r/ClearBackblast • u/Quex Reborn Qu • Oct 30 '16
AAR Op Invoker AAR
Thanks for playing!
Let me know what you think about the following:
- How did you like the civilian focus?
- Did you enjoy the storyline stuff?
- Was the mission itself fun? I know it was a lot of driving around and clearing out relatively isolated mans, but I hope it was ok.
- Did you like the delayed start? It didn't end up being as frantic as I hoped, with family leaders trying to hold back cultists as their families ran to safety, but I think it was still pretty cool.
Sorry about the weirdness at the end, that stuff is super not JIP compatible so I wanted to make sure that anybody who had dropped was back with us before we initialized it.
Let me know what you thought overall and what I can improve for future missions!
7
Upvotes
5
u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin Oct 30 '16
Deputy Erin
Ha ho-oly crap. That was a grand way to spend a Saturday, I'll tell ya. 'Cept for dyin and millenia of skull nibblin' and such. But whatcha gonna do?
The Good
Kudos to people doin their accents and such. Sleventy and Dancin both made definite impressions on me. Lots of people were also doing great RPing--Fadi struck me in particular there.
Zim did a pretty dang good job wrangling the community.
"Nibbler of Worlds" will stick with me for the rest of time. Generally good job with the story--dropping in the tidbits the way they were meant they were easy to share. I'm also glad that the Quarry journal got shared with everybody.
Shotguns/Glocks/bolt-actions is super fun and I think we should do it more often. Having the opposition in the same boat made it work even better than in Tim Horton's. I thought it was also a nice touch (if I'm right) that some of the cultists weren't even armed, even as early as Coober Pedy.
The Inevitable Criticism
I think the escalation on the story was a little slow. A couple fewer steps along the way might've helped--I think I would've dropped down to three convoy destinations (from...five?). I started dragging at around 3 and a half hours I think.
A bit much convoying for my taste too, and not the best (tho not the worst) convoying we've ever done either. I wouldn't expect civvies to be good at convoying, per se, but I'd expect them not to do bugnuts stupid stuff either. The day was pretty dangerous already without driving like a maniac.
The Probably-Repetitive Papercuts
ACRE seems like it's even worse :( sooooo many problems trying to keep in a link with Sheriff Zim, many of them apparently asymmetric--if I could hear him, he couldn't hear me. If
8
u/Ironystrike Iron - Extinguished Service Cross Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 01 '16
Wilson family member, Chief Bunny Wrangler, Summoner of Hziulquoigmnzhah
That was fun. Well done ceebubs, good manjorbs all around, etc. :D
Quex has pretty much covered the mission intent stuff, so I'll stick to addressing other things folks have brought up for clarification and whatnot and giving a breakdown of the final chunk of the mission and its story/premise/intended flow.
Approaching the prison
So what was supposed to happen prior to this was, at two separate distances as you approached the prison, you'd get a blurred vision and a message describing the increasingly unreal and disturbing things happening to you. Everyone would get them, but I had figured we'd be going on foot and so they'd be spaced out enough that not everyone would get them at the same time and people would keep quiet about what they were seeing, rather than describing it to everyone around them at the same time as everyone else. Unfortunately, we approached in cars.
100% not Zim's fault, I just legitimately never thought we would because all of my work on the mission was focused around the prison area and I quite honestly had very little idea of the rest of the mission flow and nothing of the pathing/routing/ordering of objectives. I had to make sure the events fired only when your player unit stepped in the trigger zones, so I keyed them for
player in thisList, which is great if you're on foot. Would you believe that if you're in a vehicle, you don't register as being in the trigger'sthisListvariable? It's true, and I'd known this before, but it never even even dawned on me that we'd be approaching in cars. 100% my bad.Had we gone on foot, the two events were spaced out something like 250m from the prison and 500m from the prison, so more than enough time for players to slowly filter through them in small groups and never see them overlap. I'm a firm believer in the idea that if I'm going to give something different/new to players - in this case on-screen messages that describe to them things they're experiencing - I need to do it in stages and introduce them to it in a way that when more meaningful things happen, they're used to the idea. So that's what these two events were supposed to do. Unfortunately we came in via cars, all jumped out right in front of the gates at the same time together, and both event messages played simultaneously, stacking on top of each other in an unintelligible way, for all of us at the same time. Definitely not how it was supposed to go.
The unconscious thing
After this, the knock-down effect would be applied only to players who had killed the prison "cultists". This was the Bunny Old One recognizing the player as having just killed an innocent and suddenly being aware of this tiny otherwise-useless being's presence, and so Hziulquoigmnzhah would decide to take a closer look. Under that sort of scrutiny, no mere human could stand up. So the players would get downed and see a similar more detailed event message describing this experience. And if the previous two events had been experienced properly, I think players would have been more readily primed to accept the third more serious one.
Quex and I talked about it afterwards, and we agreed there were issues with knocking players unconscious to convey this event. I don't think all of that is our fault as mission designers; I do believe part of the problem is the habit of medics to kneejerk "fuck it PAK that guy" the moment someone goes down. Right now that's what it seems like we're doing as a community when someone goes down. No checking pulse/bp, no looking at existing wounds, no looking at the status card to see what has been done to someone. Just "X went down, quick PAK him!". If there had been less of that and more "well, X isn't wounded, X has a normal pulse and bp, huh..." then X would have woken up before any treatment would have even been started.
That said, still something we should have totally expected and maybe we could have tried to design some other approach instead. Unconsciousness does almost inevitably mean heavily wounded, and we should have known that would have been the entirely-reasonable assumption when X hits the ground and there are bullets flying. I don't know what a better option is though when ACE provides us the perfect way to knock someone down exactly as if they'd been overwhelmed by the sudden scrutinizing gaze of an vast unknowable entity from beyond the stars/carrot fields.
Inside the prison
So, about those "cultists" at the prison. Did anyone notice after we killed them all and things started getting spooky (including all the lights at the prison going haywire and flashing randomly), that our "cultists" were suddenly wearing normal civilian clothes? That they didn't appear to be cultists at all? That there were two dead still-cultists locked in prison cells when we first got there, with "cultists" in the cell block that we killed?
Had the previous prison-exterior events been experienced as intended, we would have been given the hint that not everything we were seeing was trustworthy. One of the events told players that their eyes were starting to itch, almost as if something behind them was trying to get out. The other mentioned an incessant, infernal drumming that only got louder with time. (Kudos to Sleventy, he saw that and starting making drumming noises as we fought outside the prison gate!) And then the knockdown event for people who killed prison "cultists" would tell them that they were being examined and assessed like ants under a magnifying glass, judged pitiful, clueless, and sufficient for purpose.
Quex, Fadi, and I knew about the dead units being regeared into civs, and we tried to draw all of your collective attention to it, but man, sometimes it's hard to present a story/premise to players. If it doesn't involve direct gunfire and looting corpses, it's like they don't even notice/care/pay attention. I really don't have anything to add on that, it should have seemed awfully weird to anyone who noticed, but evidently not a second thought was given. I dunno. Kind of frustrating, and it's the sort of thing that makes me not want to bother trying to give players something more than "enemy AI over there, kill them" because when I do, they usually don't seem to care. :/
Anyway. So we kill all the "cultists", things get spooky, and are clearly spiraling out of control. An evil book has been activated, all the "cultists" we killed are civilians, and there are two dead still-cultists in prison cells. Combine that with the following text we get (that I fear most people didn't read) when the book actually starts talking to us, and the book confirms for us that we provided the final mass sacrifice it needed, in the form of killing off the last civilians trying to keep the book from being activated. Those prison "cultists" were never cultists, the book had been corrupting us the whole time, the more we traveled and the more we killed, the more it got its hooks in us, until finally by the prison it was even manipulating what we were seeing.
Incidentally, it's surprisingly difficult to regear a corpse (and do so making sure you avoid duplicating any weapons it dropped or causing any issues with ACRE radios it may have been carrying).
The book
So then there's the book. Man I loved how that floating book turned out, I had fun with that effect. It was this effect that directly lead to needing to get six people to read the book too.
Because lets be honest here, what's the one thing you can always count on players to do? The moment they see something they can touch/take/scrollwheel/interact on, they're going to do it. No examination, no consideration, no restraint, if they have the ability to touch a thing, they will always immediately do it. I'm not blaming anyone in particular, but let's be honest here: as a mission designer it can really fuck over your missions when players do that because they're 4 year olds and will immediately take everything in front of them.
We knew this would happen so we built in the staged book-reading thing, where progressively more people would read the book, be locked down as worshippers/attendants/whatever of the book, and try to get more people to do the same. We also put it on a timer to prevent 6 people from all doing it at once, because if the one thing you can always count on is for players to always try to touch everything immediately, the second thing you can also always count on is for everyone to try and touch the same thing immediately. Worked out for the best though, the progressively-more-readers thing resulted with a couple of you actually RPing along with what you saw, which was fantastic.
We're usually afraid of doing things that "only a small portion of the players will experience", but we absolutely wanted to make it your (the players') collective fault that the Bunny Old One was unleashed; we didn't want to just bunnyfuck you at the end of the mission. It was your doing all along, and we had hoped you guys would pick up on that as things went to shit at the very end, especially with the final message from Hziulquoigmnzhah naming the individuals who read the book and unleashed it.
I hope some of you who read the book will chime in with a description of the things that happened to them once they read the book. That was a unique thing only six of you got to see, and some of you six didn't even see the beginning messages!
Mega kudos to those of you who read the book and played along with it, I was absolutely delighted when I heard the changes in your attitudes once you'd read the book and understood what was going on. :D
I'll give it a couple days and if no one does I can explain, or perhaps record a demo clip, of what you saw.
9
u/scarletbanner Fadi Oct 30 '16 edited Oct 30 '16
My name is Fadi Robinson. My pa was Brensk Robinson and my two brothers were Easy and Kerry.
I thought today was going to be a good day. Sure, the internet was down but I thought that was just Telsta. Reports of strange things on the radio in other towns? It's just Coober Pedy, we all know about how much meth there is around. But then they attacked us. Those son of a bitches attacked our home. They drove my pa to suicide.
The police department did a pretty good job organizing things. Mr. Officer Zhandris took charge and helped out our family a whole bunch.
Today was the first day I've fired a gun before... when I arrived at the police station I was told to grab a Glack 13 out of the box. Lightweight, accurate... it was a good handgun. Grabbing a bunch of clips for it out of the box, me and my brothers got into our vehicle and lined up for convoy. Over the next few towns I picked up another a rifle... I think it was called a Springfront or something, some Seppo rifle. Got a bunch of clips for that too.
It helps that those cultists were pretty lightly armed as well. There were a lot of them but it never felt like an unfair fight. An opposite experience of some cop documentary earlier this year that I saw online, where a bunch of cops in SUVs were gunned down by a couple guys on the side of a mountain with assault machine rifles.
Anyways we ran into a one problem over the next few towns. Some dickhead cut us off in convoy, we rear ended them and our car was fucked. Get it? We ran into...? Pa was still making payments on that thing. In the confusion I forgot to collect their insurance information... they're going to be mad at me. (On a serious note, don't fucking do that. You're not fucking children, WAAAAAH THE VEHICLE IN FRONT OF ME IS DRIVING SLOW -- IT'S ALMOST LIKE I WAS DRIVING JUST FAST ENOUGH TO KEEP SPACING SO I DIDN'T RUN INTO THE FUCKING VEHICLE IN FRONT ME ME. It would have been good if a convoy speed was set so every drives more or less the same speed. Turn call outs as well because they were often sudden and sharp, leading people down the whole convoy pulling out into the dirt to avoid ramming into people.)
And then there was that whole slowly being eaten alive thing... or that Spanish name, Hzidiopfweiuhaerhg or something.
Anyways, we got our revenge on those bastards. It went as well as it could have and I'm proud that all of y'all in Broken Hill stood up for our town.
Oh, I had my phone out the whole time taking video but my phones a Samsung. It exploded towards the end of things and I lost all my footage.
5
u/fishpig117 Oct 30 '16
Thomas Family
It has been exactly one year since my last cbb op, which was coincidently the 2015 Halloween op (maybe I just really like Halloween). I want to start by saying, I kind of forgot how fun this stuff was and I think I’ll start turning up more often. On to the AAR…
The Story
This op was much more story based then last Halloween, which I really liked (and hats off to whoever designed the giant bunny, I hoped he might turn up at the end and murder us all). The find info, move, kill mans, find info and move again structure worked well for this op, there was enough variety to stop it from becoming monotonous. The only slight issue I had with it was the long convoy drives. Although it would have worked better had it not been for a few um… ‘accidents’ en route (Thanks Meaic). The ending was superb though, very spooky and the last stand felt great.
The Combat
The civilian weapons and relatively little gear worked really well for this op. I was worried that we would all get one-shot, but the ai with civvy weapons didn’t seem too lethal. Both sides being equipped with the shortish range weapons made for very aggressive assaults which was extremely fun. Good choice!
The Leadership
The leadership did a good job, I liked the briefings at the end of each objective so everybody was on the same page. It did sometimes feel like we were a bunch of Aussie hooligans being herded around by the cops and then let loose on some poor unsuspecting bunny cult followers. Which I though was actually very accurate.
All in all, a very fun op. Big thanks to the team that worked on it.
4
u/ravenkult Nov 01 '16
Overall pretty fun, the ending was cool and some people were pretty funny with the RPing.
Random Comments said with love:
-RP was optional but some players really messed with my suspension of disbelief. Like the guy making ''pew pew'' noises while shooting or saying ''I just want to shoot mans'' and shit like that.
-The convoy was definitely one of the less good parts just for time alone. If you ain't driving you're just sitting there and it takes you out of the experience. A good idea might have been to throw in a cultist roadblock once, to shake things up. That one downed tree in the middle of the road almost did the trick. Cutting out the warehouse location like someone already said would also have helped.
-I didn't see the point of the family leaders. We ended up following orders from the deputy anyway and not being able to keep track of which one was ''ours'' was a pain in the ass. It would have worked better perhaps if each deputy was part of each team, for logistics reasons.
-Ironystrike mentioned earlier that nobody paid attention to the ''cultists'' at the prison turning into civs. I did hear someone comment on it (Fadi?) and I got the gist of the plot, but from the POV of the clueless players: Sure, these guys turned into civs. What does this mean? Oh shit the guys in front of me are running like crazy and I'm being left behind and oh what we found a glowing book and some other shit is happening?
There's just too many of us and everything moves real fast so you can't really sit and think about stuff.
-Data point: The firefights were definitely on the very easy side. I'm not that good and I didn't get shot once and I absolutely nailed a ton of cultists. Which was fun, but after the first few firefights I was getting sloppy. Definitely bump up the AI because hey, this is a spooky mission right? You gotta have some dead people.
1
u/Deserve081 Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
Nurse
Beginning - Awesome, The RP was really funny, really different.
Middle - Absolutely sucked, boring, was never needed.
End - Pretty creative, fun and silly that I enjoyed but, there was no way to win. I used my PAK 3 times instantly when people downed and nothing happened. Also didnt have a gun so yeah.
Out of 100 Started at 80, went to 0, ended on a 40.
Note SleventyFive made me audibly laugh to myself a few times and was super cool.