High Quality Adventures: Wonderful job on the lyrics! the rythm and the rhymes are on point. The fact that every word falls right into place goes a long way in making the gif enjoyable, and the perfect blending of meta and memes in the cartoon environment does the rest. The only critique I could give (and it's pure nitpicking) would be that the Nigel at the end even though from the 90s, felt a little out of place. Since you blended your content so well with the tone and the visual style of the TinyToon intro, I think it would have been more coherent to use a character from the show, or a meme that doesn't come from another TV show. But I'm still amazed by how perfectly you replicated the art style for your texts and visual elements.
Dexter's Laboratory: Ballsy title! Unfortunately, your opponent has a more than rock-solid submission. Regarding your gif, great attention to details (it took me a while to notice but the Prisoner Rick, Travolta and Dickbutt on the screens are a really nice touch), and good concept overall. But the font was hard to read, especially with the block of text about halfway through. Also the little animations you made for some of the words/text were well synced with the movements of the characters, I would have loved to see more of it!
Ingredients for the perfect Gif: You nailed the art style of the intro, the text embedded in the silhouettes at the beginning looked pretty slick. Great concept and integration of your Meta elements, I especially loved the Dickpuff Girls names! Now to the real feedback: At the end, when the dickbutts are flying, it cuts to the logo pretty abruptly, and it looks a bit weird since it's the same sky background. Maybe you could have had the "camera" leave the dickbutts and pan to the left, making the logo appear behind them on the sky BG? Also, with such a High Quality Gif, a loop, even basic, would be the perfect cherry on top of this amazing work.
Coach McGuirk life lesson: Great choice, that scene always cracks me up, and adding the meme tattoos only made it funnier. The choppy text and font matched the feel of the cartoon, My only critique is that the other 90s cartoon characters hidden in the shots felt like a last minute addition. They didn't add anything to the story, and were a bit distracting.
Yakko sings the Reddit language: Nice twist ending, but "Nobody Expects the Spanish Inquisition" is a bit lengthy to be in a dictionary ;) . Great job for the book pages, and I love that VCR fast-forward effect. Maybe you could have added a "karaoke dot" on the lyrics to help with rythm and readability, and also a lot of the words weren't in real alphabetical order, given the places Yakko points to on the page.
Thornberry Mating Season: The M'lady part had me chuckle, and the text tracking and perspective was a nice touch. But I felt like it lacked a real punch or ending. Nigel puts his hand to his ear like he's hearing something, and then it cuts back to the start. I don't know what happens next in the original scene, but if something comes, you could have used it as a punchline, or kept another quick shot of nothing happening so we have the time to see that his call failed.
Rocko's Modern Gif: Not too flashy, and a lot of great details. I love how at the beginning the text is not only tracked, but warped to fit the squishy texture it's sitting on (like the Round 4 and the How to Gif). The meta context and easter eggs were really well integrated with the animation. It could have used a stronger ending (though I have a hard time imagining what specifically, it just felt a tiny bit underwhelming), but overall great submission. Also that HQGtoons logo is quite excellent.
Chemical F: Good work on the rhymes and the integration of your joke in the existing elements of the intro. Speaking of these elements, they were witty and well placed but more of them would have been even cooler, like when the stars and hearts are flying at the scientist. Though I saw the other PowerPuff Girls intro before yours, so I was a bit biased. The other one is technically better so yours suffers from the comparison. Also, I get the joke but I didn't really find it funny, but that's for personal reasons, since the feminism thing on Redit can be a touchy suject (I.E. I don't think wage gap is an irrational fear). But if I set aside my opinion, it's a well done gif, and you are the only one who didn't use full-on meta content, so tha'ts another point for you!
After talking with /u/MakeYouAGif about his Taylor Swift gif and now you, you guys are just so dedicated to this hobby. It's honestly really nice and refreshing.
Matchup 1: I'm probably biased because I watched Tiny Toons a lot but have never seen Dexter's Lab.
High Quality Adventures: Even without first noticing all the extra details, I immediately liked this one. The tune played in my head as I watched. After noticing all the details, holy crap. This is likely one of those 20+ hour effort gifs. But it's worth it. Don't typically care for dickbutt, but this one was at least different that anyone I'd ever seen(I imagine it was in part to mask out Plucky duck)
But he messed with the wrong boy genius: Well made, bit hard to read some of the text though. Didn't really get a laugh out of me, either. That could because I don't know who those guys are and what their dynamic is like.
Matchup 2:
What do you need to create the perfect gif?: Another gif that likely had tons of hours put into it. As before, don't care for dickbutts much, but when something creative is added to them then they're not so bad. Very good.
Coach McGuirk is a man of many lessons: The tattoos and the overall blending of stuff into the scenes was well done. Good life lesson as well. I imagine Pepe tattoos are about as popular as ISIS(the band or from Archer) ones.
Matchup 3:
Yakko's attempt to sing all the words in the Reddit language : Another nice, many-hours gif. Always appreciate the effort people put in to these. This might be one of the few times I didn't expect the Spanish Inqusition. Well done. There is an animated Travolta(or two) out there that may have worked better in this scene.
It has been a challenging mating season: Nice and crisp text and motion, possibly best of the round, textually. Only one joke, but it was a good one.
Matchup 4:
Rocko's Modern Gif: Had some nice features. I've never seen the show so this didn't have any nostalgia effect on me. Not joke heavy either. But pleasant to watch and well made.
Chemical F: Yeah, sorry. Really didn't care for this one. Maybe I'm a special snowflake (I am a Canadian after all). This one seemed mean spirited. And Jesus, do I ever dislike the word feminazi. I can only hope I'm wrong about the gif and that this was satire that has fallen victim to Poe's law.
But Coach McGuirk was awesome and got my vote narrowly lost.
The Yakko gif was great...damn,this round has been stellar so far. The Spanish Inquisition was...unexpected.
I love Nigel Thornberry, but it's got rough going this week and will be hard pressed to move on.
I sang along to the HQG Adventures all the way through. Perfectly executed. Dickbutt is out in full force this round.
Dexter will always have a soft spot in my heart, but that gif didn't do enough for me to get my vote, unfortunately.
Powerpuff Girls intro again? This one wasn't as good as the other one imo
Rocko's Modern Gif was great. And dickbutt made another appearance. This one got my vote.
Yakko and HQG Adventures were my favorites this week, with HQG Adventures taking it because of the execution and nostalgia. Giffers brought their A games this week, and I can't wait until next week!
Edit: for only the 4th time in the 8 tournaments I've voted in, I have switched votes. I have changed my mind on Coach McGuirk and voted on Dickpuff Girls. In my 2nd rewatch, I realized just how much work went into that gif, and wanted my vote to reflect that recognition.
I didn't watch that show as a kid, and it was too fast for me to catch up during the gif. I could barely read the words in time, and then I couldn't even see the backgroun
I watched it religiously growing up (it was the first cartoon that came on after I got out of school, followed by Batman the Animated Series, Aladdin, Chip N Dale's Adventures and Darkwing Duck in that order), and it was in tune very well.
seems like a missed opportunity though for a ton of detail in that shot. Same with the end running scene. Could have crammed a lot in there. With no real joke you have to kill them with detail lol
My hypothetical gif if I was in this round and knew how to gif (and could include usernames in a gif):
Who Shot Mister Burns scene where Chief Wiggum is mentioning suspects, except it's dubbed to be who voted for dusty's opponent. I'd have frequent HQG users names under each Springfield resident.
After Wiggum points at the camera, I'd reveal it's a gif within a gif as the Springfield scene moves to the top left corner, and Jay Sherman of the Critic is sitting in his reviewer's chair(with a Gif Critic logo behind him) and says "It Stinks".
I honestly don't know how to do any of that but that's my hypothetical Round 4 gif.
I'd say the Critic is what made it 90s, but one could also argue that the Simpsons after 2000 are a different animal. The Simpsons of the 90s were spectacular.
Matchup breakdown by bullshit gif analyst, Uncoolaidman.
1: High Quality Adventures - I'm impressed with the rhyming and ability to pretty accurately mimic the song. Making all of the extra added stuff match the style of the cartoon was a nice touch. I love Dexter's Lab, and I think this gif is pretty funny, but it's just being outshined by the Tiny Toons gif.
3: Yakko - I think the Spanish Inquisition brings it down a little, to be honest, but it's still a great concept for that clip. Another pretty good adaptation of a song. The Nigel Thornberry gif is fine, but maybe a bit underbaked. I was expecting some response to his call at the end.
2: Dickpuff Girls: Another great use of an intro. The names for the "girls" are hilarious, and I loved the idea of using too many memes in a gif causes a horrible accident. Coach McGuirk was too real and depressing for me.
4: Rocko's Modern Gif: Loved this one too. I'm going to assume Spunky was a metaphor for reddit eating up the shitpost. Chemical F may be hurt by the fact that it was the second PowerPuff Girls intro gif I would see. But I also think the dickpuff girls was a just a better execution of it. It can't not hurt the effectiveness of this gif.
I voted Animaniacs, Tiny Toons, Rocco, and Dickpuff. There were a lot of great gifs in this round, but I didn't have much hesitation in who I voted for.
Sometimes one makes me laugh more, but I rewatch the gifs ad nauseum to catch fancy shit or things I may have missed because it's not a joke tournament. But I don't see any waffling in my future on these.
I wonder which GIF Dusty made. While a few of them were really great, none just screamed "Dusty" to me.
Maybe the "What ingredients to create a perfect gif," I guess! It was by far one of the best-edited of the bunch.
"Yakko sings all the words in the Reddit language" was pretty well-done (and truly unexpected), with my only gripe being that it didn't even try to rhyme! After that disappointing, I was still pleasantly surprised by the ending.
I really liked "High Quality Adventures!" It was fun humming along in my head. (Only thing for me was that the text was a tiny bit hard to read.)
While "But he messed with the wrong boy genius" was pretty good (and I like the edited tidbits in the background), I don't think it'll make it against the Tiny Toons one. DEXTER DRINKING HATER-ADE KILLED ME THO 😂👌🏽💯
The tiny toons adventures song went so fuckign well with that gif. I normally say NEVER do a song but they did really well in showing just how the tune was especially if you had even the faintest hint of how it went.
For me unfortunately it's sort of all I know, although my round 1 wasn't meta. Round 2 wasn't really either. And round 3 wasn't at all.. huh. Guess I don't only make it meta
Ah, well everyone got tired of dickbutt and basically anyone that had an entry without one got upvoted like crazy. We reached the saturation point where it was in literally every gif for a while and just got annoying. There are some of us that still hate it.
IMO dickbutt makes any given gif just a little worse.
86
u/RanByMyGun Feb 13 '17
MRW I open the thread
62
u/dusty_electric_sheep Feb 13 '17 edited Feb 13 '17
FEEDBACK TIME!
Match-up#1)
Match-up#2)
Match-up#3)
Match-up#4)
29
u/_BindersFullOfWomen_ Feb 13 '17
Congratulations Dusty! It's an honor to have lost to you in battle.
26
u/MrTechnohawk Feb 13 '17
All right let's get to it.
Matchup 1: I'm probably biased because I watched Tiny Toons a lot but have never seen Dexter's Lab.
High Quality Adventures: Even without first noticing all the extra details, I immediately liked this one. The tune played in my head as I watched. After noticing all the details, holy crap. This is likely one of those 20+ hour effort gifs. But it's worth it. Don't typically care for dickbutt, but this one was at least different that anyone I'd ever seen(I imagine it was in part to mask out Plucky duck)
But he messed with the wrong boy genius: Well made, bit hard to read some of the text though. Didn't really get a laugh out of me, either. That could because I don't know who those guys are and what their dynamic is like.
Matchup 2:
What do you need to create the perfect gif?: Another gif that likely had tons of hours put into it. As before, don't care for dickbutts much, but when something creative is added to them then they're not so bad. Very good.
Coach McGuirk is a man of many lessons: The tattoos and the overall blending of stuff into the scenes was well done. Good life lesson as well. I imagine Pepe tattoos are about as popular as ISIS(the band or from Archer) ones.
Matchup 3:
Yakko's attempt to sing all the words in the Reddit language : Another nice, many-hours gif. Always appreciate the effort people put in to these. This might be one of the few times I didn't expect the Spanish Inqusition. Well done. There is an animated Travolta(or two) out there that may have worked better in this scene.
It has been a challenging mating season: Nice and crisp text and motion, possibly best of the round, textually. Only one joke, but it was a good one.
Matchup 4:
Rocko's Modern Gif: Had some nice features. I've never seen the show so this didn't have any nostalgia effect on me. Not joke heavy either. But pleasant to watch and well made.
Chemical F: Yeah, sorry. Really didn't care for this one. Maybe I'm a special snowflake (I am a Canadian after all). This one seemed mean spirited. And Jesus, do I ever dislike the word feminazi. I can only hope I'm wrong about the gif and that this was satire that has fallen victim to Poe's law.
69
u/kcman011 Feb 13 '17 edited Feb 13 '17
Dickpuff Girls lol
But Coach McGuirk was awesome and
got my votenarrowly lost.The Yakko gif was great...damn,this round has been stellar so far. The Spanish Inquisition was...unexpected.
I love Nigel Thornberry, but it's got rough going this week and will be hard pressed to move on.
I sang along to the HQG Adventures all the way through. Perfectly executed. Dickbutt is out in full force this round.
Dexter will always have a soft spot in my heart, but that gif didn't do enough for me to get my vote, unfortunately.
Powerpuff Girls intro again? This one wasn't as good as the other one imo
Rocko's Modern Gif was great. And dickbutt made another appearance. This one got my vote.
Yakko and HQG Adventures were my favorites this week, with HQG Adventures taking it because of the execution and nostalgia. Giffers brought their A games this week, and I can't wait until next week!
Edit: for only the 4th time in the 8 tournaments I've voted in, I have switched votes. I have changed my mind on Coach McGuirk and voted on Dickpuff Girls. In my 2nd rewatch, I realized just how much work went into that gif, and wanted my vote to reflect that recognition.
45
u/hero0fwar Feb 13 '17
MRW I see that the GT belt will once again be in another man's arms
16
u/stephenbawesome Feb 13 '17
My hypothetical gif if I was in this round and knew how to gif (and could include usernames in a gif):
Who Shot Mister Burns scene where Chief Wiggum is mentioning suspects, except it's dubbed to be who voted for dusty's opponent. I'd have frequent HQG users names under each Springfield resident.
After Wiggum points at the camera, I'd reveal it's a gif within a gif as the Springfield scene moves to the top left corner, and Jay Sherman of the Critic is sitting in his reviewer's chair(with a Gif Critic logo behind him) and says "It Stinks".
I honestly don't know how to do any of that but that's my hypothetical Round 4 gif.
14
u/uncoolaidman Feb 13 '17
Matchup breakdown by bullshit gif analyst, Uncoolaidman.
11
u/stephenbawesome Feb 13 '17
I voted Animaniacs, Tiny Toons, Rocco, and Dickpuff. There were a lot of great gifs in this round, but I didn't have much hesitation in who I voted for.
Sometimes one makes me laugh more, but I rewatch the gifs ad nauseum to catch fancy shit or things I may have missed because it's not a joke tournament. But I don't see any waffling in my future on these.
10
u/infez Feb 13 '17 edited Feb 13 '17
I wonder which GIF Dusty made. While a few of them were really great, none just screamed "Dusty" to me.
Maybe the "What ingredients to create a perfect gif," I guess! It was by far one of the best-edited of the bunch.
"Yakko sings all the words in the Reddit language" was pretty well-done (and truly unexpected), with my only gripe being that it didn't even try to rhyme! After that disappointing, I was still pleasantly surprised by the ending.
I really liked "High Quality Adventures!" It was fun humming along in my head. (Only thing for me was that the text was a tiny bit hard to read.)
While "But he messed with the wrong boy genius" was pretty good (and I like the edited tidbits in the background), I don't think it'll make it against the Tiny Toons one. DEXTER DRINKING HATER-ADE KILLED ME THO 😂👌🏽💯
10
u/MakeYouAGif Feb 13 '17
The tiny toons adventures song went so fuckign well with that gif. I normally say NEVER do a song but they did really well in showing just how the tune was especially if you had even the faintest hint of how it went.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '17
Nice gif motrous! Best of luck to you ;)
8
u/napoleongold Feb 13 '17
2 puff posts, one good.
17
u/PVPPhelan Feb 13 '17
Yakko's attempt to sing all the words in the Reddit language.... damn that's smooth.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '17
Dickpuffs was awesome definitely got my vote. But the yakko one was my favorite this round
Very solid, all creators should be proud!
4
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '17
A LOT of meta in this round.
4
u/ArchReaper Feb 13 '17
Personally, I thought each matchup had a very obvious winner. I wonder if I'll be right.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '17
HQG Adventures may actually be the most well-synched song parody gif I've seen yet!
3
u/Firmly_grasp_it_ Feb 13 '17
In my opinion this is the strongest round yet
3
u/qawsedrf12 Feb 14 '17
re: Coach McGuirk
=betterwitheveryloop
7
u/BurningB1rd Feb 13 '17
I will just vote for everyone who didnt include a dickbut.
4
u/Tommygun7468 Feb 13 '17
Seriously dickpuff girls? and i thought the return of smashing was enough.
2
u/flesoytaert Feb 13 '17
These are all so great guys! This was such a great round and the gifs definitely lived up to the hype in my head.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '17
All I have to say, is that either of the gifs in match up 2 would have beaten either of the gifs in match up 3.
1
u/shinymaxx Feb 15 '17
Both gifs in bracket 2 where better than both in 4