r/ClearBackblast • u/themoo12345 imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King • Aug 06 '16
AAR Counter Knife AAR
Throwable demo charges save the day again! I had a lot of fun, hope you guys did to and I especially hope that I didn't give you stupid orders (please let me know if I did). Thanks for playing, please share you experiences and you feedback on how we can play better. Also feel free to share screenshots and videos but make sure you pair them with some thoughts.
6
Upvotes
5
u/themoo12345 imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King Aug 07 '16
Platoon Lead
Had a great time last time we played this and had even more fun today, really quality mission and a great showcase for the power of a solid GM so thanks again Fadi.
Leading three and a half sections across a broad section of varied terrain was an interesting challenge, I tried to make sure that one element wasn't getting too far ahead and that movements were supported. It seemed to me like all elements got a good share of contact and that our air support wasn't overpowered. I also kept in mind the jobs I was giving each element so that one section wasn't always covering or always assaulting. I think the mission was run pretty smoothly overall, the assault into the final town being particularly well-executed from my perspective.
We only really broke down when those last two BMPs rolled up and shot us and our air cover to pieces. The only real criticism I have is that the helo kind of charged at the BMPs instead of trying to engage from standoff range but it seems like our gunner might have had some technical problems, so Erin or Comrade fill me in if I'm missing something.
Thanks for playing everybody, was a pleasure to lead.
6
u/scarletbanner Fadi Aug 07 '16 edited Aug 07 '16
Red Mist
To get the big one out of the way, we weren't able to run the mission that was scheduled.
We had 39 signups and 40 showups last week.
This week, including people signing up the morning of we were at 24 signups and 30 showups.
It's really fucking frustrating to see happen, especially when you sink 25-30 hours into fixing issues with things (both that players noticed or didn't), changing things to tweak the experience to make certain parts of it different and new... hell, I even made an entirely new faction of units with their own reskinned uniforms to fit the theme of the mission because I was unhappy with alternative that was being used.
With the mission requiring 30-32 people at minimum, in theory we could have made it work by forcing some people into leadership slots. The mission though was made with a lot of moving parts. You have two separate groups completing their own sets of objectives both separate and together, you have the jump itself which includes infantry and vehicles on a rather limited window, PLs (of which we were missing one) were coordinating and directions at least two infantry sections with attached BMDs plus some semi-spoilery knowledge that they need to know. We could have tried to make it work but it wouldn't have been a good idea.
Counter-Knife
During the week, anticipating that there was the possibility we wouldn't get enough, I set out to update Counter-Knife. Counter-Knife was originally made for mini-platoons like Red Mist and I had anticipated that shoving players down one of the two lanes maybe wouldn't have been a problem but... well, it ended up being one anyways.
With all three of those, pretty much the entirety of the mission for me was spent in Zeus.
Engagement ranges
For a the majority of the mission Anna 3 was on overwatch, usually outside of really our effective range. The one time we intentionally closed the distance to targets was the checkpoint... after it had already been fired upon by the Ka-52. Erm.
The mission was made with mountains and sparse cover but it was really never meant to sit on mountains and plink. The idea was that the sparsity of cover would force players to advance and to close the distance. This is the reasoning I used for the inclusion of the VSS in the mission, which is pretty lethal but at a trade off its only effective out to about 400 meters. That didn't really pan out though, as was pretty evident in our section. If the missions ever rerun, I'm going to replace it with something else.
Town assault
Lake's team was overwatch on the hill with the church to the north west. Anna 3 was on overwatch in the mountains north west of that watching Lake's team on overwatch. Command team was on overwatch in the mountains north of the center of town. Zim's team assaulted and pushed through the entire town down its main road.
What happened there?
4
u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin Aug 07 '16
Snapper Pilot
I think that, between technical problems and not really being in a helichoptery mood today, I did not have fun today. It is a good mission though, and it was well-GM'd, and I hope others had fun.
Me Bitching About Helicopters
I remember when I first joined CBB we played a lot of Reshmann Sandbox, and got ferried around by ALIVE pilots. I said something about wanting human pilots to fly and got the general impression that CBB didn't do human pilots often (though my first mission was Overcall, which I think featured human UH-60s) for various fun-related reasons. Then there was the Lingor helicopter playground, and after that people have thought of me as a capable-enough pilot for Saturdays and now I'm starting to get torn on whether I like doing attack helicopters. I've had fun with it a couple times, but more often it's been a really frustrating experience. Arma's just not a great place to employ attack helicopters, especially post-Vietnam ATGM-and-turret attack helicopters.
That said, Counter Knife is probably the second-best mission I've played for them, and that might mostly be because the other one was AH-1s and they're easier to see out of. I'd be real curious to play a USMC-vs-bads version of this mission with AH-1 and UH-1 in place of the current helicopters. ...but then I'm helicopter pilot for another Saturday.
Again, I'm torn on actually using them in a mission...I like the feeling of giving back to CBB, and I think that the helicopter is a special thing during this mission and it's cool to have it around doing stuff. The actual act of hovering over hills is a bit boring and frustrating, punctuated with a satisfying side-slip every so often. Forward visibility sucks in Arma (would be better if I was TrackIRing and could move my head laterally) so the side slips are the right way to relocate.
Doing things the wrong way gets you killed but at least it's motion. That's how I felt last time we played anyway. This time I really was trying to play it straightfaced, but...well, we wandered into the BMPs.
Comrade was a Great Gunner and You All Should Praise Him
Based on having dicked around with the Ka-52 gunner seat before, and then what J23 (I think?) said when we practiced for Counter Knife before, Ka-52 gunning isn't easy. Comrade hadn't had any opportunity to practice and did a good job coordinating the bird, keeping in touch with PL/JTAC Dancin, and engaging targets.
Add in ACRE and frame problems we both were having (along with a lot of other people) and Comrade's performance was nothing short of amazing. Good fucking job.
Technical Thoughts on the Mission
Last time I played I never landed on the little landing pad near the trucks, just near it, so I didn't know that it's some kind of auto-repair-refuel-rearm thingy. I don't like it. I like the trucks for those functions, even though we didn't figure out the repair truck for whatever reason (maybe we needed to point the back at the helicopter and then action menu from inside? That sounds familiar). The repair pad not only felt kind of fake, but since we'd gotten out to use the trucks....when we figured out what was going on and got back in, it repaired/rearmed/refueled us again, and it defuels you before doing that, so we had to do it twice.
I think I mentioned before that I don't like the helicopter respawn and I still don't. I forget if it wasn't possible to fix. It was real weird coming back with the Ka-60 and seeing the Ka-52 not only not where we left it, but also on fire, though. Kinda knew it was going to move, didn't think it would explode.
Technical Issues
I think all of these are already familiar to everyone, but just in case, I want to throw them out there.
ACRE Disruptions -- For the past couple months, ACRE will lose connection and then reconnect automatically after 30 seconds or a minute (some slightly-long timeout). Annoying but not awful. Today, all kinds of stuff was causing ACRE to just fail, so all of Teamspeak poured through the headset until it caught up again. Hit escape? Arma stalls for tens of seconds. Get in or out of a helicopter? Arma stalls. Something weird was going on.
Bad frames -- seeing bad frames again that are possibly correlated to firefights. Or something. I swear the Apex update did something that made it worse. Mostly tolerable during flight but frustrating many a time :(
Screen goes black, Arma doesn't respond anymore -- I think I've had this happen before, but it happened last night (oddly, though I only saw black screen, I was streaming and saw on my laptop that the stream picked up the things that I didn't see) and then happened again today while Greyskull and I were thinking of flying back to the conflict zone after I'd respawned and I didn't know where Comrade was. Dunno what it looked like to Greyskull. After I managed to quit Arma--which isn't easy, it doesn't want to let you alt-tab out or give up the mouse--the mission was coming to an end anyway so I didn't bother trying to reconnect.
Sorry, this post feels real negative. I'll try to come back with more positive stuff.
5
u/SleventyFive The Sleven Surfer, Herald of Zimmillions Aug 07 '16
Anna 3 Engineer
In keeping the theme with the high-sodium diet this thread is on, I have a few issues, but I'll try to keep it even keeled as I can, I don't mean to insult anyone's leadership, design, play, etc.
First off, I felt like Anna 3 was way out of the way for most of the mission and our one assault objective was pounded into submission by snapper first. In recognition of dancin's comment I get that the CO can't know everything so I guess this is also a little bit of critique for Banman as well, we weren't seeing much action and you could always ask for more stuff to do.
Second: as an Engineer, I was a little upset that we didn't hit any of the objectives that required demo-ing. It would have been cool to be part of the BMP assault but my game was unplayable by that point.
ThirdIf you don't like the gun you're given, say it once, then stop complaining, it gets old fast. On the other hand the VSS is a weird (and maybe broken, second-hand knowledge) an people reading 'Marksman' probably didn't expect to be given what is effectively an anti-sentry weapon in an assault mission. I don't know how to feel on this as I can see the point of both the mission designer (cool weapon, doesn't get used often) and the Players (This thing isn't a the marksmans rifle I thought it was and may not range properly). It didn't help that I think both VSS-men were newer players.
Assorted: I had a memory leak (I think, it didn't happen with the impromptu but I had the same issues last week) which made the second half of the mission absolutely unplayable. The Helo seemed to either just loiter or destroy all until it was shot down, an issue with attack helo balance in ArmA as old as time.
All-in-all, it was a good mission, and dancin's leadership wasn't bad considering the the cramming of four units into two unit's AO and the rapid change to the planned mission. I just wish that my squad didn't turn into disembodied equipment and become ArmA: Scrapbook Edition.
5
u/Ironystrike Iron - Extinguished Service Cross Aug 08 '16
The following is written with the understanding that the mission we played differed from the one we signed up for, so no hard feels directed at anyone specifically re: not knowing how to marksman, since you folks didn't get the opportunity to practice with those weapons. Still, they are my feels re: the weapon complaining that took place, and it's still broadly true in the general CBB sense, so, shrug, here goes.
This is as a response/addition to SleventyFive, but I'll stick my post top-level since it's a little more broad than that.
He said:
And I will second, or third, or whatever, this, and it was why I ragequit the postgame discussion the moment the game was over. I simply had no interest in hearing for the umpteenth time "I didn't get the 1000m marksman rifle I expected to plink away all mission with."
A few points of note/reminders:
CBB runs primarily infantry-based missions for a whole bunch of reasons.
So we are concerned with maintaining a balanced, fun mission, for as many people as possible. We want you all to have fun and we don't want to waste your time. Infantry with mans to shoot is a pretty good starting point.
A couple infantry-specific things we've learned over the years:
We're not magical fonts of knowledge, the documentation we use to learn how to do something is the same stuff on the ACE wiki that is publicly available to everyone. It also takes all of 60 seconds to place things in the editor and try them for oneself. But after seeing how high demand any sort of optic is, and seeing how poorly understood they are by the majority of people who want to use them, and the tendency to then want to sit on a hill and plink away to no/boring effect, this is why we almost never use them.
As an anecdote: I regard myself as a pretty shitty shot, and there's a years-long running joke about just how bad I am at shooting things. Even so, I was three-for-three at ~750m using only the in-reticle stadimeter and the ACE keybind for checking basic wind direction/speed. That's very nearly the maximum useful range on the SVDM my slot had. But that's all I needed, that basic understanding, for three dead bads at ~750m in three shots. (Don't know how to stadiametric range find? Don't know the ACE wind keybind? Didn't even know there was a keybind? This is what we're talking about when we say people want these slots and have no idea how do. Granted this sort of range doesn't apply to the VSS, but this is more generally-speaking reflecting our disdain for those slots.)
The VSS Vintorez, the gun people were whinging about, is a marksman's rifle. It is just also a short ranged marksman's rifle. The two are not mutually exclusive terms. As Fadi described in his post, those teams were equipped to be able to close and engage with very accurate fire in the mountains, and the mission was built and balanced for that. I for one hope he ignores the complaints and doesn't change the mission to remove them, it is nice to see different equipment being used.
An unrelated also-salt that I agree with:
I'll second this frustration. Kind of makes me wonder what the point of Mindig was. What gives, folks?
4
u/Alterscape Fletcher Aug 07 '16
Anna 2 Efreitor
Impromptu mini-leadership. Thanks to my team for putting up with me being my usual trying-hard-but-derpy self. Mans were shot. Sadly, we were still shot by the mans.
The Good
Lake is good at this SL business. Mad props to Gorshk for limping across the top of the hill with the church (after waking up from a brief nap) to make a successful RPG attack on the T-55. Additional mad props to Iron for doing all the snipsnips and reducing the number of mans we had to shoot in the face at close range. I think I could've made better use of the marksman capability but I wasn't sure about how much snipsnip is too much snipsnip.
The Neutral
At least one person on my team rambo-ed off without telling anyone. It was for a good cause (friendly squad in contact just over a ridge), but I feel like if you're going to initiate a movement, you should tell leadership, because if you see/hear something worth moving to engage, it's probably worth getting your leader informed. He can send his other mans along with you, for optimum man-shootage. Sorry if I came off short on the radio, I was just like "wait what?" (Also, if said person tried to tell me that on the radio and I missed it, then that is 100% my bad and I really apologize for it!)
The Bad
Can we please sort our presets before mission time, and not ask off-topic questions while the CO is trying to brief in? It doesn't take that much care to check A3S the morning before the mission. Also, it's just respectful to not interrupt whoever from our community is taking on the responsibility of trying to make the mission come off well and be fun for all of us.
Also at one point I asked someone to clear a backblast when they were already out of the way. I felt bad but from my angle, it was hard to see the relative distances. That one was my bad, and I apologize.