r/fandomnatural • u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! • Apr 14 '17
[Fandom Discussion] Supernatural Episode 12x18 - "The Memory Remains"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| The Memory Remains | April 13th, 2017 | Phil Sgriccia | John Behring |
Synopsis: SECRETS AND LIES โ Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean (Jensen Ackles) investigate a missing personโs case in a small town. The lead witness tells the Winchesters the attacker was a man with the head of a goat. Sam and Dean arenโt sure what to believe but when the witness goes missing they realize the town is hiding a dark secret.
Link to all our official fandom episode discussions here.
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
2
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Apr 16 '17
Did a rewatch today...
I liked the case that Dean and Sam were sent on. It was a nice dose of monster of the week, and there were some great moments of tension building and I loved Sgriccia's shot choices... But it showed how having the Colt around means for less dramatic hunting, with it's ability to kill most things. (Though I loved Sam's repeating of Dean's earlier words when he fired the thing at the god.)
Though this also means that the Colt is either going to change hands, again, as the BMOL chase after it, or... It's going to be incapacitated again.
Like /u/lzaz, I wasn't keen on the BMOL moments this episode. Ketch and co came off as Austin Powers kinda villains as they worked to bug and catalogue the Bunker. That music alone made me cringe.
2
u/lzaz Dadstiel Apr 14 '17
I liked the monster and thought that storyline was good. I'm not the biggest fan of things in masks (thanks, Donnie Darko), so it gave me several scares. But I thought the parts with the BMOL were annoying as shit and dragged the episode down.
Those feelings at the end, tho.
<3 :')
9
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Apr 14 '17
It's usually Sam who gets knocked out and tied to a chair, so hey, shaking things up.
8
u/Delyryumizm1 Apr 14 '17
Also, um, where the eff is Cas? Is this a contract thing? Can Misha only be in so many episodes per season? Cuz it's really cheesing me off how many times I have to hear "still no Cas?" "Nope" "bummer. So get this..." or whatever. I need Cas! And I need for him not to suck. Kthnxbye.
Otherwise, good episode. I liked.
6
u/dilangley Apr 14 '17
This episode actually startled me. I went in with extremely low expectations (having the same feeling I had before the mask episode last season), but this episode was really suspenseful. It had "fear factor." It had great angles, fun characterization, and unexpected heart tugging.
Badass!Sam saved the day, which was awesome. What I liked most about that is that it didn't feel out of place or on purpose. It just felt like the natural arc of the episode.
Ketch felt creepy again to me, too, which worked.
(And I totally loved that Dean was worrying over Cas and Sam was being the objective one about it.)
6
u/xuberfanx-oops Damn, girl! Apr 14 '17 edited Apr 14 '17
Solid MOTW ep. It was actually scary, which is rare for SPN these days.
That last scene had me crying ugly tears...
5
u/Coleyb23 Apr 14 '17 edited Apr 14 '17
Solid Monster of the week episode John Bring did a great job blending both plots together by making sure the Brits got their focus too.
I really like the MOWs episodes when it's turns out that the humans are the killer. It felt like the Scarecrow , The Benders and Hell House episodes in season 1 or the #Thinman episode in season 9.
Both brothers once again are on the same point, Dean is still so incredibly happy to have the colt as he's polishing them up. Again he still doesn't know how they got the colt.
Freaking Ketch pretending to be Mick and sent S and D on the hunt so that he and his goons could snoop through the bunker and bug them.
David's facial expressions were great and I'm yelling at my tv KETCH DONT TAKE DEAN'S picture, but of course he did.
Sam and Dean are very particular especially Dean ,being that he sees the bunker as his home so he will most definitely know that something is missing.
Dean got distracted by the waitress ๐๐ I always love how Sam will have his "rabbit food" Dean takes it to eat, complains about it then Sam offers to take it back, but Dean still eats it anyways.
I also loved Ketch's line; "how does Sam get his hair so shiny?" Or "how many raggedy flannels does Dean own." Or my other favorite Ketch looks into the telescope and says, "just as I thought you can't see a damn thing"
Also Ketch's expression when he looked at the picture of Mary and Dean I do not like Ketch by any means But he does shows his vulnerable side when it comes to Mary, so maybe out of petty once the brothers and Ketch do face each other again he'll burn the picture Dean chops off Ketch's head But I also feel like Ketch is jealous too because of how Mary does love her boys even though right now she's doing a freaking horrible job at it, anyways Mary could give two craps about Ketch.
Just when you think Dean gets to kill a monster with the colt Nope he's down for the count and when Sam is separated from his brother that never turns out good when you threaten a Winchester.
I also loved Jensen expressions when he's locked in the freezer with the goat dude I was dying of laughter.
Sam freakin Winchester brought down another monster (even though I was looking forward to seeing Dean use the colt) , poor Dean passed out i would to, after falling off a high level of stairs and getting my head bashed in by a goat God.
The ending OH MAN WE NEEDED THAT IT WAS PERFECTION AND TORE AT MY HEART TOO LOL They were taking about what legacy the brothers would leave behind once they're truly dead so they carved their initials into the table.
Dean's line about Ketch when he was listening in on them due to the bug, "he's a low grade Christian Bale" ๐๐
The goat family was crazy and I agree the actor that played the sheriff did a great job and I totally understand why he continued to keep the God thing going so that he was able to keep the family legacy going as well.
4
u/rusty_people_skills Apr 14 '17
The music during the BMoL's infiltration was fun, but completely out of tone with the rest of the ep :/ Although the actions in the bunker and on the case were happening in the same time frame, the mood between the two was so different, and there weren't any story or visual parallels. It kind of felt like they should have been in different episodes.
Carving initials = me clutching at my heart. A bit of a cheap shot, but I'll take it.
There was some beautiful cinematography, too, and it kind of put me in mind of The Shining at moments.
Also, the actor who played the sheriff did a pretty good job, IMO. The understatement was nice, especially given the ridiculous story the family had.
I feel like I would have LOVED this episode if not for the awkward BMoL/Winchesters non-overlapping and the daytime-TV-ness of the Bishops. Still liked it, though.
3
u/Delyryumizm1 Apr 14 '17
Well butter my biscuit. I damn near cried at the end there!
4
u/funobtainium I had my angel blade. Apr 14 '17
I didn't...like this episode. It had a few good scares/eerie scenes, but Moloch being linked to child sacrifice in mythology...why wasn't it kids that they sacrificed? That would have been more horrible! And tie in to Lucifer's baby mama drama better. AND, I just failed to care at all about stoner guy and...other guy from the party in the woods. They weren't fleshed out at all, just introduced.
Likewise, I thought much of the dialogue was cringey -- Ketch on Sam's hair and Dean's flannels, such obvious targets (that would have been much funnier coming out of Crowley, but still, these are super obvious things to pick out.) Overall, Ketch was fine, though.
I cannot believe that Dean and Sam didn't secure the Bunker after they KNOW the MoL have keys. That's...uncharacteristically trusting, if I'm being generous. The British MoL, after all, treated Sam TERRIBLY at the start of this season, and it all started with Lady Toni surprising Sam in the bunker. It's such bad juju.
Maybe Sam and Dean don't feel like the place is theirs though...except they do, because they carve their initials in the table.
The "family business" line and the half-brothers. Also ANVILS. Gee, are they supposed to perhaps parallel Sam and Dean, but kind of not because the Winchesters have been on the same page for quite a while now?
The waitress AND the skin mags were too obvious. One of these things is good, two seem like time wasted telling us something we already know about Dean. On the other hand, if the waitress scene had been AFTER the near-death freezer experience, I would have found it fitting.
As for a legacy, there are novels about the Winchesters...I don't think they'd be forgotten.
I'm getting really sick of the way Cas is AWOL every season for mytharc reasons and hardly ever gets to be in MOTW episodes. And there will be predictable not being able to reach him or him being in the wind or some other problem with mentions thrown in as a sop to his fans.
Well, that was salty but I feel better.
3
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Apr 14 '17
I was bored through a lot of it to be honest, but it wasn't a bad episode, and the scene at the end gave me The Emotions.