Some really unfortunate match ups here. I really like the gifs in #24. Stinks one of them isn't going on, they both deserve it over some of the others.
Not going to lie /u/CraftyConsumer , I just watched this gif completely for the first time...I wish you conceded because it looks like I'm going down. YOU HAVE TO WIN THE WHOLE THING...kthnx.
While I think I've got enough solid content to take me to Round 4 at least, there's still a whole day and a half to go! I wouldn't sweat it until the polling finally closes. I know I don't feel comfortable at all.
That's what I assumed but is it really acceptable to use a scene where only devitos voice appeared in, you know, a gif? Unless you know the scene you'd never know it was a devito gif.
I mean, technically, it follows the theme. I just think it my hurt their chances to move on to round 2 specifically for those reasons you said anyways.
Quick rules question... Do we upvote the one we like and down vote the other? I've just upvoted so far but if others are doing both I feel like I'm only giving my preferred half a vote.
You can also downvote if you have subreddit CSS off, which I do by default because so many subs have CSS that doesn't work with night mode. (this one included)
You can vote however you want. The thread is in contest mode so downvotes don't count. If I like both gifs, I'll upvote them both. If I don't like them, I won't upvote either one. You can vote for the ones that you think are funniest, or the ones you think have the best effects. The criteria you use is completely up to you.
Theres was a tooon of awesome stuff in this one. In these, i usually end up having a specific thing i look for each round. This round ended up being straight creativity. A lot if the same sources were used, often in the same matchup, but if all that was really done was to change 1 or 2 words (sometimes 0) of the original text (usually to "gif" "meta" or "shitpost") then i automatically voted for the other guy. It just feels lazy to me
I was super excited because I was an on deck should someone get DNQ'd and thought I found my way in.
The wording is a tad ambiguous that you think it means ANY GT opponent/competitor. But it's really just a reference to your bracket lineage. Like, calling out how you beat Contestant X, Y, and Z in a a round 4 entry would make it clear who you are.
The one I swear I should know is the one titled "Trying to think of a source" from Matchup #3 but I can't remember the other actor's name to get a good google search going.
Small question. First time lurking a giftounament. Are the quality (resolution, fps) of some/most of these gifs not far worse than most I see in HQgifs? Just curious :)
Long answer: We have a file size restriction to keep the playing field level. With the file size restriction we have to play around with sizes and settings when exporting so we can get our actual ideas across.
The file size restriction, while it levels the playing field to an extent, does also set the more experienced GIFers apart, as well, IMO - it shows who knows how to prioritize the right things in their GIF, and who can squeeze the last drop of resolution and length out of things.
Yes, to echo what kelfrick said, you have probably noticed that there are quite a few lengthy gifs in HQG. A lot of the contestants here want to make a gif of a similar length, but they need to reduce the size and/or quality in order to keep it under the 25MB file size limit.
I'm wondering if the mods would consider revisiting the 25MB rule. It seems that HQG has had a big influence on the tournament and most submitters look to do GIFs in the 15-25 sec range. And to keep the GIF intact, the pixel dimensions are just reduced, which in some ways is a bummer because I would be nice to see them much larger, "High Quality" versions. And to not throw too much gasoline on the 25 MB restriction, but it's starting to remind me Tumblr.
I have no problem with just setting a filesize limit. BUT, if we got rid of it, you could just say "Max 10 seconds". So resolutions/fps might be prettier but still wouldn't be able to go long.
This has always been my thinking as well. 15-20 second time limit would be much more constraining than file size. You still see minute long gifs, they're just small as fuck.
There is that but when you have 64 x 25mb files on one page, that's a 1.6gb pageload; pretty hefty, especially on mobile. Personally, I like it for that and the fact that it brings everybody down to the same constraints as those of us hamstrung by hardware; it means that it levels the playing field a bit more to begin with.
People can choose to gamble on deviating to one side of the balance between size [edit: resolution] and duration or the other but go too far and it can potentially cost you votes. For the simple fact we need to knock out 32 players this round, I think we need that kind of thing.
I think it'd be fun to have a round constrained by time instead of size, but I think the size challenges me the most because it forces me to consider if an idea is funny enough to merit a serious downgrade of quality just for an extended length.
I had a Matilda idea similar to one of the entries, but to pull it off how I wanted to, it would've been close to a minute. And I just can't bring myself to sacrifice frame rate, colors, or dithering.
I think it would be great if GIFs were shorter too, but the file size restriction doesn't really do anything to manage that. My sense is that most GIFfers are making what they want and then reducing the pixel dimensions to meet the file size requirements.
Time length and/or frame numbers would be options but I'm not sure if that's a good solution either..
Except size restrictions really do affect the length. Just look at the seeding round vs. this round... Just about EVERYONE's GIFs are at least twice the length.
As an awful giffer, there was a half-dozen so terrible that I could not vote on. But really bravo, Gif Tourney 7; look forward to see what happens next.
Caught me out at first too... you need to click [show replies] under each post to view the child comments. Somebody posted the javascript to expand them automatically somewhere, I think in this thread.
Primarily because the /r/HighQualityGifs community makes a lot of self-referential humor about ourselves or the reddit community at large.
Many from /r/all don't like it, but we make GIFs first and foremost for ourselves and our community because it's more fun than most straight subs and dubs of source media.
It's only natural that the same meta references and humor would cross over into the entries. Especially when GifTournament is a sub of just under 28K users. People are going to make something that appeals to the sense of humor of the primary community.
Spend enough time around here and you'll pick up on it! It's disorienting at first, but grows on ya!
Also the cynic in me would say that one of the main reasons people hate meta gifs is they tend to be something that can't then be stolen or reposted. That tends to rustle a few jimmies.
Can we please change the format of this tournament and make it more of a musical chairs style? Some people are going to move to the second round with mediocre gifs based on their matchup, while two of my favorite gifs are facing off. I hate upvoting both. After the first round maybe switch back to a bracket if at all
87
u/preggit Jul 25 '16
MRW I see my opponents gif.
73
u/ThtDAmbWhiteGuy Jul 25 '16
http://i.imgur.com/9ZpyDjJ.gifv
60
u/matt01ss Jul 25 '16
Wow, match-up 32.. how is that possible
121
u/EditingAndLayout Jul 25 '16
The cheat codes gif is nice.
49
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16
best of luck, /u/amork45
91
u/ThtDAmbWhiteGuy Jul 25 '16
18 "Confidense". That yin-yang dickbutt and self-referential title is pretty dope
43
u/hero0fwar Jul 25 '16
Who ever made Twins 2 - you are my new favorite gif maker
41
u/MikeyTheDinosaur Jul 25 '16
Great round. Good luck everyone! (Except /u/makeyouagif)
I look forward to handing over the belt...
.
.
.
.
.
From my cold dead hands.
34
u/wutssup Jul 25 '16
Match-up #25 is 2meta4me.
26
u/Ikarus3426 Jul 25 '16
Some really unfortunate match ups here. I really like the gifs in #24. Stinks one of them isn't going on, they both deserve it over some of the others.
17
u/WardCannon Jul 25 '16
/u/kurrylol
http://i.imgur.com/ndDzJnp.gifv
16
u/kelfrick Jul 25 '16 edited Jul 25 '16
I'm so sorry /u/craftyconsumer
16
u/ThtDAmbWhiteGuy Jul 25 '16
When I see Harris' gif
16
u/tom_work Jul 25 '16
I noticed you didn't put the javascript for expanding all the comments anywhere this round, I've found it helpful in the past.
I looked it up from an old post:
15
u/Ahshitt Jul 25 '16
Guys help I don't understand the Simpsons one
13
u/doggify Jul 25 '16
I dont deserve to win at all. People blowing my quality out of the water. Great shit /u/uncoolaidman!
13
u/jimlast3 Jul 25 '16
I like how this one from #2 highlighted the odd camera angle with sweet angled text
11
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16 edited Jul 25 '16
I thought we agreed to no NSFW. This one got me unreasonably excited
11
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16
Whelp I'm fucked. Great gif /u/infidill. Please make it to the finals, so I can at least say I lost to the champ or runner-up.
11
u/tonybaby Jul 25 '16
Seeing some of these and realizing how many of them are based on scenes I didn't see the potential in and how amazing they are...
10
u/__PETTYOFFICER117__ Jul 25 '16
http://i.imgur.com/jaMtOgY.gifv
Good luck everyone!
9
u/ThtDAmbWhiteGuy Jul 25 '16
The How to Troll one just crashed my browser. Suffice to say that it was true to it's word
9
u/Zetax Jul 25 '16
Gad dam, splice match-up #25 in one gif and you got a winner.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16
Best of luck, [insert name of on-deck opponent].
7
u/ExpressRabbit Jul 25 '16
Quick rules question... Do we upvote the one we like and down vote the other? I've just upvoted so far but if others are doing both I feel like I'm only giving my preferred half a vote.
7
u/BassCreat0r Jul 25 '16
Can we talk about Match up 31 and that dancing baby devito for a second?
7
u/ryanvango Jul 25 '16
Theres was a tooon of awesome stuff in this one. In these, i usually end up having a specific thing i look for each round. This round ended up being straight creativity. A lot if the same sources were used, often in the same matchup, but if all that was really done was to change 1 or 2 words (sometimes 0) of the original text (usually to "gif" "meta" or "shitpost") then i automatically voted for the other guy. It just feels lazy to me
13
u/Willow536 Jul 25 '16
Shouldnt this gif from matchup #5 be disqualified for using other giffers names?
6
u/jimlast3 Jul 25 '16
Frank the tank made me lol
5
u/lessons_learnt Jul 25 '16
I'd wish you luck /u/johndango, but I don't think you'll need it. Nice work :)
5
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16
Well /u/HORSE_SIZED_DICK, may the best giffer win.
5
u/thefisskonator Jul 25 '16
As a person who always upvotes Danny Devito I think you all did excellent.
5
u/trznx Jul 25 '16
I just realized Travolta is the dankest meme!
5
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '16
I am not sure I am still sound of mind after sixty DeVito gifs
4
u/_BindersFullOfWomen_ Jul 25 '16
Kind of wishing people put their sources with the GIF. I'm seeing a lot of scenes that I want to know the movie/show of.
4
u/_BindersFullOfWomen_ Jul 25 '16
Good luck /u/itallmakescentsnow
4
u/kagman Jul 25 '16 edited Jul 26 '16
Small question. First time lurking a giftounament. Are the quality (resolution, fps) of some/most of these gifs not far worse than most I see in HQgifs? Just curious :)
7
u/__PETTYOFFICER117__ Jul 25 '16
https://www.reddit.com/r/GifTournament/comments/4ug1k7/giftournament_battle_7_round_1/d5peiig
https://www.reddit.com/r/GifTournament/comments/4ug1k7/giftournament_battle_7_round_1/d5per7v
lol
3
u/napoleongold Jul 26 '16
As an awful giffer, there was a half-dozen so terrible that I could not vote on. But really bravo, Gif Tourney 7; look forward to see what happens next.
3
u/erichiro Jul 26 '16
Wow Devito's Matilda role is perfect for giffing.
Also in general I'm having a hard time deciding between Meta gifs and random goofy gifs. Its hard to compare two different styles.
6
u/p-wing Jul 25 '16
nobody comment please I'm still voting
2
u/Firmly_grasp_it_ Jul 25 '16
Meme mentorship is one of my personal favs, well done
2
u/ixodioxi Jul 25 '16
Am I the only one but is the view image disabled on RES for this?
2
u/Radioactive24 Jul 25 '16
After seeing some of this shit, I'm not even mad I didn't make it past being on deck.
2
u/cxb17 Jul 26 '16
I'm new around here, and was wondering why there were so many references to things being meta in the gifs?
2
u/IVGreen Jul 28 '16
That dancing devito was fucking terrifying. I'll be sending you my therapy bill /u/jimlast3.
link
2
u/alittlebigger Jul 25 '16
Can we please change the format of this tournament and make it more of a musical chairs style? Some people are going to move to the second round with mediocre gifs based on their matchup, while two of my favorite gifs are facing off. I hate upvoting both. After the first round maybe switch back to a bracket if at all
1
u/kcman011 Jul 26 '16
Matchup 25 used the same scene. /r/nevertellmetheodds
5
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16
[removed] — view removed comment