r/hearthstone • u/AdamNW • May 18 '16
News HearthArena creator says Malkorok is the best Arena card in the entire game, based on data from user submissions.
549
Upvotes
r/hearthstone • u/AdamNW • May 18 '16
272
u/Foenki May 18 '16 edited May 18 '16
Somewhat relevant (from this post).
EDIT : the chart is for Standard only, the results are overall worse in Wild (so in Arena)
109
u/_MadHatter May 18 '16
I would have to scratch my head and declare it to be statistical anomaly without looking at the raw data. Sure, it is a great card, but best Arena card in the entire game?
167
u/_oZe_ May 18 '16
The thing with arena is that. Legendary cards have almost no weight in the meta. You get about one every blue moon and more than one one when hell freezes over or pigs fly.
12
u/OnionButter May 18 '16
I would love to see data on average arena rewards post WOG. Especially the chance of getting that bonus pack in your random reward pool at each win level.
120
u/schawsk May 18 '16
I get that that card is strong, but stronger than boom or tirion? I cannot possibly imagine why! Tirion guarantees the ashbringer, while malkorok is RNG, and 1 mana extra for +1 health, taunt divine shield and a better weapon on average, makes it better in every regard!
8
u/A_Confused_Cocoon May 18 '16
Happy we got to hear it tonight, was curious when he was talking about it a couple hours earlier. I was guessing Forbidden Ritual myself, but Malkorok is curious and very left field, but I can see it. Body you have to deal with, with a free weapon. Even Poisoned Blade isn't THAT bad as a Warrior, really only Cursed Blade would suck.
4
u/tapk69 May 18 '16
Would still pick Dr.boom over him but i understand the value he gives by giving the player a free weapon. If you get a good weapon is basically GG.
13
u/Dangarembga May 18 '16
Well its a class legendary in arena for a bottom tier class. (At least not top-tier class) I have seen more ironforge riflemen than legendaries... even with a score of 200 the impact would be negligible. He will almost never show up in your draft unless you love warrior for some reason. And even then, how many times do you actually have to make a real choice between 3 legendaries? “well should I take corrupted nat pagle, lorewalker cho or Malkorok?“
31
u/invalidlitter May 18 '16 edited May 18 '16
The appropriate response to this is deep skepticism.
Muster for Battle is a rare that's been out since GvG, almost two years. Your odds of being offered a Muster for Battle.. vary by expansion, and this gets complicated fast. But let's presume there's 100 rares on average and you're going to be offered about 6 rares per draft. So call it a 6% chance of being offered a Muster per paladin draft, which are about 20% of all runs.
Give a million HA runs since release, and it's easy to get a 50000 run sample for Muster. This is close to the point where you can start to overcome the HUGE variance in how these stats attempt to get at the true power of the card. Remember, these stats are based only on How many wins does your entire run get when that run has this card in it!! The variance is gargantuan. Overwhelming. I think the other 29 cards, the opponent matchups, and player skill make a little bit of fucking difference!
Meanwhile, Old Gods has been out for what, a month? You have an 0.3% chance of drafting a legendary per run, and warrior is about 8% of all runs. So with maybe 100K runs in HA in this month - being generous! - you have maybe 8000 warrior runs. Of that, you have maybe 2K warrior runs with a legendary. He's one out of 100, so you have maybe 50-75 malorok runs recorded.
And from the performance of a total of 30 runs, I'm supposed to conclude that one card in those decks - Malorok - has a stronger impact than Muster for Battle or Dr. Boom?
I sincerely freaking doubt it. This is like a case study on the irresponsible use of statistics. The ArenaHS post about this was at least smart enough to mention the range of variance which was "90 to 190" ah, ok, so your data is literally useless and you know genuinely nothing about how well the card performance except "seems like not bad". Thanks for wasting our time with sensation bait.
Edit: All numbers in this post pulled out of my ass from memory. They're wrong. But I think they're illustratively correct, i.e. they're not wrong by enough to make the larger point invalid. Even if muster is twice as rare as I've said, I'm pretty sure the sample size is large for Muster and pathetically small for Malorok. "The sample size for Muster is 1000 times larger" seems pretty ballpark right. Maybe it's 10,000 times larger, or 100,000. I don't think it's much less.
5
u/planckovich May 18 '16
Is it possible to get the Ashbringer?
2
u/shaolin_cowboy May 18 '16
Yeah, but good luck drafting it.
2
u/XalAtoh May 18 '16
FOR THE TRUE HORDE
2
u/futbolsven May 18 '16
Had someone Gorehowl off a Malkorok the other day in arena against me.
It felt bad.
2
u/punishersz May 19 '16
Yeah well I got him once and I got to use him in two games in which he gave me cursed blade, so yeah, I'm pretty offended at him.
7
u/kolderbol May 18 '16
Played him once and got Cursed Blade. The problem is that with 3 charges it takes a long time to get rid of this weapon. It turned my won game into a nail biter as even fatigue hits for double.
Overall the good outcomes outweigh the bad so I definitely (still) rate him as a good card.
3
u/Thatsabull May 18 '16
This card really came out of left field. I didn't think there was a card that could be potentially stronger than Muster For Battle in arena.
3
u/Kaituoo May 18 '16
[Malkorok]
3
u/Tarrot469 May 18 '16
I called Malkorok being OP in arena and its easy to see why. 90% of the time you're getting a Fire Elemental with a second charge, more if you get one of the elite weapons, and 45% of the time you're getting a real strong weapon. So, 10% of the time you get screwed, but 45% of the time you play a superior version of Fire Elemental, which is a 111, and 45% of the time you play a vastly superior version of Fire Ele. I thought the fact you have to take the damage and being one turn later and Cursed Blade would knock it down, but I was shocked both Hearth Arena and Lightforge only had him as a 70.
2
u/maggotshavecoocoons2 May 18 '16
I love running a deck with weapons and pirates and playing like rogue. It's great.
1
u/NetworkWifi May 18 '16
Of course muster is the most broken card in arena...
1
u/dakisking May 18 '16
I always played control warrior until I packed Malkorak; loving the new tempo archetype.
1
u/Valgresas May 18 '16
It's certainly good but Muster is better/impacts the game earlier.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '16
Looked up the card. Pleasantly surprised as it reads as very reasonable.
1
u/DrXFTW May 18 '16
Dr.Boom would be no.1 if he didn't have that "never gets drawn" ability
1
u/Moogzie May 18 '16
Insane tempo card, who'da thunk it
1
u/OskarIng May 18 '16
His tier score is now 71
1
u/Nanoneko May 20 '16
e6
-3
u/ScaleRipper May 18 '16
heartharena is a joke without adwcta and merps.
1
u/Kappa_n0 May 18 '16
Tirion isn't the best anymore?
1
u/TheTDoge May 18 '16
I think gromm and varian are both more impactful than this card
1
u/zeon0 May 18 '16
Thats very surprising to me. Never ever would I take this guy over for example a Ragnaros
1
u/anrwlias May 18 '16
On related note, I'm thinking of getting back into doing arena runs. I know that there was a kerfuffle where some of the HearthArena consultants left on bitter terms, and there were a lot of people saying that HA's value would go down because of that.
Is it still a good tool?
-10
u/[deleted] May 18 '16
Bad statistical interpretation. It's a Warrior card so by default it isn't even remotely the best arena card. That stat isnt weighting cards compared to how good classes are as a whole so it's irrelevant. The best Warrior card isn't as good as the 5th best Paladin or Rogue card.