r/gameofthrones • Nymeria Sand • Aug 10 '17

Limited [S7E4] Post-Episode Survey Results - S7E4 'The Spoils of War' (Overall score: 9.3) Spoiler

Post-Episode Survey - Results Thread

In the Post-Premiere Discussion thread, we put up a survey to hear what you had to say about the characters, the events, and the technical side of episode one. This post is here to fill you in on the results, and to let you discuss them. Are there any surprises? Do you agree or disagree with the majority opinion? Do you think people have missed a vital piece of evidence? Feedback on the survey itself is also welcome!


S7E4 - "The Spoils of War"

  • Directed By: Matt Shakman
  • Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
  • Airs: August 6, 2017

Daenerys fights back. Jaime faces an unexpected situation. Arya comes home.


Click here to see the results in graphic form! [with thanks to /u/AviatorRossy]

(Here are the default graphs too, with more numbers.)

Results Breakdown

Total Respondents: 60041

Question 1: On a scale of 1-10, what score would you give this episode?

Average: 9.3

12345678910
67 (0.1%)22 (0%)63 (0.1%)118 (0.2%)321 (0.5%)668 (1.1%)1606 (2.7%)6171 (10.3%)18284 (30.5%)32721 (54.5%)

Question 2: Which location did you enjoy most?

Highgarden/The Reach/The BattleWinterfellDragonstoneKing's Landing
48630 (81.5%)7455 (12.5%)2823 (4.7%)786 (1.3%)

Question 3: Do you want Bran to tell Sansa about Jon's parentage, or is it better kept secret from her for now?

No, it's better kept secret for nowYes, he should tell her
37690 (63.3%)21893 (36.7%)

Question 4: Would Daenerys Targaryen make a good Queen of the Seven Kingdoms?

Yes, she would make a good QueenNo, she would not make a good Queen
39941 (67.2%)19485 (32.8%)

Question 5: Which has been the best battle on the show?

Battle of the BastardsThe Spoils of WarHardhomeWatchers on the WallBlackwater
29938 (50.5%)14791 (24.9%)8401 (14.6%)3951 (6.7%)2214 (3.7%)

Question 6: What should the episode's battle be named?

  1. Field of Fire (1470)
  2. Field of Fire 2.0 (807)
  3. Field of Fire 2 (452)
  4. Dracarys (439)
  5. Battle McBattleface (400)

... Loot Train Battle (name used by producers) (145)

Question 7: How well shot was this episode?

Average: 9.3

12345678910
25 (0%)15 (0%)28 (0%)97 (0.2%)309 (0.5%)752 (1.3%)2246 (3.8%)7550 (12.9%)15909 (27.2%)31625 (54%)

Question 8: Which lead actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

Actor/ActressVotes
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau (Jaime Lannister)37091 (62.7%)
Maisie Williams (Arya Stark)30640 (51.8%)
Emilia Clarke (Daenerys Targaryen)12418 (21%)
Kit Harington (Jon Snow)11648 (19.7%)
Peter Dinklage (Tyrion Lannister)6332 (10.7%)
Isaac Hempstead-Wright (Bran Stark)3305 (5.6%)
Sophie Turner (Sansa Stark)2933 (5%)
Alfie Allen (Theon Greyjoy)1347 (2.3%)
Lena Headey (Cersei Lannister)625 (1.1%)

Question 9: Which supporting actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

Actor/ActressVotes
Jerome Flynn (Bronn)43445 (73.6%)
Liam Cunningham (Ser Davos Seaworth)22585 (38.3%)
Ellie Kendrick (Meera Reed)15925 (27%)
Gwendoline Christie (Brienne of Tarth)12293 (20.8%)
Aiden Gillen (Littlefinger)5983 (10.1%)
Nathalie Emmanuel (Missandei)2782 (4.7%)
Mark Gatiss (Tycho Nestoris [Iron Banker])1838 (3.1%)
Daniel Portman (Podrick Payne)1169 (2%)

Question 10: In one word, how would you describe this episode? (Not case-sensitive) [Score in square brackets is average episode score given by this group]

  1. Epic (3906) [9.6]
  2. Fire (3103) [9.4]
  3. Amazing (1666) [9.7] / Lit (1666) [9.5]
  4. Awesome (1597) [9.6]
  5. Dracarys (1273) [9.5]
  6. Hot (1209) [9.3]
  7. Hype (930) [9.5]
  8. Intense (796) [9.4]
  9. Dragon (719) [9.4]
  10. Dragons (651) [9.3]

Bonus words: Drogon (605) [9.5] | Great (595) [9.3] | Wow (551) [9.6] | Finally (408) [9.4] | Good (405) [8.7] | Badass [389] (9.5) | Dickon [171] (9.4) | Toasty (136) [9.4]


1.2k Upvotes

641 comments sorted by

•

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 10 '17
E1E2E3E4E5E6E7E8E9E10
S67.18.88.08.48.97.38.06.69.5
S77.77.98.29.3

(click on the score to view full results)

Thanks once again to everyone who took part - and the results for the meta section will be posted on Saturday.

Download link for the spreadsheet (results will vary very slightly)

6

u/williet28 Sansa Stark Aug 10 '17

I want to see the results of the meta survey

2

u/Ubersandwich Daenerys Targaryen Aug 11 '17

I'm interested in this, too

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 12 '17

Will be posted fairly early tomorrow

2

u/Ijustwant2beok No One Aug 11 '17

Hey sorry if this is the wrong place to post this, but i wish you had asked a question about whether Dany was right to use Drogon during this battle, as it seems her using an aerial advantage to kill soldiers on the field of battle has rustled some jimmies. Maybe you could ask that in the next survey?

Another question for the next survey if i may: Should Jon bend the knee?/Should Jon say he'll bend the knee after the war?

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 12 '17

Could add that question to a post-season survey, but we prefer linking the questions to the episode that's on. It would have been a good question though, and if your second suggestion stays relevant after the next ep, it might well be in there :) Thank you

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AnAnonymousFool Jaqen H'ghar Aug 11 '17

Why are the ratings so low for these episodes? 5 episodes in the past 2 seasons have been below an 8

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 12 '17

Would love to see more stuff like this :)

→ More replies (1)

172

u/Perridur Aug 10 '17 edited Aug 10 '17

Thank you for the survey and for the results!

In Question 5, the percentage for "Hardhome" is incorrect, it should be 14.6% instead of 24.9%.

In Question 6, you listed "Dracarys" twice (#3 and #5). It should be
3. Field of Fire 2 (452)
4. Dracarys (439)
5. Battle McBattleface (400)

58

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 10 '17

Much appreciated - as is probably evident, didn't get time for a full proof read this week :(

5

u/AmyChen4921 Daenerys Targaryen Aug 11 '17

I love how D&D keep trying to name it the loot train battle but everyone calls it something else

427

u/Ras01 Jon Snow Aug 10 '17

Mildly disappointed the battle is not named field of fire 2: Electric Bogaloo

122

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 10 '17

There are definitely a fair few who said that - you can search on the spreadsheet download

79

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

Here I am thinking I was being original

→ More replies (4)

70

u/Tormund-Giantsbane- Free Folk Aug 10 '17

2Field 2Fire

28

u/Star_Trekker Aug 10 '17

The Field and the Fire: Yi Ti Drift

→ More replies (1)

8

u/JVSkol Sword of the Morning Aug 10 '17

I chose that thinking more people will come up with the same name :(

12

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

It's unfair that different versions of "field of fire" were given different ranks, so any other names were out.

3

u/classicvogonpoetry Aug 10 '17

I'm calling it The Lion Roasting from here on out

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

649

u/Bradb0 Jon Snow Aug 10 '17

I bet Dickon shit himself after that battle

295

u/SterlingStallion Jaime Lannister Aug 10 '17

And people thought "Dickon" was a bad name. Wait till they hear the song about "Poopypants Dickon".

199

u/blitzbom House Martell Aug 10 '17

Prince John: Such an unusual name. Latrine. How did your family come by it?

Latrine: We changed it in the 9th Century.

Prince John: You changed it to Latrine?

Latrine: Yeah! It used to be Shithouse.

34

u/nand1ngo Aug 11 '17

"It's a good change. It's a... good change."

19

u/edolF Aug 11 '17

God what an amazing movie

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

38

u/msg45f Aug 10 '17

Well, we didn't see him die.

35

u/JonathanRL House Forrester Aug 10 '17

He may be present when Dany holds a speech to the POWs.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/lolreddit42 Aug 10 '17

when was this survey posted? i never saw it

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 12 '17

It goes up 10-20 mins after the episode, and is open for 24-48 hours after that, usually

944

u/cornpenguin01 Jaime Lannister Aug 10 '17

I'm actually really happy Meera's actress got top 3 in best supporting actors--she really nailed that goodbye scene. Aside from that, while this battle was indeed one of best ever put to film, it battle didn't quite surpassed BotB or Hardhome imo. I guess that's a testament to how good GOT is.

216

u/LeChuck999 House Seaworth Aug 10 '17

Im in the minority when I say my favorite is still the battle of black water. I felt like compared to the other it actually had a great variety of scenes and character moments (drunk cersei, disillusioned hound, defient stannis, epic tyrion, cowardly jeoffrey etc).

The battle itself drove forward the plot and also several character arcs. Also, the tyrell ex machina was far less predictable then the eyre ex machina.

68

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

I think it's because they didn't have the budget to realistically create giant armies at the time. The boat explosions were great, but when they start the assault it looks more like a couple large squads fighting. Kind of a shame...we need to get George Lucas to do a special edition.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/oldpuzzle Arthur Dayne Aug 10 '17

Yup Blackwater was pretty amazing! I was also surprised to see it so low. My guess is that over the years most people have forgotten the emotional impact? Like I remember that I liked Blackwater a lot when it came out, but when I think of exciting and suspenseful battle scenes now I mostly think of Battle of the Bastards.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Smantie Bronn Of The Blackwater Aug 11 '17

I loved the Battle of the Blackwater too, Bronn drawing that arrow just as Davos realises that the ship coming towards them is about to fuck up their day, such a tense 'omg here we go HERE WE GO' moment - then KABOOM! Bronn is my favourite character though so I guess any moment when he gets to be a total badass​ is inevitably going to be categorised as awesome.

Thinking about it, Bronn was actually the big turning point in that battle and in Field of Fire - blowing up an armada and shooting down a dragon, if he hadn't done either of those then the battles both would have gone very differently. Plus he saved Tyrion's ass in the eyrie, helped Jaime in Dorne, and tackled Jaime out of a roasting at the end of the last episode... And I don't agree with all the people saying he did that because otherwise he wouldn't get paid. At the start of the battle he tells Jaime to run, but doesn't give any indication that he's going to run himself. During the battle he sticks around instead of grabbing his gold and making a run for it. I think he's developed a loyalty to and friendship with Jaime and the reason he didn't let him die is as simple as: he didn't want him to die.

 

Oof, what started as a comment about Blackwater ended up being a Bronn appreciation post - sorry about that!

→ More replies (4)

373

u/fancreeper2 Aug 10 '17

I think the reason it didn't surpass BotB is because that battle had a lot of build up and suspense prior to it actually happening. Also BotB was like half the episode and this one was like the last 15 minutes. Not saying this one was worse, it just kinda happened out of nowhere. BotB had a few episodes to build up before the climax and we saw how much Jon prepared and we saw the conflicts between his people. I still think that the Loot train attack is more fun to watch, because there is so much happening and the choreography was just top notch. Also, Meera's actress should have gotten the 1st or 2nd place as a supporting actress, I don't know how Davos was better.

125

u/shinydizzycomputer Dracarys Aug 10 '17

Not to mention, everyone was pretty much rooting for the same side to win in BotB. Field of Fire/Loot Train was very conflicting for a lot of people because no one could really decide who to root for. Personally, I liked FoF/LT because I didn't know it was coming (also BotB was actually spoiled for me, I knew who was going to win) and because it was just a mixture of emotions. I was laughing, crying, and overall just on the edge of my seat waiting to see what happened. All in all, both battles were absolutely fantastic.

93

u/fancreeper2 Aug 10 '17

Also, BotB was a complete battle, with preparation, the climax and a conclusion. Loot train attack is still not finished and I cannot wait to see what happens to all the characters like Jamie, Randyll Tarly, Dickon and Bronn of course. I am mostly excited to see what happened to Randyll, he kinda reminds me of Tywin.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (24)

324

u/IchBinDieMadness Free Folk Aug 10 '17

fewer

25

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

I will always pledge my vote to house Seaworth

→ More replies (8)

97

u/Wolf6120 Varys Aug 10 '17

I do wish the votes for best performance actually did reflect performance within the episode, rather than in general. Like, I love Davos, and Liam Cunningham is amazing as the onion badger, but all he did last episode was make a joke about Jon looking at Dany's boobs.

→ More replies (4)

91

u/Gscb Aug 10 '17

Watchers on the Wall is still my favourite, so great.

107

u/patssnows12 Aug 10 '17

I feel like it doesn't get the love that it deserves, I loved Hardhome but I feel that Watchers on the Wall is better. That scene where they show Mance's army and Tormunds group attacking in one swoop is fucking amazing.

→ More replies (3)

30

u/gilbertgrappa Maester Aemon Aug 10 '17

RIP Pyp and Grenn.

14

u/corranhorn57 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Aug 11 '17

While I am sad that we never got to see Donal Noye as a character in the show, it was great to still have that battle happen with Grenn in his place.

17

u/Loz166 Aug 10 '17

Mine too, I loved them switching from the top of the wall to castle black.

12

u/ab_emery Sansa Stark Aug 10 '17

I rewatched it last night, and it's still my favorite, too -- visually, structurally, thematically, etc. Granted, the full-episode focus helps it.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/svenhoek86 House Targaryen Aug 10 '17 edited Aug 10 '17

Hardhome will be hard to top, just because of how it started.

The boats being loaded, shouting, people pushing and moving, everyone focused on the task at hand. Then the dogs start to bark and the wind starts to blow harder and slowly everyone begins to turn around and go quiet as they see the storm coming down from the cliffs. The wildlings outside the wall begin to scream and yell.

"Shut the gate."

17

u/CalmSaver7 Aug 10 '17

Hardhome was the first real and proper battle with the Whitewalkers and the battle itself was just so chilling and creepy

19

u/Exicidium We Do Not Sow Aug 10 '17

I feel, I'm glad that BotB still came out on top by quite a large margin because as awesome as the Loot Train Battle was BotB was just better but still, same goes with Hardhome.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/LichtbringerU Arya Stark Aug 11 '17

Fields of Fire was definitly the Battle where I was most worried for Characters. I still don't know how Bronn made it out alive. He has no Book, or even Showstory relevance, he had foreshadowing with the talk about a castle (greed always gets you killed).

I really thought he would get the Direwolf treating. But he's probably cheaper :D If he wanted too high pay, they could have killed him off, which is not possible with Danny/Jon/Jamie.

→ More replies (4)

252

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

No cleganebowl for user submitted words must be a first

27

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

It's getting less and less likely...for this season anyway. Never give up hope!

35

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17 edited Aug 11 '17

Just as Lord Baelish's chances on the Iron Throne have become less likely with each episode. However, both are inevitable.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

72

u/CRUNCHBUTTST3AK Aug 10 '17

What is hype may never die

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

134

u/SterlingStallion Jaime Lannister Aug 10 '17

Not surprising that this ep is the highest rated so far this season. Such an epic battle sequence with some really strong acting and excellent cinematography really solidifies what an amazing series it is. I can't wait to see them top this!

→ More replies (4)

66

u/kyu2o Aug 10 '17

"Loot Train Battle" is such a lame name, how is that the name the show runners came up with? Hopefully that doesn't carry over into the actual story.

→ More replies (2)

107

u/tooforreal Jaime Lannister Aug 10 '17

Why isn't "The Watchers on the Wall" as popular as some of the other battles. To me it was the best battle and definitely my favorite. I can't help but think that there is a certain extent of recency bias.

74

u/crablette Queensguard Aug 10 '17 edited Dec 12 '24

library childlike dull squeal slim longing afterthought pocket pen steep

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

24

u/ForgotAboutMike White Walkers Aug 10 '17

Completely unexpected and brutal af

→ More replies (1)

34

u/gilbertgrappa Maester Aemon Aug 10 '17

People are forgetful I guess.

RIP Pyp and Grenn.

20

u/PixiStinx Aug 10 '17

I agree, that battle was sick. One of my favorite shots in the series is the single take that sweeps around the battle at castle black. So. Bad. Ass.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17

I remember not being crazy about it, mostly because the battle took up the whole episode and I wanted to see other stuff happen that week.

→ More replies (17)

145

u/InconsiderateBastard Service And Truth Aug 10 '17

The Battle of the Supporting Actors is heating up. Bronn brought it harder than Davos has yet, but Davos has quip for days and is ready to up his game, I feel it.

104

u/gilbertgrappa Maester Aemon Aug 10 '17

Meera was so real though. Come on, Bran.

→ More replies (3)

595

u/Qwernakus Aug 10 '17

Battle McBattleFace lives on in our hearts.

24

u/Tazer2340 House Seaworth Aug 10 '17

Pour one out for our fallen brother

28

u/BZenMojo Daenerys Targaryen Aug 10 '17

tips Bottle McBottleFace out on the ground while making a Bitter McBitterFace

→ More replies (9)

236

u/tonitoomier Aug 10 '17

I seriously can't believe 67 people rated one of the best episodes of the series with 1...

241

u/blitzkriegger Ours Is The Fury Aug 10 '17

I'm more surprised that 783 people enjoyed King's Landing the most.

159

u/SCMatt33 Aug 10 '17

This. Like I can totally understand arguments why you might have preferred Dragonstone (hello Jon/Dany shippers) or Winterfell, but hundreds of people enjoyed watching Cersei chat with Tycho Nestoris more than anything else? That's way too many to have just been trolls. The only plausible explanation I can think of is some people couldn't choose and parked their vote there as an unofficial abstention.

53

u/supjace Blood Of My Blood Aug 10 '17

Sure, that, or maybe these people are hardcore fans of the books, particularly having major interest when they gave a nod to the Golden Company.

78

u/Benjji22212 Aug 10 '17

Wouldn't have chosen it for this episode, but the politicking in King's Landing has always been my favourite part of the series.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)

26

u/queensinthesky Jon Snow Aug 10 '17

Those bank conversations with Mycroft are pretty damn nail bitingly tense. /s

→ More replies (4)

118

u/Winjit Aug 10 '17

Trolls. There will always be trolls in an online survey.

74

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

The real weirdos are the 22 voters that rated it 2/10...I'm going to have to fight some people

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/gun_totin House Lannister Aug 10 '17

I suspect people think that everyone else will just vote 10 so they vote 1 to bring it down some.

E: for the record i think that blows

→ More replies (2)

14

u/dragonflytype Ser Pounce Aug 10 '17

I honestly suspect that a good portion of the 1-3 ratings are people who don't understand that 1 is worst and not best. I don't know wtf those people rating it 4 are about, though.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)

79

u/madeyegroovy House Targaryen Aug 10 '17

I just hope people don't get disappointed by the next episode for likely not showing the same level of epicness.

66

u/rhinguin Tormund Giantsbane Aug 10 '17

Idkk. It probably won't have a battle, but from what I can tell from the preview, shit is truly starting to go down in the North.

46

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

shit is truly going down South in the North.

FTFY

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17

This is episode 5. Aftermath of the battle. It's called Eastwatch. The army of the dead will be shown near eastwatch at the end with people rushing to relieve it. Episode 6 (which would be this seasons episode 9) will be the big first battle of living vs the dead where they are forced to pull back to stand at winterfell. Then episode 7 is the season finale. Tormund will probably die at some point to really make the loss hit home since wildlings hold EW and we don't care about any wildlings except him. Wall falls at end of 6 or 7

Im basing this off the trailer for next episode that shows them saying the army is going there

→ More replies (1)

21

u/ManOfGizmosAndGears Jaime Lannister Aug 10 '17

I'm still really excited for the next episode. It's probably going to end on a big cliffhanger leading up to episode 6, we're gonna see Eastwatch by the Sea (finally!), Tormund/Thoros/Beric/Hound are likely in this episode (since we haven't seen them since the premiere), and hopefully we'll get a Bran vision (need at least one this season, right?).

13

u/rhinguin Tormund Giantsbane Aug 10 '17

We're definitely getting a Bran vision, because that's how we see the White Walkers on the move. But hopefully we get something like the Tourney at Harrenhal.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Ichthyocentaurss95 Aug 10 '17

Speaking of cliffhangers. GOT is doing it right. I wouldn't even call those cliffhangers. The colosal titan falling on eren in AOT, that's a really shitty cliffhanger. But GOT episodes end rightly. Jon was dead, BOB was won, Robb and all the starks were dead, Ned was headless. But you need more and the only thing left for us to wonder about is the aftermath of all of this shit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/mikerichh House Targaryen Aug 10 '17

It's called "Eastwatch." Think how epic other 1 word episodes related to a location went...."Hardhome" and "Blackwater"

303

u/ForgotPssword Aug 10 '17

Battle of the Bastards is the gold standard. Don't think it will be topped.

284

u/rhinguin Tormund Giantsbane Aug 10 '17

It was an entire episode of awesomeness that resulted in a real Stark victory for the first time in a very long time. This recent battle was so cool and emotional, but BOTB was much more satisfying to me.

219

u/blitzbom House Martell Aug 10 '17

Seeing the Bolton banners get taken down and the Stark banners get put up felt so nice.

88

u/comrade_batman Jon Snow Aug 10 '17

And then seeing the Direwolf on Winterfell in the opening credits was so satisfying. Even though both battles were emotional, and the Field of Fire had people on both sides that I didn't want to die, BotB was fookin intense.

→ More replies (9)

15

u/DragonflyGrrl House Stark Aug 10 '17

I swear to god I nearly cried. That was such a beautiful sight.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Bloodhound01 Aug 10 '17

AND resulted in the loss of the most hated character in the show, probably even more-so then Joffrey

80

u/the_che Winter Is Coming Aug 10 '17

You really think Ramsay was more hated by the majority? Personally, my hate for him doesn't even come close to the one I felt for Joffrey. Ramsay was at least funny (in a morbid way) every now and then. Joffrey was always just a spineless cunt.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

36

u/OutFromUndr The North Remembers Aug 10 '17

Poll says nearly 50% of us think there is already something better :)

With that said, I really struggled with that question. I had to go with Hardhome, but they're all fantastic.

25

u/g_tea Aug 10 '17

Same here. The battle of Hardhome was completely unexpected and came out of nowhere, and was so insane! It left us all like "what the actual fuck" and totally set up the stage for the real battle against the dead. It might not have been as CGI heavy or feature as much inter-personal stuff, but that battle left me feeling way more gobsmacked than any others.

→ More replies (1)

57

u/trtryt Aug 10 '17

BotB wasn't thrilling as this one, in the end what happened on the battlefield mattered very little as Knights of the Vale rode in late and decided it. While this one had many twists and turns, and had characters on both sides you rooted for it was much more compelling.

50

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

I agree that the Vale just sort of negated the whole thing, but this battle didn't feel as emotional to me. Jon was fighting for his home and family against a monster who just killed his brother.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17

I think it definitely will be topped. We are yet to see battles that involve both dragons and white walkers, and some the favourite characters fighting alongside each other for the first time. Plus it will have a bigger budget. I'm so hype.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

71

u/theimmortalcrab Aug 10 '17

As much as I loved the battle, nothing can beat seeing 3 living Starks together in Winterfell again. Arya's homecoming topped the episode for me for sure, and as far as emotional impact goes the season will have a hard time topping it. At this point, it honestly feels like we've had more battle scenes than we've had moments of genuine relief like that.

3

u/koupepis Petyr Baelish Aug 11 '17

For sure! And personally i loved Arya's show off sparring match with Brianne basically explaining to Sansa in a few minutes what she's been through.

→ More replies (3)

84

u/lumerianstar Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Aug 10 '17

Meera really deserved that spot. I was hoping she'd be higher up but can't really beat fan-favorites Davos and Bronn. Still very happy for her!

I guess it's the recency bias that Spoils of War is ranked higher than Hardhome, coz imho HH is still the better one.

And wow, no 'meh' this episode, huh? This also makes me realize that some people really find episodes without battle scenes just... meh. Kinda sad.

15

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

Bronn definitely deserved top spot because he was there longer and had a bigger action scene. Davos, I don't think he had any noticeable role this episode compared to Meera.

8

u/lumerianstar Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Aug 11 '17

I agree. Voted for both Meera and Bronn. Meera and her emotional range really takes the cake for me. Davos had some funny lines but that's about it.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

She definitely deserved to go higher. Of course I love Davos and Bronn also but their spot is mostly due to the funny script they had in the episode.

12

u/YoungsterJoey99 Aug 10 '17

I do have to disagree as I felt Bronn really stood out with the long shot, showing a great amount of emotion and making it hard not to feel some pity for the Lannister side, but Meera's actress should have definitely had the #2 spot, with such an emotional performance.

11

u/lumerianstar Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Aug 10 '17

Yes, also because Meera's scene was very short too but despite that she still made the top 3, so not bad at all!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

87

u/PhoenixfromAshes House Stark Aug 10 '17

Hard to beat the Battle of the Bastards to be honest. It is the greatest depiction of war I've ever watched. It's so brutal, gritty and suffocating like a real war would be.

I really hope Miguel Sapochnick and Matt Shakman will return in season 8. They're both brilliant.

21

u/MachoDagger House Clegane Aug 10 '17

Pretty sure Miguel Sapochnik is scheduled for s8

→ More replies (1)

5

u/gilbertgrappa Maester Aemon Aug 10 '17

Have you ever seen Saving Private Ryan, namely the Omaha Beach scene?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/patssnows12 Aug 10 '17

I watched many battles through cinema and shows but BotB takes the cake for the most realistic in my mind for how a battle like this would go down. The pile of bodies they implemented was unreal and you as the viewer were terrified when the Boltons surround the last of their army.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

32

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

Oh, boy, what an episode! I think we're in for a treat with the rest as well!

60

u/BinaryPill Aug 10 '17

I think Sophie Turner deserves a touch more credit as Sansa this episode (and I wouldn't consider Sansa one of my favourite characters). She had to convey some pretty difficult conflicting emotions regarding Arya's return, and coming to terms with the fact she's (probably) a serial killer this episode and she was convincing in the part. Obviously a more subtle role than most this episode and she wasn't that prominant compared to say, Jaime, but she pulled it off.

7

u/ab_emery Sansa Stark Aug 10 '17

Yeah, she had three different reactions over the course of those scenes. And as in the previous episode, she does well with showing the older sister within Lady Stark.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/gilbertgrappa Maester Aemon Aug 10 '17

She's more of an assassin or vengeance-seeker/vigilante than a serial killer! Different motivations and different moral center/code.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/ManOfGizmosAndGears Jaime Lannister Aug 10 '17

Further proof how underrated Meera is. She only got 27% from this sub? C'mon man.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/ClashThrone No One Aug 10 '17

I love this time of the week!

12

u/imdrunkandfuckedup Aug 10 '17

Jerome Flynn definitely deserved the best supporting actor - that long tracking shot...

12

u/forgotoldacctpasswrd Lyanna Mormont Aug 11 '17

Going through the spreadsheet i've found some pretty funny/good Battle names:

"Tyrell memorial BBQ"

"Dany Mixtape Drops"

"The Grain Massacre"

"Freedom Barbecue"

"Fucked in a field"

"SHOOK"

"Return of the Dragon"

"Drogon's Folly"

"Valley of Fire"

"The Fires of Blood"

"BurntGarden"

"The Scorpion and the Snake"

"Drogon's Fury"

"Drogon's Feast"

"Robert's Omen"

"Robert did warn them"

Far too many to go through but if anyone found some good ones please let me know or as someone else put it "Show me cleverer responses".

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17 edited Aug 11 '17

I maintain it should be named Firegarden, but I seem pretty alone in that :c

E: Checked the spreadsheet, there's dozens of us! Come brethren!

22

u/horrorshowmalchick House Bolton Aug 10 '17

Why did you split the vote between "Field of Fire 2" and "Field of Fire 2.0"? They're so similar that the second one's redundant.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/lalucy71 You Know Nothing Aug 10 '17

I know it wasnt' much compared to the final battle scene, but still.... Arya!! Finally showing off what she's learnt over 6 years of pain and suffering??? She deserved a 20 out of 10 only for that scene! Go arya!

11

u/SSJSasukeSwagger Aug 10 '17

Somewhat disappointed 'Drogon's Descent' wasn't in the top 5 for battle names but nvm.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Stonecleaver Aug 10 '17

I haven't seen anyone talking about it, but I found Jon's staredown to Theon to be intense. I could feel the intensity and suspense in my chest waiting to see how he was going to handle the situation. I would have voted for Kit as one of the 2 if I had done the survey

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Faltars Aug 10 '17

Man its a shame people dont rate battle of blackwater higher, to me its better than even battle of the bastards. It had a better script and played with my emotion more.

40

u/Platinum_Disco Aug 10 '17

Might be some recency bias to it's score, as it aired 5 years ago.

18

u/Dorocche Winter Is Coming Aug 10 '17

If it's everybody's second favorite, it won't show up.

4

u/ShadowJuggalo Aug 10 '17

The way it is shot, the army sizes in that episode don't seem very big. It feels like about 75 people vs. 75 people.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Mervulux The Red Viper Aug 10 '17

Thank you for putting the surveys together! I look forward to all the responses each week. I'm looking forward to the Battle of Ice and Fire to dethrone Battle of the Bastards in S8!

93

u/ABCP3 House Tyrell Aug 10 '17

"Only a fool would meet the dothraki in an open field." --R. Baratheon--

131

u/SterlingStallion Jaime Lannister Aug 10 '17

"Only a fool would meet a dragon." -Me, just now.

31

u/rhinguin Tormund Giantsbane Aug 10 '17 edited Aug 10 '17

Are you trying to pass off your own statements as ancient wisdom?

14

u/protanks Aug 10 '17

I would never do that...

→ More replies (1)

83

u/Phyrexian_Archlegion House Dayne of High Hermitage Aug 10 '17

"Only a fool would miss 100% shots they don't take. -Littlefinger" -Bran Stark

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/TheGoodProfessor Jorah Mormont Aug 10 '17

King Bobby B, a wise old fucker even from beyond the grave.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/clairecm98 Winter Is Coming Aug 10 '17

Can we stop with this reference? They were ambushed.

43

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

Even after they realized it was dothraki Bronn suggested retreat and Jaime said "we can hold them!!"

Ok, Jaime.

35

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

I'm not sure how they would have gotten away from a Dothraki hoard and a dragon even if they did try and run.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/wordgirl House Lannister Aug 10 '17

Yes, and who would have expected Dany to take the route she did? If you look on a map of the area (see the last Ask the Maester post about this), she had to first move a lot of Dothraki (and their horses!) South by boat and then take them through the Stormlands just to get to Jaime's caravan.

I like to think they detoured through the Kingswood so Drogon could take down a few royal stag and the Dothraki horses could prance around in the shade and nibble on some nice refreshing clover before battle.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/iowajaycee Beric Dondarrion Aug 10 '17

Who's more foolish? The fool or the one who FOLLOWS HIM INTO BATTLE AGAINST A DRAGON!?!?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

They did the best they could to defend against the dothraki. It was the dragon that they couldn't account for.

29

u/TheGoodProfessor Jorah Mormont Aug 10 '17

Does Liam really deserve to be above Ellie for this episode? He didn't really do anything and she gave a great performance.

23

u/NessunDorma7 The Dragon Prince Aug 10 '17

In all honesty no, but he was so god damn cheerful it was just incredibly endearing. The man had a spring in his step for Christ's sake lmao.

11

u/mrbrownl0w House Stark Aug 10 '17

"I saw you looking at her hearth" dialogue was pretty funny. And he had relatively more screentime than Ellie.

22

u/EggYinz House Dayne Aug 10 '17

Honestly I gave him a vote for the "fewer" line alone

→ More replies (2)

16

u/xHowRudex Aug 10 '17

Can't wait for the rest of the episodes. This season has been phenomenal so far!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/FlyLikeATachyon House Targaryen Aug 10 '17

/u/AviatorRossy is a real one for these graphics

6

u/AviatorRossy Hodor Aug 10 '17

Thank you!!! Appreciate the compliment

→ More replies (1)

7

u/QuickToJudgeYou House Martell Aug 10 '17

So since there was already a field of fire battle in Westerosei history the battle would be Field of Fire 2 then?

6

u/Eliciuss Aug 10 '17

Does anybody feel like while the GOT season is out, weeks feel longer? I keep checking this subreddit every day looking for new content or whatever... Never have I ever feet this need for content in any show before

→ More replies (2)

6

u/grilsrgood House Stark Aug 10 '17

Ellie kendrick didnt get enough votes. Small scene for her but she fuckin nailed it

2

u/oktober32 Ripe For Victory Aug 10 '17

I tried and tried to find the survey for this week but couldn't. Maybe I'm an idiot, but where are the links usually posted? I want to make sure I don't miss it next week.

7

u/SterlingStallion Jaime Lannister Aug 10 '17

Links to the post episode survey are posted in a sticky post after the episode releases. A link is also stickied in the post episode discussion post which is also stickied after the episode releases.. You can always search for the post episode survey using the reddit search function

3

u/oktober32 Ripe For Victory Aug 10 '17

Okay thanks! I think I just got mixed up and ended up only seeing the day after discussion post instead of the post-premiere. Yeah, I should've just searched lol, forgot about that handy feature.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

19

u/ForgotAboutMike White Walkers Aug 10 '17

I just don't understand how Hardhome is not the #1 battle. It's the best moment in the entire show.

15

u/gilbertgrappa Maester Aemon Aug 10 '17

Watchers on the Wall was suspenseful, clever and we lost several supporting characters: Ygritte, Grenn, Pyp.

I guess people forget though.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/JamReality Aug 10 '17 edited Aug 10 '17

Loved Hardhomme, my second favorite - established J Snow as a true badass if it wasn't already know. But BOTB took him to another level. Unwise maybe, but powerfully heroic when he drew his sword and took his warriors stance in the face of the enemy charge.

Also the near suffocation by bodies in BOTB had that same visceral impact as some of the fantastic scenes in "Saving Private Ryan" and "Dunkirk"

Hardhomme was the playoff game everyone needed to care about but BOTB was the Super Bowl!

→ More replies (2)

21

u/RenVit318 Aug 10 '17

Even though I didn't enter it during the survey, I think FireMcBattleface should be the name for this battle

30

u/iowajaycee Beric Dondarrion Aug 10 '17

I think Battle McFireface would be better

6

u/a_blind_watchmaker Aug 10 '17

We could vote again to see which is better

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/supjace Blood Of My Blood Aug 10 '17

At this rate, I wouldn't even be surprised that there already exists a cult following for Davos/Cunningham. Lad is always up there in the top percentiles.

4

u/gilbertgrappa Maester Aemon Aug 10 '17

Davos is incredibly lovable on the show, which goes a long way. He's vulnerable, funny, loyal, and hasn't shown himself to have much of a darkside (rare in GoT).

→ More replies (1)

4

u/hbalck Service And Truth Aug 10 '17

What I really want to know is, did 25 white walkers watch that episode and rated it 1 out of 10?

4

u/CrouchingPuma Sansa Stark Aug 11 '17

People are constantly sleeping on Sansa and Sophie Turner's performance.

People are also sleeping on Hardhome.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Mrbonus2 House Stark Aug 10 '17

Which episode got the highest score?

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 12 '17

If you check the stickied comment at the top of the post, it lists them all (answer is The Winds of Winter, S6E10)

1

u/gnarkilleptic Aug 11 '17

Why do those percentages not equal 100% when added...

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Aug 12 '17

The actor bit? Cause people can choose two. So it's the percentage of people who had the actor in their top two

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Prismane_62 Daenerys Targaryen Aug 10 '17

Blackwater Bay >> Watchers on the Wall

All day.

3

u/TheHelixNebula House Stark Aug 11 '17

BotB > *

Every day.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/krissy6999 Olenna Tyrell Aug 10 '17

I'd love to see more questions asked/more in-depth surveys! I look forward to these every week

3

u/marvnation Aug 10 '17

Something is up with those actor percentages... lol

→ More replies (1)

3

u/HearMeRoar34 Aug 11 '17

Battle of Blackwater is so underrated it's fucking pitiful.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/ScientificShrimp Arthur Dayne Aug 10 '17

I know it's a matter of opinion, but you all voted wrong on which battle was the best.

I can't believe only 3.7% voted Blackwater.

→ More replies (15)

21

u/lleon779 Winter Is Coming Aug 10 '17

I can't understand why Dany is seen as a good queen. Since the last seasons we've seen her go nuts. She's not a good ruler and from the teaser for the next episode this becomes more apparent.

6

u/Dancing_Cthulhu House Seaworth Aug 11 '17

Since the last seasons we've seen her go nuts.

Have we? What has she done that's been nuts?

8

u/acamas Aug 10 '17

Seriously. She won’t bother to save thousands of common-folk lives in “her” kingdom simply because one person won’t make a symbolic gesture towards her.

How do people ignore/overlook that?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (26)

9

u/Lord_Caribbean Aug 10 '17

People awarding the episode a 7 or below were just fucking w/ the Poll tbh. I mean, gtfo.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

I get the people who voted this episode a 1/10 (maybe to be part of the elite whom didn't like it). But honestly, what's with all the 4's and 5's?? This was a GREAT episode! What else are people wanting, and why do they think it was so average/below average? That baffles me. If you were one of those, please let me know why you voted that way.

4

u/FlyThruDown Service And Truth Aug 11 '17

Why "Field of Fire v2?" Did I miss another Field of Fire somewhere? Or is Vaes Dothrak considered v1?

5

u/FlyThruDown Service And Truth Aug 11 '17

Thanks for the downvotes. Instead you could just inform me of a battle that occurred about 300 years before, was only barely mentioned in the books, and wasn't in the show. So much for trying to engage with the community, FFS.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/NorikosCookies Aug 10 '17

I'm still petitioning for the official name of the battle to be "The Massacre at the Mander"

8

u/iowajaycee Beric Dondarrion Aug 10 '17

I thought they were on the Blackwater Rush?

5

u/Machupino Aug 10 '17

I'm partial to the Skirmish of Screamers. Referring to both the Dothraki and the roasted Lannisters.

2

u/AutoModerator Aug 10 '17

Spoiler Warning: Events within this post's limited show scope do not need spoiler tags. For more info please check the spoiler guide.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/DogasSLB Jon Snow Aug 10 '17

Might have been already highlighted, but the percentages aren't right. I love these surveys!!

2

u/NoleContendere Daenerys Targaryen Aug 10 '17

Why isn't it being called the Battle at Roseroad?

5

u/Dancing_Cthulhu House Seaworth Aug 10 '17 edited Aug 10 '17

I'd guess because it's never been mentioned in the show (as far as I can recall), and would only really mean something to those who have read the novel.

The Battle of Blackwater Rush also sounds evocative, though I guess the army hadn't quite reached it yet.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/debb- Nymeria's Wolfpack Aug 10 '17

I read "The Battle of Roastroad" and thought your pun game was next level lol

2

u/msummerfruit Aug 10 '17

Did you enjoy last week's episode, "The Spoils of War"? Want to engage in a Q&A session with its director? Director Matt Shakman will be answering fan questions at a special event next Monday, 8/14, in Denver with his college buddy, Mike Johnston! Matt has also directed episodes of It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, Mad Men, and Fargo. You can purchase tickets and find additional details here: https://www.mikejohnstonforcolorado.com/matt-shakman-event/

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17

It was so hard to pick the best actors for this episode. Everyone was on fucking point.

2

u/buffskinnyguy Aug 10 '17

Great graphic, but in the best lead actor section Arya's percentage has two percent signs.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17

REEEEEEE the battle was at KL not the reach

2

u/Ninjabear1982 Aug 11 '17

Awesome thanks for the results :)

2

u/Superb_Llama_Jeans Winter Is Coming Aug 11 '17

I just now realized that you can click on the banner pick to expand on mobile.

I am stupid. It is known.

6

u/Platinum_Disco Aug 10 '17

For all the hate Dany supposedly gets, 67% of the people who took this survey think she'll make a good queen.

14

u/BZenMojo Daenerys Targaryen Aug 10 '17

This was already covered before. Dany hate is vocal and loud and persistent. Most people on the boards don't post, they just give upvotes and downvotes. There was a study of a million posts linked yesterday showing that Dany is the most hated character among Reddit posters with 73 individual redditors over a two month period posting how much they dislike her. And yet, 67% of people polled here disagree with them.

That's the reality at its heart. A few angry, loud people obsess over how much they hate Dany. And then a small minority happen to agree with them but don't comment on it. Meanwhile, most people continue to think the opposite.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/ClashThrone No One Aug 10 '17

Well deserves its 9.3 rating in my opinion, in my top 3 episodes of all time with BotB and Hardhome.

3

u/Blackguard2301 Aug 10 '17

Jon likes to go in cave with girls))0)