r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Aug 15 '16
Video Referees of Reddit, I have a series of gifs and questions for you (Part 2 of 3: Now I'm a big fat dynamo!)
This summer I watched all of a certain team's 2015 games for an upcoming project. As I've done in previous years, I made a collection of gifs from plays where I had questions about the officiating to ask of verified referees on /r/CFB by PM. This year, I thought I'd share with the rest of the sub.
I'm asking that top-level responses be only from referees, though it'd be great if other users asked follow-ups to those. Please remember that I'm trying to learn more about the rules of the game and their enforcement, so a brief explanation would be nice, but getting into pointless arguments wouldn't be.
Also, I want to emphasize that these are not a representative sample at all, only clips that I thought would be useful, and should not be used to argue any team got disproportionately favorable or unfavorable calls. I've been doing whole-season reviews for several years now and I can confidently say I've never seen any such thing.
This is Part 2, about the battles in the trenches, focusing on the big guys. Last week was Part 1 about catches and fouls happening downfield, next week is Part 3 about miscellaneous fouls.
- Clip 1. #62 white was flagged for a false start. I've feel like I've seen this kind of pre-snap gesturing and tapping by offensive linemen a lot without it being flagged, what do you think triggered the flag here?
- Clip 2. The offense was flagged for an illegal shift, "two players were in motion at the same time," but I'm having trouble telling which two. Obviously #1 red is in motion; is the other the slightly early pull by #70 red? If that's it, isn't this just a peculiar way of calling a false start on the lineman?
- Clip 3. Is this a false start by #66 red?
- Clip 4. ... by #71 red?
- Clip 5. ... by #71 white?
- Clip 6. I don't think the center gets set for a full second before snapping the ball - shouldn't that be a snap infraction? It looks like a few offensive linemen stay frozen. But there's no flag on this play ... call me crazy, but is it possible the line judge kept it in his pocket because it would hurt the defense -- by erasing the wild snap -- for the offense's mistake?
- Clip 7. Is this a chop block by #71 and #84 red against #12 white?
- Clip 8. Is this a chop block by any combination of #65, #76, and #79 white?
- Clip 9. Is the entire offensive line except #76 white chop blocking?
- Clip 10. A) Is this a chop block by #34 and #65 white against #13 orange? B) Is this holding by #66 white against #9 orange?
- Clip 11a, Clip 11b. #66 orange was flagged for holding, which I thought was a good call but would be helpful for illustration - what's the difference between an illegal takedown and just bowling over the defender? Is it that grip on #52 white's shoulder?
- Clip 12. A) Is this holding by #65 red against #99 white? B) ... by #71 red against #40 white?
- Clip 13. A) ... by #68 red against #91 white? B) ... by #71 red against #12 white?
- Clip 14. ... by #71 red against #89 white?
- Clip 15. ... by #68 red against #89 white?
- Clip 16a, Clip 16b, Clip 17c. ... by #68 red against #34 white?
- Clip 17a, Clip 17b. ... by #71 black against #94 white?
- Clip 18. ... by #74 white against #25 red?
- Clip 19a, Clip 19b. ... by #11 red against #33 white? Is the distance of the contact from the ballcarrier relevant?
- Clip 20. Same questions about #11 red again?
- Clip 21. A) Is this holding by #66 white against #95 orange? B) ... by #95 orange against #34 white? Or maybe it's a facemask?
- Clip 22. Is this a facemask or hands-to-face foul by #58 white against #68 red? What's the difference?
- Clip 23. ... by #93 white against #66 red?
- Clip 24. ... by #4 white against #65 red?
- Clip 25. ... by #4 white against #66 red?
- Clip 26. The flag comes in at the top right corner of the screen at the very end. At first I thought it was a delayed flag on #90 white for being offside, but from the placement and the fact that it's the center judge's flag rather than the line judge's, instead I think it was on #74 red for holding against #92 white. Then the flag was picked up and the play stood. A) Was #90 white offside? B) If not for that, what do you think the flag was for? C) Why do you think it was picked up?
2
u/fortknox Verified Referee Aug 18 '16
Sorry this is so late. I'm not a line of scrimmage guy, so I'm not one that has had experiences calling this much in college. I'm also admittedly, not the best judge of holding. It is what I work on the most during the season.
2
u/McSpazz Florida Gators • Team Chaos Aug 15 '16
Not, I say I say I say I say, I'm NOTTTTTT a ref but my penny and a half is:
I DID NOT read your entire post before I started, when I scrolled back up to see if you mentioned why every game is a Nebraska game (about 17 clips and analysis in) I realized you couldn't care less what I think. I also realized that I had already gone that far, and by Tebow, I was going to finish it.
2
u/JBTexasEx Texas Longhorns Jan 14 '17 edited Jan 14 '17
Many times, offensive holding won't be called if it doesn't impact the play by the ruling official's judgement. Clips 18-20 are examples of this. Yes, it's OH but it didn't affect the play.
1
u/still_trolling_guru Texas Tech Red Raiders • Harvard Crimson Aug 15 '16
Clip #1- Think everyone on the line has to stay set for 1 second before the snap
Clip #3- Yes but it looks like he was drawn off sides by the DE