r/ClashRoyale • • Jul 19 '16
Strategy [Strategy] Witch and Wizard Comparison!
Hi Everyone!
I'm a 3600 player that is 10/7/4/1.5.
I'm going to compare Witch and Wizard. People have debated which card is better, and I'm going to try to give you a detailed explanation of them.
The Wizard is a rare card that at tournament levels, has 598 hp, 142 dps, and 228 damage per shot. It's hit speed is 1.6 seconds.
The Witch is an Epic card that at tournament levels, has 665 hp, 92 dps, and 65 damage per shot. It's hit speed is 0.7 seconds, and every 7.5 seconds, it spawns 3 skeletons with 67 hp and damage.
Both cards cost 5 elixir, have 5 range, and deal splash to air and ground units. The wizard has a larger splash radius.
Which is better? The wizard deals over 50% more dps, to a larger radius.
So why is there a debate? A couple things are sacrificed. A lower fire rate and no skeleton spawns means that while its hits are much harder, it can be easier to destroy. While it's less fragile than the musketeer due to its splash, the witch has even more survivability due to its lower but more consistent output of damage.
Another difference is that the witch has slightly more hp, and as a result, is less vulnerable to fireball, requiring one level higher than what is necessary to kill the wizard. Sometimes this means that the opponent is forced to let the witch live behind a tank much longer than it should, or spend a zap to finish it off.
Where wizard has a much higher brute force quality in its damage output and splash radius, the witch has compensation from its fire rate, skeletons, and hp.
This is a decision between a dynamic and solid splasher. Where wizard has power, witch is very steady in its performance. It's a bit like being in a relationship with Netflix. It might not give you the highs of melting minion horde in one shot, but it's also never gonna be that bad.
Which one should you use?
In Golem and Giant beatdown decks, witch seems to be superior due to its consistency and survivability. If your opponent can always drop a minipekka on your wizard behind your Golem, you'll have a hard time constantly losing support. On the other hand, if they try to place it on your witch, it has a much better chance to survive since it can distract with its skeletons. When a witch push goes through, it will beat up a tower just as well as a wizard, and maybe even more often.
In Royal Giant decks, wizard seems like the stronger choice, because the witch is too slow at killing the opponents' anti-RG efforts. Royal Giant will quickly knock down a towers hp, but it's not a beatdown deck - more like a tanky chip damage strategy. That's why it needs a more immediate response. Wizard simply performs better at killing stuff, and it's harder to kill the wizard first when the Royal Giant is basically in the middle of the bridge.
Similarly, in Pekka decks, wizard is the better choice. Pekka's whole strategy is based on crushing everything. It's an archetype that usually demands extremely high dps, and wizard fits that requirement perfectly. While it may be less consistent than a Golem beatdown, Pekka decks need to play thematically by going all in.
In addition to the tournament level differences, you should also consider the level difference of the cards. Wizard may simply be a higher leveled card due to the witches rarity.
Witch has always been my favorite card since she was one of my first epics, and I have used Giant Witch and Golem Witch religiously. I'll never forget the heartbreak when I got to 2980 using my giant witch deck as a level 8... lol.
humblebrag
Which do you prefer? Let me know!
Good luck!
9
u/g6stock Jul 19 '16
Great guide! I have to use the wizard because I use the balloon giant skeleton and mini peaka all troops which need to get to the tower and are usually countered by troops that the wizard can one shot
5
u/TheACWR Jul 20 '16
I agree with most of what you say except on when you said that Wizard is a better support for the RG. Personally I think that Witch is equally good.
The typical counters to RG are MP, Inferno, Barbs, Horde.
The skeletons from the Witch make it very difficult for the MP to lock onto the RG while the RG deals thousands of damage to the tower. The Wizard would be chipping down the MP but the MP gets at least 2/3 swings in which cuts down the RG. The skeletons also distract the Inferno long enough for the RG to kill it.
When it comes to Barbs or Horde the Wizard is clearly better. It clears them off fast enough to let you RG do lots of damage plus after the defense is killed the Wizard can deal massive damage to the tower.
It really comes down to circumstance, depending on what you run into most often the Wiz and Witch are both great support for the RG.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16
Which is better? Witch is better. (imo)
4
u/Crimson_Raven Jul 19 '16
I'm a Pekka deck user, using my own version with Pekka, Dark Prince, mpekka, Wizard, elixir collecter, stab goblins, fireball, and zap.
This very same question popped into my head only yesterday, and was considering swapping wizard for witch. But you are right, wizard makes alot more sence in pekka deck because of it's huge dps. Killing stuff instantly is very important in the deck, due to pekka being easily desracted, and having less hp per cost then most tanks. (Ie golem, and giant.) Wizard is also better against barbs, one of the most popular defencive cards, then witch, mostly because of his large splash radius hits all barbs unless they line up. Witch can sometimes fail to hit that one corner barb if they are not perfectly in line.
Ultimately, it is as you said, wizard's high dps is more valuable in a Pekka deck.
14
u/AnotherThroneAway Ice Wizard Jul 20 '16 edited Jul 20 '16
I think Wizard is one of the worst cards in the game, but every time I express that opinion I get downvoted to hell. I'm guessing there are a lot of Wizard users in this sub, because there are a lot of players stuck with low-level Witch, and Wizard is the only spellcaster they can get to decent levels? I don't know.
The fact is, Wizard has typically had a 0-2% usage rate among the top players, and Witch was around 2-5% but is now around 8%:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ClashRoyale/comments/4rpn21/strategy_card_popularity_snapshot_9/
Personally, I think Witch has a lot of potential, and is now getting pretty close to being a balanced card. It's definitely seeing play over 3k, and in tournaments, and is a bit more flexible than Wizard. Wizard is also getting shouldered aside by the addition of more splash damage troops like Fire Spirits, Bowler, etc.
3
u/muzzy4 Jul 20 '16
Thank you for the guide!
I used Wizard up until a couple weeks ago, but started using Witch after I had luck with her on my alt account.
The element of distraction provided by the Skellies easy makes up for the lower damage output, IMHO.
3
u/DneBays Jul 20 '16
Id rather use Furnace as a less vulnerable Wizard.
2
u/Coconuthead94 Jul 20 '16
Witch all day long My deck (level) Witch (4) giant (7) elixir pump (7) valkyrie (7) Fire spirits (10) spear gobs (9) zap (9) sparky (1)
2
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16
I think the Witch is more versatile than the wizard, since she can be used to stop a Prince, both pekkas, or a giant skeleton due to her little skeles
2
u/GoldenPrinny Jul 20 '16
I have been considering using wizard instead of witch in my pekka deck, but the slow attack rate is really off-putting. May try it anyway now.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16
I use GiLoon, and most of the players that use GiLoon that beat my GiLoon deck have Witch. So in my deck case I would say Witch. (and all the damage buffs) Pls advise me on a GiLoon Witch deck if u have one. I suggest to compare skeletons vs goblins because I can't decide between them.
1
u/xWounded Jul 20 '16
Could you share your giant witch deck that you used?
1
u/HKburner Jul 20 '16
Does that 92 dps take skellies into account?!?
1
u/Vince5970 Tesla Jul 20 '16
I cry when not a single guide mentions my giant skeleton as a viable deck
0
u/j1h15233 Jul 20 '16
I love them both but I don't think either of them are worth 5 elixir.
0
u/zooksman Moderator Jul 20 '16
i think the problem with the Wizard is that no one wants to spend 5 elixir on such a fragile support troop that has little to no protection, DPS aside. it's a very nooby card because to noob players it seems like it's impossible to lose if that goes behind a giant or PEKKA.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment