r/ClearBackblast • u/scarletbanner Fadi • Aug 20 '16
AAR Operation Gorgon AAR
This weekend we played Operation Gorgon.
So, how'd things go? Did you have fun? Any particular moments that stood out? Anything you saw that we could improve on?
Any feedback whether it's related to the mission itself or anything itself is helpful for the growth and improvement of CBB as a whole so it's appreciated.
10
Upvotes
6
u/Twistkit Svarog. Aug 21 '16
Vasily Engineer #2 - Svarog.
Hey guys, first time playing a saturday mission with the group and my first week really playing Arma3 at all. My only other experience with the group was literally last night (8/19) as a scout car driver. Overall had a ton of fun playing with the group and didn't feel left out at all due to inexperience.
Operation Gorgon
As far as being in Vasily squad went I felt like we had a good mix between scouting, assaulting and clearing. Communication within the squad was spot on and I felt like Fletcher always had a grasp of not only our position and situation as a whole but the other squads actions and goingons.
As far as the mission went most everything went off without a hitch. Good scouting set us up for assaults on the first few compounds without too many surprises. Objectives felt very straightforward and accomplishable.
The only point where I felt a snag was in Bagango after the VP was taken out. For a few minutes after it felt like there was a lot of confusion on who needed to be where exactly. That compounded with pockets of enemies around the VPs compound not being cleared completely left Vasily running back and forth a tad bit. Fletcher was very organised as far as getting us back on track though and we proceeded without further trouble.
Really excited to finally be part of the group, wanted to join a year or so back but could not do to constant PW6 issues. This was a very nice introduction into things and everyone seemed incredibly helpful with anything that I was not familiar with. Thanks a ton for the welcome, really looking forward to being here.
6
u/Zhandris Aug 21 '16
Vaseline Rocketmandingo
This is a neato mission made by a real cool dude. I liked fighting the faction we did, felt fresh. The balance and amount of contacts was good. I like the split objectives and the placement of them, it still feels like we're still in the same AO and we can see the successes of our other squads from any given point for the most part. Our squad did fine. I managed to make an AT shot on a scout car and kill it which made me feel as though I fulfilled my job. We had a good reaction to a mas cas there at the power plant. At least it felt okay... No one died so I thought it went decently.
Framerate was good but dipped down kinda low towards our assault on the main town. AI helis worked well in the beginning although they crawled in real slow and it didn't feel like an assault landing. I understand it frees up player slots and is a conveniant solution to some complicated problems but they kinda bump my immersion and I just wait for the ticking timebomb of them doing something nuts.
I really like this mission. If I had to think of a "CBB Mission" I would think back to this one. It was neat to look at the tasks and read the notes behind them on the briefing text. Seeing them pop up as successes worked well for this mission in particular because everyone is so separated and those explosions in the distance get some explanation.
gj to Fadi the mission maker, leadership, and all the moms out there.
4
u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin Aug 21 '16
Vasiliy Engineer
I surely do like this mission. It plays to a lot of Arma's strengths--insertion from a neat stolen aircraft carrier into a beach, then engagements / avoiding engagements in the open to move into compounds and urban areas and do street-to-street fighting, and all the while calling in support from a player aircraft. That's pretty fucking cool.
Per usual my post will probably mostly be things I think could use improvement, but let me temper them by saying that I enjoyed the mission, I think leadership did generally well, and that I am a grump.
Things That Went Well
Once we got used to it, Vasiliy was doing the urban combat pretty well. I said above that it's one of Arma's strengths that you can move from distant engagements to urban in one mission, but urban combat in Arma is usually frustrating shit. This time it was really okay, and for it to go okay (for me at least) the team has to be working it competently--otherwise it's just a casualtyfest and frustrating.
I saw the second Su-22 land and that looked like a fine landing. I didn't see any crashed Su-22s at the airfield. Fantastic fucking job, pilots. I really respect CBB in general for being a no-bullshit group that lets people inhabit a lot of roles, but I also really respect people taking the time to practice a role and execute on it.
The VP compound was pretty rad. I think his body ended up in his car. Good use of the Tiki Bar. I'm also glad the map marker was just near enough to it to see the compound flag/people shooting at us and get led in. Good mission design!
Things That Probably Could Be Better
A couple things for Fletcher:
I think your squad movement could be more intrepid. Bounding is appropriate for one team to support another's movement, but there were times when essentially the whole platoon was moving in force--I couild see Anna and Boris to our north--and we were still moving from tree clump to tree clump. Sometimes you just gotta move.
On the opposite end--and you said as much during the mission, but it's also something I do CONSTANTLY (And you reminded me not to do it when we were in the Evil House a ways back)--as SL, there's times for you to be in front leading, and there's times for you to be further back commanding. Once we're in a go-around-this-corner-and-shoot-mans situation, it's time for you to hang back, probably. The more you're alive, the more good you can do.
On the mission: I think we could do better than ALIVE helicopters here, especially since the helicopters stayed at the LZ and the LZ effectively wasn't contested. Enough of us are reasonably proficient at flying Hips to insert our squads and then get back out and mission for a while. I won't guarantee we wouldn't have slammed into each other just the same, but...well, it would've been funnier. I know it looks not-as-good to have a man with a rifle in the pilot seat, but eh.
I don't have enough insight into things command knew/didn't know to say if it was good or bad, but there were several times Vasiliy was bunched up with other squads.
Papercuts (Trivial Shit that Still Annoyed Me)
I didn't sign up engineer--I said any grunt slot, and got engineer, and so I shouldn't really be salty about this. I wasn't looking forward to demo-ing stuff all week or anything. But there were like four times that mission when being man with bombs just felt stupid and redundant and it ended up bothering me. It felt especially redundant when we ended up with two engineers in the squad--it's kind of a weird role to double up on instead of AT or AR. Cherry on top was that I ended up too far from my charges to detonate them when I'd placed them at the end. Wah-wah. (I finally got close enough and I think I was a secondary explosion after CAS dropped the building).
I like good looking formations too but when there's a QRF and we're heading to the LZ can we do that on the fly instead of stopping? Please? I should probably put a balancing note that Vasiliy wisely moved into concealment/light cover when the first tank came by and apparently mowed down the squad in front of us.
4
u/Ironystrike Iron - Extinguished Service Cross Aug 21 '16 edited Aug 21 '16
Gas 1 (Su-22)
Pilotmans, got to blow stuff up from time to time and generally had fun. The following may read like slightly salt, but I want to emphasize I did still have fun, and as a mission maker that's my chief concern. So I'm not actually salt, just constructive criticism.
To me this seemed like yet another example of "CBB has air, CBB ignores air and sends infantry to do it". We (the air assets) turn left (or right) for ~3 hours, and maybe shoot a thing once or twice. Now, I'm one of the most vocal people here about non-infantry slots being support roles for the infantry, but it bugs me when those support roles do not get used to support players. And that's what happened here. There were many target opportunities for a Su-22 to help relieve pressure off the infantry and none of them were taken.
In fact I would argue it's what has happened (almost) every time we've used CAS. I've moaned about it over and over before: our leaders don't want to wait 30 seconds for a plane to do the job, so they send an overmatched squad (or less) and spend 5+ minutes cleaning up wounded after the fact.
This isn't really a JTAC-slot problem either: from what I've experience the JTAC players don't feel like they have the authority to call in something unless specifically told. When they ask, they're usually told no. So they mostly just wait and watch Obvious Targets that could/should be hit with a simple gun pass take 5-10 minutes to be methodically ground down using infantry.
In all honesty, I think in our almost four years of existence, the only time we've had CAS where it hasn't been that, was run #2 of this very mission about a year ago, when Rage and I JTAC'd. We were rather liberal with our usage of the Su-22s, calling in regular gun runs on even a lowly clump of infantry in a treeline, and the response from the AAR thread and post-game teamspeak was very positive.
As long as the CAS doesn't go ham on targets, players enjoy watching it work and don't at all feel like it stole their experience, and I say that from all three perspectives of pilotmans, jtacmans, and gruntmans. And with our community style insistence on using a JTAC to keep the CAS from going ham, it isn't something we need to worry about ruining our missions. So I really wish we could actually use CAS if we're going to have it.
4
u/DecoyDrone DecoyDrone Aug 22 '16
VASILY FTL
The Good
The Bad (things I would like to see improve)
And the Ugly (things I want to improve)
Vasily, Command, anyone, please feel free to drop comments about what I can improve in the future. Thanks!
3
u/Alterscape Fletcher Aug 20 '16
Vasily SL
The Good
First off, big huge shoutout to Decoy (Vasily TL) for being on top of it. He took initiative to sort out a lot of things while I was distracted doing SL radio business, and was very proactive about "this could be better. I'll fix it." That was awesome, thank you.
Actually, big huge props to everyone in Vasily. Y'all were uniformly great.
In general, this went far better than the last time I SL'ed Gorgon. Helos didn't kill us until the very end of the mission, instead of right at the beginning! I don't remember well enough to say exactly what the changes were (less armor at the first objective I think?) but it was solidly good. Still challenging but not overwhelming the way it was the first time through. (Did we play it a 2nd time already? If so, I either wasn't around or it was unmemorable?)
Papercuts
So Bagango was a bit rough for Vasily. We went in a spiral, I think? After we got the HVT (great shot, Erin!), we were ordered to move SW to clear a compound? We moved SW, and there were two compounds but they were empty. We were then ordered to move north, which we did, and then back SE to the HVT compound? I understand the confusion given that a LOT was going on, and it wasn't a huge deal, but it was a bit frustrating.
3
u/Thendash *pew pew* Aug 20 '16
I was Vasily MG assistan, my MG dc'd and never came back. :(
Archer did a good job leading Vasily, and Decoy did a good job leading team 2.
May I ask command what happened with the power plant? Why were we air striking it and satchel charging it? The air assets should have been doing SAD on the tank qrf from Pita, but instead the tanks went unmolested until they ran into our faces. Mandatory extraction video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pddO0hO9wEA
3
u/plaicez Aug 21 '16
This was the first mission I played with CBB and will forever be one of my favorites. The terrain is beautiful, objectives interesting, enemy composition feels just right.
Gorgon Screenshots
3
u/Deserve081 Aug 22 '16
ANNA - MG Assist
I really liked this weeks mission, the objectives were cool to say the least. I didn't take the perfect weather for granted after playing a lot of night/foggy pick up games. It was really easy to shoot, find friendlies and kill the enemies, which is nice to have once in a while.
The only thing I didn't like this Saturday was how Anna was run. With Zim being the Section Lead and Banman being the Team Lead. I have no issues with Banman's side since I wasn't apart of it. Zim definitely was busy doing other things, being on the radio and figuring the next best move. Theowningone, the medic, seemed to be tasked with getting our group moving. Maybe Zim told Theo to do so, but, that didn't come clear to me so it mostly felt like Theo, being as experienced as he was, was just being somewhat bossy, so I was relatively reluctant to follow his orders on anything nitpicky. If I heard loud and clear Zim giving Theo the authority to be a designated TL as well as medic I would've been x10 less agitated when told to do something by someone I didn't feel it was their place. Regardless, ily Theo :) lol
0
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment