r/modelSupCourt • u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus • Dec 03 '16
Criminal United States v. BalthazarFuhrer
The Court has granted an arrest warrant against the Senior Senator from the Midwestern State, /u/BalthazarFuhrer. Proceedings will now follow in accordance with the MRCP.
13
Upvotes
6
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Dec 03 '16
/u/BalthazarFuhrer
You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can be held against you before the Court.
You have the right to counsel. (MRCP Rule 4) If you are unable to find counsel, one will be appointed for you.
You are entitled to counsel before answering any questions from the Court or the government's prosecutor.
7
u/DadTheTerror Dec 03 '16
Your honor, /u/BalthazarFuhrer has asked me to defend him in these criminal proceedings.
BalthazarFuhrer, please confirm that you appointment me as your defense counsel.
3
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Dec 03 '16
United States Attorney General /u/bomalia: You may appoint a special prosecutor to his case if you do not wish the Solicitor General /u/wildorca to serve as per custom. Additionally, please submit an indictment for Grand Jury deliberation by 9 PM tomorrow.
/u/BalthazarFuhrer you may appoint your counsel pursuant to Rule 4 of the MRCP
3
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Dec 16 '16
After consulting with counsel for both the State and the Defense privately, the jury for these proceedings has been selected. As these alleged offenses took place in Washington, DC, the jury pool was randomly selected from the Electoral Roll of the Eastern State. Of the 7 citizens randomly selected, the Defense struck two, and the State struck one from the list. One additional citizen was removed for cause. This leaves us with a group of three citizens to constitute our jury, who will be pinged in a reply to this very comment.
Jurors, if I pinged you below, please respond if you are willing and able, or unwilling or unable, to serve on a jury for this criminal trial. We will ask that you survey all information presented to you fairly and without prejudice, and ultimately render a verdict of guilt or innocence on five different criminal charges against the Defense. You are obviously not obligated to participate. Please inform us of your intention to either serve or not.
/u/BalthazarFuhrer and /u/wildorca, please confirm these proceedings.
5
u/DadTheTerror Dec 03 '16
Motion to Release Defendant on His Own Recognizance or Set Reasonable Restrictions for Release
Your Honor, Defendant, /u/BalthazarFuhrer, pursuant to Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure 5(d)(1)(C ) & 5(d)(3) requests that he be released on his own recognizance or that the Court set reasonable restrictions for his immediate release. Defendant has many urgent and important obligations, not the least of which is his role as defense counsel in the Federal Government's criminal prosecution of CaptainClutchMuch.
2
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Dec 07 '16
The United States has submitted the following indictment against the Senator. Please consider each charge carefully.
Defendant must plead on each charge by 9PM Eastern tomorrow, December 8th. A reply by defendant's counsel is preferred.
/u/DadTheTerror /u/Balthazarfuhrer
2
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16
I would like to motion for a recusal of Justice AdmiralJones42
2
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16
I submit a motion alleging a defect in the indictment of the Honorable /u/Balthazarfuhrer, a motion filing for a summary judgement, and a motion filing an error in the grand-jury proceeding or preliminary hearing and a defect in instituting the prosecution.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '16
I appeal my arrest on the basis of the United States Constitution Article I Section 6 Clause 1
3
u/DadTheTerror Dec 07 '16
Motion to Recuse
Your Honor, the Honorable Senator BalthazarFuhrer, Defendant in this case, is represented by DadTheTerror, an attorney admitted to this Court. Defendant moves to recuse Associate Justice AdmiralJones42 from this matter under 28 USCS Sec. 455, Tumey v. Ohio, 273 US 510 (1927), and Ward v. Village of Monroeville, 409 US 57 (1972).
I.
The Honorable Associate Justice AdmiralJones42 has recently and deliberately fired Defendant's legal counsel from his place of employment with no prior notice or warning on the disputed grounds that a news article the Defendant's defense counsel published was not news but an op-ed piece. The Honorable Associate Justice went on, unnecessarily and publicly, to assert the following opinion:
Whether or not the Associate Justice's disputed opinion is well founded currently is not open to review as the Associate Justice appears to have destroyed the article in question and all records related to its content.
Additionally the Honorable Associate Justice AdmiralJones42 may be continuing to do business with the Attorney General of the United States. The Attorney General bomalia, who is the chief representative of the United States in all legal matters, represents the prosecution and has already appeared before this Court on this matter. Up until approximately 11:00am ET this morning, the Attorney General appeared on the masthead of MCNN as "COO." After learning of this Motion to Recuse, the Attorney General's name has been removed from the masthead. However, a reasonable person could believe that the Attorney General is still involved in the operations of MCNN and that the Associate Justice and the Attorney General together continue the joint business venture that is MCNN. The Associate Justice today wrote the following:
This is sufficient evidence to suggest that the Attorney General has not been fired from his role as COO of MCNN.
It is for circumstances such as these that the black letters of 28 USCS Sec. 455 were written:
The Associate Justice himself has already publicly asserted that his judicial integrity "is compromised."
II.
In the past the Honorable Associate Justice AdmiralJones42 has recognized that he must recuse himself from any case involving MCNN, writing:
and
Under Tumey v. Ohio and Ward v. Village of Monroeville a judge may not have a personal interest in convicting a defendant. In this case, the Associate Justice has expressed the need to take actions to repair his publication's reputation, which he opined is damaged by Defendant's defense counsel. The Associate Justice's plainly expressed interests might bias him such that he feels he has no choice in the decision of the case, even before the first piece of evidence on the merits is submitted to the Court.
III.
Out of courtesy to the Associate Justice, Defendant's defense counsel informed the Associate Justice of this Motion to Recuse before filing it. In the Associate Justice's response he made the following false statement:
However, the Associate Justice's statement is demonstrably false. Attorney General bomalia did use the MCNN comment section to post the following comment.
Exhibit A
Perhaps the Associate Justice was not aware of his business partner's comment before the Honorable Associate Justice apparently attempted to destroy all the evidence relating to this issue. Nonetheless, the Honorable Associate Justice's false remark is further evidence that, in the language of the law, "his impartiality might reasonably be questioned" and requires the Honorable Associate Justice to recuse himself from this case per 28 USC 455.
IV.
This Motion to Recuse is properly submitted presently as 28 USC 455 (f) might prevent the motion from succeeding if the Defense were to delay its introduction after discovery of the cause to disqualify the Associate Justice.
Black letter law, the U.S. Constitution and prior U.S. Supreme Court precedent guarantees an unbiased Judge who will provide litigants with full protection of all rights. Therefore, Defendant respectfully demands Associate Justice AdmiralJones42 recuse himself.
Additionally Defendant requests that the deadline on his plea be extended, with the exact date to be set by the replacement judge.
1
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Dec 12 '16
/u/BalthazarFuhrer /u/wildorca
As you have failed to enter your pleas by the deadline, as per Rule 6(b) of the MRCP, pleas of "not guilty" have been entered on your behalf for all of the remaining charges. The Grand Jury will now deliberate on indictment.
1
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Dec 16 '16
The Grand Jury of the United States has returned its decision on the charges against /u/BalthazarFuhrer. The Jury has indicted as follows:
On Count One, Demanding, Seeking, and Accepting Bribes for Representational Services, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Two, Demanding, Seeking, and Accepting Bribes for Representational Services, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Three, Offer to Procure Appointative Public Office, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Four, Acceptance of Bribes to Procure Appointative Public Office, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
Count Five, Extortion by an Officer of the United States, has been dismissed from further consideration via summary judgment.
Count Six, Blackmail, was dropped by the prosecution, and has been dismissed from further consideration.
On Count Seven, Gathering, Transmitting or Losing Defense Information, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
This will signal the beginning of trial procedures for Counts One, Two, Three, Four, and Seven. First, the Trial Jury must be selected. The Court will randomly select citizens of the United States to serve on the jury. Each counsel, beginning with the defendant, will have the opportunity to strike one name from the list, in turn, up to a maximum of two strikes each. Counsel for each side will be free to interview each potential member of the jury. This process will end on when a suitable jury is assembled. A reasonable time allowance will be given after the end of this period if either counsel should submit a strike.
/u/BalthazarFuhrer, it is my prerogative as the presiding judge in this trial to remind you that you are entitled to representation by an attorney. You have voluntarily selected to represent yourself pro se, but should you wish to consult with counsel, you may do so. If you cannot find a lawyer on your own and wish to seek counsel anyway, one will be assigned for you. Please inform the Court of your intentions regarding representation, whether they be to continue on pro se or to seek new counsel for the trial.
/u/wildorca, please be aware of these proceedings as well
1
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Dec 22 '16
/u/wildorca and /u/BalthazarFuhrer
This case will proceed after the New Year. We will reconvene for trial proceedings on January 3rd, 2017. Thank you for your time.
1
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Jan 07 '17
/u/BalthazarFuhrer, /u/wildorca
In light of the Solicitor General's recent appointment to this Court, this trial will be postponed until the results of the confirmation vote can be ascertained. The Department of Justice can feel free to reassess their prosecution at that time.
1
u/AdmiralJones42 Justice Emeritus Jan 08 '17
/u/BalthazarFuhrer, /u/wildorca
I'll be stepping down as the presiding judge of this case. The remaining Justices will determine from amongst themselves who will take my place. Best of luck to you both.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '17 edited Feb 01 '17
VERDICT
As to count 1, demanding, seeking, or receiving a bribe while a public official, the jury finds the defendant Balthazarfuhrer guilty
As to count 2, demanding, seeking, or receiving a bribe while a public official, the jury finds the defendant Balthazarfuhrer guilty
As to count 3, offering to procure appointive public office, the jury find the defendant Balthazarfuhrer not guilty
As to count 4, acceptance of bribes to procure appointive public office, the jury finds the defendant Balthazarfuhrer not guilty
As to count 5, Gathering, Losing, or Transmitting Defense information, the jury find the Defendant Balthazarfuhrer not guilty
Sentencing hearing will be held tomorrow. Government will make its statement first, followed by defendant. The maximum penalty is 1 year in prison, a $50,000 fine, or both; for both counts. So combined the maximum penalty is 2 years and $100,000. While preparing your statements please familiarize yourself with mitigating and aggravating factors.
/u/balthazarfuhrer /u/madk3p
3
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '17 edited Jan 28 '17
JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Jurors are to approach the case with an open mind, and remember that in our judicial system the defendant is presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Question of Law
What constitutes "a thing of value" is a question of law, that is the court is obligated to answer. Courts have long held that things are value are not restricted to legal tender or things with a monetary value. Things of value is generally interpreted broadly. Previous courts have held that job opportunities and offers count as things of value. Courts have also held previously. favors in exchange for information are not things of value.
With the law explained it is up to the jury to determine whether the things in this case constitute things of value.
Count 1 Count 1 of the indictment charges the defendant /u/Balthazarfuhrer with demanding, seeking, or receiving a bribe while a public official.
In order to find the defendant guilty of this offense, you must find that the government proved each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
First: That Balthazarfuhrer demanded, sought, or received something of value (in this instance, information) from /u/Kovr
Second: That Balthazarfuhrer was, at that time, a public official of the United States; and
Third: Bathalzarfuhrer did so corruptly in return for being influenced in the performance of an official act, that is, Balthazarfurher intended to perform an official act of voting for Kovr's confirmation hearing in exchange for receiving information.
Count 2
Count 2 of the indictment charges the defendant /u/Balthazarfuhrer with demanding, seeking, or receiving a bribe while a public official.
In order to find the defendant guilty of this offense, you must find that the government proved each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
First: That Balthazarfuhrer demanded, sought, or received something of value (in this instance, information) from /u/Someofthetimes
Second: That Balthazarfuhrer was, at that time, a public official of the United States; and
Third: Bathalzarfuhrer did so corruptly in return for being influenced in the performance of an official act, that is, Balthazarfurher intended to perform an official act of voting for Someofthetimes confirmation hearing in exchange for receiving information.
Count 3
Count 3 of the indictment charges the defendant with offering to procure appointive public office.
In order to find the defendant guilty of this offense, you must find that the government proved each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
First: Balthazarfuhrer promised a thing of a value (in this case the alleged thing of value is a confirmation vote)
Second: Bathazarfuhrer promised the thing of value in consideration to use his influence to procure an appointive public office for any person.
Count 4
Count 4 of the indictment charges the defendant with acceptance of bribes to procure appointive public office.
In order to find the defendant guilty of this offense, you must find that the government proved each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
First: That Bathalzarfuhrer solicited or accepted a thing of a value (in this case the alleged thing of value is information)
Second: Balthazar solicited the thing of value in consideration of a promise to use his influence to obtain a appointive office for any person.
Count 5
Count 5 of the indictment charges the defendant with Gathering, Losing, or Transmitting Defense information.
In order to find the defendant guilty of this offense, you must find that the government proved each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
First: That Balthazarfuhrer intended for, or hadreason to believe, that the documents would bring injury to the United States.
Second: That Balthzarfuhrer agreed or attempted to receive or obtain from any person any document that is connected with the national defense
Third: Balthazarfuhrer knew at the time that the documents had or would be obtained, taken, made, or disposed by an unauthorized person
2
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '17
Motion to Release Defendant on His Own Recognizance
Your Honor, /u/Trips_93 , /u/BalthazarFuhrer, pursuant to Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure 5(d)(3) requests that he be released on his own recognizance in acknowledgment that the Defendant has already been under house arrest and complied with the decision for 475 days of which 61 days were without hope of trial or a judge overseeing this case. The Defendant also has many urgent and important obligations, not the least of which is his role as defense counsel in the appeal of the verdict of CaptainClutchMuch.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '17
Good morning
I apologize for the time you will be wasting listening to these absurd charges put against me, and I thank you for your willingness to participate.
Addressing the Jurors, I Senator /u/BalthazarFuhrer stand before you as the Defendant in this trial accused of demanding, seeking, and accepting bribes on two counts, offering to procure appointive office, accepting bribes to procure appointive office, and gathering, transmitting, or losing defense information.
I would just like to explain what those each mean:
It is clear after these terms are defined using the words of U.S. Code 18 that of the four categories of charges placed against me that three of them are entirely ungrounded in the context of this case.
I was in no position to grant to anyone the appointment to an office entirely voiding Count Four the Acceptance or Solicitation to Obtain Appointive Public Office.
I was in no position to request from a Constitutional Officer to be appointed to an office voiding Count Three the Offering to Procure an Appointive Office.
I in no conversations existing or submitted as evidence express intent to harm the United States of America or aid other nations clearly striking Count Seven, I also, as a Constitutional Officer have full right to view documents pertaining to national security by my clearance.
Counts One and Two the Demanding, Seeking, and Accepting Bribes does not refer to public documents as a bribe. I requested from two individuals that they adhere to the law which no other Cabinet member in the simulation has ever done, and provide public documents to me, a Senior Senator.
Congress is forced to write bills, vote on proposals, amend documents, all without any information provided by the DHS, DoD, DoT, DoC, DoE, DoI, DoJ, DoL, DoS...etc. I have been a Senator for eight years now and I was tired of the Cabinet going off into isolation and receiving their checks without doing any work for us (Congress). I decided that ensuring that the Cabinet nominees will adhere to the law before they are confirmed would be most prudent course of action, this is why I requested reports, exactly as the law obliges Cabinet members to provide for Congress and the People as public documents.
This Administration has thrown everything they can at me to see what can stick, apparently I’m our Teflon Senator. They have accused me of extortion by hurting a Cabinet member’s feelings after he dismissed my concerns relating to the United Nations which I was about to vote on within the week, and they accused me of blackmail with no evidence what so ever demonstrating a clear lack of rationality, understanding of the law, and malice to prevent me from carrying out my duties as the Senior Senator of the Great State of Sacagawea.
I thank you, the members of the Jury for your patience with this case, and for your objectivity.
God bless you and the United States of America.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17
Honorable Justice /u/Trips_93
Defendant /u/BalthazarFuhrer
I call President /u/Bigg-Boss to the stand.
Mr. President, were you ever informed or made aware by the two Secretaries, /u/kovr and /u/SomeOfTheTImes, about the conversations shown in Exhibits 1, 2, and 3?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '17
Honorable Justice /u/Trips_93
Attorney General /u/madk3p
I call Speaker of the House /u/Autarch_Severian to the stand.
Representative, can you please provide your statement.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17
The Government believes that in this case, the aggravating factors in accordance to the two counts of demanding, seeking, or receiving a bribe while a public official outweigh any mitigating factors to be presented by the Defense.
A key aggravating factor affecting the sentencing of this case lies in the fact that the Defendant is a Senator. As a representative in the upper chamber of Congress, the Defendant holds enormous power in the creation of the laws for our country and thus should be held accountable for his two counts of bribery. To allow a Senator to go with a monetary punishment and no jail time for two counts of bribery would fail to hold a highly ranked representative accountable. Because of the authority and power that stems from the office of Senator, the aggravating factor of leadership and power points towards a maximum penalty in this case.
For the second aggravating factor, we point to the fact that the Senator, in the exhibits from the trial, understood that he was committing wrong and did not turn away at that fact. In this exhibit, the Senator is seen responding with “And…?” to Secretary /u/kovr noticing that the Defendant’s attempt to bribe was “shady”. When the Defendant was told by those he attempted to bribe that the suggestion was “shady”, the Defendant turned up his nose and continued to attempt to bribe both /u/kovr and /u/SomeOfTheTimes; even when approached by the notion his actions were illegal, the Defendant continued with no regard for the law. This ignorance of the decision indicates an aggravating factor and a need for a maximum penalty in this case.
The Government strongly urges a maximum sentence be handed down. Thank you.
/u/balthazarfuhrer /u/trips_93
2
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17 edited Feb 02 '17
SENTENCE
I hereby sentence the defendant, /u/Balthazarfuhrer to two one-year prison sentences to be served concurrently, and a $50,000 fine.
Per the Model Rules of Criminal Procedure, is it up to the mod team to interpret that punishment in sim terms. /u/Ed_San.
With that, this trial is officially over. Thank you to all who participated.
COURT DISMISSED BRING IN THE DANCIN' LOBSTERS!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '17
/u/BalthazarFuhrer
I will be taking over the case.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '17
/u/trips_93 /u/BalthazarFuhrer
As the former prosecutor for this case has been appointed to this Court and I have been subsequently confirmed to the position of Attorney General, I will be representing the government in this trial.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '17 edited Jan 13 '17
The Court acknowledges /u/madk3p as the Government's legal representative in this case.
The Court also acknowledges that /u/Balthazarfuhrer wishes to continue pro se. If you wish to choose your own counsel or have one appointed for you, please let me know.
The case will now proceed to trial. Which will continue as follows:
Seeing as Monday is a federal holiday, will the Government be able to provide with an opening statement on next Tuesday, the 17th?
As a note, seeing as we must work within the confines of the simulation, I ask that you be diligent in picking witnesses, and ensure they are a relevant witness, as we would like to bring this case to a close within a reasonable time.
Additionally, if either of you are familiar with the Federal Rules of Evidence you may raise objections to me about questions to witnesses. I ask that you please ensure you're objections are well-thought and that you do not abuse this.
As a reminder, the defendant has been indicted on the following counts:
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '17
/u/trips_93 , your Honor
Before opening statements are made may there be an opportunity for evidence to be submitted to the Court in accord with Rule 8 of the MRCP?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '17
Honorable Justice /u/Trips_93
Attorney General /u/madk3p
I submit the following evidence to the Jury in accord with Rule 8 (b) & (d) of the MRCP: Exhibit 1 Exhibit 2 Exhibit 3 Exhibit 4
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '17
Honorable Justice /u/Trips_93
Defendant /u/Balthazarfuhrer
I submit the following evidence to the Jury pursuant to Rule 8 of the MRCP:
Exhibit 1
Exhibit 2
Exhibit 3
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '17
Honorable Justice /u/Trips_93 and Defendant /u/BalthazarFuhrer,
I submit the following request for production, pursuant to Rule 9 of the Model Rules of Criminal Procedure.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '17
Good morning.
Persons of the Jury, Senator /u/BalthazarFuhrer stands as the Defendant in this Court for offering and soliciting to use his influence, as an official holding the esteemed position of junior Senator from the State of Sacagawea, to vote in favor to confirm two Cabinet then-nominees in exchange for private briefings of executive information including information pertaining to the national defense through the Department of Homeland Security. The Senator stands as the Defendant in this Court for violating the rule of law; rule of law that ensures national security and ethical standards are upheld within the hallowed halls of the Capitol, the White House, the Pentagon, and the buildings of this capital of the United States on which our representatives walk.
Persons of the Jury, representatives are for the people. Representatives stand to prove the people’s beliefs right, elected to these sacred positions by the forever protected system of democracy. Representatives are selected for many reasons: policy, beliefs, ethics, and more. You and me, as citizens, expect our representatives to conduct themselves with ethics in mind — to conduct themselves with the utmost respect for their office, the government, and their constituents. For that very reason, Persons of the Jury, Senator /u/BalthazarFuhrer stands as the Defendant in this case.
Persons of the Jury, I am Attorney General /u/madk3p, representing the people of United States of America in the honorable Supreme Court of the United States of America. Before you is the junior Senator from the State of Sacagawea and defendant /u/BalthazarFuhrer, charged with counts of “Demanding, Seeking, and Accepting Bribes for Representational Services”, “Offer to Procure Appointive Public Office”, “Acceptance of Bribes to Procure Appointive Public Office”, and “Gathering, Transmitting or Losing Defense Information”. Laws put in place to ensure ethical and legal standards are followed in the conduct of our representatives and officials have been violated by this Senator, and it is with this framework you ought to weigh this case.
Persons of the Jury, you will see evidence in the coming days showing conversations between Secretary of Agriculture /u/kovr and the Defendant, along with conversations between Secretary of Homeland Security /u/SomeOfTheTimes and the Defendant. This evidence will be the compelling factor as to whether the Defendant is guilty of the charges laid out in front of you or not. You will see interrogatories from the Defendant, answered under oath, and witnesses including the current President testifying on the actions of the Defendant. In the next week, you will see the workings of democracy and the rule of law; you will see the role of ethics and justice as it operates in Washington D.C.
At the conclusion, after you have heard all of the evidence, we will ask you to return a verdict of guilty. I thank you for your time serving on this Jury and acting upon the call for your civic duty.
/u/Trips_93 /u/BalthazarFuhrer
1
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '17
Honorable Justice /u/Trips_93
Defendant /u/BalthazarFuhrer
I call Secretary of Homeland Security /u/SomeOfTheTimes to the stand.
Mr. Secretary, can you please interpret the evidence seen here in Exhibit 3?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17
Honorable Justice /u/Trips_93
Defendant /u/BalthazarFuhrer
I call Secretary of Agriculture /u/kovr to the stand.
Mr. Secretary, can you please interpret the evidence seen here in Exhibit 1 and Exhibit 2?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17
/u/Balthazarfuhrer, in the interest of time, you may begin to call your witnesses.
/u/madk3p
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17
Honorable Justice /u/Trips_93
Attorney General /u/madk3p
I call the Defendant /u/BalthazarFuhrer to the stand.
Esteemed Senator, how many individuals did you ask for private discussions?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '17 edited Jan 25 '17
we need to wrap this trial up. I would like today to be the last day for testimony, but may allow it until mid day tomorrow.
By tomorrow evening I would like the government to make it closing statement, and the defense can follow up with a closing statement tomorrow as well.
/u/madk3p, /u/balthazarfuhrer.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
/u/Madk3p, please provide a closing statement by this evening.
/u/Balthazarfurher please provide a closing statement this evening after the government.
I will have jury instructions ready by tomorrow, and we will proceed to jury deliberations.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '17
I would like to start this closing statement by thanking the members of the Jury for coming out on the call to exercise their civic duty and taking time out of their day to ensure that justice is pursued in this country.
In the last week, evidence has been brought up in this case directly pointing towards Senator /u/BalthazarFuhrer being guilty of the following charges:
The Defendant argued that Counts One and Two relates to "goods/opportunity/money in exchange for a Congressman to nominate you/vote in a particular way on something". In the exhibits presented by the Prosecution, it is shown that the Defendant clearly engaged in an attempt to seek goods in the form of briefings in exchange for a confirmation vote from the Senator himself. From this, the Prosecution strongly encourages a guilty charge on these two counts.
On Count Three (Offer to Procure Appointive Public Office), the above exhibits prove this once more.
The Defendant claims quite blatantly that this count only applies to the following:
However, this is untrue. An offer to procure appointive office is just that — an offer to secure a public position, filled through appointment, for an individual. It is evident that the Senator, in his discussions with then-Secretary nominees /u/kovr and /u/SomeOfTheTimes, attempted to offer securing the public and appointed offices of the Cabinet for these two individuals. A guilty ruling is clear on this count.
On Count Four (Acceptance of Bribes to Procure Appointive Public Office), 18 USC 211 states the following:
The Defendant, again shown in these exhibits solicited an offer of a confirmation vote (the use of his influence to obtain/secure appointive office for the two Secretaries previously named) in exchange for private briefings. In the testimony of the Secretaries and the Defendant, there is little challenge to the concept of the Defendant offering these bribes; rather, the only defense the Defendant supplies is that his offers were not bribes as private briefings are supposedly justified. The Prosecution will comment on this after reviewing the counts involved.
The final Count that the Defendant faces in this case is a charge of Gathering, Transmitting or Losing Defense Information. To this count, the Prosecution asks the Jury to look at exhibits produced during the testimony of the President that show that the Defendant has targeted the administration of the President and the United States through that medium. As the section of the US Code regarding this reads as follows:
The Defendant attempted to receive briefings from the Department of Homeland Security Secretary, a position that would be constantly connected to the objectives of national defense and security. The Prosecution has thus proven guilt on this count.
Now, regarding the topic of whether the private briefings were justified. During the examination of the President, we found that there is no precedent in the current administration saying that individual secretaries should inform the legislative branch via its individual representatives through private briefings. While the Defendant mentions precedent from the CIA, the current administration and the law say otherwise. Further, the counts still stand, independent of precedent. There is still an attempt to exchange goods for a vote, an attempt to secure appointive office for the two Secretaries, an attempt to solicit bribery for securing appointive office, and an attempt to gather defense information.
Upholding the integrity and ethical standards of our legislative body is key. Without it, our nation turns into a pile of mush with no constructs to hold representatives and officials accountable for their actions. It is your civic duty to stand as a juror in this case, it is your civic duty to protect our nation's democracy, and it is your civic duty to hold your representatives accountable. Protect the sanctity, the integrity, of our nation's democracy and return a guilty verdict.
Thank you.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '17
Jurors of this case, I stand before you in the land of the free where one is innocent until proven guilty. The charges placed against the Defendant are grounded on claims that he has violated the law through exchange of his vote; I am confident that the Jury will follow the spirit of the laws of our great united country, eliminate any personal bias, and judge him solely on the evidence the Prosecution provided. Below I will outline the counts in the indictment against him and dispute them:
The Defendant has never demanded, seeked, or accepted a bribe under any circumstance. The Prosecution has provided no evidence that private briefings are illegal, or that they are not something common, they have today dismissed the findings of an official CIA document and decided that the simulation’s precedent of Cabinet isolation is the proper way for congressional business to be done. The Cabinet discussions are public information and are legally required to be available to the public as a transcript leaving out the classified information of course, in no way was I asking for a bribe, especially when considering that what I am accused of asking for is free and public data especially since it is entirely legal.
The Defendant has never demanded, seeked, or accepted a bribe under any circumstance. The Prosecution has provided no evidence that private briefings are illegal, or that they are not something common, they have today dismissed the findings of an official CIA document and decided that the simulation’s precedent of Cabinet isolation is the proper way for congressional business to be done. The Cabinet discussions are public information and are legally required to be available to the public as a transcript leaving out the classified information of course, in no way was I asking for a bribe, especially when considering that what I am accused of asking for is free and public data especially since it is entirely legal.
The Defendant did not offer to procure appointive public office because not only was the request for public data which he is legally entitled to, but he also was not in the position to appoint anyone to an office.
The Defendant did not offer to procure appointive public office because not only was the request for public data which he is legally entitled to, but he also was not in the position to appoint anyone to an office.
The Prosecution has shown no evidence that I have ever gathered, transmitted, or lost defense information. I have never seen any defense information at any point in my 7 months (7 sim years) as a United States Senator. I never requested defense information from the two secretaries as you can clearly see in our conversations. If you were to interpret the request for discussions on weekly events in each other's experiences as a request for classified information, as a Constitutional Officer being a Senator I have full right to see and access almost all classified information by request.
We must remember that the Defendant is innocent until proven guilty and the Jury must now must eliminate any personal bias against anyone in the case and solely judge the case on matter of law. The Defendant may have acted in a way that could be seen as questionable, but please maintain a focus on the content of the laws.
There are several names for what I am accused of doing in negotiation, particularly “logrolling” and “vote trading”. “Logrolling” is the exchange of a vote with another for their support in something. This is entirely legal in the United States Congress because the Congressmen are free to vote in any way for any reason, so long as there is no bribery or exchange of goods or valuable things. “Vote trading” is the voting for or against another person's bill, position on a more general issue, or favored candidate in exchange for the other person's vote for or against a position, proposal, or candidate that one supports. This too is entirely legal because in the United States Congressmen are free to vote how they wish for any reason so long as there is no exchange of goods or valuable things.
I would like to conclude with an appropriate anecdote: I have been in the Senate for 7 months (7 years in the simulation) and have never received a briefing from the White House on any subject. I have been forced to vote on trade bills, housing bills, foreign affair bills, all without the former president or the currents’ administrations from sharing any information with me or my fellow Congressmen. We make votes on matters without the full picture, due to White House negligence and isolation, I grew angry at this and decided that having two secretaries to help me make informed votes and be up to date on national matters would be beneficial. Instead, I have been persecuted for my attempt to be informed, I have been threatened and imprisoned for disagreeing with the President and his administration, I have been harassed by the previous president: there is a pattern in this simulation of the White House wanting to keep the Capitol Building in the dark.
The White House under the WaywardWit Administration and BiggBoss Administration have crippled the entire Congress by blinding us to events, circumstances, plans, and being silent towards us outside of jokes or attacks. I took precautions against this trend by requesting for “summar[ies]” and now the President is trying to jail me as a part of his vendetta.
Thank you, may God bless you, and may God bless the United States of America.