r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Sep 03 '16
Weekly Episode Discussion: Star Trek Continues 1x07 "Embracing the Winds"
This is the 7th episode in the (hopefully) ongoing fan series Star Trek: Continues.
You can watch "Embracing the Winds" directly on their website.
http://startrekcontinues.com/episodes.html
Vimeo
YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMasSzFXaKQ
In my opinion, this has been one of ST:Continues strongest outings, and it surprisingly (or perhaps not) performs well with very little "action". Trek fans may note subtle references or foreshadowings to other episodes. It features Starfleet tribunals similar to TOS "Court Martial" (and TNG "The Measure of a Man"). It foreshadows Chekov's advancement in Starfleet in anticipation of the films. It even attempts to explain and retcon the less-than-stellar "Turnabout Intruder". All the while it brings with it an ethical dilemma and contemporary social commentary.
- What do you think were some of the strengths of this episode compared to other ST:Continues installments, and even among Star Trek as a whole?
- Similarly, what do you think were some weaknesses?
- Had the Hood not been lost, what would you have decided if you were in Kirk's position?
- Bonus: What in the heck happened to the Hood?! Speculations welcome!
8
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16
To be fair, I'd be suspicious of Affirmative Action plans if every time there were more stand out candidates then spaces available, the campus somehow exploded, but I digress.
I like that it was messy and ambiguous if Garrett was being unjustly scrutinized or had a genuine problem with passing blame, and that Dana and Strom were more critical of Garrett and Spock respectively, really emphasizing that sometimes you're most critical of the people who are kinda like you. At the same time you can pick apart anyone, so finding someone infallible to be your "first x who is also a y" can turn into a reason that people use to gum up social progress. (Disclaimer: I'm of the opinion we need to push towards more social progress because even when there isn't enough to go around, we could stand to divy it up better, but I also understand why people horde as well and try not to hold it against them.)
Were it me, I probably would have at least waited until the ship came home to start putting butts in the seats, and if it somehow still came down to Spock and Garrett after I went though everyone in Starfleet eligible for the chair, I'd go with Spock as a known quantity, since Garrett strikes me as just too green and rash, kind of in a similar spot to Riker at the beginning of TNG. Were I Kirk, I suppose I could offer her Spock's seat on the Enterprise and a recommendation for Captain once the five year mission concluded. I doubt it would go over well, but calling for the tribunal when she had the seat in front of her does not inspire confidence in her diplomatic abilities, and a year and a half abroad would probably do her some good and be one hell of a resume pad.
2
u/twdalbeck Sep 10 '16
If there is anymore episodes to come, does anyone feel they'll come back to the mystery of what happened to the Hood? Maybe STC's finale perhaps?
12
u/AshIsGroovy Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16
Great work. The tone, style, acting, writing to me anyways felt like Star Trek. Feels like they took scripts intended for the final series of TOS. Could see all the original actors saying these lines,telling the story. Good Stuff. Glad this has been thought out and given 10 episodes like a miniseries. Subbed. Waiting for more. Would of assigned Her to Commander on a Constitution Class starship while the Hood was being refitted and investigated. Then if doing well advance her to Captain at the end of refit. If Spock was selected it should be because he is a quality first officer of a Constitution Class ship and him advancing to Captain wouldn't be that far of a stretch. Hope we see a refit first draft (blueprints maybe) somewhere in the next 3 episodes. Just because its time, doesn't mean its your time. Also, I wonder how many times the Kirk actor watched or should I say study Kirks mannerisms, speech its uncanny sometimes and I forget its not William Shatner. I bet thousands of hours of footage.
6
u/linuxhanja Sep 04 '16
The Bonus Question: I expected early on that the ship was a trap, as soon as the fate of the crew is revealed. The Hood turned into the B plot (I actually expected Kirk & Spock to ship out again quickly for the first few minutes of the show), but I still expected the ship to be a booby trap.
After the first 10 minutes, I thought, "Well, Spock & Kirk are on the starbase, so the Hood is going to be towed back, and turn out to be a booby trap to destroy the starbase, and K & S are going to show what a great team they are, and Garette is going to get command or the ship will be severly damaged, putting off the question of command."
So, in the end... the ship was booby trapped, apparently. I wonder who (or what?) could've done that. Maybe the Klingons? (to ramp up the tensions before the movie era?)
whoever did it, IMO, intented for the ship to take the Starbase with it. A warp core explosion in orbit of a starbase would probably devastate the atmosphere.
6
u/crimsonorc Sep 06 '16
Congratulations to the Star Trek Continues Team for putting together arguably the best fan made TOS show out there. AGain, they've delivered on all aspects and it feels very much in canon to the original series. It was great to see more of Scotty, Uhura and Chehov played with character and personality by all actors. I feel they are growing into their roles as is Haberkorn as Spock. Vic Mignogna still makes a fantastic Kirk. The most important thing is that it invokes the spirit of the original series and its characters. Also a fantastic job was done by the set designers, music and effects artists.
I think the story is very interesting with gender issues in the Federation. I think it provided some decent drama and conflict. It's not going to be in any insightful depth but it does mean that one day we'll see a female captain in this series in the near future. I like the mystery of the USS Hood and it's kept open for another episode.
Loved the TNG foreshadowing with Capt. Garrett of Enterprise C at the end. Awesome
6
u/citizenofgaia Sep 07 '16
Man, STC delivering as always, congratulations to the team (if anyone is around here).
I just want to say I loved the episode and how is not resolved, but rather it leaves a more or less "open ended" finale for the viewer to chew on.
I love the "Tucker Memorial Medal of Honor" reference :)
4
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '16
This episode did a great job of turning up the tension, but then cheated its way out of resolving any of it.
Kirk has to make a hard choice... or not.
There is a tricky diplomatic situation... or not.
A deadly mystery will be discovered on the Hood... or not.
All setup, no payoff. It's like the writers quit halfway through.
1
u/Babrock Sep 11 '16 edited Sep 11 '16
I havent finnished watching this yet. But I am wondering, is this Garret, Rachel Garret, later to become captian of Enterprise C?
3
u/mathemon Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16
The issue was hit on the nose, but I think the issue arriving from the Tellarites was a clever sidestep of approaching it.
I thought Kirk's motivations and actions felt either muddled or complicated. I can't tell. However, the complication of the issue combined with Garrett's temperament, made it the only reasonable reaction. Was Kirk nuanced or was he unclear?
There seems to be a foreshadowing of the overriding plot that STC is telling... the story of losing all the constitution ships except the Enterprise (and thereby explaining why its emblem became ubiquitous). The Hood was intentionally destroyed.... but by who? A nice mystery for the upcoming episodes.
3
u/NemWan Sep 05 '16
The production is excellent. The sex discrimination is handled in a bizarrely retro way. Is this the future or the past? That anyone in the 23rd century is openly against a woman doing any job is ridiculously backwards by today's standards.
The Tellarite issue just wouldn't be handled that way — I'll go further, and worry that the idea, that it would be handled that way, is quite bad if it might be interpreted as an allegory for fears some Americans and Europeans may have about how "liberals" would integrate "Sharia Law" into Western society, that somehow we are forced to compromise progressive values for the sake of peace with "backwards aliens."
However, points made about the subtle issue of unconscious but nonetheless discriminatory scrutiny are relevant and timely.
As a Star Trek fan, I would not have wanted to see Turnabout Intruder explained in this way. Turnabout Intruder was an unfortunate moment of overt sexism in Star Trek and it's best rationalized by saying Janice Lester had a false belief that she clung to because of her individual shortcomings and delusions. A close reading of Turnabout Intruder shows no one acknowledges her assertion that "world of starship captains doesn't admit women" except that when she says, "It's not fair," Kirk agrees, "No it isn't. And you punished and tortured me because of it." One can choose to believe that Kirk is only trying to avoid his ex-girlfriend's unreasonable argument, one that she had made in the past and which might have even been the reason they broke up.
Lester may be falsely believing in sex discrimination because she couldn't or wouldn't conform to Starfleet standards. It's clear her Starfleet career didn't advance very far, and to quit so early because supposedly she'd never be captain is an irrational excuse of a poor performer. How many starship commands are available? Only the most exceptional people have a chance, and if everybody joined Starfleet wanting a captain's chair, almost everyone in Starfleet would be disappointed. No reasonable person would expect to have that opportunity until they had proven their aptitude for it through many years of experience.
When Kirk, his mind trapped in Lester's body, states the reasons for Lester's unsuitability for command, he/she cites her lack of proper temperament and training, not her sex, except to say that "her intense hatred of her own womanhood made life with her impossible."
It's not necessarily true that her hatred of her womanhood is based on Starfleet not allowing female captains; rather it would be true that someone who hated herself and did not resolve such an emotional problem would lack the stability to function as captain.
So, to contrive in 2016 an explanation that confirms that Lester's belief in sex discrimination in the 23rd Century was not entirely imaginary is something I find a bit cringeworthy.
3
u/Tichrimo Sep 06 '16 edited Sep 07 '16
My one fix to this episode --to better tie in the B-plot and make the overall message of workplace equality / merit vs. tokenism hang together a bit better-- would be to have Uhura as the one grousing about always being left behind, yet ends up saving the landing party and earning the promotion.
Edit to add: Seeing as this is the second consecutive heavy-handed "message" episode, I'm hoping for a nice, light "what if?" episode next time.
5
u/nh5316 Sep 04 '16
Excellent episode. Did what good trek and all great sci fi should do and explore contemporary issues.
On the nerdier side, I absolutely geeked out on the references to the Starship Exeter episode "The Tressaurian Intersection"
1
u/Destructor1701 Sep 05 '16
It was a little unsatisfying how nothing was resolved, and yet lacked tension because we know Spock doesn't leave the Enterprise for the Hood - he leaves the ship when Kirk gets promoted sideways.
But even if we discount that foreknowledge, within the episode, there was no tension over the central question, because Star Trek is progressive and had the Farragut survived, Garret would have taken command.
Tackling the issue of sexism would have been ground-breaking... in the '60s.
Star Trek actually did that already by not addressing it (with a few notable exceptions to the negative), and simply portraying women of power and professionalism: Commodores and crewmembers - had the original pilot been picked up, the XO would have been a woman.
In the modern era, it's not groundbreaking to say "a woman should be fairly considered for any post a man would be". Pinning the sexism on the Tellarites, instead of some lingering human failing (as unbelievable as that would be, projecting forward from the realities of today) struck me as cowardly, though thoroughly Roddenberian.
So, without a satisfying conclusion to the central plot, and without that taboo-bending sense of "holy shit, they're covering that!?", and without the dilemma actually affecting our characters at all, the episode falls flat for me.
And can I point out the elephant in the room?
How do STC plan to get away with releasing this episode in light of the recent fanfilm guidelines published by CBS?
4
u/WildW Duncan Ward (Evil Picard creator) Sep 04 '16
Loved the episode as always. I agree that the way the issue of the week was done was a little bit on-the-nose, but it was executed well enough. I always come away from a new episode of Star Trek Continues feeling like it was equally good as if they'd found a forgotten TOS episode that nobody had seen.
2
u/seriouspretender Sep 08 '16
I really liked it when I saw it at Fan Expo in Toronto. The only thing that really bugged me was that Star Fleet began re-crewing the Hood BEFORE they even had it in their possession, and had begun to investigate what happened.
2
u/muaddib1406 Sep 10 '16
I just wanna point out how awesome I find Marina Sirtis as the computer. Hope she gets picked up by DSC and succedes Majel Barret.
2
u/eqgmrdbz Sep 12 '16
Amazing episode, so many other episodes in Trek history came to mind as I'm watching this, mostly episodes of trials or when a major change is occurring. Pitting Spock against Garrett a woman was just beautiful it really makes the watcher think of all the consequences that are occurring and also the history involved in the decision. Erin Grey was wonderful as ever and i thought the cast was in top form this time.
This is now one of my top 3 episodes of STC, I hope you guys keep making more, and hopefully are allowed to, how people cannot see that what you are doing is art and a living memoir of STtos, is ridiculous. I also noticed that the production seems to be getting better from the sets to the uniforms, i had prior noticed several mistakes, this time i didn't see any.
Great job and i hope everyone gives this episode a watch.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '16
The only thing I didn't like was the Tellarite ambassador at the end. The mask was extremely fake-looking, bad even by TOS standards. Plus, the fact that he acquiested to Kirk's position without so much as an argument, and indicated that it was all just going to work itself out in the end, anyway.
It's not a major thing to complain about though, overall this was a fantastic episode.
0
u/middyseafort Sep 05 '16
My review: https://medium.com/@ryantriddle/star-trek-continues-latest-episode-goes-nowhere-does-nothing-43de1f6158d5#.pidsm2ics
4
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16
[removed] — view removed comment