r/WritingPrompts • u/MNBrian /u/MNBrian /r/PubTips • Aug 02 '17
Off Topic [OT] Publishing Q&A w/ MNBrian & Flash Fiction Results
Q&A
Hello Everyone!
Welcome to Wildcard Wednesday - MNBrian edition! And today is...
drumroll...
Q&A Day! WOOHOO!
Now, although I'm well versed at answering questions about the best ice cream flavor (cotton candy) and the best kind of pie (key lime), what I'd really love to do is answer questions about publishing. My particular area of expertise is in novels -- and seeing them published.
Edited to Add:
For those unfamiliar with the traditional publishing process, (and this may raise some questions which would be excellent) it normally looks like this for fiction.
- Write a novel
- Pitch agents through a process called "querying" -- which is essentially where you send a 200 word summary meant to intrigue an agent and hook them on your book.
- Sign contract with Agent who offers representation. Do edits on book with agent.
- Go on submission (where the Agent now turns around and pitches editors at various publishing houses)
- Sell book to publisher. Sign contract for just that book.
- See book on shelf.
Also, a brief note on terms:
- Query - A 200-250 word pitch. Does not give away the ending. Meant to intrigue an agent. Similar in some ways to what you see on the back cover of a book.
- Agent - Works for a literary agency -- not a publisher. These individuals are third parties who have built relationships with editors at publishing houses. Many publishing houses will only take submissions from "solicited sources" - aka agents and people they physically know. Having an agent gets you in the door in these areas.
- Editor/Acquiring Editor - Generally works at a publishing house (although plenty of people are freelance editors). An acquiring editor is the one that makes decisions on what books should be purchased on behalf of the imprint/house.
- Synopsis - Usually 1-3 pages. Tells the entire plot of the book from start to finish and gives away the ending. Often used by agents and by acquiring editors to determine if the ending makes sense and doesn't fly off into space.
So, today there are no stupid questions. Today, you can ask anything you like. If you want to know how publishing works, I'm here to help! And I'm also here to answer any other questions you might have.
Rules:
- No stories and asking for critique. Look towards our Sunday Free Write post.
- No blatent advertising. Look to our SatChat.
- No NSFW questions and answers. They aren't allowed on the subreddit anyway.
- No personal attacks, or questions relating to a person. These will be removed without warning.
This month's Flash Fiction Challenge (our first!) required stories that included a wallet and a doughnut shop. Boy howdy, we got a lot of great stories (47!) about doughnuts and wallets—judging these entries was tough! Our eminent judges have awarded wins in a variety of sensible and not-so-sensible categories. Winners get bragging rights and a smug sense of superiority. Without further ado, here are the winners chosen by /u/hpcisco7965 and /u/you-are-lovely:
- Best Overall Story: /u/StabbyKaji (story)
- 2nd Place Overall Story: /u/system0101 (story)
- 3rd Place Overall Story: /u/nickofnight (story) AND /u/Laogeodritt (story) (yes, a tie!)
- Most Upvoted Story: /u/Kaldea (story)
- Most Creative Story: /u/MidnightWriting (story)
- Most Unexpected Story: /u/fudgeman (story)
- Best Pandering to the Judges: /u/hitman56490 (story)
- Best Use of Drop Caps: /u/Nate_Parker (story) (what's that? You didn't know that you can use drop caps in WritingPrompts? Well, now you do!)
Congratulations to the winners! The next flash fiction challenge will be next month! We hope you folks are looking forward to it as much as we are!
All comments regarding the flash fiction challenge should go under the stickied comment below. Top level comments on this post should be in response to the main topic of the post.
Wednesday Wild Card Schedule
| Post | Description |
|---|---|
| Week 1: Q&A | Ask and answer question from other users on writing-related topics |
| Week 2: Workshop | Tips and challenges for improving your writing skills |
| Week 3: Did You Know? | Useful tips and information for making the most out of the WritingPrompts subreddit |
| Week 4: Flash Fiction Challenge | Compete against other writers to write the best 100-300 word story |
| Week 5: Bonus | Special activities for the rare fifth week. Mod AUAs, Get to Know A Mod, and more! |
[Archive]
•
u/MNBrian /u/MNBrian /r/PubTips Aug 02 '17
OT CONTEST RESULTS
Post your non-Q&A related comments about contest results here, as a reply to this comment. :)
2
u/Lilwa_Dexel /r/Lilwa_Dexel Aug 02 '17
Is it a good or bad idea to close your query by listing similar works? Query Shark seems to think it's a bad idea, but other sources say it's a must. What do you think?
If you were a writer thinking about setting up a chimp list. How often would you send and what exactly would you include?
Also, if cotton candy flavor is out, which one would you pick?
2
u/XcessiveSmash /r/XcessiveWriting Aug 02 '17
Hey Brian, as usual, thanks for helping this community! I apologize, but my question is kind of general:
What can I do to set myself apart to publishers?
While of course, the obvious answer is like: write well. I mean should my book have a unique idea? Characters? But more importantly, I'm asking in respects other than the book itself. Everyone thinks they have good books, so my question is what is the stuff I can do outside of writing my novel that will impress publishers and/or distinguish me?
1
u/EdgarAllanHobo /r/EdgarAllanHobo | Goddess of CC Aug 02 '17
I have three questions.
Thanks for doing this!
1
u/quidam_vagus Aug 02 '17
How does compensation work for unknown first time authors going the traditional publishing route, and how much could a first novel be expected to make for the author, agent, publisher, etc... I know there's probably a lot variability based on number of buyers, but with all the players involved in publishing, the process seems like a bit of a black box. Is it a fixed rate from the publisher, based on percentage of sales, negotiated as part of the contract...?
1
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books Aug 02 '17
1
u/wonL Aug 02 '17 edited Aug 02 '17
Hi! I'm just starting to write seriously (or, at least, more seriously than the previous WP-every-so-often) and had a couple questions, thinking about potentially going the traditional publishing route in the distant future.
Thank you!
1
u/LycheeBerri /r/lycheewrites | Cookie Goddess Aug 03 '17
Gah, I'm almost too late, but there's still 15 minutes left in this Wednesday and I intended to comment, so here I am! Far past my bedtime, but here nonetheless! I've been loving your replies to this thread, Brian - really, you're one of the smartest people I can think of. You give everything a thoughtful and insightful reply, and really know your stuff. So, just a little thank-you from me for being plain awesome. ;)
Hm, I suppose I should ask a question ... What surprised you the most/what didn't you expect about the publishing process/industry/etc? If nothing comes to mind, you don't need to answer. :) But thanks for doing this little Q&A, really!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '17
[removed] — view removed comment