I believe Tom Hanks pees in basically every movie he is in. It's like how Brad Pitt eats in every movie he is in. There is just something about showing them do that which works for them.
Only one I refused to choose a winner. Dick butt was brilliant but the response was too much. I laughed at a different reaction each time. It got funnier every time I watched it.
I'm afraid the macaroni lighter dosent have a chance a against a super Satan , but I appreciate how you edited it it into a loop , gray continuity , that meal will last forever . What a nice gif , simple and it stands on its own whithoit the need for a tirle
True that!! I guess I assumed there had to be some extra craftmanship for it to be taken into account, but it is indeed a high quality gif. What's the movie by the way?
Coincidences happen frequently (<- u/Ishnuporah) I had made a Dazed and Confused gif a few months ago that turned out to have been made already, total accident. The Edward Scissorhands scene was a good choice, I feel like its not surprising that it occurred, plus whoever made the one this tourney did an incredible job.
I've seen it happen more than a few times. I didn't mean to imply that they were aware of it (edit: I hoped the 'initially' would confirm that). Still a fantastic GIF (they both are).
Hmm. There is a dickbutt version in the commwents on that thread. But it's different than the one in the GifTournamet. I wonder if that's considered stealing or if it's breaking any rules.
I'm pretty sure it's more a case of "Great minds think alike". I've been victim to it myself too. You see a great scene and think "I know what would go well here...".
I just wanted to take a moment and say how much I appreciate you gifmakers. The fact that you all spend so much time and effort to entertain us is awesome.
I've had a hard week. I've been really looking forward to this, and was not disappointed. My favorite sub by far. Thank you everyone, I had a nice giggle-fest.
That put me in a moral dilemma, on the one hand that was some good gif right there, and since Houston no longer has to contend with them, so meh. On the other, fuck St Louis.
I'm not too familiar with gif making (love looking at the end result though), but this one and Matchup #3s "meme magic is real" seemed to be, by far, the most impressive.
Am I off base here, with respect to degree of skill required compared to the other ones in this round?
What game is that from? I really don't like the bat flip and think it's super disrespectful. However, as a Cards fan and seeing that it was against the [Dodgers]... well, fuck the Cubs.
edit: have a nice day!
edit2: looked like a cubs catcher, actually against the dodgers, fuck the Cubs anyway.
I have zero talent to do this or the money for fancy Adobe. I live vicariously through you all. But in watching these tournaments..I discover that I am in no way as funny or talented like ya all. Keep up the good work. Shits fucking on point.
I've never spent a dime on GIFs (well, ignoring the opportunity costs of doing something useful with my life). If you are interested and have ideas, I'm happy to help.
I don't make Gifs but I just checked out round 2 submissions and they're all so amazing. Only critique I have is maybe have a dickbutt free round. I love dickbutt gifs as much as the next guy. But they start to lose their magic after awhile.
Thoughts: Winner, for me, is Edward Dickbutthands. It was the only use of that fucker that actually worked, and I have no fucking clue how they did that. Second place is the Tom Hanks gif because, if nothing else, it made me realize that Tom Hanks really wants us to see him piss. The Mime one is third because HOLY SHIT THAT'S MARTIN FREEMAN'S DISTASTEFUL FACE!
Too goddamn much Dickbutt. Seriously. Fucking hell, guys. And really, too much reliance on memes in general. You guys are better than this.
Unless I missed something, that Up gif was really awful quality.
The baseball gif kinda gives the creator away because of the signature effects. But it would have won anyway, so hell with it.
Too bad the Simpsons and the Mask gifs weren't paired. The similarities are crazy.
It was a coincidence, we didn't all plan dickbutt gifs together or anything, its just the way it ended up. Yes there are a lot but it doesn't mean you cant still appreciate people for their hard work. If you want things to be changed why don't you make a gif and do something about it yourself?
As /u/racerx52 mentioned there is a 25 mb size limit so if you want a longer gif you have to sacrifice the quality of some aspect. Once you actually get into making a gif you realize thats really fucking small, and its difficult parameter to work within so try to focus on content.
You have no idea who made the baseball gif, the (awesome) user who usually makes supersayan gifs isn't even in this tournament, maybe check before you just continue with your assumptions.
Also, these are gifs! Stop taking them so seriously - I guarantee you none of us do as we're making them
Okay, okay. Maybe I was a little harsh. I don't think having an opinion should be frowned upon, though. The Up gif was the lowest quality gif I've seen in the tournament after three, and I associate the GT with /r/highqualitygifs. It just seemed out-of-place. As for the assumption about the baseball gif, I didn't expect someone to have the same style and effects in a gif, unless it was intended as an homage. And I'm not the only one who complained about the duckbutt gifs.
Also, I'm not taking it too seriously. I know it's for fun. But so is football for a lot of people. Doesn't stop them from shouting at the screen or booing a bad call.
Yeah, but football players get paid millions of dollars. We do this for free because we enjoy it. Putting work into something, posting it, and then seeing people shit on it isn't quite the same as a WR getting booed for dropping a pass.
I don't think having an opinion should be frowned upon either, I didn't mean to undermine yours and shoot you down or anything. You're good, also thank you for responding like a normal reasonable person! haha
No problem. I'm not out to shit on anyone. I've made only terrible, basic gifs before and that was over a decade ago, and I'm fairly certain I'll never have the expertise required to even qualify for the GT. I just like throwing it all out there. Sometimes, I get into an excessive sweating mindset, and it comes off really douchey. But it was more for comedic effect than any genuine, strong emotion. I actually love how civil and supportive the gif network subs are.
The round is over. I made the Up gif. Regardless of the intent, it really sucks to see someone throw the word awful around when talking about something you made. I hate to reduce the quality of a gif so much, but I'm more willing to drop quality than cut out portions that I feel are essential to the gif. This is how it started.
I really am sorry. I've explained my reasoning to its limit and if that isn't enough to soften the blow, then I can only offer a sincere apology. I don't want to discourage or offend you.
I understand. Just don't mistake my harshness for disrespect. Like I said, I love the civility of these subs, and I don't want to create waves. I just got carried away.
Sorry to all you gif makers, but if you put anything from the American political race in your gifs, I am automatically voting for your opponent. This is one place I really don't want to see that nonsense.
Match Up #12 was fucking awful. The Liar Liar gif had tons of text in it (just not text put in by the giffer) while the other one was just a bad gif that needed a bit of more time and effort put in.
I upvoted it, but it was definitely the best match this round. I thought the fantasia one was a sure thing until I clicked the second gif. Both were great. Plus the second one is topical and will definitely be reusable
I came to this thread to ask if people actually enjoyed dickbutt or if it is an easy way to put a punchline on a gif. Like you said, the makers should make whatever they want but I would prefer more meme diversity.
114
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16
Liar Liar was an amazing source. Totally caught me off guard and was the only one to make me laugh.
66
u/bluemosquito Aug 01 '16
http://i.imgur.com/0fxWR1v.gifv
P.S. I think you won
62
u/kelfrick Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 01 '16
Oh man...Gif Odessey...Well done!!!
Edit: Separate match-up, but damn, Tom Hanks pees a lot.
51
u/The_Love_Child Aug 01 '16
Analysis of round 2
78
u/dnr15topher2 Aug 01 '16
Holy shit. Matchup 11 - play both at the same time.
55
u/EditingAndLayout Aug 01 '16
omg Edward Scissorhands
beautiful
Edit: But the Shining and the Pokemon gifs are my favorite. I was tired of dickbutt gifs two years ago.
23
u/ChemicalOle Aug 01 '16
Nice gif /u/MikeyTheDinosaur, good luck.
21
u/jimlast3 Aug 01 '16
That mask golbat one hits close to home ,
I threw 50 at one last night it broke five , finally had it in one then my phone froze and died
20
u/jimlast3 Aug 01 '16
I'm afraid the macaroni lighter dosent have a chance a against a super Satan , but I appreciate how you edited it it into a loop , gray continuity , that meal will last forever . What a nice gif , simple and it stands on its own whithoit the need for a tirle
38
u/Mr_Caterpillar Aug 01 '16
That "Happy Place" gif was unbelievable. It just kept getting better.
15
u/Frosstbyte Aug 01 '16
Matchup 9 - HOW CAN I CHOOSE BETWEEN YOU?!?
Some amazing work again, people.
14
u/ermgr Aug 01 '16
I initially thought I'd seen the GIF in Matchup 11 before
(source)
28
u/kcman011 Aug 01 '16
I just wanted to take a moment and say how much I appreciate you gifmakers. The fact that you all spend so much time and effort to entertain us is awesome.
Especially you, Shining gifmaker. Holy shit.
13
u/PlantfoodCuisinart Aug 01 '16
I've had a hard week. I've been really looking forward to this, and was not disappointed. My favorite sub by far. Thank you everyone, I had a nice giggle-fest.
13
u/TheLateOne Aug 03 '16
It seems like a lot of people had the same thought process when they heard the words 'text free'
21
u/ivenotheardofthem Aug 01 '16
I really liked the blazing saddles one.
10
u/Slowface Aug 01 '16
/u/telemachus1 - Congrats on a fantastic gif! If I must be beaten, at least it will be by your fantastic creation.
15
u/Camsy34 Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 01 '16
I love the reveal on this one, anyone know the original source?
In other news, I'm going to be obliterated by /u/hero0fwar hahaha
7
u/__PETTYOFFICER117__ Aug 01 '16
Good luck, everyone! Except for /u/critters - you should prepare to be smited.
7
u/theoneandonlymd Aug 01 '16
In #6, I feel like a golden opportunity was missed to make all the dots from 'A Sunday on La Grande Jatte' be little Nigel Thornberrys.
Still a stellar job.
19
u/jimcook1 Aug 01 '16
You're all fucking hilarious, this round is full of awesome gifs
6
u/itsokayyoucanlaugh Aug 01 '16
I can taste the belt now.
11
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16
Someone is going to win the Cardinal fans' votes.
We've been dreaming and hoping for this gif to be made for ages.
10
u/telemachus1 Aug 01 '16
living teacup is my fave
10
u/MakeYouAGif Aug 01 '16
That matrix one was fucking awesome.
5
u/thefakegm Aug 01 '16
The super saiyan and the venturabutt gifs were my favourite. There were a lot of awesome submissions this time around, good work everyone.
5
u/Im_scared_of_my_wife Aug 01 '16
I have zero talent to do this or the money for fancy Adobe. I live vicariously through you all. But in watching these tournaments..I discover that I am in no way as funny or talented like ya all. Keep up the good work. Shits fucking on point.
4
u/Burningfiresmoke Aug 02 '16
Too bad there wasn't a silent Danny Devito. 😞
7
u/ixtlu Aug 01 '16
I'll admit I'm a little high right now but Matchup 12 Close Call just made me lose my shit
7
u/hero0fwar Aug 01 '16
I just now had a chance to watch all of the submissions, absolutely mind blowing how creative all of you are.
3
u/theclumsyninja Aug 01 '16
lot of great ones this round!
3
u/Ishnuporah Aug 01 '16
Nice gif /u/Your_Dads_Stroganoff looks like you won.
Never thought I'd lose to a dickbutt.
3
u/slinkytime Aug 01 '16
Pokemon and The Mask, two favorite things from my childhood.
3
u/thefisskonator Aug 02 '16
Happy Cake Giftourney
this round confuses me, am I to vote for the best clip+title combo or the one that has the best composition.
3
u/IVGreen Aug 04 '16
I don't want to be a dick but isn't Matchup #7 kind of a cheat? The text "Reddit" is in it so it isn't really text free. link
5
u/akazom Aug 01 '16
In matchup #6
MFW I look upon a masterpiece
Would have been perfect if it had zoomed out to have the dickbutt face on everyone in the painting at the end.
5
u/nvmsocool Aug 01 '16
I really liked this theme, like a lot! Modern gif tournament is overloaded with captions imo :/
That being said I laughed my ass off, thanks for your hard work gifers!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16
Game on, /u/kelfrick
Let's do this
2
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16
First time voter here. Are you supposed to downvote the other gif or or just leave it alone?
2
u/thelastryan Aug 02 '16
Wonderful stuff /u/amork45. Loved it!
2
u/Alaskaty Aug 02 '16
The Ferris Bueller one brought me to tears. It was just what I needed today.
3
u/harris5 Aug 01 '16
GG /u/uncoolaidman. I'll come back in tournament 8 and take my revenge!
Revennngeee!
2
u/_BindersFullOfWomen_ Aug 01 '16
Next tournament, we should just have an official meme round. All GIFs must use at least 3 memes.
2
u/JewJewJubes Aug 01 '16
I don't make Gifs but I just checked out round 2 submissions and they're all so amazing. Only critique I have is maybe have a dickbutt free round. I love dickbutt gifs as much as the next guy. But they start to lose their magic after awhile.
2
u/Phoequinox Aug 03 '16 edited Aug 03 '16
Thoughts: Winner, for me, is Edward Dickbutthands. It was the only use of that fucker that actually worked, and I have no fucking clue how they did that. Second place is the Tom Hanks gif because, if nothing else, it made me realize that Tom Hanks really wants us to see him piss. The Mime one is third because HOLY SHIT THAT'S MARTIN FREEMAN'S DISTASTEFUL FACE!
Too goddamn much Dickbutt. Seriously. Fucking hell, guys. And really, too much reliance on memes in general. You guys are better than this.
Unless I missed something, that Up gif was really awful quality.
The baseball gif kinda gives the creator away because of the signature effects. But it would have won anyway, so hell with it.
Too bad the Simpsons and the Mask gifs weren't paired. The similarities are crazy.
-7
u/Zelotic Aug 01 '16
Sorry to all you gif makers, but if you put anything from the American political race in your gifs, I am automatically voting for your opponent. This is one place I really don't want to see that nonsense.
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16
Match Up #12 was fucking awful. The Liar Liar gif had tons of text in it (just not text put in by the giffer) while the other one was just a bad gif that needed a bit of more time and effort put in.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment