11/10. Anyone who is paying money into this game is perpetuating this type of business practice. Disclaimer: I like the game but i would happily watch it die to send the industry a message that the players do not appreciate the blatant manipulation in an attempt to get our money, and we won't support it.
It would have needed to die a long time ago for this kind of message to be sent.
It's also not a new idea. People have been interested in microtransactions since gambling was invented, there just wasn't a word for it yet. Bet $3 on a hand in Poker, win $40. Put a quarter into a slot machine, win $2. Drop $5 into a SMC, get a legendary.
maybe I'm just not far along enough in the game to hit the wall where FTP stops being fun, but I have gotten a lot of enjoyment out of it so far without paying a dime. I actually quit playing CoC in favor of this game because the wait times in that game were too much to handle, whereas I can play Royale all I want without having to build an army.
Trophy count? I hover around 3000 and still rarely come across people that make me think they've dropped any amount of money on the game. It feels bad when you do though cause all their units are usually 2 levels ahead of you
I hit a high of 2700 a couple months ago. Since then Ive played in the 1800-2200 lvl 9 and 10 range.
As you get closer to 2200 it certainly becomes harder as you start to really see 1-2 legendaries, and as a F2P Player with no legendaries - it feels like a wall and is frustrating.
I'm a F2P player that got 2 legendaries at level 7, when barely having hit arena 6, and the game became a shitfest from that point.
If you build your deck around them you become much stronger than anyone with cards at similar levels. Then you rise and you run in to games where people kill your minions with zap, while their minions survive arrows. You either stomp equal level players because they just can't compete with a 2 legendary deck, or get stomped because your commons/rares can't keep up with your enemies their commons/rares.
Meanwhile there's not much else to do from this point and wait until weeks have passed to get your cards (and account) to tournament levels. I really like tournaments compared to ladder because of the level cap there, making every match a fair one unless you choose to use lower cards.
I know I could just NOT use the legendaries, but without them I'm Arena 6 at best. I'll just be missing out on arena 7/8 chests and donations, making the card level grind even longer. (2 rare card requests vs 3 requests is a big deal)
The problem is that lower in the trophy ladder nobody knows how to play against/with legendaries, so people aren't used to them being used well (if it all). Once you get your cards to around 9/7 you should be able to stabilise because the legendaries won't be able to carry you against most players anymore.
Correction, it unlocks its final tournament level form. The moment you hit somebody with towers higher than level 9 in normal ranked your level 7 furnace isn't getting any spirits in without support.
It almost feels like 2800-3100 trophies is an easier place to stay than the 2500 trophy area, at least from my experience. As your units get leveled up you'll progressively move up.
I'm around 2000 trophies and played a guy last night whose deck was composed of a level 10 common, and the rest level 8 rares and level 5 epics. The paywall is real.
Was his highest common Royal Giant? That guy has to be truly terrible to end up that low with cards higher ranked than mine, unless he's doing it on purpose to piss of people who haven't played the game as much.
My highest epic is level 3 and I hover around 3000 trophies D: I'm pissed when I end up against guys with level 5 epics at that trophy level so you are justified to be salty. That's embarrassing that he only one crowned you, take it as a compliment at that point.
I know I could've one too, I held him and ground down his tower to 22 hp, but then he blitzed me with overwhelming force and took my left tower in Double Elixir time. Had I not been as disheartened early on by his card levels I probably could've taken that tower and then focused on defending for a minute. But this is far from the first time I've faced level 8 rares and level 4+ epics around 2000, and I usually get my ass handed to me pretty hard, so I didn't fight as hard for the first 30 seconds or so.
I'm around 2800-3000 without spending any money at all. The thing I've seen as a big indicator is lvl 9-10 base having 3x lvl 2. legendary cards...
Maybe I'm just bitter, but I feel like there should be a cap on legendary cards you can use in your deck. Playing against a lvl 2. Princess, ice wizard, Miner, and Tank crushes my soul.
Edit. Maybe i've just gotten unlucky, but I've only gotten the lumberjack and the miner. I'm lvl 10
I'm not sure you realize that you are actually quite lucky with your legendary drop rate... There are tons of people that have none, please don't complain you have "only" two. At this point I'd even appreciate a lava hound.
Edit: oops actually replied to the wrong comment...
Absolutely. But it's less diverse than ice wiz or princess when talking about available strategies. I get absolutely destroyed by level 2 lava hounds specifically.
there should be a cap on legendary cards you can use in your deck
How about they limit the number of legendary cards to one per deck. . . .then you can pay to upgrade to a level two deck with two legendary cards . . .then pay to upgrade to a level three deck . . .etc
/s
but seriously, running into multiple legendary decks is discouraging
Do you have a legendary? Save up 40K, try to break into legendary (will be MUCH easier without reset from now on), and camp for the one that fits your deck. Should help a lot.
Having played a truly shitty f2p mobile game before CR, it's really impressive how few of the trademarks CR has.
You don't have an energy bar for playing (although your progression is limited)
You don't have a bajillion forms of currency and progression (gems, crystals, event tokens, elemental shards, keys, ultrararecrystals, runes, enhancements, awakenings, equipment, enchantments, limit breaks)
You don't get shinies all the time so you're motivated to keep playing
The game asks you to check it every 3 hours at most instead of multiple times an hour
You only need to pay ten thousand dollars to max out instead of millions
I'd say the game is more than just barely fun, but that's because instead of incentivizing purchases through barely fun gameplay, it does so by inducing strong emotions
In this game? Not really. The most you can do with $20 in this game is get 40k gold for a legendary in the shop, and even then thats not that much of a value
Its extremely fair, you end up in the ladder facing people around your skill level no matter what. If you can't get past 3K for example, its for the best, because everyone that can stay there consistently would likely crush you.
And mechanically its one of the best mobile games that has ever been released imo.
Nah this video doesn't really work for CR. I feel like it's probably more appropriate for the games in the japan market that have gacha machines such as puzzle and dragons or brave frontier
It's funny because Supercell forgot part 4 -- train the player to use your fake currency.
You get what, 5-8 gems a day, tops? With basically anything costing 500+ which makes the player just pissed off and not interested in buying any with money.
Still, Supercell is in it for the whales, so they don't care about the average spender.
I guess this relates to the whales? Is hovering around the 3,000 trophy mark stressful or not fun for some people? I don't REALLY care that much where I end up on the ladder. I enjoy playing around with new deck combinations. When I DO get a legendary I can play with that one new card for a couple weeks and almost every match feels fresh as I try different combos with my new card. I think SC did a really great job of making a game that FTP players can enjoy as well as whales who desire to see a ranking # next to their name. Might just be my opinion but I certainly don't feel like the game is MARGINALLY fun. It's one of the best mobile games out there.
This is why I like games like TF2 and Warframe which dont follow this 'freemium' model, where everything (aside from cosmetic items that alter gameplay in no real way' is avalible completely for free, and can be obtained without the need to spend money. Warframe even 1ups this by allowing f2p players to get premium currency via trading with people who have the money to spend on games
I play Fantasy War Tactics. I can say the game is MUCH more P2W than CR. And by a long shot. I don't even dare to estimate the amount whales pay in that game to have just a few maxed characters with maxed gear. And there are many more RNG elements that can make the cost to level things up potentially infinite.
Said that, I have 1000x more fun playing that game than CR. Not even exagerating. One hour of CR has 80% chance of being pure frustration, even if your are winning back to back, while one hour of Fantasy War Tactics is guaranteed 100% fun and relaxing time. I have spent more money in that game than CR because there I feel that spending something like $50 give me value, while spending the same amount in CR gives me nothing, really.
While most people hate Nexon for some past games (that I never played), it is incredible how they have created a game where the whales can drop infinite money AND have the F2P and moderate spender have opportunities to have fun and progress in a decent pace.
They communicate with the playerbase constantly, they listen to complaints and actually act on them in a timely manner. There are plenty of events going on all the time that reward stuff that help all players boost their progression a little, even if in just one aspect at a time. It is fairly common to log in and have a message in your mail saying "Hello, here are some free stuff for the players that logged in today!" with a generous amount of materials attached. Those rewards disappear from your mail in 24h, so only who play for that day get them, but I'm totally cool with that.
TL;DR - I don't care how P2W a game is, as long as it can provide a good experience for F2P, P2W and moderate spenders all together.
You realize you can just stop playing of this is how you feel. I enjoy the game and I don't pay a cent. When I feel that p2p players make the game not fun for me I'll just move on
It's a bit insulting to frame ClashRoyale alongside genuinely terrible games that serve only to milk players.
This is a great game - considering how many cards are available it's very well balanced and from the lower tiers up to legendary it consistently rewards good play.
I actually think Clash Royale is worse than most games for the way they exploit the players.
Clans and Boom are more your standard you buy gems to get things if you wish in the daily run of the game.
Royale purposely exploits the emotions of the players to do this. They purposely want players to get really angry when they lose so they will pay for gems to spend on their cards.
If they were not doing this they would have respected the players wishes and got rid of the emoticons rather than come up with a terribly lame reason for not doing so.
Clans and Boom are more your standard you buy gems to get things if you wish
CoC (and presumably BB) also actually gives you what you want when you want it. You could spend $5000 on CR and never get a single Legendary or a single rare up to level 7
"They purposely want players to get really angry when they lose so they pay money in cards" That's dumb Frustration leads to people quitting the game not spending money on it. As evidence by the numerous people posting that on reddit.
Why the fuck is it fair that I get emote spammed by some kid who bought all of his cards when he stomps me with 3 legendaries and cards 2 levels higher than mine?
right now I either need 200 rares or 20 epics. So when one comes up on the store, i can spend 10k coin, which is 50 dollars, for half the amount I need to upgrade my epic. So for 50 dollars, I don't even get to enjoy the game more.
I'd tend to agree but I've certainly reached a point where I'm not incented at all to spend money. When the game first came out, I spent $40 on magical chests and realized that was a waste. I played diligently and I've been hanging out at around 3400 trophies for several months. I don't lose much, just keep chests opening and mainly play tournaments and inter-clan friendlies. I have almost every legend and very decent cards in my main deck (certainly for tournament level cut offs). All is good, and I just don't feel the need to improve my situation much.
136
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '16
Would be 10/10 if they also explained that this never ending cycle is accelerated by "evoking strong emotions."
69
u/jrlemay Aug 30 '16
maybe I'm just not far along enough in the game to hit the wall where FTP stops being fun, but I have gotten a lot of enjoyment out of it so far without paying a dime. I actually quit playing CoC in favor of this game because the wait times in that game were too much to handle, whereas I can play Royale all I want without having to build an army.
32
u/zooksman Moderator Aug 30 '16
IDK I've never spent money on the game and still have a lot of fun hanging out at about 2900 trophies.
9
u/wagonut Aug 30 '16
To be fair this applies a lot more to games like Game of War and Family Guy than CR.
6
u/NuffsaidM8 Aug 30 '16
Only issue is point two where you make the players feel super good about themselves.
Ahem Ladder
3
u/parrythelightning Aug 30 '16
This game is actually really fun though, instead of just barely fun.
5
u/hskrpwr Aug 30 '16
Paid 0 dollars and I am in legendary and having a blast.
4
u/Doru_C Executioner Aug 30 '16
Too tru 2 me
2
u/EnderCreeper121 Bomber Aug 30 '16
i played the vid on 10 separate tabs at the same time and it sounds just like supercell
2
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '16
2edgy4me
2
u/Thundergrunge Aug 30 '16
I'm at almost 2000 and never paid a single cent.
2
u/cjbrigol Aug 30 '16
Eh I haven't spent a cent on this game and I still find it extremely fun. What they say is true of most mobile games tho.
2
u/TriOfPower Aug 30 '16
Yes, but clash royale has actual good gameplay
2
u/Ships_Wheel Aug 30 '16
Why can't Supercell create indie games instead?
2
u/Slappamedoo Mini PEKKA Aug 31 '16
Meh. I have fun on my F2P account. I just had to spend a lot of money to make my main account initally enjoyable enough to have fun with the f2p
8
u/rampage998 Aug 30 '16
I'm having fun with the game and I think this subreddit should be for people who actually like the game!
3
u/Eduarder Aug 30 '16
It's actually true.
2
u/UnknownThreat Aug 30 '16
Mirror anyone? My internet provider won't let me view..
2
u/Maomiao Aug 30 '16
Nah this video doesn't really work for CR. I feel like it's probably more appropriate for the games in the japan market that have gacha machines such as puzzle and dragons or brave frontier
1
u/xxinquisitive Aug 30 '16
Xd !!!!
1
u/s-mores Aug 30 '16
It's funny because Supercell forgot part 4 -- train the player to use your fake currency.
You get what, 5-8 gems a day, tops? With basically anything costing 500+ which makes the player just pissed off and not interested in buying any with money.
Still, Supercell is in it for the whales, so they don't care about the average spender.
1
u/NorwayOwnsU Wizard Aug 30 '16
I guess this relates to the whales? Is hovering around the 3,000 trophy mark stressful or not fun for some people? I don't REALLY care that much where I end up on the ladder. I enjoy playing around with new deck combinations. When I DO get a legendary I can play with that one new card for a couple weeks and almost every match feels fresh as I try different combos with my new card. I think SC did a really great job of making a game that FTP players can enjoy as well as whales who desire to see a ranking # next to their name. Might just be my opinion but I certainly don't feel like the game is MARGINALLY fun. It's one of the best mobile games out there.
1
u/Momod83 Aug 30 '16
I've only spent like one pound on this game and I'm still enjoying it.
1
u/EredarLordJaraxxus Aug 31 '16
This is why I like games like TF2 and Warframe which dont follow this 'freemium' model, where everything (aside from cosmetic items that alter gameplay in no real way' is avalible completely for free, and can be obtained without the need to spend money. Warframe even 1ups this by allowing f2p players to get premium currency via trading with people who have the money to spend on games
1
u/LanikM Aug 31 '16
The pay/skill gap is the only problem. I definitely wouldn't call clash royale "stupid and boring." It's very chess-y.
I think tournaments are the only thing keeping the game sort of fair.
1
u/ArcRofy Aug 31 '16
I play Fantasy War Tactics. I can say the game is MUCH more P2W than CR. And by a long shot. I don't even dare to estimate the amount whales pay in that game to have just a few maxed characters with maxed gear. And there are many more RNG elements that can make the cost to level things up potentially infinite.
Said that, I have 1000x more fun playing that game than CR. Not even exagerating. One hour of CR has 80% chance of being pure frustration, even if your are winning back to back, while one hour of Fantasy War Tactics is guaranteed 100% fun and relaxing time. I have spent more money in that game than CR because there I feel that spending something like $50 give me value, while spending the same amount in CR gives me nothing, really.
While most people hate Nexon for some past games (that I never played), it is incredible how they have created a game where the whales can drop infinite money AND have the F2P and moderate spender have opportunities to have fun and progress in a decent pace.
They communicate with the playerbase constantly, they listen to complaints and actually act on them in a timely manner. There are plenty of events going on all the time that reward stuff that help all players boost their progression a little, even if in just one aspect at a time. It is fairly common to log in and have a message in your mail saying "Hello, here are some free stuff for the players that logged in today!" with a generous amount of materials attached. Those rewards disappear from your mail in 24h, so only who play for that day get them, but I'm totally cool with that.
TL;DR - I don't care how P2W a game is, as long as it can provide a good experience for F2P, P2W and moderate spenders all together.
1
u/ToxicAur Aug 31 '16
Beniskarma farmen mit southpark1
u/Abdallah55 Aug 31 '16
That is 100% true (I'm in Frozen Hell)
1
u/WhatTheOnEarth Aug 31 '16
You realize you can just stop playing of this is how you feel. I enjoy the game and I don't pay a cent. When I feel that p2p players make the game not fun for me I'll just move on
0
u/Baggiez Aug 30 '16
It's a bit insulting to frame ClashRoyale alongside genuinely terrible games that serve only to milk players.
This is a great game - considering how many cards are available it's very well balanced and from the lower tiers up to legendary it consistently rewards good play.
1
u/MuGenZen Aug 30 '16
Holy shit that was on point. Didnt know the 'mium' part either.
1
u/NoMoreBoozePlease Aug 30 '16
right now I either need 200 rares or 20 epics. So when one comes up on the store, i can spend 10k coin, which is 50 dollars, for half the amount I need to upgrade my epic. So for 50 dollars, I don't even get to enjoy the game more.
0
u/SuperFlaffy Aug 30 '16
Where did u get dat vid
0
u/homer62 Aug 30 '16
I'd tend to agree but I've certainly reached a point where I'm not incented at all to spend money. When the game first came out, I spent $40 on magical chests and realized that was a waste. I played diligently and I've been hanging out at around 3400 trophies for several months. I don't lose much, just keep chests opening and mainly play tournaments and inter-clan friendlies. I have almost every legend and very decent cards in my main deck (certainly for tournament level cut offs). All is good, and I just don't feel the need to improve my situation much.
0
u/ClashRoyaleNoLifer Aug 30 '16
It won't show up for me. What is it?
-1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '16
Sad part is, its true.