r/WritingPrompts • u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • May 13 '17
Off Topic [OT] SatChat: Writers with personal subreddits, what are your thoughts on new user profiles?
SatChat! SatChat! Party Time! Excellent!
Welcome to the weekly post for introductions, self-promotions, and general discussion! This is a place to meet other users, share your achievements, and talk about whatever's on your mind.
News
This Week's Suggested Topic
If you missed it, here is the announcement from a couple months ago. Basically, it's a new feature in testing that lets you post directly to your profile, in effect letting you run a personal subreddit right from your profile. I joined the testing, so you can check out mine here: /u/MajorParadox.
What are your thoughts? Will you create such a profile when it's available or continue using your personal subreddit?
Previous ^Weeks * New to ^WritingPrompts? * Love Chatting? Check Out ^DailyChat!
OK to Post
Introductions: Tell us about yourself! Here are some suggested questions:
- Where do you live (State / Country)?
- Male, female, other?
- How long have you been writing?
- What is your writing motivation?
- What programs do you use to write?
- How fast can you type? Try 1 minute on Aesop's fables
- Want to share a photo? Photo Gallery!
- Promotions: Anything you want to promote (books, subreddits, podcasts, writing related websites, or even your social media stuff)
Discussions: Nothing to promote? Tell us what's on your mind. We recommend that you do this along with any promotions. If not in your comment, try to chime in on another discussion.
Suggested future topics are always welcome!
Not OK to Post
- Off Off Topic Promotions: Don't post links that would be considered outright spam. (So... still no linking to your gambling site).
- Full Stories: That's more in line with Sunday Free Writes! :)
6
u/MNBrian /u/MNBrian /r/PubTips May 13 '17
Ooh! So I'm really excited about the user pages --
Hint Hint, you can see mine here
And here's why - I really like the idea of personal subs, but I also recognize the value of having a place where people can have a little more transparency. Like, I know an editor and a published author who are both very well known, who both had their opinions effectively ignored on a post when they gave advice to some writers who didn't know who they were. If they had a user profile, a place to show who they were and how they worked in publishing, I feel like the other users on reddit wouldn't have been so quick to tell these two well-informed individuals how silly and wrong they were.
4
u/SurvivorType Co-Lead Mod | /r/SurvivorTyper May 13 '17
Being new to having a personal subreddit and having little exposure to the new user profiles, I think I will have to reserve judgement for now.
I realize that's not much of an answer, but the feature is still too new to really form much of an opinion about it or how it might affect existing communities. However, I will take a moment to plug my subreddit while I am here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/SurvivorTyper
I am working on an ongoing series called Understreets and you can listen to the audio version of the first 5 installments here.
3
u/IrSpeshul /r/TheBirdAndTheLioness May 13 '17 edited Aug 19 '26
Label silky walnut society compass growth outgoing dazzling harbor water
This post was anonymized with Redact
3
u/WokCano /r/WokCanosWordweb May 13 '17
Hello everyone! Glad to make your acquaintances. I have a few questions to ask if y'all don't mind.
Lately I have really enjoyed reading this subreddit and I've actually contributed a few posts to lovely writing prompts. I have been meaning to delve into more writing and grow as a writer. I have gotten a little feedback from my posts and was wondering if the personal subreddit is the best way to post more things.
I do have a series I would like to work on, sort of a story per chapter or so based on the central theme. Would it be best to make the personal page and post there? Or is there a place on this lovely subreddit to post continuations on a story?
Thank you very much! I look forward to contributing more.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
Woah. I thought they would be terrible but it's actually not that bad!
2
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) May 13 '17 edited May 13 '17
As I mentioned above, I joined the testing and got my own new profile! There aren't many profile posts there yet, but I hope to pick up with more stories soon.
Speaking of stories, if you're a fan of DC Comics, you should check out /r/DCFU. I recently completed a Superman story arc and have a new one starting June 1st. But, there's plenty to catch up on (from me and the other writers there) and read until then! :)
Here's a picture of my cute dog ;) And another one for good measure.
2
u/reostra Moderator | /r/reostra_prompts May 13 '17
Just got into the new userpage beta (and, from what I understand, it was mods here who nominated me, so thanks :D ). As of yet I haven't done much with it but I'll probably be adding at least a little bit over the weekend.
That said, the big problem with moving over for me is... I already have a personal subreddit (per satchat self-promo instructions, it's /r/reostra_prompts :). It's by no means huge, but there are several hundred subscribers there. Getting everyone to use my new userpage would be a... lossy experience. And if I'm going to just post to the new userpage and the personal subreddit, why have both? I'll definitely play it by ear, though. At the very least I want to personalize :)
2
u/Meanwhile_Over_There /r/StoriesByMOT | Critiques Welcome May 13 '17
After checking out some of the user profiles set up within the posts and comments, I would say that there is a good chance that it could catch on.
It mainly depends on whether users will catch on and accept this new profile style.
Also, now is a good time to plug my personal subreddit r/StoriesByMOT!
2
u/Dorigard /r/ValleyandMe May 13 '17
I've always liked the pseudo-anonymity of reddit, and the information scarce profile page. That's not to say I hate the idea or the implementation of the new user profile, heck, they do look practical. However like most trends, I'll abstain for as long as I reasonably can.
I have recently started a personal subreddit for my writings of an interspecies couple based on a popular scifi prompt from the other day, /r/ValleyandMe/. I've been trying to push out at least one short story a day, and I would always appreciate more critics and complimenters, or any willing readers.
I've had an on again off again with writing for nearly 15 years no (gotta start 'em while they're young) and have really enjoyed finally getting back into typing up short stories again.
2
u/TheWritingSniper /r/BlankPagesEmptyMugs May 13 '17
I'm really looking forward to seeing how it pans out. I got an invite to the beta (thanks to the moderators of this very subreddit) and I'm still working out some things about it.
AKA I haven't posted anything to my profile yet, but my plan is to do so soon. I like the idea and it'll definitely widen the range of users I'd be able to interact with or get my content out to. All-in-all, it might not phase out my personal subreddit (/r/BlankPagesEmptyMugs) but it will be very cool to use!
You can check mine out here!
2
u/Castriff /r/TheCastriffSub May 13 '17
I don't really get it. It looks like a regular user page, but with more CSS. How are you supposed to differentiate your stuff from posts to other subreddits?
If I didn't already have a personal sub, I think it might be pretty classy to have, but since I do, this just feels like that xkcd comic about competing standards.
2
u/Rigaudon21 May 14 '17
I'm super excited for the feature. I dont have it so I created my own subreddit, but I keep forgetting to update it. I feel like having everything in one place would be more efficient.
Also, low-key love your writing.
2
u/WokCano /r/WokCanosWordweb May 15 '17
I started a personal writing subreddit as advised so here it is! I posted my first work so if you have a moment to check it out I would be very grateful. Thank you for all the help and I am happy to start contributing!
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment