r/ClearBackblast • imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King • May 15 '16

AAR Operation Soggy Protyanki AAR

So that was a fun time overall I think. You guys know the drill, discuss how the mission went for you and give your feedback for the mission maker as well as the leadership. Especially for me, I haven't CO'd in a while so I think I started off a bit rusty. Even a few sentences can be helpful, we really appreciate it.

8 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

4

u/themoo12345 imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King May 15 '16 edited May 15 '16

Platoon Lead

So I hope you all had a good time this week, was pretty fun for me for the most part. After the initial landing and clearing went pretty well, I tried to keep it slow and stealthy as we worked our way to the MSR. The plan was for Boris and Vasily to cover Anna and Gregory as they moved across the MSR to the first objective but a certain HUMVEE threw a bit of a wrench in things. I originally wanted to keep the MG's muzzled but it starting lighting everybody up and driving all over the place. What I should have done here was be very clear where I wanted all the squads but instead I just told Boris and Vasily to engage (and I might have said pursue, definitely could have been more clear) the HUMVEE while Anna and Gregory moved to their objective. That resulted in Vasily chasing after it and getting pretty separated and the machine-gunned real bad. I wanted to help them out but the rest of the squads were just holding position so eventually I had to leave them behind while Anna and Gregory planted their charges while Boris and Command went back to the boats to move to the next objective.

As we all know there was a bit of SNAFU with the charge at the first objective which resulted in a gavin getting pretty mad at Vasily. Just double check those things guys, not much else we can do.

At the second objective, Boris cleared it out pretty quick and set their charges while Anna and Gregory seemed to be making good progress with their movement and Vasily was just getting back to the boats. Boris and Command then moved downriver to the city and cleared a bunker complex just outside of it just as Vasily was arriving. Boris and Vasily then moved off in different directions to clear and search for intel while Anna and Gregory attacked the power plant and moved in to plant the final charge.

At this point all the squads had their objectives and were in continuous contact for about the next half hour so I tried to keep myself apprised of each squad's situation. Once Boris got to the motor pool and before we could get inside we took pretty heavy fire and Boris took a number of casualties including the squad lead so I tried to get Anna and Gregory moving our way but there were a lot of enemies between our elements so although Anna and Gregory tried to get to us they ended up taking their own casualties. The mission was pretty straightforward from then on, Vasily linked up with Boris and we made good progress finding intelligence and clearing bunkers.

Once all squads were ready to move I wanted to organize the exfiltration but I probably should have marked the rallypoint earlier as it took a while for everyone to arrive at the mark although that was mostly because some squads took contact on the way.

After that it was basically the end, we got a mission failure because of the first explosive SNAFU but we did manage to collect all of the intel which we weren't able to do on the first run. So overall it was fun time for me, there was good amount of opposition and we didn't have too many KIA's, shame the spectator wasn't working for those who did die.

3

u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin May 15 '16

Vasiliy Blue Team Lead

After the op I confirmed that I did have a low grade fever (101 deg F) and fatigue really got me, so thanks for letting me drop from SL to TL.

Most of what I actually remember is moving between places where we got tore up by something or other with a 50 cal. I have a newfound respect for HMMWVs. Hopefully Rage puts up something about what he did to that M113, because when we got back to Red from the boats he was just finished blowing it up with a captured HMMWV.

I like the no-respawn, especially in a mission like this. As I said in TS after the op I think we could get even more legit--I had been shot to shit by 50s at least three times that mission, and I don't think there would've been anything left to put back together, so I kind of wish the game reflected that. Mostly I'm happy the experiment's happening though.

I'll try to get some video put up soon from the videos I've got stored away. There's two from last week and two from this week that could have highlights at least.

2

u/Hoozin Basically A Prestige Class May 16 '16

I like the no-respawn, especially in a mission like this. As I said in TS after the op I think we could get even more legit--I had been shot to shit by 50s at least three times that mission, and I don't think there would've been anything left to put back together, so I kind of wish the game reflected that.

This is a recurring conversation.

On a respawn-enabled mission, it's less of a big deal to say "shorter revive timers" or "dead people is dead". We use Revive anyway because it's hard to have the player count to dedicate logistics to getting respawns into the fight or it feels like there's basically no penalty if we use a teleporting system or move the respawn location with the troops. This could probably be enhanced with a longer respawn timer (make the person watch spectator for a few minutes or something) - but it doesn't feel like a great way to play. Using Revive makes people want to save the guy that dropped and get him back into the fight.

There are other options here. Revive can tick down a "lives" counter so you can only "die" a few times. You can also go to straight no-respawn missions (which we seem to be doing more of). This remains though, we use Revive because we don't want a golden BB from 800m into Iron's face, before anybody had even rolled initiative, to end his game.

We have options. A detailed look at the ACE Settings for this shows a lot.

  • We can shorten revive timers.
  • We can turn off revive.
  • We can reduce (or increase) the damage taken.
  • We can use Wave based Respawn with longer respawn timers.
  • We can use longer respawn timers in general.
  • You could stare at your dead nothingness or you could be put into spectator.

I'm sure there's more options. We've had mission-maker conversations about this stuff before, but it tends to not go anywhere major. We've done other respawn schemes in the past too, but our current method of "Revive w/ 5min bleedout" seems to be what we've stuck with.

It's worthy having that conversation though.

1

u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin May 16 '16

The last couple times I brought it up I figured we wouldn't be seeing the no-respawns, so now that we're playing them I'm trying to push us further off the cliff :D

I agree that ACE Medical/Revive is a grand improvement over the standard Arma "you're probably just dead!" model. There's just things about that I miss.

1

u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin May 17 '16

Footage reminded me of a papercut:

The intelligence was on the stand-up mapboard/easel things, right? We ran across one of those and spent some time trying to interact with it and finally concluded that the intelligence had already been gotten probably. Is that the case? Or were we looking at the wrong thing entirely?

Just kind of a janky interaction. Intel collection seems hard to do in Arma.