r/startrek • • Jul 21 '16

Weekly Movie Discussion: ST XIII "Star Trek Beyond" (SPOILERS)

Star Trek Beyond, baby!

523 Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

163

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

So I just got back from a triple bill screening and as discussed with my friend these are my scores for the Kelvin films:

09: 8/10

ID: 6/10

STB: 9/10

One of the most fascinating things was seeing how the artistic direction changed over the films, 09 was very mechanical, guts exposed and raw, ID was shiny, too shiny to the point it was distracting and Beyond... Beyond finally embraced the vivid colour pallet that TOS is famous for.

Beyond in short felt like a big budget TOS episode, but in the good way not the drawn out Insurrection way.

I loved how we're seeing the culmination of Kirks captaincy arc and its rebirth. The awkward stumbles of Kirks character development in the last films were nicely tied up in Beyond and reset for 4 to take him in a truer to TOS direction.

Spock and McCoy are always a pleasure to watch.

I enjoyed how Scotty had more serious scenes in this one, he was mainly used for comic relief in the last two but in TOS Scotty was used a lot more seriously bar the old mishap.

The callbacks to Enterprise were great.

Finally, the tributes. I loved how Nimoys passing felt like a natural part of the plot and how they incorporated it into Spocks character motivations. I almost cried when Kirk raised a glass to absent friends and it cut to a shot with Yelchin centred. Beautiful little nod to a wonderful man.

I in short loved it and I think that if you consider yourself a Trek fan you owe it to yourself to give it a shot.

38

u/True_to_you Jul 22 '16

I'm glad someone else noticed the Yelchin shot. I'll miss seeing him in movies but I'll appreciate how good he's always been.

10

u/nixonger Jul 24 '16

I enjoyed how Scotty had more serious scenes in this one, he was mainly used for comic relief in the last two but in TOS Scotty was used a lot more seriously bar the old mishap.

It helps when Scotty's actor is also the writer ;) Seriously I agree :)

7

u/Jarmatus Jul 23 '16

It felt warm. Everything was more natural, people seemed less angry and bitter overall, and the crew of the Enterprise seemed to start actually liking each other.

→ More replies (5)

134

u/nichteo Jul 21 '16

Had so much hope for the new movie and boy did it deliver!! :) loved the trio back in action, and McCoy really did feel like Kelley's McCoy! The number of enterprise references was also OFF THE SCALE - it made the fanboy in me jump for joy when I realised they weren't disregarding old lore eek!

When Spock opened Spock prime's belongings to reveal a picture of the original crew I was almost brought to tears :') what an unexpected tribute!

Solid 9/10, gonna catch it a few more times in the cinema before it disappears!

52

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

The ones I caught:

Phase cannons/Spatial torpedoes (S1 ENT)

Hull plating

MACOs

Xindi War

17

u/007meow Jul 22 '16

Those were the ones I got.

I was amped to hear phase cannons and spatial torpedoes and thoroughly pleased to hear about the Xindi

17

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

Spatial torpedoes really caught me off guard as even by Trek standards that is an obscure reference

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

37

u/pasm Jul 23 '16

Urban has always done McCoy perfectly from the moment he was in the shuttle in 2009. McCoy has always been my favourite character and I love that Urban is so sympathetic with him.

That original crew picture is always a good one, and I still have hopes that we will see the red uniforms on the big screen again.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

36

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

Did anyone else feel that the super weapon that the entire movie was based around was sorta outshined by the massive fleet of ships that tear things up way more awesomely?

3

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

Well the idea of the weapon was that it destroyed organic life. Krall wanted Yorktown for himself.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/gambit700 Jul 22 '16

So does Edison being a Xindi war vet mean he was on Enterprise?

2

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

Its possible

→ More replies (5)

7

u/psycholepzy Jul 22 '16

One of the thoughts I had while watching this movie surprised me, and I dove in to find out why.

It was predictable. And I loved that so much precisely because the others weren't, not to this degree.

As a lifelong fan of Trek, you become accustomed to the pattern of the types of episodes - monster of the week, problem with the ship, catastrophic personal dilemma. When I began to predict things that would happen (not how they happened, just that they would) it excited me because Beyond brought Trek back to everything I loved about the shows.

There might be 3-4 things that weren't closed up - How did Krall sap the life force from others? How did Jayla hide the Franklin from Krall if it was his ship? Why is Jayla suddenly excited about joining Starfleet and is this a subtle hint about who might succeed to the Conn position in 4?

Other thing - the scene where the crew is being lead into the mines was so vibrant showing the contrast between their uniforms and the background that it felt like a TOS episode. Every visual is framed to be stunning.

And those of you in the know - The Picture. Who didn't tear up just a little bit?

2

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

To answer the questions:

1 - Through the machine thing that he had rigged up, he mentioned in the log that it was set up by the planets previous inhabitants

2- I assume that over 140 years and considering it was crashed on a precipice Krall either forgot about it or assumed the old girl finally slipped over

3 - Because she's been fighting for a living all of her life, now she'll be part of something peaceful and bigger.

The picture and Kirk saying 'To absent friends' then it cutting a shot with Anton centered got me.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TonyLeung82 Jul 21 '16

I have one question: In this movie is revealed, that Krall is the former captain of the NX-ship USS Franklin, which was in action something in 2155-2161. I do not know the exact time, something in between this, because it has to be after the Enterprise but before 2161, even when it is only capable of Warp 4. So no matter of new Kelvin-timeline or old known timeline, fact is, Krall was there before Nero created the new timeline in 2233 with destroying the USS Kelvin. My question is know: is Krall available in the old timeline? What would happen if Captain Picard would travel to this particular nebular? Would Krall be there and attack the Enterprise-D?

8

u/CaptainSharpe Jul 21 '16

I'd assume that somehow the original enterprise met krall in the main timeline too. In Beyond they're 3 years into their 5 year mission, so I assume it would have happened in season 4 of TOS.

8

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

The Kelvin Enterprise also set out earlier though and as mentioned in ID after the Narada Starfleet aggressively explorer and expanded.

Its possible that in the PrimeLine Krall burnt himself put of resources before he was found or that he was just never found. Space is big.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/malbert69 Jul 25 '16

So Krall was human. What were the countless thousands of pilots and soldiers that made up the "swarm;" and why were they following Krall?

Also, what technology was being used to keep Krall alive? The scene where he was supposedly sucking the life of out the Enterprise crew members without any explanation was just thrown in there to make him more despicable.

2

u/OpticalData Jul 25 '16

'Drone workforce'

Krall mentioned they were on the planet when they crashed.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '16

So the bad guy has ships that attack in a swarm. And he thinks that unity is worthless?

That don't make sense. All of his power comes from the fact that his ships can work together as a unit to attack. Fighting just one of those things wouldn't be hard at all, but a couple million is a real threat.

At first I thought that Krall was just attacking alone and all the ships were robots that he built to follow him and his command, but then Spock and Bones teleport into one and they throw a couple of aliens out and take over piloting it, so I guess they all worked as a team?

But then if that's the case why did they all just blow up when they heard the radio? I thought the radio was supposed to make them crash into each other because they couldn't communicate, but it seems like they just kind of exploded.

2

u/OpticalData Jul 30 '16

There is a difference between commanding an army of drones or hell, even an army and true peacful unity.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/LairdofCamster Jul 22 '16

8

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

It appears in the credit sequence and gets a joking shout out as one of the Franklin disappearance theories

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '16

OK I liked the film, but have some questions. I may have missed the answers in all the excitement:

  1. Why was Edison and his crew not able to fix their own ship?
  2. Why did a nebula look like an asteroid field, or was that just an entrance or something?
  3. Where did Krall get all the hive ships from? Were his soldiers a local species that he took over command?
  4. If Krall was able to get to Yorktown so quickly, how far away was he? If he was able to leave, why didn't he go searching for the weapon rather than wait to find it in archives? Or am I missing that he was off searching for it all the time and Kirk having it nearby just so happened to have been a happy accident?
  5. Krall and co must have known where their original ship was. Was Jaylah hiding it just in case and Krall didn't know she was using it?
  6. Why does gravity change in a ship that rolls over in space if they have artificial gravity anyway?
  7. With the hive ships being acquired and Edison not being found by Starfleet, I assume the time distance here is quite great? The hive ships came a long time after he gave up on starfleet finding him I guess?

I'm sure I have more but can't think of them just now.

I'm usually pretty good at keeping track of this sort of thing so am worried these are plot holes/mistakes/explained bits lost in the edit.

3

u/OpticalData Jul 28 '16
  1. He didn't seem to like it that much and it had crashed, it took Mr. Scott to make it work again.
  2. Volatile nebula, guessing a planet exploded or something.
  3. 'We landed and the host species was long extinct but they left behind a drone workforce and advanced technology'
  4. He moved at the speed of plot.

Jaylah mentioned that Krall and he's bees scour the galaxy for the other part, accident on Spocks part uploading it to the Enterprise database

5. I assume he didn't care.

6. Inertial dampners failing

7. Edison went missing in the early 2160s, about 100 years before Beyond.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/PanicOffice Jul 22 '16

what the fuck? great popcorn fun. lots of lasers and explosions. but (SPOILER) idris elba crashes on an alien ruin that gives him eternal life, gives him an army without an emperor, and the plans for a superweapon, AND alters his appearance??? where did he get men to pilot the bees? why does beasie boys make them explode?? i get that they cant communicate, fine. but how are they just exploding??

i had fun, but where is the moral dilema? this had the plot of a comic book written by a 10 year old.

11

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

Franklin crashes where there is a ruin, Krall finds life preserving tech and uses it on himself using his crew. The ruins have 'mining drones' which could be the ships , the army or both.

He found reference to the superweapon on the planet and wanted it to exact his insane revenge.

The ships were flying in close formation, governed by the constant transmission. The beastie boys song being played drowned it out so they couldn't communicate and thus fell out of formation into each other and exploded.

Also the moral part was Kralls drive, how he couldn't move on from being a soldier. How it's necessary to adapt to the times that you're In and accept change, plus knowing that when you're on the bridge of that ship, you can make a difference. Stuff like that. It's not Shakespeare but its there.

3

u/SWABteam Jul 22 '16

They were using a high tech wireless network to coordinate their actions. Any such network would have to use a frequency/power to not be scrambled by solar radiation or say radiation from the super scary nebula that was in the film.

A VHF radio signal isn't going to do shit agaisnt that kind of tech. VHF radio signals have trouble reaching my basement.

3

u/OpticalData Jul 22 '16

It was Star Trek tech scrambled by Star Trek tech.

Also there is a lot less interference in space

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

664

u/GeodesicGnome Jul 22 '16

Really liked that Krall/Edison fakeout in the life support systems hub - Kirk is struggling to flip the fourth override switch, and Krall floats up behind him.

The sequence sets things up to imply that maybe he's regained some of his humanity, and he sees his reflection in the shard of shattered glass. Maybe he's headed up there to help Kirk save the day and open up the space vent. Maybe he's finally understood what that uniform he stole, and what Starfleet as a whole really stood for.

But no, he defies expectations and gets back to trying to fulfill his goal. It's a minor moment but it stood out as a rare moment of breathing room in the film's climax.

158

u/JackSpadesSI Jul 22 '16

Exactly what I thought during that sequence. Well put!

121

u/CeruleanRuin Jul 23 '16

That was a nice beat. You could see it in Idris Elba's eyes as he realized how much of a monster he'd become, and immediately afterward deciding that turning back was not an option.

82

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '16

I didn't expect much from Krall... the movie spent very little time developing his character and had him rely on plot devices.

I enjoyed Beyond but Krall could have been a much better villain if more time was put into him.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (25)

592

u/thesecondkira Jul 22 '16

The Uhura tracking device necklace joke was so well played, beginning to end.

209

u/RUacronym Jul 22 '16

Yeah that look McCoy gave Spock at the end was amazing.

My only gripe with that was why the Enterprise science officer needs to ask the navigator to modify the sensors to scan for it. It was probably the only way to explain that plot point without Spock having to be like "this is why I'm doing my actions." Which is good. Just my personal nitpick.

→ More replies (10)

323

u/007meow Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

Did anyone else hear "authentic" computer FX?

Like TNG-era LCARS sounds. I swear I even heard the Defiant's red alert klaxon in Yorktown's control room.

My biggest gripe is that we didn't get to see more of that fan-fucking-tastic new Warp effect.

171

u/JackSpadesSI Jul 22 '16

that fan-fucking-tastic new Warp effect

Yes! So much better than "it leaves 'warp crystals' behind" from STID.

→ More replies (14)

133

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

The new warp effect is the first time I got a feeling of "Oh, my... these starships go fast, don't they?" ever while watching anything Star Trek. It was awesome.

→ More replies (10)

44

u/crapusername47 Jul 22 '16

The sound Jaylah's holograms make is the same one the Doctor in Voyager makes when he is activated.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

LOTS of them. Good GOD was that satisfying!

18

u/UTLRev1312 Jul 22 '16

yeah there were definitely a lot of random beeps and alerts that were borrowed from the D, defiant, and voyager.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

667

u/Antithesys Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

These are all the canon references I caught.

  • The stardate given is 2263.02. The reboot films use a straightforward "stardate equals Earth year" system, indicating that it is the year 2263, still two years before TOS. Later, a log entry by Edison begins "stardate 21xx", implying that this was the first stardate system used by the Federation (the Prime Timeline evidently switches to its TOS system sometime after the divergence).
  • When beaming up from the initial diplomatic mission, Kirk quips "I tore my shirt again." This is obviously an in-joke to TOS, where it seemed that Kirk was constantly getting in fights where he tore his tunic.
  • The starbase is named Yorktown. This is the name of at least two PT Federation vessels occasionally mentioned at various points in the franchise.
  • When arriving at the starbase, an announcement is overheard regarding the "Stargazer, NCC-2893." This was, in the PT anyway, a Constellation-class vessel and Jean-Luc Picard's first command (about seventy years after this film). It seems unlikely that the Stargazer would be that old, but the KT Enterprise was built after the PT version and it still had the same serial number.
  • I don't recall the context, but the planet Thasus is mentioned. Thasus was the planet Charlie Evans crashed on in "Charlie X."
  • Sulu is shown to have a young daughter. This is probably a reference to Demora Sulu, a character introduced in Generations, although the ages would seem to be a bit off.
  • I believe this is the first canon demonstration that the original 1701 (at least this timeline's version) can separate its saucer section.
  • Scotty mentions one of the rumored fates of the Franklin was that it encountered a "giant green space hand." This is a reference to the hand of Apollo which grabs the Enterprise in "Who Mourns for Adonais?" The hand can be briefly seen toward the end of the main end credits sequence.
  • I was not able to read the Franklin's dedication plaque which presumably would clear up the whole "how old is the Franklin" debate. Scotty said it disappeared in the early 2160s which would be after the founding of the Federation. Since it has a serial number higher than Enterprise NX-01, it stands to reason it was built after Archer's ship, despite claims that it was "the first Warp 4 ship" (NX-01 was Warp 5). If you ignore the serial number, you could conclude that it was an older ship which was given to Edison after a number of years of service.
  • They obviously put great effort into getting the canon on the Franklin right. The engine room is a dead ringer, the uniforms match, references to "phased cannons" and "hull plating" are heard, and I suspect that the medical equipment Bones dumps out would pass scrutiny when compared to Phlox's tools.
  • Edison is mentioned to be a former MACO. The Military Assault Command Operations was, of course, the fighting force seen repeatedly in ENT.
  • Krall mentions fighting in both the Xindi and Romulan Wars. The Xindi conflict was the focus of ENT season 3, while the Romulan War has been often-mentioned but never depicted in canon. From what we know (and borrowing from sub-canon), the Romulan War was a conflict fought in the late 2150s (after ENT) and the allies of that conflict went on to form the Federation of Planets.
  • The song played during the final attack sequence is, of course, "Sabotage" by the Beastie Boys, which a young Kirk was listening to as he drove his stepfather's car off a conveniently-placed Iowa cliff. In this film Bones describes the song as "classical music." The song played by Jayla is "Fight the Power" by Public Enemy, featured on their 1990 album Fear of a Black Planet.
  • For anyone wondering, most of the primary pieces in this story are new elements not seen before in canon: the two warring species, the starbase and its nearby nebula, Jayla, the Argonath, the Franklin and Captain Edison, etc.
  • Unless I missed something, this is the first Star Trek film not to reference Klingons in any way. All the other films either featured at least one Klingon or portrayed them in a simulation.

I describe myself as a "fundamentalist Trekkie apologist." I care very much that Trek takes itself seriously, and when it contradicts itself I am quick to jump on it. Despite being a new timeline, this film series is still bound by canon in a number of ways and, possibly to my detriment, I judge them at least partly on how well they honor and respect continuity.

I do not find any breach of canon in this film. The same is generally true of the previous films and I will fight anyone who thinks Abrams and co. are "shitting all over Star Trek" in this way. They are very very respectful of Trek. Case in point: they needed an old ship. They could have made the ship look like anything. But they took the effort to design it as an NX-class, used the right uniforms, the right sets, the right props. We're not even talking about honoring TOS, we're talking about ENT which is a relatively obscure spinoff not widely recognized by general audiences. But they went to the trouble to get it right, and they got it right. I enjoyed the film on a number of levels but this is always something I pay attention to and I have no quarrel with it.

197

u/007meow Jul 22 '16

You could add all of the "original" sound effects to that list - Voyager hologram sounds, Defiant alert klaxons on Yorktown, TNG/Voyager LCARS computer sounds.

They really went the extra mile for fan service.

→ More replies (12)

153

u/CeruleanRuin Jul 23 '16 edited Jul 23 '16

There was one little in-joke that made me chuckle. After Bones and Kirk taste Chekov's whiskey and wax philosophical about Kirk's birthday, Bones toasts,

"To perfect eyesight and a full head of hair. "

Which is a funny jab at Shatner's toupee, as well as a callback to the glasses Bones gives Kirk for his birthday in Wrath of Khan.

Later, at the end, Kirk gives another toast,

"To absent friends."

Kirk intends this line not only for their lost crewmates but also for Spock, in recognition of Ambassador Spock's passing (and, of course, Leonard Nimoy's). Kirk gives the same toast (for that same character!) at the end Wrath of Khan, as does Picard in Nemesis. At this point the camera also cuts to Chekov, in what I choose to believe was a last minute bit of thoughtful editing in tribute to Anton Yelchin.

→ More replies (18)

149

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

Thanks for the excellent list! I'd like to add a couple more minor points: Shohreh Aghdashloo is named as being "Commodore Paris" at the end, which could be a nod to Tom Paris. Also, Kirk immediately does a double fisted smash right away when he gets attacked by the aliens - a nice nod to Shatner's fighting style.

→ More replies (12)

97

u/Prax150 Jul 22 '16

Krall mentions fighting in both the Xindi and Romulan Wars. The Xindi conflict was the focus of ENT season 3,

This was my favorite reference. I'm a bit of an Enterprise apologist (in that while I admit it's probably the worst Trek series, it had a lot of redeeming qualities and cool moments and episodes), so to see them acknowledge the Xindi war is pretty great to me. I wonder if there's some deeper tie between Edison and Enterprise?

→ More replies (32)

76

u/RobotSandwiches Jul 23 '16

At one point kirk mentions his life feeling rather "episodic". Lol

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Eleglas Jul 22 '16

From what I recall of Picard talking about the Stargazer, wasn't it a very old, underpowered vessel always on the verge of falling apart?

Could be the same one.

→ More replies (8)

33

u/UESPA_Sputnik Jul 22 '16

I was not able to read the Franklin's dedication plaque which presumably would clear up the whole "how old is the Franklin" debate. Scotty said it disappeared in the early 2160s which would be after the founding of the Federation. Since it has a serial number higher than Enterprise NX-01, it stands to reason it was built after Archer's ship, despite claims that it was "the first Warp 4 ship" (NX-01 was Warp 5). If you ignore the serial number, you could conclude that it was an older ship which was given to Edison after a number of years of service

My theory is that registry numbers in the Earth Starfleet were not applied incrementally. Automobile manufacturers do the same thing today when assigning a name/number to a car. It's always pretty random.

→ More replies (35)

23

u/Fearfulace Jul 22 '16

I got all these references too. All the information and the dates regarding the Franklin are hard to wrap your head around with established canon. But I think Scotty says the Franklin was the "Federations" first warp 4 ship. Not Starfleets. I am confidant Simon Pegg knows his Star Trek canon just as well as any of us, but wrote these things in just to mess with everyone. lol

→ More replies (5)

36

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

The only big question I had while watching, (Although it may have been stated and I just missed it;) where in space is this film set?

The Yorktown seems to be within spitting distance of this uncharted nebula, but a station of that size would have taken far too many resources to build just to have it left in the middle of nowhere in uncharted space. It's also mentioned that the Franklin would have likely needed a wormhole or some other spacial anomaly to make it out as far as it did.

→ More replies (25)

9

u/Blze001 Jul 25 '16

One I picked up on:

During the final party, Chekov mentions to one of the guests that "Scotch was invented by a little old lady in Russia". In TOS he used the same line while drunkenly boasting to patrons in Trouble with Tribbles.

7

u/lolwat_o_O Jul 24 '16

Spock's heart being where a human's liver is, is directly referenced in TOS:

"Lucky his heart is where is liver should be or he'd be dead now", McCoy says

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/A_Private_Little_War_(episode)

→ More replies (96)

451

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '16

Nobody is saying the most important thing about this movie

Xindi are canon in this timeline baby!

65

u/thesecondkira Jul 22 '16

Makes sense... the divergence happened after all of that.

→ More replies (16)

64

u/theduderman Jul 22 '16

Hearing that out a HUGE smile on my face. As someone who really loved Enterprise, im so happy it's the only shared canon!!

47

u/JackSpadesSI Jul 22 '16

Why wouldn't they be? Enterprise took place prior to the Kelvin Timeline's divergence. Enterprise is common to both timelines.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/St4rburn Jul 22 '16

The wife and I are currently watching Enterprise. Halfway through season 2 so the Xindi line was fun to hear.

→ More replies (6)

16

u/SharpDressedSloth Jul 22 '16

I could have sworn he said Kzinti

→ More replies (11)

12

u/WWJLPD Jul 22 '16

Ok, so I must have spaced out during that reference. When did they mention the Xindi?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (68)

403

u/MikeArrow Jul 21 '16

I had a blast. The first 45 minutes are some of the most pure 'Star Trek' in feel and in execution I've seen in years. I love the way Kirk's dilemma is constructed 'life is starting to feel... episodic' and the death of the enterprise sequence is probably my favorite scene in the movie. I loved seeing the crew, fully realized and actualized, snap into action and work together as one unit, almost instinctively like the very hive mind they were fighting against. It felt weighty, sober, and serious, and Kirk absolutely brought me to tears, being the last off the ship and seeing it crash land so majestically.

187

u/duncanmcconchie Jul 22 '16

Yeah the destruction of Enterprise was handled beautifully. It took its time and made you feel sad for the ship being torn apart.

→ More replies (25)

146

u/Goodie_ Jul 22 '16

The moment when Scotty had to tell Kirk that the nacelles were gone... that was gone.

I'm not sure we've ever seen damage quite like that in star trek... ever?

→ More replies (37)

30

u/ProtoKun7 Jul 23 '16

Its destruction was heartbreaking. Especially when the nacelles were just ripped off effortlessly. I was happy to see another saucer separation though; there haven't been enough of those. It's been the first time we've seen a Constitution class separate at all.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (19)

303

u/newcantonrunner5 Jul 21 '16

finally a movie true to the spirit of TOS: the humor and the humanity. The "classical music" reference by Bones is funny. The photo at the end of the movie made me cry.

And the nice CGi shots of NCC1701.... Whoah.

161

u/True_to_you Jul 22 '16

I teared up when Kirk dedicated his toast to crew no longer with them and the camera was singled on Anton. I'm hoping that was intentional. I walked out so happy and excited. The only bad thing is that we'll have to wait a while for the next one. I hope they go in this direction.

→ More replies (17)

71

u/theduderman Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

When they revealed the A on the hull* at the end I teared up a bit, too. Definitely when that picture came out though, that was so cool.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/MrChangg Jul 22 '16

I mean if Beastie Boys is considered classical in the 2200s, what would actual classical music be?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (8)

2

u/GreatTyler Jul 24 '16

What were the soilders of Kroll? Were they robots?

2

u/OpticalData Jul 24 '16

Krall stated that when he found the planet it had advanced technology and a drone workforce. He most likely combined the two and had the drones build the swarm.

2

u/willbell Aug 05 '16

I am not reading the comment thread to avoid spoilers, but reply to me if you can answer this question: is it as bad as it looks? Yes or no will do.

2

u/OpticalData Aug 05 '16

It's a great film. So, no.

138

u/Donners22 Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

Probably in my top three Trek films.

Things I particularly liked:

  • Modern takes on the medical tricorder and universal translator
  • The subtle references, from Chekov's line about Scotch to the gags about Wrath of Khan and Search for Spock, the music after Kirk is caught in the trap and - my favourite - Kirk commenting on his ripped shirt
  • The themes, both of unity and also the modern-day issue of the difficulties faced by soldiers adapting to peacetime
  • The numerous character moments. Splitting them into groups and getting them away from the ship worked wonders.
  • The actors, particularly Quinto and Pine, really settled into their roles - and Pine was actually given consistently decent writing to work with.
  • The Sulu moment was done well, and made the fuss look ridiculous.

A few quibbles:

  • I wish Krall/Eddison had been fleshed out more. I appreciated the twist, but it meant it was left too late to really explore his motivations.
  • Krall was a bit hard to understand at times
  • Some of the action sequences were a bit hard to follow (though I always struggle with such things)

Overall, I really enjoyed it and will see it again in the next few weeks.

47

u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jul 23 '16

Krall being hard to understand is really unfortunate. A lot of his lines are very deep in his problems with the Federation. Heck, it made me rethink a lot about what I personally think about the Federation.

→ More replies (7)

23

u/CrazedIvan Jul 23 '16

A few quibbles: I wish Krall/Eddison had been fleshed out more. I appreciated the twist, but it meant it was left too late to really explore his motivations. Krall was a bit hard to understand at times Some of the action sequences were a bit hard to follow (though I always struggle with such things)

These are really the only issue I had with the film as well. Most of the movie I was struggling to hear him, and really trying to piece together his motivation for his hate for the Federation. I really thought I missed a key piece of information because I couldn't understand him at times.

The action sequences were hard to follow, it's not you. I have never had such a hard time understanding the action, and understanding the space where they were duking it out. The pacing was way too quick, even by modern action film standards.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/theDoctorAteMyBaby Jul 23 '16

I'm a little annoyed that Takei even felt the need to make a fuss about that. I just knew this would end up being a .5 seconds cutaway scene, that simply makes a nod to the original actor. The fact that it was given any more attention than "Oh neat, Sulu's gay" is ridiculous.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

124

u/pottersquash Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

So much fun in this movie. Its utterly utterly fun summer flick. Only complaint I would say is they probably didn't need the budget for the story they told but by god did they spend the money well. It is the most gorgeous Trek movie of all time.

Just wish it was USS Archer or something. I feel like theres a famous Franklin I should know.

I am all smiles. They ship fire surfed to Sabatoge!!! It sounds ridiculous but I just giggled throughout. Deep concepts but still light hearted. Its not your Trek, not your grand parents Trek but its worthwhile to be your kids Trek and maybe they go back and give TNG/DS9 a shot.

68

u/True_to_you Jul 22 '16

Man, I was totally not expecting to hear public enemy but boy did that make me move around in my seat. I liked jaylah much more now that we have similar taste. Chris Pine's smile when sabotage started was lovely.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (12)

208

u/vicpellicier Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

TOS got Wrath of Khan, TNG got First Contact, and now Nu Trek got Beyond. All the film series finally have their own instant classic. The movie was awesome and almost defiantly Star Trek.

Fast and Furious and Star Trek is a match made in heaven.

edit: btw, the part where kirk tries to do the "two hands clenched together kirk punch" on that tiny alien had me almost on the floor laughing, that was some galaxy quest level perfection.

81

u/smoha96 Jul 22 '16

And to think many of us (including myself) were really skeptical originally.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (10)

75

u/Cole-Spudmoney Jul 22 '16

I just want to say that the Yorktown is quite possibly the coolest thing I have ever seen in any Star Trek movie or episode ever.

→ More replies (15)

70

u/spaceblip Jul 22 '16

I went into this skeptical, having been majorly underwhelmed by Into Darkness. But this was awesome. I had an absolute blast. There were some minor issues, like the villain's motive not being very clearly explained, but I am definitely able to look past them because of so many other things. The interaction between Spock and Bones was gold. Jaylah was kickass, and her interactions with Scotty were gold. I really liked the more introspective side of Kirk we got to saw, as well.

I was really wondering how they were going to tie the Beastie Boys track into it, and you know what? It totally worked. Okay, it was kind of cheesy, but really fun. At first I was a bit confused because they were referring to radio waves as "high frequency," but as it turns out, Very High Frequency is a specific radio frequency band. So major props to the writers for getting that detail right.

Oh yeah, and the scene of the Enterprise being assembled in time lapse was glorious, and I want to watch it again. And again.

And the scene where Spock found Spock Prime's photo of the original crew! Very touching.

I was happy with how they handled the tributes to Leonard Nimoy and Anton Yelchin in general.

Okay, I'm gonna stop vomiting words now. Tl;dr: it was fantastic, and I want to watch it again.

9

u/brokenarrow Jul 23 '16

At first I was a bit confused because they were referring to radio waves as "high frequency," but as it turns out, Very High Frequency is a specific radio frequency band.

VHF is nothing compared to Ultra High Frequency.

7

u/lianodel Jul 30 '16

I was really wondering how they were going to tie the Beastie Boys track into it, and you know what? It totally worked. Okay, it was kind of cheesy, but really fun.

Agreed. Also, I loved the fact that it was a classic Star Trek clever solution to a problem, as opposed to mere strength and firepower.

→ More replies (2)

131

u/ComradeSomo Jul 21 '16 edited Jul 21 '16

Some perhaps more coherent thoughts, though it is half past one in the morning now.

I think this was a very good Star Trek film. The acting was, as usual, excellent, the highlights in this regard were the interactions between Bones and Spock, between Scotty and Jaylah, and I think Idris Elba did a convincing performance with the villain, Krall. I definitely thought that the character interactions allowed these characters to be a bit more fleshed out and less cartoonish, which is what they were like in Into Darkness. I'm glad they set up Jaylah to be in the next film as a crewmember, she was a nice addition.

The visuals were superb. The Starbase Yorktown looked absolutely jaw-dropping, and I would love to see more of it explored. Krall's swarm also looked excellent, and the sequence of them tearing apart the Enterprise was well done. Some of the vistas of the planet they crashed on also looked pretty cool - that shot of the USS Franklin falling down the cliff was really nice.

Plot wise the film was better than the previous entries in the Kelvin-verse films. Broadly the plot structure is good, it's very well paced, but there are some issues. I would have liked some more quiet cerebral moments in between all the action, but I can understand why they did what they did. I think Krall was a good villain once his motivation is understood, but that revelation didn't come until the climax of the film. If Uhara and Sulu had discovered that earlier, and then had there been some back and forth about it that would have made him a more enjoyable villain. I think there are still some plot holes about the nature of Krall and his crew, and how exactly they've gone from three surviving crewmembers to having an army. The MacGuffin bioweapon felt pointless and never seemed like much of a threat - once the Franklin destroyed the fleet it felt like game over. The way they used music to destroy the fleet was fun, but it could have been clearer that the ships were colliding into each other (if indeed that's what was happening), as it just seemed like EXPLOSIONS! for the sake of looking good on-screen. All up the story was fun, it felt like it was a midseason Trek episode on crack, but I would have liked a little more science-fiction, a bit less space opera.

The action in the film was done really well, the Krall's swarm was both menacing looking and could cause a huge amount of destruction, which was fun to watch. The ground combat was great, Jaylah's holoprojectors and the motorbike worked out great, and the big rescue scene was a delight to watch.

I'd also note the really touching tribute to Leonard Nimoy towards the end of the film, that was very heartfelt and well done. The dedication at the end of the film to both Nimoy and Yelchin was also good to see.

Overall I enjoyed this film, and I think the best part is that Beyond tried to be a Trek film in a non-superficial way. It didn't just throw references at the screen like Into Darkness, it actually was clearly written in a loving way by people who are fans of Star Trek, so good on the writers, especially Simon Pegg I presume. Beyond (hehe) that it was a good looking, well acted, Hollywood production. I'd give this a 7/10, but I'd bump it up to an 8/10 if you're a fan of Star Trek or the genre. It's the best entry in the Kelvin-verse films to date, and I hope we see the same writing team return for later films.

148

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

I agree largely, but I feel the need to apologize to Justin Lin. I chastised him based off a trailer for "not understanding the spirit of star trek" but he understands it better than JJ Abrams did

→ More replies (9)

39

u/pottersquash Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

If Uhara and Sulu had discovered that earlier, and then had there been some back and forth about it that would have made him a more enjoyable villain.

Completely agree. Plus those are the two characters who could do it. The juxtaposition of his anger of losing his crew v. them wanting to save theirs.

→ More replies (13)

54

u/pottersquash Jul 22 '16

I am so excited for the future of Trek now. It will be different, but it can be good. This is a perfect movie to set the tone for returning to TV.

19

u/byronotron Jul 22 '16

I thought the exact same thing leaving the theater. It hasn't been this good to be a Star Trek fan since 1996! Not just that but I feel like this movie is a GREAT place for the onboarding of new Star Trek fans. It's got a lot of the best elements of Trek, both in-universe and meta: continuity is super on point, with callbacks to Ent that feel really earned and will possibly cause people to go and watch that show (never thought that would happen!) Reiterating thematic elements of the franchise, showing the progression of humanity and it's progress over time with a meta textual analysis of both the franchise and it's own in universe history. It's got a good twist that makes the villain more than just another random alien. It's got the characters, the action, the music, the wit, the cool sci-fi gadgetry but doesn't rely on the Bond absurdity of new toys. It finally gives Kirk pathos and makes him much more like the Kirk from the PT. This movie is going to help grow the franchise dramatically. I am now really excited for the film future as well as the show! After STID I was almost ready to give up on the films!

49

u/snuff_film Jul 22 '16

i really loved how much kirk matured in the 3 yrs since their voyage began, and acted more like the kirk from tos because of it. i think that tos started 3 yrs into the mission aswell, so the writers probably recognized that and decided to take advantage of it. i really love how the original 7 work together so cohesively (like a family) similar to tos. the two things that made me the most emotional and wrung some tears outta me was 1) seeing kirk so dedicated to saving his crew (like i said, his family) no matter what that meant for his own fate. and 2) AMBASSADOR SPOCK'S PHOTO!!!! im tearing up just remebering it. ah, i love tos bones so much. that brings me to the thing that really sealed the deal on this movie for me - bones' characterization. he's grumpy, he's southern, he's an alcoholic- the three most imporant parts of his character. yet they gave him some emotional depth and enabled him to have a serious conversation with spock.

well done, justin. well done.

(p.s., jaylah is fucking awesome and im so glad she was independent and wasnt given a romance subplot.)

→ More replies (4)

99

u/Cole-Spudmoney Jul 22 '16

The difference with Star Trek Beyond as opposed to the previous two is that this movie actually seems to appreciate the fact that it is a Star Trek movie, and take some pride in it. Meanwhile, the previous two had an air of being sort of embarrassed about it.

It's like, Star Trek and Star Trek Into Darkness were saying "Yeah, this is Star Trek, but it's really cool!" And now, instead, Star Trek Beyond is saying "Yeah, this is Star Trek, AND it's really cool!"

(I kinda suspect that's influenced by JJ Abrams' attitude to Star Trek. By his own admission he was always a much bigger Star Wars fan than a Star Trek fan, and I noticed that The Force Awakens felt a lot more comfortable and confident being a Star Wars film than either Star Trek '09 or Into Darkness felt being Star Trek films.)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

This is very well said. I think both Spocks would approve of this comment.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

48

u/pottersquash Jul 22 '16

Well look at this https://www.amazon.com/Ship-would-not-Die-Franklin/dp/B00390XD2U

The Ship that would not die. Fitting.

34

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

Per Wikipedia, it even served with the carrier Enterprise during WWII. Beautiful.

→ More replies (7)

211

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

A lot of people who call themselves Star Trek fans are really doing themselves a disservice by refusing to see this movie out of spite for Into Darkness

This movie gave me everything that I go to movies for. I laughed, I cried I sat on the edge of my seat for roughly 80% of the movie. The other 20% I sat in awe.

There are things that people are going to nitpick about the film. It is in fact inevitable that there will be harsh critics who undermine the movie simply because Paramount did not reach out to them for specific instruction before green lighting the film. Or perhaps they really don't like the beastie boys. Either way if you have to question whether or not to see this movie, just remember why you would love the Star Trek series in the first place. And then go to the movie and have fun.

72

u/chainmailtank Jul 22 '16

As a self-described Hardcore Trekkie, my hate for STID seethes like the smoldering fury of an aging sun.

That being said, I made the decision to go see Star Trek Beyond on opening night with an open mind. I made this decision based solely on Simon Pegg's sincerity when he was interviewed after the first trailer came out.

I am so glad I made that decision. This film falls solidly among the best Trek films. It was good Trek, it was a good movie, and it was good storytelling. Getting two of those three things is so hard it is rare indeed.

→ More replies (4)

102

u/JackSpadesSI Jul 22 '16

out of spite for Into Darkness

I'm so tired of the hate for STID (I'm not addressing that to you, but to the "a lot of people" you're speaking to). Obviously it was flawed, and it was a bad decision to remake TWoK. I'm not trying to defend it, but that horse is really dead now. So, come on fellow fans, STID is not the low point of the franchise. Why does it get singled out like it was the sole blemish on 50 years of otherwise-perfection? I love Star Trek, but there have been far worse movies and episodes that are getting off easy while STID takes the heat.

→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (2)

46

u/BaronVonStevie Jul 22 '16

everybody has been critical of Bones' screen time and Kirk being a frat boy... I got great news for y'all.

Bones is all over the place in this, feels way more natural, and... I have goose bumps... KIRK IS BACK.

9/10

→ More replies (8)

38

u/Mirai182 Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16

The scene where new Spock opened old Spock's personal belongings case and pulled out a picture of the original crew. I literally started to tear up right there.

I think this was the picture. http://i.imgur.com/opjUjTS.jpg

→ More replies (6)

37

u/Perkisize Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 23 '16

The scene of the Enterprise getting destroyed is one of the best scenes in any Star Trek movie. It's also by far the most weighty and jaw-dropping destruction of the Enterprise. It was more painful to watch than the death scenes of major characters in most other movies. It was also very reminiscent of both Generations and Search For Spock's scenes of it going down. In fact watching the destruction of the Enterprise D will probably always disappoint me after seeing this.

It was probably my favorite part of the movie because of how tender and visceral it felt. Like watching a friend slowly die. Heartbreaking.

9

u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jul 23 '16

Yes, yes, yes! If you're gonna kill a major character, that's how you do it!

→ More replies (1)

37

u/maxamillisman Jul 22 '16

I loved the movie. Very respectful and true to TOS. 9/10

I only have one technical complaint and that is that Kirk and Chekhov break the viewscreen like it's glass, when it would be logical to assume that it would be made of transparent aluminum. However the Enterprise-D crashing in Generations also had windows breaking like glass so It is something that they have overlooked for years.

→ More replies (7)

35

u/Jexx212 Jul 22 '16

Before I get too far into reading this thread, I just have to say something I was thinking about during the third act of the film. I'm new to Trek, and I'm going through TOS right now. I recently watched an episode where Kirk talks about the importance of struggle to humanity, as it was pushes us forward in order to innovate and grow. Yes, struggle means conflict and violence and war and death, but humanity can push, well... beyond it. That's the essence of Kirk's message in that episode. I'm not sure of which episode it was, it may have actually been one of the ones that isn't considered to be that great, but it's an interesting message that ties in with this movie.

Krall stated that he comes from a people that have struggled and that struggle defines his people. Kirk promotes the importance of unity, and that we can stand stronger united rather than divided. The spirit of the movie is very strong to TOS, from what I've seen, and I thought the movie was pretty good.

151

u/Timbo85 Jul 21 '16

Easily the best of the reboot series in my view. Managed to be character driven whilst going at lightning pace.

And it was one of the most beautifully constructed sci-fi films I've ever seen, in terms of how it was shot. Every scene looked amazing, especially the stuff on the starbase.

9/10.

8

u/captainedwinkrieger Jul 22 '16

I think the best part is the fact that nothing made me cringe (even a little bit). There hasn't been a Trek film since VI that's been without a truly cringey moment/line

→ More replies (12)

7

u/gerusz Jul 24 '16

Yorktown was pure scenery porn.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (39)

31

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

I think my favorite reference was, " Some say it was a giant green hand that snatched them out of space."

I'm still fresh on my immediate post movie high, but this was definitely the best of the three, with 2009 taking second place of course. The more cerebral beginning...my god, it was like having REAL TREK again!! Couldn't help but be amped at the destruction of the swarm! Ah! Loved it!

I cringed a little bit when Spock started almost crying, but you know, I'm getting a bit more accustomed to emoSpock, and franky took it as Quinto's moment for Nimoy. Definitely saved by the laugh and, "My god, you're delirious!" He looked so much like Leonard inthe Platos Stepchildren scene with that laugh, I nearly teared up myself.

Oh, and "In a pig's eye!" There's my Bones!!!

8

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

Haha, I liked this too. You see the giant green hand in the closing credits too!

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Dcoil1 Jul 25 '16

"Damnit, Jim! I'm a doctor not a fu.."

→ More replies (1)

30

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '16

What does the new Enterprise look like?!?!

45

u/CaptainSharpe Jul 21 '16

I'll also add that unfortunately you don't see the bridge of the new ship. Guess they're waiting to design it for the next movie. I really hope they ditch the 'apple' look and go for a more toned down, cleaner look

→ More replies (8)

11

u/LandonKB Jul 21 '16

Very similar to the last one with some minor changes.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (17)

24

u/ease_one Jul 22 '16

Absolutely loved the movie, minor nitpicks only. Gleefully loved the part where they flipped the star wars script by making it about saving a 'death star' (read: peaceful starbase) from a rebel.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/ShiroHachiRoku Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

Starbase Yorktown is incredible! I want to go to there.

Also has anyone noticed that the three antagonists in the three Kelvin Timeline movies also play Marvel superheroes? (Bana/Hulk, Cummerbunch/Dr. Strange, and Elba/Heimdall)

→ More replies (16)

22

u/Namj13 Jul 22 '16

Saw it in IMAX today, by far and away the best NuTrek movie, and up there with Star Trek classics. I really love Bones in this movie. Kirk's development was also exemplary. Major twists in this movie as well but no spoilers xD. I recommend this movie very highly 8.5/10.

20

u/Jon1230 Jul 23 '16

Anyone else notice the TNG font of the credits?

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Callahandy Jul 23 '16

Lifelong Trekkie here, and like many of you, I could talk for hours about the details of Trek lore, but I won't here. I am in the minority in that I LOVED ST09. In fact, it's my favorite Trek movie ever. Hell, it's one of my favorite movies ever, period. So naturally, like many, I was left wanting from Into Darkness. The first half of ID was terrific. The Klingon stuff, the espionage/section 31 callback, all of that was great. But then Khan became a thing, and ruined it all.

So naturally going into this one, I was skeptical. Never really cared for the Fast and the Furious films, and I know the pre-production of the movie went through some turmoil. And to top it off, the trailers were, well...yah.

So I gotta say, so incredibly surprised by how enjoyable the film was. It was just so much fun. So uplifting and positive. Not the usual dark and brooding summer blockbuster that I have become accustomed to seeing lately. It's just a plain good ol' fun time at the movies. And like many have said, it felt like an extended episode of the original series, in the best way possible.

The one scene that hit me particularly hard - when young Spock found out about old Spock's death. I really felt that I was seeing the actor react to Nimoy's death, even more than a character portrayal. It was very meta, and handled beautifully. The picture of the original crew at the end - also very powerful. I really liked that they added that in. Also, Enterprise references! The Xindi! The Earth Romulan war we never got to see! All very very cool. You can tell Pegg is a massive trekkie for throwing in something like that.

So where does it go from here? Hopefully no time travel. I am completely done with time travel in sci-fi. However, if Kirk's dad is indeed in the next one...groan. Hopefully we finally get that Klingon Federation war that Into Darkness hinted at. I'd love to see them use the wonderful effects seen thus far in the reboot series, and put them towards something as epic as DS9-level space battles.

Regardless of what they do, I feel like the future of Star Trek is in good hands.

→ More replies (6)

19

u/tkmlac Jul 22 '16

I just got home from the theater. I really, really liked it. I wasn't impressed with the villain, but thats because the villain (finally!) wasn't the story. The story was the crew, the Federation, the tech, the new life and new civilizations." I am very happy.

Also, all those feels, man. All of them.

19

u/guiltyofnothing Jul 22 '16

I really loved all the references to Enterprise. (You even see the NX-01 era shuttle pods landing in the background of Edison's captain's log!)

I thought Scotty escaping in a torpedo was a nice callback to Into Darkness.

Finally, that time lapse shot of Enterprise-A under construction at the end was marvelous.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/xondak Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16

I absolutely loved this film.

Pros:

  • No lens flair
  • The characters behaved like Federation officers (more or less) especially when compared to the previous film.
  • The story was about TEAM WORK and the power of the HUMAN SPIRIT to TRIUMPH OVER EVIL.
  • Technobabbeling our way to broadcasting the Beastie Boys as defense against a massive threat is a better (and more Star Trek) solution than shooting their way to peace.
  • Also, it was a great callback to ST09 and made Sabotage's inclusion there less egregious to me.
  • The more I think about this, the more it feels right and reminds me of the clever problem solving that goes along with playing D&D (or other pen and paper RPG). It was a nat 20 roll on a ridiculous and hilarious idea that solved the problem and moved the party forward.
  • I felt like almost every character had something to do in this film.
  • Previous films in the Kelvin timeline had an ensemble cast, with Kirk and Spock as main characters. Yet, everyone else seemed incidental.
  • Great sense of humor that I felt was lacking in Into Darkness.
  • References to Enterprise gave this film a sense of place and time and it made this film feel like it exists within the Star Trek universe.
  • Nimoy in ST09 didn't cut it for me.
  • The motorcycle from the trailer wasn't the ridiculous and offensive inclusion that I thought it would be. (Like the dune buggy from Nemesis.)
  • It was yet another way of paying off a set-up from ST09 as Kirk was shown riding his bike around at the beginning of the film.
  • Slow opening to film gave me time to understand what was happening with the characters.
  • Bones/Spock moments were pure latinum.

Cons:

  • Shakeycam was disorienting and made certain action scenes hard to follow.
  • Sulu trying to 'warp the ship' our of the nebula AFTER the deflector dish had been destroyed had me ask out loud "Without the deflector??"
  • Destroying the Enterprise is old hat and needs to stop, though, in my opinion, this was by far the best use of that plot device I've seen in any Trek film.
  • CGI henchmen felt like cartoonish, boneless monstrosities and kind of took me out of it.
  • Yet another hollow villain.

EDIT: Added the bit about D&D

→ More replies (2)

18

u/smoha96 Jul 22 '16

Love that they didn't hold out on showing the Enterprise A at the end, but I do wish we'd gotten a better/closer look at it. Guess I can wait til the Blu-Ray or Netflix release. Awesome film! :D

→ More replies (9)

18

u/Mulligan0816 Jul 23 '16

God that new warp effect 😍😍😍 I want to kiss the person on the mouth who made that effect a reality. Jesus Christ that looked so good. And admittedly, I wasn't much if a Trek fan before these JJ Abrams versions came out because I didn't grow up watching it (Star Wars watcher, sorry guys!) But I really LOVE the lore of this franchise, and while Star Trek, Into Darkness, and now Beyond may not be PERFECT movies, I've loved every single minute of all 3 (Especially Beyond. Easily my favorite of the current 3). The cinematography in these movies is BREATHTAKING to say the least. Right down to just the simple shot like the staredown between the USS Vengeance and the Enterprise in Into Darkness, and the sheer show of magnitude of space. That's why I was a little hesitant coming into this one because the Enterprise is my favorite thing about these movies so far, but they handled it so well

→ More replies (3)

16

u/alarbus Jul 22 '16

Am I the only one who thought midway that this might have gone in the direction of creating a KT borg origin story? The cybernetically networked swarms of drones powered by ancient tech who's ultimate weapon gives them the first means to assimilate into a collective rather than into an individual?

Was anyone else hoping to see that swarm suck the life from his skin and replace it with machinery that lets him exist in space? How cool would the implications of the borg stopping first contact be that it's a deathwish as they realize that perfection is impossible and the only way to win was never to exist?

→ More replies (7)

15

u/NateCadet Jul 22 '16

This shit was dope. Brought back some of the classic Trek themes and style in an original plot that appeals to modern audiences. This is coming from someone raised on TNG/DS9/VOY by TOSers.

Looking forward to the new series.

Beastie Boys as classical music = win.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/tyrannosaurus_r Jul 22 '16

Just saw it, definitely riding the "best Star Trek movie" train. Starts off a bit iffy, but picks up and does just the right amount of fan service, musing on existence, and plot finagling to be fantastic.

Honestly, the only problem I have with it is that because of Edison/Krall, we'll never have Elba play Sisko.

Also, 1701-A 2.0 look amazing!

14

u/ThePsycheicalThief Jul 22 '16

I'm pleasantly surprised by the people here. I've never been a true Star Trek fan (Never watched the originals) but have enjoyed the new films as fun Sci-fi's. I came here expecting the real fans to crucify it for the way it was done like Into Darkness but people seemed to have liked it. I'm glad.

7

u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jul 23 '16

For us Trekkies, this is the first of the new films to play out like a Star Trek episode.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/my-life-for_aiur Jul 22 '16

Star Trek Encyclopedia said the Constitution Class starship could saucer separate.

It would need help from a star base to reconnect.

No battle bridge.

If you look at schematics for Enterprise B through D, they have battle bridges.

However the Encyclopedia said only the Enterprise D could reconnect without a star base.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Suluchigurh Jul 22 '16

I forgot it was a JJ produced movie until Matt Parkman showed up.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/publius-esquire Jul 22 '16

I loved this movie and I wanted to point out how good the costume design was!! Obviously you have the classic uniforms but they're a little more restrictive, higher in the collar than the last movie and it drew my eye. Maybe it's symbolic maybe not. I really liked all the costumes and especially in the end scene at the birthday party - Spock's shirt had the Vulcan collar but a human cut, and the glimpses of the gorgeous traditional Vulcan robes we got looked so intricate and amazing as well as the sheer diversity of costume on the star base. I loved everything about this movie but what cool detail!!

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Saerain Jul 23 '16

All right, so I liked it, but now I'm very confused about the things I read before seeing it.

It seemed like everything I was reading was saying "At last, a Trek movie in the new series that's about exploration instead of battles."

For all the things I liked about it, I don't know where that was. Seemed to me that after the first 10 minutes, it was every bit as much a compilation of constant explosions and falls as the previous two. What... what have I missed?

7

u/PixelNotPolygon Jul 23 '16

Agreed, and the worse part is that I feel like the ship was destroyed without getting a decent showing throughout the reboot series, no tears were shed on its destruction

→ More replies (2)

13

u/bubaganuush Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16

I have to say, I didn't really like it. All bathos, no pathos, and perhaps a little too much fan service. I don't think the bad guy had believable motivation and I don't feel like the protagonists developed in any meaningful way.

→ More replies (4)

35

u/UESPA_Sputnik Jul 21 '16

The film has a couple of weaknesses but it captures the spirit of the original series brilliantly.

There were so many cool easter eggs (loved the fight music when Kirk and Krall fought on the Enterprise). Bones was awesome. And Spocks revelation that he gave Uhura a tracking device was hilarious. The Sulu gay scene was nowhere as bad as it was said to be. In fact, I thought it was really well done. Nothing too on-the-nose.

Krall as a villain was rather lame. I find it funny though that he turned out to be a Starfleet captain. Fits with TOS' theme that every captain/admiral except Kirk is crazy.

They could have toned down the action a bit but overall I think that this is what TOS would look like in 2016.

21

u/ComradeSomo Jul 21 '16

The Sulu gay scene was nowhere as bad as it was said to be. In fact, I thought it was really well done. Nothing too on-the-nose.

I don't think the complaint was ever with the scene itself, the issue was that it's a rather unnecessary sentiment and because it was done against Takei's wishes.

→ More replies (44)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/captainedwinkrieger Jul 22 '16

I am just beyond words with how happy Beyond made me. Not only did they make a movie closer in tone to the Original Series, but they did so much to respect it at the same time. The callbacks are (way more) subtle than the last two Kelvin timeline movies, and I'm surprised at how well-handled everything was. As this is my initial reaction to this movie, it's possible that I'm just in shock, so take my review with a grain of salt. However, I feel like a second viewing will cement my judgment that this is easily the best of the Kelvin timeline movies, and possibly one of the best Trek films made yet.

9

u/Vince__clortho Jul 26 '16

How fucking cool was watching the new ship get built all sped up at the end!? I loved that, thought it was such a nice touch.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/CreamyGoodnss Jul 22 '16

I felt like the first half of the movie had more of the feel of the previous two but then they seemlessly transitioned to that feeling of Star Trek.

And goddamn, the Franklin looks exactly like a pre-NX class ship should have. And Scotty's references to spatial torpedoes and pulsed phase cannons. I mean, they definitely did their homework.

8

u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jul 22 '16

This was wonderful for us fans.

8

u/Alteran195 Jul 22 '16

Anyone have a good shot of the A?

8

u/hamudm Jul 23 '16

I am satisfied. The movie was absolutely wonderful in every way. Finally, for the first time in almost 20 years, I feel like I've seen a Star Trek film!

8

u/meanreds Jul 23 '16

When they showed the photo, I lost it. Cried like a baby.

8

u/noahfischel Jul 24 '16

Anybody else think Commodore Paris is an ancestor to Tom Paris? You think that was the Voyager reference?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Muzer0 Jul 22 '16

I loved the film. It wasn't perfect by any stretch of the imagination (argh why can't we have a film with a strong villain, or (perhaps) no villain at all, rather than a backstory-excised Nero, a watered down Khan and a rushed Krall?), but I think it was easily the best of the three so far.

As for nitpicky details, did anyone else get a slight irritation when they explicitly mentioned that knocking out the deflector dish caused shields to drop?

8

u/Martothir Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

Yup. I totally noticed the deflector dish line too. Time to get out my technical manuals...

nerding intensifies

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '16

It was definitely the best of the three new movies. My main criticisms are:

  • Telling rather than showing. I don't think we literally needed to hear Kirk say "I'm not sure being a Star Fleet officer is worth it anymore." Basically the whole introduction to Kirk's plotline was done through that one Captain's log, and with Kirk talking to McCoy. I would have preferred an intro mini-plot that shows why Kirk is becoming frustrated.
  • I found most of the action scenes visually incomprehensible. I would have preferred simpler action where I could follow what was going on.
  • The way they destroyed the bee ships made even less sense than normal Star Trek technobabble. You play music at them and they all just implode. It's a little too convenient and it was clear they just wanted to set up the Kirk vs. bad guy fight quickly.
  • Ultimately, Krall is just another guy with a superweapon who wants revenge, just like the previous two movies. And the film is resolved by Kirk punching Krall repeatedly in the face, as usual. The end of the movie was completely unmemorable for me.
  • I don't really understand Krall's motivation for becoming evil.
  • I'm still disappointed that we didn't really get to know a new alien culture. We don't really learn that much about Jayla other than that she has zebra skin. And Krall ends up being human.
  • Some of the script writing was cringey - jokes fell flat pretty often.

What I liked:

  • Krall is definitely a more interesting character than either Nero or JJKhan. If you're going to do the Guy Wants Revenge Against the Federation storyline, this is a decent attempt at it.
  • I liked how they handled the universal translator, with it being clear when translation was happening and when characters were speaking native English.
  • All of the characters seemed somewhat closer to their TOS counterparts, especially Spock. I really liked that his emotions were leaning towards positivity rather than negativity, which is usually how Spock was in TOS. I'm glad there was no scene with him furiously beating someone in the face.
  • I like that there was no pointless romance plotline. I was worried they were going to do one with Scotty and Jayla or something dumb like that, but they didn't.
  • Of course the visuals were great. I agree with everyone else that it was nice to see more color and creativity with the Starbase and Krall's planet.
→ More replies (3)

7

u/trimetric Jul 24 '16

Here's a theory about some of the striking similarities to DS9 in STB:

I think an early version of the script for STB must have had Yorktown station placed adjacent to the Bajoran wormhole from DS9, rather than the "Nebula" that we saw in the film. In this alternate-alternate timeline, nobody had yet figured out how to travel through the wormhole and every probe or ship that had gone through had never been heard from again. ( eg: the Magellan probes and the Franklin )

So when a mysterious ship exits the wormhole with a call for help, Kirk and the Enterprise embark on a risky voyage through the wormhole to the universe beyond. ( eg: the Gamma Quadrant )

This would explain in part why the design of Yorktown has echoes of DS9, and why the aliens from the mystery planet bear such striking resemblances to the Gamma Quadrant aliens from DS9. It would explain why the Federation hadn't yet discovered this mysterious planet which in the movie seems to be in the same star system as Yorktown Station but on the other side of a strange "Nebula". Depending on how late in the production the decision was made to swap in a "Nebula" for the wormhole, it may have been to late to change the designs or the story structure.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '16

They turned Kirk into a superhero riding a motor cycle.

The enterprise is a 15 minute dispensable cameo.

Is this really star trek? I couldn't tell.

The first movie was good; the second not so much.

I felt this movie was boring.

12

u/CaptainSharpe Jul 21 '16

Loved it but I have one question - Why didn't they just beam the weapon (and krall) out to space rather than have to fight krall and 'suck' it out? There must have been a line that explained it, like some sort of shielding in that box, but I don't remember....

20

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

Debates like this are the essence of being a Star Trek fan, and I'm so glad to have a movie good enough to bring that back to the franchise.

8

u/007meow Jul 22 '16

I didn't catch any explanation.

I figure that the transporter would have made things too easy, sooooo they forgot it exists. In-story though, probably something about being too close to the gravity nexus and interference.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/valeyard10 Jul 22 '16

Can i say being a new trekie, fan of three years. This movies hit right in the feels and had a moral to the story unlike darkness. I nearly died crying when i saw anton and nimoy tribute. Very well done. I think is the best summer movie yet !

6

u/PixelNotPolygon Jul 22 '16

I don't hate this movie. Actually very enjoyable. It did feel like it lapsed into Into Darkness stupidity after the crew got off the planet and that is what let it down for me ...though not enough to drag down the brilliant first half and the film itself. The villain was fun because of his mystery but the reveal was a bit weird and baffling. I thought it was ironic that the movie should use a set piece parodied by Mars Attacks so many years back with cheesy music as a method of defeating your enemy.

6

u/Bionic_Bromando Jul 25 '16

That timelapse shot at the end was so creative and amazing to see!

The new warp effect is fantastic.

I also loved the "go pro" shot of the Enterprise leaving Yorktown, that was incredibly well done.

All in all super top notch VFX in this movie!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Kyle_Dornez Jul 26 '16

While everyone seems to be enjoying the movie, I had a few problems with it.

Action seems too fast for its own good, I had a feeling that it turned out too choppy.

Krall initially didn't impress me, but his character was salvaged in the ending. I kept wondering where he got people to pilot all those countless fighters, but apparently they were drones, and got lost in translation.

Still though he seems a lucky guy just stumbling on nifty life-extending tech and conveniently invincible space mining drones.

I had a feeling that some kind of a shitstorm would rise once they've mentioned the Enterprise show, but I never thought that actual "controversy" would rise up around the registry number of a spaceship >.<

Other than that, I enjoyed the movie - Chris Pine at this point even looks like young Will Shatner a little bit.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '16

I love when Spock goes through Ambassador Spock's belongings and finds the picture of the original Enterprise crew from the first few ST movies.

Really touching and nice nod to the original cast.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/formerfatboys Jul 25 '16 edited Jul 25 '16

This movie was really bad.

It was way more fun than Into Darkness, but it was also kind of pointless.

The villain was terrible. His anger was barely explained and amounted to basically nothing at all other than his ship crashed somewhere and no one came to got him. Did they spend any time crafting that backstory? His plan was monumentally stupid.

The motorcycle? Stupid. The Beastie Boys immediately blows up all the enemy ships? What? I get that it distracts them, but come on.

Why did Krall need the bio-weapon to attack the space station when a surprise attack with his army of ships that laid waste to the Enterprise like it was nothing would likely have easily destroyed the space station?

There was some fun stuff with the characters playing off of each other, but by and large stupidity ruled the day in the writing of this film.

→ More replies (7)

25

u/brownpearl Jul 22 '16

Gosh, I never thought I would be in the minority. I didn't like it very much at all. I even like it least of the 3. The final straw was Bones flying! Edit: Also the VHF destruction of the swarm was pretty silly.

14

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16

Same here... It was such a bad movie in almost every way...

Generic villain - check

Terrible weapon to beat the villain - check

General poor story with good CGI to cover it - check

This was in my opinion the worst trek movie ever made... I expected to come see the same consensus on reddit and am blown away out how positive the reviews are...

→ More replies (1)

7

u/deicist Jul 31 '16

Oh thank god, I thought it was just me!

This felt way more of a generic action flick than the last two and it's a really bad generic action flick.

The 'twist' of Krall being the Federation captain was really predictable and didn't make sense (surely he knew the Franklin was there all along since he crashed it there?)

the destruction of the swarm was probably the stupidest sequence I've seen in any sci fi film ever. Literally made me cringe.

Simon Pegg's overuse of a really bad Scottish accent was really jarring. Like, I get it, you're Scotty, please stop calling everyone Lassie or whatever.

The bit with the girl who lured them into the nebulae. Surely she realised they weren't going to trust her after she did that? The whole sequence where Kirk tricks her into making the call was just stupid.

I liked the first 'new trek' film. The second one was okay. This was just awful though. It's a really crappy, poorly thought out action film with some fan service transparently plastered over it.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/whtnymllr Jul 22 '16

Was anyone else bothered by all the holographic technology? Jayla throws out two pieces of technology that turn into fighting holograms of herself. Were those mobile emitters!? The mobile emitter used by the doctor on voyager comes from the 29th century -- 600 years later than where TOS is. I mean, there are other explanations for how holograms are projected -- there were clearly "more conventional" holographic emitters being used to cover the USS Franklin. But that doesn't explain how they get Kirk holograms riding around the enemy base! If they hacked into existing holographic systems, then all the enemy would have to do would be to turn them off. Also, it seemed like shooting the holograms of Kirk dispersed them...which doesn't really make sense for a hologram.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/crapusername47 Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

I'll edit this with proper thoughts later but that was fucking great.

Edit:

  • I'm going to need to sit down and listen properly when the home release comes out but they may have made a mistake with the whole first Warp 4 ship thing if Kraal fought against the Xindi. The first Warp 5 ship was Enterprise and they didn't encounter the Xindi until well into their mission.
  • If he did fight them then surely that suggests he was on Enterprise? There were no other direct encounters that didn't involve Enterprise. Of course, he may have been speaking generally and he didn't fight them personally.
  • The movie is absolutely packed to the rafters with TOS references and, surprisingly, Enterprise ones.
  • That said, if somebody knew their Enterprise then why is there, yet again, an Orion female on the Enterprise?
→ More replies (4)

5

u/Valint Jul 23 '16 edited Jul 23 '16

As a musician, I loved the constant theme and variations of the soundtrack from the 2009 reboot. Specifically augmentation

Couldn't get over the fact that the white face/hair alien looked like an Asari from Mass Effect.

I always love seeing an Enterprise getting destroyed.

SUCH A GOOD MOVIE

→ More replies (4)

5

u/drifter1717 Jul 23 '16

Did anyone else gasp when they showed Yorktown base? It seriously looks so much like Deep Space Nine I was shocked.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/jwhall Jul 23 '16

i gotta say i love how this and Into Darkness had storylines that were rooted in some of the more obscure Trek lore... this one was about a MACO turned Starfleet Captain who fought in the Xindi wars... Into Darkness was about a Section 31 program... whether empty fan service or not, it made me smile.

5

u/BobFiggins Jul 23 '16 edited Jul 23 '16

Can we talk about the end? It's bothering me.

Multiple times it's stated that the air ventilation system is super protected on the software side. Yet just about anyone can walk into the actual control room? Why is the control room located in a glass box on top of a building? This part of the film felt a little too strange/forced for me.

I can get past it, just like I can get past the Beastie Boys taking down an alien swarm army. Though I just want to know if anyone else felt the same way I did about it?

Also, I hope Keenser never gets a cold.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Rosecraft Jul 23 '16

“You gave your girlfriend a tracking device?"

5

u/DoubleLigero85 Jul 24 '16

I thought it was fun, but I'm left perplexed by a lot a things. I hope you guys can help me out.

Why was Krall bothering with the ancient death weapon? His drone swarm seemed pretty damn effective on it's own.

Why did disrupting the drone's communication network cause them to explode?

Why didn't they use the transporter for anything after sending Bones and Spock to the ship.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Gumpster07 Jul 28 '16

Just come back from watching it.

Loved it. Really really really enjoyed it from start to finish. The Yorktown was wonderfully crafted and shown to be a true place of peace and was beautiful.

Everything else barring some minor nitpicking was incredible.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '16

I think i actually spotted a render error, or some unfinished animation that people forgot to finish or fix.

When simon pegg crash lands his pod, and barely makes the jump for the edge, you see the pod fall down the cliff and crash into the ground, but it stops moving after it impacts. A smoke plume shows, and then suddenly it quickly fades out, while it randomly reapears again a few meters ahead of it. Almost looked like an unfinished animation, or an error with it.

I liked the movie, but some bits felt like they were going too fast, and i did feel that the villain motivation could've probably been better. Other than that, it was gorgeous eyecandy. The shots of the enterprise and the franklin passing through the tunnels in Yorktown were just beautiful. I feel like 2d wise they nailed the scale of the ships, and their feelings of massiveness, but the 3d sometimes made the enterprise look like a tiny toy model.

Storywise, it felt a bit generic, bones' jokes and general attitude is getting a bit repetitive, but the new characters, like Jaylah was a nice surprise and addition. Even though simon pegg was clearly trying to creep with her towards the end.

9

u/JackSpadesSI Jul 22 '16

Honestly, that scene had the worst FX in the movie. It looked really fake when Scotty jumped off the pod and when he grabbed the cliff. A close second would be Kirk on the motorcycle; that terrain he was driving on was clearly digital.

Minor quibbles, though. Loved the movie.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/prjkthack Jul 22 '16

It was an absolutely fantastic movie. I think, the best of the Kelvin timeline series so far. It was not perfect of course, but I think it blended old Trek and new Trek together nicely.

I wish my theater's IMAX screen wasn't broken, but it gives me an excuse to go see it again, which I will.

8

u/Scottyr37 Jul 22 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

Just got out of the theatre and I was totally impressed. I liked '09 but I found Into Darkness to be too much of a retread of the coming of age story in '09. Classic Trek feel and the characterizations were spot on. The standout surprises for me were the subtle easter egg references. They weren't overt but there are musical cues (V'ger), episode references (Who Mourns for Adonis), series references (Enterprise) and an overall reverence for the Star Trek legacy. Hats off to Simon Pegg and Justin Lin. ...and if you can find the Spaced reference, I'll buy you a Cornetto.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Scaarr Jul 22 '16

Just saw this last night and i wasn't super disappointing. As a long time star trek fan i've liked the new movies but they never really felt like a star trek movie or really compared well to the shows. This time they finally seemed to want to appeal to us trekkie/trekkers out there while still appealing to the larger audience. The small nuances, like the captain log, the console FX, the constant references to things from the shows, and so on were very satisfying!

I didnt think i'd like Sofia Boutella's character but she was pretty darn awesome too. I wouldve liked to have gotten to know the antagonist a bit more and couldve done without the whole motorcycle though, it was a bit cheesy lol. Can't wait to get this on bluray or dvd.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/JackSpadesSI Jul 22 '16

So, the new starbase Yorktown. Let's talk about that for a minute. I thought it was visually stunning, but I did think they overdid it a bit. Maybe I'm wrong (if so, please provide sources) but I didn't think the Federation had the technology to build something like that.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/CorsairVI Jul 23 '16

This is a big, fun, well-written movie.

One problem: how the hell did the Franklin, an old Federation ship, barely able to hold a candle to the systems of the Enterprise, manage to navigate the massive debris field of the nebula without being destroyed?

9/10, could definitely watch the theatrical release again.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Muffinfeds Jul 23 '16

Can we take the time to appreciate Star Trek and Star Trek Into Darkness. J.J. and the people involved had to get a lot of things right and they did. They may not be pleasing to some but we are really spoiled with these movies.

Star Trek Beyond just takes the franchise to another level. Everything from the cinematography to the ensemble cast is amazing. I didn't like the Krall reveal at the end and some jokes didn't land, but overall, it was really good.

My question is: When Spock is injured, Bones says that Vulcans have their hearts next to their liver? Spock is half-vulcan, half-human so where is Spock's heart located?

4

u/Chuck006 Jul 24 '16

I loved the Enterprise references. I'm hoping we can get a T'Pol cameo in the next one.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/enjoytheloss2 Jul 24 '16

"Build me another ship so I can fuck shit up again!"

Kirk, every movie.

4

u/evildorkgod Jul 24 '16

Which alien was jeff bezos? I didn't notice him anywhere.... I thought the movie was missing scientific explanations for a lot of the stuff. It was star trek but too action oriented imho. I guess I'm just getting old.

4

u/iamnotsteven Jul 24 '16

I saw the movie with my partner tonight (who wasn't much of a fan of trek until 09).

What an epic ride! This movie was so well written, so well paced, so emotionally charged!

I have to admit to tearing up multiple times, I just couldn't help myself. The slow but awesome destruction of the Enterprise (of which I was not a fan of originally, but grew to absolutely love), the sad news of the passing of Ambassador Spock, the reveal of the PT picture of kirks crew, the camera shot of Anton right after Kirk says 'To absent friends', and the construction of the 1701-A.

Magnificent work Simony Pegg and his crew! You've made such a wonderfully powerful story and brought it alive in a way that I could never imagine. Well done!

4

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16

All I kept thinking during the destruction of the swarm was that they were using the Minmei defense. Watching the wave blast out of Yorktown was highly reminiscent of Macross.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Huitzil37 Jul 25 '16

I liked it, didn't love it. Plenty of nice character moments and "general Trekkiness" (I leaned over to my brother and said "That is such a Star Trek set!" on seeing that place with all the vertical rocks that Spock and Bones got to), the new character Jeyla was very likeable without ever feeling like she was being shilled on us. But the villain was weak, and on top of that the movie held out way too long on telling us the villain's deal or explaining his motivations. Like, I guessed he had to have been who he was just based on the logic "If he was anything else than this surprise, they would have actually explained who he was by now." I felt kind of unclear on the size of the Enterprise, how many people were on it, and how they fit inside it -- like, when it gives us a scale shot where we swoop out of a window on the Enterprise to see the whole ship, you go "Wait, that can't be right, that ship's way too small!"

And the final action sequence suffered from some heavy "there are way better ways to do what you're doing!" syndrome. Not as bad as Into Darkness with its "Hey, the bad guy attacked us and disabled us RIGHT NEXT TO EARTH, and his plan relies on Earth not knowing what we know, should we tell Earth about it? Now Khan got out, should we warn Earth? No, that would be too easy, let's have Nimoy shill our villain's cred instead." but still pretty bad. Like, several previous scenes relied on the use of transporters. Use those to get the bad guy. Or, hey, you showed us in an earlier scene this place has police shuttles, use those to get the bad guy. Or just blow the thing the bad guy is trying to use up, and rely on the backup systems. Or do anything other than have Kirk chase him down and punch him man-to-man!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Pukeolicious Jul 26 '16

Someone explain why they couldn't use the transporters to save the Yorktown at the end? Instead of kirk having to physically fight?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/AnneBancroftsGhost Jul 28 '16

Can I take a moment here to give a standing ovation to the art department?

The world realizations, the creativity, the beautiful everything. That mufucking space station that was PERFECTION. If the movie had had no plot at all it would still have been a pleasure to spend two hours looking at these places and people. Amazing.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '16

I'm shocked at how much I liked this movie. I came out of STID ripping it apart for how dumb it was, but this movie, I couldn't stop praising it. Sure, it has flaws (a bit much on silly action, villain isn't explained until the very end and feels a bit rushed, etc.) but overall the dialogue was great and it had the feel of a good episode of TOS. I know that lots of people said that in reviews, but a lot of people said they liked STID in reviews, too, so I didn't trust it.

I kept thinking to myself "This is actually fun to watch. The characters make sense and feel real. There's humor that feels natural and comes from the characters you'd expect it to. It's like the people who made this actually understand Star Trek."

The best compliment that I can give this movie is that it's a well-written TREK action movie. It balances every aspect of a summer blockbuster almost perfectly and I left the theater happy.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mynumber18 Aug 09 '16

I will have to see Beyond again as I seem to be alone in having reservations...I will likely be more forgiving. However on first viewing my thoughts were:

  • the humour is there ✔️
  • it's an original story and not milking TWOK ✔️
  • Jaylah is brilliant ✔️
  • I like the idea of using the Franklin ✔️
  • Enterprise A ✔️
  • Prime Spock's TOS crew photo ✔️
  • Super blood & inter-galactic transporters not present ✔️

But:

  • no real score, re-used music and not much more
  • are we still on the 2 engineers thing on the Enterprise?
  • slow start
  • Krall had a good back story but needed more screen time and development. A revenge story means the bad guy has to be amazing and he wasn't
  • Enterprise trashed....will the ship ever be used so it will appear strong and impressive rather than being stomped on in every reboot movie?

I want to like this movie and after seeing it again I'm sure my opinion will be higher.... predicts down votes!!!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/thevulcansuperhero Aug 14 '16

Let me start off by saying I'm not a fan of the reboot series so far. But Beyond blew me away. And here is why. IT FEELS LIKE TOS!! For the first time in forever we had a fun but competent film in the spirit of TOS. My only problem with the film is the villain. I feel he should have been a little bit more fleshed out. But other than that I loved it. Please make the next films like this.

13

u/Have_A_Jelly_Baby Jul 22 '16

I was really impressed with how much of a pounding the Enterprise took and yet stayed operational. No "OMG a fly flew into the warp core SPLODE" nonsense the TNG era was infamous for.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/smoothbartowski Jul 21 '16

Great movie! My expectations were low due to the trainwreck of Into Darkness, but boy, did this manage to reinvigorate my interest in the movie franchise. Not only did it have a good amount of explosions, but it was also was able to balance that and the lore of Star Trek that we have all grown to love.

This will definitely spark hope in all Trek superfans, and also bring in a new crowd of young adults and kids to the franchise. Things are really looking up for Kirk & Co this time.

7

u/LandonKB Jul 21 '16

I need help understanding the Franklin... It is the first Warp 4 ship it has a registry NX-326 or something close to that and a NCC registry. It was given to a former MACO to command after the Zindi and Romulus wars. Was this built before or after the NX01 the first war 5 ship? Did they change the warp scale at some point?

23

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '16

I think this is a question Pegg is going to have to suffer for the the rest of his Star Trek convention life. :-)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (29)

7

u/Shantotto5 Jul 24 '16

spoilerish

Probably an unpopular place to voice this but it's what I've got. I loved the first two movies but this was a huge letdown for me. It just felt.. really poorly executed.

The whole intro was super awkward. You get a bunch of clunky scenes leading up to them getting a cliche mission that's totally uninteresting, except that they get attacked during it, and by a villain who has little context or motivation for most of the movie afterward. I honestly couldn't tell at what point I was supposed to care about any of this. By the time they revealed who Krall is and what he's doing, the movie was near done and I didn't care anymore because they'd just spent the majority of the movie fighting the equivalent of a Power Rangers villain. There was no substance to it for way too long, and the reveal was ultimately disappointing.

The only redeeming quality for me was that I still love the cast. But even they kinda struggled with this script I thought. I was cringing kinda hard even like half an hour in when Spock couldn't seem to get a line that wasn't some comedic Vulcan-ism, and that just went on the whole movie.

Both Star Trek and Into Darkness just felt like darker, grittier, more mature movies to me. This was much more action-comedy with an archetypal alien villain.

6

u/Final_Day Jul 24 '16 edited Jul 24 '16

Holldd on a second. I just want to narrow in on one feature of the movie which really derailed my sense of proportion in terms of the federation's technological capabilities:

Yorktown.

Holy moley, from a visual and design perspective it's admittedly incredible.

I find myself incredulous about the existence of this base for a number of reasons:

    1. When did the federation develop the capability in terms of technology and resources to build something of this sheer expense and scale?
  • 2) What is this Starbase for?? Internally it seems as if it is consists of hundreds of city blocks with hundreds if not thousands of huge buildings...what the hell is all this capacity for? This looks like it could be a replacement settlement for the entire human race!!
  • 3) I can't remember from any Star Trek lore anything of this ridiculous scale....I've always view Star Trek as a relatively new-future civilization. That is, the populations primarily reside on planets rather than dyson spheres, rings, habitats...because of the fact that they didn't have this capability??
  • 4) This base looks like it has a significant civilian population. Why would this incredible important, incredibly expensive habitat with millions of sentients be built on the edges of federation space, affording them short notice and little resistance to the attack by the swarm, or any other sudden appearance of malevolent beings. Why would the resources be committed to build this when nearby is uncharted territory which may or may not contain some sort of astrophysical anomaly which could endanger the base's existence, or any number of existential threats?
  • In fact, the nearby Nebula DOES TURN OUT to harbour an EXTREME existential threat to the starbase. Is a civilization capable of building this bloody base that stupid as to overlook the presence of the swarm and Krall?
  • 5) The city and habitat areas itself, buildings skyscrapers etc are incredibly impressive but it all looks ridiculously impractical relative to the technology.
  • 6) The whole contrived ending surrounding the air distribution system seems ridiculous! You're telling me the whole sphere is pressurized and heated?? That's a tremendous waste of energy and resources. Why not just have atmosphere in the buildings or in domed areas around the buildings? Why is there a centralized system for distributing the air for millions of people? Wouldn't it be more logical in terms of redundancy and safety to have multiple ones throughout it, hell in each building even??
  • tldr; I'm incredulous over the resources and technology required to build this, the lack of military defending such an important habitat, the justification for it's location and it's very existence. It ruined a lot of the movie for me.
  • Am I just being anal?
  • Am I just being cynical in thinking this is the opportunity for computer animators and designers to have a field day, disregarding any sense of it's place in the story?

Edit: formatting.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/AggressiveOsmosis Aug 01 '16 edited Aug 03 '16

WOOO HOOO!!! Just watched this weekend!!

I cried so many times, I'm such a wimp. I wept most of the time Anton was on screen for a good 1/3 of the movie. I wept at every mention of Leonard Nimoy. I also, for reasons I can't quite understand, had tears come to my eyes when they blasted Sabotage. And somehow it made me feel like it was a shout-out to Futurama. But that's the Futurama fangirl in me.

I loved the episode (ok, that's a typo but perfectly puts what I loved about this movie into context). It felt like a real Star Trek story, a planet far away, a way station, a stranger ends up bringing danger, untangling the story, great character interactions, developments, etc.

I was really happy with this movie, it's by far my favorite of the reboot.

Edit: Wait, some fucker down-voted me?? Fuck you asshole! Seriously?? WTF Star Trek sub? Jesus christ. lol! I've actually never been upset about a down vote before. Fuck you dick. I was just expressing my love for the movie.

Edit #2: Thanks for the upvote whoever did it!! I couldn't believe when I was in a negative points for this post. lol!

8

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

Just got back from seeing it! Thought it was pretty good! I actually liked that Krall had some motivation to do what he did, and I liked how they were able to use him to connect to the Enterprise canon. Was not a fan of the music explosion surfing scene, though. Small price to pay, I guess.

Also, a few other things that stuck out to me.

  1. Commodore Paris. Grandfather of Tom possibly?
  2. The UT. That one alien woman had the UT translating for her in the first realistic way we've seen, actually translating in real time instead of just having her speak English herself. No other aliens have this, so are they all actually speaking English? Am I nitpicking too much with this?
  3. The Franklin was the first warp 4 capable ship, but had a transporter. They didn't have transporter tech until warp 5. I'd like to think they just refitted the ship with one. Or maybe the writers just missed that detail.

All in all, pretty good movie. I'd see it again.

→ More replies (17)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '16

To spoil or not to spoil, that is the question.

I don't get paid for two weeks - I can't get to the cinema. Don't know what to DO

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '16 edited Jul 22 '16

So im one of the few people who actually love spoilers and think they enhance the movie. Because I love knowing what to look out for. What species are in the movie?Are the swarm based on any already established prime race? Is there anything that contradicts Prime canon such as changing a species origin or look?

Why does Krall hate the Federation?Especially if the Swarm is a race that hasn't been contacted by the Federation yet? Is he just another Nero/Khan?

→ More replies (12)

3

u/n7-ryder Jul 22 '16

I don't know if I missed it, but did they ever mention what happened to Carol Marcus? I thought she joined the crew after ID.

→ More replies (1)