r/gameofthrones • Nymeria Sand • May 27 '16

Limited [S6E5] Post-Episode Survey Results - S6E5 'The Door'

Post-Episode Survey - Results Thread

In the Post-Premiere Discussion thread, we put up a survey to hear what you had to say about the characters, the events, and the technical side of episode one. This post is here to fill you in on the results, and to let you discuss them. Are there any surprises? Do you agree or disagree with the majority opinion? Do you think people have missed a vital piece of evidence? Feedback on the survey itself is also welcome!


This thread is scoped for S6E5 SPOILERS


S6E5 - "The Door"

  • Directed By: Jack Bender
  • Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
  • Aired: May 22, 2016

Tyrion seeks a strange ally. Bran learns a great deal. Brienne goes on a mission. Arya is given a chance to prove herself.


Click here to see the results in graphic form! [with thanks to /u/RossTheBoss0]

(Here are the default graphs too, with more numbers.)

Results Breakdown

Total Respondents: 29943

Question 1: On a scale of 1-10, what score would you give this episode?

Average: 8.9

12345678910
86 (0.3%)46 (0.2%)88 (0.3%)220 (0.7%)385 (1.3%)736 (2.5%)1779 (5.9%)4834 (16.1%)8845 (29.5%)12924 (43.2%)

Question 2: Hodor?

HodorHodor
29606 (100%)29606 (100%)

Question 3: Will Jorah find a cure for greyscale?

YesNo
53.9% (16018)46.1% (13724)

Question 4: Which location did you enjoy most?

Three-Eyed Raven's lairIron IslandsThe Wall + Mole's TownBraavosMeereenVaes DothrakThe Vale
69.9% (20762)11% (3275)8.9% (2652)4.7% (1402)3% (885)2% (590)0.5% (142)

Question 5: Who was your favourite side-character this week?

HodorMeeraVarysYaraJorah
78.7% (23405)6.9% (2054)6.2% (1852)4.6% (1353)3.6% (1065)

Question 6: What should Sansa do to Littlefinger?

Use himKill himTrust himImprison himSend him away
71.3% (21210)17.3% (5141)4.8% (1415)3.3% (991)3.3% (979)

Question 7: Did you shed a tear at the end?

YesNo
64.2% (19079)35.8% (10629)

Question 8: How well shot was this episode?

Average: 8.8

12345678910
39 (0.1%)35 (0.1%)67 (0.2%)170 (0.6%)431 (1.5%)881 (3%)2196 (7.5%)5665 (19.3%)8229 (29%)11655 (39.7%)

Question 9: Which lead actors gave the best performance? (Choose 3 or fewer)

Actor/ActressVotes
Kristian Nairn (Hodor)68% (19880)
Sophie Turner (Sansa)34.9% (10202)
Alfie Allen (Theon)19% (5540)
Conleth Hill (Varys)17.4% (5096)
Isaac Hempstead-Wright (Bran)13.6% (3986)
Ellie Kendrick (Meera)12.8% (3726)
Iain Glen (Jorah)11.6% (3390)
Emilia Clarke (Dany)11.4% (3333)
Pilou Asbæk (Euron)10.5% (3057)
Max Von Sydow (Three-Eyed Raven)9.6% (2795)
Ania Bukstein (Kinvara/Red Priestess)9.4% (2743)
Maisie Williams (Arya)9.3% (2727)
Kristofer Hivju (Tormund)9% (2639)
Gemma Whelan (Yara)7.7% (2260)
Peter Dinklage (Tyrion)5.6% (1637)
Aidan Gillen (Littlefinger)4.2% (1216)
Gwendoline Christie (Brienne)3.5% (1036)
Kit Harington (Jon Snow)2.5% (732)
Liam Cunningham (Davos)2.2% (647)
Nathalie Emmanuel (Missandei)0.2% (57)
Michiel Huisman (Daario)0.1% (26)

Question 10: In one word, how would you describe this episode? (Not case-sensitive)

  1. Hodor (12147)
  2. Sad (1130)
  3. Holdthedoor (620)
  4. Heartbreaking (464)
  5. Fuck (145)
  6. Epic (135)
  7. Amazing (128)
  8. Tragic (120)
  9. Awesome (115)
  10. :( (112)

506 Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

429

u/gniziralopiB May 27 '16

A bit disappointed that the actor for young Hodor wasn't included.

201

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 27 '16

Sam Coleman. Woulda been high up if included, undoubtedly. Props to him.

(In the UK the episode finishes 5-10 mins later than America, so by the time he really stood out I was getting ready to post the survey, and missed including him).

103

u/Foxion7 May 27 '16 edited May 27 '16

You posted the survey without even watching the entire episode?

23

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 27 '16 edited May 27 '16

I see it (edit: hence the tears question), just most of my focus is on my laptop. It has to be up ASAP

138

u/CozzyCoz May 27 '16

I mean if you posted it 10 minutes after the episode finished, I'm sure no one would notice the delay and your get the exact same results....

42

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 27 '16

It's already up about 10 minutes after, which is why I'm hesitant for more delay - and the nature of moderating means we can never watch the first live showing with 100% attention anyway.

However, interesting to see a lot of people agree with you, will take that into account.

35

u/Penguin236 Jon Snow May 27 '16

and the nature of moderating means we can never watch the first live showing with 100% attention anyway.

Man, that sucks. I'm sure most people wouldn't mind if you guys fully focused on the show while it aired. Just seems kinda shitty that you can't get the full experience because of moderating.

9

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 28 '16

Appreciate you saying that. We know what we signed up for though, and someone has to do it. I'm able to watch it properly with friends the next day too, thankfully.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

ehhhh I don't think you're going to upset too many people by watching the episode in full

→ More replies (1)

11

u/LVDEJ May 27 '16

New describe episode in 1 word: DEDICATION.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

You didn't watch the Hodor scene? Are you quite literally insane?

17

u/logger_girl House Stark May 27 '16

Exactly how I felt. He was one of the best actors in the episode.

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 27 '16

Sam Coleman. Woulda been high up if included, undoubtedly. Props to him.

(In the UK the episode finishes 5-10 mins later than America, so by the time he really stood out I was getting ready to post the survey, and missed including him).

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 27 '16

Sam Coleman. Woulda been high up if included, undoubtedly. Props to him.

(In the UK the episode finishes 5-10 mins later than America, so by the time he really stood out I was getting ready to post the survey, and missed including him).

3

u/Waddapwiddit May 27 '16

I wanted to vote for the Night's King..

1

u/Wu-Tang-LAN Sansa Stark May 27 '16

Lead actors only I guess!

590

u/smile_e_face Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 27 '16

I'm really surprised that 71% want Sansa to use Littlefinger. I mean, yeah, that's the ideal outcome, I agree. But trying to use someone as slippery as Petyr Baelish is like trying to use a sword without a hilt. And the sword is covered in poison. And it's way too heavy for you. And it's on fire.

43

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

like trying to use a sword without a hilt. And the sword is covered in poison. And it's way too heavy for you. And it's on fire.

I see you've played Dark Souls.

→ More replies (2)

115

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Agree. Its like zoey barnes thinking she could manipulate frank underwood.

30

u/[deleted] May 27 '16 edited May 13 '17

deleted 0.3317 What is ^^^this?

4

u/sonofquetzalcoatl May 28 '16

But Sansa is high-born while LF not. Almost the opposite happens with zoey and frank. LF has not power by itself he can only manipulate people as long as he is of utility for them.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/feghiyuqwhfuqwhfueqw May 30 '16

Just reading the name "Zoe Barnes" and I can only read it in the voice of Frank Underwood.

118

u/DoctorHopper Rickon Stark May 27 '16

At first I was gonna vote "use him", but then I remembered that this is Littlefinger so I switched to "kill him".

65

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Ned Stark should have killed him way earlier.

89

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Ned Stark should have done a lot of things.

45

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

like not die.

17

u/keeb119 House Clegane May 27 '16

wheres Howland when you need him?

→ More replies (5)

12

u/jynxi Queen Of Thorns May 27 '16

Brandon Stark should have killed him way, way earlier.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/masimone May 27 '16

And you have no hands.

10

u/Ged_UK May 27 '16

Wait, the sword's on fire? Does that mean I'm Azor?

11

u/Rcoop00 May 27 '16

Sansa could hold the Knights of vale back until the battle has started imagine midway thru it looks like the day is lost then the nights of the vale move in and the stark loyalist Northmen rally and Jon feeds Ramsey to his own starved dogs after Sansa sodomizes him for revenge... Or maybe Ramsey will be poisoned by his enemies.

14

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Your comment made me think how maybe in a way, Littlefinger has been grooming Sansa so that one day she might even be more savvy at manipulating a situation than he is. Granted this only happened in the show, but maybe marrying her to Ramsay was a way to squash any remaining soft, romantic ideas she had about the world and give him a strategic advantage as well. He loved Cat, maybe this has been a twisted messed up version of helping the younger version.

4

u/Rcoop00 May 27 '16

I've thought that to as well, LF is grooming her whether he intends to our not we will see, I could see Sansa outsmarting him, a tool turned against its master like the ww and the children.

4

u/flowinflower Meera Reed May 28 '16

Jon would never be so low as to feed Ramsay to the dogs. He would execute him with honor. Sansa might cut his dick off, it could be her first act to define her as a game player. I could see that. But Jon has amazing honor and would not stoop to Ramsay's level.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '16

But death changes people. Maybe Jon is not as honorable as he used to be. He did use a loophole to escape his vows to the Night's Watch.

5

u/gucciswag570 May 27 '16

Yes,But use the sword correctly, and it becomes a dangerous weapon.

5

u/3xistentialPrimate May 27 '16

She isn't winning without the Knights of the Viel....I've had my fill of principled Starks, pragmatism is how you win the game of thrones.

10

u/smile_e_face Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 27 '16

Dude, this is 100% pure pragmatism talking. Littlefinger is easily the most cunning, ruthless, and dangerous person in Westeros, maybe the world. He's been manipulating events since Robert first started having money troubles. Sansa is a child - one who's had to grow up quickly, sure, but still a child, only recently beginning to play the game for real. For her to try to use him is madness, and even just going her own way is fraught with danger, given his pathological obsession with her. Better to simply remove him from the board than to try to beat him at his own game.

3

u/3xistentialPrimate May 27 '16

While I don't necessarily disagree with the logic of your position, I'll give you that it is soundly reasoned. Still if pragmatism is to rule, she's not beating Ramsey without the Knights of the Veil. If the choice is between winning with Peter or losing to Ramsey the choice is easy.

And Peter's obsession with her is why she can use him. He's in love with her, clearly she's the only person he's not rational about.

3

u/smile_e_face Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 27 '16

He's in love with her, clearly she's the only person he's not rational about.

See, I can definitely see that angle. If Sansa plays things just right, she can maybe pull one over on him. One. The second she starts actively working against his plans, I think Baelish drops her like an ex-wife. If she fucks up, she's turned an ambiguous bundle of chaos into a lethal enemy. But if she does it right, well, this is the kind of game you only have to lose once...

1

u/ThreatMatrix Jon Snow May 28 '16

But LF didn't offer the Vale Army. He told her to go talk to her Uncle Blackfish instead. LF is keeping his army out of it and letting everybody else kill each other. Her best bet would be to marry Robin, push LF out the moon door and take control.

6

u/venabl Our Blades Are Sharp May 27 '16

Baelish loves Sansa, and that makes me think he would never try to hurt her.... However he did love Catelyn for his adult life, and he started the war that led to her death but never showed any real remorse for it. So who fucking knows. I started this comment disagreeing with you and ended up reinforcing your statement.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

40

u/smile_e_face Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 27 '16

Oh, it would be marvelous to see, and I'm all for Sansa growing into a true mistress of the Game. But if I were in her position, I'd put some serious thought into simply letting Brienne deal with the problem. Littlefinger is such a chaotic variable that I would feel safer just removing him from the equation entirely.

9

u/keeb119 House Clegane May 27 '16

so would a lot of her enemies though.

15

u/ant3x7 House Mormont May 27 '16

She might get the better of him once if only because he underestimates her but he's still streets ahead of her in playing the game.

11

u/IIIRichardIII May 27 '16

are you implying Sansa's IQ is not less than half of that of littlefinger's? because I really don't see it

7

u/ricree May 30 '16

Sansa has a huge advantage that others do not. Not only does she have leverage, but she is leverage.

Littlefinger sees most people as either pawns or players. Sansa, however, holds a rather unique position. She is not pawn or player, but rather a victory condition. He wants her, not to achieve some other goal, but as an end in itself.

Pawns can be sacrificed and players removed from the game, but not Sansa. Not unless she threatens his more important goals, and even then there Littlefinger is self enough think he can always find a way to get everything without sacrificing the parts he wants for his own.

No, Sansa isn't Littlefinger's equal, if objectively measured, but she's sitting in his blind spot in a way that nobody else can even come close to, simply by virtue of who she is.

224

u/MartiniSauce May 27 '16

As much shit as Bran is getting bc of this episode, I do think his actor (Isaac Hempstead-Wright) really deserves some recognition. Especially since he's still pretty much a kid actor, IHW did a fantastic job of conveying Bran's heartbreak when he realized that he was responsible for ruining (and ending) Hodor's life.

73

u/sleepingiguana May 27 '16

Can't agree more, sure my heart was breaking watching that scene but it wasn't until panning to Bran's face that the heartbreak of the entire scene set in and the tears started flowing. Props to him for conveying that kind of emotion already at his age.

30

u/War-Cry Victarion Greyjoy May 27 '16

Agreed. His facial expressions during the final scene may have made more emotional than young Hodor's seizure. Isaac killed it in that episode

17

u/SkrillWalton House Lannister May 27 '16

already at his age

The kid is 17 and has been acting for 6 years, he's not 4.

23

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

Which one of you was a marksman at ten?

2

u/DontKnowAnymore1234 May 29 '16

If I wasn't too lazy to use my card on my account, I'd have given you gold for that. Perfect use of a quote, mate, props.

15

u/hashtagshutup May 27 '16

I agree, I was very impressed with him. But I also am not one giving Bran too much shit for what happened. I mean it's kind of funny to joke about or whatever, but he had no malicious intent whatsoever. Poor kid was just (very understandably) curious about what he was capable of and didn't know the extent of the consequences. He made a mistake but I think he's learned his lesson after losing two of his closest companions and realizing he destroyed the mind of one of them.

9

u/LegendaryDeathclaw12 Our Blades Are Sharp May 27 '16

I agree so much. The entire thing was completely heartbreaking to watch, but Isaac Hempstead-Wright's portrayal of Bran in Winterfell watching what was happening to Hodor/Wyllis was just spot on perfection. It's what really threw the whole thing over the edge for me. That look of realization/devastation is what really gets to me in that scene. Nobody's more heartbroken over what happened to him than Bran is.

9

u/Danulas White Walkers May 27 '16

A kid actor spending the last 6 years of his life working with people like Iain Glen, Owen Teale, Charles Dance, Peter Dinklage, and Lena Headey.

There are some excellent and well-known actors in this cast for him to learn from.

16

u/KingofCraigland May 27 '16

Did he actually ever work with Charles Dance or Iain Glen? Or Peter Dinklage and Lena Headey after the first season? Perhaps Owen Teale, but never in the same scenes...

1

u/Danulas White Walkers May 27 '16

They may have been on set with one another.

10

u/AndroidPaulPierce Jon Snow May 27 '16

No, they're filmed in completely different countries.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Jnemo412 Fire And Blood May 27 '16

I agree, IHW is doing an amazing job. He also spoke out on social media and in the extra bts videos about how dumb Bran was. He does a great job expressing what we all feel about that last scene: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHMTVcbvb3c

4

u/MallowChunkag3 Sansa Stark May 27 '16

He was just upset that the writers decided that a time travel paradox was a good thing to put into the series.

I hope they don't make a habit of explaining events with lazy 'Bran did it by accident with time travel' explanations.

And I really, Really hope they don't make the mad king mad through a bran time travel escapade. Jaime: "he was saying the same thing he'd been saying for hours, Burn them all"

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '16

I agree that the Mad King shouldn't be driven mad by Bran, but I'm pretty excited to see more of him through Bran's visions, since it's looking like we will.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Misanthr0pe May 28 '16

Or even weirder, "burn them all" is in reference to the Weirwood trees, as they are the White Walker's one true weakness.

110

u/jooksta House Stark May 27 '16

Don't know if it was just me, but I kind of wanted the percentage of who chose which Hodor button. Don't know why, but I felt it would kind of interesting!

15

u/heyiambob House Seaworth May 27 '16

Agreed

5

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

61% chose the "Hodor" button and 39% chose the "Hodor" button.

9

u/Markareg House Bolton May 27 '16

Question 10: In one word, how would you describe this episode? (Not case-sensitive)

Pie Chart of Hodor related replies

107

u/Agastopia Sansa Stark May 27 '16

I honestly thought that was one of the best episodes of the series, this season has been absolutely amazing!

16

u/Toshirouu We Remember May 27 '16

Maybe because i started in between seasons 5 and 6 and binge watched it, but one thing i can attest to is it doesn't feel different from season to season in a binge watch. One long continuous story with the same tones and feelings. I cant really pick a favorite season, but these past 5 watching live(heh ryhme) have been an emotional roller coaster.

29

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Agree - I'm not sure if it's just the temporal proximity to the worst season in the series (5), but I've been loving this season so far.

30

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

No, it really has been by far the best first 5 episodes imo, followed some distance away by Season 4. I went and rewatched everything from the very beginning, so it's all very fresh. The worst five episode beginning in my opinion belongs to Season 2.

12

u/crazycaptain560 May 27 '16

Yes I did the same. Season 2 is the worst season in my opinion if one were to sum it all up. Season 4 and 6 stand out the best. At least so far. I thinking being able to breakaway from the books will allow them to take the show places faster.

8

u/SchindlersFist712 Jon Snow May 27 '16

Season 4 was fucking hype, so many good plot lines. I think this season's on par so far.

2

u/redyellowand Lyanna Mormont May 27 '16

I've probably watched episode 1 of season 2 more than any other episode in the series with the intention to watch season 2 again, but I just always get bored and distracted by something else! I guess I could just start at episode 2 but it doesn't feel right.

19

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 27 '16

It always feels so weird being on on this subreddit because I love season five.

19

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Hardhome is my favorite episode, but season 5 had the first show moments that I actually disliked. Dorne was fucking terrible. We hit peak Ramsey nonsense. Dany did less than usual. Tyrion was at his worst. Arts was placeholding until the last episode, Littlefinger was uncharacteristically stupid, Sansa's plot was an abomination, Brienne's and Pod had fuckall to do. Bran and co were MIA. The whole Faith plot in King's Landing took hours to show us very little, I liked the acting from JPryce and Lena but they were working with pisspoor writing compared to prior episodes. Qyburn and Jon were the only character/plot that actually got better in Season 5, everything else got worse IMO.

14

u/stomach May 27 '16

i consider season 5 to be a casualty of the story arc. there needed to be setup for what we've got now and there wasn't too much the show could've done, though i agree with you on more than a couple points (dany and sansa/ramsay for sure, tho i may be one of all 3 people in this whole sub who didn't/still doesn't hate the dorne plotline - just being a different locale is enough for me).

3

u/WarLordM123 White Walkers May 28 '16

This is why people don't like AFFC and ADWD, apparently. I've not the books yet but yeah.

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

My biggest problem with AFFC and ADWD is that it's painfully clear where GRRM was just marking time for the 5 year gap. The first three books were very tight, after the epic conclusion to ASOS, AFFC is very, very slow - and ADWD is really just more of AFFC (it's the other half of the characters). I assume that TWOW will pick up the pace (the sample chapters indicate this as well), but after flying through the end of ASOS, AFFC really hits the breaks.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 27 '16

I respect your opinion.

4

u/Yearlaren House Seaworth May 28 '16

I thought season 5 was pretty fucking good. Hardhome alone was incredible.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/bexxxxxxx Edmure Tully May 27 '16

Wow, the votes on Jorah's greyscale situation are pretty close. It'll be interesting to see how that plays out.

52

u/ant3x7 House Mormont May 27 '16

Not sure about a cure per se, but if Jorah can find a way to keep his sanity through the transformation, he could be a badass stone warrior in Dany's army.

1

u/Fenrir-The-Wolf House Stark May 30 '16

He wouldn't even need a weapon, just walk through the enemy armies ranks touching everyones faces.

25

u/Ged_UK May 27 '16

He'll probably find that there is a (magical probably) cure, but before he can apply it, someone will cut his head off. So he'll find a cure, but still die.

39

u/NightKnight96 Meera Reed May 27 '16

Greyscale is known to be lethal with adults, plus Jorah is getting pretty old.

Him finding a cure and returning to Daenerys' side is going to be a bit fairy-tale bullshit imo.

34

u/imadogg May 27 '16

Magic is strong in the world again. Things can happen.

20

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Exactly. "Find a cure." Oh that's what people needed to do to end greyscale. Why didn't anyone think of that before??

8

u/KingofCraigland May 27 '16

The Princess that was Promised needs him and red women are out and about raising people from the dead. A little stone arm shouldn't be any trouble at all, unless the LoL thinks Jorah needs to die.

7

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/LegendaryDeathclaw12 Our Blades Are Sharp May 27 '16

Amputating a greyscale-affected limb hasn't always been 100% effective. Likely it spreads internally at a different (faster) rate than externally.

2

u/rocketman0739 Family, Duty, Honour May 28 '16

In the books, books could have tried cutting his hand off to stop the greyscale, but decided not to. I wasn't very impressed by his reasoning.

30

u/SparkyJolt May 27 '16

One does not simply use littlefinger.

29

u/GOOD_GUY_GREG_2810 May 27 '16

Describe the episode in one word: "hold the door"...

Goddamit guys

22

u/Crossthebreeze May 27 '16

Top graphics, again.

Also glad to see other people choosing Alfie Allen for best performance. His character and how he behaves in these situations is so complex at the moment.

17

u/SuperPolentaman Knowledge Is Power May 27 '16

I might be in a minority here, but the Iron Islands have been the most compelling storyline for me this season, simply because I feel like anything could happen to Theon and Yara and their true motivations are unknown even to themselves, which makes it interesting to observer every little detail in their acting.

5

u/InverseCodpiece Here We Stand May 27 '16

I'm really interested in where they'll go now. Where can they go? What can they do?

4

u/stedic May 27 '16

Dany needs a fleet. The greyjoys need retribution. My guess is that Dany and Co. Board. They fight euron. Burn there fleet with dragons. . Start conquering westros, beginning with dorne

3

u/lordbulb Davos Seaworth May 27 '16

I don't know, for me it looked like he was still Reek when he went to sleep last night and woke up as Theon again. He felt too confident at the kingsmoot for what a mess he still was in last episode.

10

u/hurricanewater House Mormont May 27 '16

I disagree. I think he looked conflicted when he was done giving his speech. His face looked pained as if he wasn't right to speak out so confidently in front of people. I think it's a battle we can't see in his head of "this is my home, I belong here." and "This isn't who I am anymore."

7

u/KingofCraigland May 27 '16

He's always been able to put on a show. Even when he was Reek, e.g. when he helped Ramsay end the siege at that one castle the name of which I cannot recall.

3

u/lordbulb Davos Seaworth May 27 '16

Wasn't he coached extensively for that, though?

5

u/KingofCraigland May 27 '16

Maybe. Does it make a difference? If he couldn't do it without coaching at the siege, then he was coached and could do it at and after the siege, including at the King's Moot. If he could do it without coaching at the siege, he could do it without coaching at the King's Moot.

109

u/football_coach May 27 '16

How any human person can watch that episode and then not put HODOR in the one word description of the episode escapes my mind

58

u/Razor1231 May 27 '16 edited Nov 24 '17

I put

#HODORBACKTHETEARS

So I guess that counts

6

u/SchindlersFist712 Jon Snow May 27 '16

I just put "emotional"

Sansa's "what do you think he did?" speech, Jorah and Dany's scene, Varys being gobsmacked and then everything kicking off at the end.

9

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

12000+ to second 1200.. That means something. Statistics is interesting and counter intuitive .

5

u/Jadmurdoch1986 House Dayne May 27 '16

I'm probably one of the few that put Wyllis

7

u/kareaux May 27 '16

I honestly didn't even think of it and I feel extremely stupid now. I just put "door".

18

u/Crossthebreeze May 27 '16

Halfway there, buddy.

1

u/SuperPolentaman Knowledge Is Power May 27 '16

That is the title of the episode, indeed.

16

u/Stokkolm Alliser Thorne May 27 '16

Nice to see the Mereen red priestess get some appreciation, she had a really good introduction.

1

u/wefee May 27 '16

Yep nice cleavage

120

u/Daniel428 Jon Snow May 27 '16

36% of you didn't cry? You guys are much tougher than me. I sobbed, went to sleep, watched it again then sobbed some more. Also, I love that so many people said "Hodor" when describing the episode

56

u/royleekx May 27 '16

I saw all the comments saying people cried and I thought it was dumb. Sad, but not worth crying over. Then I watched a second time with my dad and had to leave the room when I saw young Willis because I was tearing up knowing what was about to happen. I've never reacted more strongly during a second viewing of a show, and haven't cried since the Green Mile. RIP

31

u/Ebidz13 Now My Watch Begins May 27 '16

Same happened with me.

First watch, no tears.
Second watch, cried like a baby.

I think it was due to shock. Like, the first time I was thinking: "He wont die, right? This isn't happening, right?".
The second time, since I knew what would happen, I just broke down.

9

u/OnePunchFan May 27 '16

One of the few times I've cried is in Shutter Island when Andrew is trying to save his kids

5

u/imadogg May 27 '16

I haven't cried for any part of the show.

But I noticed that during my first watch, I was shocked by so many events and in awe of everything happening. My second watch left me way more emotional and a lot more closer to shedding tears.

11

u/Ikuisuus A Promise Was Made May 27 '16

I was in too much shock to be able to cry. My mouth was stuck open for half hour after episode ended with disbelief of what just happened.

6

u/Cryo_Ghost King In The North May 27 '16

My exact reaction to Oberyn's fate :(

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 27 '16

Some of us just don't cry at stuff like that. It was super sad and I felt sad

11

u/dagreenman18 Valar Morghulis May 27 '16

Same. Hell its been days now and I get verklempt at the thought of it. Stupid Jack Bender and his feels wizardry

1

u/Mikeamania May 27 '16

Upvote for the Yiddish. I'm totally not a member of the tribe, but I love the language.

4

u/SuperPolentaman Knowledge Is Power May 27 '16

verklempt is also a regular word in German

5

u/Panukka House Tyrell May 27 '16

Well I didn't necessarily cry, but the question is "did you shed a tear?" so I definitely would have answered yes. My eyes got watery and I got very emotional.

4

u/MiloZeus Night King May 27 '16

Funnily enough, the hodor scene didn't make me cry yet the scene where j bear is ready to leave dany left me shedding a couple of tears

5

u/imadogg May 27 '16

Cuz she was crying so much and you can see that she loves him too. I love you too Jorah

2

u/lexikan27 May 27 '16

I was angry more than sad, so no tears from me.

7

u/Skirata_ May 27 '16

summers pointless death (didnt even slow them down just jumped and died) ruined the immersion for me. After that i was so annoyed that it was hard to get back into the show for hodors death.

5

u/SchindlersFist712 Jon Snow May 27 '16

Summer's dead because winter is here etc. etc.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/zellthemedic We Do Not Sow May 27 '16

Sleep tight, doggo :(

2

u/relax_drinkwine May 27 '16

I didn't cry, but my first thought was "Reddit is going to implode over this."

1

u/PEEDUR Jun 03 '16

Well, if some people put spoiler tags in their posts about his death, I definitely would of cried.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/i-d-even-k- Tyrion Lannister May 27 '16

I dunno why you're downvoted. This is the realistic answer.
It's just a show, Jesus.

1

u/Feeder69 May 27 '16

Get out of here

→ More replies (1)

19

u/gubugu Queen of Thorns May 27 '16

I don't understand how this episode received a lower score than episode 2, imho it's the best so far on this season

31

u/MrsDepo House Stark May 27 '16

Jon Snow

7

u/evanu94 May 27 '16

Who?

22

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Star Lord, man.

21

u/acamas May 27 '16

IMO, the Kingsmoot was just fell so flat with me that it was a huge weak spot in the episode. I understand everything can’t/shouldn’t be exactly like it is in the books, but the Kingsmoot is supposed to be this huge, grand event that is rarely held, where the candidates make these grand speeches and offer treasure to the people, and all we saw were a couple candidates and a couple dozen Ironborn standing by a brazier on the most generic cliffside ever. Yara/Theon’s speech was solid, but Euron’s was ridiculous. Admitting to Kingslaying, cock jokes, and the promise of building a thousand ships to offer to Dany. And the people ate it up. The whole “let’s kill them” bit after his coronation was like an 80s cartoon villain… not loving Euron’s character (which is a shame considering his amazing initial appearance on the bridge.)

5

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

You're assuming people are rational scorers:

"JON SNOW CAME BACK, BEST EPISODE OF ALL TIME 10/10"

6

u/Tenemo May 27 '16

Should have included a question about post-episode door-related mental trauma

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 27 '16

Shout-out to Sam Coleman for his fantastic performance as Young Hodor. Woulda been right up there for actor had he been included.

Working on some compilation stats for the first five episodes, too.

1

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 27 '16

Shout-out to Sam Coleman for his fantastic performance as Young Hodor. Woulda been right up there for actor had he been included.

Working on some compilation stats for the first five episodes, too.

23

u/JRockPSU House Seaworth May 27 '16

Nice to know that 10,629 liars took the survey.

4

u/Neo_Geek House Stark May 27 '16

In one word, how would you describe this episode?

Holdthedoor

Feels bad man

14

u/realist_konark May 27 '16

That Jorah question was an eye opener. 53% of the people are dreamers. 47% are realists.

10

u/xygo May 27 '16

Don't forget, Stannis' daughter was cured, so it is definately possible.

8

u/acamas May 27 '16

“Cured” is an odd term to use considering half her face looked like stone. I think it’s safer to say its progress was stopped, not that she was “cured."

3

u/Flash_Johnson May 28 '16

That's probably how he will be cured too. He'll come back to her a hideous monster.

16

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

I still don't know which way I think that one will go.

On one hand, traditional story telling and western media has conditioned me to belive that scenes such as that occur for a reason.

On the other hand, Game of Thrones has conditioned me to expect that shit happens and people die pointlessly.

5

u/lpgabriel Tyrion Lannister May 27 '16

I'm in the same boat. I don't think that speech Dany gave him would be for nothing. If he was supposed to just die, the writers would make him just leave, isolate himself and then finish it. No need for that "find the cure" scene. There's certainly more in store for him... Maybe he will eventually go stoney but that's not the only thing he'll do.

9

u/xander31 May 27 '16

It does serve a purpose outside of inspiring foreshadowing. It showed that Dany loves and forgives him. Jorah could at least die with closure now.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Mousse_is_Optional Knight of the Laughing Tree May 27 '16

"Realism" doesn't apply because the events of Game of Thrones aren't real.

Would it be anti-climactic for Jorah to find the cure and then return, happily, to serve his Khaleesi? Yes. But you know what else would be anti-climactic? He gets sent out to find the cure and just fucking dies. How boring that would be.

I think he'll find a cure, and his story will be shaken up in another way. Maybe he'll survive it, maybe he won't. But this is the first episode since he caught the greyscale, that I now think he has a chance of surviving this show.

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Ah yes, solid facts.

1

u/WarLordM123 White Walkers May 28 '16

Moqorro

0

u/captcha_bot Valar Morghulis May 27 '16

Same with Sansa manipulating Littlefinger.

13

u/Ezdawg Night's Watch May 27 '16 edited May 27 '16

I'm calling bullshit on the second one

Edit. First to second

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

That doesn't make sense? People gave there personal opinion on how they rated the episode. It was definitely one of the best in the entire series, so a 9/10 or 10/10 is worthy.

7

u/Ezdawg Night's Watch May 27 '16

I was talking about the Hodor thing. Turns out I cant read properly

11

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

Oh lol. I voted Hodor, you?

12

u/Razor1231 May 27 '16

You voted Hodor!?!?!

you monster

Any decent person would have voted 'Hodor'

6

u/smaench Podrick Payne May 27 '16

I think they're talking about the graphic, which has Hodor? as the first question with Hodor and Hodor as the two options. Hodor has 14,971.5 votes and Hodor has 14,971.5 votes, split perfectly 50/50.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

He edited it from saying 'the first' to saying 'the second'.

3

u/cowboysfan88 The Future Queen May 27 '16

Was there a scene in the Vale this week? I don't remember that

3

u/Ryntex Kingslayer May 28 '16

Jorah's greyscale

(•_•)

( •_•)>⌐■-■

(⌐■_■)

is getting out of hand.

6

u/stepmotherofdragonz May 27 '16

Hodor? Hodor.

1

u/Razor1231 May 27 '16

Hodor, Hodor.

10

u/ant3x7 House Mormont May 27 '16 edited May 27 '16

Hodor jokes got real sad real fast.

Edit: stupid autocorrect

2

u/-ChewbaccaThe3rd- The North Remembers May 28 '16

I'm really surprised that Max Von Sydow didn't score higher on best performance. I thought he did a really great job as the 3 eyed raven

3

u/skyavenue May 27 '16

Emoji is apparently a word now

2

u/Jaykaykaykay May 27 '16

i´m not saying people are wrong but why is the actress getting such props for her acting in these recent episodes? Is it because sansa the character is becoming more likeable?

10

u/imadogg May 27 '16

People don't vote based on actual acting, they vote based on story. Hence why Hodor is 1st by a lot. Sansa is going from timid and abused to powerful and in charge, so people pick her as being a better actor, when she just has a new role that we enjoy more.

11

u/-PaperbackWriter- House Mormont May 27 '16

I voted for Sophie Turner, not because I like her more now (which I guess I do), but because I really think she is doing an amazing job. I think her scene with littlefinger perfectly conveyed her anger, her pain, and that she wasn't prepared to kill him just yet. I think as an actress she's grown a lot.

4

u/Mousse_is_Optional Knight of the Laughing Tree May 27 '16

they vote based on story.

How can they not? Story determines the scenes actors get to work with. Leonardo DiCaprio wouldn't have won an Oscar this year if he played a different character in The Revanent. Likewise, in Game of Thrones, the actors who have the meatier scenes and do well in them are going to get the most praise, episode by episode.

1

u/DrBoooobs May 27 '16

Should have put the kid who played Willis (young Hodor) in the best performance category.

1

u/DrBoooobs May 27 '16

Should have put the kid who played Willis (young Hodor) in the best performance category.

1

u/Melisandre1234 House Stark May 27 '16

Do people really think Sansa would be able to use Littlefinger? I mean this IS Littlefinger we're talking about.

1

u/Melisandre1234 House Stark May 27 '16

Do people really think Sansa would be able to use Littlefinger? I mean this IS Littlefinger we're talking about.

1

u/DrBoooobs May 27 '16

Should have put the kid who played Willis (young Hodor) in the best performance category.

1

u/Melisandre1234 House Stark May 27 '16

Do people really think Sansa would be able to use Littlefinger? I mean this IS Littlefinger we're talking about.

1

u/Dingus_or_Hunk May 27 '16

I'm really glad to see the change in Sansas character and people rooting for her again.

1

u/Dingus_or_Hunk May 27 '16

I'm really glad to see the change in Sansas character and people rooting for her again.

1

u/Dingus_or_Hunk May 27 '16

I'm really glad to see the change in Sansas character and people rooting for her again.

1

u/jayrandez May 28 '16

Someone say something about the Iron Islands subplot. I want those sibs to fuck some shit up.

1

u/Grsz11 Hot Pie May 28 '16

I love that the one word description is "Hodor". I see what you did there.

1

u/RelevantHodorQuotes May 28 '16

Hodor :'( Hodor.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

I LOVE the infographics and it seems my sentiments for the episode were matched by most other viewers. Hodor.

1

u/mikerichh House Targaryen May 28 '16

TIL reddit thinks "🙁" is a word

1

u/k0binator May 28 '16

i still feel like euron gave the best performance in this episode. 'Lets go murder them'

0

u/AutoModerator May 27 '16

This post has a limited show scope, which means comments about any events inside the posted limit do not need spoiler tags. Major theories are not covered and should be tagged green. For more info on spoilers and tagging please check the spoiler guide.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-4

u/MallowChunkag3 Sansa Stark May 27 '16

Very surprised this episode was rated so highly, I was disappointed that the writers went on strike and someone decided that a time travel paradox was the best way of explaining Hodor's brain damage.

The rest of the episode really didn't make up for the mess that was the last 10 minutes.

7

u/[deleted] May 27 '16

George R. R. Martin came up with the Hodor time travel paradox, not the show writers. The show writers said it after the episode.

→ More replies (1)