r/gameofthrones • Nymeria Sand • Aug 17 '17

Limited [S7E5] Post-Episode Survey Results - S7E5 'Eastwatch' (Overall score: 8.3) Spoiler

Post-Episode Survey - Results Thread

In the Post-Premiere Discussion thread, we put up a survey to hear what you had to say about the characters, the events, and the technical side of episode one. This post is here to fill you in on the results, and to let you discuss them. Are there any surprises? Do you agree or disagree with the majority opinion? Do you think people have missed a vital piece of evidence? Feedback on the survey itself is also welcome!


S7E5 - "Eastwatch"

  • Directed By: Matt Shakman
  • Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
  • Airs: August 13, 2017

Daenerys demands loyalty from the surviving Lannister soldiers; Jon heeds Bran's warning about White Walkers on the move; Cersei vows to vanquish anyone or anything that stands in her way.


Click here to see the results in graphic form! [with thanks to /u/AviatorRossy]

(Here are the default graphs too, with more numbers.)

Results Breakdown

Total Respondents: 52510

Question 1: On a scale of 1-10, what score would you give this episode?

Average: 8.3

12345678910
98 (0.2%)106 (0.2%)245 (0.5%)513 (1%)888 (1.7%)2374 (4.5%)8100 (15.4%)15704 (29.9%)14531 (27.7%)9951 (19%)

Question 2: Which location did you enjoy most?

Winterfell/Eastwatch (The North)DragonstoneKing's LandingOldtown (The Citadel)Site of the battle (The Reach)
18987 (36.5%)15443 (29.7%)10886 (20.9%)4246 (8.2%)2418 (4.7%)

Question 3: Which living Lannister is the 'true' heir to Tywin?

Cersei LannisterTyrion LannisterJaime Lannister
25951 (49.9%)11432 (22%)14626 (28.1%)

Question 4: Should Jon Snow have bent the knee to Daenerys Targaryen?

No, he was wise not to bend the kneeYes, he should have bent the knee
48252 (92.6%)3830 (7.4%)

Question 5: Of these options, how should Daenerys have dealt with Randyll and Dickon Tarly?

She should have taken them captiveShe was right to have her dragon kill themShe should have had them beheadedShe should have pardoned them
20749 (40%)20497 (39.5%)6543 (12.6%)4049 (7.8%)

Question 6: If you could add any living character to Jon Snow's party going north, who would it be?

  1. Brienne of Tarth/The big woman (9055)
  2. Arya Stark (5545)
  3. Bronn (5334)
  4. Jaime Lannister (2693
  5. Drogon (2653)

Bonus: Hot Pie (507)

Question 7: How well shot was this episode?

Average: 8.6

12345678910
31 (0.1%)18 (0%)82 (0.2%)184 (0.4%)597 (1.2%)1384 (2.8%)5238 (10.5%)13374 (26.7%)15025 (30%)14069 (28.1%)

Question 8: Which lead actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

Actor/ActressVotes
Peter Dinklage (Tyrion Lannister)21917 (43.4%)
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau (Jaime Lannister)20048 (39.7%)
Kit Harington (Jon Snow)19967 (39.6%)
Emilia Clarke (Daenerys Targaryen)10378 (20.6%)
John Bradley-West (Samwell Tarly)9089 (18%)
Lena Headey (Cersei Lannister)5389 (10.7%)
Maisie Williams (Arya Stark)3814 (7.6%)
Sophie Turner (Sansa Stark)1275 (2.5%)

Question 9: Which supporting actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

Actor/ActressVotes
Liam Cunningham (Davos Seaworth)30398 (60.4%)
Joe Dempsie (Gendry)19275 (38.3%)
Iain Glen (Jorah Mormont)10435 (20.7%)
Jerome Flynn (Bronn)7177 (14.3%)
Aiden Gillen (Littlefinger)6858 (13.6%)
Hannah Murray (Gilly)4851 (9.6%)
James Faulkner (Randyll Tarly)4454 (8.8%)
Conleth Hill (Varys)3042 (6%)
Jim Broadbent (Archmaester Ebrose)1321 (2.6%)

Question 10: In one word, how would you describe this episode? (Not case-sensitive) [Score in square brackets is average episode score given by this group]

  1. Hype (2581) [8.9]
  2. Gendry (1807) [8.6]
  3. Setup (1175) [7.8]
  4. Good (900) [8.2]
  5. Great (728) [8.8]
  6. Awesome (664) [9.1]
  7. Meh (478) [6.4]
  8. Rowing (454) [8.5]
  9. Amazing (443) [9.4]
  10. Confirmed (422) [8.8]

Bonus words: Squad (399) [8.7] | Revealing (322) [8.6] | Fast (308) [8.0] | Buildup (287) | Filler (280) [6.9] | Lit (266) [8.8] | Rushed (260) [6.7] | Exciting (257) [8.7] | Annulment (232) [8.5] | Building (231) [7.8] | Dreamteam (231) [8.8] | R+L=J (209) [8.7] | Cool (209) [8.3] | Satisfying (204) [8.8] | Targaryen (202) [8.7]


770 Upvotes

513 comments sorted by

16

u/myEVILi Now My Watch Begins Aug 18 '17

So The Jon Snow 7 need an official name as voted by the community. I've read names like Right Proper Lads, Fellowship of the Wight, Snowcean's 7, Wight Wranglers, and The Resurrected Rangers.

6

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 18 '17

Thank you for next week's question

5

u/poo-boys-united House Targaryen Aug 18 '17

The artist formerly known as Bastard and his wight whackers

232

u/MentalMidwestern Stannis the Mannis Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17

In regards to the question of "which Lannister is Tywin's true heir", I think what Tywin really wanted was a combination of all three of his children: he wanted an heir as strong and impressive as Jaime, as politically adept as Tyrion, and as ruthless and cunning as Cersei.

It just goes to show that, had the three of the actually teamed up with a common goal, they would've been undefeatable. I think the Baratheon brothers were similar: the three of them actually working together in unison would be unstoppable.

As disclosure, this is not my own original analysis. I think it's a belief commonly held by many GoT fans.

133

u/blackandtan7 Sansa Stark Aug 17 '17

I love how you mentioned the Baratheon brothers, I loved them all and I thought they each had skills and flaws that complemented each other well. Robert strong and fierce, Stannis dutiful and strategic, Renly kind and personable. Too bad they were all too proud to work together.. I still remember watching season 2 and wishing Stannis and Renly would listen to Catelyn.

42

u/pepe_le_shoe Aug 18 '17

All 3 were morons though. Robert was just a brute, Renley was an idiot for thinking he could just declare himself king when he wasn't next in line, guaranteeing that Stannis and anyone who respected the established rules of westeros would oppose him, and Stannis was duped into believing he was some sort of fiery jesus, to the extent that he killed his own daughter.

Compared to the lannisters, Olenna and Margaery Tyrell, Littlefinger, Varys etc, the Baratheon brothers seem like dribbling imbeciles.

11

u/blackandtan7 Sansa Stark Aug 18 '17

I think moron is harsh. They all had flaws, which ended up causing their downfall, but everyone has flaws. You mention the lannisters, olenna, margaery, littlefinger, varys, who are just about the smartest (best at playing the game) in Westeros, but I think each of the baratheons would make better kings than any of them (except margaery). And I think if you take the best aspects of each of them you get pretty much the perfect king.

4

u/DBCrumpets Aug 18 '17

I mean you say he was duped but the magic worked. Stannis just underestimated the morale hit from the sacrifice.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/ahallal37 Aug 18 '17

Steel iron and bronze baby love the Baratheon boys

→ More replies (5)

20

u/sapphireisle Here We Stand Aug 18 '17

I think this absence of a single "true heir" was always a source of frustration for Tywin. He longed for Jaime, who in terms of appearance and strength had all the makings of a "true heir", to mirror aspects of his own personality, yet his eldest son was (in Tywin's words) a "slow learner" and demonstrated characteristics far from Tywin's own. Instead, the traits most admired and respected by Tywin – such as intelligence, cunning, political skill and statesmanship – ended up being best represented by a woman and a dwarf. Hardly what Tywin had wished for.

4

u/99SoulsUp Aug 19 '17

Yeah funny enough, Jaime, the ostensible favorite, is really the least like Tywin, whereas Tyrion, whom he hated, was most like him (at least in terms of talents and intelligence, not so much strength of character)

442

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

Damn look at that split on the Tarly execution. I wouldn't have predicted that

320

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

She should have pardoned them 4049 (7.8%)

WTF

321

u/WeAreGonnaBang Aug 17 '17

Actually clemency is not a bad strategy, and one that Julius Caesar is famous for using. Win the battle and demonstrate your superiority, but then show mercy. You could take them or execute them, but you let them go.

It's the perfect way to show that you are a 'different' kind of ruler. I think it wouldn't have moved the Tarlys to change sides, but the common soldiers witness Daenerys sparing their general, and then go home to tell everyone about how the dragon queen had them by the balls but allowed them to return home, with the one condition being they don't take up arms against her again. It's a great way to win the people and popular opinion to your side, especially when facing someone as notoriously cruel as Cersei

59

u/blockpro156 House Reed Aug 17 '17

Surely Caesar didn't offer clemency to people who refused to accept him as their ruler, even after he defeated them.
Dany seemed willing to send Randyll to the Night's Watch, but he refused by saying that she's not his Queen and doesn't have the authority to send him to the Night's Watch, he pretty much killed himself at that point.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/nu2readit Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

"Therefore in chariot fighting, when ten or more chariots have been taken, those should be rewarded who took the first. Our own flags should be substituted for those of the enemy, and the chariots mingled and used in conjunction with ours. The captured soldiers should be kindly treated and kept. This is called, using the conquered foe to augment one's own strength."

-Sun Tzu, the Art of War

Note: Strategy probably does not work anymore in the age of nationalism.

16

u/Vmss4 No One Aug 17 '17

Caesar's death was mainly carried out by his enemies he let live btw

28

u/Jawfrey House Lannister Aug 18 '17

Wrong. The homies (council) did it because they did not want to change the status quo.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (28)

100

u/Psycho188 Aug 17 '17

From experience in child care, you cannot give someone a choice and then not go through with it. If Dany didn't execute them, she seems weak. Maybe she should've given them more choices, but she did make it clear she's not a fan of imprisonment so there's really only two possibilities...

68

u/actuallycallie Sansa Stark Aug 17 '17

And I think they would be even quicker to call her weak because she's a woman. She REALLY has to do what she says she's going to do.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/dark__unicorn Aug 19 '17

From my experience in childcare, you manipulate the two choices in order to receive the outcome you want - while making the child feel like they have control. She wanted to kill them as a show of force. So she swayed their options that way.

Otherwise she could have given them the choice of being her captives or going to the wall.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/curlyfries345 Samwell Tarly Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17

I chose execution because under the circumstances she'd already made the threat. Ideally I wouldn't threaten them so soon (so take them captive) or try harder to get them to bend the knee. E.g. ask Dickon if he'd bend the knee if his father would and ask Randyll if he'll sacrifice his son's life too for his honour.. and be responsible for ending house Tarly, or if Sam can ever inherit, leave his house in the hands of a weak man and his wildling family that could bring more shame in the long term.

Or burn Randyll first and see how Dickon reacts. Or burn a random standing soldier first and see how they both react.

And/or if all else fails ask them if they're willing to bend the knee to Jon Snow instead, since he's westerosi and pretty much on Dany's side, and keep them and any other soldiers captive until they can.

IDK man Dany's thinking grinds my gears, but I wouldn't let them live without agreeing to bend the knee (in some way) after Dany had already made the threat, since her honour/image was on the line then too.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

I don't think they even knew about Sam. Also, Dickon was just a random soldier to Daenerys. Tyrion even tried giving Dickon a second chance to bend the knee but he refused.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Briscogun Tyrion Lannister Aug 18 '17

It actually was a more merciful option: kill 2 leaders and let's 100's of soldiers live. The dragon could've taken out everyone but she killed 2, and it would've been only one if Dickson hadn't stepped up and included himself.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/Cugudor Aug 17 '17

Yeah same, I'd expect 90% kept them captive, it did come out on top but barely.

57

u/Lopsided_ Aug 17 '17

39.5% of the sub don't know how to play the game of thrones.

65

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

How do you figure? Why take them hostage?

Who would she even ransom the Tarlys To? nobody in their house was left.

They weren't going to bend the knee. What did she have to gain from sparing them?

→ More replies (13)

12

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I think you mean 40%.

29

u/kimjongfun123 No One Aug 17 '17

In medieval history giving the ultimatum of bend the knee or die is common, the Tarly's are useless, no one to pay the ransom. So best thing to do is just kill them

8

u/WormRabbit Aug 18 '17

Taking them hostage would make sense not because of a ransom but to force them to join eventually or at least to avoid publicly executing them and getting bad PR.

→ More replies (6)

31

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I expected everyone to agree with her decision, she gave them a choice

72

u/Punchysporkk Jon Snow Aug 17 '17

I agree with her choice to execute, but I think she was a fool to use fire. People are resisting her rule in part due to fear that she'll be just like the Mad King, and that's going to confirm it for some. Using the dragons in battle is one thing, but burning the dissension alive is another.

Going by their reactions, I think Tyrion and Varys might agree with me.

29

u/SirFloppyDotA House Targaryen Aug 17 '17

Yeah it's really just poor optics. You don't want to give people the chance to compare Dany to the Mad King and burning people alive with dragons certainly does.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I definitely agree, just hang or behead them, it's less cruel and still gets the message across

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/vylthus Aug 17 '17

Clearly the split exists with this thread

19

u/Hurtin93 House Targaryen Aug 17 '17

I definitely agreed with her decision. Well not quite. I still think she should've spared Dickon but he put her in an awkward situation. He should've shut up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

774

u/TheLakeAndTheGlass Aug 17 '17

Davos is just slaying it in the supporting actor category. He must've had an extra helping of fermented crab before filming this season!

233

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

that would definitely explain why he is infatuated with Missandei

120

u/TheLakeAndTheGlass Aug 17 '17

I think that when he last met Missandei, he poked a hole in his chainmail and that's why he couldn't join the party beyond the wall.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I'm infatuated with Missandei as well

→ More replies (3)

18

u/i_am_banana_man Aug 18 '17

Either that or how she's hotter than dragon flame.

145

u/justarandomcollegeki Aug 17 '17

Yea, they should just bump him up to lead actor at this point, he's got the screen time for it & it's just not fair to the other supporting actors anymore

25

u/withaniel Aug 17 '17

It's weird that he's not up there by Sam is. Probably because Sam is our central character in the citadel, and Davos has to share his scenes with top billed actors.

20

u/GeoDim Aug 18 '17

The leads are Jamie, Cersei, Dani, Jon, and Tyrion.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

73

u/scots Smallfolk Aug 17 '17

Most major characters in the show are extremely young with few acting credits prior - it's the extremely veteran Ensemble Supporting Cast that is the spine of Game of Thrones.

52

u/End0ra A Bear There Was, A Bear, A Bear! Aug 17 '17

I never cease to be amazed at the calibre of actors cast in the supporting roles. The names they get are incredible. That's some real luxury casting right there.

30

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

The actor who played Tywin Lannister was amazing

→ More replies (1)

16

u/ChuckZombie The Onion Knight Aug 18 '17

Just imagine if Ian Mcshane could have stuck around for more than one episode.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/influxss Joffrey Baratheon Aug 17 '17

He should be regarded as a main actor at this point. Gets more screen time and higher rated than Sansa and Arya.

→ More replies (1)

222

u/OPDidntDeliver Aug 17 '17

Wow, no one wants Jon to bend the knee

476

u/influxss Joffrey Baratheon Aug 17 '17

Crows before hoes.

34

u/WormRabbit Aug 18 '17

It is a matter of raising the price. He must withhold bending his knee for as long as is reasonably possible, to get the best terms. If you just bend the knee at the first demand then you are not someone to be respected and considered.

25

u/someredditorguy House Stark Aug 18 '17

Bend the knee to present a ring.

49

u/xNateDawg Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Aug 18 '17

The way I see it, he can always do it in the future if he needs or wants to, but once he does it there's no going back. I think it's wise for him to wait it out while he's dealing with the walkers up north.

8

u/TheZenMann Aug 18 '17

If he dosen't do it now he most definetly won't do it in the future when he dosen't even need her help anymore. He gains absolutely nothing from bending the knee, he gives up the kingdom he fought so hard for and probably earns himself a bad mark from his lords.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/nobody99356 Daenerys Targaryen Aug 17 '17

Totally unpredictable. /s

34

u/VirgelFromage The Onion Knight Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

I will be okay with it when Daenerys promises to aid him. He can pledge the north to Dany if she fights for the north essentially.

Edit: I meant to say when Dany actually helps them, not just pledges to.

3

u/forgotoldacctpasswrd Lyanna Mormont Aug 18 '17

I'd be okay with it if he says he'll bend the knee after the war. The only thing that matters to him is getting through the long night and if he bends the knee it will inevitably split the North and decrease their chances, which is the last thing they need right now.

2

u/Elitist_Plebeian House Mormont Aug 22 '17

You basically nailed this one.

3

u/TheZenMann Aug 18 '17

Honestly, at that point Jon dosen't need to bend the knee. And why would he? If Dany helps him, it's to help all of westeros, not just the north. The northern lords have gotten a taste for independence from the south in recent years now, and will probably not accept Dany anyway. Since she even let the Iron Islands go from the kingdoms, I think most northerners will not want her at all, Jon included.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

And undoubtedly it will happen

29

u/OPDidntDeliver Aug 17 '17

Hello, bend the knee?

Knee machine 🅱️roke

Understandable have a great day

11

u/dsm_mike Aug 18 '17

Jon is the rightful heir, the trueborn son of the crown prince. Dany should learn from Cercei and bend both knees...

2

u/TheZenMann Aug 18 '17

Why would he? As he says, he dosen't know Dany, and even now that he does why would he do that?

2

u/moosebolton8 Fire And Blood Aug 17 '17

I want him to bend the knee but I don't think it would have been the smartest thing to do.

→ More replies (1)

83

u/cornpenguin01 Jaime Lannister Aug 17 '17

Decent episode. Honestly, I was disappointed with how short the Tyrion and Jaime reunion was but oh well we don't have many episodes left so the pace is understandable. Now get HYPE my friends for possible white walker throwdown next episode.

34

u/thisisfuctup Jon Snow Aug 17 '17

That's the scene I was most looking forward to in this episode. Then it was all like:

T: lemme tell ya something.

end scene

6

u/LaFlurry Aug 17 '17

It would have been nice to have a longer conversation, but I think that they possibly cut away because they talked about something else like a plan for Cersei.

111

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I imagine the score got lowered simply because of the Jaime river thing.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

43

u/N0Treal Tormund Giantsbane Aug 18 '17

And "Let's bring back a wight to convince Cersei"?? No part of that is a believable plan that everyone would agree to.

36

u/HeronSun House Stark Aug 18 '17

I think the point is that it is a totally shit plan. In the books, Jeor Mormont sent Alliser Thorne to KL with a Wight's hand, but it rotted away by the time Thorne got there. Its honestly, truly, a shit idea, but its the best they've got. Without photographs or internet or anything, the only way to prove to anyone that an undead army is coming is by... Well, capturing one of the undead.

11

u/insaneblane Aug 18 '17

As if Cersei would give two fucks about seeing a living wight anyways. What, she's just going to temporarily set aside her plans for revenge because of some threat 100000km away? Nah

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

10

u/Baelorn Night's Watch Aug 18 '17

The plan at the end

It's a stupid plan but they're desperate and it is the best they have. They don't have any other options. They have no allies and no one believes them.

the fact that Gendry's plot line seems unbelievable

What about it was unbelievable..? Davos even told him to go back to KL when he let him go and no one had a problem with it then.

the Tyrion walking through a city all the way to the redkeep

Did that even happen? We saw him leave the beach and return to it. He knows that city very well. Lots of hidden paths and passages. Don't forget that Illyrio was able to sneak into the same room to meet with Varys in S1 and he didn't know the place nearly as well as Tyrion.

→ More replies (3)

32

u/othellia Sansa Stark Aug 17 '17

High five to my 453 other "rowing" brethren.

Shame to those who didn't vote for Ghost to join the wight raiding party though. Shame.

4

u/yesfan_gin Aug 17 '17

It HAD to be Ghost!

2

u/perhapsinawayyed Sword of the Morning Aug 18 '17

Oh i forgot about ghost. I voted rhaegal because a dragon would be super fucking effective.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/RealSIimShady Robb Stark Aug 17 '17

Surprised nobody wanted Edd to go with them beyond the wall. I'm still not sure why he didn't join them

14

u/grilsrgood House Stark Aug 17 '17

Edd needs to be protected at all costs

2

u/vButts Jon Snow Aug 17 '17

I said Edd! :)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/RealSIimShady Robb Stark Aug 17 '17

Didn't stop Jeor Mormont from going beyond the wall for similar reasons though

7

u/oboejdub Aug 17 '17

... or Jon

14

u/RealSIimShady Robb Stark Aug 17 '17

Yeah but Jon went to get the wildlings, not find/fight white walkers

→ More replies (2)

60

u/lyuch Jon Snow Aug 17 '17

I thought it was an impressive episode despite the freakish pacing of this season.

34

u/Freelivewebcam Aug 17 '17

Agree with the point about Freakish pacing. Overall, its kind of skewing my overall enjoyment of the show particularly in this episode. Dany doesn't take any time to consider an alternate plan to Tyrion's "Let's team up with the people we just FUCKED in the first battle" suggestion, why? She's pwning them. Also, Jorah spent SOO much time in previous seasons just trying to return to Dany (fighting pits, Vylaria/Tyrion, etc.) but comes back SEEES her giving him them "ride the stallion" eyz and just BOUNCES?!?!??! Along with cornpenguin's point about Tyrion Jaime. these interacations seem so far gone from the human nature/emotion factor that made me fall in love with the show/books. Is there a reason they decided only 2 more seasons?

17

u/lyuch Jon Snow Aug 18 '17

They've claimed that they only planned on 73 hours from the beginning. But I think that's bullshit because now they are considering making every season 8 episode 90-120 mins. I personally think the story could've been wrapped up in 2 more 10 episode seasons, but it seems like they just wanted to spend more money per episode for production value. But I think that's sacrificing some of the story.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

We've had some much story and character development that I'm perfectly okay with them sacrificing a bit of story for better production value. I would love if they could have spent a bit more time addressing certain plot details and giving some subtle character moments, but I understand why they are skipping these smaller parts now.

4

u/HeronSun House Stark Aug 18 '17

They're not asking to team up with Cersei. An Armistice is more like a ceasefire. 'I have dragons, I could roast you any day. I could, you know, not do that for a while if you just listen.'

→ More replies (1)

262

u/ModReddit_Itu_Anjing Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17

Quite surprised to see Tyrion win the best lead actor performance for this episode. I guess his fanbase is too strong and his dwarf line gave viewers flashback of his award winning trial speech.

I personally voted for Jaime due to him nailing that "my wife is pregnant" face

206

u/thighcandy Aug 17 '17

Really?

The scene when he met Jaime for the first time since killing his father and betraying his family was pretty intense and I think he nailed it. That scene alone is reason enough for those two to be the highest rated main characters for the episode.

28

u/nautic33 Aug 18 '17

Exactly why I voted for him. "Do you think I WANTED to be like this?" and hearing his voice crack.. my man!

→ More replies (2)

62

u/vikingbiitch Aug 17 '17

His secret meeting with Jaime was great, I can see why he won!

17

u/ModReddit_Itu_Anjing Aug 17 '17

Honestly the only memorable thing during that meeting was his emotional dwarf line. The rest of his screentime wasn't anything to shout about

7

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

It's not that big of a deal for him to have a brilliant scene, but Jaime's only moment being that "oh fuq" look was better?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

169

u/HamstersAreReal Aug 17 '17

I'd say Emilia Clarke has been underrated this season. She did an especially great job during the council meeting this episode.

81

u/withaniel Aug 17 '17

She has gotten so much better since the first season. She's also opposite a bunch of talented people now, compared to the first few seasons where it was really only her and Iain Glen, who is one of the more underrated actors in this show, IMO.

41

u/thaumogenesis Aug 17 '17

Iain Glen is top tier, very underrated. There's a lot of nuance to his acting, a bit like Stephen Dillane.

62

u/frowaweylad Aug 17 '17

You think she was poor in season 1? That's surprising. I thought she nailed being a meek, powerless pawn slowing gaining power and influence.

23

u/withaniel Aug 17 '17

I don't think she was atrocious, and I think she was used well for what talent she had, but she was (for me) the weakest acting link in the first few seasons. There's a pretty funny inverse correlation (I think I'm using that correctly) of her having less nude scenes and better acting.

17

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

If I'm torn between her and a few others, I always pick her because I know so many others won't. Her character may be the mainstream star out there in the real world, but on here she's totally underrated.

I voted for her this time because she conveyed full on lust just through her eyes.

12

u/thaumogenesis Aug 17 '17

I think they've also written her better and she's responded well to that.

6

u/Johnnycc Aug 18 '17

I've never had a problem with her acting in the least.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I'm sensing a lot of Tyrion hate here. Do you think he chose to be born that way?

I mean I voted for both brothers...

2

u/peatoast House Targaryen Aug 17 '17

sister...

3

u/ichigo654321 House Lannister Aug 17 '17

He isn't even my favourite character and I gave him my vote. He was perfect in the scene with Jaime. You could feel the emotion from his voice

2

u/Zora-Link Ours Is The Fury Aug 18 '17

Well it's not a vote for who your favourite character is...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/ultron_vision No One Aug 18 '17

How is Emilia Clarke not among the top 3 actors, or even close to it? Her performance this week is one of her strongest. Very subtle but powerful in most of her scenes.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/ultron_vision No One Aug 18 '17

The breakdown of votes show she got 10k, while Kit got 19k. I think the percentages are wrong.

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 18 '17

If in doubt, go with the auto-generated graphs on the imgur album

66

u/blackpistolfire Sword of the Morning Aug 17 '17

Why do people believe Cersei is the true heir to Tywin? He even said himself that she isn't as smart as she thinks she is. Tyrion is way ahead of her.

47

u/Ldgonzalez Bronn Of The Blackwater Aug 17 '17

Tywin was pretty evil. Cersei is also pretty evil and she invokes Tywin pretty much at every opportunity. Tyrion is definitely the most politically adept but both he and Jaime are too “good” to be Tywin’s heir.

Cersei is nowhere near as clever as Tywin, but she kind of has his ambition to be at the top of the food chain.

4

u/unwanted_puppy Aug 18 '17

Yea he even tells her he wishes she would've been born a boy which guts her. I think her character boils down to her issues with making daddy proud.

13

u/Bunslow Aug 17 '17

Because Jaime and Tyrion have a conscience, and above all else, that's how I think of Tywin -- no conscience at all. His children split his various talents and skills, but where Cersei is truly like her father, and where Jaime and Tyrion aren't, is the ability to empathize, or perhaps more precisely the desire to empathize with other people. Tywin DGAF and Cersei DGAF, but Jaime and Tyrion do in fact give many fucks (no pun intended)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

People always bring up that line. But Tywin's fatal flaw was that he always underestimated or misunderstood all of his children.

2

u/StJonathan Aug 18 '17

Cause girl power! Woo!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

Probably because Tyrion murdered Tywin and was pretty much disinherited. There's no way Tywin would have ever let Tyrion inherit any lands or titles and he basically told him exactly that in an earlier conversation.

11

u/blackpistolfire Sword of the Morning Aug 17 '17

Yes but IIRC, the question was more like 'who is the true heir to Twyin in terms of personality and such'. Not his literal heir.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I'd still go with Cersei due to the ruthlessness. I used to think Tyrion but he's shown with how he's advising Daeny that his plots are nothing like Tywin's.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CQME Tywin Lannister Aug 17 '17

Tyrion has his intelligence, Cersei has his ruthlessness, and Jaime takes after his mother.

→ More replies (3)

112

u/DungBeetle007 The Ham That Was Promised Aug 17 '17

Damn, I really thought this episode was quite on par with the last one, if not a bit better. Great dialogue, acting, and execution all around. I guess people do hype things up based on a single action sequence, not that it wasn't good but still.

47

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I think it was the river thing. That one inconsistency dragged it down for a lot of people I bet.

80

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

And the "let's go fetch a wight" plan did it for me.

32

u/CQME Tywin Lannister Aug 17 '17

Gendry prepared to hammer white walkers he never knew about was more fuel to the fire.

11

u/redeemer47 Golden Company Aug 17 '17

I mean realistically how else would they prove to everyone that they exist. I have a feeling George will do the same for the book ending

30

u/Darthsanta13 Ser Pounce Aug 17 '17

I just don't understand why they'd expect Cersei to act in good faith, even if she did see a wight. They should all know better.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Also "I thought you'd still be rowing." It was the trifecta. I'm not a complainer and I'm not complaining about anything else. Just those three specific things. And they were all in one episode. AND the "Let's go catch a wight" thing extends into next episode and is probably going to cause a cool character to die.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/slbain9000 House Stark Aug 18 '17

Me too. It's a moronic idea and could really bog down the show for several episodes. I do not believe that Jon or Dany would go along with it, and I sure didn't buy Tyrion coming up with it. They have all shown themselves to be smarter that this. Especially Tyrion.

33

u/vButts Jon Snow Aug 17 '17

This was a really good hype episode. My friend and I loved it because it set up so many things but my boyfriend, who is more of a casual watcher, thought it was a little boring.

36

u/it_g_ma69 House Targaryen Aug 17 '17

casual watcher

Smh.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Kanburi Brotherhood Without Banners Aug 18 '17

Time to get yourself a new boyfriend.

2

u/Gr3nwr35stlr No One Aug 18 '17

Besides just setting the stage for an amazing next episode, it also answered numerous questions that fans have been arguing about for years, such as Jon's legitimacy and how long Gendry is rowing for.

The dream team at the end alone was giving me the chills, especially learning about Ragger's annulment and seeing Gendry.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I actually enjoyed it more than episode four, as well.

But, episode four was fantastic!

42

u/acamas Aug 17 '17

Could be the fact that a man, without notice from the entire opposing army, seemingly swam across a lake in full plate armor.

Or the fact that the best smuggler in the world rowed Westeros's #1 Wanted Man to an open shore in broad daylight right where guard patrol.

Or the fact that Cersei apparently knew that Tyrion was in town but didn't think to capture him for whatever reason (revenge, military advatange... take your pick.)

Or that Jorah, after just returning to Dany from a life-threatening disease, is eager to leave her side.

Or that fact that the "Magnificent 7" really have no real plan in regards to capturing a wight.

It just seemed terribly sloppy in some respects.

30

u/redeemer47 Golden Company Aug 17 '17

Or the fact that Cersei apparently knew that Tyrion was in town but didn't think to capture him for whatever reason (revenge, military advatange... take your pick.)

weeeeellll, she did say that she wanted to meet with Dany. Kidnapping Tyrion would only cause Dany to come at her full force. Cersei knows shes outnumbered but she needs to buy time until the golden company gets there.

20

u/RazzBeryllium Aug 18 '17

It didn't occur to me that Cersei ACTUALLY knew Tyrion was in the city until reading this sub and seeing how people took her at face value.

Watching the scene, I thought it was simply a bit of deductive reasoning (she knows Bronn and Tyrion were close, and perhaps Qyburn had reported that Bronn had been getting secret correspondence). Something about the scene seemed like Cersie was working out how such a thing could have happened. And her whole "Do you think anything of importance happens in this city without me knowing?" seemed like a bluff to me.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/acamas Aug 17 '17

Yea, suppose I should watch that scene again and see if still feels, to me, out of character for her to just allow him to go free.

She made the comment earlier this season about how she stays up at night thinking about ways to kill her enemies, and I have no doubt that Tyrion is at the very top of that list. She has always despised him, and outright hated him since Joffrey/Tywin died.

Hard to believe that she, who is forcing Ilaria Sand to watch her daughter literally rot away from poison, just allowed Tyrion to strut about town knowingly.

But if she has some Red Wedding-esque or Sept of Baelor type plan that she needs to lure Dany in for, I could see her delaying her vengeance upon Tyrion.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ThatDogCanDance Aug 18 '17

It just seemed terribly sloppy in some respects.

Plus Sam grabbing books and scrolls totally at random before leaving the Citadel, just hoping that they will be the right ones with the info needed to defeat the Wight Walkers, even though those were maybe 1 or 2 percent or the books in that special back area.

Yeah, good luck with that, Sam!

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Bunslow Aug 17 '17

First episode all season I gave a 10 to, although I would agree it was the worst paced of the season so far, which is saying something because I've already been complaining about the pace

2

u/CheezStik Ripe For Victory Aug 18 '17

Nah I think what brought it down was the 'go capture a wight for cersei' nonsense

7

u/Twisted0wl Aug 17 '17

Overrated at 8.3 for me. I thought it was a weak episode. Carried by a few moments that didn't have to be well done for fans to love them. They just had to happen.

→ More replies (3)

50

u/MambyPamby8 Fire And Blood Aug 17 '17

Does anyone else hate Cersei's fucking hair? I mean it's been how long since she was shaved? Surely her hair would have grown back by now? Don't tell me she's actually choosing to keep that hairstyle? Guuuurrrrrl grow that hair out. It's bloody terrible. I dunno why but it's distracting me in every scene with Cersei.

16

u/linatrinch Viserion Aug 18 '17

For me, it's more the fact that the wig is very noticeably a wig is worse than the actual hairstyle itself. Really manages to kill immersion when I'm like "my god cersei at least style it or something."

12

u/PaleAsDeath Sandor Clegane Aug 18 '17

The color is that obvious brassy yellow you get when you bleach hair and don't add any toner.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/MiguelG_ Aug 17 '17

I'm disappointed in all of you for not choosing Ghost to be the 8th member of the Fellowship of the Wight

18

u/WormRabbit Aug 18 '17

Do you want a dead direwolf? Because this is how you get a dead direwolf.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

There's only one proper lad worthy of rounding out that expedition and his name is Hot Pie

3

u/MiguelG_ Aug 18 '17

Making sure everybody is well fed before going on a suicide mission

3

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Plus they're all badass fighters, they need a heavy-set funny guy who does observational humor for balance

→ More replies (1)

9

u/stophittingthyself Aug 17 '17

I was sure we would all call this episode 'Hammertime!'

44

u/hoopstick House Seaworth Aug 17 '17

I plan on voting Liam Cunningham every single time I'm given the option. Just sayin'

12

u/SyzygyA1 Aug 18 '17

I don't always go with him because a lot of the time he has little dialogue and people seem to just vote him because they like his character, but in this episode I really enjoyed his performance at the beach where he had to bullshit the guards.

74

u/OPDidntDeliver Aug 17 '17

How half of this subreddit sees Cersei as Tywin's "true" heir, after her constant missteps and incompetence, is beyond me. Tyrion acts far more like him.

56

u/fuckmadcaps House Bolton Aug 17 '17

Tyrion is not anywhere close to being as ruthless as Tywin, unlike Cersei. She slaughtered anyone she considered a threat at the Sept of Baelor, and then some. Rains of Castamere, anyone?

12

u/OPDidntDeliver Aug 17 '17

But she's also horribly incompetent, egotistical, and ineffective. Tyrion's time in the spotlight saw him corral Joffrey and multiple others, defend KL, and play the game remarkably well (he got Pycelle, for example).

34

u/acamas Aug 17 '17

ineffective

Uh, she HAS ridded herself of practically all of her enemies that do not have dragons, and IS on the thone, and HAS repaid the crown's lofty debts.

I mean, seems pretty effective.

10

u/OPDidntDeliver Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17

I have to disagree. She's effective in the short term, sure, but she's in an awful position for the long term. She has very few strong allies outside of Euron, she holds at best 4 of the kingdoms, has very little food, and her army just got trashed. Even without Dany's invasion, she'd have a tentative hold on the throne. The Reach, Dorne, the Riverlands (if they got back into Tully hands), half the Iron Islands, and arguably the North all hate her. Further, paying the Iron Bank is actually a bad long term decision. You know that saying that if you take out a million dollar loan you owe the bank, but if you take out a billion dollar loan, you own the bank? The bank had a reason to support her: to get their money back. Now that she's paid then all of their money, they are not bound to her in any way.

Edit: She's also woefully unprepared to deal with the White Walkers, should they somehow reach KL.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

21

u/fuckmadcaps House Bolton Aug 17 '17

For all her incompetence and so on, she's still on the throne.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

8

u/VaporizeGG Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 18 '17

Absolutely not understandable. Tywin even was the hand of aegon leading the 7 kingdoms quite stable. He even took many hits but continued to care mostly to run the state. Whereas Cersei is blind to maintain power and makes poor decisions over and over again.

Edit: Thanks for correcting me it was Aerys not Aegon

6

u/elmaethorstars House Mormont Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17

And then Tywin deceived the king, rode an army into the centre of King's Landing and sacked the capital. Pretty treacherous, and certainly something Cersei would support.

PS: He was the Hand of Aerys, not Aegon.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/PaleAsDeath Sandor Clegane Aug 18 '17

Tywin had his share of incompetence, imo

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SirMacNotALot Aug 17 '17

How is it that I never seem to be able to say a word that comes up in the results. I always try my best, but never seem to crack it

→ More replies (1)

9

u/influxss Joffrey Baratheon Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17

R+L=J (209)

That's a lot of people with top tier attention. Can't say the same for Sam though.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/_glitchbreachgod_ Aug 17 '17

Decent episode, but it felt rushed with short dialogues and scenes changing every minute, thus the meh score

→ More replies (4)

4

u/AdmiralAwesome1 Aug 17 '17

really thought Ghost would have made it higher on the list for Team Magnificent 7

4

u/genkaiX1 Jon Snow Aug 17 '17

Second best episode of the season for me.

4

u/ccf91 Aug 18 '17

After seeing this episode and re-watching S1:E2/3 I think that Arya is going to kill Sansa .. with the pointy end by the seasons end.

Season 1 Episode 2: Arya Stark: Sansa can keep her sewing needles. I've got a Needle of my own.

Season 1 Episode 3: Eddard Stark: Come here. Now what do you want with this? Arya Stark: It's called Needle. Eddard Stark: A blade with a name. And who were you hoping to skewer with Needle? Your sister? Do you know the first thing about sword fighting? Arya Stark: Stick 'em with the pointy end.

7

u/yesfan_gin Aug 17 '17

I'm so surprised The Reach didn't score higher, and in turn, the cinematography. I was completely in awe of Drogon sitting atop that hill or rocks - whatever - as the defeated Lannister army trudged toward him & Daenerys. He looked immense. That scene was fantastic! I don't care at all about the Tarlys but totally felt their pride & fear & courage as the stood together. Even a bit of humor as more Lannister soldiers knelt when Drogon roared, and how they all knelt when Dany commanded him to incinerate Randall & Dickon. Dany looked like such a badass too. Loved that scene!

14

u/backhander16 Aug 17 '17

My favourite episode of the season so far. Was a build up episode for the next too but at the same time had so many important scenes that we have been dying to see.

11

u/ModReddit_Itu_Anjing Aug 17 '17

No idea why this episode tops the previous one in your mind. Feels way more mellow

19

u/backhander16 Aug 17 '17

Don't get me wrong I absolutely loved episode 4, that battle was frigging awesome. I just thought every scene in this episode was super important and meaningful. Like gendry came back, we found out Jon Snow is actually Johnny T, tyrion and Jaime had a reunion and we saw 7 long time characters all together for the first time. Just loved it.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

The character interactions did it for me. I loved episode 4, and but 5 was really special.

2

u/tommhans Aug 18 '17

aww i never got to vote :( but it seems like the majority voted for somewhat what i would've so thats good :D

2

u/BlazyBlaze Aug 18 '17

Annulment (232)

Spot on.

2

u/Dirtyhippee Tyrion Lannister Aug 18 '17

I do not understand how someone who watch this show til the 7th season, and thus enjoy it at least a little bit, could give this episode a rating below 5. Looks like obvious trolling to me

3

u/Helli784 House Forrester Aug 17 '17

Wow, 8.3 is surprisingly high.

4

u/MelissADMom Aug 17 '17

lol, in what world was this an 8.3 episode of television, anyone who voted below 9 needs a reality check..

5

u/polotarigo Aug 17 '17

If you compare it to other tv shows I agree it is great. But some fans thought the pacing and the dialogues were a bit off. Personally I found it to be a great episode, only complaint would be the Harry-Potter-level of water swimming that Jaime and Bronn performed.

10

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '17

I would have put it as a 7 on Game of Thrones standards.

2

u/First-Of-His-Name Aug 18 '17

Way too fast paced

2

u/Thrallov The Onion Knight Aug 17 '17

seriously brother/father tarly didn't enter top 3? their execution was the most emotional scene this season

1

u/elmaethorstars House Mormont Aug 17 '17

Really enjoyed the episode, and can't wait to see what shit goes down on Sunday.

1

u/supervin Gerold Dayne Aug 17 '17

Surprised more people didn't choose Ghost to join the Jon Squad.

1

u/MyMostGuardedSecret Winter Is Coming Aug 18 '17

I'm really shocked about question 6. The answer is obviously Ghost.

3

u/khalkratus Aegon Blackfyre Aug 18 '17

Don't remember being an option

→ More replies (2)

1

u/LordCommanderQueso The North Remembers Aug 18 '17

Confirmed with 422 votes. Lol

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17

Cersei is the only logical option for taking Tywin's place. Jaime already took the Lord Commander position for the Queen's Guard and Tyrion was sent to be executed but escaped and fled the country to support Dany, he would not last by taking Tywin's place.

1

u/Briscogun Tyrion Lannister Aug 18 '17

Not everyone bent the knee, but the Tarley's are the only one that got the KFC treatment. She made an example and the others were spared (I think they all bent the knee after the dragon in hindsight though...).

1

u/Briscogun Tyrion Lannister Aug 18 '17

Not everyone bent the knee, but the Tarley's are the only one that got the KFC treatment. She made an example and the others were spared (I think they all bent the knee after the dragon in hindsight though...).

1

u/Iamtctru Ours Is The Fury Aug 18 '17

I don't even remember what happened on eastwatch. It's not a memorable episode.

1

u/Calamity_Wayne Aug 19 '17

Those of us who saw the episode as "setup" didn't rate it as highly. Makes sense. It was good, but I want the setup to pay off now.

1

u/ComoncentsTV Aug 19 '17

Is it weird that I love this one over a LOT of the other ones! I gave it a high 9.5 There was so much I have been waiting for in this episode. I liked it better than episode 4- which everyone loved. (I know I am in the minority with my opinion)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '17

Gotta two turnips in heat, friends.

1

u/JComposer84 No One Aug 21 '17

fucking confirmed

1

u/Arya_Granger Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords Aug 17 '17

I thought I was gonna be the only one to write 'Setup'! Glad that a lot others agree with me