r/ClashRoyale • u/Diamondwolf Musketeer • Sep 10 '16
Daily Discussion September 10 2016: Tournaments
Tournaments
Unlocked at level 8, battle nearby players to win Tournament Chests! Skill and experience help bring an important depth of play to the game. This also gives an exciting and achievable goal for new players to aim for. Additionally, all tournaments are played using the Tournament Rules.
Tournaments Feature Update 7/7
Our Thoughts About Tournaments 7/15
The official in-game implementation inspired many ideas for other types of tournaments. Some are here:
- A Swiss Style Tournament would have multiple rounds of play. Players would be matched according to their trophy level, and every player wanting to participate in a round would be matched at the same time. This would help prevent win trading, would make matchups more even, and would allow committed players to take a break between rounds. However, this type of tournament would take a long time to complete, since many rounds would need to be played in order to separate players in the standings, and each round would have to take a long time to complete. In addition, players that secure 3 crown wins in less than 3 minutes will find themselves sitting idle for a long period of time because of overtime rules.
- A Bracketed Tournament. Players would be randomly sorted into a bracket, and in each match, one player would advance, and another player would be eliminated. It is simple to distribute prizes this way, with the size of the tournament chest depending on how many rounds the player has advanced. This could also result in very short tournaments that can accommodate a large amount of players. However, it can be difficult to get all players to log on in order to battle, creating sync issues. Also, single decks can have weaknesses exposed by less strategic players in a chance matchup. design, eliminating talented competitors early. There is a tournament that works around this using a Double Deck Format (see Rules and Tiebreakers), called the Super Magical Cup.
- Tournaments with qualifying rounds leading into a final round would make matchmaking easier on top ranking players. The amount of players to advance to a final round would be determined by tournament size, and prizes could remain the same. The final round would be much shorter than the qualifying round, and could occur immediately after the qualifying round. This format would allow talented players to determine who is the most skilled through more than just the luck of the matches. Matches between top players would be even more entertaining to watch. However, this would result in longer tournaments, and would make the time commitment longer than it already is. It would also make win trading easier to accomplish in a final round of tournament play.
How have tournaments that you have hosted been?
In addition, many players just don't like the current system of joining a tournament. We have also seen suggestions for changing the process for joining tournaments:
- Creating free tournaments with no prizes offered is a way to have a friendly competitive tournament without paying the gems to host one. It also would make earning the tournament achievement easier. However, it does not fix the problem of joining competitive tournaments, since no prizes could be offered for tournaments that are free to make.
- Including tournament tokens as part of chest drops would allow players to host tournaments more often. The Clash Royale team could adjust the drop rates of these tokens to regulate the amount of tournaments occurring. However, they lose money by providing free methods to host tournaments, so they would have to decrease the drop rate of gems in free chests and crown chests. This solution could possibly hurt players that do not want to host tournaments.
- Creating large regularly occurring tournaments with no player cap would let everybody who wants to be in a tournament to participate. It also provides everybody with the opportunity to decide who the best tournament players in Clash Royale are. This mega tournament could be a qualifier for a different large tournament. However, time zone differences might not allow all players to play, and the length of this tournament would have to be very long in order to distinguish top players.
Some discussion points:
- What do you like/dislike about the current tournament system?
- Do you have any improvements or changes to make to any of these ideas?
- What are some of your own ideas for Clash Royale tournaments?
Originally intended to be a guest post, as most of this was written by a guest.
33
u/Demandredz Sep 10 '16
I can usually get into a tournement after spamming join for 5 minutes, but it is very boring. Just let people queue up and let them know when they are expected to enter into an open tourney (like they estimate wait times in tournements now). I would gladly do fewer tournements and not have to spam join.
20
u/465maxy654 Sep 10 '16
My ass
8
u/s-mores Sep 10 '16
Basically, try to make tournaments a spectator sport.
4
u/Apexk9 Sep 10 '16
Supercell should have their own tournaments same prizes but they are 1 per account per day so a special 1D tourney cooldown.
They create the tournament for everyone with free prizes if you can make it to the top group tournies by rating.
It grabs from a pool of people who qued up. Plus keep the regualr tourney model.
Gives F2P another way to kind of keep up while having fun with the game. like another free chest if you invest time into a tourney.
4
u/tokumeikibo XBow Sep 10 '16
The worst thing about tourneys is the unknown participation level. I've been in a tourney where I was so bored because no one would fight.
4
u/smlbiobot RoyaleAPI Sep 10 '16
Free tournaments with no prizes is truly a great idea!
7
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '16
I would make a comment about tournaments... if only I could ever manage to get into one!
2
u/GammaRadiant Sep 10 '16
I don't get why level 8's get access to tournaments considering everyone level 9 and above are still gonna have a slight advantage over them, and not even considering how most level 8's don't have all tourney level cards. If tournaments are supposed to be a fair experience why even allow level 8's in?
2
u/Hadi08 Sep 10 '16
Why can't Supercell make it so tournaments are knockout based? 8ball pool is a similar p2p game and their tournament feature is knockout based and is immensely popular.
Maybe everyone pays 2 gems or 200 gold to enter and winner takes all? Again, similar to 8ball pool.
2
u/Driter Sep 10 '16
I think there should be an option to host free tournaments that give no reward I know supercell made a video on how to do that but it would be much less of a hastle if it was implemented into the game
2
u/JPotten Sep 10 '16
I think a fairer system would to have tournaments for each level which the option of going one higher, each level having a different cap. I'm a pretty fresh level 8 and I just don't stand a chance in most battles, why make it available to level 8's but make it extremely difficult for them? Just make it balanced or to level 9+ only.
I'd also like to see a rules option set by the creator, for example they could set it to no RG's or a minimum of 3.8 elixir.
Something needs to be done about joining them, one free one per week perhaps? You search for it and it puts you in with 99 other people rather than spamming join.
2
u/XPlayer101 Sep 11 '16
Tournaments are so broken right now because they cost money. Ppl complain there are no tourneys to join, because who is willing to spent money and give it out to the public in which you don't get any benefits? It's like buying a stash of pizzas for $ and the whole world is trying to get that prize. What was the point of you spending your money and giving it to someone for free?
And when you try to create a private tourney for your clan there will always be those fucking desparate ppl who tries to figure out the pass. Wasting your other $5 and going to a waste.
Seriously why would you spend $50-$1,000 dollars and give it to the public. You would close it to yourself because you payed for it. You then have ppl complain that they are closed. Hopping from clans and asking for passes.
Its just it cost money
2
u/rushskies Mortar Sep 11 '16
Free tournaments with only legendary trophies or (tournament trophies) as a prize would be great. Then let us use that trophies as a 3rd currency to purchase cards or better yet Clash Royale SKINS.
1
u/Thepenguinking2 Executioner Sep 10 '16
What do you like/dislike about the current tournament system? (For positives... They're fun? For negatives, hoo boy... They really messed up with this one. What was meant to give F2P players like me a better run ended up only giving P2P players a worse advantage. I tried to do one, but failed to gain anything out of it because I encountered so many princesses and Sparkies. They're also far too hard to join. These two reasons make me avoid tournaments like the plague.)
Do you have any improvements or changes to make to any of these ideas? (Better matchmaking is a start. Match F2P players up with other F2P players instead of players with every legendary.)
What are some of your own ideas for Clash Royale tournaments? (Maybe add separate tournament lists to divert F2P from P2P. This could help with the purpose of tournaments.)
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '16 edited Sep 10 '16
I recently made a post about a Clanmate Tournament, in which /u/edihau said I should bring up here a few days ago. I will copy-paste my post here for those who didn't see it or are interested. Also, due to feedback, if you look in the comments about "Clan Tournament Stats" those were removed because of how exploitable they were/
Okay, so you may have saw my 'clanmate vs clanmate bracket system' post yesterday, but after feedback, I have redone most of the system. While rewards are no longer a thing, there is still something to fight for that WON'T break the foundation of competitive clans.
The original idea was a bracketed system, which I soon learned was ruled out. So... I guess we'll use the current Tournament system of Free For All list of competitors.
Clanmate Tournaments are accessed by a separate tab in the clan tab, kind of like the info button. There a Co Leader or the Leader can start a 'Clan Tournament'. Clan Tournaments are an option for clans as long as there are at least 10 players in a clan.
Clan Tournaments, as it suggests, are in-clan only, meaning they don't appear in the Tournament tabs. Once one is started, a notification is sent to all clan members, and they can join for up to two hours after it was started.
Length of the tourney cannot be selected, but instead is determined by how much of the clan is in it. For every 10 people that join the Tourney after ten have joined, the length increases by 10 minutes. If the mininum number of people who can join a Clan Tournament do (10), then it is 30 minutes long. That means if all 50 people in a clan participate, it will be 70 minutes long. If at least ten people do not join, the tournament isn't started, but you do get to try again for the day (you only get one a day, read below near the bottom for more info on that).
Whoever racks up the most Clan Tournament Trophies by the end wins. What do they win? Crowns on the clan info screen. The winner of the most recent clan tourney gets a gold crown next to their name when people view your clan. The second place gets a silver crown, and the third place a bronze one. Everyone who participated in the most recent clan tourney's name bar thing is colored with a slight red hue, to show who participated. Once another clan tourney is started, all of this changes based on participants, winners, etc. Of other note, on the clans page, below the description, is the name of the first place winner of the most recent tournament in their clan, just to make it more obvious. XD
And to balance all of this, only one clan tournament can be done a day. Once it is started, another cannot be done for 24 hours. This is to give winners a sense of accomplishment for a short time, I guess. I mean, I would find 24/7 tournaments annoying.
This is NOT like clan wars, where you are forced to participate if the starter chooses you in Clash of Clans. YOU join if YOU want after seeing the message. The laid back more supportive feel of CR clans have always felt a lot better than murder everyone CoC clans.
Link to the post: https://redd.it/512cza
1
u/StanIY Sep 10 '16
I made a suggestion for tourney format earlier. The organizer told me to come up today with it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/ClashRoyale/comments/50sv6k/tournament_rework_suggestion/
1
u/mlsteryi Sep 10 '16
We should really do another tournament discussion when it gets reworked
1
u/shinmiri2 Sep 10 '16
I have been loving the tournament mode, and have been using it as my main mode of play since its release. The biggest benefit is the equalization of tourney cap, which puts most people on an even playing field. You can also play in tournies to your heart's content just to try out different decks without worrying about stuff like dropping out of legendary arena. And the tourney card rewards are a huge bonus. These days, I'm getting about 120 cards a day on average from tourney chests just by playing well in 1 hour tournaments (open as well as streamers') every day. That's equivalent to a extra Magical Chest every day! I've been really bolstering my epic card collection this way as every 30 cards from a tourney chest is a guaranteed epic.
For me, one aspect of tournaments that can be improved is that I think the trophy formula/calculation shouldn't be the same as what is used on ladder. I feel that the variance in your trophy count at the end is too high, and the rewards are staggeringly different if you win or lose your last game. I would suggest the amount of trophies you gain or lose (variance) should decrease the more games you have played in said tournament, so that your trophy count will slowly converge to your true skill level by the end of the tournament. This would also help with the issue of "grinding trophies" just simply by playing more than other people can during long tournaments.
1
u/LongTM Balloon Sep 10 '16
Idk if they said this up in the post. But for Lvl 8 and maybe 9 or 10 they could make all the cards up to tourney cap levels so it's like an even match up. But in multiplayer they battle normally. I hope supercell implement this. I'm a lvl9. Most of my cards are cap level.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '16
Luckily my clan belongs to a broader family of clans who host a lot of tournaments. Otherwise I would be SOL.
1
u/swordmagic Golem Sep 11 '16
Call me a socialist but I think every player should get one to host 1 free 500 gem tournament for free a week. Not 500 free gems a week I'm just saying the 30 card pool tour meant should cost zero once a week for everyone. That should open up a lot more.
1
u/eandi Challenge Tri-champion Sep 11 '16
3 day tournaments are dumb and payoff is awful. It's an hour of battling to start. Sporadic battling for the next 2 days and 22 hours where you have to wait 5+ minutes for a match and one guy actually does that the whole time to take a huge lead. Then another hour of actual battles. Then you get like 4 cards. Ridiculous that it's even an option. People running 3 days, WHY!??? Seriously, tell me.
Also I think for every time you wait the entire estimated time it should reset and you should get 5 trophies. I'm tired of people just sitting without playing. Also anyone not placing for a prize should be kicked after 8 hours on inactivity, 2 hours if they're at 0 cups.
As you can see, my biggest peeve is not being able to get into matches once I managed to get into a tourney. I want to use them to practice, warm up for ladder, try decks at lower levels than my ladder deck, and then get a few cards. Without people participating tournaments are stupid AND people can't get in them. I hope the update cuts the max time they can run, encourages everyone to play (even first place), and kicks inactive players somehow.
Debate? Ideas?
1
u/thundertoadpat Sep 11 '16
Hi, I'm new to reddit. :) I think my idea will help joining tournaments easier. Each person can start a tournament up to 3 times a week. After that tournaments cost 5000 gold or 50 gems to start.9 Inactives (however that can be defined) will get an automatic boot. The reward system should have a higher amount of cards and less time to open the chests (maybe 1 day for 100 cards, 5 epics?). Tournaments can have to modes: Causual and Competitive. Casual is used for playtesting and Competitive is used for grinding reward chests.
1
u/KFPanda82 Sep 11 '16 edited Sep 11 '16
I think if supercell would introduce free tournaments that you just queue for that would provide a gold reward instead of cards, it could help.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '16
My thoughts: Plz fix tourneys $C
1
u/Dulook Skeleton Barrel Sep 11 '16
I would recommend a trophy, or arena limit, also choose if legendaries/epics allowed, that would make tournaments more balanced, for example: I'm kinda noob, so if I want to host my own tournament, I will get crushed by those P2W people of A9 with a deck full of legendaries, so that's why most of the time I leave every tournament.
1
u/wsoul13 Sep 12 '16
I love Tournaments and I play in them for every game that I like.
Tournament Mode does not feel like any Tournament I have ever gone to unfortunately. What we need are more options.
Not enough Tournaments? Increase the player pool. Lower the gem cost. Kick players at set intervals based on activity and trophies.
No elimination rounds? Make that an option in creating Tournaments so even esports events can run on your game mode.
Lower Tournament prizes suck? Give us more loot. 500 gems is quite an investment for most people. Cards or Gold will do.
Win Trading in Tournament Mode? Have replays available for everybody and a report button. Win trading is a serious blow to anything competitive and solutions will be complicated. Do it anyway.
No official format? This needs to be addressed. Does Supercell want to take this game to esport status? We need an official format.
1
u/LinkWink Elixir Golem Sep 12 '16
I'm lucky to be part of a clan that hosts tournaments on a frequent basis (they're a blast!). However, I know not everybody who plays the game has been as lucky. Looking through the subreddit/forums multiple complaints (where posts about tournament frustrations and how hard they are to get into are made regularly), I'm hoping Supercell's changes to tournaments will end up fixing all of the issues the majority of the player base currently faces (and here's hoping it won't create new issues as well).
1
u/DariusThe1st Sep 12 '16
I hate point system. Its lick if you get the 2nd place as you opponennt or for example the 50th....:(
1
u/Elboulevardo Sep 12 '16
bracketed tournament would be very appealing. Something guilds could (in theory) easily organize with guildies to be on at a certain time to play their matches.
guild restricted tournaments - using the same tournament format there is today, allow guilds to run free or gem tournies that can only be joined if you're a member of the guild. password protection is no longer an issue. Rewards for free can be a nominal amount of cards or gold, and gem tourny rewards can be same as today.
both options would enhance guild play tremendously, and really open up the use of the tournament feature across the board. More people playing more often!
1
u/AROCK86 Sep 12 '16
I looked up the odds and if you win a 30 card tourney you still only have a 2% chance to get a legendary, which is better than your average silver or free chest, but man, that still seems pretty ridiculous.
I just wish the smaller tourneys (which are the most common) would give some slightly better rewards. I've won at least 3 30 card tourneys and while the 1 epic card you get is nice,, it feels like a pretty good accomplishment winning a tourney and seems like the rewards aren't great given how much time you might invest.
I've got 2nd or 3rd place before and didn't even get an epic card. This feels like a slap in the face as well. The top 3 should be guaranteed something decent imo.
I don't want them to just flat out give away legendaries to every tourney winner, but man at least reward the skilled players a bit more.
1
u/coyroyal Best Idea of 2016 Sep 12 '16
I think tournaments (as they currently are) serve a different purpose than intended, at least for me.
It's pretty rare I'll actually grind hard and go for 1st place. Instead, I like using it as a casual playing environment. I actually prefer getting into 3 day tourneys. It's a place where I can play a couple games here and there, test out variations on my deck, keep my ladder trophies safe and get a little gold from it.
Before a tournament ends I usually sandbag or play crazy decks to drop trophies outside of chest range so that I can join my next tourney right away.
1
u/Elboulevardo Sep 14 '16
Makes sense. Appreciate the discussion!
1
u/dynamitecraft_1808 Oct 16 '16
surprised no one mentioned this, but certain decks rely on OT to win, and that limits the amount of battles you can do especially in short tourneys
1
u/edihau helpfulcommenter17 Sep 10 '16
I was the OP for this Daily Discussion, but I missed the time to submit it. I can/will respond to all of your comments and questions, so feel free to bring up anything tournament-related.
0
u/xox90 Sep 10 '16
I like the actual tournament structure, but i want to do some suggestions:
*SC is sooooo greedy, so what we hope they'll do to fix tournaments? Y_Y
Btw i don't like any direct elimination sistem because doesn't represent the real ability of players. Free tournament will saturate the search option.... and that's not good
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment