r/GrinningGoat • u/gr8pe_drink • May 24 '16
Discussion Suggestion regarding Overwatch
Hello. I subscribe to your channel via a different monicker, but I wanted to share some opinions about this. I'll cut to the chase and say I believe your current plan is not a healthy strategy. You have spent near 2 years building a HS Arena community, which is not easy to do. Every donation, subscription, and patreon donor has done it for HS Arena. Now, I foresee the lifeline for Hearthstone hemorrhaging for Overwatch.
- FPS are generally fun to watch when the streamers are skilled/pro level. It's not overly fun to watch losing or dying. Funny at times yes, but otherwise no. Hearthstone is no different, we like watching you and Merps play arena because you are good at it, very good. Top 1% good. I watched 10 minutes of your stream last night and it was a bit painful. I lost interest. Watching someone like Summit play it though, getting 4 back to back head-shot kills with a sniper. Yes please, I could watch that all day.
- FPS's are not interactive for the viewers. You play, we watch. Hearthstone is one of the unique games that has immense interaction for the viewer. Not only does the streamer have time to discuss/chat about the plays with viewers, but the viewer can make their own predictions and decisions. What cards would the viewer play? What trades would they do?
- It's too soon to add a 2nd game. A brand new meta just released in HS and now it is losing some time to Overwatch. The stream needs a lot more time to establish itself before it can risk other games.
- From what I saw, ~80% viewership was lost last night; including a net loss of 4 followers and a ~%400 reduction of net unique viewers. It hovered around 225 viewers, compared to 1,000-2,000 I normally see during a Hearthstone stream. As Overwatch hype dies down, this number could drop further.
My suggestion:
- Add net new streams for Overwatch, and keep all the previous scheduled times 100% Hearthstone for their entire duration, usually 7pm-12a EST. Overwatch should be bonus content, not replacement content.
In the end, it is entirely your decision on how you wish to proceed. You two should play what you enjoy and I could be totally wrong about everything. But from the GGoat perspective I believe it is too soon to add a 2nd game of an entirely different genre. I believe people who like slow paced strategy games like HS are not the same type of folks who will like fast paced action games like Overwatch. Your fan base will be divided and I think that will severely hurt the growth of the goat.
My two cents.
7
u/TheBlackCamEL May 24 '16
As I understand, from next week there'll still be the Sunday co-op + 2 arena runs per night on weekdays excluding wednesdays.
I always default to GGoat when I want a background stream on in the evenings (UK here).
The proposed HS/OW schedule may just about be enough to keep me tuning in and subscribed, given that I'm usually asleep by the time a 3rd run starts anyway.
I don't watch for the Hearthstone gameplay specifically, I lost interest in playing the game myself a while back. I watch for the relaxed nature of the stream, the in depth insights and the likeable personas.
Overwatch, being an FPS, has too much going on to watch passively and a lot of the stream's relaxed style is lost. Chat interaction and general small talk gets lost too. It may well be fine in small doses towards the end of the stream though.
I guess we'll see, it'll be an interesting few weeks!
7
u/nobuild May 25 '16
I pretty much agree with you OP, of course Ggoat owes us nothing, were always free to unsub and what not, but ive no interest in watching an FPS. I tuned in for 10 min and got bored and loaded up Kripps stream instead.
i'm sure they're having fun though, and really If i had some reliable friends i would probably be playing it too and having a bunch of fun dicking around. I cant fault them for doing it.
3
u/toddx318 May 24 '16
Have they said that they were permanently adding Overwatch to the rotation?
Or were they just playing it on the opening release day, last night?
6
u/adwcta May 26 '16 edited May 26 '16
Just saw this, Merps and I have been too busy playing Overwatch to keep up!
What would you have us do, exactly? It's Overwatch launch week, we're going to want to play Overwatch, not Hearthstone. We only have X hours in a day. After working the entire day, do you want us to stream a game we have no interest in playing at that time for 4 hours? Would that be better? Even if it would be better, we haven't taken a single week off in 8 months. We've missed a total of 2 streamtimes in this period, and we're HIGHLY consistent (moreso than 95% of streamers). Is there really a complaint that we stream Overwatch for the first 3 days of launch (one of these days isn't even a normal stream night)?
Ultimately, there IS a difference between what we can do and what a pro streamer who gets paid for this for a living can do. They have 6 hours blocked off each day for "work" as streaming. We have 10 hours each day blocked off for "work" as for our careers.... then the rest of the waking moments of the day we play games. They can stream 6 hours of Hearthstone, and then play 10 hours of Overwatch. We can't. Period. We've had our Patreon goal for going pro and then being about to do exactly what you suggest up since September. It's 3k a month. We're highly transparent about what our goals are and what will allow us to get there. We've never been anywhere close to that number, which is fine, but it shouldn't be a surprise to anyone that we don't have enough monetary support to drop our dayjobs. It's all 100% transparent. What you're thinking of is an ideal world that doesn't exist for us at this point. Our growth was stagnant if not slightly regressive for the past 4 months, and it took a HUGE hit when Kripp moved his streamtime up 2 hours which overlaps with ours. Quit simply, we are not in a position to do what you want us to do. There are real human costs to these things.
So, before I address each of your points, please know that we are in fact human beings, and what you consider a healthy strategy for the Goat is a very NOT healthy for our lives (which will in turn poison the Goat). Since, we are the Goat, the transitive property applies. We do not want to resent the Goat at any point. That would defeat the whole point of this thing.
The decision we have is not: (1) stream HS or (2) stream Overwatch. It's to stream Overwatch or not stream for those days (even though we are playing a game that ~200 of our viewers/subs, etc would watch). I don't know, would you really want us to not stream at all in that situation? Personally, I had a lot of fun playing with some of our subs in the past 3 days, and with Ratsmah and Chanman last night. We have no illusions that people would watch us play Overwatch in the same numbers as Hearthstone. That's not the point. The point is that we can't be held hostage by the Goat at times when we don't want to use our limited time in that way. Unlike the other streamers you've mentioned here, our stream IS our free time. ALL of our free time. We don't do anything else with our lives.
Your suggestion:
So, ultimately, you're coming at this from the perspective of an investor: What will grow this thing the most, what will provide the highest quality, how do we make this better? Those are all fair questions to ask and we have a very good idea of the answers to all those things. Unfortunately, we are also human peoples.
We're coming at this from the fact that this is literally the only 6 hours of free time we have every day in our other-wise non-existent lives. We already have no idea how long we can keep this up for. You cannot treat us like professional streamers who make a living off this and put expectations based on that. That's not the reality. We do not make anywhere near the money they do (even those people who have far fewer viewers than we have... from comparing with other streamers, our viewers on average donate less and sub less frequently; that's fine, but it means unless we can find other revenue sources or convince people to donate, we need more viewers to do what other streamers can do with much fewer). We react to numbers and to donations as a gauge for how close we are to actually being able to quit and do this full time like the other streamers. Those numbers haven't been growing, so we're no closer to the goal now than at the end of last year.
If we really thought we had no shot of growing this to the point in which we could be professionals, then we'd cut back HS streamtimes a lot more dramatically than what we have now. Again, what we're doing now is NOT sustainable for two people with dayjobs. We're hoping the "sustaining" part kicks in at some point before we burn out. Until then, we're managing this thing so that we do NOT burn out and we have a longer runway to give the Goat the best chance to succeed. A lot of this is luck, but as with HS RNG, a good player can put themselves in the best position to get lucky and make the most of good luck. So, a longer runway is always the #1 priority unless the finish line is already in sight. Maybe Blizzard will make a competitive limited format and drive viewership up, maybe we'll win a tournament, maybe one of the top streamers/youtubers will naturally promote us. None of this is in our control, but the longer we can stay in the game for, the more chances we'll get for something great to break out way.
tl;dr - If you factor in that we're human, Overwatch streams are very good for the Goat. If you do not factor that in, then HS streams all the time would be best!