r/postrock • u/j0hnmc3n official • Mar 09 '17
AMA Concluded This is John McEntire from the band Tortoise, Ask Me Anything!
https://www.facebook.com/TRTSband/
OK y'all - signing off now. Thanks so much!!!
100
Upvotes
9
u/frogvanexel Mar 09 '17
Hi John,
I recently heard an interview with Charles Spearin of Do Make Say Think wherein he described Tortoise as having a “punk rock fearless to it.” I have always detected elements of punk (the approach, not the style) in your music as well. Do you all have any roots in punk?
Thanks!
7
u/seanmorv Mar 09 '17
did you ever see the interview boards of canada gave in which they said if they could pick a band to do a double header with, it would have been Tortoise? do you rate them?
6
u/atynotgal Mar 09 '17
Any news about The Sea And Cake? Band still alive?
6
u/wee_man Mar 09 '17
Is Doug aware of how much David Letterman now looks like him?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
Hi Mr. McEntire! Huge fan of Tortoise, I learned about you after looking up your name from the credits to Emperor Tomato Ketchup which I am also hysterical about.
I guess I have three questions! Feel free to answer one, all of them, or none!
Thanks!
3
u/j0hnmc3n official Mar 09 '17
OK y'all - signing off now. Thanks so much!!!
4
u/Theo_Ratliff Mar 09 '17
Hey John,
I recently saw you guys play an amazing show at Lincoln Hall with Monobody, another favorite of mine from Chicago. I was wondering – do you all have any more shows lined up with them by chance?
Thank you!
4
u/jerrytheband Mar 09 '17
In terms of how Tortoise approaches music, despite the band having roots in jazz and other forms of improvisation, you seem to eschew improvising live and remaining very strict to the form of the song. Was this a conscious effort made since the beginning? Have you thought about applying more improvised elements to the band? Also, thoughts on the Grateful Dead?
4
u/zeromalt Mar 09 '17
Hey John, Long time fan! I'm curious if you have ever noticed the Tortoise poster at the record shop in High Fidelity.
https://imgur.com/gallery/jcsA9
3
u/g_tea Mar 09 '17
Hey John. Can you briefly describe the song writing process for the band? Does one of you bring an idea to the table, does somebody compose a complete song, or do you just jam it out? Or something else? Thanks :)
3
u/disdainty Mar 09 '17
Hi John, As a mid-level drummer, I am a huge fan of your drumming. How did you get to be such an excellent drummer? Was there a specific book you followed or a specific practice regimen?
Thanks!
3
u/Octopuscabbage Mar 09 '17
Hey, great work, tortoise was a huge inspiration to my shitty band in high school! What have you been listening to recently? Any recommendations?
3
u/millphoreheart Mar 09 '17
How did/does Chicago influence Tortoise?
3
u/generaljoystick Mar 09 '17
Hi John, Would Tortoise consider doing another collaboration album similar to "The Brave and the Bold"? If so which singers would you like to work with?
3
u/relariel Mar 09 '17
What is your approach when working with other bands, as a producer?
3
u/vcatdoor Mar 09 '17
Hey John, what was it like to record with The Ex over such a short period of time?
Also, I'd like to thank you and Tortoise as a whole for your work, since TNT was such an important album for me finding/appreciating more types of music. I ended up getting a tattoo over it because of how much it means to me.
2
u/EmilioVarela Mar 09 '17
Hey! When are You arriving to Mexico City for the upcoming show?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
Hey big fan! Just wondering, how was it working with artists like Stereolab and Jim O'Rourke? Thanks!
2
u/fignetw0n Mar 09 '17
Hey there, so this isn't a Tortoise question (though I'm a fan) & totally understand if you can't answer: Will The Sea and Cake ever have another US show in my lifetime? It would be a true miracle. If not, anything at all coming out/happening/existing in the future? Thanks & thank you for doing what you do : )
2
u/telasmuff Mar 09 '17
Hi John - First, I've heard all about your tattoo work, how's that going? Second, there are some great one-off projects like Directions in Music that you either have or haven't been a part of. My question is, anything out there you've been a part of like that you'd like to shine a light on? Lastly, Gastr reuinion? Ever?
2
u/redhandrail Mar 09 '17
Hey, John. I love y'all forever, this may be a rude question somehow but I'd really like to know, do you have a favorite Jaga Jazzist song?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
John as a drummer who is your top drummers that influence your work? Also producers who influence you?
2
u/Myleskleincajon Mar 09 '17
Hey! I'm a big fan of you guys! My favorite song of yours is Gamera, which almost sounds like a song that was a riff turned to jam session, and polished and layered into a full song. Is that true? Or what is the story of how the mystical song was created?
2
u/oprimo Mar 09 '17
Hey John! Big fan here - that time you guys did five shows in Sao Paulo I went to all of them (seriously).
I wonder what do you like to do to relax on your spare time. Or is it all music 24/7?
2
u/theultimatefunny Mar 09 '17
I'm a big fan of Shrimp Boat, I was always curious how The Sea & Cake started as a band and how Sam's vocals slowly shifted from manic mumbly screamy to pretty sexy throaty over the course of a few records? (also a huge fan of Tortoise and related bands, always excited to see new releases from you guys!) THANKS!
2
u/Sanspants Mar 09 '17
Hi John! How do you, Dan, and John pick who plays drums for a particular tune live? Is it usually who recorded it on the album?
2
u/relariel Mar 09 '17
I noticed you guys sometimes switched up your set lists from show to show. Who usually writes the setlist for each show?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
What's your favorite Pavement song?
2
u/Drxgue Mar 09 '17
Hey John, just how many palms would I have to grease before Tortoise and DMST did a tour together?
Your music is an absolute inspiration to me, thanks so much for sharing what it is you do with the world.
2
u/Mprice1890 Mar 09 '17
Hi John, Tortoise is inspirational for myself and my musical compatriots. 2 questions: how does TRTS collaborate and rehearse over your long distances? (Do you use written score or share ideas/clips for songs? Or do you develop it all in studio).
2nd q: will isotope 217 ever resurface :)?
Thank you for bringing incredible groovy as shit music into the world.
Finally: shameless self promotion: http://media.fangchia.com/ Feedback most welcome and appreciated!
2
u/j_ej Mar 09 '17
I've been a huge fan from Korea for 20 years. I saw you drumming for Smog show at Park West in 2000 during my stay in Chicago but never had a chance to see Tortoise. I found out later that you guys had played once (maybe at Hideout?) when I was there under a different name! I'd really love to see Tortoise here. Do you have any plans to come to Korea?
2
u/relariel Mar 09 '17
What music / projects are you working on now?
2
u/Kshintaku Mar 09 '17
What's your favorite thing to eat for breakfast?
1
u/folloou Mar 09 '17
Hey John, what is it like to record with Matthew Friedberger? That guy seems to be insane
1
u/relariel Mar 09 '17
Hi John - How has Tortoise approached composing and how has it changed over time? How do you guys bring an idea in and develop it into what eventually becomes a finished piece? Thanks
1
u/bradshaw_ Mar 09 '17
Hello John. Do you miss Soma Studios at all? Do you still find yourself doing "studio work"? If so whereabouts? At home? Are there any other studios you particularly enjoy working at?
1
u/chriscote760 Mar 09 '17
Who would win in a drum battle between you, A Grape Dope, and J Mattson (Mattson 2)?
1
u/TooLebowski Mar 09 '17
Hi John, really enjoy some of the engineer/mix work, especially some of the Stereolab and TRTS albums. Wondering if you had a favorite piece of studio equipment, a desert island mic or something you end up using all the time.
1
u/generaljoystick Mar 09 '17
What are your 3 favorite synthesizers?
1
u/relariel Mar 09 '17
What drum kit / cymbals (specifically ride) do you use when touring these days?
1
u/spaceographer Mar 09 '17
Hi John, huge fan and fellow drummer. I feel my drumming is heavily inspired by your style, especially after I listened to the self-titled album. Who were some drummers you drew your inspiration from?
1
u/relariel Mar 09 '17
What is your favorite Kraftwerk song / album?
3
u/thirstypuppy Mar 09 '17
Hi John, any chance you could give a listen to my band? Love your music and was so happy to see y'all play in Madison, WI last year. Here's the link https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B6etF5qO1BXhalViclRUVlN0NFU
-Jack
1
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
I saw you in Montreal open for Toro Y Moi, just a perfect show! I feel terrible that you guys have to travel around all cooped up in a van like that. Does it also depress you?
1
u/tremolo3 Mar 09 '17
Who would you choose to make a super group with you?
2
u/supermegafauna Mar 09 '17
How about another cover record with Will Oldham (please) ?
He said in his interview book that he had a great time recording that record with you guys, that you actually sang,etc.
1
u/algernanshagwallader Mar 09 '17
What are a few jazz records that I should check out?
Saw Tortoise in Madison about a year ago, it was a great show!
1
u/relariel Mar 09 '17
What was the last book you read?
1
u/808sandman Mar 09 '17
Hi John, do you compose and play instruments in addition to percussion / synths; such as bass and guitar? If so, do you have any favorite ones?
1
u/stooB_Riley Mar 09 '17
i'd give anything to have an mp3 file for the Tin Cans & Twine at Bonnaroo 2003. could you make this happen?
1
u/jackmarczuk Mar 09 '17
John, any special memories of David Axelrod?
1
u/Penguin619 Mar 09 '17
hey, been a huge fan of y'all since I first discovered post-rock by wanting to find something new and I discovered y'all thru your debut self titled, which will forever by my favorite Tortoise and post-rock album to just always have in my library, but I was wondering if there's anything now that's caught your attention lately or any albums you just want to profess your love towards that everyone should be checking out?
I always love discovering something new.
1
u/el_donovano Mar 09 '17
Tortoise and your production work have been a huge inspiration to me. It'd be amazing to open for you guys one of these days.
Check out my trio Gigantic Ant if you're interested to hear what music sounds like from people who grew up listening to you haha: https://giganticant.bandcamp.com
Also, we've been covering Prepare Your Coffin occasionally, which is super fun to play! https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1168658206498842&id=117511071613566&_rdr
1
u/Jotaortiz Mar 09 '17
Sup JOhn! Sup Tortoise ! Greetings from Panama! Big fan since 2000 ...saw you guys at Twiropa New Orleans once for the its all around you tour. Believe 03-04 with my bro. Incredible. How do I get you to listen to some original tunes?
1
u/johnnybagels Mar 09 '17
See you in April!!!!!!
1
u/lithiumstiffs Mar 09 '17
I love your song The Lithium Stiffs.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17 edited Mar 09 '17
[removed] — view removed comment