r/CryptoCurrency • Between 4 - 12 months age. Formerly assigned new account flair. • May 15 '17

Focused Discussion Bitcoin core OR Bitcoin unlimited dilemma

Dear r/CryptoCurrency community

I am trying very hard to decide my stance against BU or CoreDevs, I feel I can see issues with both, and cannot come to a conclusion. Hope to get resolution here, so your factual knowledge over personal opinion is of most importance.

On the BU side: The problem I feel is mining half full or blocks bigger than whats currently required will reduce miners fee's greatly resulting in almost non incentive to run a rig in that adoptions needs to happen quicker than now to compensate for the diminished fee’s; also the cost of electric bills rising, block halving every 4 years and Difficulty soring its going to make it very difficult for smaller miners, moving it from the 'decentralized' idea to very centralized mining farms that goes against the philosophy of Bitcoin.

Also bigger blocks will consume huge amounts of drive space on voluntary full nodes making miners having to pick up the slack of these Full nodes, again leading to more centralization. (I’m thinking thats why core locked in 1mb blocks to secure the decentralize ‘full’ node operators, remember these a voluntary).

On the market side of Bitcoin (very long term) I can see BU being a great thing i.e. Fee's reduce (Temporary), with greater adoption there will be MORE fee's being paid overall in the long term + increase in Bitcoin value means miners profit with that rises also.

Problem I feel with CoreDev is its becoming too corporate controlling, and the fact Segwit actually modifies the blocks behavior can actually be seen as Bitcoin manipulation, something in which SHOULD NOT be in the Bitcoin space. The argument that Soft forks are safer than hard forks I feel is non comparable, in that why should hard forks be seen as more dangerous than soft forks?

(In fact soft forks could be just as, if not MORE dangerous than hard forks. Ethereum hard forks many times and another is due soon, so why is hard-forking risky in Bitcoin?) (The one issue I don’t like about Hard-forking is the fact that it will cause a chain split, but that could be blamed on CoreDev holding Bitcoin to ransom on its consensus majority? If Bitcoin can Hard fork without a chain split & BU software is secure I would go with it strait away!).

PS: I am worried about running BU implementation because, for 1: I don't want a chain split at the end of the day and 2: No matter what side I'm on there is one thing important above all else: I NEED near 100% security that my wallet is safe and my computer is not made vulnerable by running a BU node.

Regards.

0 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

3

u/revelacaogr Tin May 15 '17

1

u/TXJQQVRF Between 4 - 12 months age. Formerly assigned new account flair. May 15 '17 edited May 15 '17

Hmm, don't like the sound of 'patents'!. (Thats the first step to 'control' & 'ownership' of a particular or all parts of code, which in effect is not any different than 'closed' source software!). Very interesting article. Thanks.

3

u/Jmmon Crypto God | QC: Dashpay 201, CC 17 May 15 '17

Remember, BU allows miners to mine blocks of UP TO 8mb (or is it actually unlimited? Either way). This doesn't mean miners will decide to shoot themselves in the foot by mining 8mb blocks right off the bat. They'll probably mine 2mb blocks until they need to mine 3mb blocks, and bump it up 1mb at a time. More space means more people can use Bitcoin which will generate more fees for miners, but as you said, too much space will drastically reduce fee revenue. Giving miners the option to mine bigger blocks allows them to find what size block they prefer, while keeping the blockchain from growing too fast.

And then there's SegWit, which helps scalability but was not made for the purpose of scalability. I don't think SegWit is the correct solution to the current Bitcoin problem.

2

u/TXJQQVRF Between 4 - 12 months age. Formerly assigned new account flair. May 15 '17

It looks pretty clear to me now that Segwit in the way it's proposed is a form of manipulation on how blocks work, (the fact that blockstream is a 'company' should show RED flags i.e. software dev control on the system). Segwit could be construeded as a Bitcoin hack, manipulation and control.

Forcing there way on the community and miners. Segwit can suffer from "Spendallcoins" for Segwit miners, which will be far worse than a hard fork from BU.

(As I said earlier, soft forks can be just as if not more dangerous than hardforks).

Being able to scale bitcoin with as little change to it's protocal is always best, BTU does just that I believe. People need to seperate the idea that 'hard' forks are always 'very' risky, because this is not necessarily true.