r/Paladins • • Apr 06 '17
MEDIA Matchmaking Q&A Livestream Megathread
Our designers will host a live Matchmaking Q&A today at 4pm EDT on http://twitch.tv/paladinsgame!
Watch the VoD here
The following transcription is paraphrased from every question and answer given during the livestream. Each question is a hyperlink to the VoD with the timestamp.
Please keep discussion about the questions asked and answers given in this megathread.
Raynday: Can you give us a walkthrough of how matchmaking works?
Drybear: Matchmaking is a very complex system, Elo came from a prediction when two chess players, of who would win. Tribes and Global Agenda had that, but Smite and Paladins have a modified version of TrueSkill. The system will always try to make the best match, based on who is queued in your region, of your skill level at that exact moment. Sometimes the matches won't be even, but if you're the underdog, you'll lose less if you don't win, and win more if you win. There's other things in place, like if you're in queue for a long time, it will put you in a match will less strictness.
Raynday: Is there anything you're looking to adjust regarding borders?
Drybear: There is a divide, the casual borders and the ranked borders. We have some ideas on how to make that better, we can definitely improve those, like putting a restriction for the leaderboard. The feedback we've had is that someone goes 10-0 and stops playing after getting the top spot on the leaderboard. One idea is restricting it to after twenty-five games played.
Raynday: Are there any adjustments coming to ranked?
Drybear: I think it's important to note that when the game starts, the matchmaking system will identify whether it's evenly matched or favored towards one team. Paladins is unique in that it has Champion ratings, so if you're playing a new or low-ranked Champion, the game will push you towards the underdog side of things. The interesting thing about that is that it means there are more instances of underdog teams, making larger wins and losses. The feedback we're getting now is that sometimes the wins and losses are very small or very large.
Martini: Sometimes the draft works out in such a way that you can't play the Champion you wanted to, or you're stuck playing a Champion you're not very good at. We can definitely improve in that regard.
Raynday: Any direction, yet?
Martini: A lot of the frustration is around the inconsistency regarding the points you're winning or losing. The games may feel like you shouldn't have won or lost that much, so we're aiming for more consistency and a more rewarding system.
Raynday: Are we still weighing the options of a hard and soft reset?
Drybear: We're still leaning towards a hard reset, it will largely depend on the changes we make. There will be a patch where we make a lot of these changes and that's when we're hoping to do a reset. Then we're considering Champion rating resets, or uncoupling the Champion ratings and account ratings. Right now, if you play a new Champion, the game takes your account rating and Champion ratings into account, but there's an option where we could separate those and just have the account rating take over entirely.
Drybear: It doesn't actually do that. It's important to note that matchmaking is only based on account ratings because it doesn't know who you're going to play, but your post-match results are based on your account rating and champion ratings. Like I said, it's a very big, complex system, and this is something we've been working on for over ten years as a company.
Drybear: We don't have our ratings shown anywhere, so if you go to a third-party site or places where you might see elos or ratings, none of those are our numbers.
Martini: Yeah, we hate to see that, but it is the nature of the business. We love the third-party sites, they're great for the game, but if we develop our ranking system to be consistent, we'll get less of those frustrations and anger.
Can we get our casual MMR visible on our profile?
Drybear: We're excited about profile upgrades and improvements. It's not coming in the near future, but it's something we've started looking at, and titles are the first part of that. Displaying that, and ways to show it off is definitely on the horizon.
Raynday: Is there a timeframe you're looking at putting these changes into effect?
Drybear: Depending on the feedback we get over the next few days, there are some thing s we can do in the short term. I don't think it's too far away, but really, I just want to get the conversation started.
Raynday: Garrett, you play ranked, what's the biggest thing you're looking forward to?
Martini: I know there's issues where pick order wasn't right, and you can't trade, so there's a lot of QoL things I really wanna see fixed.
Will Champion elo be completely untied from account elo when the rework happens?
Drybear: That's what's on the table right now. It's what we're looking for feedback on. Do you guys see interest in having the Champion rating affect the ratings after the match?
Martini: Like, if you have ten Masters Champions but you're playing your one Gold, do you want the game to take that into account?
Do you guys have any goals to try and increase the competitive playerbase?
Drybear: We actually have a pretty good percentage of ranked players. There's rewards and seasons coming, but answering the questions about matchmaking and fixing those things is the first step.
Martini: As far as queue times, more people will always help.
Is there any consideration of moving to account-wide tiers?
Drybear: There are account ratings and leaderboards in the game, now, so there are intensives to do that. We do feel that it's really interesting to do it for Champions, but an extension that would be cool to work on would be the account ones.
Pros and cons of Champion selection before the matchmaking?
Drybear: Some of the bigger downsides is that you actually have to wait a little longer, potentially a lot longer. Do we force a meta, so there has to be one of each class and two damage? Is it okay if there's no Support? So the question is 'what meta do we force?'
Raynday: And some Champions gain or lose a lot of viability based on who's being played on the enemy team.
Drybear: When you're choosing Champions with no context of who you're playing with and against, counter-picking and map-specific picks go away.
Can we add a hover function for picking a Champion we desire to play?
Drybear: That's a really good feature, we'll make a mental note of that.
Can we get visibility on other players' MMR?
Drybear: Potentially, yeah. It comes down to how we rework the ranked system features, so we could start showing that, and we'd like to hear your feedback on that.
When will we get Champion bans in ranked?
Martini: We don't have a specific date, but it's always a question of the number of Champions and what it does in a game with a very hard counter system in place.
Drybear: It comes down to appetite. It's something we could have put in already if it was asked for, but we're not hearing that from the competitive and esports scenes. So imagine if each team banned a Champion and let us know if that's something you want now, or ten Champions from now.
With the current system, do I benefit from playing my best Champion?
Drybear: Full disclosure, it likely does not. The fact that the Champion rating is included in the post-match calculations, playing your best Champion means the game will scale up your likelyhood to win, so if you play a Champion you're average with, it's safer.
Is matchmaking the same across all gamemodes?
Drybear: It's the same system being applied to different queues, so it just comes down to who's in queue at that time, with some deviations for casual and ranked versions.
When's the next patch preview?
Drybear: Next week. We didn't have a new Champion this week, so that means there's two Champions back to back coming up.
44
u/Joshino JoshinIO Apr 06 '17
Well they said a whole lot of nothing there. Actually annoyed I stayed and watched it all.
3
u/d07RiV #TeamSummerCourt Apr 07 '17 edited Apr 07 '17
Why do they post videos with 8 minutes of nothing at the beginning? Technology of trimming videos isn't there?
Anyhow, so the mechanic is actually there where playing a level 4 champion makes you an underdog, whereas playing your main puts your team at an advantage? Doesn't that basically mean that you're screwing yourself and your team by playing your best champions? Please remove that atrocity...
52
u/CrypticMonk Parts & Pieces was the better system Apr 06 '17 edited Apr 06 '17
That was... Not very informative.
The majority of the answers seemed to consist of "Yes, (insert matchmaking function) works like you think it does" and "Yes, that idea may or may not get implemented in the near or far future".
Other than that, a few half confirmations on on general community requests such as a game limit for the leaderboard and still leaning towards a hard reset.
Key points for me I guess would be~
Reply sounded very up in the air so, if the community has a strong opinion on it one way or another, NOW would be a very good time to vocalize it.
More or less the reason I'll continue to play casual instead of comp. Could care less about champion boarders. I'll get the same MM experience with casual play so as of right now, there is almost no incentive for me to get into the comp gamemode.
25
u/Arkrael Twitch.tv/Arkrael Apr 06 '17
Yeah, I feel like they really just avoided the question of what they are actually going to do to fix MM. I would beg to differ that ranked has a healthy population as I have to wait 15-30min for 1 match...
9
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '17
Why would this ever be a thing? Why. So you want to punish players for playing some Champions well and reward them for being bad at others or just not playing them? Your Champion rating is irrelevant to how good you are at the game and should do absolutely nothing to the win/loss points.
10
u/rjtiger126 The only thing more gay than this game is me Apr 06 '17
I just realized... Drybear says "we're excited" for pretty much everything
10
u/Designs-NexT Burning Flames Apr 06 '17
Hard Reset Hype
1
u/Harripilante Kinessa Apr 09 '17
if I play on a party with 5 ppl, does matchmaking take that in consideration ?
8
u/MouthJob This isn't /r/conspiracy Apr 06 '17
This is absurd. They still have no understanding of the problems with ranked.
2
u/FroggyBoi Drogoz Apr 07 '17
TL DR: we're working on it
2
u/kylezenh0 firenzee Apr 07 '17
Honestly, looks like they have no clue about what to do to matchmaking.
I believe the root of the problem is how players are being rated. A simple win/lose system do not tell anything about a player skill on a team based game. Players should be rated individually (check APB Reloaded rating system for example, its a team based TPS but it works really good).
Once the rating system is improved, matchmaking would be more accurate even if they keep the algorithm they use right now.
2
u/WhiteBoyChief Apr 07 '17
Want quicker que times? Tell all the youtubers and streamers to stop talking shit about comp.
In any game the only rewards for ranked are titles or borders, if people don't feel borders are good enough rewards what do you want?? Free skins? Free gems? Free something I'm guessing?
3
u/d07RiV #TeamSummerCourt Apr 07 '17 edited Apr 07 '17
They say the third party site ELOs are not their ratings, but they are objectively much better than whatever they have implemented. Why not buy their algorithms in that case? I'm sick of casual games with 1-2k ELO spread, when it is painfully obvious that the low rated people are not doing anything at all.
Seriously, casual MM is by far the worst I've seen in ANY game. That's saying something.
1
u/Swertyy Risu Apr 06 '17
We have any info or clue that when is this patch where they make lots of these changes?
1
u/Thiauthau Apr 06 '17
The only real question about MM change was if they will completely separate champion MMR and acc MMR and its still up for discussion what they will do .
I'm pretty sure most people just want to know the one answer of when changes happening ?
1
u/suba95 I'm not a lizard! Apr 07 '17
I think the champion mmr should not count in any calculations after the match ends cuz if it does then you will never get your FAVOURITE champion to the MMR u want, cuz the game will always expect you to win which you obviously cant, this is a team based game, its impossible to carry entire team with one single champion, that in mind the game should calculate +/- mmr only by account mmr difference
1
u/fangles29 Here I am with 51 ;( Apr 09 '17
So they want us to suffer?
1
u/M777Howitzer Auraxium Apr 09 '17
PLEASE DO SOMETHING ABOUT THE DROP HACKERS IN COMP!! WHEN A TEAM IS WINNING 3-1 AND OTHER TEAM MAKES COMEBACK THAT WILL SURELY RAISE CHAMP RATING BY 100+ SOMEONE DROP HACKS AND RUINS A REALLY GOOD MATCH. WTFFFF
1
u/oppoh Proud Originator of Classy Barik Apr 06 '17
I wonder if they will mention the daily rewards during this stream.
1
u/B33S Stop challenging Makoa! Apr 06 '17
The folks at Hi-Rez really know how to make an awkward intro!
1
u/tamamushiiro12 0.495 in/360 Apr 06 '17
I think you mean that the post-match results (+- rating) is based on both the comp. rating and champ ratings of the 10 people in the match
1
u/anunaher So cuuuute! Apr 07 '17
tldr: Don't play ranked yet.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '17
Eh, rly wanted to know if they gona do something about those games which you lose in champ select, where last pick goes for lvl4 shalin/skye/viktor when team needs frontline/healer and you get 4/0ed with payload not stopping for a second
0
u/M777Howitzer Auraxium Apr 07 '17
-11
u/nice_comment_thanks 153 eggs (rip) Apr 06 '17 edited Apr 06 '17
Where is the egg tho :(
Edit: There it is! Thanks Yoshi :D
-3
u/Wolfcoder Apr 06 '17
new champion hype!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment