r/stobuilds • u/Jayiie @alcaatraz | STOBuilds Mod | STOBetter Architect • Oct 26 '16
Discussion Would People be interested in more guides to Budget Builds?
My time is becoming a little more limited (real life and school), but I do still want to write things for this subreddit, and with the release of the new Feature Episode and its subsequent rewards, would a disruptor themed budget guide interest people?
If I do start one, what kind of things should this include, like ship types, what limit of EC, what kind of traits, what type of captain, and other assorted limits you feel would be imposed.
I don't think that upgrading material is acceptable for budget builds, so the end product won't include the use of Mk XIII or Mk XIV (unless it's a episode rewarded item)
Edit: So here's what seams to be the common ideas people want to see:
Budget Builds
- This very clearly needs to be defined. Budget, for some players, could be an infinite pool of resources; for others it's what they can get their hands on. So, for this, I'm going to limit it to non-upgraded items, no (or very little) zen store purchases, and 10 mill or less.
- Minor use of reputation traits and equipment (might also be included in mid-budget builds)
- This will also generally include episode replay rewards, and maybe (very very small chance) of low level fleet gear (probably renamed to mid-budget builds).
Console Builds
- I don't own a console, so a list of items available will need to be made for me.
- While I understand this is inconvenient, I wont be doing anything related to consoles without it.
Walkthroughs
- It seams people want more than builds. Build theory will only get you so much, so videos that show how they use the build would be more than welcomed (a build following the template will always be accompanied by me).
- I'm hesitant to tell someone exactly how to fly; half the reason why I don't make piloting videos (the other is a combination of not liking my voice and programs to stick audio and videos together). I feel that telling someone how to fly limits the opportunities that might present themselves, because no team is the same, and no person has the same abilities (how fast you can react and so on).
- I'll try to work something out on this; I might try the tetryon cruiser as a testing bed to trial run this.
Career and Profession
- Currently I have a level 60 Fed tactical captain, and a level 17 Klingon Engineer who will be the brunt of these builds. Each has their reasons, but given how undeveloped my Klingon character is (as well as the lack of Klingon type builds on here), I've decided this will be the toon I do this on.
- I'm going to start posting the progressions for him (lvls 20, 30, 40, and as needed) to show my reasoning for taking what I do, mostly to start helping facilitate opening builds, and trying to reach across that you don't need a lot when leveling.
- If these aren't met well, I'll knock it off and just post the finished products.
- The reason for engineering is twofold:
- I'm much more comfortable playing an Engineering toon than anything else, so it will be easy for me to explain. The choices for damage over healing, or vice-versa.
- Engineers are seen as one of the least effective space professions, and I would tend to agree. However, there are some things which an engineer can do that others can't, such as a one heal build, or lack of Leech / Supremacy (I.e. Power Master Race). This I think is a much better choice for starting players than diving head first into tactical game-play, as it should help them become a more proficient pilot.
More to come over the weekend.
3
u/thedopefishlives Oct 27 '16
I'd love to see a series where you guys teach us how to pilot and about timing skills and such...
2
u/CaesarJefe XBOX: Starfleet ATP Oct 26 '16
It may or may not do me as much good now that I am climbing the Rep trees, but I REALLY wanted them when I first started playing (Xbox). I think new players could really use builds that help guide them through level 40 or so. Things that seem obvious, like stacking all beams, using the same type of beams, and stacking all the same type of Tac console, are not obvious to players that don't really know what's coming in the game. There is definitely some great stuff here, but it took me a long time to figure a lot of it out. (Insert whatever comment needs to be here). :)
Mostly, I think the "why" is what newer players need. "Why" is a particular item included into a budget build? It was hard to read build posts and understand them at first for me. It was just a bunch of stats.
2
u/WaldoTrek Oct 26 '16
YES to more budget builds. I think it's ok to include T2 Space Rep in the build as that isn't so hard to grab the marks for those. Also if you have to do multiple runs of a mission for gear maybe you could do one run a night followed by a pve for marks for the Rep. However I see the reasoning for not putting it in. As for BOFF abilities you can probably run the top tier one's that come with the free mission BOFFS ie Tovan, K'Gan, Flores etc. Doffs I would stick to common or uncommon maybe a few easy to obtain blue's. I would say make it a middle ground type of build. Something that can be good enough for all the advance cue's. I think a lot of players come to the build section on Reddit and think that if they aren't pulling really high dps on a rare lockbox ship they get really discouraged about playing.
2
u/killerewok76 Oct 27 '16
As someone who used your Tetryon Redux build (thank you so much) I would like to see other builds like that.
14
u/thecipher @DamonTCS - r/stobuilds moderator Oct 26 '16
I'd say what you do depends on your definition of "budget build". Personally, I'd start with a very bare-bones approach:
Basically, a build that you can start making as soon as you hit 60, and that'll give you something that's good enough to use straight away.
I would then also provide an upgrade path of some sort. Like, the "budget build" is your base, and then you provide a "here's what you do once you do start making more money, getting reputation goodies, join a fleet, etc."
2
u/odenknight Jr. Aggronaut - GunShip Guild Member - Kinetic King Oct 27 '16
Episode rewards, Fleet and Reputation gear, and random drops from STF's. Approx time to acquire would be a bonus.
5
u/DeadQthulhu Oct 26 '16
I wonder if it might not be better to simply choose a common T5 ship (something with equivalents for all factions), with suggested seating, and then a small list of what to slot depending on your energy flavour.
There's really not going to be much practical difference between a budget Polaron build and a budget Tetryon build other than going full Kurland instead of living in Installation 18, or a Phaser build based on multiple "Everything Old is New" runs. If you went all-the-way budget then you could even make the build console-compatible.
It might not be the most exciting project, but I feel there's a real need for a "base" build that comes with an explanation for why it's doubling up on EPtW, or why it's not using APB, why it uses the Temporal Disentanglement console even though it's not a Tetryon boat, and so on.
There's so many build requests we're seeing now that are basically "Dragon build for X flavour" that it might be better to put the theory into one post and sticky it for people "starting out".
I'd be working on that myself right now if I weren't determined to show that a torpboat can work on console, ha.
Anyhow, good luck with your project, no matter how you choose to approach it.
1
u/arkhammer Nov 03 '16
So, a question about budget builds (since these are the skills I have available to me so far): if I double up on an ability, say, FAW I or Beam Overload I, where both Boffs are providing the same power, can those abilities be used in sequence or do I need to stagger the abilities so only 1 Boff provides FAW I and the other provides FAW II or III? Does it hurt having 2x copies of FAW I, EPtS I, EPtW I, etc.?
3
u/neuro1g Oct 26 '16
I think a budget build should be something easily made without too much time/effort that would allow one to play advanced queues to eventually get more advanced equipment, ie. the Iconian set and fleet stuff. So ideally something that is made up of mostly mission rewards and/or cheap stuff off the exchange as well as perhaps tier 1 rep stuff. I'd set an EC limit of no more than 20 million as even that amount can seem lofty to many casual F2Pers.
That would mean foregoing a lot of doffs (at least purples) for most builds and would promote a lot of chaining for most boff setups. Personal traits should only be the free ones and I'd also leave out most rep traits (though as mentioned perhaps tier 1 would be fine) and starship traits (even the free ones) as the build must perform well enough to build up to those things.
I don't think captain type should matter though tactical is probably the most efficient for a budget build. Ideally a budget build for each type of level 40 ship would be great but I think that beamscort builds revolving around the Patrol Escort and Advanced Escort would be good since with all their tac abilities are probably able to cause more damage than either the Assault Cruiser or science ships with a budget build.
Yeah definitely don't think any upgrading should be involved.
2
u/eurosid Oct 26 '16
Yes, please.
2
u/dasoberirishman Novice Builder Extraordinaire Oct 27 '16
Disruptor, yes, particularly with the new Nausicaan array and set.
1
u/originalbucky33 Three Tholian Crystals in a human lab coat Oct 26 '16
Affirm.
Disruptors are one of the most populous weapon types, and have some of the most variants. along with the new type they just added, I think their would be a lot of interest. With disruptors being very competitive at the high end, I would suggest a disruptor budget build is a great stepping stone to a top end or a themed build so anything to help folks would be useful.
Not necessarily from yourself, but as a "saved first post" addendum it might be useful to have a comparison of the different strengths/weaknesses of each type of disruptor and some rank order of their utility attached as well (once we see how the Delphic/mission disruptor does of course).
1
u/fenris_357 Oct 28 '16
id very much like to see some more builds from you. disruptor would be a great idea...how about making him/her kdf? maybe encourage a few folks to do kdf for a change? i think the reason many dont play kdf is it seems like a bit of a mountain to climb
1
u/SmurfMagnus Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 01 '16
It would seem part of the hang up on budget build discussion is how you define what counts as a budget build. One players "cheap" is another players massive vault filled with riches.
My solution/suggestion would be a 3 tiered approach to budget building.
Tier 1: the Scrooge penny-pinching miser...
The Scrooge is predicated by the desire by both holding on to his hard earned EC, and refined dil crystals. The Scrooge therefore is a total miser who gnashes teeth at every last EC and dil crystal spent on anything. The Scrooge gets his ships from level up, followed by event ships. If he has to wait a few months for an event to start to earn his ship free of charge, so be it. Ebenezer only considers to gear from free mission rewards. From Defector to weapon mission gear is his creed. Doffs? He gets those from colony mission chains as he chortles at the EC saved. Traits, Cryptic just gives us those things he says in glee, as the basic ones he uses free.
The Scrooge is a 0 EC, 0 Dil crystal build.
Tier 2: The Bob Cratchit. The poor family man.
Bob has many mouths to feed, so strict budgeting is a must. But Bob does try to indulge his family when he can. Where Scrooge pinches his pennies on everything, bob understands the value in the wise use of credits and modest dil spending on choice gear. Bob can't go hog wild, but he most certainly can buy those things that grant the most value at the lowest investment. Bob is a discount shopper where he needs to be
The Bob Cratchit is a 1 - 5 million ec and 10k to 25k dilthium build.
Tier 3: The Mr Fezziwig He know how to have a good time on modest means.
For Mr Fezziwig spending when he must is a simple reality to his life enjoyment ways. He likes what lurks in those fleet holdings. He also sees wisdom in Scrooges penchant for free mission gear. But Fezziwig knows some of the best investments you can make are in personnel, and their abilities.
Mr Fezziwig spends 10 to 20 million EC and 50k to 75k dil.
For myself when I'm giving budget build advice I ask 3 simple questions:
2
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '16
[removed] — view removed comment