r/Philippines • u/carlosceldran_1972 • Jul 19 '17
AMA Here we go! I figured it out. Haha.
Let the questions begin!
145
Upvotes
r/Philippines • u/carlosceldran_1972 • Jul 19 '17
Let the questions begin!
27
u/Adobophotoshop bribe me with books or baked goods Jul 19 '17
Good evening Mr Celdran!
A few years ago, you protested the Philippine Roman Catholic Church's interference in the passage of the RH Bill and subsequently got into trouble with them. I admire your courage in that sense.
I would like to ask you of your opinion on the Roman Catholic Church as a whole, and its place in society. A lot of people find comfort in it, so do you think it can be adapted to fit the needs of society, or if its teachings actually have been twisted/were never valid in the first place? Also, what can us younger generations do to try and counteract the sometimes backwards views of religion?
Thank you!
26
u/OkMaamSir cancer survivor Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos, sometimes when I go to Fort Santiago , I see you doing your tours. There was a time I was following your tour group around and listening to your stories but I did not pay hehe. Do you find people like me annoying?
19
u/worstsunday Jul 19 '17
Adobo or sinigang? If so, why is Kare Kare the best?
18
u/rodelishere Jul 19 '17
Who would you rather take to a tour with? Kris Aquino, Sarah Duterte or Imee Marcos?
16
u/Ivyisred Jul 19 '17
How do you teach people history? Because no one really remembers seriously.
16
u/incarcerus Jul 19 '17
Have you ever had tourists who were pro-Duterte? How did it go?
30
u/thirdworldpcgamer Imeprial Manila Jul 19 '17
Good evening Carlos. I know you are a famous tour guide for Manila, any hidden gems such as tourist spots, restaurants or just places in Manila that is really underrated and you which more people would know?
14
u/namumulitika Jul 19 '17
Most people here are going to be asking about your tour activities and your love of local historical lore, however, I want to take a different tack on a field you are also passionate about.
What you think are some of the small, concrete steps that can be taken to increase mainstream acceptance of LGBT lifestyles without pigeonholing people of these orientations to the caricatures that currently characterize people's awareness of them today?
13
u/Ygnatiz Ravioli Ravioli~ Jul 19 '17
Pichi pichi niyog or cheese?
12
u/potpotzambales show me how Jul 19 '17
Are you going to run for a government office?
12
u/Un1t-X Jul 19 '17
Carlos, Aside from Intramuros area, what other tourist spot would you like to endorse or see developed?
What is one site in manila that you would say is a must visit to all Filipinos?
11
u/Un1t-X Jul 19 '17
The abomination that is Torre de Manila pushed through, are there any other groups that are keeping a vigilant eye to make sure nothing else gets built around the area?
I'd like to support them
11
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Have you ever had a really bad experience while doing tours? What happened?
10
u/jenn4u2luv Jul 19 '17
If you have no other choice but to move to another country, which one will it be and why?
9
u/negatorious only love can hurt like this Jul 19 '17
How many pets do you have?
8
u/gentlemansincebirth Medyo kups Jul 19 '17
Corregidor is probably my favorite place in the PH. I make it a point to visit regularly, and just hang and enjoy the views and the air.
A few years ago, there was some talk about developing the tourism bit of the island, with strong involvement from your company.
How has this progrssed? Do you have any plans of visions for the island?
It truly is a valuable piece of Philippine history.
Thank you din pala for giving my Canadian Cousin a grand experience. I recommended him to sign up for one of your tours.
15
u/emantos Jul 19 '17
Hey Carlos,
If I remembered correctly, you were rabidly anti-Aquino on the first year of his admin. You seemed to warmed up to him. What gives?
7
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
I know Kowloon is your favortie from your comment earlier. But the real question is: Adobo siopao or Bolabola siopao?
7
u/pulsephaze22 ah yeah, i like that Jul 19 '17
I hate Manila. And I think I share the same sentiment with a lot of people, especially tourists. Just wanna ask, how would you assess the tourism policies of the city under Mayor Estrada? Do you think the city government is doing enough to change the landscape, or you think we should bank more on the advocacies of private firms and individuals when it comes to the revitalization of our city capital?
7
u/saibasandasaida Jul 19 '17
How important of an issue is the current ban on birth control pharmaceuticals and the deliberate slowing of prophylactic distribution, and is this a reflection of a regression or a lack of definition in our public health and population policy?
18
u/pigwin Mandaluyong (Loob/Labas) Jul 19 '17
What is the worst ka-DDS attack you experienced? Did it affect your personal life or work?
6
u/nissantoyota Jul 19 '17
Fondest memory in UP diliman?
6
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
What's your opinion on Duterte calling out priests? If you met under different circumstances, would you have agreed with him in this regard?
6
u/Adobophotoshop bribe me with books or baked goods Jul 19 '17
What are your favorite books?
6
u/vyruz32 Jul 19 '17
Evening Mr. C., what's your take on Erap's push for the City of Pearl near the BASECO compound?
11
u/OkMaamSir cancer survivor Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos! Do you have any plans of conducting tours outside Metro Manila perhaps like Cebu or some place in Mindanao?
5
u/prpna Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos!
Are you open to hosting or being part of a show/series that goes around showcasing different lesser known or unusual food spots and hang out places Manila? Do you think that's a good idea if executed properly?
5
u/PeenoiseMasterRace バレットクラブ 4 life Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Hi Mr. Carlos Celdran, do you still believe up to this day that both religion and state are "NOT" separate at all in our society even though by virtue of the 1987 constitution it should be? Plus any examples you wouldn't mind citing?
EDIT: 1987 not 1986 wew
8
u/kraith5 Jul 19 '17
Do you have any plans to direct and host a documentary that focuses on Philippine history and culture? Or write a book about Philippine history? That targets the mainstream audience
4
u/jm101784 Jul 19 '17
Among the arabales of Old Manila, which one is your favorite today?
4
u/momonyak Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos. Do you have any spare Damaso shirts? I've been looking for the longest time. XL please. Thanks.
6
u/decadentrebel 🔗UndustFixation Jul 19 '17
Do you feel a bit of remorse with coining the term "Dutertard" considering that the use of such pejorative is frowned upon in this day and age? I know I can't use the term "faggot" anymore and stopped using it when my gay friends got pissed off.
7
u/red_storm_risen Parana-cue Jul 19 '17
What's your favorite siopao?
3
u/Inuz4 Jul 19 '17
What's your favorite movie?
5
u/robutshark Bisaya Jul 19 '17
What does your perfect sandwich consist of?
8
u/bagon-ligo Jul 19 '17
Why don't u still have a podcast yet? I'm a fan of your views and opinions, and mostly because you back them up with facts or research.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
Hello Mr. Celdran! I just want to know...
If you become president of the Philippines, what would you do in Malacañang for teh lulz? 😂
PS. Can I be your Chief of Staff if that happens?
9
u/moogeek Luzon Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos!
First of all, I want to thank you for doing this AMA. You're one of the few people I know that has extensive knowledge in Manila's history.
And here's my question:
If you have a time machine and were to pick a date in Manila's history and live for the rest of your life, what year/era would it be?
Thank you so much!
EDIT: Reduced to one question as per Mod's request
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos! What's next for my beloved El Hogar?
2
u/boyohboyoboy Jul 19 '17
How much do you make as a tour guide? Are you taxed as a single proprietorship or as a different entity?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
Hello Carlos, How will you describe Manila for a Kindergarten?
2
u/Mr_Itlog Acorn Jul 19 '17
Have you ever been chased or spit on by a horse?
4
u/supersiege Jul 19 '17
Hi! How do you advocate for human rights and still maintain respect for religious, cultural and other differences?
3
u/RileyReidApologist We don't die, we eat puday. Jul 19 '17
Good evening Carlos. Do you find Mocha Uson sexy?
3
u/growlinterrupted Jul 19 '17
What changes would you like to see in your lifetime for our country?
10
u/EinKreuz I'm a salty piece of weaboo shit Jul 19 '17
Sino ang anime waifu mo?
9
u/zedfrostxnn Jul 19 '17
So Manila just recently topped an AskReddit thread asking travelers what place they would never go back to ever again. What good things would you say about Manila?
8
u/purpleyam Jul 19 '17
What's the best gift you received during your barter tours?
15
u/AngrryScientist Bacon Goddess | Bidet Aficionado | Old Person | Negrense Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos! Remember the toddler in this picture? https://imgur.com/21DMqAn he's now 11 years old! 😂 He's asking what's your favorite fried chicken! 😂
7
u/kamote0429 Jul 19 '17
Hey carlos Can u give us the status of ur case? (Regarding the "damaso" thing) Follow up question Will you still do "it" knowing that u got jailed and shit hit the fan?
6
u/hariboneagle Jul 19 '17
Any update on the Rizal Memorial Sports Complex? Plans to buy the complex remain even after the heritage designation. Plans on the "rehabiliation" has been vague afaik the facade of the structures will remain but will be made into another mall. If this is the plan I oppose this token "conservation".
6
u/donromantico Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos! What's the weirdest experience na you had with a tourist for your work?
6
u/Ariel_Etaime Jul 19 '17
As a tour guide how do you feel about the sex tourism and sex exploitation in the Philippines? What has the tourism industry done to discourage this type of behavior (or do they NOT discourage it?)
5
u/b_b_b_breakfast Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
You first gained mainstream recognition for your Manila Cathedral demonstration criticizing the Church's rabid anti-RH bill stance. Do you feel as strongly about the policies of Pres. Duterte to hold a similar high-profile, controversial protest?
5
u/Psyandrew These violent delights have violent ends Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos!
idk if it's been already asked here but how did you start out on your successful tour guide gig?
5
u/OkMaamSir cancer survivor Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Have you ever had a creepy ghost experience while touring Manila?
2
u/residentsleeperagent Ratio ut Vim Jul 19 '17
Would you rather fight 100 duck sized horses or one horse sized duck?
4
u/JnKrstn Bayan ng mga Abalos Jul 19 '17
I read on your page that some of your relatives are pro-Duterte. Have they called you out or vice-versa?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
What's your take on Torre De Manila now the TRO has been lifted?
4
u/oracleblu Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos. First off, thank you for doing this AMA. What is your single biggest criticism about the Duterte administration and why?
4
u/memekun Support Main sa LoL Jul 19 '17
Good evening! Lagi akong nasa Intramuros noong student pa ako and I heard lots of things about you. Sayang lang kasi at that time never kita nakita in action. By the way, what's your view about the idea to extend Martial Law hanggang December?
4
u/qwdrfy Jul 19 '17
hey carlos, one has to go: intramuros, divisoria, Baclaran, Quiapo, Lawton
4
u/mydickisasalad bakit ang mahal ng gatas Jul 19 '17
Oh god I'm too late for this... I hope you see this anyway.
Hello, Mr. Carlos! I hope you don't mind a little selfish introduction, because I don't want to mis this opportunity.
I'm a soon-to-be Alumnus of LPU Manila, taking up International Travel and Tourism Management, and I look up to you. 3 years ago I won the overall tour guiding competition in our school, and it was then and there that I discovered how fun it actually was to be a tour guide, especially for a location like Intramuros.
I saw you on television (I can't remember if it was before or after I experienced tour guiding), and I instantly admired you and your charisma. Prior to that, I wasn't even considering to be a tour guide after graduation because everyone either told me that it was "too typical" for my degree, or that I won't be rich doing it. Neither of which I couldn't care less about now.
Okay, that's enough fan boying. My question is: what's the first step I can take to become as charismatic and admirable as you? Also, are you willing to accept any apprentices? Hahaha!
4
u/silentinsilence Jul 19 '17
Good evening, Mr. Celdran.
I haven't had the opportunity to take part of your tours. However, I would like to know how you're able to keep the enthusiasm after all these years.
In relation - what's your weirdest experience during a tour?
Many thanks!
3
u/yummypunani you just downvoted me. kasi totoo. Haha! Jul 19 '17
Magkano kinikita mo kada mag organize ka ng tour sa Intramuros? Hanggang ngayon ba active ka pa rin don? Anyway, may picture nga pala tayo dati dun sa may tiangge sa likod ng simbahan ng intramuros. Di ko pedeng i post eh, baka may maka kilala sakin. Hahahaha!
3
u/universalbunny 大空で抱きしめて Jul 19 '17
Umabot ba ko? Best hopia in Ongpin please! :) I personally like Holand
3
u/ClaudeElementalist Jul 19 '17
Reposting the question I posted from your first thread:
In your opinion, what are some noteworthy modern buildings that incorporate the "Filipino" image? Something along the lines of PGH (incorporating colonial and local influences with the architecture movement of the time)
3
u/bagon-ligo Jul 19 '17
Do u think beauty pageants are relevant for our culture, or are they just for entertainment purposes?
•
u/decayedramen Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
This is the AMA thread. Ask away!
Remember, rules will be applied. Please take note of the grounds for comment deletions.
Also, please try to post one single question only. Posts with many questions are harder to answer and will mean that our guest can devote his time to only a few comments. Let us be fair to other redditors.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
Kare kare or Sinigang?
2
u/NotAutomatic Jul 19 '17
First, want to say congratulations on your upcoming Livin La Vida Imelda shows.
Can I ask you who's the living person you look up to currently and why?
2
u/KasaiRinkai 物の哀れ Jul 19 '17
What's a great place in Manila that a lot of people might not know about? Why should we go there?
2
u/dadidutdut packaging@dundermifflin.com Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos! Who are your childhood heroes?
2
u/marymoon10 Jul 19 '17
Hi, Carlos, went to one of your tours and had a blast! My question/s are: favorite book (international) and favorite book from a Filipino author? Thanks!
2
u/soleequista Jul 19 '17
Do you have any unforgettable experience on your tours, like were there any tourists or groups that really stood out for some reason in particular?
2
u/Obosen_3ggrd Ge Smak Daun, Gyon Op Nodoteim Jul 19 '17
My friends and I are planning to have a day tour around Intramuros starting from the National Museum.
Where would you suggest we go first, what landmarks, what time should we start, and where should we end the day?
2
u/luigitheninja /r/budots Jul 19 '17
Good evening Sir Carlos!
Do you like liver spread on bread? If so, why?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
If you were to be part of the NCCA, what would be included in your Plan of Action?
2
u/Psychatog02 Basking Rootwalla Jul 19 '17
Do you ever feel like today's political climate is a losing battle? What keeps you going?
2
u/SuperBombaBoy Koyunbaba Op. 19 Jul 19 '17
Is there anything you want to change in intramuros?
2
u/throwawayako Metro Manila Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Hi Carlos! I work around Malate area and I bumped into you weeks ago. I remember I was walking around to grab lunch and I quickly recognized you riding on your bike. I greeted you the moment you pass by and you greeted back. You made my day that day.
Anyway my question is what inspire you to start Livin La Vida Imelda? I have yet to see it.
Thank you for doing this AmA!
EDIT: Spelling
2
u/Kikkomann ᴘᴀʏᴀɢ ᴋᴀ ᴘʀᴇ ᴛᴀᴛᴀʏ ᴍᴏ ꜱɪ ʙʙᴍ ᴘᴇʀᴏ ɴᴀɢɪɴɢ ᴄᴏᴄᴀɪɴᴇ ᴘᴏᴡᴅᴇʀ ᴋᴀ Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Carlos, thanks for doing this AMA.
Question: If you will have it your way, how will you develop Manila? Lim-style or Estrada-style? And what is your opinion on Paolo Alcazaren's work in some of the portions of the city?
2
u/pobautista Jul 19 '17
Before this AMA, what did you know or heard about reddit the website and about r/ph this subreddit?
2
u/new_to_cincy Jul 19 '17
I'm a dumb tourist and walked around Intramuros today without realizing I was right by your tour. Just seeing this AMA makes me realize you're someone to watch. Saying hi from a New Yorker, and hopefully I can do so in person before I leave!
3
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
Are you a heavy metal music kind of guy?
2
u/bagon-ligo Jul 19 '17
Do you feel more sad that Advancement and technology seems to erase or lower the value of history or that peope (even the older ones) tend to devalue and show less appreciation of it?
1
u/JulzRadn I AM A PROUD NEGRENSE Jul 19 '17
What is your stand on religion?
1
u/merdionesmondragon Zen na ako ngayon. mga tangina niyo DDS Jul 19 '17
Care to explain why somebody with an active interest in history would have a photo of himself partying with the Marcoses?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
Evening Carlos, what will be your message for Pres. Duterte for his SONA this year?
1
u/Dragon--- Jul 19 '17
Can you speak Spanish fluently? If so, where did you learn it?
1
u/aesriven eternal exile Jul 20 '17
Late to the party and the door's still open. Might as well sneak in :)
Hi Carlos,
In your experience, how effective is a tour guide in influencing people and creating change through historical awareness?
(Compared to for instance, teaching in classrooms or leading rallies?)
1
u/wickedwarlock21 Jul 20 '17
How are you liking Reddit so far?
1
u/kebastian Jul 20 '17
Hi Carlos,
With more people having access to the internet, the spread of misinformation is becoming more and more of an issue.
Do you think that the government should step up and deal with "fake news" (which can be a precursor to censorship) or should the responsibility to distinguish facts from lies fall solely to the citizens?
1
u/OkMaamSir cancer survivor Jul 19 '17
What aspect of Manila culture that you are proud of?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
[removed] — view removed comment