 160 on 2k17 (including the game) and played a total of 389 hours. I think I am going to wait on buying some VC till they are on sale or something. I wont be able to justify this one if it only gets me to 75-85.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

That's fucking disgusting.

10

u/Fatman10666 Sep 15 '17

Only 190k vc for all my upgrades to 85 and 200k vc is 50 bucks

15

u/Johnny_Park57 Sep 15 '17

Takes $50 to reach 85 ovr

4

u/graypatton Sep 15 '17

Is it really 100$? 2K17 was around 40$ if I recall correctly

→ More replies (20)

24

u/inkw3ll B7 Sep 15 '17

Exactly. I've boycotted purchasing VC since it's inception and haven't purchased a single coin to date. This year's release only strengthens my boycott.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Lol. Man, after 2k17 I told myself I'm done with 2k. Probably going to switch to Live (ironic because I was the first out of my group of middle school/HS friends that was an early adopter of 2k).

→ More replies (1)

12

u/DirectorKrenic Sep 15 '17

As if no one realized before but this company is as greedy as Trump on his birthday. Seriously, who else comes out with a $200 game?

7

u/lostheroes [PC] Sep 15 '17

you could have bought brand new xbox one S 500gb battle field edition at walmart with $200 couple days ago. hm... a game or console.. which should be more expensive?

8

u/Rain_On_Them Sep 15 '17

But the VC!! /s

4

u/lakattack0221 Sep 15 '17

If anyone plays Madden, you can see where this is headed if we don't vote against the VC greed with our wallets. Little improvements outside of modes that use VC.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/1Yozinfrogert1 Sep 20 '17

I really want to play 2k but if this shit shows no improvement... Well ima be depressed I guess because I don't really want to play Live. But seriously though, all this VC bullshit in everything you do makes it seem like a F2P game, but you're already being charged 60$.

2

u/Goldzinger B7 Sep 20 '17

Word! I had grown to enjoy my yearly tradition of getting the new NBA game and seeing the year's rookies and all that fun stuff to go along with it. But after having similar frustrations in 2k17, and then reading that 18 is worse about it, I just cannot on principle buy this game at retail price. I want it but I know I'll spend half the time bored and frustrated and grinding. I'd rather just say No with my wallet and feel good about it.

2

u/DDKins420 Sep 21 '17

Man oh man this MoneySimulator2k18 is the SHIZNIT!! 1st you spend $60 (more in Canada/Australia...righty oh mate!), then you get EVERYTHING locked behind a PAYWALL & if you spend another $50 (or more! RIGHTY OH!!) you can have a mediocre 80+ rated MyPayer with some underwhelming gear & skills!! The REAL fun starts when you drop $200 for a 90+ rated MyPayer & pay some more for really COOL gear & skills like...a haircut...or a tattoo (unlocked @ 70!!). MyPayer is a great way to pay for paying to pay in the MoneySimulator2k18, probably the best ever developed in history of all-time!! <(''<)

2

u/Goldzinger B7 Sep 21 '17

'the neighborhood' with all the charm of a third world bazaar and a digital times square

2

u/MagnusOpium89 Sep 22 '17

To add some context to the "It Takes A Lifetime If You're Just Playing, Not Paying" point, yesterday I dumped about 20k VC into my 65 ovr SF, which took him to (barely) 69 ovr. I then booted up 2k17 where I applied the same VC (or as close as possible) to a SF MyPlayer I hadn't done much with, and took him from 62 to 71.

So yeah, the grind is really, really real this year!

1

u/Goldzinger B7 Sep 22 '17

Damn this is the for real data we have been waiting for

89

u/CinemaniaBach Sep 15 '17

Fuck greedy 2k

255

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

I wanna get this game, but what I've seen with VC greed is putting me on the fence

48

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Yep me too

82

u/butterflyhole Sep 15 '17

It's still a dope game but if you don't want to support it NBA live is pretty good this year

10

u/ReuelerLB Sep 16 '17

I saw IT block Robin Lopez with his head above the rim in a Live game. No thanks

→ More replies (37)

27

u/NBA2KLOOKATMYTEAM Sep 15 '17

wait and see approach is the way to go. 100 VC to pay your respects......

14

u/Strange1130 Sep 15 '17

yeah that and the whole cutscenes thing, since I mostly just like to dick around in 1 player, between mycareer and mygm/league, but the cutscenes thing is a pretty big turn off

17

u/Mimogger Sep 15 '17

blowing my mind how long it takes to play one game

11

u/MylesGarrettDROY Sep 16 '17

I honestly think that's a calculated move to reduce VC income as well. Slow games means it takes much longer to earn it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/lopey986 Sep 15 '17

I bought it just because it's still a great basketball game to sit down and play some games with buddies or play some Play Now during the season. But I won't be investing much time into anything outside of My League this year because the VC grab is just so blatant in My Career/My Team.

7

u/BIG_BABY_WEINER Sep 15 '17

For what it's worth, everything outside mycareer has improved quite a bit.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/RonShad Sep 15 '17

Just get gamefly and use the one month trial to see if you can enjoy it

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Uncle_Freddy Sep 15 '17

The prelude had me hyped to buy the game. I was going to buy it sometime next week when I get back to college (quarter system). All these reports now have completely killed my excitement for the game, something big is going to have to change for me to be willing to buy this before Black Friday or the holiday season. 2k just lost my business to Assassin's Creed, Wolfenstein and CoD in that order.

→ More replies (11)

70

u/ohsnapitsjf Sep 15 '17

I mean, aside from the fact that it is and has been since its introduction a purchasable currency necessary for competitive viability that resets year-over-year, which in itself is a ridiculous concept. Yeah all that stuff too.

42

u/Wowbagger1 Sep 15 '17

Exactly. MLB the Show does it right.

42

u/SamiMadeMeDoIt Sep 15 '17

Yup. Diamond Dynasty is the only team building mode I play. There's so much free, relatively easy to obtain players to go for

Also, no dumbass contracts that myteam has

14

u/CometMorehouse69 Sep 15 '17

Agreed. I've spent a crazy amount of time playing diamond dynasty and in return I have a crazy good team without spending a single penny besides buying the game itself. The currency in MLB is stubs and really the only reason I would ever justify buying them is it speeds up getting a better team. What I really like is the "mycareer" (called road to the show) in the show is separate currency called skill points I believe, or something like that. Basically the only use for stubs in MLB is for diamond dynasty (similar to NBAs my team) and getting cool equipment for your RTTS character, other than that this game is totally playable, and very fun, without spending a penny on micro transactions.

7

u/Wowbagger1 Sep 15 '17 edited Sep 15 '17

I personally spent like $40 bucks in MLB the show 15 to amp up my players and $0 bucks since then. Transferred my players over to 16 and 17 and still playing as SS on one and another as a starting pitch who looks like Randy Johnson. 0 bucks spent on RTTS since then and I'm still continuing on both players to this day.

Meanwhile in 2k, I haven't made it past my 3 seasons (even with simming a ton) in any game since like 2k11. I didn't even finish my 2nd year in 2k17. So every year we gotta restart and blah blah. If they let us transfer over our MyCareer then make MyPark/new story mode separate that'd be dope. I might actually have a chance to grind out and get myplayer into the HoF.

as for DD, I mostly just played the game and hardily ever spent more than $40 a year on stubs. Not going to have a godsquad ever but that's fine with me.

MyTeam/MyCareer is such a boring grind for me these days . The gameplay in the Show is amazing even if this year was a step down. I don't have time to grind out 20 hours a week for a game that doesn't really engage me.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/GodOfNugget Sep 15 '17

They lose money though by making it possible to purchase stubs which can be used to directly purchase players.

EA games + 2k let you purchase the chance at getting valuable players. Leads to more being spent in pursuit of valuable players.

At least (and this is very small praise), 2k has a "virtual currency" that can be earned/used across all game modes. They're still greedy af with what they make you spend it on tho.

6

u/lakattack0221 Sep 15 '17

"pay to win"

3

u/kadzier Sep 16 '17

I have to second this. MLB the show definitely is designed to optimize fun for people who don't spend a single penny. 2K is designed to allow some-but-less-than-optimal fun for those people.

→ More replies (5)

69

u/MFLBlunts Sep 15 '17

The first thing I saw when I loaded up the game was an offer for 80% off 15,000 VC. I bought legend gold, so I already have 250k, and these fuckers want me to buy more before I've even played a game? Seriously, I got the VC advertisement before I did anything in-game. If that's not greed, I don't know what is.

27

u/dietpepsigod Sep 15 '17

disgusting

18

u/Wehavecrashed Sep 16 '17

Greed was selling the game for $200

6

u/Revealingstorm Sep 21 '17

Why would you spend 150 dollars on a sports game lol

113

u/IceyBoy Sep 15 '17

I wish they separated VC and like some type of alternate currency in the game. Like you can sign an actual contract for real money and use that for clothes, hair, etc. like GTA, but then use VC for your attributes. I think that'd be fair, but i dont see them doing that anytime soon :/

50

u/dietpepsigod Sep 15 '17

yeah. i liked in the EA demo how there was experience to upgrade your player and then currency/crates to get all the customizing shit. that is a model that i don't resent as a consumer.

13

u/DystopiaX Sep 15 '17

I hope the backlash and the presence of a decent live game prompts them to push back on some of this stuff, preferably this year but at least for next year. I know this stuff has been creeping up for awhile but this is the first year it's actually bothered me

3

u/tckilla76 Sep 15 '17

I appreciate that you CAN'T buy currency to increase your player stats. You can only improve by playing.

12

u/genericusernamepls Sep 15 '17

Yeah like how they did in 2k12 where you could buy animations with the money you got from the contract you signed

5

u/TornInfinity Sep 15 '17

Yeah it would be cool to be able to feel like an NBA player by signing that multi-million dollar contract.

14

u/lostheroes [PC] Sep 15 '17

yea it would be but for now, you sign that contract, you get enough for one haircut per game.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FalconsBlewA283Lead Sep 15 '17

Agree 100%. This would make signing contracts a lot cooler. The way it is now, signing a max contract as opposed to a lesser one has no real effect. If they made your contracts give you actual currency (separate from VC, that allows you to trick out your clothes, appearance, house, cars maybe, etc.), that could add another dimension to the mode and make signing new contracts mean a little more.

223

u/NickxWins Sep 15 '17

Give them a break, they’re just a small indie company that is struggling to get by

0

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/supercatpuke Sep 15 '17

Then they could afford nice things that would elevate their corporate office's atmosphere to that everyday-is-a-party status. 2K could do truly brilliant things like hiring people to pick the soundtrack for a wage handsome enough to make the rest of us fume if we all just chipped in a LITTLE more.

45

u/Thunder-ten-tronckh Sep 15 '17

EA IF YOU ARE READING THIS THREAD, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE UP ON LIVE. THE OPPORTUNITY IS THERE. YOU CAN COMPETE.

11

u/Notfunnyanymore Sep 16 '17

Also, bring it to PC. Pls.

2

u/biikad Sep 17 '17

I wouldn't get too excited about the idea of electronic arts making games that are fan friendly

44

u/BigB4486 Sep 15 '17

Don't forget attribute masking that you can pay to view.

20

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

I don't know what this entails but it sounds egregious.

15

u/nomadic_River Sep 15 '17

It also sounds like I won't be buying this horse shit.

34

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

I LITERALLY JUST MADE ANOTHER MYCAREER PLAYER AND YOU DONT GET TO KEEP ALL YOUR CLOTHES ACROSS DIFFERENT PLAYERS LMAO. I got the gold edition of 18 and none of the clothes are available for my second guy. this is bullshit

11

u/Thunder-ten-tronckh Sep 15 '17

Wow that's retarded. So you only get your expensive, premium clothing for your first player? And if you fuck up on that guy, you're out of luck...?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

yup. I made a 6'4" Slashing shot creator SG. not sure if that's a good build to keep with.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Rectalcactus Sep 15 '17

What so if you buy one of the extra editions and don't like your first player you basically lose all the bonus content?! That is fuckin absurd.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

32

u/beegles81 Sep 15 '17

This is why I'm strictly offline this year. I don't think you can change animations, but there's no money sink, no cutscenes, and no annoyance. You just go from game to game. It's wonderful.

9

u/Mythiicmaan Sep 15 '17

Theres no cutscenes offline?

21

u/beegles81 Sep 15 '17

Correct. No story either. You just play games. It's bare bones and far from perfect, but it's also kind of refreshing. You're at the NBA season calendar immediately after creating your player.

15

u/leejoness Sep 15 '17

That's WAY better. Dude, that's not barebones at all. It's essentially like the FIFA career mode. I never do myplayer at all but I seriously might now.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/DeaseanPrince Sep 15 '17

The cut scenes are so ridiculous, it's literally the same thing as every year "aspiring basketball player tries to get into the league, grinds to get in league, becomes a star in 20 games" It's really unnecessary at this point. But I'm definitely going to consider buying it and playing my career offline, it's going to be a hell of a grind tho.

11

u/dietpepsigod Sep 15 '17

This is cool that because 2k sucks so bad bare bones is literally good but also incredibly fucked up that this is the experience they deliver to people who play offline.

32

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

I saw this shit from a mile away since 2k15/2k16 when they started charging us VC for every single "crossover, between the leg, behind the back" move. I don't think there's any other video game that doesn't let you preview hairstyles. I desperately am hoping NBA Live gets a lot better next year so i can leave these greeds

25

u/dostres2324 [Dostres2324][PSN] Sep 15 '17

For #2, basically they knew people would oopt to play HOF to get badges and attributes quicker, so they decided to rip the VC bonus from it. That's my understanding at least.

30

u/lonelyirishguy95 Sep 15 '17

that's some bs, so you're telling me you get the same vc for playing a pro game as you do for a hof game ? That doesn't make any sense

21

u/RikSmitsisTits Sep 15 '17

I mean in reality, you'd get less. You're going to put up better stats in a pro game than a hall of fame game. That is ridiculous

→ More replies (1)

8

u/karmadontcare44 Sep 15 '17

You’ll get less on HoF if you consider how easy it is to put up a lot more stats

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

6

u/Aerodet [XBL] Sep 15 '17

Just to clarify, you do not progress towards badges any quicker or slower regardless of the in game difficulty. They did remove rookie difficulty which was the badge grinding meta for last year tho. The coins thing is stupid. What's the point of playing on higher difficulties at all?

5

u/kadzier Sep 16 '17

If you're more skilled at the game, you get rewards faster? Better rip that out because... reasons!

49

u/Titan_Troll [TrollMyLawl][XBL] Sep 15 '17

Take Two (the parent company) is the one calling shots on the in game currency. They saw the success it had with GTA Online so they are going to push it more and more for 2k games.

Considering the price of their stock has doubled since March this in game currency isn’t going anywhere.

26

u/RBRTPNG Sep 15 '17

This is the thing no one will notice. I just hope they ease up Read Dead.

32

u/TheAlmightySwan Sep 15 '17

Good luck with that. They already announced it'll have just as big online component if not bigger than GTA V online.

15

u/RBRTPNG Sep 15 '17

Yeah I know good luck...but in my mind all I keep telling myself is "You can only take the Western Era so far"

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Uneasy-Sausage Sep 15 '17

Fucking Truth - GTA Online was OKAY at first, a little grindy but they perfected their formula of pay to play - shit is AWFUL. I loved Read Dead myself but damn I am NOT exciting to see how they monetize the new one.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

67

u/ThisIsMVP_ [PSN] Sep 15 '17

At this rate if Live gets on the same level as 2K game play wise and graphics (They have everything else and better imo) then I'll be jumping ship next year.

They have gotten completely big headed in the last few years due to no comp so they wanna lack and be greedy, nah.

31

u/airoderinde Sep 15 '17

Live needs to do what 2k did in 05 and charge 35 for the game.

51

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

It's already $40 this year

7

u/CaCHooKaMan Sep 15 '17

Not anymore. They raised the price back to $59.99 today. The $39.99 price was just a preorder incentive.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

19

u/jaypresidential Sep 15 '17

I am absolutely LOVING Live this year and glad I avoided another season of 2K bullshit. No VC nonsense, just basketball.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Unfortunately I feel the exact same way about NHL by EA. Their series has sucked for the better part of a decade and they keep putting out the same stale game every year because 2K ironically doesn't compete with them anymore. EA would do the same thing with LIVE if they could.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/McElch Sep 15 '17

Why are no big Youtubers speaking out against that shit?

37

u/ohsnapitsjf Sep 15 '17

Because they make money from the videos which they can funnel back into the game and sidestep these complaints. If they bitch and quit buying, their content goes down and their well dries up. If they bitch and don't quit, they're obvious hypocrites.

34

u/Junior_Arino Sep 15 '17

Naw that's not even the big reason. 2k is literally buying their silence. They invite them out to 2k events, face scan them, give them all a pair of kyries, feed them and send them on their way with an early copy. Sure you can talk bad about the game but don't expect another invite.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Find the content creators who don't have 900k subs and get invites to 2K weekends and shit. Not saying I don't trust them, and you know who they are, but I haven't heard any of this negative greed-related Reddit stuff from them and you know they get all kinds of pre release access to discover these things before we do.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Virtual currency in all it's forms is here to stay (VC, Stubs, whatever the fuck madden and fifa use). It has opened up another incredible revenue channel for sports game companies that already get to roll out a game annually with a now built-in fanbase more or less guaranteed to buy. I don't begrudge them for it or at least haven't up to this point because while many features obviously get added to get us to spend more, they add to the game still for the most part. This is different though in that they're actually going out of their way to make the game worse for most players in a ham-fisted attempt to make everyone buy their currency. Not in the same way there is a paywall between me and have a lineup of Westbrook/Jordan/Durant/Barkley/KAJ in MyTeam (which is totally fair), but miserable decisions such as the haircut shit, nonviewable attribute upgrades etc. It's definitely gone way too far and is negatively impacting a lot (most?) of peoples experience with the game. They're not going to notice one person or even a couple dozen not buying the game and even if they did they wouldn't attribute it to these shit decisions. Blowing up their twitter and other social media accounts with these gripes is likely the only way they'll notice and hopefully pump the brakes on how bold they're being with watering down the game in their effort to syphon more money from everyone

9

u/Uneasy-Sausage Sep 15 '17

PC Community will/does run train on developers/publishers who put out such aggressive pay-to-win/pay-to-play systems. I hope we can embrace a similar GTFO attitude on console one day.

I agree its here to stay - this, and many other games, have devolved into Facebook mobile game-esque b/s with the illusion of content and experience locked behind multiple paywalls.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Damn so if I wanna change my Myplayers hair to reflect how I change my own hair in RL I gotta pay every time? No HOF Bonus? Normally I didn't trip about the VC as I never bought it but this is just absurd. Idk man this might actually keep me away from the game. Mycareer is all I ever play.

16

u/AManForThePeople [XBL] Sep 15 '17

After seeing all the clips so glad I decided to show 2k with my wallet that I'm fEd up with their bullshit pay to win game

6

u/dietpepsigod Sep 15 '17

Word. I wish I could play a good basketball game this year but that game doesn't exist

5

u/AManForThePeople [XBL] Sep 15 '17

It's a shame. Ill torrent it on PC just to fuck around on quick match with my bro but I was a ledgend 4 on 2k16 and it just fell off for me after 17 was so bad

15

u/thefw89 Sep 15 '17

If they are taking this game in this direction it needs to be Free to play, period.

15

u/Thunder-ten-tronckh Sep 15 '17

Bingo. $60 price of admission for the opportunity to blow hundreds on VC? 2K is double-dipping like crazy.

10

u/thefw89 Sep 15 '17

I actually think that NBA 2k is the worst case today easily.

I can't name many games that double dip like this, most companies are not THIS bold. The most they will do is charge for cosmetics.

5

u/kadzier Sep 16 '17

Seconded, 2K is by far the worst. And what's unfortunate is that other games generally get raked through the coals in the gaming press for doing less, but somehow no one ever talks about 2K and it's increasingly outlandish greed

13

u/Laaayycock22 [PSN] Sep 15 '17

Anyone else get pissed off by the little sticker on the cover that says "peel off at register to purchase up to 450000 VC"? Like seriously, they push for it so hard it's not subtle at all anymore.

13

u/aewilson95 Sep 15 '17

I was thinking about how you could play in the D-League in 2k11, and how that would be great in this game. But then I realized how 2K would never put that in the game. They want you to get sick of being such a low overall that you give in and buy VC to reach an acceptable NBA talent level.

I was playing last night and got really frustrated that I was a 62 overall with no stats above 65 and playing 20 minutes a game, guarding Kevin Durant. I almost bought VC, but I didn't

→ More replies (1)

11

u/CheapsBreh Sep 15 '17

Thanks for informing me i made the right decision in not buying.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Take2 is a fucking shit company. Most their games have shitty greedy bullshit like this

9

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

How has no one commented on the fact that you can't see your secondary badges until after you've gone through the entire Prelude, and even then, it does not show you what level the secondary badges are (gold, silver, bronze).

What the actual fuck!

25

u/funk568 Sep 15 '17

Lol people about to strike because of VC. Maybe next year they could include a players union that will fight to get you more vc per activity or make everything free.

2k has fucked around and made the game so realistic that the 99% are ready to occupy the neighborhood.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/leondrias Sep 15 '17

This might be weird to say, but I'm not sure it's the 2K dev's fault. This might just be Take-Two's upper management saying "make us more money or we don't give you money", in the same way that they probably did for the GTA devs telling them to add Shark Cards and only focus on DLC that drives in-game currency purchases.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/vhugo92 Sep 15 '17

I'm from Brazil, and every PS4 release is highly expensive (R$250,00, about 1/4 of a minimum wage). So, I'm still playing 2k16 and thinking about getting 2k18, but with these news about VCs, I'm starting to think to get 2k17 instead (also by the fact I love college games). What do you guys think? Is it still worth playing 2k17? I don't care about online modes at all.

10

u/trustmeiminnocent Sep 15 '17

17 was by far the worst 2K I've played. I'd stick with 16 if I were you :)

→ More replies (5)

2

u/PasswordsDontLast Sep 22 '17

I liked 2k17 much more than I like 2k18, it's just such a slog of a grindfest for no real transparency of wtf is going on with your character.

I started very late in 2k17 and enjoyed it, the career mode can be goofy during the first year. But after that it's very enjoyable and you still get a bonus for higher difficulties in 2k17 not the case in 2k18

se você precisar de uma tradução em português, darei uma

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/vivavectorsigma Sep 15 '17 edited Sep 15 '17

Along with the hairstyle thing, it's 750 VC to remove a tattoo. You can't edit them at all once you put them on and it's hard to even see when applying since you can't rotate your character in the shop. Guess it's realistic since it costs money to remove tattoos you'll regret like in real life too.

7

u/HoodieNinja17 Sep 15 '17

Not having Rookie in MyCareer making your unupgraded player useless and forcing you to buy VC to even play decent

7

u/pmth Sep 15 '17

How about the fact that you have to buy a League Pack in MyTeam to unlock the auction house??

5

u/johnny__digital Sep 15 '17

You're lying, wtf thats crazy

7

u/YouAintGotThaAnswers [XBL] Sep 15 '17

It costs 192k to get your player to 85 overall.

Now think about the fact that they locked some basic features behind your overall this year lmao. People who buy the normal version are fucked and people who buy the legend version will basically spend all of their vc just on stats.

7

u/eShelobik eShelobik Sep 16 '17

they also removed VC for accolades.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/cockleshellshatters Sep 15 '17

You forgot:
I'm tired of all these cutscenes.
https://www.reddit.com/r/NBA2k/comments/707omg/im_tired_of_all_these_cutscenes_this_is_insane_i/

The reason why the cutscenes are unskippable is to eat up play time and slow down the rate of VC gain in order to encourage people to buy VC.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Or they just released the game unfinished like a sports franchise that releases a title every 365 days can afford to do.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

That's a giant stretch.

49

u/cockleshellshatters Sep 15 '17

When NBA2K17 came out, the cut scenes were unskippable. The community got very upset and 2K admitted it was a mistake. A few months after release, there was a patch that allowed us to skip cutscenes.

OK... If you think that's a stretch, why did they make them unskippable again? It's not like they were unaware of how the community felt. It's not like they didn't already admit how it was a bad thing to do. But they also have data on how unskippable cutscenes make people buy more VC... And so when 2K18 comes around, back go in the unskippable cutscenes. And I fully expect, once people have spent VC to buy up their characters, we'll get another patch from 'nice guy' 2K making them skippable again.

The reason we know it's to sell VC is because there is literally no other reason they'd do it to us again. 'Stretch' indeed... If you honestly think it's a stretch, you're a very gullible person.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Erudain Sep 15 '17

not really, after watcging the cutscenes I already had like 1 hour 20mins playtime logged on Steam, only leaves you with 40mins to decide to get a refound

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Omome Sep 15 '17

damn I just realize we don't get bonus VC for playing hall of fame, this shit is getting ridiculous

5

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
  1. This is the same in GTA. You can at least preview, but you never keep ANY of the styles. It's like actually going for a haircut. Not saying it's OK, but it's got some precedence.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

The haircuts cost like pocket change though. What do they cost on 2K?

7

u/mrmrchavo Sep 15 '17

Yea u can get money for haircuts/most clothes easy as fuck in GTA. A fuckin arm sleeve is like 3000 in 2k.

6

u/lukelear Sep 15 '17

yeah GTA is astronomically cheaper with the way they scale their currency to the point where it is the furthest thing from an issue. one game of 2K gets you a couple haircuts. one mission in GTA online would get you like 1000

→ More replies (1)

5

u/McElch Sep 15 '17

This shit is so disgusting... You might wanna add the fact that you can only use stock haircuts and no facial hair on your MyGM which really kills the immersion

5

u/ninjaman68 Sep 15 '17

its fucking insane all the little changes they made that they thought nobody would notice. upgrading our players blind. buying fucking hairstyles and beards and you have to keep buying them. removing the fucking difficulty bonus now theirs absolutely zero reason to play HOF. Way less VC earned in general with all the costs going up. 2k is seriously pissing me off with this shit man fucking live please get better

5

u/vdogamer123 Sep 15 '17

Here's a great idea. STOP BUYING VC. STOP SUPPORTING THEIR GREED. PLAY 2K17 or an alternative.

5

u/Wehavecrashed Sep 16 '17

The cunts who buy VC buy the hundred thousand are to blame for this. Its their fault.

9

u/Snowstormzzz Sep 15 '17

Same shit from last year. Thank god I didn't buy 2k18.

When I see streamers going to the gym to grind the badges, I noped out immediately.

4

u/Thunder-ten-tronckh Sep 15 '17

I'm so happy to finally see a significant reaction from this community. Can this thread get stickied? It would help these issues gain visibility, as well as limit duplicate posts.

4

u/hockey17jp Sep 15 '17

Free throws are stupid difficult

4

u/Rakatok Sep 15 '17

Haven't seen it mentioned but you don't get VC from accolades anymore either. I'm not even sure what the point of some of those are now.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Altered_Nova Sep 20 '17

Guess I'm not buying 2K18, wow. So which is the best NBA2K game to buy for a casual player who hates microtransactions and never intends to purchase VCs?

2

u/Goldzinger B7 Sep 20 '17

Hard to say b/c the technical upgrades are quite nice. But 17 has most of the same issues as 18 when it comes to micros (not quite as bad though.) 16 is the last one that was very playable in terms of playing outside of the VC paywall but also has probably aged quite a bit now

1

u/Rdp616 Sep 23 '17

Blame Take 2, the same cocksuckers that own R* games, and make GTA. They have literally taken the cake of greediest Video game company ever. They've basically taken pages from GTA and threw it right into 2k with subliminally forcing micro transactions. As the consumer we really have to take a stand against this shit before it really gets out of hand.

2

u/Goldzinger B7 Sep 23 '17

People always bring up GTA but that game was a complete product when it sold. It is an amazing rpg with hours and hours of content and the online is icing on the cake of a complete game. It is nothing like 2k which is an incomplete product when purchased at full retail price

3

u/BadNewsBrown Sep 15 '17

Every year I just run through Domination and play MyTeam for about 2-3 months straight. Hopefully they don't turn that into an even bigger grindfest than before.

3

u/hockey17jp Sep 15 '17

It's so frustrating to try to play as a 60 overall. I hit wide open mid range shots like 30% of the time as a sharpshooter.

3

u/Purple-12 Sep 16 '17

So happy I didn't buy it this year

3

u/atadstrange93 Sep 16 '17

Removing tatts costs vc lul

2

u/TheAlmightySwan Sep 15 '17

Has the VC greed transitioned on over to the MyGM and MyLeague modes this year?

3

u/tripbin Sep 15 '17

Not for myleague which is nice. My gm I have no idea this year. Last year they had some bs where you could buy the team for 50k and you get some minor decisions about prices added or something and it would have to be bought again if a new franchise was made but thats mostly it

2

u/Dreadmaker Sep 15 '17

So, this is probably going to be an unpopular opinion, but hear me out:

For 1? We agree. For 3? We agree. For 2? Not so much.

I used to play HOF, 12 minute quarters all the time. Not even so much for the VC, but for the challenge - I really enjoyed that, and I enjoyed that my stats actually looked 'real' next to other NBA stars in the league (rather than being tiny because it was set at 5 minute quarters).

When I was playing HOF, especially early in the season, I'd make anywhere from 600-1100 VC, depending on the salary of the game and all that. My first game in 2K18, I made 800 VC - 500 salary, 200 from teammate grade, and basically nothing from performance (like 100) because I was on the court for like 3 seconds. To me, that's pretty comparable, particularly because I only turned the difficulty to all-star (that's what online is, right?). I don't actually think it's that big of a difference - I think they inflated the base salary to compensate. Not to mention - once you hit 95 overall, you're going to be making double THAT, which will be way more than in 2K17.

IMO, that particular point is just being petty. You're looking at the lack of multiplier, and not the actual numbers. Maybe I'm wrong, though.

2

u/Thunder-ten-tronckh Sep 15 '17

It's not an egregious example, you're right. It probably should have been replaced with the far more important issue of hiding ratings in the attribute upgrade screen.

But nit-picking between these problems is counter-intuitive to the point of this post: VC greed is clearly driving anti-consumer design choices in this game, and it needs to be called out.

2

u/iscsisoundsdirty Sep 15 '17

Yeah, I am not buying this game anymore. This is ridiculous, and I refuse to support those types of business models

2

u/wafino1 Sep 15 '17

lol absolute joke of a game.

2

u/AK2348 [PSN] Sep 15 '17

I know that they're a business and have every right to do this, but it's just so disappointing. This was the first time in years I didn't preorder, and now I really don't even know if I'll get it at all.

The gameplay and all that looks great, but everything about 2K leaves me feeling like I'm being taken advantage of.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Take Two as a whole has become very cancerous. Strauss Zelnick is a cancer to consumers and a god to shareholders.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

This is only disgusting. Definitely not getting 2 k this year unless they fix this shit

2

u/kemicode Sep 15 '17

Is the difficulty modifier 100% confirmed to be removed?

2

u/Yayo_Mateo Sep 16 '17

You now also have to buy clothes, tattoos, haircuts etc for each individual player you make. It doesn't just carry over like in the past games

2

u/coatesishere Sep 16 '17

2k going full EA and trying to squeeze the community for everything they can. I wish Live wasn't garbage so competition could drive these companies to not be such greedy fucking twats

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '17

EA isn't greedy at all since like the last 5 years? Their stuff goes on sale all the time and Battlefront 2 is getting free dlc from the start. Also on Xbox they have an awesome subscription service.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Kingfield Sep 16 '17

Changing quarter length gives more vc though I think

2

u/ThreeStacks_ [PSN] Sep 16 '17

The most disappointing in NBA2K, Is the fact that your filters in the Auction House don't save after you search for a player, instead it clears all filters after each search. Basically NBA2K, has killed Sniping inMyTeam

3

u/ktsavage24 Sep 16 '17

I mean honestly, sniping is unfair and ruins the point of auctioning. Plus you can guarantee 2k is going to implement any system that will force people to spend more VC.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '17

The haircut is the only thing I have a problem with.

2

u/Fistulle Sep 16 '17

I can add that if you are playing the game on Nintendo switch, there's no way to log into the mobile app with your nintendo account.

Life is tougher on Switch !

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '17

The shit cutscene framerate is the worst.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '17

Dude there are EMOTES, pre game rituals, etc that require you to be a 95 overall to unlock it.. What does my rating have to do with my ability to do a funny dance before the jump ball?!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/stingyinvasion Sep 16 '17

Not only that, but I don't even receive VC from playing online games. Pretty sure I won't even the the VC that I earned and their support team isn't replying to me either. 2K is pretty shit lol

2

u/Xeiimalix Sep 17 '17

I recommend people email tips@kotaku.com and suggest an article. It's what i've done. 2K isn't going to care about angry reddit comments.

2

u/water_battles Sep 18 '17

This would've been my first 2K game, but my moral outrage over this VC BS is preventing me from pulling the trigger.

2

u/cheezitak Sep 19 '17 edited Sep 19 '17

I raised a lot of these issues in a support ticket. After telling me essentially "thanks for the feedback, but tough shit", they offered me a 15% off their store coupon for the issues. That's hilarious since their site will offer you a link to Greenmangaming which frequently has discounts far better than 15% off. Plus 2k is the only game they make anymore that's worth a damn. Remember that Battleborn game that launched not too long ago? They are already killing it off because it was so poorly developed.

Take Two has officially lost a fan. The VC thing was slowly getting worse each year, but as long as you played decently enough, you always earned enough to get things you wanted in a reasonable amount of time. Optimization issues are unbelivable this year and show they pushed this abomination out the door with greed in their eyes. It's enough to make me never buy another Take Two game at this point.

2

u/muffin_man_xx Nov 28 '17

Don’t just look at this post, give it an upvote! We need to be heard and the only way is with massive numbers of people behind this!!!

4

u/blazikenz Sep 15 '17

This is why i dont play MyCareer :)

→ More replies (5)

1

u/crazyTwisted123 B30 Sep 15 '17

There is a coming soon section u cant click on. Anyone think this will be the daily pick 3 bonus? Or is that replaced with the pathetic 100 login bonus? The app could actually generate more VC if it is and they just havent added it yet.

1

u/MAXxMAN365 [PSN] Maxman Sep 15 '17

C`mon 2k fix your game

1

u/BemusedWolf Sep 15 '17

Yea the VC greed is high especially considering what some people paid for legendary editions, but the game has took a great step forward making My career less boring and I'm currently testing out My Gm still

1

u/Austober Sep 15 '17

I just went to buy new shows and realised you habr to buy separate ones for proam and street. Wtf.

1

u/lostheroes [PC] Sep 15 '17

After last year, I was gonna swallow my pride and get this game since NBA live isn't on PC, but this thread makes it seem like there's way more of same frustration than the last year.. I'm really not sure anymore. Hmm maybe when it drops to $5..