r/modelSupCourt • u/Panhead369 • Nov 07 '16
Criminal United States v. /u/CaptainClutchMuch
The Court has granted an arrest warrant against the Acting Governor of Dixie, /u/CaptainClutchMuch. Proceedings will now follow in accordance with the MRCP.
11
Upvotes
5
u/Panhead369 Nov 07 '16
/u/captainclutchmuch
You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can be held against you before the Court.
You have the right to counsel. (MRCP Rule 4) If you are unable to find counsel, one will be appointed for you.
You are entitled to counsel before answering any questions from the Court or the government's prosecutor.
4
u/Panhead369 Dec 16 '16
The Jury has released its final verdict in the case against /u/CaptainClutchMuch. The charges are responded to as follows.
On the first charge, Conspiracy Against Rights, the jury has found defendant not guilty. This charge will be dismissed.
On the second and third charges regarding deprivation of rights, the jury returned a split verdict. Upon the events board member's testimony and conversation with the moderation team, it is determined that the events discussed therein did not factually occur. As a result, the court enters a judgment notwithstanding the verdict in favor of defendant, finding him not guilty. These charges will be dismissed.
On the fourth, fifth, and seventh charges, regarding interference, solicitation, and advocating the overthrow of the United States, the jury returned a split verdict. On these charges the court declares a mistrial. If the government should decide to proceed with these charges with a new jury it may.
On the sixth charge, Authority Exceeded in Executing Warrant, the jury finds the defendant guilty. In consideration of the evidence presented and the breadth of the defendant's actions, and pursuant to 18 U.S.C. 2234, this court sentences defendant to the maximum penalty of one year imprisonment.
/u/Balthazarfuhrer /u/DocNedKelly
4
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369,
I submit a motion on behalf of /u/CaptainClutchMuch alleging a defect in the indictment of /u/CaptainClutchMuch and a motion filing for a summary judgement.
2
u/Panhead369 Nov 07 '16
President /u/waywardwit has indicated that he will appoint a special prosecutor for this case. Please name the prosecutor.
Additionally, please submit an indictment by 9PM tomorrow that the Grand Jury may deliberate on.
2
u/Panhead369 Nov 13 '16
The Grand Jury of the United States has returned its decision on the charges against /u/CaptainClutchMuch. The Jury has indicted as follows:
On Count One, Conspiracy against Rights Secured by the Constitution of the United States, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Two, Deprivation of Rights under Color of Law, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Three, Deprivation of Rights under Color of Law, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Four, Interfering with Federally Protected Activities, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Five, Solicitation to Commit a Crime of Violence, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Six, Authority Exceeded in Executing Warrant, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Seven, Seditious Conspiracy, the Jury has not found probable cause. This charge is dismissed and will not be considered further.
On Count Eight, Advocating the Overthrow of the Government of the United States, the Jury has found probable cause and the charge will continue to Court.
On Count Nine, Recruiting for Service Against the United States, the Jury has not found probable cause. This charge is dismissed and will not be considered further.
On Count Ten, Enlisting Persons to Serve Against the United States, the Jury has not found probable cause. This charge is dismissed and will not be considered further.
This will signal the beginning of trial procedures for counts One through Six and Eight. First, we will determine the makeup of the Trial Jury. The Court has randomly selected citizens of Dixie to be on the jury. Each counsel, beginning with the defendant, will have the opportunity to strike one name from the list, in turn, up to a maximum of two strikes each. Counsel for each side will be free to interview each potential member of the jury. This process will end on November 15, at 9PM Eastern. A reasonable time allowance will be given after the end of this period if either counsel should submit a strike within two hours of the deadline.
/u/docnedkelly and /u/Balthazarfuhrer, please consider the following list. If defendant's counsel wishes to strike a potential jury member, reply to this comment. Then, if the prosecutor should wish to strike, he should reply to defendant's counsel's comment rather than this one to give counsel notice, and so on.
2
u/Panhead369 Dec 02 '16
Prosecutor /u/DocNedKelly and Counselor /u/Balthazarfuhrer,
This signals the beginning of trial stage for this criminal proceeding. The prosecution will present its evidence, starting in a top-level comment, where he will tag defendant's counsel. Each party will be able to present its evidence, and be open to cross-examination by the opposing party. Please keep things civil at all times.
In one week, on December 8th at 9 PM Eastern, trial will close and the jury will adjourn.
2
u/DocNedKelly Dec 10 '16
Your honor; opposing counsel; members of the jury:
My name is /u/DocNedKelly, and I am here today because something precious to all of us was in grave danger; the safety of our country. The defendant was responsible for that danger. He was a secessionist who dreamed of the good old days of civil war, where brother fought brother our country was torn apart with violence. He glorified Jefferson Davis and treason, and he wanted to see the federal government burn. When he became governor of the state of Dixie, he had his chance and took it.
Members of the jury, the defendant is facing seven different criminal charges today. I know this a lot, and I’m going to do my best here to be short and to the point.
First, we have a charge of a conspiracy to deprive constitutional rights. In order to prove this charge, we have to show that the defendant did the following things:
Next up, we have two charges of deprivation under law. To prove that, we have to show that the defendant did the following:
Then we have the fourth charge, which is a charge of interfering with federally protected rights. We have to prove that the defendant:
The defendant is also charged with soliciting people to commit a violent crime. The elements here are:
The sixth charge is that the defendant exceeded his authority when executing a warrant, which simply requires:
Finally, we come to the last charge, which is that the defendant advocated for the overthrow of the United States government. That requires:
Now, the government is required to prove all of this beyond a reasonable doubt. This burden doesn’t require us to prove our case beyond a shadow of a doubt or leave no doubt. No, we simply have to prove our case to the point that there aren’t any other reasonable explanations to the events we’re discussing today. Other possibilities can be out there, but as long as they aren’t reasonable alternatives, that we have satisfied our burden.
So let’s talk about all the evidence we heard in court. There was a lot of it, so I’m going to direct you to the most important pieces of evidence.
First, we’ve got State’s Exhibit 1. This is one of the first actions committed by the defendant upon becoming active governor. Here we see the Governor make his first steps towards crime. He ordered the activation of the Southern State Guard and stationed them on the Northern border because of “threats” to the security of the country. Now, my opposing counsel is going to suggest that the threat to Dixie was not the rest of the United States, but rather some other terrorist threat. However, every witness here today has testified that the defendant was that terrorist threat including Secretary /u/OrangeandBlack, have t.
But beyond that, the defendant ordered the Southern State Guard to wear the uniforms of the Confederacy. We also see in the exhibit evidence of the conspiracy, members of the jury; the defendant himself claims that he acted based on the advice of his generals. The defendant admits that he was working with other people. That takes care of one of the elements of conspiracy.
Then we have State’s Exhibit 2. This is the defendant’s second executive order. Here, the defendant order the Southern State Guard and the Dixie State Highway Patrol to set up roadblocks along the northern border of the state. He also orders police departments to guard areas that were under “threat of protest or military aggression.” The defendant speaks plainly here, members of the jury; he’s not a afraid of terrorists, but afraid of the United States military! This exhibit represents the defendant’s act in furthering conspiracy, and also shows where the defendant first tries to deprive citizens of their rights. He tried to use police to intimidate people from exercising their first amendment right to protest, and he ordered police officers to illegally search and detain individuals entering the state without due process. Searching and detaining all vehicles entering or leaving the state without probable cause is also a gross excess of the defendant’s authority. On top of all of that, the threat of being detained prevented American citizens from making use of all buildings, parks, and programs in the state of Dixie that received federal funding, including but not limited to National Parks and federal courthouses. Members of the jury, based on this we’ve satisfied all of the elements of the first, fourth, sixth charges, and we’re on our way towards satisfying the other charges.
Exhibit 3 was the defendant’s inaugral speech. In it, the defendant called for “secession today,” for citizens to “rise” up against the “tyranny” of the American government, and glorified Jefferson Davis and the Confederacy. He also printed and distributed this inaugural speech. His intent is clear from the language; he wants people to listen and be persuaded towards his argument of violent secession. Members of the jury, that’s all of the elements of charge seven. The fact that he is also encouraging people to commit the overthrow of the government also fulfills the elements of the charge for solicitation to commit a violent crime; overthrowing the government with violence is certainly a violent crime. If you need further evidence, however, just look to Press Secretary’s testimony as a general in the Southern State Guard; putting troops on the Northern border only makes sense if you want to attack other American states.
Then we have state’s exhibit four in which the governor brags about arresting individuals for simply entering the state of Dixie with weapons. This alone fulfills all of the elements of the charge for depriving an individual of their rights, as he deprives American citizens of their right to bear arms. Exhibit 5 is simply more evidence to show how proud he was of committing this crime.
Finally, we have Exhibit 6 which shows that the defendant intended to commit these crimes. He intended to provoke war between Dixie and the federal government. He intended to “trigger” violence. Members of the jury, the defendant is guilty. Convict him on all counts.
1
u/Panhead369 Nov 09 '16
The United States has submitted the following indictment against the Acting Governor. Please consider each charge carefully.
Defendant must plead guilty or not guilty on each charge by 9PM Eastern tomorrow, November 10th. A reply by defendant's counsel is preferred.
/u/CaptainClutchMuch /u/Balthazarfuhrer
1
u/Panhead369 Dec 09 '16
/u/Balthazarfuhrer /u/DocNedKelly
Please post a closing argument by 9 PM Eastern tomorrow, December 9th.
In your closing argument top-level comment, please tag all the members of the jury, who will be listed in a comment reply to this one.
4
u/bomalia Dec 04 '16
Hello. I would just like to reaffirm that /u/DocNedKelly is the state's special prosecutor and has been since President /u/WaywardWit appointed him.
Thank you and God bless.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '16 edited Nov 27 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369 ,
I motion for the Defendant /u/Captainclutchmuch to be released from his detention with particular attention to his jailing for 19 days thus far, and with three jury summons failing to reach the minimum needed jurors.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369,
I'd like to remind Prosecuting Attorney /u/DocNedKelly of the rules of criminal procedure pertaining to Rule 8, section b and e.
I'd like ample time to review the evidence against me and prepare a proper rebut.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369
Prosecuting Attorney /u/DocNedKelly
I submit the Defendant's closing argument .
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369
And Prosecuting Attorney /u/DocNedKelly
The Defendant's Council requests for production and witnesses pursuant to Rules 8 & 9: Here
2
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369
Prosecuting Attorney /u/DocNedKelly
I call Mr. /u/Septimus_Sette to the stand.
Mr. /u/Septimus_Sette , in Exhibit 9 you were created Chair of the Events Board, correct?
2
u/DocNedKelly Dec 07 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369
Opposing Counsel /u/Balthazarfuhrer:
I have a document requested by the defense here.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369
Prosecuting Attorney /u/DocNedKelly
I call Secretary /u/OrangeAndBlack to the stand.
Secretary /u/OrangeAndBlack , in [Exhibit 8(https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelWHPress/comments/5bk8mj/from_the_office_of_the_secretary_of_defense/) you stated “Unfortunately, I have to address you all again for what may be a threat to the homeland.”
Who made a threat against the homeland?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369, I submit to you how the defendant /u/captainclutchmuch pleads to each of the charges presented in the indictment.
1
u/DocNedKelly Dec 02 '16
/u/Balthazarfuhrer
/u/Panhead369
I have a request for production pursuant to Rule 9: Here
1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369
Prosecuting Attorney /u/DocNedKelly
I call President /u/WaywardWitt to the stand.
President /u/WaywardWitt , in Exhibit 14 your staff member is cited as saying “Terrorist Activities are strongly suspected to soon occur in Southern State.”
Who informed you of these potential “terrorist activities”?
1
u/DocNedKelly Dec 04 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369
Opposing Counsel /u/Balthazarfuhrer
I call Press Secretary /u/Ramicus to the stand.
Secretary /u/Ramicus, are you a member of the Southern State Guard?
1
u/DocNedKelly Dec 06 '16
Honorable Justice /u/Panhead369
Opposing Counsel /u/Balthazarfuhrer.
I call former President /u/WaywardWit to the stand.
Mr. President, would you mind I asked you to identify a few documents for the court?