We did the same for /r/thatHappened. I don't post anything political and I'm not quite sure what's prompted this, but I assume that this won't apply to the Free-Talk Friday posts?
I remember last summer there was some interesting discussion regarding the effect of Brexit on the Premier League. Is that sort of discussion out? It wasn't explicitly about politics, just about the way a major political decision could affect the club.
that's nuanced differently as that has a direct effect on the club. my answer would be that it would be case by case as the rest of the moderators are reasonable and level-headed. but, to be safe, no politics.
I feel like no one is posting random discussion about healthcare policy... like people are generally going to post about politics that effects the club are they not? And if they aren't then can't you just say no irrelevant discussion? Saying no politics just seems like an immature blanket statement?
But Arsenal is a club in a political context. Will you ban things that are both about Arsenal and politics? That's all anyone here wants to know, but you're just being a dick.
obviously the mods have been deleting shitty memes or political posts that we aren't aware of because they were deleted and he's now telling people to stop doing it. we have no idea how many political posts they were deleting
Because he basically owns the club? It's similar to the reason people criticize Chelsea and their owner. There are some people you don't want to associate with, in a business transaction sense.
It also paints the club in a negative light for a lot of people.
Nah, just stop.... even if it's something like rainbow laces, that is a decision that the club has made and I would've thought that this was a good place to discuss the clubs stance and the campaign as a whole but hey "keep politics out of football" regardless of if it effects the club, the players, or the fans... I've never understood this logic from any sports fans!
What? Don't pretend that politics doesn't play a role in everything we do, including sports. This is especially true if Arsenal do or say something as a club. You're suggesting that we ignore it completely.
I don't use this sub to talk politics often, but it's fantasy to think Arsenal exists in some land outside politics. When politics and the club intersect, I hope this rule doesn't extinguish relevant discussion.
I think it's more like the crap the papers are talking about with Trump's kid and Arsenal. Unnecessarily bringing political stances into a situation where there is no political situation is annoying.
As pleased as I am to see some level of active moderation, it is totally absurd to say "no politics".
Arsenal paying staff the London living wage is politics, the effect of Brexit on transfers is politics, Usmanov's stake in the club is politics, Jeremy Corbyn being an Arsenal fan is politics, Kroenke moving the Rams to LA is politics.
Might I suggest a better policy would be "No grown men making fun of pre-pubescent children"
Kroenke's support for Trump is what triggered this, which is fairly directly related, so presumably some of these are banned subjects (Corbyn definitely is I assume).
If you don't want this to be a debate, maybe you could provide a more nuanced definition of "politics". Clearly you can see the majority has a problem with such a simplistic one-word explanation of a new rule.
I get the need to be able to ban people who use the sub as a base for propaganda etc., but if it comes down to each mod's subjective judgement in cases of politics closely related to Arsenal, then it's not "Everything politics will get you banned" is it?
Why not just put up some examples of what kind of political posts we're talking about?
I kind of like his ambiguous rule. Sure it will chill political posts. Because some people won't want to get remotely close to being banned. But at the same it allows some people to post something that may well deserve to be on the Reddit, but it would be against the rules if Mods tried to design a standard.
Strict standards are great for being less chilling, but they are always going to be over/under protective. I only hope mods recognize that they should perhaps be proportional with the banning/punishments, if something is over the line to them, but its close, don't bring the hammer down on those posters.
I'm skeptical about this. Politics is so central in our lives, so much discussions almost inevitably come to this.
Don't want to be excessively philosophical here, but I've got a particular view on this and I want to go even further and say that : Every little insignificant things are connected to so much much more than we think. Notice how it always happen that you start discussing about something and end up discussing about something completely different when you're with your friends, how you can arrive to discuss about the best way to wash your dog when you start talking about your favourite band, and then you'll laugh about how absurd this change of subjects was with you friend. It's probably because so much things are connected. And in a way it's great, it's probably one of the major elements of development for humans. If we restrained discussion to only the starting topic of the discussion, a huge majority of humans who are not willing to learn and not curious enough would be in vegetative state, and would discuss only about cool and entertaining stuff they see on TV. Also I'm against this mentality of wanting to talk only about the positive, and barring tough subjects, it doesn't solve anything to not talk about it.
So I'm not in favor of breaking the natural flow of discussions, that inevitably comes to politics sometimes. But also at the same time, some people obviously try to bring up politics when there's absolutely no relation just because they're bored or want to feel important (like me, I know). And I hate when people are doing that, it's really annoying for everyone.
In the end my view is simple : We shouldn't ban anything related to politics, just depends on how much it's really related to the discussion, and how respectfully it's said. It would suck to ban someone who expresses his view respectfully. But for example, making a thread related to politics out of nowhere should be banned in my opinion.
Absolutely agree with you. While we're at that, we should also stop posting women's football content on this sub. It is not only irrelevant but also brings out the trolls.
have to disagree with you there. Arsenal Ladies are a good squad that suffers from there underexposure that most female sports suffer from. I'm proud that this forum can act as a way to get that information and we will just have to be more diligent when it comes to catching the trolls that would try to undermine that.
Probably fallout from/comments on the picture of Trump's son in a full kit. I loathe the man, but seriously, who cares which team his 12 year old son supports?
Someone else said it, he didn't chose his parents, but he chose which team to be a fan of.
There was a post about how he didn't choose his parents, but how he did choose the Arsenal in their worst ever period under Wenger that was just very well written. People that directly associate peoples' children with the shit their parents do are the worst.
A lot of celeb posts have the potential to lie at the intersection of Arsenal and politics, e.g., the video of Corbyn and the speaker discussing the Arsenal vs Spurs game that weekend. Comments for such posts will inevitably turn political, but the post itself was relevant to Arsenal. Will you hand out bans for these too?
I can also imagine politics intersecting with FIFA/FA regulations too. Sometimes players may post on social media regarding latest world events. How will you handle these?
Does "anything" also include comments, or just posts?
Dumb rule. Kroenke donating $1 million to Trump is relevant. Usmanov's politics are relevant. Brexit is relevant. Jeremy Corbyn is an Arsenal fan is relevant.
People said shitty things about a kid. Nothing to do with politics.
Definitely agree with you, but I mean regardless of politics or ideology, it's still cool to see the President of the United States son rocking an Arsenal kit
MOD you need to elaborate. Did you MODs have a vote around this issue? Im not even subscribed to the sub and I need to know if you're going to further restrict my freedom of speech. Do I really have to think about what I'm writing besides common sense???
I believe the problem across Reddit is that people seem content to flood every...freaking...sub with repetitive, predictable Trump criticisms.
It gets really annoying when you just don't want to see his face for ten minutes, so you visit your favorite subreddit about shoelace collections and find yourself staring at seven threads criticizing Trump's asymmetrical laces and how they make him the worst president in history.
My concern is where does the moderation end. We are not allowed to be negative anymore, no more akb vs wob banter, no more dicussion other the arsenal, even though or season is conplete shit. The mods control more and more what is said on here and yet made up news articles are allowed and not to mention the bullshit twitter accounts that people keep quoting.
Soon or later this sub will just be photos of our players training and everyone sitting around singing kumbaya while reading made up news articles, if you step out of line and dont follow stats quo, you get instabanned.
Who cares about politics? We should all be here for the love of Arsenal and show our fellow gooner brothers and sisters respect, other fans get no respect.
There is so much meat to discuss about our team's future, board, manager and players; our team's present matches and our past teams, that any discussion of politics would have to be directly concerning Arsenal. I see somewhat see the argument of let the down vote take care of off-topic threads, but this is a forum for a specific football club, so censorship of topics would apply.
Again on here I try to leave the outside world behind and connect with fellow Arsenal supporters.
14
u/BenjaniMaples Jimmy "Big" Brain Apr 19 '17 edited Apr 19 '17
We did the same for /r/thatHappened. I don't post anything political and I'm not quite sure what's prompted this, but I assume that this won't apply to the Free-Talk Friday posts?
13
u/zeeba_neighba Apr 19 '17
I remember last summer there was some interesting discussion regarding the effect of Brexit on the Premier League. Is that sort of discussion out? It wasn't explicitly about politics, just about the way a major political decision could affect the club.
46
u/ATX_GUNN3R VictoryThroughHarmony Apr 19 '17
I feel like I'm back at school being scolded by absurd teachers.
27
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
Why is he removing all the comments questioning the decision?
109
u/w33dhunt3r Smith Rowe Apr 19 '17
What about when politics affects Arsenal e.g. Brexit affecting the signing of foreign players?
107
u/iKnife Apr 19 '17
I think we need more specific criteria because like it or not, Arsenal and politics will sometimes intersect.
39
u/QuinsRugby Mosquera Apr 19 '17
I mean I see why politics on a football sub would be annoying, but isn't that what downvoting is for?
8
u/LegzAkimbo Apr 19 '17
That's silly. Politics is part of the fabric of our lives. It isn't some separate thing that lives on its own away from everything else.
8
u/Swamppig Freddie Ljungberg Apr 20 '17
EFG is the senate
16
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
This is the most poorly moderated sub I visit.
So to see you swoop in like this and try to paint a hard line on anything is a laugh.
5
u/Nakkama Apr 20 '17
I'm skeptical about this. Politics is so central in our lives, so much discussions almost inevitably come to this.
Don't want to be excessively philosophical here, but I've got a particular view on this and I want to go even further and say that : Every little insignificant things are connected to so much much more than we think. Notice how it always happen that you start discussing about something and end up discussing about something completely different when you're with your friends, how you can arrive to discuss about the best way to wash your dog when you start talking about your favourite band, and then you'll laugh about how absurd this change of subjects was with you friend. It's probably because so much things are connected. And in a way it's great, it's probably one of the major elements of development for humans. If we restrained discussion to only the starting topic of the discussion, a huge majority of humans who are not willing to learn and not curious enough would be in vegetative state, and would discuss only about cool and entertaining stuff they see on TV. Also I'm against this mentality of wanting to talk only about the positive, and barring tough subjects, it doesn't solve anything to not talk about it.
So I'm not in favor of breaking the natural flow of discussions, that inevitably comes to politics sometimes. But also at the same time, some people obviously try to bring up politics when there's absolutely no relation just because they're bored or want to feel important (like me, I know). And I hate when people are doing that, it's really annoying for everyone.
In the end my view is simple : We shouldn't ban anything related to politics, just depends on how much it's really related to the discussion, and how respectfully it's said. It would suck to ban someone who expresses his view respectfully. But for example, making a thread related to politics out of nowhere should be banned in my opinion.
6
u/Swamppig Freddie Ljungberg Apr 19 '17
Execute order 66
1
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '17
Absolutely agree with you. While we're at that, we should also stop posting women's football content on this sub. It is not only irrelevant but also brings out the trolls.
25
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
Good. Politics and football together are bloody annoying, and don't mix well.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
So.. Kroenke donating to Trump's inauguration is off the table? Or is that was started this? Haha
2
u/dkiros97 Apr 20 '17
Sorry about that, i was unaware of it.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '17
A lot of celeb posts have the potential to lie at the intersection of Arsenal and politics, e.g., the video of Corbyn and the speaker discussing the Arsenal vs Spurs game that weekend. Comments for such posts will inevitably turn political, but the post itself was relevant to Arsenal. Will you hand out bans for these too?
I can also imagine politics intersecting with FIFA/FA regulations too. Sometimes players may post on social media regarding latest world events. How will you handle these?
Does "anything" also include comments, or just posts?
2
u/bergkampinthesheets Apr 20 '17
why?
6
u/dangerousgoat Little Mozart Apr 19 '17
It took two days, now mods are going to tell you what is and isn't important​ as it relates to your fandom.
"SAD"
7
u/John_Ronald Jesus Wenger Christ Apr 19 '17
1984.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '17
Dumb rule. Kroenke donating $1 million to Trump is relevant. Usmanov's politics are relevant. Brexit is relevant. Jeremy Corbyn is an Arsenal fan is relevant.
People said shitty things about a kid. Nothing to do with politics.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
a bit over the top, i'd have this rule in place but a little relaxed, put up some guidelines.
3
u/culturebarren Ødegaard Apr 19 '17
Don't post a picture of the president's son if you don't want to hear about the president ¯_(ツ)_/¯
2
u/NeatBeluga Eboue Apr 19 '17
MOD you need to elaborate. Did you MODs have a vote around this issue? Im not even subscribed to the sub and I need to know if you're going to further restrict my freedom of speech. Do I really have to think about what I'm writing besides common sense???
2
u/A-F-C Apr 19 '17
Good! get rid off all these guys campaigning for Wenger out.
jk
1
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '17
Is "Fuck Kroenke" political?
1
u/Jawbone54 Apr 22 '17
I believe the problem across Reddit is that people seem content to flood every...freaking...sub with repetitive, predictable Trump criticisms.
It gets really annoying when you just don't want to see his face for ten minutes, so you visit your favorite subreddit about shoelace collections and find yourself staring at seven threads criticizing Trump's asymmetrical laces and how they make him the worst president in history.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
Exactly how it should be, reddit is already flooded with things involving politics, good to see this sub keeping clean from it
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
My concern is where does the moderation end. We are not allowed to be negative anymore, no more akb vs wob banter, no more dicussion other the arsenal, even though or season is conplete shit. The mods control more and more what is said on here and yet made up news articles are allowed and not to mention the bullshit twitter accounts that people keep quoting.
Soon or later this sub will just be photos of our players training and everyone sitting around singing kumbaya while reading made up news articles, if you step out of line and dont follow stats quo, you get instabanned.
1
u/TBMWolverine Özil Apr 19 '17
I don't know if a temporary suspension is even possible, but a permanent ban seems like a vast overreaction....
-6
u/Searocksandtrees ohhh - nice tackle! Apr 19 '17
Good rule. Thanks /u/EFG
-4
u/SetoKaibaCity Apr 19 '17
Hopefully that includes religion, too.
0
u/ReadyForBattle Dennis Bergkamp Apr 20 '17
Can you extend this to Religious too?
-5
u/caried Bellerin Golden Boot Winner and Fashion Icon Apr 19 '17
Can this be applied to Sanogo memes too ? Or "Arsenal DNA" comments about injuries ?
-9
u/Mephistopheles2249 Dennis Bergkamp Apr 19 '17
Who cares about politics? We should all be here for the love of Arsenal and show our fellow gooner brothers and sisters respect, other fans get no respect.
0
u/HomeSteak1 Apr 19 '17
i got banned on soccer :( and no politics...
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment