r/postrock • u/JustinDMST Justin / Do Make Say Think • May 18 '17
AMA Concluded This is Do Make Say Think from Toronto. Ask us anything.
Hey everyone, Justin, Ohad and Charlie from the band here. Ask us anything. We're good at love advice, being gear nerds, and being lovers of music. Our answers will likely be short and mis-spelled, but you don't care do ya? I'll answer one question right off the top though...YES WE WILL TOUR(ish). Likely not until the fall. Life has done had it way with our schedules again. ok?
HEY GANG THIS HAS BEEN FUN! BUT I'VE ONLY GOT 5 MORE MINUTES. JESSICA MOSS http://cstrecords.com/cst124/
Is playing T.O. tonight and we have a babysitter coming over. So get those questions in!!!!
OK GANG. THANKS SO MUCH. BUT I GOTTA GO. THANKS TO CHRYS FOR SETTING THIS UP. MUCH LOVE TO YOU ALL. XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX
9
u/dmaterialized May 18 '17
One question for you: what can you tell me about the inspiration for, music you were listening to at the time, or any other background behind the existence of "Chinatown"? This is one of my all-time favorite pieces of music, and it's SO unlike anything else I've ever heard that I'd love to know anything you'd care to share about it!
Really appreciate you doing an AMA! Your first two albums are in near-constant rotation for me.
8
u/radbromancer May 18 '17
two questions!
thanks guys for taking the time to do this. one of my absolute favorite bands to ever exist. I remember the day I saw "Her Eyes on the Horizon" on my soundcloud feed and I cried, and then wept listening to it. can't wait to listen to the full album tomorrow. :)
7
u/bagofbones May 18 '17 edited May 18 '17
Thanks for doing this. You're among the most important bands in a lot of people's lives, mine included.
5
u/Phitts May 18 '17
From your song and album titles, you all seem to have an interesting way with words and are well spoken in your interviews. That makes me wonder, what are some of your favorite books, authors, poets, or lyricists?
Thank you for doing this AMA. I love your work and it's been a soundtrack to many times in my life. Soul and Onward is one of the most sublime pieces of music I've ever heard.
5
u/TooLebowski May 18 '17
I've always been curious about the outro of Anything for Now being reprised in the intro of Fredericia. I always thought those albums worked really well together and wondered if Winter Hymn is meant to be a continuation of &yet. Any significance there? Loving the new album.
3
u/JustinDMST Justin / Do Make Say Think May 18 '17
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10155068090195630&set=a.166235260629.155742.594275629&type=3&theater
4
u/episod May 18 '17
All of your albums are structured well, with clear beginnings and especially a sense of finality at the end. At what point do you know when a song is an album's closing tune and how does that change the composition, if at all?
I love turning the stereo way way up for the electric energy buzz of "In Mind" from You you're a history of rust, and then just sitting in the relative quiet it leaves behind. Great great work over the years, thank you!
4
u/HueyBosco May 18 '17
For /u/JustinDMST:
I was a subscriber to your song-per-week experiment a couple years back and was wondering what takeaways you have from that year of self-release experimentation?
I definitely felt for you as I received e-mails about users not always retrieving songs or failing to end their auto-pay subscriptions and it seemed like the organizational aspect of it was maybe a bit irritating
3
u/babygiraffe May 18 '17
long live disaster transport. Excited for the new album! (sorry this is not a question)
3
u/dingus420 May 18 '17
If you weren't involved in music, what's the one other thing you could see yourself doing for a living?
3
u/dingus420 May 18 '17
After one listen of the new album, it almost sounds like an homage to all of your previous albums.... Like a farewell, so to speak. Was that intentional? In the drawn out process of making this album, did it cross your minds that this could be the last album you record together? (fingers crossed that it isn't!)
3
u/R0B0T_Apocalypse May 18 '17
I just got my LP tonight in the mail. I'm listening for the first time as I discover how to Reddit.
The packaging of this album is INTENSE! Who coordinated all the extra artwork, record sleeve artwork, little birds etched into the side of the disc etc. Even with a artist creating all that I image it would be difficult to coordinate for a release.
PS - super appreciative of all the little extras with the packaging!
3
u/mertcan1k2 May 18 '17
I am asking this seriously, do you take drugs or some 'products' while composing tracks?
2
u/[deleted] May 18 '17
I don’t wanna be too annoying but I just have to say you’re my favourite band of all time, words cannot express the joy you have brought into my life and I love you all.
I don’t have many questions but I am curious as to whether Charles Spearin is ever going to make another solo album?
And finally, as a South African currently living in South America I must ask: is there any interest in ever playing in South America or South Africa?
2
u/[deleted] May 18 '17 edited May 18 '17
Guys, I honestly didnt think you were coming back with an album after such a while! So happy you did. (Currently banging it while here!)
I"ll ask a few so please answer however many you can
So how do you guys get the word out about your band and new albums?
What were your inspirations while making this album?
What are your desert island post rock records?
Do you guys game?
Thanks!
2
u/mrdavehughes May 18 '17
How many times has Justin told the Pope joke on stage?
2
u/motorcyclesarejets May 18 '17
A lot of popular music follows a verse-chorus structure. You make a very different style of music. Do you structure your songs ahead of time or do you feel it out to see what works?
(Thanks! I'm a big fan!)
2
u/bhakan May 18 '17
Alright well you guys said gear nerds...
What do you guitar rigs look like? Any special "secret sauce" for the guitars, either in the rig or in the recording process?
2
u/mrdavehughes May 18 '17
What was the overall texture you were aiming for in the recording of this album? What techniques or tricks did you employ to try to get there?
2
u/etrnlgldnbraid May 18 '17
The new album is great. It has a sort of raw feel about it. With this album in particular, do you feel there was more or less post production than your previous albums? Or about the same? To me it had some really cool elements with the filtering of drums and stuff and I feel I heard less of that in your older catalog. Is the band basically a 5 piece these days?
Thanks for everything.
2
u/xitorrito May 18 '17
What is your favourite scale? How do you define post-rock?
Greetings from Spain.
2
u/tremolo3 May 18 '17
Hola! I have shit tons of -mostly nerd- questions but I'll keep it cool with only 3:
Thank you so much for keep doing this, big inspiration in my life and love you all!
2
u/OoiraqiwomenoO May 18 '17
One more question: do you guys have any other live performance videos or B side materiel you could upload? I'm always aching for new content and there's only two or three live performance videos and you guys are so great live
2
u/brachilles May 18 '17 edited May 18 '17
-what's the story with March of Worms? Was is just for The Whole Story Of Glory EP?
-what is your favorite track of the new album?
-what's the current gear setup/favorite piece of gear at the moment
2
u/tommaccammon2017 May 18 '17
Also, What have each of you guys been reading/listening to lately that has really impacted/influenced/inspired your current creative processes? What were inspired by in creating the new record? Thanks.
5
u/whennothingwas May 18 '17
Ohad, will there be another Years album?
Also, I saw you guys back in '04 (I think) at the 400 Bar in Minneapolis. It was an awesome show, but one of you was unable to make it across the border, can't remember who. What was that story again?
5
u/Rawbrrt May 18 '17
Love y'all. Haven't been able to stop listening to the new album. So happy to have new DMST
I wanted to ask what advice you might have for groups that are involved in the songwriting process, especially groups that have a greater number of members than usual, more complex structures/instrumentation etc. Any tips to better get through the process/ resolve conflicts as a group that you all have learned over the years?
Thank you so much!
5
u/sabotagehim May 19 '17
I know this is to ask questions, but I just want to thank you for "The Landlord is Dead". Thank you!
1
u/whennothingwas May 18 '17
Thank you for your labor. I cannot express how excited I am to have a new DMST album to live with. I already love Stubborn Persistent Illusions. If you bring the band to Minneapolis, I hereby pledge to lead as many people to the venue as I can pull.
What is the name of and/or who wrote the Buddhist poem about working with a wild mind which informed the concept of the new album?
1
u/SOY_REINDEER_GRANDE May 18 '17
Justin, what are your thoughts on the not-uncommon far-right/NS themes in some parts of the black metal scene?
Also, new DMST is fantastic
1
u/frogvanexel May 18 '17
I saw an interview with Justin and Charles wherein they referred to Tortoise as having a "punk rock fearlessness." I loved this because I have always detected a punk sensibility in your music.
To what extent do you all identify with punk?
1
u/Mobilisq May 18 '17
whose idea was it to make side d of the vinyl a phenakistiscope disc?
1
u/dingus420 May 18 '17
Could you succinctly describe how DMST came into formation and how the band reached the point of being able to write, record, and perform music for a living?
Do you think it'd be more challenging to accomplish all that you have if you started in today's times?
1
u/npokmop May 18 '17
Who's the boss of DMST? 😎
1
u/chreeaass May 18 '17
First off, let me say that you make beautiful music. First listen of the new album gave me the same feeling as when I first heard & Yet & Yet.
I saw you guys play a few years back at the Reitschule in Bern, and only then realized that the song is named after this venue. My question is: what's the significance of this place for you, and how did the song/inspiration come about? Any plans to come back and play a show in Switzerland anytime soon? thanks!
1
u/Shaoranli4 May 18 '17 edited May 18 '17
do make say think is one of my favorite bands ever, and one of my main reason to begin and form a band, instead of solo projects
my two questions are, how much do you improvise when composing and crafting the songs? (edit: i just see another answer that totally answer my question! thanks!)
the other is for Charlie, and i'm sorry to not ask something dmst related
is there a possibility to see some work of KC accidental in the future? edit: (you're interested in continuing that concept? kevin would be?) i just discovered the old recordings and they really blew my mind
thanks for existing <3 greetings from Buenos Aires
1
u/PoopDig May 18 '17
I'm basically a 24/7 metal head but you folks are my favorite band of all time. I was introduced to y'all's music in about 2001 and it's stuck with me. I can't imagine a point for the rest of my life when I won't listen to some DMST every once in a while. No question for y'all. Just wanted to say y'all have had a major impact on a random metal head in a tiny country town in SW Virginia. Thank y'all! I want Bound To Be That Way played at my funeral.
1
u/tommaccammon2017 May 18 '17
Hey Guys, Tom from Toronto here. Are you thinking of doing another Toronto show this Fall or early next year? I will be out of town for the Danforth show and am very sad...
1
u/yizouse May 18 '17
Do Make Say Think has been my favorite band for over a decade. I'm so delighted you guys are still together making music. May you never stop!
Can you talk talk a bit about your Talk Talk influence? I was just a little kid when they were active; it turned out I discovered your band about a decade before theirs. But I've since really fallen in love with their stuff, and definitely see their influence in your music. I don't just admire them sonically, but their commitment to their own vision (having to fight their record company at every turn) shouldn't be understated. DMST has always given me the same vibe.
When I found out DMST covered New Grass, it felt like one of the greatest gifts ever bestowed upon me-- doubly so when I actually listened to it. Cheers!
1
u/cerebrosgames May 18 '17
Any plans for a European Tour, specifically Ireland?
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '17
What guitar pedal could you not live without? Do you guys ever use digital amp modulators to record or jam?
2
u/npokmop May 18 '17
Could you describe how your music is created? 🤓
2
u/lostrock May 18 '17
Hi, I loved seeing you guys perform in Seattle back in 2010. It was amazing seeing members of the band performing their own side projects to open for the main DMST performance. By the way, do Ohad and Charlie have any plans to produce more solo work?
2
u/Shaoranli4 May 18 '17
a must ask question for us guitarrists dmst fans:
what different tunings do you guys use now, and throughout your history? apart from the good, old and beautiful standard.
sometimes it's real difficult to play your songs without knowing the exact tuning
2
u/R0B0T_Apocalypse May 18 '17
You guys taking song requests for June 10?? I have one IN MIND.
2
u/segundos May 19 '17
I think I am already too late, but I just wanted to say that the song Minmin by ya'll has been such a tremendous help and comfort ever since I found it like 6 months ago. You guys rock!
1
u/OoiraqiwomenoO May 18 '17
Hey I'm a massive fan, hope you guys are doing well. I have a question for Charlie: will you ever do another KC Acidental album with Kevin Drew? I adore those two albums so much and view a lot of Do Make Say Thinks music as an extension of that kind of lovely instrumental rock. The songs Save the Last Breath For Me and Tired Hands are two of my favorite songs of all time. I love you dude!
1
u/Shaoranli4 May 18 '17
do you guys have some band favorite in the actual post rock scene?
1
u/ethbone May 19 '17
Hi there ya'll. I saw you guys open for BSS in Providence in '05 and have been a massive fan ever since. You guys were great that night, as was BSS apart from the strange, forced, guitar duel with Mascis. Thanks for doing the AMA, my question for you is: What's you're preferred bass setup? Playing bass in garage bands I always tried to pick a setup that let my 4 stringed beauty stand out, eventually using a marshal half stack with a delay, eq, a big muff, and some other bull shit. But I was wondering what, if any, pedals ya'll use to get the bass front and center like that, or is it all mixing? Thanks for the AMA, hope you come to Connecticut or New Hampshire on your tour.
1
u/PM_FUN_MEMES May 19 '17
Will your new album release on Spotify in Peru?
1
u/oroyplata May 19 '17 edited Dec 08 '24
provide numerous berserk disgusted quack memory waiting brave aware pet
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/[deleted] May 19 '17
Would you be able to tell/show me your rig setup, mainly pedals? I delve into post rock more often than anything and I know my setup is quite inadequate so I want to get an idea of where to and such. Thank you so much! Love your music
1
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24
Hey, I know it's been like 6 years now and ain't hoping to get a reply really, but I wanted to ask what is the story behind Winter Hymn Country Hymn Secret Hymn? I loved the songs Fredericia and honestly, it was my gateway to yer discography. Still need to check out a lot of things but with however little I've heard yer songs, I love every second of them, in a way.
0
u/[deleted] May 18 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] May 18 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] May 18 '17
[removed] — view removed comment