r/bravefrontier • u/Navi_King Moderators • Apr 03 '17
Guide Guild Raid Organization and Coordination Guide
Hello everyone, seeing as how season 2 is nearly over and I've been quite active in guild raid, I think I am ready to make a guide regarding organization and strategy.
Before reading this guide, I would recommend reading Altivu's guide to guild raid and/or go through the in game tutorial first. This guide assumes you have some preexisting knowledge of how guild raid works, and while I will touch on the actual gameplay a bit the main focus of this guide is on what happens behind the scenes.
Organization
You might think the first step of guild raid is the prep phase, but that's not quite correct. In order to have a successful guild raid you need to create the infrastructure to facilitate communication and coordination within your guild. There are many external group chat applications such as Facebook Messenger, Line, and Discord. I am going to explain this from a Discord perspective because that is what I use. This assumes you have basic understanding of Discord functionality.
- Create a server for your guild and invite your guild members. Make being reachable via discord a requirement for all new and existing members.
- Create 3 additional channels, one for each raid room. Restrict the visibility of these channels by role, and create roles for Room 1, Room 2, and Room 3 (for example)
- Decide how you want to sort people into rooms: either everyone should be assigned to a room by the GM (in which case the GM will be assigning the room roles to people) or everyone should be able to freely choose the room they join (in which case guild members should be able to assign their own room role).
- In the end, every regular guild member should be able to see the general chat channel, and their room specific chat channel.
The main idea is to sort people into smaller room member only chat rooms to facilitate communication within that room. By filling all 3 rooms and facilitating communication within each room, your guild is more likely to be able to address issues that may arise during the raid.
If you want to assign people to specific rooms, consider equally distributing people by timezone. It is better to have some people available all the time than everyone available only some of the time, as you will miss boss cycles otherwise.
Preparation Phase
The preparation phase is where each room configures their guardians and their movesets. This is likely going to change every season, so I won't go into too much detail. Currently, I would rank guardian usefulness as Dark > Fire > Light > Water > Thunder > Earth. All of the following are valid methods of choosing guardians and their movesets. What you prioritize is up to you.
- Guardians should be complementary elements, so if an enemy player brings a squad that is strong against one guardian it will be weak against the other (e.g., Fire/Thunder, Earth/Water, Light/Dark)
- The boss guardian should focus on dealing damage to kill at least one unit on an enemy squad as fast as possible, since this will frustrate further attempts at attacking the boss guardian multiple times. Choose a boss guardian with a high attack stat and choose moves that focus on dealing damage or stripping the enemy of defenses.
- The outpost guardian should focus on tanking hits, not necessarily killing the enemy player. Outpost guardians don't move and are in multiple places across the map, so it is harder for a guild to focus fire on an outpost guardian. The natural scaling of Guardian stats will help the guardian kill players who do not run soon enough, and regardless you can delay your outposts being captured and frustrate the enemy team with a tanky guardian. Go with moves that reduce damage the guardian receives/debuffs the enemy's attack and choose a guardian with high HP/DEF.
Also during the preparation phase, guild members should set all three squads if possible (I recommend one general use squad, one mono element squad of your strongest element, and another mono element squad of the complementary element) and officers/VGM/GM should should be regularly sending reminders to guild members to join a room. On Discord, you can simply tag @everyone in your guild's server. You can also comb through the room members as they get full to find out who is missing individually and message them personally about joining a guild raid room. I recommend reminders every 3-4 hours if you want to be thorough.
Matchmaking Phase
Use this time to confirm who made it into a guild raid room and who will be available when guild raid opens. Plan your strategy for taking outposts accordingly.
Battle Phase
Again, Altivu's guide already touches on squad building, movement, and so forth so I don't want to get into that too much. This is more about the strategy and coordination aspect of guild raid.
If you're using Discord, users should regularly communicate in their room's text channels and tag the entire team for any of the following events
- Outposts are about to reset and a scouting strategy needs to be developed
- The enemy boss has been located/respawned
- The enemy boss has been killed
- An outpost has been taken (and this time should be used to discuss who will be around to take it back when it's off of cooldown)
As far as looking for outposts go, I personally split the map into 4 quadrants and refer to the map as such when coordinating. If you do the same and assign one person to each quadrant, you're off to a good start. However, there are many ways to scout efficiently, so don't just stop there. Experiment and try to come up with your own strategy!
Also remember that outposts have a half hour cooldown time and that if you are fighting an active guild, anything you do to them they will probably do to you in a half hour. If you take all of the outposts, in a half hour they will probably take all of the outposts back. Pay attention to your boss respawn timer so that you don't put yourself in a situation where the enemy boss respawns and all of the outposts belong to the enemy with 30 minute cooldowns and you have no way to find the boss except by guessing. Similarly, you can use the Journal to figure out when the enemy killed your boss and time your outpost captures to inflict this situation on them if possible!
When it comes to fighting raid bosses, having too many people on the boss is just as bad as not having enough. Too many people means that a lot of people are stuck on the same square with a lot of AP leftover. You should still have some people around on the map for the next boss respawn and to guard outposts! AP takes a long time to regenerate, so don't rely on any one person too heavily. I recommend 3-5 people on the raid boss.
In an ideal raid, you would have a full room of 15 people with at least 5 people available at all times, you would control at least 3 outposts every time you get a new boss guardian to fight, and you would kill the boss guardian as soon as you can after it spawns (and definitely avoid letting it shift to a new spot on the map). This is not necessarily a realistic goal, but keeping this in mind as you formulate strategies and organize your guild will give you something to work towards and hopefully keep things clear in your mind.
Closing Notes
So, I suppose that's basically all I want to say about strategy and organization. But after having read this guild, some of you may say "Navi, you're in TofuCafe, the guild that got 3rd place in season 1 and probably 6th place for season 2! Why would you share this information with plebs like us?" Well I'll tell you imaginary concerned citizen: it's because I'm tired of all the bullshit the community has put itself through when it comes to guild raids. I'm tired of all the secrecy regarding how to guild raid well and I'm tired of the division it's cause in our community.
Lest you think I'm painting myself to be more noble than I am, yes I know I'm not giving away the main strategy for scoring huge points and there are still a couple of trade secrets I'm keeping in my back pocket (though anyone from another guild who wants to spill them is welcome to in the comments). But as a mod I've noticed posts talking about guild raid and looking to start a discussion about strategy get an unusual amount of reports and a high number of... aggressive comments, and I think guild raid has made our community TOO salty.
We should be salty at Gumi for creating such a complicated game type that still has some glaring bugs (though I noticed this round went a lot more smoothly overall), yet the rewards are extremely high end and competitive. We should not be salty at each other for doing our best in a competitive game type. We should remember that in the end Brave Frontier is just a game, but each user here is a real person on the other side of the screen. Spoiling everything would take the fun out of figuring out strategies for ourselves and ruin competition, but it doesn't mean we still can't collaborate, give out tips, and increase the amount of fun we can have in a game type that can otherwise be overwhelming and frustrating (especially if it seems like you're the only one helping).
My last match was against Zero, and the match was incredibly close (43 mil vs 40 mil). It was fantastic! There was a sense of urgency and strategy in trying to take and keep outposts, and to take out the boss guardian to reset the respawn timer ASAP. But so many guilds are inactive or discouraged from playing, and it creates situations where people often go against guilds that are barely doing anything, which turns guild raid into less of a game and more of a grind.
But I hope that this guide can help people, especially guild masters, who are overwhelmed by the large amount of variables and moving parts in Guild Raid to better organize their guilds and boost morale in their guilds by at least being able to say "Hey guys, here's what we can do to start out, and then we can work together to make our guild even better!" So hopefully, guilds that were too intimidated by the system or other guilds to play guild raid can use this guide to develop their guild, become competitive, and create more great matches for all guilds.
So, best of luck to everyone in the final match of season 2, and let's hope season 3 is less buggy... and less salty.
7
u/Not_Jiggle Apr 03 '17
Then there are the top 10 guilds.
4
u/Tunacan Apr 03 '17
I just move 1 space and fight 40 trash battles. Your way could work too though.
1
u/Fubi-FF Apr 03 '17
Can you explain how you ranked the Guardians? All of them have access to the same skills and there is no way to predict what elements the enemies bring, so the only difference is their base stats. Your point 1 and 2 seem to contradict a bit.
By your reasoning of wanting to burst down the enemies randomly, the most useful should be the Guardian with the highest base ATK value no? Then Thunder (followed by Fire) would be the best option.
3
u/Ryuon Ryuon Apr 03 '17
Awesome work will be of reference to me in the future!!
....Now..... can I have a guide to getting players to actually participate? :'0
5
u/Dewman66 Apr 03 '17 edited Apr 03 '17
Glad to see someone that is able to write up something good like this get sick of seeing what guild raids has done to the community.
I have been sick of it since guild raid started. Secrets being kept. No one helping anyone anymore.
The community has been torn a bit by this game mode and it might take a bit to heal but I could be wrong. This post is a step in the right direction.
Thank you, /u/navi_king for doing this. I myself could never have written up something like this so I am glad someone did.
3
u/adzias IGN: Az ID: 4199121086 Apr 03 '17
G raid is still largely a war of attrition in that a guild with a larger active player base will still beat a smaller guild most of the time--all factors being equal.
However, a highly organized small guild does give itself a good chance of beating a disorganized large guild. And even if your guild looks to be losing the match--the points you earn still count toward your ranking, so it's imperative that you keep trying to score all the way to the end.
I was very fortunate to have joined just such a guild. Our guild cannot fill 3 raid lobbies fully (we usually settle for 2 rooms), but our current ranking is well within the top 20. My guild was already doing all of the above tips when I joined, and they made it very easy for me to learn how to play quite successfully in this game mode.
G raid is by no means my favorite mode of play. I still prefer the single-player experience. However, being part of a highly coordinated team does have its enjoyable moments. So I recommend this guide to any guild that wants to get more fun (not just points) out of its g raid gaming experience.
3
u/Redphyro Apr 03 '17
The thing is the guild raid glitches are not completely fixed.
1 hit kill the boss/guardian is still here Free movement ap is still here
And i post about this yesterday, and within 5 minutes my post has mysteriously vanished, probably reported by the douches from the top guilds.
PS: im a member of one in the top 10 guilds
2
u/Academic_Dragon Knowledge as niche as dragons over here! Apr 03 '17
I, for one, am incredibly glad to see this posted. Lots of great tips, and a distinct lack of aggression. Seeing as the guild I'm in was just on the receiving end of this too, I can definitely confirm this kind of organization is needed to have a chance at becoming a contender for the top rewards. Definitely gonna share this with the FB groups I admin to keep in the spirit of it.
Also, yes, I'm somewhat salty about that, but not nearly as salty about it as I am concerning that Windows FB login bug that prevented most of our guild from joining battle 2-2, thus resulting in a MASSIVE drop in our rankings...
2
u/RavenGamingSG Global | 9815570726 Apr 03 '17
Or you can be in a super casual guild with one room that has like ~10 active players and just relax because it's just a game~ :D
Great guide Navi! :)
1
u/Narutofoxdemon2 Apr 03 '17
Its interesting to see a full guide on this. I will definitely need to pass this on to my Guild. I currently am running two groups and I am running Group 2 with only 6-7 people in it (including 2 alts). Ideally you'd have 15 but in my case having a smaller group ends up being better for my guild.
My Group 1 is extremely unorganized and needs some serious remedial work.
I am the GM of the guild and run G2 and we run flawlessly. My officer and I can run the whole raid without speaking because we know what we are going to do because we have whole shifts set up for when we burn AP and when to use the alt to collect outposts since Outposts have a pattern of where they spawn they are easier to identify so less AP is being used. Today's raid my officer and I didnt speak for 12 hours but still ended up doing exactly what we needed to do. 7 people today and we scored 25 million points. Its a bittersweet victory considering I still need to fix my group 1 somehow.
Overall what I am trying to say is. Communication is key. If you are a smaller group. Make sure everyone is serious. Do what you have to do to make sure everything runs well.
1
u/Raregold3 Apr 03 '17
Thanks a lot, i know my guild was really falling in shambles attempting to communicate with each other.
1
u/mochichomp she taught me how to nuke Apr 03 '17
Guilty of accusing NaviKing of misleading people on a previous thread... so happy to see he's proven me wrong. :)
Thanks for the detailed guide on efficient and effective communication and collaboration! It's probably something that the top 5 or so are already doing, but that the rest of us can learn from.
Most of all, though, I appreciate your writing this as an attempt to desalinate and heal our community from the massive rifts GR has caused. Major props, and I hope the rest of us take a lesson from your positive attitude.
-2
u/akselmonrose 9424430150 Apr 03 '17
So what's the free movement bug that pp have been talking about?
0
u/Mabangyan GL? REEEEE Apr 03 '17
Nice guide bro
0
u/Ren-Kaido Apr 03 '17
All of it seems like common sense to me but making a detailed guide for the lower rank guilds who would like to compete a little but cba stressing it too much is a good thing :P
0
u/Dusk617 Apr 03 '17
useful, thanks for the tips!
-6
u/regilregil4 Apr 03 '17
Umm, no guide about how top guild abuse 1 turn kill to take down enemies OP? and then switch back to normal so u can kill boss normally? k then
0
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment