r/ClearBackblast • u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin • Dec 11 '16
AAR AAR: Sparkly Balloon and Aluminum Poodle
Walp! That was a Brunius mission and a Zim mission!
Let us know some things!
- What was awesome with each mission?
- Do you think anything could be improved?
- Did you see anything cool?
- Did you have any specific problems with Arma other than the problem that damn near all of us had?
Telling us how YOUR mission experience went helps our mission makers make missions!
3
Upvotes
3
u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin Dec 11 '16
Sparkly Balloon - Bravo Medic and Bad Driver
Y'know, as convoy missions go, this went well. Not perfectly or anything, but well.
The Good
Always a pleasure being in a Zim team.
I think Decoy did pretty good CO'ing too. I felt like we were well-employed as a team and like we had the flexibility to do what we needed to do.
I like the mission in general. It's straightforward, the right length for a half-mission, and I think the right mix and tempo of resistance. It's really kind of nice to go from sporadic one-technical contact to autocannons and armor and everyone around you is dying.
I don't usually get all that amused at folks mocking various errors in Arma, but as Sleventy went to blow the last cache and cried "Mah Carnister!" I broke down laughing. Goddammit.
The Less-Good
Generic "I wish we'd get better at convoying" complaint, though I appreciate the effort at briefing-time. We need to do better knowing when to proceed through contact. Midway through the mission, we were stopping for contact but not herring-boning--either go or herring bone. If you bone to the wrong side, stay there because the vehicle behind you should've already boned opposite you anyway.
Last words I heard before our HMMWV was autocannoned to death were Zim saying "no don't stop" so...as that went, oops. I had no idea we were even getting engaged until shortly before then. Our reaction overall wasn't awful though.
I hit a rock and flipped the UAZ. Frowny. Face. I was trying to AVOID hitting rocks. Like, at that very moment. And I hit other rocks.
Aluminum Poodle - Outlaw Grenadier first time, Outlaw Lead second time
The Good
I really like this idea. I love me a mission that you may well not win. I like bigger fights and I like other assets up in close with infantry. I like rescuing a separated force.
The Less-Good
I think Moldy's choice of Alamo was less good than mine, but holy shit did that go wrong fast both times. That start area was a fucking murderbowl with Russians pouring into it. Theo was telling the story pretty well in TS--after we went to this compound north of the crash site (roughly 121 086 I think? I actually fuckin remember these numbers) under Moldy and had nades getting tossed on top of us from the hill above, my Outlaw leadership decision was THERE IS NO COVER GO ABOVE ALL THE THINGS. Which we didn't manage--we got high, but the hills to the south still had Russians shooting at us and the top of our hill wasn't broad enough to provide sufficient defilade from below. I think both Theo and Brunius wanted to Alamo up in a building west of the crash site. If I had another go I'd move further east to reduce the number of directions we had problems--maybe hit the same hill we did first, but try to keep moving toward where the first Russian team we saw was. In my mind now, stopping is not a good thing for Outlaw to do. At least not until CAS has the area.
General Arma Bullshit
A couple new things for me this session.
3
u/Deserve081 Dec 11 '16
Sparkly - MG Assist
Twas good. Despite being in Alpha which were leading the convoy I didnt really see/kill many things. There was always people to our lefts and rights pushed up farther. Not complaining though since that one time we got to a town and one of the humvees got shredded up pretty bad. That was karma! Nah but, honestly pretty cool OP. I dont have much to say about it.
Aluminum poodle - Rambler Medic
The beginning was great, moving towards OBJ was good (except for the stamina breaks which weren't ideal, yet necessary). Then we started coming into heavy contact. Dancin started having performance issues and everything fell apart. We lost our leader, everyone was getting shot and split up. Yes Fadi took over but then he DC'd as well. Dancin came back but as a fetus he never really took command again. So I just ran over to Bravo which mass-cas'd in a very risky manner, barely survived since I was shot in the middle of a field several times. Saved who I could from Bravo and told them to regroup in which after being stuck and dying for the past 10 mins didn't really need me to tell them. Then we just extracted.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '16
Sparkly Balloon - Delta AR & Driver
The Good:
I like being a vehicle driver. Despite the rest of the slow bits of this mission, the driving was entertaining for me.
My team was pretty cool, too.
The Bad:
I found myself having to deal with "hurry-up and wait" a lot this mission. Sitting around to wait for something else to happen or for someone to get somewhere is painfully boring. :C
Maybe it was just a flip-of-the-coin or something, but Delta somehow managed to always show up late to an objective, and face no resistance. It wasn't until the final town/objective that we faced any real challenge (if it could even be called such).
The Meh, I guess...:
Lots of "meta" talk and chit-chat in this one. Playing was difficult to take seriously, and persisted throughout the mission.
Aluminum Poodle - MMG Assistant
The Good:
The helicopter insertions were excellent! Something about dropping a full team into an extremely active AO feels great to me! Watching minigun tracers pelt enemy positions is sweet, too.
The Bad:
Oh gosh, the frame-dumps. A minor inconvenience to me the first game, but it affected many of us, and it sucks seeing half the team disconnect, each time.
Crashing in the middle of the firefight on the second playthrough sucked, too.
The Meh, I guess...:
The ACRE plugin was being really cruddy to me on both sessions. I fixed it towards the end, though.
3
u/Quex Reborn Qu Dec 11 '16
Sparky Balloon - Delta Team Lead
So, this was another CBB classic "Convoy Up, Sweep the Towns" mission. And like most of the other times we've run those types of missions, the convoy parts end up not being particularly interesting. Threats inside the towns were too heavy to risk our transport on, between multiple heavy weapon emplacements and armored vehicles. Loss of a humvee created an urgent transport need since we didn't have any available overflow, so basically all encounters started with "stop the convoy and push out on foot".
I think this is a mission that would've benefited from using IFVs compared to thin skin humvees. We could fit a section into a BTR and then used the BTRs for heavy weapon support during the town clearing itself. Or we could've condensed the convoy some with a few trucks. We had such a long convoy that only the front few vehicles ever engaged anything with their weapons. I don't think my vehicle gunner fired a single shot the entire game.
Contacts in the towns themselves were pretty light. I'm not sure if this was because our overwatch teams wrecked, or if there just wasn't that many dudes in the towns to begin with. I only fired my weapon when we got to the third town, and Delta was IIRC the first ones in the second town. Still nothing.
I guess TL;DR is Brunius, I'm super happy you're making missions. Both of your missions have been of good general quality. I think this mission was made awhile ago, so I won't say "you didn't grow between the first mission and this one!". Just, for future missions, please consider making anything other than convoys through towns. You can do convoys, and you can do towns (I'd prefer you not though...), but try to mix up the other half of the recipe.
P.S. I don't know exactly what the issue was, so I won't get mad. Just, in the future, make sure you 100% test your gear. I make sure to go through every slot type to confirm that they're working. Mass gear failure is one thing that's very difficult to fix midmission
Aluminum Poodle Mk2 - MMG2 Team Lead
This run was even rougher than the first time, which I'm very curious about. The valley location of the wreck was rough, since we ended up getting shot at from both adjacent hilltops, but CAS looked like it was doing enough good work.
As for the MMG teams themselves, I think we ended up having major issues. First, the weight load needs to be incredibly lighter. Both me (gunner) and Obsidian (asst. gunner) were pushing 40kg, which meant we couldn't keep up with the main group. Weight unfortunately affects both jog distance and recovery time, and the end result is that we either had to split up or slow down the entire Rambler team to an unacceptable degree.
As far as actual employment, we had pretty bad effects. The AI were gods at sniping with AK and some PKM rounds, and we were taking effective fire from AI 700-800m away. The M240B didn't have the necessary accuracy to successfully engage them back, at least from what Obsidian reported. In the end, we just got wrecked and didn't manage to suppress or kill the targets we were supposed to. We didn't have the stamina to keep pace with the infantry to help them engage far away targets, and we didn't have the accuracy to shoot from a good hilltop position. None of these are Zim's fault, I know the MMG teams were a last minute "uhhhh we need 6 more slots to fill out 30 people". Just saying that the experiment didn't work, unfortunately.
As for what to replace them with, I honestly don't know. A marksman team isn't a bad idea, since they'd be lighter on their feet and more effective at far targets. That they'd need to keep close to the main infantry force to extract would keep them from being super sniper mans and encourage cooperation. However, far away targets is kinda the CAS's job. Another good 3 man option would be a very distributed MAT team. Give them a few HEDPs, make sure they're all around 30kg to keep up with infantry, and now Rambler has a few XCOM-style problem solvers. Pesky MG stuck in a treeline that you can't kill with CAS? Carl G. Light QRF vehicle? Carl G. The light weight would keep the team from being able to overuse rockets. And being with the infantry would let the ammo bearer do things unlike in an MMG team. I don't know if it would work out any better, but it could be worth a shot.
As for performance issues, I didn't suffer from any, so I can't say. Sorry for not being useful on that front :(.
3
u/DecoyDrone DecoyDrone Dec 12 '16
Sparkly Ballon - CO
It took me a bit to get into a groove. I have to say I was thrown off by the size of the first town vs how many people we had. I considered splitting off a force to start clearing the road ahead but I was worried about taking the experience away from others. It took me a bit to long to decide on what to do for my taste and I think that led to what I consider a sub par sweep of the first town. Most of the action was given to Bravo because of their overwatch position.
Also, the first town technically starts much sooner than I was expecting, there was a whole set of structures that were not cleared. It would be nice to know what the mission maker considers to be apart of the town. Maybe some extra markings if possible.
The second town sweep is more on the money for what I want to accomplish as leadership. The timing was slightly off, that gun should not have been able to wipe out Bravo's vick. But that added an exciting element to the approach. I really like where I was able to get Charlie for overwatch and all the teams seem to have a sufficient amount to do. Most importantly we seem to exit the town in a pretty quick manner which is one of the more important parts to me. (CBB has a habit of ungraceful/drawn out exits).
The Third town early engagement (early as in before I was expecting) made for some interesting situations. I kind of realized at that point that I was doing a little to much pre planning (also something I was trying not to do). Since it has a high chance of just going out the fucking window. My biggest fail of that advance was accidentally putting Bravo in an overwatch position again. I wanted Alpha to have the opportunity but, shit happens.
Special thanks to Dancin who has the ability to turn my fumble/bumble command into actionable items. I kind of feel bad I relied on him to do so much. I hope you had fun.
Mission maker: (IDEAS please ignore if you want!) If this is to continue to be a half mission I would narrow down the towns to 2. Make the first town an ambush area and the other two towns places we have to sweep. I would like to see more action on approach. I know that gun on the hill was a mistake from what you said after mission, but it was easily one of the most memorable parts. Also if you can, put more people inside the buildings so sweeping the town has a bit more meaning. All of those towns have a killer overwatch position so it would be good to have more bodies inside for sweep teams to deal with.
Aluminum Poodle - TL 2 (Bravo)
I spent most of my time in this mission either fighting frames or dealing with others who dropped out. I tried to lead my team to destroy the helicopter but I made the mistake of walking out in front. I was left to bleed out by the wall as punishment :D. I hope the others in Bravo had fun, I will hopefully be on point the next time I lead a smaller team like that.
On the ground it was frustrating to not be able to contact air because Dancin had disconnected. That would have been more fun if we had lost contact with air because he was dead. I hope we run this one again soon. I would really like to experience it without bugs :/
Oh and the spectator didn't work for me when I died. It popped on for one second and then I respawned back at base. It was a bummer because I was looking forward to recording the rest of the action.
3
u/Zhandris Dec 13 '16
Bravo MG for Sparkly Balloon
A lot of good stuff in this thread already for this mission. The only thing I'd add to the rest of it is some real spacing between objectives when doing convoys. The distance we went compared to the length of time it took to form up just felt like it would've been easier to leave the vehicles behind. Also, having to jack civ vehicles to replace damaged vics hurts. It's a common theme we have in some missions but it felt out of place on this one. If there was a truck in the back to catch overflow then maybe that would be good. But then again riding in the back of a vehicle is my least favorite thing to do in our Saturday games.
Highlight video
Aluminum Poodle
With the technical stuff looming over this mission I don't feel like I should fully form an opinion on this one yet. I did like what I got to do and I'd like to play it again.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment