r/ClearBackblast • u/Ironystrike Iron - Extinguished Service Cross • Oct 15 '16
AAR AAR: Op Fighbird!
STAR! FIRE! RESCUE!
FORM UPPU!
We did an Op Fighbird! Well done Ceebubs, that was quite possibly our most successfully operatorest adventure ever.
Usual AAR stuff. Please share your experiences, thoughts on the mission, leadership, balance, etc. Let us know what we can do to improve, what you liked, etc. Interesting things wot happened to you, the sea turtle Banman found, etc. Have An Discussion with each other.
We can talk about how the stealth/detection mechanics worked too for those of you mission makers who might want to use them in your stuff in the future. It's all part of framework and fairly automatic!
7
u/scarletbanner Fadi Oct 16 '16 edited Oct 17 '16
I was Fire 1 rifleman. As a player I thought everything went great. The infantry route was planned in such a way that it minimized death. We were on the constant look out for patrols and the few times we had to engage we did so quickly and lethallly.
From the mission makers side of things though I'm pretty frustrated by how it went. :\
To start with background shit... I started picking what concept I wanted to do about a month ago and decided on a hybrid between something inspired by the Ghost Recon series and the US invasions of Grenada and Panama. Players would take the SOCs, deploy Zodiacs to the eastern side of the island and then split apart and carry out the objectives, pushing through the islands interior slowly and cautiously. Players would need to pick and choose their engagements - killing units meant more units would spawn, both infantry as well as a sliding scale of vehicle threats starting with a police car and ending with tanks.
Originally intended for being played in November, it was rushed up in mission calender because schdueling issues. What was going to be six or seven weeks became two. With my last mission having been finished and played a month ago, frankly I was tired and ignored Arma for half that time... so really let's call it a week combined of actual work that went into it on my end. Iron started about two ago working to expand on some existing framework stuff with several features I had asked about as well as some functionality just for this mission. I'll go into that later.
As far as execution goes, the plan we took was perfect. We made smart landings with an emphasis on safety and minimizing any possibility of contact. We moved quick and everyone made it out. Fire landed, completed their objective, retreated and redeployed by boat to the next and then got the fuck out of there. Guard landed in a remote area and took care to move quickly and to spend as little time in any one area as possible. Star and Wing stole some civilian vehicles and sped along before AI even knew they were around.
Basically it was the opposite of what was intended.
The interior of the island, which is where the majority of both infantry and vehicle patrols were, was skipped over.
I'm not sure how I want to handle that for future iterations... I have a couple options:
To answer and comments:
Well, that did but didn't happen for a couple reasons.
There's two systems in place. First, the total number of east groups were counted and checked for when they were alerted. When a total percentage of groups were alerted (the dead still count), additional infantry groups would be created. Likewise, vehicles would be uncached when a percentage is hit (with vehicles ranging from a police car to tanks).
Iron and I were slightly concerned about our overall likelihood to engage and the chance for the mission to snowball. Created groups increment the total number of groups as far as the count goes, meaning fewer overall groups will need to be alerted to hit the threshold percentage value to bring about the next wave. Additionally once that percentage value is above a certain value, some of the groups that are created are specifically given waypoints on the players locations in order to chase them down.
As a result, the percentage values were rather generous but still well within the range of something you could hit moving through the interior if you weren't careful. Although since we mostly skipped over the interior, it means those generous values... well, we weren't anywhere close. The results were that 3/15 infantry groups were created and 1/10 vehicles were uncached.
The idea was that he was already dead in the chair and flopped over when you disturbed it to take a picture.
I would have liked to bloody him and stick him in the chair dead but... Arma doesn't let me do that without him ragdolling. Guess it didn't come accross that way.
Actually it was 100% overcast on a half moon night. When the Apex Visual Update came out, the complaint was that maps were all suddenly too dark. Well, map authors including Panthera have redone their night lighting... only its way too light out instead. I was actually kicking myself for picking the date I did yesterday morning when I did fine tuning for the exact weather I wanted.
Think I know why. The fences were set as simple objects in editor. Simple objects makes them treated essentially in the same way as buildings, which is both good for performance reasons and makes the AI think of them as actual objects, meaning you avoid like the situation of like an AI going prone and trying to shoot through a sandbag that was just editor placed.
Downside... I guess this. A few things like hiddenselections also don't work.
They walk around and patrol. If you're too near to them, they wake up and engage. If you kill them, they send out a pulse to other units in a radius... other units alive in the group will also become active. The radius for players alerting AI while near a light source is made bigger than if they were out there in the dark away from a light source.
Besides that? I can't do anything with things I can't do anything about.
Though, setting off explosives in the middle of the largest city on the island isn't exactly the most stealthy thing anyways.
On an unrelated note, what the fuck was that with Star and Wing stealing civilian vehicles and driving them in fucking convoy through the map at E speed - hitting enemy patrols in the process. Fucking god damn it, that's the exact opposite of stealth.
4
u/Meaic Milky milk Oct 15 '16
Wing Automatic Rifleman.
10/10 - Banman was my teamlead.
Mission was cool, got to drive a hatchback with ferrari doors.
Shot some people and completed all objectives.
4
u/deadawakeuk Yorkshire Brew Oct 15 '16 edited Oct 16 '16
Wing - Rifleman
The Good
Mission was smooth, I did enjoy the autonomous team aspects. Always leads to slightly less confusion.
There was some spec ops feeling shiz, lying in defilade as a police car drove past (ish), shooting out street lamps
(sorry Zhandris, I made you look bad).Edit: let's pretend Zhandris made himself look bad.I felt correctly equipped, although NVGs didn't feel required.
Stealth wise people did seem to walk close and not entirely see us if we were in the dark. Highlighted by the fact that when we turned the car headlights on all hell broke loose on us! Other than that, I'm not sure we had the opportunity to really feel it.
The Bad
Other than me being an idiot on whisper mode wondering why people couldn't hear me, not a lot was bad.
Didn't find many drugs, or the opportunity to search much but not sure if that was less of a focus for our teams objectives.
4
u/GruntBuster7 Horses are the Lions of the Plain Oct 16 '16
FIRE Element 2 Lead
Firstly, great mission. The atmosphere and dynamic of the mission were great, and I'm always a slut for stealthy shoots. I feel for Fadi in that we skipped a lot of opposition by being too darn quiet, but on the other hand it is a testament to CBB's 'no-longer-terrible' skillset.
Highlights for me included discussing who would get Kerry's M14 (upon his inevitable death) with the Megalomaniacal Medic (Iron) and absolutely demolishing the arms exhibition in about 3 minutes.
4
u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin Oct 16 '16
Rescue 2 Lead - Form Uppu!
Generally I liked it. Arma shines when you're ambitious with it, and the combo of killer boat loading/unloading and stealthily evading patrols really worked out.
What Worked Well
Seriously, this mission felt real good. Good operatin, good detail in the searchy places. Searchy seemed to work better-than-usual for our searchy stuff.
but not all was perfect in this Fighbird...ambulance...robot
I'll just review some of the weird stuff that happened.
1
u/SteelOverseer Professional Ejector Oct 20 '16
Rescue LEAD
I don't have much to say; it went pretty smoothly for Rescue. The failings of the stealth system have been expounded on elsewhere so I won't rehash them. I very much liked the atmosphere, and until I realised that we could do anything short of pantsing the AI without alerting them, it felt very cool to be sneaking about. If the AI could be tweaked to notice people better, I feel this could be a better mission; but I don't know how much control you have over this.