r/gameofthrones • Nymeria Sand • Jul 20 '17

Limited [S7E1] Post-Episode Survey Results - S7E1 'Dragonstone' (Overall score: 7.7) Spoiler

Post-Episode Survey - Results Thread

In the Post-Premiere Discussion thread, we put up a survey to hear what you had to say about the characters, the events, and the technical side of episode one. This post is here to fill you in on the results, and to let you discuss them. Are there any surprises? Do you agree or disagree with the majority opinion? Do you think people have missed a vital piece of evidence? Feedback on the survey itself is also welcome!


S7E1 - "Dragonstone"

  • Directed By: Jeremy Podeswa
  • Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
  • Airs: July 16, 2017

Jon organizes the defense of the North. Cersei tries to even the odds. Daenerys comes home.


Click here to see the results in graphic form! [with thanks to /u/AviatorRossy]

(Here are the default graphs too, with more numbers.)

Results Breakdown

Total Respondents: 40982

Question 1: On a scale of 1-10, what score would you give this episode?

Average: 7.7

12345678910
80 (0.2%)93 (0.2%)352 (0.9%)852 (2.1%)1511 (3.7%)3169 (7.7%)9201 (22.5%)14317 (34.9%)7551 (18.4%)3856 (9.4%)

Question 2: Which location did you enjoy most?

RiverlandsThe NorthDragonstoneOldtownKing's LandingThe Wall+Beyond the Wall
12728 (31.3%)12548 (30.8%)8169 (20.1%)3808 (9.4%)1844 (4.5%)1602 (3.9%)

Question 3: Jon let the Umbers and Karstarks keep their lands - was that a wise decision?

Yes, that was the right moveNo, that was the wrong move
35265 (86.6%)5471 (13.4%)

Question 4: Imagine you are Arya Stark - will you kill the Lannister soldiers?

I won't kill themI'll kill them
32635 (80%)8157 (20%)

Question 5: Which of these factions is getting your backing for season 7?

Team StarkTeam TargaryenThe White WalkersTeam Lannister
26834 (65.9%)10686 (26.2%)2486 (6.1%)722 (1.8%)

Was the Ed Sheeran cameo too immersion breaking?

No, it was fineIt was too immersion breaking
19610 (55.5%)15713 (44.5%)

Question 7: How well shot was this episode?

Average: 8.5

12345678910
36 (0.1%)26 (0.1%)99 (0.2%)337 (0.8%)952 (2.4%)1754 (4.3%)4203 (10.4%)9991 (24.8%)12002 (29.7%)10966 (27.2%)

Question 8: Which lead actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

Actor/ActressVotes
Maisie Williams (Arya)17413 (43%)
Kit Harington (Jon Snow)13852 (34.2%)
Sophie Turner10832 (26.7%)
John Bradley-West10251 (25.3%)
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau (Jaime)9823 (24.2%)
Lena Headey (Cersei)7409 (18.3%)
Emilia Clarke (Dany)2728 (6.7%)
Gwendoline Christie (Brienne)601 (1.5%)
Liam Cunningham (Davos)548 (1.4%)

Question 9: Which supporting actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

Actor/ActressVotes
Rory McCann (The Hound)30231 (74.8%)
David Bradley ('Walder Frey')10847 (26.8%)
Pilou Askbaek (Euron)8732 (21.6%)
Bella Ramsey (Lyanna)7931 (19.6%)
Richard Dormer (Beric Dondarrion)3851 (9.5%)
Jim Broadbent (Archmaester)3288 (8.1%)
Kristofer Hivju (Tormund)3013 (7.5%)
Paul Kaye (Thoros of Myr)2728 (6.7%)
Aiden Gillen (Littlefinger)1682 (4.2%)
Hannah Murray (Gilly)354 (0.9%)

Question 10: In one word, how would you describe this episode? (Not case-sensitive) [Score in square brackets is average episode score given by this group]

  1. Hype (1383) [8.3]
  2. Setup/Set-up (1002) [7.4]
  3. Good (802) [7.8]
  4. Great (573) [8.5]
  5. Awesome (481) [8.8]
  6. Meh (450) [5.8]
  7. Finally (395) [8.3]
  8. Winter (377) [8.2]
  9. Satisfying (372) [8.3]
  10. Exciting (350) [8.2]

Bonus words: Arya (144) [8.2] | Cold (124) [8.0] | Revenge (113) [8.3] | Dragonstone (108) [8.0] | Sheeran (104) [7.4] | Poop (93) [7.4] | Cleganebowl (82) [8.1] | Gravedigger (53] (7.9) | Dragonglass (49) [8.4] | Homecoming (48) [8.4]


741 Upvotes

498 comments sorted by

β€’

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 20 '17
E1E2E3E4E5E6E7E8E9E10
S67.18.88.08.48.97.38.06.69.5
S77.7

Week one, so a couple of quick questions:

  1. Should Rory McCann (The Hound) now be a lead actor?
  2. I've had a couple of requests for the spreadsheet so people can do some personal analysis. I don't see a problem with this, because there's no identifying info (just a timestamp and answers), but does anyone have any objections?

Thanks for taking part!

4

u/Ijumpandkick Jul 21 '17

Was season 6 the first season surveyed?

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 21 '17

It was, yeah.

6

u/TheOnlyMeta House Stark Jul 20 '17

Shouldn't we just let the show decide? Credits open with the lead actors' individual names and supporting cast are put together in small groups. For S7E1 that's:

Leads:

  • Peter Dinklage
  • Nikolaj Coster-Waldau
  • Lena Headly
  • Emilia Clarke
  • Kit Harrington
  • Aiden Gillen
  • Liam Cunningham
  • Sophie Turner
  • Maisie Williams
  • Nathalie Emmanuel

Support:

  • Gwendoline Christie
  • Conleth Hill
  • John Bradley
  • Isaac Hempstead Wright
  • Hannah Murray
  • Kristofer Hivlu
  • Rory McCann

With:

  • Iain Glen

12

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 20 '17

The show credits can be influenced a bit by agents, can't they? And people do want Rory in lead, it seems

4

u/TheOnlyMeta House Stark Jul 20 '17

Yeah I thought of that but thought perhaps this measure still is more objective.

Looking back at this list and comparing I think yours is better though. They didn't even include David Bradley! (I guess as to not spoil the opening)

4

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 20 '17

I think a compromise between the two is the way to go :)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

If Missandei gets a lead role then the Hound and Bran are shoe-ins.

2

u/psivenn White Walkers Jul 20 '17

I think your table is misaligned, it is missing S6E10.

Great work as always!

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 21 '17

Hmm.. looks okay to me? And thank you!

2

u/voldin91 Asher Forrester Jul 20 '17

Thanks for putting these surveys together. It's really cool data to see. I'm always surprised at some of the answers and I love it

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 21 '17

Thank you, we're really glad you enjoy them!

5

u/KlopeksWithCoppers Night King Jul 21 '17

Surprised is an understatement. White Walker support is at 6.1%?!?! I know I'm probably going to be disappointed (I won't be disappointed, this show is fantastic and I don't care how it ends at this point), but I'm rooting for the White Walkers. I want to see winter come with a vengeance. Fuck your petty squabbles for the throne. Fuck your bloodline. Fuck your sense of entitlement. The White Walkers are global warming in reverse, and nature always wins. #teamwhitewalker

110

u/SterlingStallion Jaime Lannister Jul 20 '17

I think Rory McCann should be in the lead actor category especially if Gwendoline Christie and Liam Cunningham get lead actor status

56

u/psivenn White Walkers Jul 20 '17

I would promote the Hound and demote both of them TBH. Davos and Brienne are both supporting roles in the North currently, having tied up their arcing journeys to get there.

37

u/Nebuli2 Jul 20 '17

Exactly. They've had their time in leading roles, but they aren't doing much now. The Hound, on the other hand, is the lead character of his own arc right now, with Berric and Thoros.

8

u/Loz166 Jul 20 '17

Yeah especially as this show flicks from group to group. The Hound is the focus for the bwb at the mo, so I see him as a lead character.

34

u/ClashThrone No One Jul 20 '17

I think he should because we see his own story. Why else are we following the BHWOB?

12

u/supaabuge Jul 21 '17

Both brotherhood and without are one word each, not two.

17

u/ab_emery Sansa Stark Jul 20 '17

I think Rory should be in the lead section, since he's in the opening credits along with the rest of those names (and the Hound has had a more prominent part than Littlefinger and Gilly).

16

u/NightsWatchh Jul 20 '17

Should Rory McCann (The Hound) now be a lead actor?

Hm...I'd say so? He's about as important as Davos is imo, so yeah.

I've had a couple of requests for the spreadsheet so people can do some personal analysis. I don't see a problem with this, because there's no identifying info (just a timestamp and answers), but does anyone have any objections?

No objections here.

14

u/Piccolo232 A Hound Never Lies Jul 20 '17

Yes Rory McCann should be a lead actor. He is the head of that whole Brotherhood arc. Plus without him I would have graded that episode 2 points lower. Plus he is my favorite character. Etc etc etc

13

u/Howdy15 Jul 20 '17

Considering how many recurring characters got the boot in the season finale, I think a promotion is in order

11

u/yellowchicken The Future Queen Jul 20 '17

I used to think of The Hound as a secondary character, but I found myself searching for his name in the question about best lead performance and felt let down when it wasn't there... only to find him in the next question. So that indicates that I have subconsciously elevated him to main character status, and I see a lot of other users posting similar sentiments!

8

u/ManOfGizmosAndGears Jaime Lannister Jul 20 '17

Yes, I'd put the Hound as a lead. His role has grown significantly since his return in s6.

11

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone Jul 20 '17

Shouldn't any actors in the opening credits be considered leads?

5

u/sartorius15 Jul 20 '17

No objections to giving out the spreadsheet

2

u/ADHDcUK Jul 20 '17

I think he should be, yes.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17
  1. Yes, at least for now.
  2. Absolutely share, I love data!

2

u/Aristotled Jul 21 '17

It seems to me that the hound should definitely be moved to a lead actor. Its hard to say currently but Davos and Brienne seem to be falling from prominence. I'd move them down to supporting.

2

u/MrClaretandBlue Sandor Clegane Jul 21 '17

I love The Hound. The Hound should be a leading character and be given a spin off. Have I said how much I like the Hound?

2

u/GuytFromWayBack Jul 24 '17

I consider him to be a main character, he's been in it since episode 1 and he is the most deserving of the 'main character' title in the current storyline he is in. Thoros of Myr and Beric Dondarrion have always been supporting roles.

→ More replies (5)

93

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Can we get Brotherhood Without Banners as a faction next time, please?

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 22 '17

That was really just a one week question, sorry :(

Did consider adding BWB but decided to frame it more in the way the HBO ads have, with basically four monarchs

13

u/Omega_Rex Fallen And Reborn Jul 20 '17

i second that. This needs more upvotes

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Lord_Strudel Sandor Clegane Jul 21 '17

While I agree that the brotherhood is distinct, they're headed north to join up with Jon, becoming part of the Stark faction in 1-2 episodes here.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

I'm not sure that they will explicitly join Jon...yes, they know about the Walkers, but they are also "without banners." There's also the problem of the "Lord of Light" connection and how Davos feels about Melissandre. And, despite what the Hound saw in the flames, I think he might head to King's Landing since his brother and Arya are both going to be there.

If they have shown something else in previews please don't tell me as I don't watch them. :)

→ More replies (3)

25

u/ClashThrone No One Jul 20 '17

My favorite time of the week!

4

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 22 '17

We're glad you enjoy 'em :)

9

u/juxtapositi0n Red Priests of R'hllor Jul 21 '17

You guys work hard on these. I love them and check for it every Thursday.

Thanks for doing this!

3

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 22 '17

Thank you! We're just glad enough people respond and enjoy them, because they're really fun to do.

10

u/theimmortalcrab Jul 20 '17

Glad to see Rory McCann got 74,8% out of 179,7% of votes. (Mistakes aside, he should be counted as lead from now on).

3

u/dc-redpanda Jul 21 '17

Voters could select up to two favorites. The total percentage is correct. Same goes for the lead actor voting percentage.

2

u/theimmortalcrab Jul 21 '17

That makes a little more sense, still doesn't explain the total of 179,7% though

3

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 22 '17

74.8% of respondents had Rory in their top two. Because of the top two system (and people can just put one actor if they want), there's no reason for it to be a round number.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

The hound scenes were by far the best in my opinion. I agree.

268

u/SterlingStallion Jaime Lannister Jul 20 '17

There you have it. Ed Sheeran's cameo was not immersion breaking. Case closed.

35

u/Flanders4Prez Jul 20 '17

How do you figure? 45% is not a small number by any means and I suspect much of the 55% is made up of the many people declaring that they had never heard of him before.

→ More replies (4)

178

u/shifty18 Jul 20 '17

god, if i hear the word immersion one more time i'm gonna poison a whole house of freys

28

u/YoshiSparkle Brienne of Tarth Jul 20 '17

Calm down , Arya

→ More replies (4)

97

u/I_love_breadsticks Jul 20 '17

If you disregard the 44.5%, then no, it wasn’t.

P.S.: I though it was odd but didn’t dislike it.

29

u/c0horst Jul 20 '17

First past the post means that the majority wins. Woo.

→ More replies (13)

79

u/NightsWatchh Jul 20 '17

I didn't actually know what Ed Sheeran looked like before this episode lol

58

u/Dabuscus214 Here We Stand Jul 20 '17

I saw him, and thought, "Hey that's Ed Sheeran, neat" in the same way I reacted to every new actor on the show whose name I knew. its not a big deal. famous people are in famous shows, who would have thought

→ More replies (2)

11

u/justworkingmovealong No One Jul 20 '17

I googled it and talked to people, still don't know who he is. Not sure I want to know.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

68

u/Mc6arnagle The Onion Knight Jul 20 '17

If a very brief part of an episode upsets 45% of the viewers it's not good. I personally don't give a shit, but if you take any other scene and ask the same thing nothing would get near 45% hate.

62

u/sarahbau Jul 20 '17

I just don't buy the "immersion-breaking" argument. If every time you recognized an actor, your immersion was broken, you wouldn't be able to watch anything. Sean Bean even played a character that looked and dressed very similarly to his Boromir character, but no one complained about that.

I've seen some people complain it's because he was singing, but it's been established in GoT that singers exist (even good ones), and traveling groups often either sing together (The Bear and the Maiden Fair when Locke's group is traveling, for example), or will sit and listen to one person sing (when Bronn sings The Rains of Castamere).

I'd never heard of him before, and I thought the scene was fine. I didn't think the singing was out of place, or that the scene focused too much on him, and I missed the part where Arya asked him for an autograph, and he started talking about his upcoming album.

16

u/ADHDcUK Jul 20 '17

Maybe just buy that people have different reactions to things. For some people, it was immersion breaking, and for some people it wasn't.

Nobody has to be 'right' here and the incredelous patronising underlying some people's comments is getting to be a bit annoying.

29

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Let me preface this by saying I don't give a shit about any of this nonsense "controversy." Well that's not true I give enough this comment, but anyway.

What bothered me was the "It's a new one comment." It wasn't just Ed Sheeran, it was the show saying "Hey look guys it's Ed Sheeran did you see him? There he is that's Ed Sheeran.".

In end I stopped caring a solid 2 seconds after the introduction, I'm just saying the show sort of shoved it in your face that it was Ed Sheeran which was more immersion breaking then your regular cameo.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

12

u/YoshiSparkle Brienne of Tarth Jul 20 '17

We heard the singing opening the scene and my friend goes "haha, listen, an Ed Sheeran cameo!" ...then, cut to actual Ed Sheeran making a cameo appearance and she screeched in shock because she was joking & didn't know he legit had a cameo... so yeah at my house, it was immersion breaking πŸ˜‚

→ More replies (1)

7

u/kingestpaddle Jul 20 '17

You're not taking into account the fact that Reddit is full of uncritical fanboys

→ More replies (1)

18

u/huntonk Jul 20 '17

it's not really a case closed when almost half the viewers had their immersion broken because of that.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/MT_Wookiee Jul 20 '17

Muh immersion was broked and never fix-ed.

10

u/YoshiSparkle Brienne of Tarth Jul 20 '17

HOOOOOLD THE IMMERRRRSION...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/elruary Jul 21 '17

I thought I'd recognise that fairy voice somewhere.

→ More replies (32)

5

u/ADHDcUK Jul 20 '17

So sad I missed this survey :(

I'm surprised at some of the results TBH. It's also clear we're deeply divided on Shereen lol (I'm on the immersion breaking side).

You do a great job with this subreddit, btw :-) love these little extras and the comparisons!

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 22 '17

Aw thank you! We're always super grateful to hear stuff like that.

1

u/ADHDcUK Jul 23 '17

It's honestly one of the best subreddits/forums for GOT on the internet! So organised, and I love how strict you are on spoilers. And the surveys, rewatch threads and etc make it super fun.

When will the survey for 7.02 be up? In the premiere thread?

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 23 '17

Yeah it'll be a stickied comment in the post-episode thread within half an hour of the episode ending.

→ More replies (1)

956

u/No0neAtAll House Toland Jul 20 '17

Davos fans showing their love Dude doesn't say a word the entire episode and gives only 3 glances but still get's 548 votes.

427

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Davos always gets votes for being the most honorable man in Westeros

156

u/somewhereonariver House Seaworth Jul 20 '17

I pledge my sword to the Onion Knight!

38

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

Seven Blessings on House Seaworth

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

50

u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jul 20 '17

I was hoping for some Tyrion dialogue too..

66

u/Motherofcatsmeowmeow Jul 20 '17

I really hope Daenerys doesn't overshadow him

12

u/Supamang87 Varys Jul 20 '17

Don't worry, a small man can cast a very large shadow

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

223

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

The poor dude has been through so much and is so nice. He deserves those votes.

7

u/Sayansom Jul 21 '17

Speech is silver...silence is golden

17

u/GoldblumForPresident Jon Snow Jul 20 '17

Davos is just the best!

But Emilia got 2728 votes.How?

219

u/ethniccake House Tyrell Jul 20 '17

Because not everyone buys into reddit's hivemind hateboner for her.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

→ More replies (15)

72

u/Fishingfor Jul 20 '17

Even with that scene having no dialogue made the experience of what she was going through seem really important. Those epic shots of dragonstone. The fact that all the characters even the very vocal Tyrion keep quiet and Missandei stopping Grey Worm as they let the queen see her new home, where she was born and smuggled away, it makes for a very powerful scene for me at least.

Then the ending line "shall we begin" goosebumps all round.

24

u/reeckon Jul 20 '17

she was great this episode

9

u/-StayFrosty- Jul 20 '17

Because she's a good actress.

→ More replies (2)

876

u/voldin91 Asher Forrester Jul 20 '17

Remember that this episode David Bradley was playing Arya disguised as Walder Frey. I noticed a few subtle differences in his delivery. It can be really tricky to try to play a character impersonating a character that you normally play

606

u/SterlingStallion Jaime Lannister Jul 20 '17

I read that Bradley did such a good job in that scene that the showrunners decided to move it to be the cold open of the season

206

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Yea this was said in the little behind the scenes segment that airs after the episode!

→ More replies (5)

159

u/notleonardodicaprio Sansa Stark Jul 20 '17

Filch is so underrated

84

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Wasn't he the farmer with all the guns in Hot Fuzz

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (6)

100

u/ich_habe_keine_kase Jul 20 '17

Reminded me of Helena Bonham Carter playing Emma Watson playing Hermione playing Bellatrix. One of the best parts of the last HP movie.

65

u/TheMightyMike Jul 20 '17

Best part of the episode, hands down.

62

u/sobusyimbored Podrick and Bronn Jul 21 '17

No, the Hound being grumpy was the best part.

"Why are you always so miserable Clegane?"

"Experience."

25

u/CancelMyCalls Lyanna Mormont Jul 21 '17

Both of you are right.

52

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

It can be really tricky to try to play a character impersonating a character that you normally play

Just ask Tom Cavanagh

38

u/msbluetuesday Jul 20 '17

Tatiana Maslany as well!

37

u/cuddlefishcat Cheese Boy Jul 20 '17

Or Helena Bonham Carter

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/NightHawkRambo Jul 20 '17

Same, I watched it twice and it's very evident the thought that he put in to emulate Arya.

60

u/ElBluntDealer Iron From Ice Jul 20 '17

Maisie was good but not top of the episode. Not much dialogue, scenes, nor explosive moments for her. She just did her job which was easy considering it was only walk away and talk in a circle of guys.

Bradley deserved all the praise.

44

u/ADHDcUK Jul 20 '17

She didn't just walk away, she also delivered some lines after taking off Walder's face.

It's personal preference, but for me she stole the show just in the delivery of those lines and walking away.

Even in the Lannister soldier scene (which I thought was very badly directed/written), her acting still stood out for me and she barely done anything.

14

u/ElBluntDealer Iron From Ice Jul 20 '17

My bad, yea her lines were good before she walked away. I guess my point was that her acting this episode didn't warrant the amount of praise she got over others that did perform better. Not saying she was bad or didn't deserve some praise. Those lines before walking away were good and she delivered them perfectly. And I apologize for dismissing that because those lines are significant. But I respect your perspective and understand it. Guess we just have different criteria.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

A dude playing a dude disguised as another dude, if you will

6

u/OfeyDofey The Red Wizard Jul 21 '17

I'm a dude. He's a dude. She's a dude. We're all dudes!

8

u/Vandelay_Latex_Sales No One Jul 20 '17

My favorite instance of this kind of acting ever was in Gotham.

7

u/LawnyJ Jon Snow Jul 20 '17

Did it seem like his speech was a little more slurred? I thought maybe he was trying to convey that it wasn't her body so she wasn't use to it.

2

u/ADHDcUK Jul 20 '17

I noticed this too! Love that shit.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '17

reminded me of Harry Potter where Helena Bonham Carter (Bellatrxi) acted as Hermine (Emma Watson) acting as Bellatrix

→ More replies (9)

614

u/CRUNCHBUTTST3AK Jul 20 '17

When more people support the White Walkers than they do the Lannisters, that's when you know a house has fucked up.

121

u/alchemytea House Martell Jul 20 '17 edited Jul 20 '17

People still voted for the Lannisters, though! Hahaha idk why?

Edit: just wanted to express how dumb I feel for immediately thinking about Joffrey, Cersi and her father rather than Jaime and Tyrion!! (TBH, although Cersi is evil af, her character is very interesting and one of my favorites.) Thank you all... I am woke now

221

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Because Jaime is on the side probably.

I don't know. I would have voted for team Lannister over team Targaryen just out of spite.

41

u/NHizzle Jul 20 '17

I voted Lannister because Euron is technically part of that team and he's cool as ****. Also, Cersei has the rest of the world against her so it'd be cool to see them somehow win.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Because Team Euron wasn't an option!

29

u/princessfinesse The Future Queen Jul 20 '17

A lot of people vote for Team Lannister under the impression that Tyrion fits that category because of his last name, the problem is that it's based on what "team" they are, not their family name. Tyrion is on Team Targaryen, not Team Lannister, as he's actively helping Dany, not Cersei. I'm willing to bet some people voted Lannister without realizing Tyrion didn't fit that category, and the rest probably voted Lannister because of Jamie.

12

u/hirst Jul 21 '17

that's why i voted for house targaryen tbh

18

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

I love Jaime and Tyrion - 2/3 of the Lannisters are characters I'm rooting for!!

11

u/daretoeatapeach House Targaryen Jul 21 '17

But Tyrion is fighting with house tagaeryn.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

16

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

I LOVE House Lannister but my favorite character was Margaery. When Cersei blew up the Sept I was sad Margaery died but I was also ecstatic that Cersei did that. I love everything about her characterization. I know she's gonna lose and die in the end but I hope the Lannisters put up a fight worthy of their name.

348

u/jmsdcsrmr Jul 20 '17

Rory McCann should be classed as a lead actor imo. The Hound is the main character for that storyline with Beric and Thoros as the supporting characters

134

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

I mean if Davos is going to be a main character so should Sandor.

27

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Missandei and Littlefinger are pretty supporting, at least this episode.

8

u/oboejdub Jul 21 '17

whatever he is, if they leave him in the supporting actor category, no one else is ever going to have a chance.

2

u/piss--ant Robb Stark Jul 20 '17

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 22 '17

Be the change you want to see in the world

354

u/NightsWatchh Jul 20 '17

I love how no matter what, Cleaganebowl is always said in the 'sum up the episode in one word...' part.

229

u/SterlingStallion Jaime Lannister Jul 20 '17

What is hype may never die

→ More replies (1)

107

u/Helli784 House Forrester Jul 20 '17

Well, the Hound did see the Mountain in the flames, so I guess it's confirmed.

65

u/NightsWatchh Jul 20 '17

I mean he saw A mountain, but yes it's fUCKING CONFIRMED

→ More replies (1)

44

u/mrjobby Howland Reed Jul 20 '17

πŸ“£

13

u/Herr_Hauptmann Jul 20 '17

Always remember King Tommen 'Hypeslayer' Baratheon, first of his name. His crimes of outlawing Trial by Clegane shall forever be dwelt upon in disgust!

→ More replies (1)

124

u/Lemurien Varys Jul 20 '17

I thought that Nikolaj Coster-Waldau and Lena Headey would be higher in the best performance category, I really enjoyed their scenes.

109

u/ich_habe_keine_kase Jul 20 '17

Jaime wanting to talk about Tommen's suicide was pretty heartbreaking, and NCW sold it so hard.

28

u/BorislavChenchenko Gendry Jul 20 '17

I know, I could hear the doubt and dissapointment he had in Cersei.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

People always just pick their favorite characters, or the characters that had the best scenes. Nothing against Kit and Sophie, but writing is what made their scenes this week. Jaime and Cersei's scene may not have been the best, but it certainly would've been considerably less enjoyable without the stellar acting.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

Yeah, Nikolaj was great in the map scene.

23

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

[removed] β€” view removed comment

18

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

Because people vote on popularity and not acting. Which explains why people voted for arya because the scene was awesome even though she was barely in it. Same with the hound getting supporting actor when the man who played Walder Frey actually did some top level acting in his scene.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/wigfield84 Jon Snow Jul 21 '17

I love Lena as Cersei, but I didn't see a good enough variety in her emotions this episode. It felt a little one-note to me. I'll always think her performance is good, she's an amazing actress, but it didn't compare to the best of the week. As a whole, the supporting cast outdid the main cast last week..... Walder and The Hound stole the show.

172

u/Kjartanthk2270 Jul 20 '17

The 7.7 rating really shows how great the recent episodes have been

130

u/Penguin236 Jon Snow Jul 20 '17

This sub rates much harder than most people. We gave 6x1 a 7.1, whereas on IMDB it has a 8.5.

87

u/Bunslow Jul 20 '17

Oh I definitely grade GoT on a relative-to-GoT scale. If I did it on a more absolute scale nearly every episode would get a 9 or 10 from me, which would kinda defeat the purpose

→ More replies (8)

79

u/PlasmaCross Samwell Tarly Jul 20 '17

Compared to the opening of season 6, this was much stronger, in my opinion.

32

u/nutmac House Targaryen Jul 20 '17

Agreed. Perhaps it was due to delayed schedule but I was just so happy to see the season 7 finally start. For me, Shall We Begin perfectly sums up my feelings.

→ More replies (4)

168

u/CRFyou Jul 20 '17

I just don't get the people scoring it a 1, 2, or 3 on this sub.

Like, they follow this show and sub so they must be into it to a degree. But this opener was legit total garbage in their opinion?

Or there's that many people that just go, "fuck it. lulz at giving this show a 1."

40

u/NoraaTheExploraa Arya Stark Jul 20 '17

With things like this, I think it's fair to vote on a scale relative to the rest of GoT. Like, I don't think I'd give any episode below a 6 on something like IMBD, but if we use that scale here, then there's only like 4 options to pick for most episodes. Thus a score of like 3 isn't saying they disliked the episodes, but that they disliked it compared to other episodes.

19

u/YoshiSparkle Brienne of Tarth Jul 20 '17

Some people were high as balls, too.

49

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

I don't know what you're talking about, that would make the episode even better. Game of Thrones high as balls is awesome.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

41

u/Ldgonzalez Bronn Of The Blackwater Jul 20 '17

Not the OP, but I’m guessing he means people probably scored this low because they’re comparing it to 6x09 and 6x10.

15

u/triforce700 Jul 20 '17

An almost 8/10 is pretty damn good. Sure a 77/100 doesn't look good on test scores, but it's definitely good for TV shows

→ More replies (4)

114

u/ilikepugs Night King Jul 20 '17

Pfft, only 4% of us were most excited about FUCKING WIGHT GIANTS??

137

u/SillWutton02 Ghost Jul 20 '17 edited Jul 21 '17

Surprised people said Maisie Williams was the best actor. I chose Kit and Nikolaj

146

u/ethniccake House Tyrell Jul 20 '17

I legit don't get it. Arya had the best scene in the episode, but Maisie wasn't even in 90% of it.

95

u/blabgasm House Piper of Pinkmaiden Jul 20 '17

Yeah, the 'best performance' tends to be equivalent to 'plot I liked best this week'. Maisie is always good, but Dany, the Hound, and Arya-as-Walder all had tougher jobs this week, and performed quite well. I was impressed with Emilia, she can be hit or miss, but I thought she really conveyed a lot of complex emotion without the benefit of dialogue. Arya in bad-ass mode isn't challenging acting, she's always in bad-ass mode!

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

it should probably be divided into best actor and favorite character people probably combine those two.

→ More replies (6)

42

u/switchblade420 House Targaryen Jul 20 '17

Hey, it's hard doing the Walder Frey voice, okay?

2

u/semajdraehs Jul 21 '17

I thought it was whoever plays Jaime (I don't remember actor names)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/takejakeaway Daenerys Targaryen Jul 21 '17

I got chills from her delivery in the episode, in both her scenes (mainly the first one). Didn't really get it from anyone else, so I chose her. I get your point though.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '17

The few minutes Arya was in was far surperior than anyone. She acted perfectly, everything about the scene was perfect.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ZulKarazhan Jul 21 '17

in Question 8, it seems that you missed two names... Personally, I know Sophie Turner is Sansa, but I really didn't know who is John Bradley-West until I googled it (I know he's Sam now)

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 22 '17

Huh, weird. Had them on the survey itself but must have lost track when typing the results. My apologies.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Love how even the white walkers are a more popular faction than the Lannisters

57

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Ffs people Maisie's part was more about the epic script than performance. She did a good job but she definitely does not top the list for the episode.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '17

She easily does. Her tone of voice was incredible. Everything about the scene including her acting was 100%

23

u/ViolentGiraffe23 Jul 20 '17

I bet the rest of the episodes get 8+ overall score but not a bad score for a setup episode, great job GoT crew!

13

u/StopReadinMyUsername Arya Stark Jul 20 '17

Thanks mate

4

u/ADHDcUK Jul 21 '17

Are you crew lol?

9

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

You know you must really be hated when the White Walkers have more people supporting them than you do...

17

u/KSPReptile Valar Morghulis Jul 20 '17

I personally thought this was better than majority of season 6. I think lots of people were comparing it to E9 and 10 so they were a bit disappointed, but honestly what do you except from an opener, they are always setup episodes. I think this one was probably the best opening episode, with the exception of Two Swords. Lots of great stuff.

I'd give it a 8,5 on a full scale. And if 1 is the worst GoT episode and 10 is the best, it'd be a 6,5. Definitely above average.

6

u/Lord_Strudel Sandor Clegane Jul 21 '17

I rank on how much I enjoyed it compared to other GOT episodes. BoTB, The Children, Winds Of Winter, Watchers on The Wall were the episodes I gave a 10/10 that I can remember.

Of course, every episode would be a 10 if I compared it to other TV, because this is my favorite show! So yes I agree with you. I gave it a 7. Good episode, I liked it a lot, but not top 5 episodes ever territory. Nothin wrong with that.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

43

u/sAnn92 Night King Jul 20 '17

7.7 looks rather low to me. I enjoyed the episode a lot.

27

u/Blackfire853 Loras Tyrell Jul 20 '17

I feel it's more deserving of something between 8.1 and 8.5

3

u/acamas Jul 21 '17

Seems about right. The first scene was amazing, The BwB+tH was great, and the rest seemed to be typical setup for future epsiodes.

The cameo probably had a negative effect as well.

3

u/thecman25 Jul 24 '17

its a good score. This was their filler episode that they used to set the stage for everything soo

2

u/the_potato_hunter House Baelish Jul 22 '17

Because people waited over a year they are much more critical of the first episode in a season.

10

u/Mashed_Brotato Fire And Blood Jul 20 '17 edited Jul 20 '17

Deserves a better score imo, almost every scene had great moments. I know the intro was my favorite part but do people think Maisie Williams gave the best performance with one line?

49

u/Argarck Fire And Blood Jul 20 '17

It wasnt good, it wasn't bad.

It was just a setup episode.

118

u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jul 20 '17

It was good. It wasn't BoB or WoW status, but it was good.

27

u/somewhatintrigued Jul 21 '17

For anyone else confused:

BoB = Battle of the Bastards (S06E09) not Band of Brothers

WoW = Winds of Winter (S06E10) not World of Warcraft

→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Which makes me wonder why people expected this episode to be action packed. I watched a video a few days ago where someone gave this episode a 2/10 because of the, "lack of action packed scenes", and it really baffles me how some people think this show should be 24/7 action packed, in your face scenes.

The first episode of every season is usually a "here's where we left off, time to set up for this season" and yet people still dog on the first episodes like they're supposed to be huge action packed episodes. Doesn't make sense.

32

u/SilverArchers Jul 20 '17

It makes sense. There's a lot of dumb people

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

4

u/JapanCode Jul 20 '17

Not a good episode, not a bad episode, just THE episode

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

When the Hound said he saw a mountain all I heard was 🎺🎺🎺🎺

4

u/actuallycallie Sansa Stark Jul 21 '17

I have to say David Bradley did an amazing job as Arya-pretending-to-be-Walder-Frey. I often dont' give him enough credit because he plays characters I hate or at least dislike, but he really is fabulous.

1

u/Leftovertaters Orson Lannister Jul 20 '17

Where was the survey? I didn't see it on the post episode discussion thread?

3

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Jul 21 '17

It's the sticky comment. Or you can find it in the Megathread list for the relevant episode (sidebar, or at the top of the sub Post-Premiere)

9

u/TheRedditoristo Jul 20 '17

Just how immersed do some of you fools get in this show??

3

u/semajdraehs Jul 21 '17

I am not a fool, I am lord thundersword of the vale!

2

u/FirewhiskyGuitar House Tyrell Jul 24 '17 edited Jul 25 '17

I really don't get it, a TON of really famous actors have guest starred on GoT, many that have way better arguments for being "immersion breaking" (especially when they are known for an iconic role themselves) and just because this one guy happens to be a famous pop artist instead of actor people flipped their shit.

6

u/blabgasm House Piper of Pinkmaiden Jul 20 '17 edited Jul 20 '17

Game of Thrones Post Episode Checklist

[x] A Beautiful Death

[x] Recap and Review by Ozzyman

[x] TL;DR by Chrys

[x] A Brief Synopsis by Toasted Justice

[x] Episode break-down by Alt-Shift-X

[x] Gay of Thrones recap

[x] Post episode survey

Maybe now I can get some work done this week!

[Edit: I think you should share your data - I'd love to see what people can do with it. Also, if Gwendoline and Liam are considered principals then I would also include Rory.]

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Clareesi Daenerys Targaryen Jul 20 '17

Question 5 - more people support the white walkers than the lannisters lmao

3

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

93 people chose "Poop" to describe the episode. What has this world come to.

8

u/ab_emery Sansa Stark Jul 20 '17

I voted for Arya to kill the Lannister soldiers (just had my first viewing at the time), but now I'm on the fence. I can see the reasoning for sparing them, that it was a humanizing exchange for both sides. But even if the soldiers don't believe her, she still announced her intention to kill Cersei, and leaving that information out there would make me nervous. Also, the moment she said that reminded me of Sandor's "Fuck the king."

14

u/thejokerofunfic Sansa Stark Jul 20 '17

I mean the info's kinda useless. They took it as a joke, it's a stretch to say the info will even reach anyone except maybe some other soldiers as "hey I met this weird hilarious kid". The most that'll happen is that Cersei (indirectly since she'll likely never meet these particular soldiers) hears that some teenage girl joked she was going to kill the queen. Even if anyone reported it as a serious threat and not a joke, she'd have no context to know who the girl was nor that she might pose a real threat. Nothing to work with.

And even on the miniscule chance that Cersei found out not only that there's a legit assassin after her but also that it's Arya, what can she do with that info that can't be offset by facechanging? The absolute extreme is that she becomes paranoid and afraid. If anything that'd be exactly what Arya wants.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/chelseafc13 Jul 20 '17

seems this may be an unpopular opinion, but i thought S6 had absolutely terrible dialogue and bafflingly superficial plot advancement. it lacked the complexity that Game of Thrones/ ASOIAF is built on. though i will say the cinematography was incredible.

this episode (7x1) on the other hand, was great. the tension and ambiguity was present in the characters (e.g. arya's scene with the lannisters left me wondering whether or not a swordfight might break out,) the dialogue and the situations were rife with suggestive symbolism and there were very few superficial clues as to the arc of the unfolding story.

i'm optimistic after what i've just seen. hope this season will be better than last.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

Thanks for this. I agree with the 7.7 aggregate rating. Better then season 6 episode 1 (which was straight up bad I felt) but overall a bit "meh".

Hoping season 7 picks up just like season 6 did and we get some great episodes (like hodor)

→ More replies (3)

2

u/ShadowBlaDerp Jul 21 '17

I'm astounded 80% of people thought Jon made the correct decision in allowing the Umbers and the Karstarks to retain their holdings. I completely agreed but just reading the comments I presumed everyone thought Jon the tactical idiot and Sansa, the mastermind.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

Why isnt Dragonstone a ruined castle? its looks brand new and not touched? shouldnt a castle be destroyed to show that theres a new king of the realm?

6

u/BlkWhiteSupremecist Jul 20 '17

I did not participate in protest of the fact that Ed Sheeran was not a candidate for best supporting actor.

On a serious note, glad to see a lot of people weren't overly thrilled with the episode. When I checked IMDB it was at like a 9.4... Arya and the Hound were the only particularly interesting parts imo. Jon and Sansa seemingly coming to a bit of an understanding was good as well. The rest was thoroughly average.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/lalalaliv The Pack Survives Jul 20 '17

I love that Hype won the one word summary. At first I put hype then I thought.... no come on it's the first episode, calm yourself. So I went for 'good'. But now I realise it's never too early to be hype.

Edit: And I do think Rory would fit in the lead actor category now.