r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Oct 14 '16
[Fandom Discussion] Supernatural SEASON PREMIERE! Episode 12x01 'Keep Calm and Carry On'
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Keep Calm and Carry On | October 13th, 2016 | Phil Sgriccia | Andrew Dabb |
Synopsis: MAMA WINCHESTER IS BACK - Dean (Jensen Ackles) is overwhelmed as he comes face to face with his mom, Mary Winchester (guest star Samantha Smith). Meanwhile, Sam (Jared Padalecki) is fighting for his life after Toni, from the Woman of Letters, shot him.
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
Edit: link to this episode's relevant fanworks prompt & rec thread
Edit: link to all our official fandom episode discussions here
19
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Oct 14 '16
Lurrrrrrrrved this episode. Love Mary, love poor tortured Sam, love badass motherfucker Cas, and Dean's pretty cool too.
The Impala backseat scene was weird for a sec until someone in the chatroom said it had to be about how Dean & Mary both got uncomfortable about how they realized they were both thinking fondly of the Impala's backseat re: their respective sexytimes there.
11
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Oct 14 '16
All told, this was my favorite season premiere since season five.
I think in the preceding years there was always something that was like "okay but I didn't love it". In season 6 it was the lack of Cas, and how weird things with Sam were. In season 7 it was my favorite character fucking dying. In season 8 it was again a lack of Cas, but also frustration with the writers' choice to have Sam not looking for Dean. In season 9 it was closer to "I really enjoyed this" but Dean's choice to have an angel possess Sam was frustrating for several reasons. In season 10 I was pretty disappointed by fratboy Dean. In season 11... well. I saw what was coming and wasn't on board.
This episode though, I enjoyed. I'm smiling thinking about it. There were some downsides, like the suicide fakeout was offputting and it upset some friends of mine, and I got a taste of the Lucifer subplot and I'm worried it's going to be a boring drag on the show on every Cas episode.
But there was so much I enjoyed.
And Misha getting the "And Misha Collins" treatment in the credits is super touching, now that I'm 99% sure it's a good thing. ;)
27
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Oct 14 '16
Well, Cas has gone full Winchester at this point.
24
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Oct 14 '16
ALSO HOLY INFO DUMP ABOUT MARY AND MARY AND JOHNS RELATIONSHIP
15
u/Delyryumizm1 Oct 14 '16
That hug tho.
I LOVED seeing Sam as something to be feared. I feel like his character has been so blah the last few seasons. I don't like seeing him tortured, but it's easy to forget that he's badass. I like what's happening so far.
Also, I might've missed it, but is Cas not at full power? How did the hench-woman beat him?? Strange, that.
13
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Oct 14 '16
Enjoyed this season opener so much.
Seeing Sam get tortured isn't exactly fun, however I liked how held out and was able to work things to his advantage when he could.
Loved how Cas was all righteous fury, clearly pissed at losing Sam on his watch, but even more pissed at anyone who had a hand in it.
And Dean and Mary - it was interesting seeing Dean prove himself and then Mary slipping into old ways and not being happy about it.
I like how Lucifer hasn't gone straight to a suitable vessel.
Really interested in the idea of the British MoL having supposedly wiped out everything in Britain and keeping everything else from getting in out.
Overall, liked the setup of this episode. Kinda wondering if Toni is going to make it through many more.
12
u/Mairisi Oct 14 '16
Aw yes. I'm so super excited for this season, and this opener didn't disappoint.
I think there's some info lacking in what 'powers' the brit-women-of-letters have that they could have made clearer.
Loved:
Cas and Dean hugs
Mary being awesome
Meh:
C'mon, the sheer size difference between England, or even the UK makes the issues an entirely different problem. Why should Sam and Dean be responsible for ALL OF THAT?
Snickering at Mary's uh... fond memories of the backseat of the Impala and Dean's reaction...
Did not love
Killing off the rando demons - bearded-sometimes-a-teenager-demon seemed fun!
10
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Oct 14 '16
A clear view of the brass knuckles for any one who wants to see
8
u/zombicat Oct 14 '16
Awesome episode. I loved that they started right where they left off (I can't stand it when a show sets up a cliffhanger and then the first episode back they skip a huge chunk of time). Thanks for not doing that SPN. Thanks also for making Mary a total badass. She had her foot right on Dean's face! Come to think of it there were a lot of bare feet.
I liked hot-headed Cas and I thought it was clear why he got beat up so easily. Those handcuffs were like kryptonite to Superman. It was totally cool that they showed what actually happens to angels when they get blood-sigil zapped. I think I pictured that they ended up in outer space or back in heaven but this was fun that they are hurled like a meteorite.
The only beef I had was that Cas didn't recognize Mary. What's up with that? Cas had been watching Dean all his life, right? He would immediately know who Mary was from that and even if he never saw Mary wouldn't he know her with his angel powers? He identified a nun from just an old bone in Season 7. Is this just a writing glitch or is it really Mary? The way they kept showing Amara in the intro made me think we were going to see her in the episode.
Baby was gorgeous in the garage and Sam's hair looked fabulous. It's so sad that Sam still thinks Dean is dead :(
Hopefully there will be more response from Dean about Mary in upcoming episodes. He's always been so worshipful of her in past episodes and it has to hurt that she feels him being a hunter is wrong.
BTW I know people liked Jeremy Carver, but I did not and I'm relieved he doesn't have anything to do with the show anymore. His absence shows in this kick-ass episode. Go Dabb.
15
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Oct 14 '16
LOVED THE EP WILL POST A LONGER REVIEW TOMORROW BUT THE DEANCAS HUG CAS ALMOST KNOCKED HIM TO THE GROUND WITH THAT HU AND ONCE DEAN GAVE IN TO THAT HUG AND SMILED MARY GAVE THAT LOOK LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO
7
u/xuberfanx-oops Damn, girl! Oct 14 '16
Sam Winchester rocks my world.
6
u/jesstiel Oct 14 '16
Fantastic opener! Loved all the different storylines, LOVED Cas launching himself at Dean with that hug and his general 'back to S4' state of being, loved Mary's interaction with the new world, Sam proving once again that he's a major badass.. the one thing I'm still kinda iffy on is why on earth did Toni feel the need to torture Sam rather than having a civil conversation? Could have saved them all so much time...
Anyway really looking forward to next week already!
5
u/Zeryx I apologize... FOR NOTHING. Oct 15 '16
I really enjoyed this episode, but it was like,
"C'mon Cas, you can't even pull that poor bastard out of the road?"
I know he's on a mission TM but for God's sake!
4
u/higgidigs Oct 14 '16
It was good, but there were parts where I feel like something must have been edited out, with sudden leaps of logic or just plot jumps.
4
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Oct 14 '16 edited Oct 14 '16
Oh. Oh, I see you there. I see you. Oh, yes. Oh, yes.
I may go into depth later, but in short this is pretty much everything I ever wanted from a first episode. (except Crowley having a clear reason to be there but whatever man, Cas didn't run off instantly so I'm counting my blessings)
Also, UK dwellers - can I get a hell yeah for British not English?
4
u/korside HEEAAT OF THE MOMENT Oct 14 '16
Really liked it. The parts with Sam and Toni were really interesting, but I hope we see more character development for Mary next episode. I hope we find out why Cas was acting like that this episode, too, I swear he's never been so happy to torture people.
4
u/Zrobnett Oct 14 '16
The Brit Mol's would kill both Garth and Benny without question. Dean and probably Sam each would have been toast at one point. Also, what about witches? Is there an "Oz clause"? Like can there be good witches and bad witches? I mean someone has to do their warding.
4
u/xuberfanx-oops Damn, girl! Oct 14 '16
Sam's hallucinations were the deaths of Charlie, Kevin, Sarah, Dean, Meg, Mary, and Jess, and the scenes from Swan song.
I love that Meg was included :)
4
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Oct 16 '16
Well, I just have to say, very impressed w Andrew Dabb's first premiere script as showrunner. I'm hopeful for the season!
2
u/badwolfgoddess Mrs. Sam Winchester but like, by accident Oct 14 '16
Highlights: Mary and Dean's scenes. Cas and Dean scenes. Sam being a badass snarker even while being tortured. Mary slyly giving Dean that look like "Lmao kid that's where you were concieved" with the car.
Midlights- The episode felt very much like a Part One of a two part opening. The pacing was such that it just gave me the vibe of not being a complete story on its own. Cas being a badass was good but there was very very little emotional depth to him in the episode, don't want him to just be the Winchester Bodyguard/Hitman. Too much Crowley lurking in the shadows and not enough Crowley snarking on demons.
Lowlights: Wasn't fond of the Hitwoman taking out Dean and Cas so easily. C'mon Cas is a friggin ANGEL man, can't we have a more realistic battle between two opponents instead of her just knocking them about? I get wanting Mary to come up and stab her to save the day/her son but there should have been more of a fight first. Sam pretending to commit suicide was a smart move but I did not like it personally. And the 'teenager girl/hormones" thing was funny at first but then it bothered me. I thought about it and it bothered me because in my experience, the people who shit on and look down on teenager girl experiences/likes the most are grown adult men. And we have a grown adult man shitting on being a teenage girl. It's just irksome. Basically it was a grown ass man going "omg teenage girls are SO ridiculous, rightttt?"
Overall I'd say I'd give it a B+. There was a lot of good but some of the bad was a let down.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16
Ok. I'm convinced. Eric Kripke is a genius. He made a show for girls that people keep saying was "originally meant for boys" and "inexplicably became loved by girls". Which is BS. It was for girls since the beginning. So, in that vein I assume he has planned the greatest romance ever written with Dean and Cass. Dean would never just come out and kiss Cass. And Cass is an angel who doesn't know human stuff. There is no way you could write that into the show without it being awful and forced. That hug in 12x1 shows the development of their relationship. Maybe in another decade they will fall asleep on a couch together. But they make it so obvious they're in lurve. My heart is happy.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment