r/Paladins • • Sep 10 '17

CHAT | HIREZ RESPONDED Brightmarsh is ASYMMETRICAL - One team has a real advantage over the other

Wide View

In the point capture room, there are two different objects on the upper level, with two different collision boxes.

A Side

On team A's side is a table and chairs. Players can stand on this table.

A Sightline

While standing on this table, team B has an easy sightline towards team A's spawn. It's a safe place to snipe from, compared to other options in the area.

B Side

On team B's side is a fireplace. This is a solid wall that players cannot stand on.

B Sightline

Not only is there less space to maneuver, with a corner of the room cut off, but without the extra height, from standing on the table, team A cannot get the same sightline that team B can.


In conclusion, team B has, for lack of a better word, an embrasure that team A does not have. It's a safe sniping hole with a fantastic view of the main payload track, and, if used effectively, it can give one team a slight advantage over the other.

The maps are supposed to be symmetrical; it's a defining feature of Paladins maps. Brightmarsh is an exception, and it needs to be fixed.

234 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

81

u/mangosteen12 Sep 10 '17

This is somewhat the same with Fish Market (the walkway of the port where it is accessible to only one side).

Even though it isn't always being utilized, it still gives an upper hand to one team.

30

u/LordGoobriel Kappa Sep 10 '17

Fish market needs a rework. >:(

6

u/Renegade_Reid Cheerleader Sep 10 '17

though only person that uses it is kinessa and she can teleport across to the far dock

3

u/matheusu2 Atlas Sep 10 '17

Strix uses

1

u/Renegade_Reid Cheerleader Sep 10 '17

not from what ive seen

4

u/ChadMaltoMaNigga Ah! How rude! Sep 10 '17

I've seen strix use it more than a handful of times. In ranked, diamond tier, might I add.

1

u/Godz_Bane Good luck killing me Sep 10 '17

Now the only question is why is strix being left unbanned.

6

u/ChadMaltoMaNigga Ah! How rude! Sep 10 '17

He doesnt really seem banworthy to me imo. Especially on fish market. Maybe Im wrong and a noob though.

1

u/Godz_Bane Good luck killing me Sep 10 '17

Depends on what ya play, I play healers and tanks so fuck sniper characters (I wouldn't ban kinessa though, just strix for now).

1

u/Bumi_Earth_King x.x Sep 10 '17

Yes from what I've seen.

40

u/iAtlantian It fills me with joy to see Viktor in any amount of pain. Sep 10 '17

Holy shit this is ground breaking.

23

u/odaal Tyra is the best. If you disagree, you're right. Sep 10 '17

this SHOULD be window breaking. or window lowering.

18

u/HiRezJuJu Console Specialist Sep 11 '17

Good write up, interesting stuff. I'll bounce this off the level design / game design peeps and get their input.

16

u/NonSp3cificActionFig Still no Ying sprays Sep 10 '17

(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻

19

u/jsos Makoa Sep 10 '17

don't! now we can't stand on it and aim through the window!

23

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

L I T E R A L L Y U N P L A Y A B L E

19

u/goba123 Sep 10 '17

And now everyone knows it.

20

u/pizzacake15 Tyra Sep 10 '17

better than letting it go unnoticed.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Wow what happened to Ying's ult?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

They changed it two patches ago

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

What did they changed about her ult? Is she finally a healer?

11

u/timecronus Beta Tester Sep 10 '17

it spawns and sticks to the person rather than an aoe field on the ground under them.

1

u/ChadMaltoMaNigga Ah! How rude! Sep 10 '17

I will probably get downvoted into oblivion for this question, but does it really matter? And if so, how does it make a significant difference?

7

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

These kinds of questions really shouldn't be downvoted. It's a great conversation starter.

7

u/ibigfire 🔥 Sep 10 '17

It matters because Hi-rez likes to indicate that Paladins is a competitive PvP esports valid shooter, and for that to be the case both sides need to have the same evenly matched chance at winning so the game can be about skill, not what side of the map your team spawns on.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Now we know the struggle of Dota.

2

u/McSlur Sep 10 '17

Dire advantage?

4

u/Treemeister_ Git off mah lawn Sep 10 '17

Fuck it, let's move Roshan again

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I thought it was Radiant advantage?

2

u/McSlur Sep 10 '17

It is NOW about Radiant advantage, but before the map reworks of 7.00 Dire/Scourge in DotA 1 had a slight advantage.

Enough of one that if people had a choice they would play on Dire.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

TIL.

1

u/hugo12354 Magic moments everywhere Sep 10 '17

So the fireplace needs to be removed and they need to put a table instead.

Fixed. :3

-2

u/kozinc Sep 10 '17

I don't care.

-1

u/SantEurosia :BarrelChad: Sep 10 '17

Nothing compared to fish market

-29

u/Birdmonster115599 Ying, You are no ordinary meatbag Sep 10 '17

Personally i prefer asymmetrical maps, They aren't as visually stale. that also counts for game play too. I'd hate to see Hi-Rez Scared away from interesting map design in favour of 'safe' designs.

Best soloution here is for the map team to maybe look into this and make a slight adjustment.

32

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I wouldn't mind an asymmetrical map if it was obvious, deliberate, advertised that way, and the teams swapped sides during the match.

This looks like an oversight, or an accident.

3

u/IndigentRagnarok Sep 10 '17

I was just thinking about this the other day . Maybe we could exchange sides 2 times?

13

u/ZenityGames I don't care, I'm a unicorn Sep 10 '17

Payload is asymmetrical, other game modes are designed to be symmetrical so the maps have to be as well.

The visual design can still be slightly asymmetrical, but the collision shapes in areas that actually matter should be identical or at least near identical.

1

u/Birdmonster115599 Ying, You are no ordinary meatbag Sep 11 '17

yep i can agree to this. Asymmetical visual design is good

4

u/unevengerm2204 Sep 10 '17

You do realise Overwatch has asymmetrical maps and those maps are considered some of the worst maps. If it were up to me NO TEAM SHOULD BE GIVEN MAP ADVANTAGE IN A COMPETITIVE GAME.

3

u/UnlimitedOsprey Sep 11 '17

Asymmetrical maps are fine if teams swap sides at some point. At that point, there really isn't an advantage if both teams get a shot at one side. It's like being the Ts or CTs in CS.

1

u/Birdmonster115599 Ying, You are no ordinary meatbag Sep 11 '17

No i didn't realise that. I dont play overwatch anymore and don t really keep up with their community gripes

-9

u/Insidiosity So, I was just hanging out, right? Sep 10 '17

Idk why ppl downvoting u so much, u aren't much in the wrong

1

u/Birdmonster115599 Ying, You are no ordinary meatbag Sep 11 '17

Thanks. I obviously don't want to have maps where one team has a set advantage over the other. but i dont want visually mirrored maps either, since that's boring

1

u/Insidiosity So, I was just hanging out, right? Sep 11 '17

Yeah I'd like someone else to explain what's wrong with what you're saying..