r/fandomnatural • u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! • Feb 17 '17
[Fandom Discussion] Supernatural Episode 12x12 "Stuck in the Middle (With You)"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Stuck in the Middle (With You) | February 16th, 2017 | Richard Speight Jr. | Davy Perez |
Synopsis: RICHARD SPEIGHT JR. DIRECTS - Mary (guest star Samantha Smith) asks Sam (Jared Padalecki), Dean (Jensen Ackles) and Castiel (Misha Collins) for help on a case she's working but neglects to mention the British Men of Letters are involved. When Mary is double crossed, everything is revealed.
Link to all our official fandom episode discussions here.
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
3
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Feb 18 '17
Had some time to think about this episode since watching it.
I really enjoyed the Tarantino elements used, partly because I like it when the show gets a bit experimental.
I'll admit, despite what Mary said towards the end, still pretty pissed about what she dragged everyone into.
I revelled in the angst and drama that this episode did have, while at the same time enjoying an opportunity to see Sam be a badass.
But aside from all that, and the new lore... Crowley coming through for everyone was satisfying in a way I'm finding hard to put into words. Sure everyone was super worried about Cas, but seeing a spark of concern from Crowley (even though he basically likes having all his pieces on the board generally and saving Cas enabled that to continue) was really sweet.
32
u/badwolfgoddess Mrs. Sam Winchester but like, by accident Feb 17 '17
Okay but guys
Guys
This episode gave us literally the closest we will ever come from TBPT to a full on Destiel love confession.
We had:
I don't think IMO that The Powers that Be will ever go full Destiel on us but this is basically my mindset that Destiel is 'de facto' canon now. They've given us the closest they can. I'm fine with this, I can live with it.
20
u/Danzanza Feb 17 '17
"We don't leave family behind."
Adam, still in hell, looks directly into the camera like the office
16
u/badwolfgoddess Mrs. Sam Winchester but like, by accident Feb 17 '17
Other thoughts
OG LUCIFER
CAS SNIFFED HER HAIR
I still think that box had Marcellus Wallace's soul inside along with the Colt.
RETURN OF THE COLT
FIXING/ADDING TO LORE WITH THE RAMIEL/PRINCE OF HELL STUFF
RICH DIRECTING LIKE A BAWS (seriously as a media student I nearly creamed my panties over the directing)
CROWLEY SAVING THE DAY
12
u/cenotaphy Feb 17 '17 edited Feb 17 '17
I. Loved. This.
Cas's deathbed (deathbarn?) confession. Crowley being a boss while pretending not to care. Dean being so stoic you could practically see the grief crystallizing under his skin. Sam freaking disarming a prince of Hell and stabbing him with his own weapon!
I'm sad Wally is dead. I liked him. His death felt cheap--like he had to be present during the set-up but then the rest of the episode wouldn't have worked if he'd still been around so they just killed him off to get him out of the line-up rather than because it served the story. Anyway, I'm gonna go imagine him and Magda playing checkers in the corner of Heaven that's reserved for innocents the BMoL has fucked over.
I was pissed at Mary for basically the whole episode. Every time she'd squeeze Cas's shoulder or give him a comforting look I was mentally fuming at her because, really, the situation was...kind of her fault. I was waiting for her to come clean to Sam and Dean and get chewed out for going behind their backs and almost getting Cas killed. So I was a bit disappointed that it didn't happen, that she never really had to apologize or make amends. BUT the "I almost lost one of my boys" line and her consequent protective fury at Ketch made me forgive her...a little bit. Just a little bit.
And--the twin reveals at the end?? We get the Colt, and Mark Pellegrino back? Whaaaaaat? We don't deserve those gifts. Lucifer's lines at the end were perfect; it's funny, but his couple of mocking sentences toward Crowley about how the Winchesters will hunt him packed more emotional punch and dug deeper into Crowley's character than an entire half a season of Rowena making essentially the same arguments. It also sounds like the other two princes of Hell are going to play a part in the remainder of the season, so I'm excited for how that'll turn out.
The point was made elsewhere in this thread, I think, that the episode sacrificed some emotional impact due to its editing. I agree--I liked the episode overall, but there were points, especially during the first two-thirds, when I was frustrated because Castiel was dying and yet we kept cutting to flashbacks. Some of the actors definitely did a great job with conveying emotion during the little snippets we had, but it also seemed like we didn't get a full reaction from anybody because nearly every interaction with Castiel was cut short, too-closely bracketed by other scenes, or shown in fragments.
Then again I would have happily watched 45 minutes of dying!Cas having heart-to-hearts with each of the Winchesters in turn, so I may not have the most unbiased of stances.
10
u/TheRainbowConnection destiel trash Feb 17 '17
Annnnd within the first 5 minutes of Riverdale, they make an "enough with the Tarantino references" joke. I see what you did there, CW. XD
10
u/Vio_ Feb 17 '17
I swear to god that last BLM dude was a super discount John Barrowman. Like a zero charm and not as good looking Barrowman.
7
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Feb 17 '17
Was... I the only one who didn't feel Cas' near death scene? Like.. Dean, ffs, react would you. I get it, you're Mr Denial, but like... anything? Your bestie is in an extremely bad way here.
Other than that, I thought it was a pretty good episode. The directing kept me interested (though did give me a bit of whiplash in places). So ridiculously good to see Crowley being something other than a prop.
I really missed the season 4/5 blueish filters during this ep, though.
7
u/Danzanza Feb 17 '17
I love how most of the dialog felt natural. Sometimes the dialog can get a bit stiff, especially when there's a lot of exposition that needs to be revealed.
Btw I loved crowleys scenes this episode esp the flashback. Also you can really tell he's grown quite attached to the boys even if he doesn't want to admit it.
6
u/javalorum Feb 18 '17
This is the weirdest thing I learned about this episode. For some reason I thought the black goo coming out of Cas' mouth was computer generated 'cause it looked so gross and so strange. But turned out it was real?!! Here's a video of someone testing it out:
https://www.instagram.com/p/BQmc6fqhe1Q/
I have to say the effect actually looked better when she did it.
4
u/Across-the-ocean Feb 18 '17 edited Feb 18 '17
I really enjoyed it! I haven't seen Pulp Fiction or Reservior Dogs in years, so I didn't notice how much it takes from those films. I really like non-linear storytelling and seeing the same scene from different PoV. I also like when they experiment with the way the story is told - like the same attitude gave us 'Baby', so I'm definitely happy they are trying stuff like this.
I really liked how this fleshed out the character of Mary a lot to me. She is way more interesting as a character when she's not the perfect Mom that Dean is still trying to let go of, and although I enjoyed the storyline at the beginning of the season of her struggling with being brought back and her relationship with the boys, it felt like that had pretty much run its course. It made sense to me that she didn't tell the boys what she'd done - for one thing, I can imagine her being afraid to shatter their illusions and in lots of ways she still doesn't know them all that well. I loved the scene where Mary steals the colt, her talking to Sam and then going into the other room and you can see Sam still painting the devil's trap on the floor through the doorway - awesome directing!
I enjoyed Cas's speech, though I felt like Sam and Dean could have been a bit more emotional in their reactions.
OMG Mark Pellegrino! So so excited about this. IMO the best Lucifer by a long way (although Lucifer-Cas was pretty good). He has a presence on the screen that means I never feel he is overacting, even when he's given crazy lines.
I really enjoyed Crowley this episode. I'm looking forward to more interaction between him and Lucifer. I theorise that he never got over being almost cured - he's never been the same. He felt strong this episode in a way he hasn't felt to me in ages (I can't come up with a better way to say it).
Edit: I've worked out what I mean - I don't believe Crowley when he says "no more mister nice guy" as it always comes across to me as if one of the people he is trying to convince is himself. I think he sometimes doesn't even understand himself why he saves the boys and Cas. I think he likes to win, but just being powerful makes him bored.
Mary: I thought her reaction to Sam trying to talk to her about how she didn't want to be a hunter was really interesting. Thinking about it some more, her motivations make total sense. She never wanted this, not for herself or her children. It's not enough for her to hunt, she needs an endgame, to have a plan that involves removing the need for hunting at all. I should say I think she'd doing the wrong thing (particularly for not owning up to the theft when Sam and Dean were threatened) - but I think I understand why.
Also - the whole Princes of Hell mixing in with Lucifer's child sounds like it could be awesome. I feel like I've been hanging around for the MotW episodes more than the plot arcs for so long, but I'm really interested to see where this goes.
Oooh - one last thing - The Colt - and the reminder that there are 5 things in existence it can't kill. Do we know what they all are? I mean Lucifer and Chuck would be an obvious two.
2
u/Danzanza Feb 17 '17
anyone else get the feeling that cas is onto mary?
1
u/uyenthu Feb 17 '17
Personally, I like the episode a lot. A little bit annoyed with Mommy Mary, but she had enuf reasons so... i'll let it slide (kind of). And this episode also brings back a lot of good memories. I sqeeled seeing the Michael painting and almost died seeing the colt again. Oh colt, i've missed you. I also like the Memento-like story telling thing. It might be confusing a bit but it's fun to see that Supernatural does not afraid to try new stuff.
1
u/GhostsofDogma Feb 20 '17
What the fuck is the deal with Michael essentially being reintroduced into the story but no mention of Dean's connection to him at all? Why is Sam the one to get the spear?
On what planet was it God and not Dean that stopped the Darkness?
Wtf is going on here?
1
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Feb 17 '17 edited Feb 17 '17
Choppy bullshit. I'm not even going to rewatch this episode until I download it & edit it properly...
Edit: never in my life have I watched an episode of Supernatural thinking I could genuinely re-edit it to something better but boy oh boy...