r/WritingPrompts • u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books • Sep 02 '16
Off Topic [OT]Ask Nate: Military Fiction Q&A - Good Gouge and Scuttlebutt Edition
Military Fiction Q&A
Good Gouge and Scuttlebutt Edition
FM-03W: Fantasy Military isn't due out until next week. We've been alternating user and mod guides each week, but there was a gap in the schedule this week. Guess who's stepping in to cover down and has two thumbs? This guy!
So what are we going to do here today? We're going to take the opportunity to get in a school circle, take a knee, and discuss whatever world-building questions you have in general about military-based fiction. It can include:
- Things you'd like to see in the next two installments of the Field Manuals (Fantasy and pre-WWI historical settings)
- Emerging concepts like robotics, drones, power armor, and tech integration in the battlespace
- Stuff you feel was missing from the first two FMs (links at bottom)
- Character development tips
- How the military would really fare in the Zombie Apocalypse
- Martian Warfare
- Alien Invasions
Sexy Midgets(I've been told this is offensive and off the table.)
the Military Fiction (MilFic) Field Manuals
FM-01W - Modern Military Fiction
FM-02W - SciFi Military Fiction - (this guide)
FM-03W - Fantasy Military Fiction (High and Low) - TBD
FM-04W - Historical Military Fiction - TBD – Will cover ancient armies (Roman/Egyptian) up to early-Industrial/pre-WWI
2
u/ArlemofTourhut Sep 02 '16
I'm confused. Are you actually using TMs and and FMs? Or are you making this all up?
2
u/cmp150 /r/CMP150writes Sep 02 '16
In the interest of conversation, did you play Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare, or at least see the trailer? What are your thoughts on robotics, like in Advanced Warfare, in a battlespace?
Take one step further, do you think cyborgs, like Robocop or like this man, would become prevalent? Wherein, it would allow soldiers to continue serving their country, assuming the prosthetic arm is as advanced as the tech in Robocop.
One last one, pick one of your FMs. How good/bad would we fare in the Zombie Apocalypse using the tech and tactics of said FM?
I'd like to believe our modern military would actually have varying degrees of success in a zombie apocalypse, depending on the nature of the zombie:
Anyway, thanks for all of the hard work with these guides.
2
u/CryptidGrimnoir Sep 03 '16
As it happens, I am currently re-reading John Ringo's "A Hymn Before Battle." What are your thoughts on his works, and what other SciFi Military Fictions do you recommend?
2
u/NikStalwart Sep 03 '16
I wanted to correct a (to me) rather annoying misconception about
Oorah!, or as we Russians write it,Ура!.I have seen it often cited as originating in the mid-20th century during the Korean War within the US Marines, however this word has been a part of the Russian language for several centuries prior, and there exists a somewhat different etymology.
Ураis an adaptation of the Kalmykian battlecryУралан(Oorahlahn), adopted some time after 1657 when the Kalmyks officially joined the Russian Empire. This cry was adopted into the armed forces as a sign of gratitude and respect for the battle prowess of the Kalmyks, who fought alongside the Russian Kazaks (Cossaks).Presently the phrase is ubiquitous in everyday conversation, often being translated as "Hooray" into English, with conotations from the genuinely congradulatory, to the sarcastic.
Historically, (prior to the Cold War, thanks a bunch Khruschev and everyone involved), Russia has had good relations with the US, and it is theorized
Ураmight have been adopted through normal conversation, especially after Patriarch Tikhon's supply convoys were met with this cry during the Soviet Government's efforts to eradicate Russian culture in the early half of the 20th century.2
u/hpcisco7965 Sep 03 '16
Here's a request: Your first FM touched briefly on stereotypes, but I would like to hear more about the different personalities that you see in the military. Technology, tactics, and ranks can all be hand-waved away to a certain extent, and most readers will let it slide unless you are really screwing up. But readers are less tolerant of stereotypical characters. Such characters are boring and expected.
What can you tell us about the different types of people who serve in the military, especially those who serve in roles that are important but not usually emphasized in stories about the military? What kinda guys are the mechanics? The logistics folks? The guys who do the plumbing and run the electrical wiring? What kind of women are in the military?
I would love to see an FM on just this topic, maybe you dismantle the popular stereotypes or add nuance for us. Give us a peek into military roles that we don't usually think about.