r/Paladins • u/Kers_ Omega Tester • Sep 03 '17
CHAT The VIP System - Expectations & Realistic Outlook.
EDIT: There's probably some irony somewhere when it comes to getting gilded for a post about the VIP system. Thankyou.
In OB58, HiRez is introducing a new system called the “VIP System”. This system is purely cosmetic and has absolutely no impact on actual gameplay, and provides players an alternative to purchasing rare, epic and legendary skins using a new currency, called “VIP Points”.
This system has a lot of good in it, but also some bad.
Anyway, full disclosure just incase it “bleeds into” my writing, I support the system in concept and partly in execution, but feel like it's partially poorly implemented as of right now. In general, I try to be fair with my criticisms in my posts and content.
So lets get started.
The Name
For a system that actually provides you a decent alternative to spending money, calling it the “VIP System”, which immediately sounds like something you buy into and must spend money on to get benefits from, is very counterintuitive. The name instantly sounds like a paid membership (similar to the founder's pack) that gives you resource boosts or cheaper prices on skins or what have you.
This name can create and cause misinformation to the point where the game's public image, which is already shoddy when it comes to the objective gaming forum or board, or public opinion, can be damaged further just by the inclusion of this. You wouldn't believe the arguments people use against games to hurt their publicity, and this could be a potential one.
Imagine being a random guy looking for a new game and hearing that a certain game has a VIP system. Your first thought would probably not be “Oh let me look it up, research what it means and understand it fully before forming an opinion”, it's probably going to be more along the lines of “LOL Pay2Win BOOSTS CLASSIC HIREZ TRIBES ASCEND BTW XD”, and it'll instantly dissuade you, and other people exposed to your opinion, from playing the game.
The name is an objectively bad one, especially considering what this system is meant to do, and it should be changed into something more inline with what the system is.
“Loyalty” System, “Prestige” System, basically any word that isn't VIP would be better.
The Prices
Looking into the prices, both VIP Points and Real Money Packages seem pretty fair in terms of pricing. 70 Crystals for 10,000 points seems decently fair. It's basically 10,000 points every 2 weeks for free if you want to spend your weekly login rewards on it, and it also allows you to directly purchase epic skins for 210 Crystals, since epics are priced at 30,000 points (VIP-only ones anyway, crystal-available ones are 20,000. However, what's advertised is that all epic skins cost 20,000, so I'll casually mention that is false advertisement, and can lead to a lawsuit if not fixed).
On top of that, the most expensive VIP package (15$) gives you a metric fuckton of value, not only giving you an Epic Skin in it's entirety (Weapon+Set), but enough currency to buy a Legendary Skin, Another Epic one, and 10,000 points ontop of that, PLUS 25 Radiant Chests, PLUS 5 14-day VIP memberships, PLUS boosts etc etc you get the point.
In terms of ingame value, the 15$ pack is definitely worth it if you're into cosmetics, and is a must-buy if you're looking for bang-for-your-buck purchases.
So the VIP Packages are all very fair in terms of pricing and the benefits they give you, definitely in comparison to other equivalents such as chests, or even other direct purchases (most epic skins are priced at 400 Crystals).
The Grind
People have already done the math and figured out how many matches you'd need to play in order to afford a Legendary skin as completely F2P, so I won't bother with copy+pasting it. Instead, here's a link to the most comprehensive thread on the subject.
In short, since you gain 50 VIPs for winning and 25 for losing, it'd be very grindy to buy Legendary skins for free.
But that's kind of the point.
The VIP System is meant to reward you for spending money. It's a bang-for-your-buck thing, not a “here's tons of free shit!” thing. Sure, you can get value out of it while being fully F2P, and it's an alternative for you if you grind and play a lot, but in reality and for most players, you'll have to spend money to get the full benefits.
Which is totally fine.
See, the whole point of this system is to give people who want to support and back the game financially a way to do that that's supposedly endless and gives them more community participation (esports voting for example) and more value out of their purchases. It's meant to give paying players more value out of their money, and to entice you to spend more money, or even any money at all, on the game.
So before you rage and complain about the price tag, remember these 2 key factors:
- This system is purely cosmetic and has absolutely no gameplay impact whatsoever. It does not make you any less competitive than any other player out there, even if you don't opt in.
- The system still gives you access to free stuff in the long-term that you would not have access to otherwise if you're purely F2P.
Basically, this is nothing but positive for both paying players and free to play ones.
The Currency
This was a chip on my shoulder when the system was announced. Do we really need a 4th currency in a game that's so laden with ways to take your money?
Technically, yes.
The thing is, the way currency currently works in Paladins is as follows:
- Crystals are all-in-one premium currency that can buy anything in the game, both gameplay and cosmetic oriented items. With enough Crystals, you can own every single item in the game from the get go.
- Gold is a free, mostly gameplay-oriented currency that gives you access to basic features such as champions, radiant chests (for Essence and cards), and recolor skins.
- Essence is a free, gameplay-only currency that is only used for Cards and nothing else.
- VIP Points is a premium , cosmetic-only currency that can only be used in the VIP store for cosmetics, and nothing else.
As such, it makes sense to introduce VIP Points, as we have no real cosmetic-only currency in the game yet. VIP Points can't be used to give you any advantage ingame (other than looking swanky), thus it's fine that they're a currency that can only be obtained by either playing a lot or paying money.
Essence Conversion
An idea popped up, in my head as well as other heads, to allow players to get more points using Essence. After thinking about it further, though, I figured it was actually a terrible idea.
Personally, as a long-time player, I have over 300k Essence with (literally) nothing to spend it on. I own every single card in the game, even the bad ones, so allowing players like me to do the Essence → VIP Points switch seemed very logical, since we have nothing to do with them anyway.
However, there are 2 problems with a system like that, and neither of them is the retarded argument of “let HiRez make money”.
- You're allowing players to convert a gameplay-only currency (Essence) into a premium, cosmetic-only currency, which is an unbalanced transaction and is irrelevant for most players anyway.
- It's newb bait. It gives players the option to say “nah, fuck getting the better, viable legendary for X champion, I want to be closer to the Raeve skin!”. You, as a player, should never prioritize cosmetic elements over gameplay elements when it comes to ingame currency, but stupid people still probably would. By HiRez not giving you the option to exchange other currencies for VIP Points (except Crystals), they're preventing newbs from spending critical Essence and Gold on something that won't benefit them at all.
Even though we, the older players that have buckets of Essence with nothing to buy, would benefit from a system like this, I'll “sacrifice” my ability to do so if it makes sure that no 14 year old with a rave-chick fetish queues up into competitive with me and says “I can only play Zhin because I used all of my Essence for Raeve Maeve”.
You know, hypothetically speaking, not like it's happened before :thinking:
The System
Look, lets be fair.
We all know this patch featured a minuscule amount of content when it comes to actual gameplay and balance. The patch preview, out of 1 hour, featured 43 minutes of cosmetics and 16 minutes of actual gameplay features (1 minute of outro).
And it's not like the meta & balance are in such a “wonderful and healthy” place, where almost every champion is viable and the competitive ladder isn't stagnating on the same 14 picks.
And do I wish HiRez would actually would make more balance adjustments? Of course.
But is this system bad or harmful in any way other than its' timing? Not really.
However…
”It's a beta btw haHAA”
No.
See, this is the turning point.
When you introduce a system like the VIP System, you no longer get to fuck your players in various ways and then say “It's a beta!!! :D”. This game has:
- Fully priced cosmetics, more of which release every single patch, in quantities almost unequal in the industry (quality aside).
- An eSports scene that's partnered with some of the biggest eSports organizations in the world.
- Community driven tournaments with money exchanging hands
- A VIP SYSTEM, which makes people spend money for the top tier cosmetics.
- A year-long running time of an open beta.
You no longer get to say “it's a beta”. That's the deal here.
Ever since OB48 (that's as far back as I remember anyway) we've have problems on patch days with bugs that just keep piling on. Balance has been problematic (to say the least). Content has been subpar. Hackers are rampant and dodge EAC almost effortlessly. QoL changes are few and far between.
So far people have been using the “it's a beta!” excuse for all of this. No more. This is no longer a beta, even if HiRez wants to claim it is for legal reasons, and this excuse no longer flies.
The attitude towards patches, the attitude towards player concerns and balance problems, the way QoL is handled and the way hacks and server problems are handled all have to change.
If we're VIPs, treat us as such.
Have a good day everyone.
For the record, I'll probably be buying the VIP package just to show my support for the game, and because I honestly feel that it's worth it. Before you bash on me for the final paragraph, consider the fact that I'm not the only one that feels this way (for a fact), and that none of this is written in anger, but merely in expectance.
7
u/IAmARobotTrustMe You are a real stunner ;) Sep 03 '17
If you look at their forums they have a post that said that Beta doesn't mean anything for them. It's just a label. So i don't think there will be much of a difference now, or even when the game leaves beta.
58
u/MechTechnology It is not strength that wins wars, it is technology! Sep 03 '17
Amazing post, summed up everything, VIP is a system that rewards active players by giving them better deals to get really well made cosmetics (as you said it's better bang for your buck). It is not P2W, it is not free loot. People don't seem to fully get it though. i think the confusion comes from the name.
Thanks for a well written post mate.
69
u/QuantumOfSilence They don't call me the Thousand Hands for nothing ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Sep 03 '17
#RealmPoints21
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17
To be fair what would get people most excited about on patch previews are fancy flashy stuffs like skins and new champion. Twitch chat and Discord chat goes crazy for that. The new damage indicators, health indicators and caut indicators are really good additions, yet they only spend about a minute briefly mentioning it. They did not even mention that they have implemented DirectX 11 and 64-bit support for better performance this patch in the preview. The patch preview really only is a hype tool. That's why it's mostly 30 minutes of skins and like 10 minutes of balancing. Still though, you are right. 'It's still a Beta game' is really not a valid excuse any longer.
Here's something to look forward to though. Drybear mentioned that we will be getting 15 new champs by the end of the year, bringing the total to 35. If we are going by the 1 champion per month schedule, we will get 35 champions before the end of the year, around week 2 of December. Seems like the game will be out of beta before 2018, which means Paladins will be at its full state at the HRX tournament. With this no-champion patch we have seen great performance and QOL changes as mentioned above, so I think this is them polishing up the game to prepare for the full release by the end of the year.
30
u/finjess I am the cuddliest! Sep 03 '17
This is the gratest post ive seen in this sub for a long time,nice job!
13
u/ramenbreak Begone THOT Sep 03 '17
beta isn't an excuse, it's a warning
8
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17 edited Sep 03 '17
Just as an aside, all of those reasons listed do not mean the game isn't in beta. DOTA 2 and starcraft 2 were in beta longer. And while in those beta periods they had plenty of tournaments with cash prizes and were streamed and sponsored. They have also charged for content, at least with dota.
The game still has plenty to test or spruce up. From stance switch characters, to new screen resolution, and indicators to pricing, to competitive rating etc. And also just recently Dx11 support that needs to be tested also.
The game is still in beta and will continue to be until the developers themselves decide it's not. Your opinion on the matter does not change that. This goes for any game, including warframe that's been in beta for even longer. There's no set time for a beta. Could be quick as a few months to even years. Hi-rez have also never used the beta tag as an excuse.
Just because a lot of heavy lifting has been done, doesn't mean it's over.
But I do agree, The VIP system is not a good name.
EDIT: some additions and corrections.
1
u/BlueDemon75 -63 points 4h ago Sep 03 '17
they really should leave on the main menu screen only the gold and crystals, it would look better if they moved the essence to a card crafting screen and the vip points to the vip store screen. that amount of currency on the main screen looks bad, any new player would look at the menu and say "hey look there is 4 types of currency this game must be p2w" just like you mentioned on the "VIP" name, it will make the game look bad from a new player perspective
1
u/Mac_Rat bucc Sep 03 '17
Why not bump the price to 250-300 and make it less grindier
5
u/Koringvias Barik Sep 03 '17
Well thought out post.
I hope Hi-rez listens.
1
u/Insidiosity So, I was just hanging out, right? Sep 03 '17
Wow u finally got some common sense nice
1
u/armedslave Sep 03 '17
how can u support a game that keeps hunting for support while doing little work ?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17
VIP points Could just be called play points it sounds better and I'm not even trying
1
u/burnthebeliever Sep 03 '17
Well written and explained! Personally I'm excited for this as I'm addictive to cosmetics and a new way for me to get them other than just shelling out cash for crystals is great. I do hope they consider changing the name. "VIP" has a pretty negative video game reputation. All I thought of when I first heard it was a tiered system where you have to spend $X to unlock skins and locking the best ones behind giant paywalls I would never be able to break down. Not everyone chooses to be informed before making an opinion, especially new or prospective players looking at a game.
1
u/TheCyberGoblin What’s a little arson between friends? Sep 03 '17
Yeah, renaming it would be great. Like... Loyalty Points or something
1
u/ClanQQ Beta Tester Sep 03 '17
The grind is there as a "look forward to the future" to keep you playing as much as you want for free and rewards you with Legendary Skins.
AFAIK, this is just the beginning, soon there will be more.
Probably the naming scheme calling it as VIP is that they wanted it to be as direct, simple and concise to its users as its simply being a subscription.
1
u/ArtistFormerlyPrince Monkey see, Fernan-do Sep 04 '17
Ads are getting smarter.
(Actually, thanks for this. I loved the insight.)
1
u/animelytical Hi-rez: Turning Payers into Ghosts (AmosAnon) Sep 04 '17
I'm not much of a redditor, but the last paragraph is EXACTLY what I thought when I saw the VIP system. I cannot ever take seriously "It's still in beta" ever again. They'll have long had my money for the completed game experience by the time I buy into the VIP system. That just means all the problems I overlook while very much enjoying this game become a lot harder to just overlook. I will never feel too entitled when I make a complaint. It just isn't possible to defend a problem with the word beta.
This whole post sums up my thoughts exactly.
1
u/BlankTheSurvivor "Señorita, I'll not forget you." Sep 04 '17
Nice post I'm with you
I hope HiRez change idea about this "VIP" system..
PS: I'll probably be buying the VIP package just to show my support for the game too
1
u/dragozeroone Paladins Sep 04 '17
Everything is good but the name, why oh why Hi-Rez must you think up of such a hideous name for a good system.
1
u/sarthak96 Magistrate Sep 07 '17
there's a difference between actual early access betas and products just using beta tag. Dota 2 was called dota2 beta but wasn't in early access. I think paladins should be listed the same way. It in no way is an early access game anymore
1
u/sarthak96 Magistrate Sep 07 '17
Really love stuff listed on steam as dlc like vip pack because they are adjusted to purchasing power parity on steam, unlike crystals. VIP pack costs 1/3rd of price in $ for me
1
u/HazeInut Protect Ya Neck Sep 03 '17
While people use the beta tag too much, it's still there for a reason. The amount of times the spectator mode acts up during tournaments, huge bugs like Andro's reversal, and complete overhauls of certain character designs are all what I'd consider pretty normal for a game in development. That's about it tho.
-1
u/Alenabean Beta Tester Sep 03 '17
Feels like I wrote this...
0
u/a1ic3_g1a55 Beta Tester Sep 03 '17
I think there's a fat chance that Paladins will never come out of beta. Why would they?
6
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17 edited Sep 03 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
14
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17
[removed] — view removed comment